Ralf and the current crew can “meet me again” any time, age is just a number and they have still got that certain class. Life is timeless, Europe endless.
ein Super Band, echt sehr Stolz darauf das einen Super Band wie Kraftwerkt inovation für jeden Gruppe beinflusst hat wie Depeche Mode, Vangelis, Giorgio Moroder, etc. etc. Viva Kraftwerk
@@veridisquo Könntest du das begründen? Mich würde die Ausführung interessieren. Ich hätte bei Vangelis nämlich auch einen gewissen Kraftwerkeinfluss vermutet, auch wenn der sich nicht gerade in Sachen Perfektionismus und Qualität des Masterings äußert. Aber so manches Vangelis Stück aus den 70er Jahren erinnert prinzipiell sehr an Lieder von Kraftwerks Autobahn und Radioaktivität.
@@paralamota8632I was about to mention that. Those mistakes and overhead cameras show they are playing during performances just not 100% of it. Ralf seems to play a lot of the melodic stuff.
I attended the Vancouver concert on July 10th, and as I walked in I passed the sound desk at the back of the theatre. Being nosy, I walked back to the sound desk after finding my seat and attempted to start a conversation with the engineers. There was no fencing around them so I could get right in there. Being respectful of their time, I simply asked what all the equipment did, as there was quite a lot of servers and other unusual pieces of equipment. They politely broke it down into video, audio, lighting, mixing, and comms. They pointed to an area of hardware and said those were the most important boxes as it contained all the tracks for the performances. I asked, do they actually play…in which one guy smiled and said “A little bit”. I have my suspicions they don’t do much as I’ve watched many videos from different cities on this tour, and the sets sound and look exactly the same. Whatever, I see them as a museum piece. Well worth the money to hear the music in its full glory, and see Ralph doing his thing. I think his vocals are genuine, but the vocoder vocals are canned, even though he lip syncs them.
Ralf plays some melodies. Vocoder parts are done live, but sometimes with pre recorded backup vocoder vocals. The other members are tweaking parts of the sound (or sometimes even play samples).
@@timschulz9563 During "Tour de France" the melody is doubled by the player to his immediate right (Henning) - during one of the overhead view videos you can see it. Some of the more known rhythm tracks from the record are sampled but it's not just a matter of Kraftwerk "jamming to our backup tracks", all the audio, video, and live instrumentation/voice are synchronized and it's pretty amazingly technical. And the two times I've seen them live the sound quality is by far the best I've heard in over 40 years of going to concerts. They are the standard.
He 100% ain't playing here,its Handsynching to the actual keys but he ain't pressing em down. All in all,its a pre-programmed Cubase Setlist,the Midi-Controllers of each person are connected via Cubase System Link and everyone has limited ability to influence the sound trough change of LFO Curves (Filters but NOT the actual programmed melodies) and can throw in a few samples at times. Its still music and art 50/50 but the times of every Performance beeing unique ended mid 80's. With MIDI and Sequencing Patterns that are save and editable on the fly,it wouldn't make much sense to stagnate and play like old Kraftwerk anyways (its like having your car build by humans instead of machines,can be done but at what cost and why)
To by bylo cos: Kraftwerk i Rammstein na jednej svenie razem wykonują "Das Model choc Kraftwerk sie wypowiadali ze im ten cover Rammsteina sie niepodoba
Parece que desceu "o espírito no home" (homem), Rakanakataka Boing Boom Tschak Peng. Kraftwerk não produs músicas, produs Obras de Arte, Visual, Sonora, Tecnológica. Químicos do Som, Físicos das Ondas Sonoras. Artitas das Matizes Musicais. Pós PhD em Psicoacústica. Só perde para o Coral dos Anjos louvando o Altíssimo nos Céus. Para quem não conhece, usando fones de ouvidos da alta qualidade, pode começar com Autobahn de 1974, para houvir um "abuso de estereofonia", uma farta sonoridade psicodélica, uma Obra de Arte, que apesar de ser de 1974 parece ser mais moderno e atual que os lançamentos dia após dia. Kraftwerk teve início... ...O tempo passa... ... Mas Kraftwerk... ...Pelo tempo que existir a humanidade... ...Será eterno.
Thats completely Bullshit. He plays always Live...you don´t see it right in the camera because the light and something. He is playing and touching the keys everytime
Ma la bellezza di una loro esibizione risiede proprio nel fitto mistero che l'avvolge, è così che si vive un loro concerto. E chi se ne frega se sono loro o le macchine a suonare: è una balla colossale che la musica elettronica sia solo fredda: e comunque le macchine se non le imposti, se non le programmi, non suonano nulla .
