The Mystery Singer in All You Need Is Love
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 พ.ค. 2020
- All You Need Is Love is one of the most familiar and beloved Beatles songs. But there's a heated debate over who is singing the callback to "She Loves You" during the wild conclusion of the song. But we have a unique piece of evidence that may solve this mystery once and for all: video of the actual recording, broadcast live around the globe in 1967 during BBC's Our World.
And as a warning, once you hear (and see!) it...you can't unhear this.
Help support my channel on Patreon and get early access to new episodes: www.patreon.com/youcantunhear...
Special thanks to @Ryan Baker Gaming for providing some of the source material for the Our World broadcast. / @ryanbaker0
Check out my other videos:
Why Is This Beatles Song So Messy? • Why Is This Beatles So...
The Hidden F-Bomb in 'Hey Jude'
• How The Beatles Snuck ...
#TheBeatles #YouCantUnhearThis #Music
----------
Questions / Comments / Ideas:
youcantunhearthis@ gmail.com
#YCUT #TheBeatles #Music - เพลง
New episode is here!! The channel is nearing 100k subscribers, and I couldn't have done it without you. Thanks for being a fan. Stay safe, and remember: Love is all you need :)
Quality over quantity, my man
How long does it take to produce a video?
How did this get commented 1 hour ago?
@SammytimGaming - Once I've picked the topic, the process from start to finish usually takes about 2 weeks (not full-time, since I have a day job too). It's a labor of love, so I try to shoot for quality over quantity.
Congratulations!
George: "Paul sang that."
Paul: "Yeah, I sang that."
Fans: "No you didn't."
-_-
The video: John
You: derp
@@bobthabuilda1525 Watch the whole video
@@judebeddoe6733 I did, 3 weeks ago. Thanks.
Joshua Caleb The video isn’t the recording on the record.
@@DavidRavenMoon The guy whom made this video even said that George Martin wanted to record it first so there would be no mistakes in the film. It was Paul.
“ringo added percussion”
holy shit. revolutionary.
5:22
Jeez, I thought John was adding that percussion
@Isaac Graham Y*A*W*N*... Zzzzzzzz
Yeah and it wasn't even Paul who didn't say it, it was John. Can't even get his plagiarised lie right.
@Isaac Graham I thought that was John that said that?
well .... it needed to be said .... obvious or not
Paul cued it in, they both sing it. I’ve been listening to this song since I was a kid (on vinyl) and didn’t even know it was a question! As you touch on, it’s funny that we think of the She Loves You callback as so far in their past and yet it was only released 4 years later. Personally I’m pretty much the same as I was 4 years ago. These guys grew so much it’s almost unbelievable.
Yes, I was just thinking to myself out loud "I just don't believe it !" too. 🌹
But they’re artists and an artist can’t remain idle. Their worlds in 4 years were much different than a commoner’s. An artist shouldn’t be complacent. They acclimated to what was happening within their world and did so brilliantly.
They sing it together. I just believe in the blend of their voices being so perfect that it almost sounds like one voice.
I agree
Yep, and that happens because of the closeness of their vocal registers, both were tenors, but Paul was an spinto when he was young and John was a dramatic one, that makes their voices sound so similar sometimes, another proof of that is the second voice on "I Don't Want To Spoil The Party", some people have speculated that it was George or that it was John making a lower harmony, but it was actually Paul imitating John's voice.
and paul sang it with his mic away from him how??? Just John sang it. Sounds like john and all the evidence is john. Why do we have to root for Paul McCartney on every little thing?? Paul did not sing on this one except background vocals in the actual song.
That's not how microphones work. Paul was singing, but all I ever heard, from the first time I listened to it, was John singing. I love it that Paul was singing along with him, but with his mic pointed toward John, his voice is all we hear.
How do I know? Two hours ago I was mixing a five-piece band with five vocalists. They didn't perform any Beatles songs tonight, but they have in the past, but they NAILED the Eagles version of Seven Bridges Road. A song or two later and they pulled out Longest Time by Billy Joel. Plus some soul, roots and originals. These guys can JAM. Look for Woosh out of Chicago if you're interested. ✌❤🎶
Paul wasn't mixed so his dad might as well have joined in too.
