It is crazy how people still doubt SHINee's live performances, how they often suspect lip-sync because it all sounds too perfect. Now this is real LIVE in Japan where they ban lip-syncing in concerts. Can we now all agree that SHINee can and do sing live amazingly well?
Shinee is literally the ONLY group I can listen to to make me feel better when I'm upset. Their vocals just have so much emotion in them and their harmonizations are perfect and soothing to the ears.
Everyone is saying SHINee's LIVES are so good, it's just like the CD BUT I DISAGREE with the CD thing.. For me, SHINee's LIVES ARE WAY BETTER THAN THE CD VERSIONS... way way way better. Those raw, unfiltered, beautiful voices... So so so good..
MyCode shinee songs in spotify are mostly live and a friend asked me why are they playing the live versions instead of the recorded ones and i said because its better
ikr i like the studio versions too, but my flamers heart flutters listening to live performances, because Minho's voice becomes so clear and distinctive in harmonization parts, i've noticed this in many lives TT TT just everyone's voices sound so fresh and the breathing
MyCode This is my theory why SHINee's music video views aren't always quite as high. Once they start performing a song live, all of the fans would MUCH RATHER watch/listen to those videos than the studio version. As good as the studio versions are, these boys are just phenomenal live.
And the music video is extremely touching, especially when you watch the 15 minute version to understand deeply the storyline. It's beautiful and I used to cry while watching it, now I cry but not only for the story, but for life imitating art.
Their vocals are unbelievably beautiful..how can they sound this beautiful🥺❤️CDNee for sure💎💎 Minho's voice sound more beautiful when he sings japan..his voice really fit in to japanese songs.
I got to know them since 2018 but damn when I started to explore them more and more gosh I was blown away They were sooo sooo ahead in time They are beyond kpop or any tag And they still maintain that standard Shinee=YOU CAN'T COMPARE/YOU CAN'T COMPETE WITH They are actually the most talented, consistent and unique artists not only in the kpop industry but in the whole world Whether it's REPLAY or DON'T CALL ME I can listen to them all day all night on repeat mode That's the power they hold any random album can blow you away Their voice in my headphones take me on a journey 😀 It's not about just title tracks,no.1 singles with shinee I love each and every song of all the albums Be it their first album or the latest album That's what legends are all about And yeah SHINEE'S BACK And I will always be here forever to support them
Same, I've been a fan since 2018. They're the only kpop group I've been listening to constently. They are incomparable, they really have their own color. There a lot of kpop groups nowadays but SHINee, they are the standards .
They're everything for me now too Listening these clips Maje me happy also sad at the same type How amazing was Jonghyunssi voice They're gifted so talented hardworking humans
This song so emotional.. Jong oppa thank u for everything. I am never forget you. You always in my heart, thank u for good voice,good work,good smile,and everything.. I miss you so much oppa.. Now I cant see your smile,laugh,voice,face and humor again.. Rest in peace oppa.. Sleep well My baby Dino My baby bling bling. You always is Shinee member forever.. You did well oppa. You did well
My singing instructor always told us if you ever wanted to tell if a man is lip syncing.. watch his throat. If they are lip syncing the adams apple will not move. You watch these boys and all of them are moving, you can also tell by how they breath, especially on those super high notes, if you are syncing it your not going to take that huge of a breath unless you are consciously thinking about it.. which as most people wouldn't even notice that there is no reason to.
Their best japanese song ever. Dont know how many times i keep replaying onew wink. So effing cute while smiling n singing at the same time. Makes me smile yet feel nostalgic knowing tat i will never hear jonghyun amazing adlibs in future songs. Can never be replaced. He is in a happy place now, away frm all the pains anitin that is depressing him. Kim Jonghyun will forever be remembered. SHINee FIGHTING!
One of my fav songs of SHINee. I just had to be here to remember how lucky I am for found them. I love you forever, my four people and my angel Jjong. Proud Shawol :")
shinee five vocalists showing how it's done... i'm so glad they ended in the group together and i got to know them and their music. happy to be shawol :))
Fly with the Angels Jonghyun you are loved by all of us fans and will be missed, rest in peace, always remembered. Prayers for your family and brothers.