@@KlingKlangMusik : Je suis compositeur de musiques électroniques professionnel et malheureusement je vous certifie que c'est du playback. Les consoles devant eux sont uniquement pour créer des effets sur les sons
@@noisesofhumanity1 you're 100% right, their main melodies are uneditable in their Cubase Set, the Controllers are to play samples or edit Filters but NOT change any melodies
![[Soundboard Rec.] Kraftwerk - Live 10.12.1981 at Muziekcentrum Vredenburg, Utrecht Netherlands](/img/n.gif)
Imagine having a grandfather as cool as Ralf Hütter ❤
Or like Till Lindemann
Ralf and the current crew can “meet me again” any time, age is just a number and they have still got that certain class. Life is timeless, Europe endless.
“Age is just a number” Ayo? 💀
"Age is just a number" And Gulag is just a building :)
Age is just a number kiddo 🤨
Great compilation..Thanks For Sharing♥️
one of Germany"s very last living Music Legends in Late 60s electronic Developments for the Future Electro Music Industry Gods......???? Ralf Hutter
Be happy, be a good person, and love Ralf Hutter. ❤️👍
Right on!
Half Rutter? 😂
@@kraftwerklover69Ralf's evil twin be like:
ein Super Band, echt sehr Stolz darauf das einen Super Band wie Kraftwerkt inovation für jeden Gruppe beinflusst hat wie Depeche Mode, Vangelis, Giorgio Moroder, etc. etc. Viva Kraftwerk
Vangelis war sicherlich nicht von Kraftwerk beeinflusst...
@@veridisquo Könntest du das begründen? Mich würde die Ausführung interessieren.
Ich hätte bei Vangelis nämlich auch einen gewissen Kraftwerkeinfluss vermutet, auch wenn der sich nicht gerade in Sachen Perfektionismus und Qualität des Masterings äußert. Aber so manches Vangelis Stück aus den 70er Jahren erinnert prinzipiell sehr an Lieder von Kraftwerks Autobahn und Radioaktivität.
@@veridisquo You Can Not Be Sure: Listen To "Chariots Of Fire". It Has A Bass-Rhythmic Like "Radio-Activity", For Example.
@@M.EngelhARTare you kidding. This is a simple one note 8th resolution bass. You hear that in every second electronic track. Come on?! 😂😂😂😂
@@FeranceLAB Thank You For Your Message And Listen To The Music And Analyze Like I Also Do It.
Tour de France superb. All of it quality music. Very German, very cool 😊👍
Das model. Was a young teenager when this came out. Love it 😊💪👊❤
the KING....!!!!!!
Ralf, the BigMasterMonster
Love Kraftwerk,but miming & not playing live, thats why it sounds so perfect. Still love the music.
You have no clue
You have no clue
You have no clue
They make mistakes many times this is live not miming at all
@@paralamota8632I was about to mention that. Those mistakes and overhead cameras show they are playing during performances just not 100% of it. Ralf seems to play a lot of the melodic stuff.
Es wird immer weitergehen...
Musik als Träger von Ideen
Musique Non Stop
Techno Pop
I attended the Vancouver concert on July 10th, and as I walked in I passed the sound desk at the back of the theatre. Being nosy, I walked back to the sound desk after finding my seat and attempted to start a conversation with the engineers. There was no fencing around them so I could get right in there. Being respectful of their time, I simply asked what all the equipment did, as there was quite a lot of servers and other unusual pieces of equipment. They politely broke it down into video, audio, lighting, mixing, and comms. They pointed to an area of hardware and said those were the most important boxes as it contained all the tracks for the performances. I asked, do they actually play…in which one guy smiled and said “A little bit”.
I have my suspicions they don’t do much as I’ve watched many videos from different cities on this tour, and the sets sound and look exactly the same. Whatever, I see them as a museum piece. Well worth the money to hear the music in its full glory, and see Ralph doing his thing. I think his vocals are genuine, but the vocoder vocals are canned, even though he lip syncs them.
thanks for the lots of information.
Ralf plays some melodies. Vocoder parts are done live, but sometimes with pre recorded backup vocoder vocals. The other members are tweaking parts of the sound (or sometimes even play samples).
It’s mostly live mixing, and the riff is played live by ralf. Sometimes the bass is played by henning too
@@timschulz9563 During "Tour de France" the melody is doubled by the player to his immediate right (Henning) - during one of the overhead view videos you can see it. Some of the more known rhythm tracks from the record are sampled but it's not just a matter of Kraftwerk "jamming to our backup tracks", all the audio, video, and live instrumentation/voice are synchronized and it's pretty amazingly technical. And the two times I've seen them live the sound quality is by far the best I've heard in over 40 years of going to concerts. They are the standard.
