"What a miserable country, they can't even hang us properly." Ouch, he definitely got one last FU in. And Sir Edward Disbrowe was right on the money in his letter to the British Foreign Secretary.
It hits hard... because it's true. Even a century later, little else had changed. Aside from you would've been more likely to be shot on sight than given a trial and hanging. How far a nation can fall...and never recover.
Some points I want to mention as someone who studied Russian history: 1) the Decembrists inspired not only revolutionaries, but also writers and poets like Pushkin. Many important literature figures knew the Decembrists personally and saw their demise as a personal tragedy. Pierre Bezuknov from War and Peace has many traits of the Decembrists in his character and it was done on purpose. 2) Since the Decembrists were noblemen, they looked at the Emperor and high-ranked officials who questioned them as their comrades and were pretty naive and too honest with them answering all their questions because it was a noble thing to do and willingly giving out information later used against them. 3) The Decembrists were beloved by the local population in Siberia and they influenced the cultural development of the region. The mansions the Decembrists owned were turned into museums. 4) Some Decembrists refused to return back to St. Petersburg even when they were allowed to and they stayed in Siberia forever as they loved the place and the people and had nothing to return to back in St. Petersburg. 5) "The Decembrist's wife" is a Russian saying meaning "a brave and selfless woman who is ready to share any fate with her partner", their wives were regarded with respect and idealized because they could have kept their privileges and high society lifestyle but they abandoned everything and went through many years of hardships just to be with their husbands. 6) The Union of Salvation (the movie) received very mixed reviews, but the majority of the vocal viewers and film critics saw it as an attempt to downplay the Decembrist's role and show their actions as senseless and the Decembrists themselves as stupid kids who rebelled out of their youthful maximalism while the "kind" Emperor was just doing his duty. The movie was released at the time of pro-liberal protests in Russia which were attended mostly by 20-30 somethings and Navalny was getting more popular among people, so showing some of the most famous Russian liberal revolutionaries in such a light at the time like that has raised many eyebrows. Popular Russian youtuber BadComedian posted a long critical video about the movie - it currently has 19 million views.
Very great read! Just curious if you know if the Decemberist in Siberia ever contemplated independence from the main Russian state, or if there is some legacy of liberal rebellion or idealism in these areas from Decemberists? Not sure if there numbers were large enough to have this impact but wondered if any long term effects can be traced to their exile
@@johngriffin8114 Interesting fact I discovered. The Decembrists while inspired by the United States constitution, were against slavery of African-Americans since they saw it as all too similar to Russian Serfdom and did not agree with the US Federal Model. They also aided in brining a US-style Republic with Belarus, Lithuania and Ukraine to be included in many of the former territories of the former Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth.
I will add from BadComedian's review of the movie, that an explicit goal of the Decemberist's Movie was "showing" that the Autocrat in control wants only the best for his subjects; and all the subjects must do to gain their rights was politely appeal, shut up and suffer, and only wait.
I think it's kind of amazing that the Aristocracy was pushing for liberal reforms. Everywhere else, it seems, the aristocracy fought *against* liberal reforms. I mean, you would think the aristocracy benefited from monarchical society. Alas, my knowledge of Russia during this period (or, frankly, any period) is quite... limited.
I feel like your studies are quite one sided seriously you may should have looked into the reactionary mind of the time and how they used to think like in french revolution where they kept giving more power to the mob and in the end it costed them of their heads
I just wanted to watch a few minutes and ended up watching the whole documentary despite having no particular interest in the Decembrist Revolution. This is how good your channel is. Thank you very much for all your great contents !
Similar experience here. I didn't think this was really going to set a hook but gave it a shot. I feel like I'm going to rewatch this one several times and look more deeply into some of the characters. Wow that was good!
On TH-cam there's the movie "The Union of salvation" and it's Russian but it's got English subtitles and a fabulous movie about this!! I cannot blame these young soldiers because when the Alexander died they didn't have a leader for 3 weeks because the head of the guard said that Constantine who was the second oldest son under tsar Alexander the first would be emperor because Alexander died without any legitimate heirs.. Nicholas the first was the next oldest son or the youngest of all.. bizarre Alexander supposedly left him as his successor but he was young and Constantine was in Poland and had the admiration and respect of the entire military which was why all of the soldiers were expecting Constantine to be emperor, it was only normal because he was the next oldest brother under Alexander 1. This one man had Alexander's will take into the Senate and after 3 weeks without a leader these young men kept thinking konstantine was going to be their emperor.. they knew he would be more open to reforms in Russia because he was more modern and liberal and this whole story was really done out of good intentions but it was treason to go against the czar.. it's just tragic because most of these young soldiers had no idea who the rules are was but they figured it would be Konstantine... That's how all of this started to begin with in addition to the fact that this young soldiers and officers wanted reform and they wanted the service to be free..
