I found that the judges don't even know their judging criteria, which is like random act. This caused the loss of many great candidates in this competition. Sometimes they are looking at how much they've changed since the beginning; sometimes they are looking solely on how well/bad they did in one performance.😢 Secondly, I don't understand why some people said 穎蕎 is trying to show off or whatever, but com'on this is a SHOW. Who is not showing whatever they got? She is performing to the max level, then people judge her and saying she is showing off!???? What?
Jer's team performance is not that bad.. Fa Je and Wing have people they want to eliminate in Jer's team ( Fong fong and 子涓 due to public opinion that we don't like them) so I am not complaining.. and no matter how messed up Day's performance is.. u can tell Fa Je will save her no matter what
I think jer's team was a bit too ambitious. It was a good idea but didn't highlight the girl's strong points, which is essential in this round. Nonetheless, it does make this competition more interesting.
Jer, the performance is not about you!!! You're just a consultant, not the director. You should have let your group members decide on what they wanted to do. This song is a wrong choice. It's sad that方芳need to be dismissed because of this performance.
Jer好用心，隊表現完成度亦高，其實佢個組表演我覺得好睇好有深度，個分數咁低真係好奇怪，如果一早default左foul邊個可唔可以唔好玩其他隊員同導師？ 好似真心被玩弄咁，心痛Jer，希望佢唔好自責，佢已經做得好好 💪
Jer really poured his heart into coaching his team. RESPECT!!
Jer 組做得真是ok, 不應該咁低分。全民造星只係一場show, 賽果並無認受性，當綜藝咁睇。
我反而唔同意喎 我同意Joey花姐説法 呢場表演佢哋只係完成咗 但係未master好 而且嗰佈景仲吸引過五位主角 喺觀眾角度睇,喧賓奪主的表現係唔理想㗎 佈景應該係用嚟襯托凸顯主角 俾主角係台上發亮先啱
我相信呢場表演本身係充滿內涵,如果可以show到,呢場表演一定會高分,但係佢哋太多disturbing動作,反而蓋過裏面嘅內涵,呢場表演低分我覺得合理 maybe 23X分 但係21X分真係太誇張
@@yw4872 係Jer野心大咗, 班選手比較無辜.
但Jer其實出發點係幾好
你錯喇，唔係一埸 show 而係一個 interview 佢哋揀人入女團，有佢哋嘅要求。
做咩搵呀Jer 做導師???? 叫個 P.A. 做咪得囉~ 浪費Jer 啲時間
花姐唔洗恰呀JER 恰到咁出面頂你“你都輸啦”wtf!?
我知花姐好想maf嗰隊安全過關而俾好低分JER, 但處理得好!!肉!!酸!!
Jer喊住話唔公平嗰度，硬係覺得之前有啲內容cut走咗
The egg sang very well ......I was quite surprised, Jer is a good teacher!
阿Jer 嗰組咁低分我好surprised!! 見到阿Jer 喊真係有啲不舒服!!
18:39 阿wing呆L左
最應該走嘅唔走 最唔應該走嘅要走 就好似最應該係成龍出事先 竟然係王力宏出事先😂
Gao 同win win都好正 好鐘意睇佢哋
見Jer喊，覺得好心痛。。。
整喊柳柳做咩姐，見到柳柳喊好心痛呀！柳柳個組係最好囉！柳柳好有責任心好好呀但係見到柳柳咁好心痛雖然已經好耐
給 ViuTV, 花姐: 賽制係出問題, 你如果心目中已有女團人選, 係咪應該直接公開個別評分, 例如合作性, 跳舞, 唱歌, 多唔多是非, etc? 搞個隊對隊評分再 foul 人根本冇意義. 如果你純粹為搞一個公平比賽, 就唔好搵有先入為主既圍內人做評判囉. 好似造星1 咁, 完咗比賽先慢慢揀你鍾意既.
Agree！ 假民主，當我哋個個都傻㗎嘅。
I found that the judges don't even know their judging criteria, which is like random act. This caused the loss of many great candidates in this competition.