Not Everything You Can Hear There Is Live, But They Always Play Live. I Can Also Hear The Differences.
O velho Ralf Zóio-de-Gato ainda manda ver!
A qualidade deles só aumenta.
I wish they'd update their outfits, they've been wearing these since expo 2000, 23 years ago!
swap with devo?
@@quantize, With ABBA
Wait didn't they use them from 1991 on mns or 1997?
Fr
well acutally 2003 they were wearing suites
❤️❤️❤️
Handsyncing. 🎹✋
whats the track at the beginning he is vibing to?
The Robots
I love them and I know Ralf can play, but in the video it seems like often he’s not actually playing the lines, just touching the keyboard?
Ralf plays always ..... No Playback!
He 100% ain't playing here,its Handsynching to the actual keys but he ain't pressing em down. All in all,its a pre-programmed Cubase Setlist,the Midi-Controllers of each person are connected via Cubase System Link and everyone has limited ability to influence the sound trough change of LFO Curves (Filters but NOT the actual programmed melodies) and can throw in a few samples at times.
Its still music and art 50/50 but the times of every Performance beeing unique ended mid 80's. With MIDI and Sequencing Patterns that are save and editable on the fly,it wouldn't make much sense to stagnate and play like old Kraftwerk anyways (its like having your car build by humans instead of machines,can be done but at what cost and why)
@Grovoeler-e5l hmmmm
2.33 song?
Trans Europa Express
Er ist ein Eloi!!!!
So im curious as to how much of this is playback ?
me too
No Playback!
.....All
Florian Schneider 🖥️
To by bylo cos: Kraftwerk i Rammstein na jednej svenie razem wykonują "Das Model choc Kraftwerk sie wypowiadali ze im ten cover Rammsteina sie niepodoba
Parece que desceu "o espírito no home" (homem), Rakanakataka Boing Boom Tschak Peng.
Kraftwerk não produs músicas, produs Obras de Arte, Visual, Sonora, Tecnológica.
Químicos do Som, Físicos das Ondas Sonoras. Artitas das Matizes Musicais. Pós PhD em Psicoacústica.
Só perde para o Coral dos Anjos louvando o Altíssimo nos Céus.
Para quem não conhece, usando fones de ouvidos da alta qualidade, pode começar com Autobahn de 1974, para houvir um "abuso de estereofonia", uma farta sonoridade psicodélica, uma Obra de Arte, que apesar de ser de 1974 parece ser mais moderno e atual que os lançamentos dia após dia.
Kraftwerk teve início...
...O tempo passa...
... Mas Kraftwerk...
...Pelo tempo que existir a humanidade...
...Será eterno.
Is he actually playing anything?
yes my sir
He wasn’t playing the songs, just going along.
He plays some leads and chords in the songs, but obviously not all the instruments 2:28
th-cam.com/video/7qpO7uLqLQQ/w-d-xo.html
Thats completely Bullshit. He plays always Live...you don´t see it right in the camera because the light and something. He is playing and touching the keys everytime
@@KlingKlangMusik he was having an orgasm at beginning
Oh my god! He’s miming! I’m not even sure he knows how to play keyboards properly! I’m crushed.
He has had classical training of piano playing... you should know that. When He sings, the others play the melody...
Ma la bellezza di una loro esibizione risiede proprio nel fitto mistero che l'avvolge, è così che si vive un loro concerto. E chi se ne frega se sono loro o le macchine a suonare: è una balla colossale che la musica elettronica sia solo fredda: e comunque le macchine se non le imposti, se non le programmi, non suonano nulla .
So German it hurts in a good way!
O Kraftwerk ao vivo é meio sem graça.
Ha. He plays nothing. ;-)
Wrong he plays live
✋ Playback ‼ Big problem one live août 2022
Thats no Playback
@@KlingKlangMusik : Je suis compositeur de musiques électroniques professionnel et malheureusement je vous certifie que c'est du playback. Les consoles devant eux sont uniquement pour créer des effets sur les sons
@@noisesofhumanity1 you're 100% right, their main melodies are uneditable in their Cubase Set, the Controllers are to play samples or edit Filters but NOT change any melodies
Saranno 40 anni , forse più, che "forse suonano e forse no" . Sono i Kraftwerk, sono l'elettronica applicata alla musica, prendere o lasciare!