*2 Beatles confirm it was paul*
The fandom: But I think it's john
It is John watch the whole video
The fandom is right
It is both. Watch the whole video :)
I've listened to the song for as long as I remember... I've always heard at least two people singing the entire time. It's both Paul and John.
They never said it was Paul singing it. They only said Paul came up with the idea.
Probably the best episode of “You Can’t Unhear This” to date.
100% agree
If you are 100% sure, it's John, then it's John.
If you are not sure, whether it is John or Paul, then it's Paul.
If you have no idea, who's singing, then it's George.
If you hear an angel, then it's Ringo.
Bro he legit solved that so good, once I saw that in depth video I could legit hear it going from paul, to both of them, to John 🤯
agreed!
@@user-bh1xo2vu1y pog
Paul’s poor microphone 😂😂😂 And that reaction to his little trill is just adorable 😁
I was planted firmly in front of the television for this performance- it was mesmerising. And what a great message! Wish we had a group like this doing this right now for the world. We need to hear this in a way that all people will relate to it- and nobody has ever come close to this broadcast’s achievement.
@@SPINNINGMYWHEELS777 what the fuck is wrong with you
John: Harpsichord!
Paul: Double Bass!
George: Violin!
Ringo: Drums.
Ringo got the drums
I once read "Lennon was the soul of The Beatles, George was the spirit, Paul was the heart, and Ringo was the drummer".
I choose drums.
John: Banjo
Me too!
I like to play... ting
Strange that when John talked about maturing musically he said "I don't wanna be singing She Loves You when I'm thirty", makes me wonder if it was a callback or sarcasm
Tonto I thought he said forty
John was in New York after Sgt Pepper, & before going to India. A reporter asked him about the future of the Beatles. He said he could not see himself in the group at 30. After finishing work on "The End", (a song on the album Abbey Road), on August 18, 1969, Lennon informed his bandmates that he was leaving on September 20th. This would be one month before Lennon's 29th birthday. The band did not know what he meant by this, but he never came back.
He was just 26 the day All you need is love was made 😀👍🎶
All of us, as humans we are, (as John too), say a lot of things and forget them later. Greets.
@@eddiewilbury1666 E.G. Pete Townshend and Roger Daltrey "Hope I die 'fore I get old" 😀👍🎶
The reason these things happen is that Paul could mimic John really well.
Hell, he did it on Real Love to make John’s vocals clearer
Bullshit !
They both mimicked one another very well, but Paul did it more because he would often record backups for John songs when John was too lazy to do it.
Feels like I'm watching a breakdown of the Zapruder film.
In the end of song before the She loves you, yeah yeah yeah, Lennon yesterday or yes he's dead ?
As you can see here, the microphone goes back... and to the left
@@robbieclark7828 I was waiting for him to make that joke!
The Zapruder film is less painful to watch than this. Even JFK would agree.
@@robbieclark7828 thanks
The existence of a "Beatle Supervoice", given by John AND Paul unison also mimicking each one timbers, has been so much underrated even by the best known Beatles musical reviewers, such as Ian MacDonald. In fact he did not noticed that the supervoice is used in virtually all early co-penned singles and at least a half of LP Beatles for Sale (No Reply, Eight Days A Week and Every Little Thing among others). This subject would deserve a Chapter of your Beatle history.
I was always surprised that Little Child is not John double tracked. It’s eerie
No Reply is credited as double-tracked John.
@@fanofanimation4293 you’re right there I think, you can tell because when the “I saw the lie” bit comes in his vocal is still double tracked. You can often tell if it’s double tracked or unison singing when they split off into different harmonies. I’m curious tho when you say it’s credited, what source are you referring to?
@@seanwade8188 Oh shit, I'm sorry I'm getting to this comment late lol. I was in Barnes and Nobles and once held a copy of the Beatles for Sale CD (the album No Reply appears on). On the back of the CD sleeve, it says which Beatle sang lead on each song. For No Reply, it says it was John double-track, for Eight Days a Week it says John and Paul, for Every Little Thing it said John and Paul, etc.
"You can't unhear this"
*laughs in memory of a goldfish*
One of the best videos on TH-cam. Congratulations. As a 57 year Beatle Nut, I never knew about the Mic Mishap until now. Thank you. I always knew it was John's voice but now I know that Paul was singing it right along with him....just not with a Mic.