Sometimes they are looking at how much they've changed since the beginning; sometimes they are looking solely on how well/bad they did in one performance.😢
Secondly, I don't understand why some people said 穎蕎 is trying to show off or whatever, but com'on this is a SHOW. Who is not showing whatever they got?
She is performing to the max level, then people judge her and saying she is showing off!???? What?
寧願人哋戥你唔抵、戥你唔開心
都唔好比人覺得你唔值得
阿Jer呢個表演做到啦。
花姐為阻止方方同子涓入廿強而傷害到Jer，咁樣真係好咩…
老實啦，我也不喜歡方方入十強。但有必要咁低分？尾二都足夠FOUL 佢兩個
咁如果foul咗嘅都有機會pick返入女團，方方同子涓入唔入20強對其他人影響都唔係咁大姐，反正三甲一定無佢地份
吓？我覺得阿Jer 組好好喎，我睇得明喎。唔通現場同鏡頭睇真係咁唔同？
預咗係呢組foul人
我覺得好過阿dee個組囉
喺最低分嘅兩組
復活咗五個人
三個So Ching, Day, Gao 入咗女團
加油！好勁！
唉。。。蛋，好可惜🥺
18:11 Marf果隊都O曬咀
21:21 Jer喊得好淒涼QQ
講時講, 成組無個唱得 但jer執一執起碼連alice都唔走音, yoyo同candy跟alfred幾個月都無粒音準
呢句真呀！更欣賞阿JER了
我覺得jer組表演幾好睇
Jer 組其實ok.以導師而言：
1. Fatboy: 呢組有兩個唱歌屬災難性，但導師能收埋佢地短處，表現佢地長處，全組過關，歸功Fatboy
2. Lokman: 呢組表演好一半歸功Val原創歌悅耳，Lokman冇幫到幾多，頂多跳舞幫到少少
3. Jer: 有pops, 有idea, 已經好過阿祖十倍。敗筆係要佢地唱歌向難度挑戰，自暴其短
4. Dee 哥： 唔應該任由組員做主，每個人自作一段Rap毫無必要
5. AK：冇好好用Marf, 失敗
我覺得AK 完全係茶水阿哥。唔知關唔關剪接事，次次話請飲請食而已。冇話佢教咩。正式感受到係肥仔、阿DEE係有真材實料教。而阿JER 有才之餘仲仆心仆命。
@@chinkrisbe1508 好似AK嗰組嘅芯齡係佢跳舞老師，AK係跳舞出生，可能係呢組冇乜offer到
JER真係好用心幫組員去完成個表演，睇得出佢對每個表演都有一定既執著，佢著重點真係唔係諗點WIN個比賽，反而想每個表演有靈魂。個表演可能到班組員係有D難度。。。
阿Jer 嗰組個表演做得幾好呀！ 一定冇可能包尾... 評分準則係咩？ 非常唔consistent.
最後： 還我Ash, 咖哩同阿蛋.
Poor Jer....
I think Jer's team performed really well though...........and they tried so hard......yes it is unfair......
最後果組的人 努力啦 人生好長。你們都很美。
Jer's team performance is not that bad.. Fa Je and Wing have people they want to eliminate in Jer's team ( Fong fong and 子涓 due to public opinion that we don't like them) so I am not complaining.. and no matter how messed up Day's performance is.. u can tell Fa Je will save her no matter what
DAY does draw people eyes... I can't tell why... but i like her (without specific reasons)
做馬。不知所謂。浪費咗導師的心機。唔公平做乜仲要比賽。D女仔個個都心裡有數。
Jer 真係好用心，將自己最好嘅比出嚟。Dee反而唔想負責任，由啲女仔做自己想做嘅，衰咗唔使負責任。
Jer組高分過Dee組會比較合理。
肥仔組 都太高分
I think jer's team was a bit too ambitious. It was a good idea but didn't highlight the girl's strong points, which is essential in this round. Nonetheless, it does make this competition more interesting.