The production value on this is amazing. A particular hats off to the narration. I don't know what it is, but the way he tells this story is absolutely gripping. The part about the botched hangings almost brought a genuine tear to my eye.
Me, my husband & kids LOVE these videos!!! They way u explain everything is exquisitely detailed yet comprehensive!!! Please do a series on WW2❣️ Thank u for all the work u put into these videos; our favorite TH-cam channel!!!🎉💯💐🍀
I can’t understand how anyone would give up before even trying. After putting in so much time and effort for this and then… they give up and accept defeat and possible execution for treason?!? Madness.
The worst part that all of them faced the trial anyway. Well, if you know you and your troops are a dead men then it's you're duty to dare to do what you've have planned.
@@mastersafari5349 I think that’s right. Those soldiers were loyal to them and died for their cause, and that death was in vain for their cowardice/poor planning.
I am Russian and I always believed that if the Emperor had listened to the Decembrists, who did not want revolution and blood, but wanted to change the country by the will of the emperor, Russia would not have passed the communist regime with all its outgoings and there would be no civil war with all its outgoings (I'm sure the population would be millions higher and would live richer) and country would now be completely different - I'm sure it would be the best possible version of Russia, and primarily for the citizens of Russia themselves and for all of Europe in the second place. IMO. But history does not tolerate the subjunctive mood. It is a pity that there is no parallel reality to find out what would happen if the history of my country went along this fork.
I know it is good manners and common sense for the Epic History TV crew to thank their patrons and financial supporters, but really, it's we - the ones who watch all of this AAA-grade content for free time and time again as much as we want - who should be thanking them. I almost feel guilty getting this for free on their dime. I promise, one of these days I'll do my duty and chip you a few ducats.
Please 🥺 we want more I've searched through the channel again for more of these. But I've already watched them countless times. Please educate us more with these documentaries Anxiously waiting for the next one
Man these guys have to be the sorriest revolutionaries I’ve ever seen. The fact that the Bolsheviks managed to capture St.Petersburg a hundred years later with only a few hundred men shows that the 5000 trained soldiers the Decembrists had would have been more than enough to do the trick. But they gave up before they even tried!
Do you think the Bolsheviks were that small? How come they were able to defeat all the counterrevolutionaries, Monarchists Nationalist, and imperialist combined. Stop listening to Western propaganda.
I think this is the best history channel on TH-cam and special mention to the narrator, whose voice I could o my wish to have, story-telling taken to the next level
The friend of Ryleyev quoted at 15:30 - Adam Mickiewicz is considered one of the greatest Polish poets ever and a very influential figure in shaping the modern Polish identity. Born in what is now Belarus, he considered himself both Polish and Lithuanian (or more like he considered being "Lithuanian" a special kind of being Polish). He studied in the Lithuanian capital - Vilnius (Wilno, as he would call it, Vilna, as it is marked on the map in the video). He found himself in Petersburg due to internal exile deeper into the Empire; a punishment for a "horrific crime" of basically belonging to a student book club.
don't lie . advocacy of violence against innocents( that is what lithuanian, not polish, mickiewicz did) is a crime. didn't you agree ? if not explain. and why are trying to culturally genocide lithuanians by calling them polish? do explain ? are you perhaps a nn?
Then maybe the misserable fool should hang himself if he think he can do a better job. You know such smarta*ses have always been a pain for people like me with realistic and pragmatic worldviews. That impudent and arogant atitude of ,,i know better than anybody" is what gets them to the rope in the first place.
Your videos on Russian history are the best I have ever seen. We are very blessed to have such exceptional quality content on this and so many other amazing events.
I dont remember the name of the movie, but it was about the decembrists. Watching the scene where the soldiers formation is gettimg shredded by grapeshot was horrifying.
I dont know what people are watching these days but pretty sure that this documentary deserves millions of likes much better than current hollywood movies
Any large country with a history associated with revolution) in the 19th century in Europe there were a number of revolutions, France, Germany, the Austrian Empire, the Italian states, Poland, Hungary, etc.
