Weird story: Paul McCartney wrote this song after reading a newspaper article about a teen-aged girl who ran away from home (which was happening a LOT in the States at that time, and I assume in Britain, too). It turned out later that he had actually met the girl once when he was judging a contest on a TV show.
That is one of BEATLES very beautiful songs , I loved that song since the first time I heard it during my high school days and I advice you to listen more songs of the Beatles and you will discover and find out how brilliant and talented group they are !!!
Hey beautiful people...please bare with the audio quality on this one. We honestly couldn't share headphones okay. But moving forward I'll sort this problem out. Hope you enjoy our reaction 😊
Ambrose Cynthia your love for the Beatles so quickly is wonderful to see. At 5:08 in your video the song says "fun is the one thing that money can't buy". That is the reason she left home......for fun and freedom. Their older songs are very different from their later songs. They are all good, but in a few years time their artistry was very different.
I've just watched a video on you tube Titled Melanie Coe . She's Leaving Home . She's the girl who left home and Paul saw the article in the Newspaper and wrote the song , great interview have a look and show on here
Songs like this are not just a song but a theater , movie and reality at the same time. Just as the later Charlie Chaplin movies... he was very funny but presenting deep issues in society so you end up wondering weather to laugh or cry. It makes you look deeper to the core of the real things in life
Hi, your idea of bringing your sister to react with you enriches the video. Did you know that Paul McCartney, a former member of the Beatles, turns 79 today? The quality sound is good.🙂
i hope you give the band Camel a check out.Camel is an English progressive rock band formed in Guildford, Surrey, in 1971. Led by founder-member guitarist Andrew Latimer, they have produced fourteen original studio albums and fourteen singles, plus numerous live albums and DVDs The snow goose album is one of my favourites. thanks and keep safe young lady.
Many thanks to the two of you for this reaction to The Beatles saddest song! Next time you invite her in for a reaction the two of you should react to one of their great love songs like And I Love Her, If I Fell, Something, Here There and Everywhere or Two Of Us! Keep up the great work on your channel and don't forget we are all looking forward to an appearance from Mom one day!! Cheers,
I think Eleanor Rigby is really their saddest song. The girl in this song probably did reunite with her parents eventually. The woman in Eleanor Rigby dies alone, lonely, and broken. Nothing sadder than that.
Oh, I have just seen that you did ANOTHER Beatles reaction video with Roseline. That was also really lovely to watch... and yes, we have another Beatles fan ! Now you should DEFINITELY introduce her to Aurora... I'm sure she will love her to pieces... just like you and me. Show her a song from the Nidarosdomen concert, that you alreaady know, maybe "Lucky". ;-) Hugs and kisses : Gerry
i just always took it to mean she finally grew up and wanted to be her own person and parents are always sad when their child moves on. even when they go off to college.
Two more very emotional songs that you should check out Cynthia are by the Bee Gees: "I Started A Joke" and "1941 New York Mining Disaster". The best versions come from the YT video entitled "The Bee Gees One Night Only" and I hope they make you cry! You will certainly understand very swiftly why the voice of Robin Gibb is so terribly missed. He sang like an Angel.
Also "Words" which my wonderful step dad, 48 years ago, sang to my mum to try and persuade her to marry him.. He had a wonderful singing voice and natural perfect pitch. Worked, obviously. Also "Run to Me" "First of May" and last but not least, "Morning of my Life".
True Story: Paul wrote this after reading in a newspaper about a girl who ran away from home and that same girl won a prize on TV from a music show about the Beatles years before.
"She's leaving home after living ALONE for so many years". Her parents never really knew her. They were too busy worrying about how she was hurting them. It was all about them.
@@michaelmelling9333 That's not the message of the song. They feel sorry for themselves. They gave her "everything". (Isn't that what parents do?) "Why did she do this to ME" Not once do they worry what might happen to HER. Paul's lyrics are very ironic. We're not supposed to feel SORRY for the parents. A young girl is on her own. She's the one to worry about!