Agree, I also think the girls are too young and don’t have the artistry to digest and perform such a deep act
我覺得係評判唔想淘汰任何AK果組既成員，所以專登俾低D分其他組
好似有心擺呀Jer上枱咁，其實想甩手方方
好明顯其中一個評判想保住Marf個team，又唔想拉攏其他評判，所以比咗0分。加埋其他評判3x70=210分。佢知道就算俾10分20分都可能保唔住Marf個team。
AK話齋，應該睇分紙。不過造馬造到當全世界無到，睇唔睇都無分別。
節目一定要保Marf個team所以即使Jer嗰組幾好睇都冇用，其實應該，foul AK同Dee組
想知18:01嗰句「有無咁誇張啊？」係邊個講🤣🤣🤣，呢句完全代替所有觀眾發聲😆
我覺得把聲似Winka 😂😂
睇唔明個Item，都已經俾第三佢地，明明第三變第尾，好欣賞子涓輸左仲笑得出，不過最尾得10個，佢地只係早一步走啫
要Ariel都唔要馬欣，可乜塑性，挑，觀眾想睇馬欣多D囉
係，我想睇馬欣多過 ARIEL，唔明佢地點揀。
馬欣，期待响舞台睇你跳舞！
Miss Ash and 咖喱!
I like Kinki, she has a pure girl next door kind of look, she looks quite like
Jer好唔開心，但呢個結果絕對唔係你問題，你既意念好好，但你既藝術唔係所有人都可以表達同演繹出來～
平心而論 做一個artist時表演嘅時候要觀眾有代入感 令到人哋可以投入到嗰件事係最能夠得到認同
其實子涓無論外型定係聲線跳舞都好適合入女團 唔明點解要因為佢國藉而攻擊佢？出身冇辦法選擇 但佢一直以來嘅努力同埋低調有目共睹
事實上方方的確係差啲嘅 個人覺得第三季時嘅佢 無論係精神狀態同埋外型都係優勝啲 講真舞蹈員比較適合佢 佢未必係女團人選 但亦都冇公眾講得咁差 見到咁多網絡欺凌都覺得佢好慘
大家對啲參賽者寬容啲啦 有勇氣參加比賽過程一路都咁努力 其實已經好值得被尊重 大家加油💪🏻希望每一個參賽者都可以走花路🌸
Jer組應有240-280分
Jer 組表演幾好睇呀，都唔明點解咁低分🙈
唔係咁點叫全民造馬
因為花姐唔單睇今次表現。
某程度上係對比賽唔公平但對女團公平。
不過公唔公平原來唔重要
為咗 托高返阿Dee嗰組 🤔
因為AK嗰組撻q，如果正常俾分好可能係尾二，而嗰組好多係viu想要嘅人
非主流既野，連表演者都唔明，得佢自己堅持。
16：19不知係咪花姐睇表現個陣諗緊其他野，注意力下降！🤣🤣
有冇發現五組分數排名，同五個導師係造星一既名次一樣?
Lokman - 肥仔- AK - 阿Dee - 阿Jer
有冇咁巧合呀?
jer and dee not even in final
唉! 亞 Jer 你做導師工作太上心, 為班學員好. 你前? 女友唔明都冇辦法. 希望好人有好報啦!
吊 無比較無傷害 最後一組一定評錯分 AK個組最應該被淘汰 仆街穎蒿個表演唔係表演囉 好冇
唔公平個人喜好
心痛Jer🥺🥺
還我呀蛋😭😭
Jer 果組乘咗0.8 ?