Listening to the harmonization of SHINee is like listening to angels from heaven. It's absolute perfection😘😘. And didn't I say I almost died from Jinki's wink ♥️😘
Perfection! It made me remember a beautiful period in my life, when my daughter and I had discovered k-pop, and it was a beautiful period for them, too, because they were 5... It still hurts so much...
It's such a bittersweet feeling hearing this song because this was the song that made me a Shawol. It hurts hearing it, but with time it'll hopefully get better. I love you and I miss you so much, Jonghyun ♥
Crystal clear voices with different decorations with pearls.✨ The voices are so different and melodious . Their voices is pleasent to the mind ,to heart and to hear.✨✨.
isn't this where dbsk did that Breathtaking Performance of Why Did I Fall In Love With You ? it's funny cause i always thought that shinee are the young dbsk but unlike tvxq i hope they continue their succes together forever and this is my favorite song of them and they are singing it perfectly
IMN 1004 OMG yes you are right this may not be the same place but this reminds me so much of that performamce. The vibes and everything, it is so similar. And yes all we Shawols hope they always stay together and reach huge milestones in their lives.
I just love how their voices are blending so perfectly. Like, omg, how can they even do that. Their voices are all unique but yet they blend so well. 👑👑👑👑👑💎💎💎💎💎
The first time I watched this, I burst into tears. Because it was so beautiful it ached. Watching for the second time in a row, I burst into tears again. Because it IS beautiful. It hurts, but it is utterly beautiful.
Jan.2,2018..."1000, always by your side"...I will be just for you,Shinee.Although,i can't help not to cry for I know it won't be the same again without Him(Jonghyun),still im fine with that and we will have to accept it and move on...Anyway,these memories and songs will FOREVER linger on...
![[SUB] The first ever ⟪HARD⟫ performance by SHINee on TV as a whole #SHINEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6RycjP37IW8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SUB] The first ever ⟪HARD⟫ performance by SHINee on TV as a whole #SHINEE](/img/tr.png)
It is crazy how people still doubt SHINee's live performances, how they often suspect lip-sync because it all sounds too perfect. Now this is real LIVE in Japan where they ban lip-syncing in concerts. Can we now all agree that SHINee can and do sing live amazingly well?
+Aiorel Aibeck agreed. and this song even i just cant listen to it without crying alone so much.
this is proof positive that they can and do sing live perfectly! i love it!
Aiorel Aibeck 👍👍
Shinee always sing live😁
ฮู้.เสียงจง.คือที่สุดเลน.คือร้องสดสุดยอด👍👍👍👍ชายนี่เก่งจริงๆๆ
I don't remember how many times I visit this performance for the last 8 years (and more)
When live performance is better than recording studio version
Shinee standard
Who else was attacked by not only their singing, but also Onew's wink at 3:14
I came here because Onew's wink 🤣🤣
I was totally unprepared for it. 🙈
I can't describe the feels!!!
My friend literally sent a link that started at the wink JUST to attack me.
It's part of my playlist on my way to work and each time when the wink occurs I smile like "I'm happy now". Love love Onew...
Minho : Hyung, what we having for breakfast? Jinki : Our CDs.
1000 years, always by your side Jonghyun 💔
2023 August and still falling in love with their melody.
2024 may.
2024 September.
Harmony is amazing. No doubt why they are called the vocal Kings 😍
Shinee is literally the ONLY group I can listen to to make me feel better when I'm upset. Their vocals just have so much emotion in them and their harmonizations are perfect and soothing to the ears.
Agree!👍
Agree...💓💓💓
They've distinguished voices
Everyone is saying SHINee's LIVES are so good, it's just like the CD BUT I DISAGREE with the CD thing..
For me, SHINee's LIVES ARE WAY BETTER THAN THE CD VERSIONS... way way way better.