4:40 ah yes, the famous mccartney "half a beard" session
Oh yeah looks like he has half a beard lol
I don’t know where the confusion arises. If you watch the ‘all you need is love’ video you can see both Paul and John singing the line. Paul starts it and John joins in.
Just to make TH-cam money.
@@brandonamezquita4501 indeed. Explains why the video is 5 hours long. Or at least feels like it
Even before you see the video, it's obvious it's Paul. This dude even acknowledged it as well and destroyed the point of the video in the first place. His point is "Its all Paul by all rights and facts, but idk it could be John so forget all that."
I know, it’s so obvious it’s both.
Just like they sang it in She Loves You. Go figure.
I think the only thing we can agree on is it wasn't Ringo!
wtf? no way. sounds like Ringo, always thought it was Ringo. Didn't ever guess it was a mystery.
Or george
Said Thomas, as he went back to the sidings.
i mean the beatles are just Ringo moving really fast- soooo
It was the spirit of Stu
Given that this song was broadcast live to 700 million during the "Our World" program -- available online -- there's no mystery at all to who sings the "She Loves You" chorus. It's John.
It was Yoko, I should know I have almost perfect pitch.
The definition of this channel is quality not quantity
QUANTITY OVER QUALITY ✊🐔
This was truly well done! Glad you cleared that up! Never saw the program. Thanks -- instant sub.
The definition of this channel is 'this guy has far too much time on hands'
When John and Paul sing in unison they create a new person
the pope
@@braulioacosta6816 Damn. You scooped me by 8 months. 🤣🤣🤣
Have you thought about doing a video on how Paul McCartney’s voice cracked on “If I Fell” at 1:46 minutes into the song? He struggled to reach the high note the second time he sang “was in vain” and his voice stopped about a half second sooner than he would have liked. Thanks for considering this!
John sang that song.
@@jamescurtis8570 right by Paul sang the high part
Coincidentally, that's the exact moment in the song where they would laugh as documented in a few live performances of the song on the US 1964 tour.
@@jamescurtis8570 they harmonize on it
@@jamescurtis8570 They both sing it. Paul on the high harmony. Maybe get your ears checked
If you also noticed it looked like Paul might’ve been about to sing “yesterday, all my trouble seems so far away”, but stopped at just “yesterday”. Has anyone else noticed that?
yeah, weird how people didn't talk about the yesterday part
I think that was John. It sounds like his voice to my ears. Could be wrong though.🤷🏼♂️
I was today years old when the penny dropped about why they say "Yesterday" at that part!🤯
That raspy bit sounds like John, but the rest sounds like Paul.
Lol
That''s because it IS Paul. Listen to "Kansas City/Hey, Hey, Hey, Hey" for a raspy Paul.
James Murphy watch the video.
Sounds like John both times to me. The most interesting thing of all, however, is that this looks very much like the original Paul to me, rather than Billy Campbell. Remember they had stopped doing live performances after Paul left the band. There was even speculation that Paul had died which was denied by the Beatles in a fan magazine. Looks like they may have brought him.back for this live TV performance.
@@surfrunnerd8457 There never has been, nor will there ever be, more than one Paul McCartney.
Have you ever noticed that when John and Paul sing in unison, as they do in a good portion of I Want To Hold Your Hand, it almost creates a third voice? Is it possible that J&P were singing in unison? That should satisfy everyone!
Paul can sound exactly like John when he wants to. Have a listen to Let Me Roll It from the Band On The Run album.
They were perfect together.
Mark Provance - If you look at where Paul is singing during the live performances of “I Want to Hold Your Hand,” you can also see George singing alongside him. So technically, the third voice is George’s. Maybe that is a possibility?
Sean McAleavy idk, not disagreeing with Paul being able to sound like John, but I felt like Let Me Roll It was very Paul lol
Resonance and harmonics.. it does exactly that
In my mind it was always Paul but in that isolated vocal at 0:50 it is so distinct and obviously John. All of it. From beginning to end.
The Beatles are famous for using that U47 microphone in omni, so that the sound is picked up from all directions. It is common that they’ve all sang together into this microphone to save track space and eventually became iconic to their sound. I think people are getting confused by who’s singing because a lot of the time it’s more than one member. I wouldn’t be surprised if the overdubs in this song were started by Paul McCartney and everyone joined in. I definitely hear Ringo in there too
- George confirms it was Paul
- Paul confirms it was him
- The video shows Paul singing it
I mean.... was there even a debate here?
