Father is still with the daughter and enjoys puri baji...... Daughter's life and her father's shayari goes together. Story does have any msg but potrayed the full bunch of feelings in relationships.....
For the people who didn't get the story:- Ira lives alone in a house where earlier about an year ago her father lived along too. the story starts when the maid is coking meal for her fathers first barsi. she has a maid working with her who knows her and her fathers choices very well (seems to be aqaunted for a long time) so now she is seen talking to her boyfriend who seemed to cheat on her for her best friend sheily, apart from this story, ira always tells her maid to cook some extra puuri and keep in a vessel. but everytime she would see that the kitchen window will remain open and the poories were less. the maid does not confess of cooking less or opening the window neither does ira does so. there is a pinch of paranormal behaviour in the house with the fatherly love for food shown. at the end, the dabba is seen to open by itself and the window too... this act makes the readers believe that her fathers soul use to visiy and eat the pooris. later ira also told maid to cook extra for "bin bulaye" guest
Bekhayali mai bhi tera khyal ata hai Jab bin bulaya koi chupke se dastak de jata hai. Its not a simple story . Its deep thought of fatherly love and described beautifully in the book. Nice
@@ananyadubey7580 actually people want to live in vertual world because most of in our societies have no courage to face the reality even educated person.
What a gem! 'Bin Bulaaye' is a masterclass in short filmmaking. The emotional depth and the nuanced performances make it a must-watch. Congratulations to the cast and crew for winning at the MAMI Mumbai Film Festival. Looking forward to more inspiring stories like this!
Absolutely loved 'Bin Bulaaye'! The storytelling beautifully captures the intricacies of desires and attachments. Ira Dubey and Arfi Lamba deliver stellar performances that keep you engaged. Kudos to Anshul Tiwari and the entire team for creating such a captivating short film!"
not necessarily, some throw their children in the orphanges or on the streets. Maybe you've had a wonderful childhood :) but please don't generalize it! Ciao.
Such a cliche! Not always, not for all. This is such a hurtful cliche too for the people who weren't blessed with loving or caring parents. And what's even more hurtful is that the people who do have loving parents just won't believe that some parents can be really mean, narcissistic and evil.
@@yuvashreesrinivasan2880 I hear you, and I know exactly what you mean. I was raised by a Narcissist mother, and I'm still suffering greatly even years after she's gone. Nobody loved her more than me, but that always stayed one sided.
@@streeteleven I'm very sorry for your loss. You are strong despite the circumstances that you've been through. Keep going forward . Try not to look back on those painful moments when you felt worse . Better days await you.😀
Desires chain us. This plebian world is an illusion. And Death is the poetry of life. It is only after Death we can Judge a person with his or her wrong doings or right ones. The father lived through his writings. With his voice in the background and her's along with him, there is a hint that she wants to follow his footsteps and ideals. Poetry being the medium of communication. When she understood desires chain us, she could let go- of the fury, of the betrayal. Like her father, her ex arrives bin bulaye. His hunger for food is his hunger for the reunion. And his eating in her thali, the Desire for that lost connection. That she learns to forgive after venting out is because, she understood, life is fleeting, illusory, deceptive. The imagery of waves repeated again and again. Waves of time, waves of change. She bonds with the woman who drunkenly kisses her boyfriend shows it is men and their world of patriarchy that separates women and attempts to break solidarity. Often, the Other woman cannot be blamed when your Man chooses to cheat. The father died physically but remains with her through his writings, his little acts of belonging in the life of her daughter. He wanted his daughter to understand, we can't skip the pages of life. Every stamp in the passport is a watermark to a new discovery, tp a land of uncertainty, perhaps to an imaginary discovery, but the discovery in reality takes place within. You don't need to sojourn the unknown to become known to yourself. It can happen within the four walls of a room. But that the passport is kept in place again, proves, ultimately it is her Choice to live the life she wants. And the Father respects her desire. Although, with the pinch, even that discovery into the unknown may chain her. Moreover, the lost of trust by putting the phone camera on is the lost of faith in relationships. What goes on in the house, behind her. Though, it can be also translated as the welcoming of the bin bulaye. To trace the untraceable. Here, bin bulaye is : Death of her father, The Betrayal, the discovery of the dairy, the Solidarity of the two woman, the journey within, the sudden arrival of the ex, and the father's attempt to reach to her daughter.