Those raw, unfiltered, beautiful voices... So so so good..
Completely agree
MyCode shinee songs in spotify are mostly live and a friend asked me why are they playing the live versions instead of the recorded ones and i said because its better
Yeah.. Exactly. SHINee is that group whom you'll even like to show the LIVE MORE THAN THE "safe" CD AUDIOS.
ikr i like the studio versions too, but my flamers heart flutters listening to live performances, because Minho's voice becomes so clear and distinctive in harmonization parts, i've noticed this in many lives TT TT just everyone's voices sound so fresh and the breathing
MyCode This is my theory why SHINee's music video views aren't always quite as high. Once they start performing a song live, all of the fans would MUCH RATHER watch/listen to those videos than the studio version. As good as the studio versions are, these boys are just phenomenal live.
2024 still love them
Eu também, rs! ❤❤🇧🇷🇧🇷☕️☕️🌹🌹🙏🙏💐💐🎁🎁❤️❤️
I had to come here. This is one of my favorite songs. It hurts so much.
And the music video is extremely touching, especially when you watch the 15 minute version to understand deeply the storyline. It's beautiful and I used to cry while watching it, now I cry but not only for the story, but for life imitating art.
This is definitely a good song to remember him by, especially with the lyrics.
schuuichiminamino i just can't stop crying for him my heart is aches too much and this song is so touching
This has always been my favorite song by SHINee!! 💔💔
Same here...2020 til forever😍
Eventhough all SHINee performances are top tier, but this one is trully really amazing!!! And Jinki's wink 😍
When it comes to kpop SHINee's got the best vocals.
1000 years with you SHINee, aight bet.
Their vocals are unbelievably beautiful..how can they sound this beautiful🥺❤️CDNee for sure💎💎
Minho's voice sound more beautiful when he sings japan..his voice really fit in to japanese songs.
I got to know them since 2018 but damn when I started to explore them more and more gosh I was blown away
They were sooo sooo ahead in time
They are beyond kpop or any tag
And they still maintain that standard
Shinee=YOU CAN'T COMPARE/YOU CAN'T COMPETE WITH
They are actually the most talented, consistent and unique artists not only in the kpop industry but in the whole world Whether it's REPLAY or DON'T CALL ME
I can listen to them all day all night on repeat mode
That's the power they hold
any random album can blow you away
Their voice in my headphones take me on a journey 😀
It's not about just title tracks,no.1 singles with shinee
I love each and every song of all the albums
Be it their first album or the latest album
That's what legends are all about
And yeah SHINEE'S BACK
And I will always be here forever to support them
Same, I've been a fan since 2018. They're the only kpop group I've been listening to constently. They are incomparable, they really have their own color. There a lot of kpop groups nowadays but SHINee, they are the standards .
@@BLUE-hx3xs yes
That's true
They are something else talentwise
I also feel the same way towards their music
They're everything for me now too
Listening these clips Maje me happy also sad at the same type
How amazing was Jonghyunssi voice
They're gifted so talented hardworking humans
Back again in 2023.. magnificnet performance and harmony. Onew please be healthy and combecak soon with SHINee, I miss your voice
He's back!!!! Our Onew is back, hello from 2024🩵
Onew's wink is everything!
shinee ballads always sound better live
この５人のharmonyがほんとに好きです。なんだろう…魂が清い感じがある。
3yrs of being a fan and I'm still by your side guys . Fighting!
Saaaaaaame!!!
☺️💙
i love all their voices individually but also when they all sing together ❤️
素晴らしい😭♥️大好きなSHINee💎改めて、何度でも、惚れ直します💕😭5HINeeに会いたいなぁ😭😭😭
무더운 여름에 들어도 바람이 느껴지는 노래
This song so emotional.. Jong oppa thank u for everything. I am never forget you. You always in my heart, thank u for good voice,good work,good smile,and everything.. I miss you so much oppa.. Now I cant see your smile,laugh,voice,face and humor again.. Rest in peace oppa.. Sleep well My baby Dino My baby bling bling. You always is Shinee member forever.. You did well oppa. You did well
Onew's voice and that wink! Come back soon, bunny. We miss you.