For all these years I thought it was Paul without knowing anyone confirmed it.
But the video shows john singing most of it did I miss something
I’m sure that it was paul and maybe some John
The video doesnt show Paul sing it AT ALL, aside from the last few yeahs
I knew it was Paul McCartney. I didn't need evidence. I could tell it was his voice. I'm not saying that there's the odd time where you need evidence to know who is singing. But for me, this wasn't one of those times.
Listen closely after She Loves You, during the fade out, someone sings “Yesterday.”
John.
@@JesperSalama Paul?
@@MrManfly Tony Sheridan?
I never heard John sing "Yesterday" until you pointed it out. It's definitely John, but it's before the She Love You part.
@@MrManfly hotel?
I never knew there WAS a mystery until I watched this little gem of Beatles information.
I always believed it was Paul that sang the ''She loves you'' segment but I absolutely agree with you that it is indeed John's voice and that totally surprises me after decades of thinking it was Paul's voice.
Thanks for putting us all right on this topic You Can't Unhear This.
Cheers pal!
As stated before, why do so many Beatles commentators seem to gloss over Magical Mystery Tour ?
It's a brilliant continuation of Pepper
I never noticed there was this much chaos during the recording! Paul's mic going everywhere! Bass flubs?? This was a wild ride
And a very weak guitar solo which doesn't really resolve.
I have always wondered why the bass dropped out there!
I gave it a listen and I am 99.9% certain that Paul says "Oh yeah!" and John sings the whole bit "She loves you yeah yeah yeah". I can tell by the the "She loves you..." It's the way John annunciates differently than Paul.
I completely agree. On both counts. John is singing "She loves you, yeah..." It seems clear to me that it is his voice.
As I always knew...Kind of pointless video. Although watching them perform in anyway, shape or form is great...
Only thing I real thing I got out of this was finding out that dude wasn't Keith Richards...
I never thought it wasn't John. Still don't.
John also enunciates differently than Paul. ;-)
And of course you know better than people who actually were there and recorded it.
SPOILER - The mystery singer is the same guy that sings "Hold my hand, yeah... yeah..." - Ron Nasty.
If you watch the video you can clearly see John singing that part.
I always thought it was Paul kicking it off and John coming in after.
So I was pretty close!
Thanks for another great video. Never knew the live satellite broadcast was where they actually recorded bits of the final record! I always assumed it was lip synced or something.
Excellent, as always. Superb bit of research. A couple of points - the guy in the purple shirt who looks like ‘Keef’ and hits Paul’s mic stand is Tony Bramwell, who had been with them since Liverpool and worked for Brian, I believe Brian’s death should be more accurately referred to as ‘drug overdose’ rather than ‘suicide’ as it’s commonly accepted there’s a strong argument that it was accidental, and finally - I always thought it was John singing ‘She Loves You’, because it sounds like John! It was brilliant to see the footage that highlighted both mics pointing at him.
Thanks for sharing - purple shirt guy has been confirmed!
I was hoping someone would know who the other guy awkwardly hanging out in the background is - it's the ultimate zoom-bombing, long before that was even a thing!
It was John singing "She Loves You" on the single release. Paul sings the "She Loves You" snippet on "All You Need is Love". Likewise it was Paul singing "Yesterday" on the single release. John sings the "Yesterday" snippet on "All You Need is Love".
You think it sounds like John? Man, even Helen Keller could could hear it was Paul.
Brian died of an accidental drug overdose.
Other than that it was "excellent", LOL
@@dallasbrubaker6054 Sure but who sings on Octopus's Garden. I think that's all we need to know from you.
@@clubredken13 Well gee, I always thought it was Richard Starkey, but I don't know.....perhaps it was Yoko Ono. Does he have any video evidence that it could be Yoko Ono?
In Mark Lewison's book Recording The Beatles, he notes that John had planned on doing some type of odd vocal at the end.
Originally he was singing "She'll be coming around the mountain" and others before singing his own song.
Great job analyzing the nuances of that session.
I would hardly call MMT and Get Back albums "troubled experiments."
