Should You Go for GENUINE or 3RD PARTY Lenses? (Sony vs Sigma)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ค. 2024
- ▼PortKeys LH7P
www.portkeys.com/lh7p/
▼Subscribe for more contents!!
/ @kenseiakatsu
▼Sony 16-55mm F2.8
amzn.to/3P98cxJ
▼Sigma 18-50mm F2.8
amzn.to/3OPFi5G
[Instagram for Photo Art]
bit.ly/3ReqXiH
[2nd Channel]
• How I Started My 2023 ...
[TikTok]
vt.tiktok.com/ZSeqNSP6b/
[Where I find high quality music and SFX]
Artlist *You get 2 extra free months with this link
bit.ly/3lqBZnl
[Where I get unlimited creative assets]
Motion Array
bit.ly/3uIz8c4
[GEARS] *Includes affiliate links
▷Cameras
Lumix S5II
amzn.to/3WgHXHP
Sony A7III
amzn.to/3u0YyBE
Sony A7IV
amzn.to/3fu5541
Sony FX30
amzn.to/3WKsTkH
Blackmagic Design Pocket Cinema Camera 6K
amzn.to/3Gi5qlJ
GoPro Hero 9 Black
amzn.to/3tbTFX8
▷Lenses
Panasonic LUMIX S 20-60mm F3.5-5.6 L Mount
amzn.to/3MpyFpy
Panasonic LUMIX S 50mm F1.8 L Mount
amzn.to/3OaWToD
Sony 28-70mm F3.5-5.6 FE OSS Kit lens
amzn.to/3IkIuzE
Sigma 24-70mm f/2.8 DG DN Art
amzn.to/3tfMJZ3
Tamron 28-75mm F2.8 G2
amzn.to/40ajl4P
Sony 24-70mm F2.8 GM II
amzn.to/3jx9xRS
Sigma 18-35mm F1.8 Art DC HSM Lens for Canon EF
amzn.to/3UVjVA8
▷Lights
Aputure LS C120d ll
amzn.to/363pNDp
Aputure Light Dome 2
amzn.to/3IfWgUe
Aputure AL-MX Mini Light
amzn.to/40kXMPg
[The Table of Contents]
Intro 00:00
AF Studio 02:10
AF Outside 03:27
PortKeys LH7P 04:59
IS Part1 07:01
IS Part2 07:59
Conclusion 10:02
The Crux 11:25
#Sony1655 #Sigma1850 #sonyfx30 - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
From my point of view as a wedding photographer, sony lenses are the best for the sony system. I have problems with third party lenses when i use auto white balance, usually the color of the skin is affected...
Thanks! This IBIS stuff is more important for the video guys. I like a good lens and am returning to photography after a 10-year absence. Lots have changed. I am very tempted to get 24-70 GM ii, but SIgma looks fantastic and is twice as cheap (1700 GBP VS 900 GBP). My thoughts are to get Sigma and SONY 20mm 1.8, heard it's incredible. But there is always that thought and we forget, that it's not lenses taking pictures, it's people.
Nowadays I think the major 3rd party manufacturers do a good job, good enough for most applications, often you can save some weight/size and usually money. Now, a reason that I see specifically for genuine would be for the new Sony cameras that have breathing compensation (need Sony lenses for that to work), and if that is something you are concerned with (are you using your camera/lenses mostly for video). I have used lots of Sony, Sigma, and Tamron lenses over the years with Sony A6400, A6500, A7III, A7IIIRA, A7C, A9, A7RIV, and A74 and have found great lenses for certain use cases but never (yet!) found the perfect lens for all cases (or at least all cases with that needed that FOV). I have the Sony 200-600mm G OSS, worked great for the A74 and A9, not worth much (AF issues) with the A7iiiR and A7RIV (though I know others haven't had issues). I like Sony for the choices (full frame or APS-C) - you have choices between budget, size, weight, manufacturer origin, warranty length etc. Not a lot of bad options here . . . . we have lots of choices!
That's true!
Best comparison I have seen so far! Thank you. I have got the Sony 16-55 G before the Sigma was released and still love it. It’s that good I almost don’t feel the need to move to full frame. On the photo side I like the extra reach over the Sigma which brings it close to a 85mm full frame equivalent and I guess it is a bit wider,too. But otherwise I fully agree with your conclusion! 👍
I'm waiting for your review on A6700, And if you can compare it with R8.