So I was just looking through your reactions and did I miss something? You haven't reacted to The Beatles Let It Be? I wonder if Rose would recognize it? I also find it interesting that reactors react to practically every Beatles song except for the one that put Beatlemania over the top. She Loves You definitely started it but I Want to Hold Your Hand is the song that blew the doors off and exploded in the U.S. I Want To Hold Your Hand knocked She Loves You off the top of the charts in the UK and it was the number one song of the year in the US (1964). Plus, both McCartney and Lennon agree they both wrote the song together and it's even sung without a lead singer (both of them sing it together). People want to pass it off as childish but it was much more than that. In my opinion, the song is the quintessential Beatles song in both structure and melody.
@@AmbroseCynthia I figured I must have been missing it. I have to go find it and watch it. lol ok...I'm an idiot. All I had to do was search Cynthia Ambrose Let It Be. lol
It was an article that Paul McCartney read in a newspaper about a girl who left home. Coincidentally, McCartney had actually met the girl from the article years before when he was the judge of a dance competition. He didn’t know it was the same person in the article when he wrote the song though.
Can’t believe your sister in law didn’t understand the story it spelt out so clearly - mind you she wasn’t listening through the third verse too busy talking
The song doesn't say that her parents didn't love her, it said that she left because she didn't have "fun" at home, she left them a note, which is very rude to do to caring parents, she was merely spoiled.
I don't know how you are hearing the music, I hear it like it comes out of a little hole in the wall. The sound quality of your videos used to be pretty good. Don't know what happened. Sorry if it's just me.
What is the problem here? The meaning is sitting on the surface. Don't complicate things by searching for deeper meaning. (Abnormal is OK. Stupid is not)
Why.. oh why... oh why Are You TALKING OVER THE LYRICS if you are trying to understand the song? Why? That makes no sense. There's a reason we have TWO EARS and ONE MOUTH.
..................if you are trying to introduce a new song with lyrics to a friend who never heard it before, you should not talk thru half the song. You should be completely silent.
@@AmbroseCynthia It was an article that Paul McCartney read in a newspaper about a girl who left home. Coincidentally, McCartney had actually met the girl from the article years before when he was the judge of a dance competition. He didn’t know it was the same person in the article when he wrote the song though.
Weird story: Paul McCartney wrote this song after reading a newspaper article about a teen-aged girl who ran away from home (which was happening a LOT in the States at that time, and I assume in Britain, too). It turned out later that he had actually met the girl once when he was judging a contest on a TV show.
I still remember the words to this song after 54 years.
60
That is one of BEATLES very beautiful songs , I loved that song since the first time I heard it during my high school days and I advice you to listen more songs of the Beatles and you will discover and find out how brilliant and talented group they are !!!
Hey beautiful people...please bare with the audio quality on this one. We honestly couldn't share headphones okay. But moving forward I'll sort this problem out.
Hope you enjoy our reaction 😊
Figured it was a problem. Hard to give your sis a fair chance to react without them though... The production is a major component of the reaction!
Ambrose Cynthia your love for the Beatles so quickly is wonderful to see. At 5:08 in your video the song says "fun is the one thing that money can't buy". That is the reason she left home......for fun and freedom. Their older songs are very different from their later songs. They are all good, but in a few years time their artistry was very different.
Today is Paul McCartney's birthday... he's 79!... born June 18, 1942
I've just watched a video on you tube Titled Melanie Coe . She's Leaving Home . She's the girl who left home and Paul saw the article in the Newspaper and wrote the song , great interview have a look and show on here
Did you know that Paul met her prior to writing this song and reading about her in the papers (even though he didn’t realize it at the time)?
@@MsAppassionata Yeh , saw the video of her
Songs like this are not just a song but a theater , movie and reality at the same time. Just as the later Charlie Chaplin movies... he was very funny but presenting deep issues in society so you end up wondering weather to laugh or cry. It makes you look deeper to the core of the real things in life
This song is a true story
I always cry when I listen that song.