@@EburdeyGordei4 у революций есть бенефициары, это да, но главные причины всегда внутри. Например февральская революция: каким образом и кто её поддержал? Вы вообще помните хронологию событий?
I rarely comment on videos, but this was one of the most fascinating documentaries I've seen regarding Imperial Russia. The narration, illustrations, sequences were above and beyond. My only complaint is that it wasn't long enough. And thats says a lot!
It would be interesting if you can cover Spanish Civil Wars like Carlist Wars...It seems a best fit for this wonderful channel...Cheers and best Epic History TV
How come no one has produced a miniseries on Alexander I ? Part one- Tsarovich and enlightenment through his grandmother Part two- Assassination of father and Succession Part three - Cat & Mouse with Napoleon and the 1812 burning of Moscow Part 4- the conquering hero and Vienna Part 5 - paranoia, plotters, death and Decembrists Now I need a studio and some 💵
Ironically the 2019 movie was banned in the US as Russian propaganda... had to buy it in Canada in order to watch it... great movie! Highly recommend it
This is fascinating. I had no idea Tsar Alexander was such an intelligent, complicated and nuanced personality. 10:06 shows him to be a man who is conflicted by fear and worry that society might collapse around him, and probably a deep personal fear of suffering the same faith as his father. And a sense of personal responsibility and accountability on the other. I.e. _I cannot tolerate open insubordination and rebellion. But I also understand that it would be hypocritical of me to go after people for having ideals that until recently I did not only share, but actively encouraged. These people are not doing anything wrong, even if it might prove dangerous and harmful to me in the longer term._
As a Russian, I consider this whole situation to be the main tragedy of Russia. Russia has never had a stable democracy, democratic revolutions have failed in many cases. And if they succeeded, then this success was only in the most difficult times for Russia, for example in February 1917 or in 1991. Because of this, democrats could never gain popular support, because soon after democratic revolutions, through intrigue and deception, an autocrat came to power, who blamed liberals and democrats for all the troubles, when in fact the autocracies before the revolution were to blame for Russia's impoverishment. And so on in a circle...
As a Russian, I like how British are interested in Russian history. But the author of this channel completely forgot to mention, that Tsar Paul was killed by support of British embassy. All that plot was organised by britains, because Paul didn’t want to be the part of anti French coalition
@@zanderC5953The assasination of Pavel I was orchestrated by Lord Charles Withworth through his mistress, who was the sister of brothers Zubov, directly involved in the plot.
Really fascinating introduction & informative video about Russian 🇷🇺 revolutionaries at 1825- 1850 ... ..👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻👍🏻 such introduction obviously proven Epc history TV 📺 channel...is a great one 👍🏻 🙏🩶🤍🤍
Before the December uprising, there were several peasant uprisings on the Senate Square: for two hundred years. The largest are the revolts of Bulavin, Razin, Pugachev. When the rebels took the cities.
When the executioner attempted to hang the five men, three of them, Muravyov-Apostol, Kakhovsky, and Ryleyev, dropped through the trapdoor only to have the rope around their necks break. Ryleyev supposedly told the crowd watching the execution that Russia was an "unhappy country, where they don't even know how to hang you." The Tsar decided to prove otherwise, and simply ordered more rope, and the execution was carried out.
There had been no executions in Russia for 50 years. In contrast to the constitutional monarchy in Great Britain in the thousands or in the French Republic in the tens of thousands.
Seems to me one of the problems was exactly the limitation to the military, which then was pulled in 2 directions of loyalty. It should have also spread support among the regular population to have had any change of succes.
They fear that the population might turn against them if they got power just like what happened during the French Revolution where even aristocrats who supported the revolution, were sent to the guillotine. Remember, the decemberists were mostly aristocrats.
Вообще то и там и там можно было спокойно работать. В случае с СССР там ещё и был шанс заработать огромные деньги. Да, заключённым платили шикарные зарплаты, которые потом постепенно отдавали из банка. В царской все было на порядок херовее. Просто если ты дворянин то условия будут лучше
I was born almost exactly 200 years after Kondraty Ryleyev. It’s interesting how The Decembrists had aristocratic support but believed they didn’t need the people, while Sun Yat-Sen had the people’s support but believed he didn’t need the aristocracy.
Even under average students perform well in their history subject when they accidentally met a legend named"Epic history" Legends says some even ask for Epic math,Epic science itself"
32:08 & 35:30 I’m crying it’s like the author wrote themselves into a corner and decided to awkwardly use Pyotr Kakhovsky TWICE get the plot moving again 😭
So unexpected and facsinating knowing that Russia had these young aristrocats who looked up to the US and wanted change and freedom not just for themselves and other like them, but also for everyone!