r頭。 第五組同nobody差唔多, 但分數差咁遠。真係全民造馬。方方終於走了悶死唔該唔好再參加喇
肥仔組太高分
唔系睇佢呢場回合的表現，系睇平時印象分？咁仲比賽把鬼？講出來都笑死人！
揀人唔係揀表現，做得礙眼。
如果花姐已經有一個名單，就唔好再搞呢個表演喇。對啲參賽者和導師好唔公平。
劇本開show時已有，戲要繼續做。
你講緊呢一round嘅導師？之前根本冇導師。名單確實有，如果係花姐揀都好啲，最怕係Wing 揀，咁死得。
我覺得 25>20 由佢地4人做評審，就已經係有內定。
@@chinkrisbe1508 某程度一定有內定，應該每組都有一定想留嘅人，Dee 哥嗰組有三個， Jer 兩個，所以咪咁俾分。估下姐
連阿Wing自己講點解可以俾Alice入20強時自己都講到口窒窒，好冇說服力囉😂
話唔係顏值擔當都冇人信。
一部分人靠樣，一部分人跳舞排舞，一部分人唱歌编曲，一部分樣樣識d。女團就咁成型了。
男女團都係, 要取悦觀眾嘅先決條件, 係要有顔值部.
跳唱唔掂, 但之後廣告商都會揾你。
就算冇口窒窒，佢講乜都唔會有說服力，因為根本冇料
咁淨返阿旦方娟 全部foul晒都可以。不過alice決賽11分就難以置信
No Ariel No Alice! No way, no way, no way!!!! Don't want them in the girls' group.
feel Alice is a trouble maker
子涓，我鐘意你！支持你做自己想做嘅事情，不枉此生。
子涓其實係最女團嘅女
@@morriswong9896 我認同,不過她和芳芳都被一般網民厭惡,雖然她擁有入女團條件,但很多網民恨不得佢早出局,今次她的一組被偏到最低分,似乎是保阿Dee那組成員,好似失誤最多嘅阿Day🤔
@@cindychan1852 講實力方方應該都唔夠子涓好～不過算啦 真係成隊mirror好多都係入唔到決賽 希望仲有機會見到子涓
D 人討厭 子涓 背景？
@@chinkrisbe1508 子涓咩背景？
Good Show!
女圑加返 Ash.
Yes Yes Yes 😂😌
我都LIKE ASH，但啲人係咁話佢結咗婚。
Val 和 Gao 一開始睇就覺得佢有潛力和才華！Ada仔同 WinWin 睇睇吓就欣賞咗佢哋！
其實暐翹就覺得佢死好命，真係唔覺得佢有乜嘢突出，只不過同隊嘅人比較強，所以佢先至可以入到20強，除咗拉丁舞之外我真係見唔到佢有乜突出！
原本已經唔討好暐翹，當佢嗰隊出綫時，佢仲笑晒口勁開心咁主動攬自己嗰隊隊友，嗰隊既隊友還有winka、yoyo、candy這三位都無笑得咁開心，得佢同Tangie即刻喺度笑，佢原本一早入咗死亡名單，無錯死好命！同埋個人唔鍾意拉丁舞，兩隻手揈吓揈吓咁唔鍾意！
一早節目已經有心水女團 Alice 有咩好？ 我覺得好偏佢 靚又唔覺～～馬欣都好，又入唔到。睇到好激氣～～～拉丁舞我都覺得好正，有好多新嘗試 而且做得好好，之前勞斯萊斯係我睇甘多個表演中最喜歡頭三位之一
比賽都多餘 都有曬人選
Jer組野心太大，handle 唔到，歌好難唱。女團只能留後生嘅，年紀大的要被犧牲，雖然佢哋表現好過d後生嘅。
方方很努力。太可惜。
因年紀大被foul, 以後就只可做老師 :-/
揀d街知巷聞的歌會容易引起共鳴，如肥仔组Wonder Girls 嘅Nobody 大人細路都啱. 難度高嘅歌玩死d學員，佢哋唔係你呀。
暐翹, 阿Gao, Marf 加油
我心目中女團人選: Marf, Ada, Gao, So Ching, Yoyo, Day, 超酸，Ariel, Ivy，榛其,Candy
No Ariel. Personality not good.