Thank you Ambrose
And congratulations from Brazil 🇧🇷 👏 ❤ 🙌
Great energy, nice idea to share with your sister in law, and as ever, intoxicating smile 🥰
Great reaction! You're sister in law's interpretation of the song toward the end of the reaction sounded spot on.
Peace
That's how it's done.. one sibling shares with another
Yeah , my little sister loves The Jam thanks to me . And early Clash .
You are both so beaitiful, pieces of art...
anything from Sgt Peppers is GOLD!!
Agreed, my favorite album ever
No marriage here. About a seventeen year old girl who runs away from home to join the peace ☮️ and love hippie scene in swinging London in 1967.
Nice, ladies -
Good reaction.
Hi, your idea of bringing your sister to react with you enriches the video.
Did you know that Paul McCartney, a former member of the Beatles, turns 79 today?
The quality sound is good.🙂
when he was younger mending a fuse, 15 years ago, did you send him a valentine, birthday greeting bottle of wine, when he was 64
As long as a recording of this song exists people will be in awe of the Beatles.
Thank you! -Terry
i hope you give the band Camel a check out.Camel is an English progressive rock band formed in Guildford, Surrey, in 1971. Led by founder-member guitarist Andrew Latimer, they have produced fourteen original studio albums and fourteen singles, plus numerous live albums and DVDs The snow goose album is one of my favourites. thanks and keep safe young lady.
Many thanks to the two of you for this reaction to The Beatles saddest song! Next time you invite her in for a reaction the two of you should react to one of their great love songs like And I Love Her, If I Fell, Something, Here There and Everywhere or Two Of Us! Keep up the great work on your channel and don't forget we are all looking forward to an appearance from Mom one day!! Cheers,
^^wonderful suggestions!
I'll have that in mind Key!
I think Eleanor Rigby is really their saddest song. The girl in this song probably did reunite with her parents eventually. The woman in Eleanor Rigby dies alone, lonely, and broken. Nothing sadder than that.
Oh, I have just seen that you did ANOTHER Beatles reaction video with Roseline. That was also really lovely to watch... and yes, we have another Beatles fan ! Now you should DEFINITELY introduce her to Aurora... I'm sure she will love her to pieces... just like you and me. Show her a song from the Nidarosdomen concert, that you alreaady know, maybe "Lucky". ;-)
Hugs and kisses : Gerry
I'll also like to see her reaction to Lucky
always cry when i hear this..beatles hit the right note
i just always took it to mean she finally grew up and wanted to be her own person and parents are always sad when their child moves on. even when they go off to college.
Two more very emotional songs that you should check out Cynthia are by the Bee Gees: "I Started A Joke" and "1941 New York Mining Disaster". The best versions come from the YT video entitled "The Bee Gees One Night Only" and I hope they make you cry! You will certainly understand very swiftly why the voice of Robin Gibb is so terribly missed. He sang like an Angel.
Also "Words" which my wonderful step dad, 48 years ago, sang to my mum to try and persuade her to marry him.. He had a wonderful singing voice and natural perfect pitch. Worked, obviously. Also "Run to Me" "First of May" and last but not least, "Morning of my Life".
When you provide financially and physically and nothing more is tragic.
Ahhh Cynthia, now you are watching the reaction.😄
😂😂
Yeah...it was fun though
This song is about freedom....anyone, anywhere anytime....
True Story: Paul wrote this after reading in a newspaper about a girl who ran away from home and that same girl won a prize on TV from a music show about the Beatles years before.
Don't be sad Ambrose, she'll be back when she has her first baby to show her parents :-)
That's true
Great taste from Detroit Michigan
Loved this narrative of two different perspectives on what went wrong.😪
Did you realise half way through that their songs get better the more you listen to them ? Nice .
I am just saying it cause I love your reactions.
Please get headphones. You have no idea what you are missing out on without them.
Two lovelies…
"She's leaving home after living ALONE for so many years". Her parents never really knew her. They were too busy worrying about how she was hurting them. It was all about them.