Slight touch of paranormal presence gives it a different dimension on father and daughter relation through deep poetry recitals making it more soulful.
Nashruddin Shah, Late Imraan khan, Anil Kapur, Navazuddin Siddiqui, Priyanka chopra, Kajol all these r legends in Indian film industry, In Pak darama Noman ijaz, Mahira Khan ,Sejal Ali, Favad khan are marvelous
These days I am watching Mandi whenever I find a little time at night. So, it is a slow progress. Now as I watch this, it reminds me of the dilapidated kotha in Mandi. Many films those days used to be in the ordinary backdrops of chawls, slums, middle class housings etc. These days, even a telefilm portrays very high end home with ornate decors, characters look from south Delhi and so they wear trendy dresses, maid looks elegant ... every frame is aesthetically picture perfect. But at the end (to my out of tune with time perspective), there is no soul and no real story in this 'award winning' short film.
एक वक़्त था ऐसा मेरा दिन रात था जहां खुशियों का डेरा अचानक से किताब का आखिरी पन्ना पलटा ओर मेरी कहानी का संग्रह संभला अब नहीं जोड़ती नई सी पंक्तियां वहां सिर्फ रोज़ाना नया पाठक मोहर लगा जाता है
I love the way she kept her friendship with her Best friend and later she forgives her boyfriend too....she lost her father a year ago and now she doesn't let go of her best friend and boyfriend even though they cheated on her.
Only a bengali can write something lovely like this....I am proud to be an bengali....if you only know about them to just "machi khabey vaat khabe" or "aami tomake bhalobashe" for your kind information they can do more than those....the writer of this story is also a Bengali.... such a lovely content... thank you
just wondering how difficult it must have got for the person who has lost a loved one recently!! and ya do let me know if you did feel his/ her presence while watching this.....
Best work writer. It just made me smile at the end. And the poetries my ghosh!!!! Ek waqt tera hai, ek waqt mera hai tujhe ek lamhe ne diya, mujhe sardiyoon main mila hai!!!! (inshallah)
Such a pretentious heavy handed film. The poetry is meaningless, the background score overwhelming, and the acting unfortunately does not live upto the stellar name of Ira Dubey. There are just huge lapses in teb direction, the scene between Dubey and her bf towards the end for example and the scene where Savita seems to be aware of the camera are just thrown in without any build up. Such a useless film
“ Touch ..hug ..and kiss ... are the three gems of memory .. “ So true !!!
Father is still with the daughter and enjoys puri baji......
Daughter's life and her father's shayari goes together. Story does have any msg but potrayed the full bunch of feelings in relationships.....
Ok
For the people who didn't get the story:-
Ira lives alone in a house where earlier about an year ago her father lived along too. the story starts when the maid is coking meal for her fathers first barsi. she has a maid working with her who knows her and her fathers choices very well (seems to be aqaunted for a long time) so now she is seen talking to her boyfriend who seemed to cheat on her for her best friend sheily, apart from this story, ira always tells her maid to cook some extra puuri and keep in a vessel. but everytime she would see that the kitchen window will remain open and the poories were less. the maid does not confess of cooking less or opening the window neither does ira does so. there is a pinch of paranormal behaviour in the house with the fatherly love for food shown. at the end, the dabba is seen to open by itself and the window too... this act makes the readers believe that her fathers soul use to visiy and eat the pooris. later ira also told maid to cook extra for "bin bulaye" guest
upasna chandel thank you 😊
By God ap ny bta dia wrna mujhy tu smjh nai iiii
It gives me goosebumps now.
@@notsoprivate
Ziada ghor se dekh lia na isi liy
@@thefooderspecialist4383 kisi ne neeche puchha tha
How beautifully she feels and experience love of her father around!
I miss my father so dearly and wish to experience his presence in some way.
Bekhayali mai bhi tera khyal ata hai
Jab bin bulaya koi chupke se dastak de jata hai.
Its not a simple story . Its deep thought of fatherly love and described beautifully in the book.
Nice
I miss you Baba..
Will wait for your unannounced arrival ❤️❤️
Yours
Ghontu!
He will definately come 🔥🔥
@@raghav_11aug ☺️☺️❤️
Ek waqt tera hai, ek waqt mera hai
Tujhe ek Lamhe me mila mujhe sadiyo me mila h🥰❤❤
Beautiful👌👌
Gajab..... ❤❤❤
@@vaibhavboni9870 thanks😊
The only things in this movie is that you recognized.
