A completely misleading and biased commentary against a gentleman scholar! Allama Parwez never refuted Ahadiths fully. He just had the view that Muslims should only accept those ahadith which do not violate Quran's principles and spirit, and also do not dishonor and deride the holy Prophet's personality and character. Today, Muslims and mullahs and Islam have become a source of ridicule because of the fabricated ahadith, nevertheless, they know very well that there are weak ahadith, but still they embrace them. Problem with Dr. Israr was, he was an arrogant guy who couldn't stand a more knowledgeable and rational thinker like GA Parwez, because he was jealous of him due to his popularity and acceptance as a great scholar among educated people all over the world! GA Parwez was a great proponent of Rational Islam!!
میرے خیال سے آپ اُن کی تعلیمات سے واقف نہیں ہیں انہوں نے تو قران پاک کے بھی غلط تفسیر کی ہے جیسا کہ ان کے نزدیک جنات کا کونسیپٹ اس کے علاوہ اور بھی بہت ساری ایسی باتیں ہیں
@@hashimimran786 First, who will decide whose interpretation is right?? Before Parwez, 99% interpretations and traditions brought only embarrassment to Islam - present state of Islam and Muslims reflect that. I think Parwez did the most exquisite interpretation of Quran, which if understood and followed, Muslims can reclaim their lost glory. He told the difference between Deen and Mazhab. Anyway, I'm not a blind follower of Parwez, but I have extensive study of the scholar. He was a giant, and these Mullahs like Dr. Israr, Mududi and countless others are just pygmies in front of him. He was the advocate of rational Islam, which we need today. So far as existence of Jinnat is concerned, I don't agree with Parwez either. I have personal experience of Jinnat- they do exist..
Are bhai jab hadith fabricated hai To tum kis daleel se ye bol rhe ho Ke baki hadith pure hai Matlab jo tum kah rhe ho wo pure hai Aur jo main kah rha wo fabricated hai Jabki dono ki sanad sahi hai balki zaeef ya moudu nhi hai Ye kis tarah ho sakta hai
Totally biased opinion , all u just tryna say is that he needs fame ? Honestly I never heard G.M name ever in my life . But majority of the indo-pak youth knew dr. Ashraf names . Now the other thing u r saying is there are some Zaheef hadiths in Bukhari or Muslim . When the whole have igtemah that bukhari-Muslim r the most authentic books after Quran .
جب آپ حدیث دین اسلام کا حصہ بناکر قُران کے برابر میں پیش کرتے ہیں تو دین اسلام الللہ کا بیجا ہوا دین نہی انسانوں کا بنا یا ہوا دیں بنتا ہے اور یہی ہوا ہے آج کا اسلام بخاری کا اور شافی کا اسلام ہے یہی وجہ ہے اس میں وہ بات نہی رہی ۔ آپ کتنی نمازیں کتے روزے اور کتنے حج کرو کتے وضیفے کرو کچھ اثر نہی مسلم دُنیا ہبکھاریوں اور غلامی کی زنگی گزار رہے ہیں نہ عبادت میں اثر نہ دعاوں میں اثر۔ غلام احمد پرویز جیسے کیی مفکر جنہوں نے یہ بات سمجھی اور اندیشہ تھا کہ دین اسلام کے ساتھ کیا ہواہے انہوں نے اپنی طرف سے کوشیش کی
Great and true analysis
شاہد مجھے بہت اختلاف نظر آرہا ہے اس بیان میں ؟
آپ کو کس بات پر اختلاف نظر آرہا ہے ؟
A completely misleading and biased commentary against a gentleman scholar! Allama Parwez never refuted Ahadiths fully. He just had the view that Muslims should only accept those ahadith which do not violate Quran's principles and spirit, and also do not dishonor and deride the holy Prophet's personality and character. Today, Muslims and mullahs and Islam have become a source of ridicule because of the fabricated ahadith, nevertheless, they know very well that there are weak ahadith, but still they embrace them. Problem with Dr. Israr was, he was an arrogant guy who couldn't stand a more knowledgeable and rational thinker like GA Parwez, because he was jealous of him due to his popularity and acceptance as a great scholar among educated people all over the world! GA Parwez was a great proponent of Rational Islam!!
میرے خیال سے آپ اُن کی تعلیمات سے واقف نہیں ہیں انہوں نے تو قران پاک کے بھی غلط تفسیر کی ہے جیسا کہ ان کے نزدیک جنات کا کونسیپٹ اس کے علاوہ اور بھی بہت ساری ایسی باتیں ہیں
@@hashimimran786 First, who will decide whose interpretation is right?? Before Parwez, 99% interpretations and traditions brought only embarrassment to Islam - present state of Islam and Muslims reflect that. I think Parwez did the most exquisite interpretation of Quran, which if understood and followed, Muslims can reclaim their lost glory. He told the difference between Deen and Mazhab. Anyway, I'm not a blind follower of Parwez, but I have extensive study of the scholar. He was a giant, and these Mullahs like Dr. Israr, Mududi and countless others are just pygmies in front of him. He was the advocate of rational Islam, which we need today. So far as existence of Jinnat is concerned, I don't agree with Parwez either. I have personal experience of Jinnat- they do exist..
Are bhai jab hadith fabricated hai
To tum kis daleel se ye bol rhe ho
Ke baki hadith pure hai
Matlab jo tum kah rhe ho wo pure hai
Aur jo main kah rha wo fabricated hai
Jabki dono ki sanad sahi hai balki zaeef ya moudu nhi hai
Ye kis tarah ho sakta hai
Totally biased opinion , all u just tryna say is that he needs fame ? Honestly I never heard G.M name ever in my life . But majority of the indo-pak youth knew dr. Ashraf names .
Now the other thing u r saying is there are some Zaheef hadiths in Bukhari or Muslim . When the whole have igtemah that bukhari-Muslim r the most authentic books after Quran .
Who decides zaieef hadees and strong hadees, so it is always better to follow both hadees. This is logic and what actually is followed.
محترم! آپ کو کس نے اختیار دیا ھے کہ اللہ تعالیٰ کے کلام کے بارے میں غلط بیانی کریں ؟
آپ جو کوئی بات کرنا چاہ رہے ہیں کھل کر بیان کیجیے
بتائیں کہاں غلط بیانی ہوئی ہے ؟
جب آپ حدیث دین اسلام کا حصہ بناکر قُران کے برابر میں پیش کرتے ہیں تو دین اسلام الللہ کا بیجا ہوا دین نہی انسانوں کا بنا یا ہوا دیں بنتا ہے اور یہی ہوا ہے آج کا اسلام بخاری کا اور شافی کا اسلام ہے یہی وجہ ہے اس میں وہ بات نہی رہی ۔ آپ کتنی نمازیں کتے روزے اور کتنے حج کرو کتے وضیفے کرو کچھ اثر نہی مسلم دُنیا ہبکھاریوں اور غلامی کی زنگی گزار رہے ہیں نہ عبادت میں اثر نہ دعاوں میں اثر۔ غلام احمد پرویز جیسے کیی مفکر جنہوں نے یہ بات سمجھی اور اندیشہ تھا کہ دین اسلام کے ساتھ کیا ہواہے انہوں نے اپنی طرف سے کوشیش کی
Yey pervez ek time ki namaz sabit nahi kar sakta or tum sabit ker k dikhaa do