If anyone thinks this kind of magic is finished. It hasn't. It's around us every day. If you have the wit to recognise that, gird your loins and keep fighting every day.
A good half of all revolutionaries across the globe were inspired by American Revolution and the Founding Fathers. Your country is (or at least was) that shining city upon the hill that everyone tried to imitate.
and not the only one case, in Spain, the jourist Antonio garcia Trevijano, writes a very good books about democracy and constitution based in the first colonial americans. long time, before de 1911 coup-the-etat made by the federal Reserve, and the 1952 dictatorship of the industrial-military-complex.
"What a miserable country, they can't even hang us properly." Ouch, he definitely got one last FU in. And Sir Edward Disbrowe was right on the money in his letter to the British Foreign Secretary.
Most based quote in the whole video.
It hits hard... because it's true.
Even a century later, little else had changed. Aside from you would've been more likely to be shot on sight than given a trial and hanging.
How far a nation can fall...and never recover.
Tsar Nicholas: Would you rather be drawn & quartered?
😂؟
The miserable country that has defeated hitler and napoleon and now on its way to defeat Biden.
Epic History TV is the greatest history channel on TH-cam hands down.
False: Mark Felton>
Yes
We know :)
@@peterd1858 say sike now
They are good for sure..top 3 (kings and generals and historymarche)
Some points I want to mention as someone who studied Russian history:
1) the Decembrists inspired not only revolutionaries, but also writers and poets like Pushkin. Many important literature figures knew the Decembrists personally and saw their demise as a personal tragedy. Pierre Bezuknov from War and Peace has many traits of the Decembrists in his character and it was done on purpose.
2) Since the Decembrists were noblemen, they looked at the Emperor and high-ranked officials who questioned them as their comrades and were pretty naive and too honest with them answering all their questions because it was a noble thing to do and willingly giving out information later used against them.
3) The Decembrists were beloved by the local population in Siberia and they influenced the cultural development of the region. The mansions the Decembrists owned were turned into museums.
4) Some Decembrists refused to return back to St. Petersburg even when they were allowed to and they stayed in Siberia forever as they loved the place and the people and had nothing to return to back in St. Petersburg.
5) "The Decembrist's wife" is a Russian saying meaning "a brave and selfless woman who is ready to share any fate with her partner", their wives were regarded with respect and idealized because they could have kept their privileges and high society lifestyle but they abandoned everything and went through many years of hardships just to be with their husbands.
6) The Union of Salvation (the movie) received very mixed reviews, but the majority of the vocal viewers and film critics saw it as an attempt to downplay the Decembrist's role and show their actions as senseless and the Decembrists themselves as stupid kids who rebelled out of their youthful maximalism while the "kind" Emperor was just doing his duty. The movie was released at the time of pro-liberal protests in Russia which were attended mostly by 20-30 somethings and Navalny was getting more popular among people, so showing some of the most famous Russian liberal revolutionaries in such a light at the time like that has raised many eyebrows. Popular Russian youtuber BadComedian posted a long critical video about the movie - it currently has 19 million views.
Very great read! Just curious if you know if the Decemberist in Siberia ever contemplated independence from the main Russian state, or if there is some legacy of liberal rebellion or idealism in these areas from Decemberists? Not sure if there numbers were large enough to have this impact but wondered if any long term effects can be traced to their exile
@@johngriffin8114 Interesting fact I discovered. The Decembrists while inspired by the United States constitution, were against slavery of African-Americans since they saw it as all too similar to Russian Serfdom and did not agree with the US Federal Model. They also aided in brining a US-style Republic with Belarus, Lithuania and Ukraine to be included in many of the former territories of the former Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth.
I will add from BadComedian's review of the movie, that an explicit goal of the Decemberist's Movie was "showing" that the Autocrat in control wants only the best for his subjects; and all the subjects must do to gain their rights was politely appeal, shut up and suffer, and only wait.
I think it's kind of amazing that the Aristocracy was pushing for liberal reforms. Everywhere else, it seems, the aristocracy fought *against* liberal reforms. I mean, you would think the aristocracy benefited from monarchical society. Alas, my knowledge of Russia during this period (or, frankly, any period) is quite... limited.