I come back at least every other day, just to satisfy myself with George's lovely violin-part
Nobody:
You can't unhear this: Making everyone's quarantine better
Why do people do this?
@@ellitbo9863 idk
Man, I specifically search out YOUR videos to watch while I wind down with a bath after work every day. You really are talented, & as a fellow content creator I totally understand how hard it is to actually CREATE your own videos. & these are absolutely intriguing to the max!
John sang "Yesterday" then Paul followed it with an "Oh yeah!" (he liked the idea and was quick thinking) He proceded to sing "She loves you..." (another old song) John joined in second time round. Simple.
The guy you mentioned waiting for a job interview, looks more like a Time Traveler going back to experience the moment! 🙎♂️🎶
Nah, he looks too bored, a time traveler would be freaking out or blending in knowing how historically significant this event is
hm, sounds dumb
I think he's a time traveler too. But one who's down on his luck and wants to apply for a job. Poor bastard.
I wish I could do that.
I'd look like having fun at least.
“Subtly makes a call back”
“SHE LOVES YOU YEAH YEAH YEAH”
Having been a Beatles connoisseur for more than 50 years I find your videos so educational and worth watching, thanks for the efforts and research
It's still nothing short of AMAZING that they could produce a song this good essentially on demand, within just a week or two.
They wrote Day Tripper in 15 minutes
Forgot to mention where one John or Paul sings, "Yesterday." Surprisingly a reference to...Yesterday.
Spencer Hendren what part of the song?
Yeah I'm surprised No One talks about it, all anyone cares about is the 'she loves you' bit
@@andrewh9005 like 10 seconds before the she loves you bit
@@maxwelledison9954 That's because there isn't a debate over the "Yesterday" part ;) It's definitely John, in an ironic callback to Paul's solo song.
@@YouCantUnhearThis yesterday seems to be an inside joke between the beatles, some session outtakes have them singing that song, and the 1965 christmas record also has a joke version of yesterday. pretty cool huh?
My interpretation has always been: John sings "yesterday" right before it, Paul starts the "she loves you" and John joins in during the second part. It was a bit of a call-and-response sort of thing. I didn't know about Paul's mic getting hit out of the way though, I still hear him a bit in the second "she loves you" but that might just be my brain filling the vocal in.
Yep, I also hear him a bit during the second time around. Maybe he was singing loudly enough that the mics pick him up from a distance?
@@YouCantUnhearThis that makes sense... I was recording a metal track one night with my guitar, but my friend and roommate had the radio on... Needless to say, you could hear the radio behind my guitar solo...
Microphones haven't really changed much since then, they were still quite sensitive...
@@YouCantUnhearThis it could also be because of them having the headphones on, if the backing track was playing it might've caused him to sing a little bit louder than usual. Either that, or he did it intentionally since he saw the mic was pointed away from him...
Yes, I also heard Yesterday
"superficial idealism?" How old are you? Were you there? Because I was (I'm 71) and I can tell you there wasn't a damned thing superficial about it.
"Baby, You're a Rich Man"
is also amazing.
My favorite group at the moment😊
11:35
HE DIDN'T COMMIT SUICIDE! He had attempted to a while before (wrote a note and everything) but he was unsuccesful. He died from an accidental sleeping pill overdose.
As he had plans to visit the Beatles with the Maharishi (i hope i spelled that right) and, based on eye witness accounts, was in good spirits the day of his death, it's very logical that it was an accident
I caught that too, it seems to be well documented that it was accidental.
We should also not rule out foul play. When a famous person dies under strange circumstances, one must always look there as well.
Brian Epstein didn't kill himself
He was murdered! Wait wrong Epstein
Brian's death seems to have been by misadventure. He was unhappy for a long time, and under the influence of pills, but he had plenty of reasons to live (like his devotion to his mother Queenie, his ongoing business ventures, a very successful year for the Beatles, a favorable resolution to the long-festering Sealtaeb dispute). Like a lot of prescription drug abusers, he was prone to misreading dosages and taking them in excess. That's what police determined in 1967, and nothing has changed that since.
I have always thought "Oh yeah" is Paul, John sings "She loves you." This hasn't changed my mind.
This! Can’t believe people are having a hard time telling John and Paul’s voices apart.
so you choose to live in denial?
It's John... I never had any doubt.