3:14 con ese guiño y su sonrisa se gano el cielo, el fandom ... todo... te amo Jinkiiiii
오랜만에 생각나서 들으러왔어.. 13년도 정말 바쁜 샤이니였는데 그 해 샤이니 팬이 되버린 나는 참 행복했는데.. 이제는 본인들이 행복한걸 1순위로 했으면 좋겠다!
My singing instructor always told us if you ever wanted to tell if a man is lip syncing.. watch his throat. If they are lip syncing the adams apple will not move. You watch these boys and all of them are moving, you can also tell by how they breath, especially on those super high notes, if you are syncing it your not going to take that huge of a breath unless you are consciously thinking about it.. which as most people wouldn't even notice that there is no reason to.
샤이니는 가장 완벽한 그룹입니다
2024 come here because I miss them
Their best japanese song ever. Dont know how many times i keep replaying onew wink. So effing cute while smiling n singing at the same time. Makes me smile yet feel nostalgic knowing tat i will never hear jonghyun amazing adlibs in future songs. Can never be replaced. He is in a happy place now, away frm all the pains anitin that is depressing him. Kim Jonghyun will forever be remembered. SHINee FIGHTING!
This is one of the best! I'm with you is also top notch.
Agree. This is a true masterpiece, both song and mv.
and they sing this after they perform Juliet, exhausting yet delivers smoothly sounds like recorded one
주기적으로 듣고 있어요. 라이브 들을 때마다 2013년으로 돌아가게 되네요.
If you are back here 2023
You rock!
2024 here!!❤
The 5 Shining Princes of Live Performances!
✨ 5HINee 💎👌
This has always been my favorite song by SHINee and I was so sad to hear the news this morning. R.I.P Jonghyun. You will be missed 😭
이 영상은 고화질로 계속 남겨야 하는데 .. 라이브 봐...
하 진짜 몇번 들어도 천상계들
3:00-3:19 dat mesmerizing voice of onew❤💕😘 😍
Luv u SHINee
the best KPOP group .....
I comeback to heard this song again. I really love SHINee
มินโฮแร็พเก่งสดๆๆ👍👍👍
この曲大好き❤
this song always makes me want to cry
One of my fav songs of SHINee. I just had to be here to remember how lucky I am for found them. I love you forever, my four people and my angel Jjong. Proud Shawol :")
shinee five vocalists showing how it's done... i'm so glad they ended in the group together and i got to know them and their music. happy to be shawol :))
Absolutely. Such a fantastic grouping of beautiful singers.
OMG!!!! onew so amazing has an angelic voice....so handsome and cute without trying to hard....love him...ILoVE shinee
My fav performance simple but incredible❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Jinki's wink always gets me SO FREAKING PRECIOUS
This song has a whole new meaning to it now. Always in our hearts, always by your side Jonghyun
onew's voice>
its already 2021 and im still here again ang again bcs of how angelic jonghyun's voice is
I miss you Jonghyun.
Their voice.. and Minho's visual.. Oh My God..
Aww this remind me why I love SHINee ♥ And I'll always love them no matter what~ I'll ALWAYS be a loyal fan
dammit jinki i wasn't ready for that wink
This lyrics make me cry so much rn. Back then my eyes just swell but now it's different. Jjong you're happy I know that.
Fly with the Angels Jonghyun you are loved by all of us fans and will be missed, rest in peace, always remembered. Prayers for your family and brothers.
I remember how magical I thought this performance seemed back then and wishing I was apart of the crowd to witness it. Still wishing it to this day. 😭
Listening to the harmonization of SHINee is like listening to angels from heaven. It's absolute perfection😘😘.
And didn't I say I almost died from Jinki's wink ♥️😘
Just noticed that Minho actually has a soft and warm tone 👍
That’s my SHINee, just live only live! Proud of them..legend!