I feel like your studies are quite one sided
seriously you may should have looked into the reactionary mind of the time and how they used to think
like in french revolution where they kept giving more power to the mob and in the end it costed them of their heads
I just wanted to watch a few minutes and ended up watching the whole documentary despite having no particular interest in the Decembrist Revolution.
This is how good your channel is. Thank you very much for all your great contents !
Similar experience here. I didn't think this was really going to set a hook but gave it a shot. I feel like I'm going to rewatch this one several times and look more deeply into some of the characters. Wow that was good!
On TH-cam there's the movie "The Union of salvation" and it's Russian but it's got English subtitles and a fabulous movie about this!! I cannot blame these young soldiers because when the Alexander died they didn't have a leader for 3 weeks because the head of the guard said that Constantine who was the second oldest son under tsar Alexander the first would be emperor because Alexander died without any legitimate heirs.. Nicholas the first was the next oldest son or the youngest of all.. bizarre Alexander supposedly left him as his successor but he was young and Constantine was in Poland and had the admiration and respect of the entire military which was why all of the soldiers were expecting Constantine to be emperor, it was only normal because he was the next oldest brother under Alexander 1. This one man had Alexander's will take into the Senate and after 3 weeks without a leader these young men kept thinking konstantine was going to be their emperor.. they knew he would be more open to reforms in Russia because he was more modern and liberal and this whole story was really done out of good intentions but it was treason to go against the czar.. it's just tragic because most of these young soldiers had no idea who the rules are was but they figured it would be Konstantine... That's how all of this started to begin with in addition to the fact that this young soldiers and officers wanted reform and they wanted the service to be free..
Imagine how Russia could be today had these men succeeded.
idk maybe
A: Russia will become a republic or
B: Russia will become a constitutional monarchy
Preferably B
@@HandsumeAJ why?
Awful ?
@@bradmetcalf5333 what are you and user @user-fn8yh2dy7v talking about
This narrator never gets old. fantastic.
The production value on this is amazing. A particular hats off to the narration. I don't know what it is, but the way he tells this story is absolutely gripping. The part about the botched hangings almost brought a genuine tear to my eye.
Excellent documentary that is clear, well presented, and with a really good narrator. Impressive content!
I love these, the best history documentaries on TH-cam.
I'd love to see one on Peter the Great and special on the Suvorov campaign in Italy
Yes! It would be cool to make a video about Suvorov
Me, my husband & kids LOVE these videos!!! They way u explain everything is exquisitely detailed yet comprehensive!!! Please do a series on WW2❣️ Thank u for all the work u put into these videos; our favorite TH-cam channel!!!🎉💯💐🍀
It's baffling just how weak those in charge of the revolution were, particularly in the North
I can’t understand how anyone would give up before even trying. After putting in so much time and effort for this and then… they give up and accept defeat and possible execution for treason?!? Madness.
@@senzoo8900
I’m amazed that they gathered their soldiers only to abandon them to artillery fire.
u think u would've done a better job?
The worst part that all of them faced the trial anyway.
Well, if you know you and your troops are a dead men then it's you're duty to dare to do what you've have planned.
@@mastersafari5349
I think that’s right. Those soldiers were loyal to them and died for their cause, and that death was in vain for their cowardice/poor planning.
You guys should go over the wars of Austrian and Spanish succession! Can you go over more events of early modern history?
English infiltration anti catholic scums. The start of the bleed out of Spain. Finally killed by Napoleon's invasion.
I would KILL for a WW2 series from this dude.
Great documentary. I enjoyed it a lot and gave me much to think about . Please keep them coming. I look forward to the documentaries.
Arguably the best rendition of history I’ve ever watched.
I am Russian and I always believed that if the Emperor had listened to the Decembrists, who did not want revolution and blood, but wanted to change the country by the will of the emperor, Russia would not have passed the communist regime with all its outgoings and there would be no civil war with all its outgoings (I'm sure the population would be millions higher and would live richer) and country would now be completely different - I'm sure it would be the best possible version of Russia, and primarily for the citizens of Russia themselves and for all of Europe in the second place. IMO.
But history does not tolerate the subjunctive mood. It is a pity that there is no parallel reality to find out what would happen if the history of my country went along this fork.
I know it is good manners and common sense for the Epic History TV crew to thank their patrons and financial supporters, but really, it's we - the ones who watch all of this AAA-grade content for free time and time again as much as we want - who should be thanking them. I almost feel guilty getting this for free on their dime.
I promise, one of these days I'll do my duty and chip you a few ducats.