No Ada plz
Alice, 但唱功需補課
Jer :(
加油
由頭到尾都係一個錯，趁咩未表演已經要淘汰，仲要次撚次都唔同評判，最離譜既係個八婆花有乜資格做監製做評判，佢識條撚咩，佢知咩叫表演咩
建議下次改賽制！男團或女團成員增至100個！😂
呢排又係遇到啲咁無理嘅事……根本當權者玩哂，而當權者只會考慮佢自身嘅感受……根本全世界都係咁亂黎，Fxxk！
無辜出局嗰啲, 希望佢哋以後自己可以組團啦唯有。😔
我覺得好好唔錯，唱功係差啲，但整個表演冇可能咁低分，評判好有問題
42:28
Jer, the performance is not about you!!! You're just a consultant, not the director. You should have let your group members decide on what they wanted to do. This song is a wrong choice. It's sad that方芳need to be dismissed because of this performance.
女團可唔可以路好有穎蕎同Ariel
馬欣佢哋唔係另有想法咩🤔
我會FOLLOW 馬欣！雖然佢入唔到十強
洗唔洗del comment😂 純粹想討論你覺得alice邊個位勾引咗jer姐😂
面对导师，玩遮面怕丑，我觉得Alice今次系做多左，有无勾引就唔知了
呢d comment 其實只係 hurt都 阿 Jer多個 Alice, 肯定困擾嘅會係阿 Jer多 d.
Alice 無才華唱跳都唔得!
唉! 亞 Jer 做導師工作太上心, 為班學員好. 佢前? 女友唔明都冇辦法. 希望好人有好報啦!
@@longkong1141 想喊唔遮面咁遮邊到？ 自己入到但係其他組員入唔到緊係會有hard feeling或者內疚之類既野。
咁都可以扯到去alice姣阿jer到lol (講緊韓文名嗰個人）
Jer 組做咗 Jer 自己想做嘅事，但五位表演者都唔適合。結果係無一個有光采。
No Alice 五音不全. No Ariel情格不好.Will not support the group if they are in. Need people with real talents. Miss Ash and Kelly咖喱。
無辜出局嗰啲, 希望佢哋以後自己可以組團。
Wing 你嘅character 都唔係好出喎！我擔心你lead唔lead到呢班咁有特色嘅女仔去到大舞台！
感覺wing除咗出嚟跟人口水同講經，仲有咩用
肥仔表情好誇張喎😅
吾公平個人喜好
真心其實方方幾慘 梁祖堯自己偏心佢 周搞到佢俾人鬧🥲
真心覺得佢一季差過一季。明白佢有努力，但好似擺到明流於表面嗰種。
@@chinkrisbe1508 我覺得上年嘅佢好努力而且表現都唔錯 但係今年就變到野心好大咁
Ariel入20強...佢入女團的話我成個團都吾會支持！
No Ariel. No Alice.
純粹留個年紀最細嘅將成隊平均年齡降低。
@@STAN_NZ 又唔係得佢一個年紀細。佢個樣唔討好，又唔覺得有咩特別突出。
@@mamamia5050 ALICE 起碼有D SWEET，會吸到一些觀眾。
唯一一個16歲，但外貌似26，甚至36。揾唔到少女味。
Alice 都入🥴🥴
No talents at all. Cannot sing. Cannot dance. No Alice in the group. Cannot stand her
@@mamamia5050 我仲覺佢跳ok, 係唱要補堂。
@@RexKo AGREE。佢OK，唱要加多幾倍努力啫
深層意義藝術性既女團其實真係無人想睇尼, 梁祖堯 女團真係唔arm你尼
方方走左太开心， 子娟就被方方拉卖落水， Kinki我觉得个样差D，Alice今集系有D姣
方方走左我也開心,但替子娟不值,佢好過好多20強女生。
個中國婆終於走
阿Jer幕後梗係保住佢條女Alice…. 🤬🤬🤬
We want 🐣🥚🍳
ALICE 係JER 女朋友?
@@chinkrisbe1508 no ahh
@@chinkrisbe1508 No 不好信這些消息
唔公平個人喜好