I want to tattoo this video on my brain so I can rewatch it anytime I want. I love this so much.
2020
I always end up watching this again.. one of their best live perf.
Perfection! It made me remember a beautiful period in my life, when my daughter and I had discovered k-pop, and it was a beautiful period for them, too, because they were 5... It still hurts so much...
It's such a bittersweet feeling hearing this song because this was the song that made me a Shawol. It hurts hearing it, but with time it'll hopefully get better. I love you and I miss you so much, Jonghyun ♥
I miss you shinee.. the king of live vocals for me...
I can hear minho 's voice in the chorus😍
SHINee's Japanese songs are on another level!
King of live...
First time hearing this song, it’s really really nice and I love the great harmonizations. Also I like Key’s eyeliner
Been years since i heard this song
This song, the mv always gets the tears
One of fav ballads of shinee
Crystal clear voices with different decorations with pearls.✨ The voices are so different and melodious . Their voices is pleasent to the mind ,to heart and to hear.✨✨.
SO GOOD SHINee!!!
isn't this where dbsk did that Breathtaking Performance of Why Did I Fall In Love With You ? it's funny cause i always thought that shinee are the young dbsk but unlike tvxq i hope they continue their succes together forever and this is my favorite song of them and they are singing it perfectly
IMN 1004 OMG yes you are right this may not be the same place but this reminds me so much of that performamce. The vibes and everything, it is so similar. And yes all we Shawols hope they always stay together and reach huge milestones in their lives.
Our precious diamond, Jonghyun thank you so much for everything you've done for us. We will forever remember the lovely memories you left behind.❤
I think no one regrets to be a shawol right?
So I am 😌❤️
Proud to be a shawol always ❤️😌.
3:00 온유 가성 쩐다 종현도 놀라서 슬쩍 보는거 같음..ㅋㅋ
I am crying so hard i already miss him and this song is just.. 😢
I just love how their voices are blending so perfectly. Like, omg, how can they even do that. Their voices are all unique but yet they blend so well. 👑👑👑👑👑💎💎💎💎💎
The first time I watched this, I burst into tears. Because it was so beautiful it ached.
Watching for the second time in a row, I burst into tears again. Because it IS beautiful. It hurts, but it is utterly beautiful.
I really enjoy their slow songs, and they all have amaaaazing voices, even the rappers! Wow! So good!!
5년째 보러오는중
YEARS HAVE PASSED BUT SOMEHOW THIS KEEPS GETTING BETTER EVERY TIME I WATCH IT
Jan.2,2018..."1000, always by your side"...I will be just for you,Shinee.Although,i can't help not to cry for I know it won't be the same again without Him(Jonghyun),still im fine with that and we will have to accept it and move on...Anyway,these memories and songs will FOREVER linger on...
A voz do Jonghyun é incrível!!
The pitch. The tone. The control. These boys are perfect singers ❤️ wow to be this good is incredible 💎💎💎💎💎
They're all amazing,/unique voices 😱😭 even the rap lines.. specially Onew's falsettos,got no words, just just 👋👍👍👃💘
They still sound heavenly like angels after 3 hr concert when I lost my voice after 1hr of screaming .... Slaying it my CDnee~
The harmony gives me chills!!!
샤이니 레전드 라이브 ㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ고화질 찾고싶다
The first song I ever heard of SHINee and they snatched my weave so badly that my hair still haven't grown an inch yet. 5HINee 💕
One of the many SHINEE songs Ilike😍😍😍Missing Jonghyun tho
Thank you shinee for always giving us your all. Jonghyun oppa you did well and thank you. Shinee fighting and shining always and always with you
I keep coming here daily because of Onew's wink.
Im crying but i wanted to say something i never got the chance to say to your face: kim jonghyun, thank you, for everthing.
i always come back here just to watch Jinki's wink
My forever favourite Japanese live😍
Onew is love ❤️❤️
And his wink...so cute...i always feel like winking back 😅😅