@@humanonly728 not like that but one of thing I thought was dope🖖😁
@@ananyadubey7580 actually people want to live in vertual world because most of in our societies have no courage to face the reality even educated person.
The poetryy...has deep meaningg...too good...day by day getting more n more fond of short filmss
Desires chain me.... There I find the birthsong of life.... Beautiful lines
Naseeruddin Shah’s voice is so mesmerizing 💙
hlo hot
It was the only good thing about the video
It's gulzar not nasiruddin
It's gulzar not nasiruddin
@@ashishmallick6624 lol….gulzar voice isn’t as heavy as naseeruddin shah
this film does not have an unexpected turn in the plot... and that is what makes it beautiful and wholesome
একদম ঠিক 👍
What a gem! 'Bin Bulaaye' is a masterclass in short filmmaking. The emotional depth and the nuanced performances make it a must-watch. Congratulations to the cast and crew for winning at the MAMI Mumbai Film Festival. Looking forward to more inspiring stories like this!
بات اگر دمدار ہو تو کتاب کے پنوں میں نہیں رہ سکتی - اسے باہر آنا ہی ہے... واہ بہت خوب
Absolutely loved 'Bin Bulaaye'! The storytelling beautifully captures the intricacies of desires and attachments. Ira Dubey and Arfi Lamba deliver stellar performances that keep you engaged. Kudos to Anshul Tiwari and the entire team for creating such a captivating short film!"
A true feelings or we can say that blessing..... S of her father .Invisible phenomenon of love.
Such a wonderful story. None can love us like our Parents do❤
not necessarily, some throw their children in the orphanges or on the streets. Maybe you've had a wonderful childhood :) but please don't generalize it! Ciao.
Such a cliche!
Not always, not for all.
This is such a hurtful cliche too for the people who weren't blessed with loving or caring parents. And what's even more hurtful is that the people who do have loving parents just won't believe that some parents can be really mean, narcissistic and evil.
@@yuvashreesrinivasan2880
I hear you, and I know exactly what you mean. I was raised by a Narcissist mother, and I'm still suffering greatly even years after she's gone. Nobody loved her more than me, but that always stayed one sided.
@@streeteleven I'm very sorry for your loss. You are strong despite the circumstances that you've been through. Keep going forward . Try not to look back on those painful moments when you felt worse . Better days await you.😀
@@streetelevenyup
Please include English subtitles for those who would like to know more about the poems. Thanks.
Desires chain us. This plebian world is an illusion. And Death is the poetry of life. It is only after Death we can Judge a person with his or her wrong doings or right ones. The father lived through his writings. With his voice in the background and her's along with him, there is a hint that she wants to follow his footsteps and ideals. Poetry being the medium of communication. When she understood desires chain us, she could let go- of the fury, of the betrayal. Like her father, her ex arrives bin bulaye. His hunger for food is his hunger for the reunion. And his eating in her thali, the Desire for that lost connection. That she learns to forgive after venting out is because, she understood, life is fleeting, illusory, deceptive. The imagery of waves repeated again and again. Waves of time, waves of change. She bonds with the woman who drunkenly kisses her boyfriend shows it is men and their world of patriarchy that separates women and attempts to break solidarity. Often, the Other woman cannot be blamed when your Man chooses to cheat. The father died physically but remains with her through his writings, his little acts of belonging in the life of her daughter. He wanted his daughter to understand, we can't skip the pages of life. Every stamp in the passport is a watermark to a new discovery, tp a land of uncertainty, perhaps to an imaginary discovery, but the discovery in reality takes place within. You don't need to sojourn the unknown to become known to yourself. It can happen within the four walls of a room. But that the passport is kept in place again, proves, ultimately it is her Choice to live the life she wants. And the Father respects her desire. Although, with the pinch, even that discovery into the unknown may chain her. Moreover, the lost of trust by putting the phone camera on is the lost of faith in relationships. What goes on in the house, behind her. Though, it can be also translated as the welcoming of the bin bulaye. To trace the untraceable. Here, bin bulaye is : Death of her father, The Betrayal, the discovery of the dairy, the Solidarity of the two woman, the journey within, the sudden arrival of the ex, and the father's attempt to reach to her daughter.
Wow you explained the story so nicely
such a wonderful explanation
only then I understood the real story and meaning of this short movie
Film name should be, Puri Sabzi... 😊 Nasir Shah's voiceover is just ❤️
It's GULZAAR Sahab Voice over.