@@PastMaster15 Why not that's the reason we are fans.😷
In the video John sings She Loves You Yeah Yeah Yeah.
No mystery. It's obviously John. I've been listening to this from the day it was released, and it never occurred to me before that it could be anyone else. It sounds like John and it makes sense that he would add this bit of irreverence to his own song.
Fantastic narration and knowledge. I was watching it on tv as a 12 year old with my grandmother
I had just turned sweet sixteen, and I clearly remember John singing "She loves you" at the end of the song. What a thrill it was! I remember getting up in the wee small hours, and seeing one of our local Melbourne trams leaving the depot before dawn. But I think everyone my age in Australia was shivering out of bed in the midwinter night for just one thing - The Beatles!
Paul was able to sound like John, and actually sang over certain parts of Free as a Bird, as the quality was poor.
Just stumbled onto this vid from another Beatles clip & stayed for the whole thing. Very enjoyable! I love to wallow in the miscellany & ephemera of music history so this channel is a great find.
As if I needed another reason to love The Beatles... And then I found your channel! Great content!
how is this not the most folkloric thing ever in the history of the beatles's careers
I thought this was another non issue like the "A Day In The Life" thing, especially as we have the video evidence this time. However, you did surprise me. I didn't know all those little details. I had seen the rehearsal take before, and I'm sure I've read that they'd done other songs in other takes.
I reckon Paul did the first one and John thought "thats a great idea" then did it better.
My thoughts as well
Interesting i believe you are correct.
I've always known it was John singing "She Loves You..... Yeah, Yeah, Yeah" I never thought it was Paul. The raspy voice sure sounded like John, anyway. That's why he was singing it before they filmed the song for the performance. Paul might've wanted to join in, but it was John singing it. Great video!!
This is a true masterpiece by John Lennon, with great orchestration by George Martin. The Lennon-Martin relationship produced some amazing stuff ("I Am The Walrus", "A Day In The Life", Strawberry Fields", etc.)
All 3 of those were better than "all you need is love" IMO
I would add tomorrow never knows to that list
YES MORE OF YOU "CANT UNHEAR THIS" I WAS WATING SOOOOOO LONG FOR ANOTHER ONE TO COME OUT YEESSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!
I really LOVE your work and descriptive undertakings with the greatest band in history... I've learned now to listen much more closely...thank you...
I'm sure I've seen a clip of that part and it was John singing she loves you at the end.
They didn’t decline after all you need is love. Magical mystery tour is arguably better
Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane were first recorded for Sgt. Pepper... but were released as A and B sides of a 45 RPM single while the rest of Sgt Peppers was being recorded. Then the Beatles only wanted new material on the Sgt Pepper album. George Martin called it his biggest mistake as Producer...not putting his foot down. Can you just imagine if Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane had been included on Sgt Pepper? WOW...
@@johncleghorn4656 In some ways they are a double album.
Things I like about MMTour are 1) Baby You're a Rich Man -the bass on that is the best psychedelic bass line I've ever heard, -the theme is anti-capitalism (John) & I think it shows the maturation of John into a political commentator. 2) I am the Walrus -a complex construction, also political - turning points
@@devnull8598 I especially like the take that's on Anthology 2 of 'Walrus' where someone screws up but they keep going a second later, it's not as over engineered as the version on Magical Myst Tour(I think it's the guitar sound that stands out a lit'l more).
@@stevenbuck07 Mike Pachelli is a guitar instructor here on youtube who focuses on teaching Beatles and whether you play guitar or not it can be interesting to watch his videos because he teaches backstory-behind-the-scenes info as he teaches the songs. Just an FYI if you haven't seen his videos you may like them.
th-cam.com/video/3j41eTpsr70/w-d-xo.html
Also, in the beginning of Good Day Sunshine, you can hear someone humming or mumbling something.
Edit: Good Day Sunshine isn't the right song. It's definitely a Beatle song but I don't know which one.
I always wondered about that. In the middle of the line "she feels good/she knows she's looking fine", right?
@@WobblesandBean There's that also. I might have named the wrong song.
@@WobblesandBean Yeah, I named the wrong song, it's a Beatle song but I don't know which one.
Taxman?
If u mean ya mean taxman I’m pretty sure that’s George
It's important to note, as you do at 10:30, just how potent this musical moment was, for the Beatles and the culture. Unimaginable today.