This must be one of the saddest stories I've heard
and it still hasn't ended
Please 🥺 we want more I've searched through the channel again for more of these. But I've already watched them countless times. Please educate us more with these documentaries
Anxiously waiting for the next one
Same idk why I watch these videos over and over.
Man these guys have to be the sorriest revolutionaries I’ve ever seen. The fact that the Bolsheviks managed to capture St.Petersburg a hundred years later with only a few hundred men shows that the 5000 trained soldiers the Decembrists had would have been more than enough to do the trick. But they gave up before they even tried!
Die Bolschewiki wurden von Lenin geleitet, der ein Philosoph, ein Ökonom, ein Rechtsanwalt war - ein Wissenschaftler mit einem breiten Horizont.
Actually, the total troop numbers the Bolsheviks managed to get in Petrograd were somewhere around 20k...
Decemberists didn't have western backers set on spoiling Russia for their own gain.
A damn shame. They had a solid chance to succeed if the leaders actually decided to lead.
Do you think the Bolsheviks were that small? How come they were able to defeat all the counterrevolutionaries, Monarchists Nationalist, and imperialist combined. Stop listening to Western propaganda.
I think this is the best history channel on TH-cam and special mention to the narrator, whose voice I could o my wish to have, story-telling taken to the next level
Some of the most powerful youtube history channel. I would be very happy to watch more videos about crusades
The friend of Ryleyev quoted at 15:30 - Adam Mickiewicz is considered one of the greatest Polish poets ever and a very influential figure in shaping the modern Polish identity. Born in what is now Belarus, he considered himself both Polish and Lithuanian (or more like he considered being "Lithuanian" a special kind of being Polish). He studied in the Lithuanian capital - Vilnius (Wilno, as he would call it, Vilna, as it is marked on the map in the video). He found himself in Petersburg due to internal exile deeper into the Empire; a punishment for a "horrific crime" of basically belonging to a student book club.
don't lie . advocacy of violence against innocents( that is what lithuanian, not polish, mickiewicz did) is a crime. didn't you agree ? if not explain.
and why are trying to culturally genocide lithuanians by calling them polish? do explain ? are you perhaps a nn?
@@sitting_nut I don't understand what are you even talking about.
@@Artur_M. i am calling out lies in your op .
In one of his poems “To My Friends the Muscovites” he recalls Decembrists
That's a pretty... Ummm... Tribe-ish last name... May want to name the nose and not imply it was a European ...
That's the most Russian response to a botched executed ever @ 46:25.
Then maybe the misserable fool should hang himself if he think he can do a better job. You know such smarta*ses have always been a pain for people like me with realistic and pragmatic worldviews. That impudent and arogant atitude of ,,i know better than anybody" is what gets them to the rope in the first place.
Your videos on Russian history are the best I have ever seen. We are very blessed to have such exceptional quality content on this and so many other amazing events.
Was literally listening to Revolutions right now, great timing
It's interesting how quickly we went from the peak era of dramatic television to whatever you call the era we're in now.
TH-cam is like the video printing press being given to everyone
Decemberists suffering from some serious performance anxiety.
Well Time for a rewatch! Thanks for your work EHTV!
If the Decemberists would've waited until May I think the nicer weather would've encouraged more people to support their cause.
The Augustists
the problem wasn't the weather - it was the timid officers - intellectuals don't make the best generals
@@johneyon5257 I just feel like they wouldn't have been timid if the weather was nice.
@@Cheka__ - that's an example of a statement that is so foolish - that it's best to leave it hanging in the air
@@johneyon5257 Better to leave it hanging in the warm air of summer.
I dont remember the name of the movie, but it was about the decembrists. Watching the scene where the soldiers formation is gettimg shredded by grapeshot was horrifying.
Union of Salvation
@@janstefanic8998 thanks my dude
This had me biting my nails. The pure intensity of suspenseful participation is legendary.
I dont know what people are watching these days but pretty sure that this documentary deserves millions of likes much better than current hollywood movies
My only complaint is that this wasn't uploaded on December 14. That would have been so much cooler!
I would love to see series about Scotland and Ireland fought for their Independence and Freedom from ruthless British regime
This was literally Epic history
Despite their failure, these where great men.
Russia is always bond with revolution , may they have peace
All revolutions till these days are being supported from abroad.
No, we shall have one soon against Putin.
@@EburdeyGordei4 if common people were happy they wouldn't join revolutions
Any large country with a history associated with revolution) in the 19th century in Europe there were a number of revolutions, France, Germany, the Austrian Empire, the Italian states, Poland, Hungary, etc.