Her parents loved her very, very much.
@@michaelmelling9333 That's not the message of the song. They feel sorry for themselves. They gave her "everything". (Isn't that what parents do?) "Why did she do this to ME" Not once do they worry what might happen to HER. Paul's lyrics are very ironic. We're not supposed to feel SORRY for the parents. A young girl is on her own. She's the one to worry about!
The saddest song, yet it might be the other side of Money Can't By Me Love.
At that time runaways was a major social problem.
You need another sound system to do this song justice
You ve got to do the Live Version of Hey Jude then she won’t look back
she wasnt in a marriage...she just left her parents house
She nailed the meaning of the song. Comparing it to a marriage, she couldn't take it any longer so she had to leave.
So I was just looking through your reactions and did I miss something? You haven't reacted to The Beatles Let It Be? I wonder if Rose would recognize it?
I also find it interesting that reactors react to practically every Beatles song except for the one that put Beatlemania over the top. She Loves You definitely started it but I Want to Hold Your Hand is the song that blew the doors off and exploded in the U.S. I Want To Hold Your Hand knocked She Loves You off the top of the charts in the UK and it was the number one song of the year in the US (1964).
Plus, both McCartney and Lennon agree they both wrote the song together and it's even sung without a lead singer (both of them sing it together). People want to pass it off as childish but it was much more than that. In my opinion, the song is the quintessential Beatles song in both structure and melody.
I have done a reaction to let it be
@@AmbroseCynthia I figured I must have been missing it. I have to go find it and watch it. lol
ok...I'm an idiot. All I had to do was search Cynthia Ambrose Let It Be. lol
Listen to James Brown Luciano Pavarotti this is a man's world
It seems sad , but the song is a satire . The parents have been selfless , but they dont understand their daughter . She HAS to leave .
It was an article that Paul McCartney read in a newspaper about a girl who left home.
Coincidentally, McCartney had actually met the girl from the article years before when he was the judge of a dance competition.
He didn’t know it was the same person in the article when he wrote the song though.
Much deeper song to have Roseline react to . BET this hooks her in
Can’t believe your sister in law didn’t understand the story it spelt out so clearly - mind you she wasn’t listening through the third verse too busy talking
You picked a real sad one!
About parents have to let go when their child falls in love
One of the only songs that they never played on.
No, it wasn't love that they couldn't buy her..It was "Fun."
Sie sieht genauso aus, als würde sie das null interessieren. Super Kontrast.
The song doesn't say that her parents didn't love her, it said that she left because she didn't have "fun" at home, she left them a note, which is very rude to do to caring parents, she was merely spoiled.
I don't know how you are hearing the music, I hear it like it comes out of a little hole in the wall. The sound quality of your videos used to be pretty good. Don't know what happened. Sorry if it's just me.
Video 3744 of commenting #BringBackDislikes on every unique video I watch (not dislike) in 2022.
One is Base and one is Woke..can you guess?
What is the problem here? The meaning is sitting on the surface. Don't complicate things by searching for deeper meaning.
(Abnormal is OK. Stupid is not)
Possibly the saddest song the Beatles ever did.
Why.. oh why... oh why Are You TALKING OVER THE LYRICS if you are trying to understand the song? Why? That makes no sense. There's a reason we have TWO EARS and ONE MOUTH.
That sound quality is atrocious, you need to redo this video properly.
..................if you are trying to introduce a new song with lyrics to a friend who never heard it before, you should not talk thru half the song. You should be completely silent.
To me it’s about suicide. But….
At some point I thought of it that way
@@AmbroseCynthia It was an article that Paul McCartney read in a newspaper about a girl who left home.
Coincidentally, McCartney had actually met the girl from the article years before when he was the judge of a dance competition.
He didn’t know it was the same person in the article when he wrote the song though.
It is sacrilege to listen to this great song on your mobile phone.
It would be better to let her listen to music with good headphones, the sound you hear now is terrible