Now that you've pointed it out, the vowel/diphtong in the first syllable on the word "loves" sounds very distinct from the first and second time it's heard. First time it has a thicker accent which might be Paul. Second time it's less thick which might be John.
It was Jonh's voice imitating Paul's when imitating him
It’s amazing how we still talk and discuss music from 60 years ago nearly and still find new things and ponder over it
Great information and insight, as always, but even more, a great piece of journalism. Just exceptionally well-written, well-presented, and engaging. I really enjoy your work and always learn something. Which is impossible, because I know everything. Well, some stuff, any way.
I agréé, but am shocked that hé said Brian killed himself. I don't remember the story being like that.
Very interesting . Thanks for the time and effort you put in !
So Paul cued John to keep going despite the mic incident. Good teamwork. It's a shame they didn't tour together more and stay together.
THEY WERE BOTH SINGING!!!!!I KNEW IT
* brackets *
The clip they showed of the Beatles singing She Loves You have both John and Paul singing together. It would make sense they also sang that part together on All You Need Is Love.
One of best Beatles moments!
Great video!!
Hehe, your videos are so much fun to watch, being an original Beatles fan, these are great revelations. Ty. I think it’s Paul first then predominantly John given the rasp is quite revealing.
The footage of John singing it during the “rehearsal” would imply that maybe it was John’s tongue-in-cheek idea, and it certainly seems more like something he would come up with, especially after the announcer implies that it’s a new song, “offered to the whole world” … definitely John’s sense of humor.
i read or heard somewhere that the reason that the “she loves you” part was originally added was because john thought that “all you need is love” would be their last song, to end it on a sort of high note (pun intended)
Great investigative work here! Thank you!
I just now viewed this, outstanding work, thank you for your time and effort, much appreciated 👍🏻
...and I thought that " there's nothing you can know that isn't known?" 😀👍
I think it's actually John, you can hear it at the second "yeah" with the classic John raspy voice
It absolutely is John. You can see him singing it in the broadcast.
Did you watch the video? It was both of them, but with the mike being moved, you hear John
I’m so confused as to why you people are commenting, still speculating that it’s just John. Did you not watch the damn video at all???
th-cam.com/video/0zRW-A5aDuU/w-d-xo.html its john
wow this is an awesome video. kudos for catching something so unique that nobody noticed before! i'm really impressed with you. i was a teenage beatle fan in the early '70's in salt lake city. if you had advertised this as a midnight-weekend showing at the broadway theatre, you would have sold-out both shows. to see footage of the beatles back then was impossible. they would show 'yellow submarine' every 4th of july. that 10 sec of the beatles at the very end of the film was all the beatles we got to see.
It's John. Definitely his voice. Plus y
ou clearly see him singing this part on the Our World show.
you didnt watch, did you?
@@stephanieweiss9220 Yes. 👍
Another thing i noticed is that around the 27 second mark in the album version, the one that was remastered 2009, you hear in the right channel someone say "check," maybe a sound engineer or maybe one of them.
Very easy, Paul McCartney does the first, John the last.
I thin it's very obviously John.
And granted they did several takes and might not remember exactly what the final mix used.
I think John sings the whole bit. The voice doesn’t change throughout the bit. Also, you can hear a GLIMPSE of John’s iconic raspy voice.
Seems to me that Paul started "She Loves You" honoring John's talent, because John honored Paul by stanting to sing "Yesterday" a few seconds before.
Paul: it’s gonna be fun.
People with signs. No not for u
It sounds like John, never had a doubt, it was also like John playing about !
The Beatles also did work with Indian musician Ravi Shankar 3 of my favourite songs The Beatles did with Ravi Shankar are “The Inner Light” (track 6 on the Past Masters volume 2 album), Love You Too (track 4 on both Revolver and The Yellow Submarine soundtrack) and Within You Without You (track 8 on Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band)
Wow this is amazing. I always thought it was Paul. But now I can hear John clearly.
This is a great series
Who sings "Hold my hand" in the Rutles "Love Life" 😀
Dirk (Eric Idle) or was it Ollie Halsell...
I remember this song which was played all the time. It was released as a single, and later on the album “Magical Mystery Tour” which was added as their last resort.
these just keep getting better & better. well done.