@@EburdeyGordei4 у революций есть бенефициары, это да, но главные причины всегда внутри. Например февральская революция: каким образом и кто её поддержал? Вы вообще помните хронологию событий?
Great job. This is better than most movies I’ve seen recently!
I rarely comment on videos, but this was one of the most fascinating documentaries I've seen regarding Imperial Russia. The narration, illustrations, sequences were above and beyond.
My only complaint is that it wasn't long enough. And thats says a lot!
It would be interesting if you can cover Spanish Civil Wars like Carlist Wars...It seems a best fit for this wonderful channel...Cheers and best Epic History TV
How come no one has produced a miniseries on Alexander I ?
Part one- Tsarovich and enlightenment through his grandmother
Part two- Assassination of father and Succession
Part three - Cat & Mouse with Napoleon and the 1812 burning of Moscow
Part 4- the conquering hero and Vienna
Part 5 - paranoia, plotters, death and Decembrists
Now I need a studio and some 💵
I'd love a video from Epic History TV about the Caucasus War
This is highly unknown topic. Thanks for making this video!
Man this is the best history channel!!
Great video. Revolutionaries note to self; involve the people...
Could you please make a video on the Russian wild west, the Russian Far east
Fascinating. I will return to watch the second half.
Excellent video. Big thanks for making it available to us all!
This is such a well done documentary. Great content! ❤
This was an absolutely wonderful series.
Ironically the 2019 movie was banned in the US as Russian propaganda... had to buy it in Canada in order to watch it... great movie! Highly recommend it
No it wasn't.
It was very historically inaccurate, but very spectacular
@@Paul_Sergeyev It is called union of salvation. A movie about the decemberists but they were the villains of their own movie.
Is this a Russian bot?
The best Christmas gift
The music you guys use is so good. Ty for the great work
Such good documentary’s, reminds me of what the History channel was when I was young. Thank you for the work you put into this.
indeed men, i miss that old history channel, the one with good documentaries, before ancient aliens came and destroyed everything.
This is fascinating. I had no idea Tsar Alexander was such an intelligent, complicated and nuanced personality. 10:06 shows him to be a man who is conflicted by fear and worry that society might collapse around him, and probably a deep personal fear of suffering the same faith as his father. And a sense of personal responsibility and accountability on the other.
I.e. _I cannot tolerate open insubordination and rebellion. But I also understand that it would be hypocritical of me to go after people for having ideals that until recently I did not only share, but actively encouraged. These people are not doing anything wrong, even if it might prove dangerous and harmful to me in the longer term._
truly a sagacious ruler. in better circumstances he could have done much for russians
Editor really loves that flame transition.
Lol
Extremely well done retelling.
Love these longer videos. keep up the good work
As a Russian, I consider this whole situation to be the main tragedy of Russia. Russia has never had a stable democracy, democratic revolutions have failed in many cases. And if they succeeded, then this success was only in the most difficult times for Russia, for example in February 1917 or in 1991. Because of this, democrats could never gain popular support, because soon after democratic revolutions, through intrigue and deception, an autocrat came to power, who blamed liberals and democrats for all the troubles, when in fact the autocracies before the revolution were to blame for Russia's impoverishment. And so on in a circle...
As a Russian, I like how British are interested in Russian history. But the author of this channel completely forgot to mention, that Tsar Paul was killed by support of British embassy. All that plot was organised by britains, because Paul didn’t want to be the part of anti French coalition
Where is the evidence of this? I'm very curious about this allegation.
@@zanderC5953The assasination of Pavel I was orchestrated by Lord Charles Withworth through his mistress, who was the sister of brothers Zubov, directly involved in the plot.
Really fascinating introduction & informative video about Russian 🇷🇺 revolutionaries at 1825- 1850 ... ..👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻👍🏻 such introduction obviously proven Epc history TV 📺 channel...is a great one 👍🏻 🙏🩶🤍🤍
Very nicely explained in simple language, and will help the students understand.
Amazing series. I swear if someone taught me history like that (or any subject for that matter) I'd not be able to get enough of school/university.
This video is amazing! The content is always so engaging.
hello i'm brazilian, you make great documentaries.
Before the December uprising, there were several peasant uprisings on the Senate Square: for two hundred years. The largest are the revolts of Bulavin, Razin, Pugachev. When the rebels took the cities.
Alexander: I am the senate!