As a videographer, I usually shoot handheld. and i really like the confidence that sony lenses afford me with the active stabilization option.
have you tried tamron 35-150f2-2.8 and 28-75f2.8, 70-180f2.8 ? i wanna know your opinion about them compared to fe24-105f4
the sony 16-55 good for youtube videos and streming too ?
So, if I want better stabilization, I should put a GM lens with ibis switch, right? What about the new release sony GMii lens..
I think the reason the Sony looke like it has better IS was the extra 200 grams of weight. The heavier the setup, the more kinetic energy it takes to move the object. If the sigma + FX30 had extra 200 grams to match the weight of the 16-55 + FX30, the results could've been more similar
Oh, I didn't expect that one was coming lol
But it sounds about right! I will consider it when I make this kind of video next time! Thank you!!
Hi! I just received my FX30, it’s crazy, but I do not know what goal to take.
As a first lens and for short films and travels, do I need a zoom (as I usually do) or 1/2 fixed focal lengths with a larger aperture)
Then, the manual focus of the sigma seems too small and too close to the camera, is it annoying with a gimbal and for the video?
Today, I can have the sony 16-55 at 644€ or the sigma 18-50 at 184€ (yes it’s huge I have the contacts haha)
What do you recommend?
Thanks for the video!
to be honest if youre using it for video, youre going to be using AF anyways. just get a zoom, especially for travels swapping primes feels like ass. get zooms that cover a wide range and f2.8 of course.
I got Sony GM's and Sigma DG DN. The Sigma is built like a tank.
true
Hello from Canada 🇨🇦, how do yoy compare the image quality of fx30+sigma18-50 vs fx3 with g master 24-70
Thank you for watching!
That's interesting!
There won't be a big difference in a day time, but FX3 with gm will be better in a low light situation.
@@KenseiAkatsu thank you ❤️ for replying, I’ve one last question, I just started doing music videos, my budget was until fx30, I wouldn’t had the budget for fx3, so I’m learning how to work with lights and proper lighting for my scenes. My question is sometimes I think if my image quality is on a level with a full frame camera, so do you think that fx30 with sigma18-50 is something serious or should I get a full frame?
My main camera is fx30 too
Great!!!
Which do you go for??
Sigma. All-rounder for a great price.
Thank you for your honesty. Great content as usual.
I always try and go native, but when the price difference is $500+ between a Sigma Vs Sony, I don’t think it justifies the small gain. For example, because if image stabilization was a huge component I’d just buy a Gimbal or some sort of attachment. As always though, it all comes down to wants and needs. Haha Keep the great videos coming!
Genuine if you have the money.
Commented before seeing the video.lets see.
Thank you for coming back!!
Does the sony lens you used for the stabilization test have a stabilization switch? Is that GM lens?
It is G lens, and doesn't have IBIS switch.
@@KenseiAkatsu So, if I want better stabilization, I should put a GM lens with ibis switch, right?
@@KenseiAkatsu please give me a reply
I use a mix of Sony GM and Sigma lenses. TBH, I dont consider any others except Tamron in specialized cases.
Good strategy!
En que casos tamron?
been having this dilemma for 2 weeks 24-70 sigma vs gmii 😂(i think deciding factor for most is budget)
Go for sigma!!
@@KenseiAkatsu Sigma is coming out with an updated 24-70 that will be lighter. I've been wanting a 24-70 but the new Sony is too expensive for me (not a pro) and the old 24-70 (both Sony and Sigma) is a bit heavy for walking around. The new one should be lighter and more affordable than the GM II. Yay.
have you tried ZVE1
Not yet, but I will soon!!!
I would get the Sigma and save the extra cash. Quality wise they almost indistinguishable.
That's what I recommend most!!
Besides my Sony GM Lenses, I have Zeiss Lenses and Voigtländer APO-Lanthar Lenses, I only want the very best prime Lenses you can get. I do not like Sigma lenses...
Why did the Sony have crushed Blacks?
This is a great comparison, but I have to say I take issue with the use of the word "genuine". This word is thrown around throughout the video but is misused. Sigma lenses are genuine Sigma. Tamron lenses are genuine Tamron. None of these are knockoffs trying to pass for something they are not. Third party manufacturers are not stamping a Sony logo on their lenses. They are real, genuine brands. Referring to Sony as the sole genuine lens manufacturer devalues the other, equally genuine brands. This has nothing to do with price and quality.
Thank you for pointing out!!