When the executioner attempted to hang the five men, three of them, Muravyov-Apostol, Kakhovsky, and Ryleyev, dropped through the trapdoor only to have the rope around their necks break. Ryleyev supposedly told the crowd watching the execution that Russia was an "unhappy country, where they don't even know how to hang you." The Tsar decided to prove otherwise, and simply ordered more rope, and the execution was carried out.
There had been no executions in Russia for 50 years.
In contrast to the constitutional monarchy in Great Britain in the thousands or in the French Republic in the tens of thousands.
@@Николай-г2ы6в Sorry, this was not my point. My point was that if Ryleyev did not badmouth his country he might survived.
It would be a terrible shame for any history buff viewer in TH-cam not to subscribe to this awesome channel!
A terrible shame indeed
Great piece, thank you.
Thank you.
Seems to me one of the problems was exactly the limitation to the military, which then was pulled in 2 directions of loyalty. It should have also spread support among the regular population to have had any change of succes.
That's the thing: they don't trust them...
They fear that the population might turn against them if they got power just like what happened during the French Revolution where even aristocrats who supported the revolution, were sent to the guillotine. Remember, the decemberists were mostly aristocrats.
Can you imagine how many people woulda had their phones out in Senate Square.?
We can't get anything done because we look at our phones all day.
These videos are incredible, nice work
Labor in Siberia in Soviet Russia: work to death
Labor in Siberia in Tsarist Russia: scout camp
Вообще то и там и там можно было спокойно работать. В случае с СССР там ещё и был шанс заработать огромные деньги. Да, заключённым платили шикарные зарплаты, которые потом постепенно отдавали из банка. В царской все было на порядок херовее. Просто если ты дворянин то условия будут лучше
Nice touch with the moving faces! That's probably brand new.
Loved this! So interesting!
25:24 Anyone else notice that this guy shoots everyone EXCEPT the Emperor? The guy he was SUPPOSED to shoot in the first place!?
35:30 - 35:48 is pure comedy
It’s better to fail boldly than suffer safely. After all, we still remember him after 200 years.
@@AYVYNWe remember him because he didn’t do his damn job.💀💀
Fantastic presentation, outstanding quality and good context.
This is such a great channel! Love all your content!
Very good! Thank you!
Thank you for a terrific history lesson.
I was born almost exactly 200 years after Kondraty Ryleyev. It’s interesting how The Decembrists had aristocratic support but believed they didn’t need the people, while Sun Yat-Sen had the people’s support but believed he didn’t need the aristocracy.
16:29 Without a superior ideal, liberty breeds anarchy
Even under average students perform well in their history subject when they accidentally met a legend named"Epic history"
Legends says some even ask for Epic math,Epic science itself"
What Emperor Alexander failed to realize is that he can put down a revolution but he can never put down its ideals.
The film. "Union of Salvation" is on YT, with English subtitles. Worth to be seen!!
Great video
32:08 & 35:30 I’m crying it’s like the author wrote themselves into a corner and decided to awkwardly use Pyotr Kakhovsky TWICE get the plot moving again 😭
7:41 I got scared when they started moving
Good documentary ... really, really good ...
So unexpected and facsinating knowing that Russia had these young aristrocats who looked up to the US and wanted change and freedom not just for themselves and other like them, but also for everyone!
If anyone thinks this kind of magic is finished. It hasn't. It's around us every day. If you have the wit to recognise that, gird your loins and keep fighting every day.
Wat
It's amazing to hear some them were inspired by the American Founding Fathers!
A good half of all revolutionaries across the globe were inspired by American Revolution and the Founding Fathers.
Your country is (or at least was) that shining city upon the hill that everyone tried to imitate.
The Founding Fathers were pro-white. I like them.
@@DizitSjetLmao no.
and not the only one case, in Spain, the jourist Antonio garcia Trevijano, writes a very good books about democracy and constitution based in the first colonial americans.
long time, before de 1911 coup-the-etat made by the federal Reserve, and the 1952 dictatorship of the industrial-military-complex.
@@tylerbozinovski427Yes she was. Read a book
A while ago its either I study for my test or watch this whole video..
Now, I am asking what the title of the movie mentioned at the last part is
Love the voice over !
This is just absolute perfection. Y'all are the best then there's all the rest..and so on.
Thank you.
Edit:I love you
Absolutely fantastic
Love this video. Amazing work.
Masterpiece, as usual
That Video was incredible interesting. Thank you Very much