@@bhavnasharma4162 Actor Naseeruddin Shah’s voice it is.
Slight touch of paranormal presence gives it a different dimension on father and daughter relation through deep poetry recitals making it more soulful.
The title in English says "the unannounced".
But the proper translation for bin bulaye will be "THE UNINVITED".
Nashruddin Shah, Late Imraan khan, Anil Kapur, Navazuddin Siddiqui, Priyanka chopra, Kajol all these r legends in Indian film industry, In Pak darama Noman ijaz, Mahira Khan ,Sejal Ali, Favad khan are marvelous
this one is good with a Ira Dubey's above average acting and a literary touch.how coolly she says "kisi bin bulaye mehmaan ke liye".
These days I am watching Mandi whenever I find a little time at night. So, it is a slow progress. Now as I watch this, it reminds me of the dilapidated kotha in Mandi. Many films those days used to be in the ordinary backdrops of chawls, slums, middle class housings etc. These days, even a telefilm portrays very high end home with ornate decors, characters look from south Delhi and so they wear trendy dresses, maid looks elegant ... every frame is aesthetically picture perfect. But at the end (to my out of tune with time perspective), there is no soul and no real story in this 'award winning' short film.
Is mandi a film?
@@Shreyaa20 A film by Shyam Benegal. Nice to watch but the ending plot wasn't well thought out.
Puri short film m sukoon tha..... Or jo phenomenon luv dikhaya h vo bhi adorable 😍😍😍
Wowww touched,,,
I wish my father also come nd meet me the same..😭
Shah's voice....... Simply amazing💕
Kash mere papa bhi aa Jaye aur dekhe k mummy akeli ghar main kyase usko yaad karti hain. 1yr ho Gaya papa nehi rahe.. Miss you baba
NS Sir, your voice was so mesmerizing it just touched my inner soul ❤️
Wonderful. Ira just reminds me of her mom, liliit Dubey, a grt theatre artist...
Agreed
Going to say
The same… especially her voice!
Baat agar damdar ho toh kitabon mein nahi reh sakti...nice line
Omg sir your voice just touch my heart
The house environment is melancholic yet beautuful
Wow!! What better in life than a touch,hug and kiss.....💞
Nice sentimental film for our lost loved ones !!!
Like for ira, if it is her real voice beautiful,
Similar to Lillet Dubey's voice.
The girl is Ira Dubey. This is her voice. She is Lillete Dubey's daughter.
Yes that's her voice
Has got her mom,s voice .ditto
Wow as i was expecting😊 thats just beautiful
Greetings from Pakistan. What a brilliant story telling. Hats off.
V.nice video......specially the end👌👌
Just loved it very much..he was in relationship...and she was in love.. 😍😍😍
Great work by everyone who worked together to make this. This is beautiful
Aaaaahhhhh, so sad afterwards I too also wanted the 3 gems 😭🙏🤗
Wenever i see Royal stag barrel select ,i m just curious to see the film. Bcoz they have such awesum short films. Bt this didnt live up to the mark.
Dz 1z jz fr Naseer Sahab!
Same here, every short story was to another level but this one failed me
That's cause you didn't understand it's depth,and did not read between the lines.
You don't thave to say everything
Love y Nasir sabh Nd Great job by all team of Beutyful concept "bin bulaye
Nice story...touch heart. bcoz...i really miss my father... I too lost him.... thx
Can cry down a little, penned down so beautifully! 🌼💕
14:23 loving lines
Yes, I agree with you
एक वक़्त था ऐसा मेरा
दिन रात था जहां खुशियों का डेरा
अचानक से किताब का आखिरी पन्ना पलटा
ओर मेरी कहानी का संग्रह संभला
अब नहीं जोड़ती नई सी पंक्तियां वहां
सिर्फ रोज़ाना नया पाठक मोहर लगा जाता है
Beutiful shayaris. N soulful voice...
The poetryy...has deep meaning, too good.
Very true..Nice Lines and meaning of life..Relationships is everything for enjoy life well.
Great movie, congratulations Anshul and Debasmita
This gave me chills. Amazing piece of art.
Can anyone tell me Why this channel no longer available? 🙄
try with vpn bro in my laptop it says your not eligible bcoz of age restriction but im already 21 lol then i changed the location with vpn
Why your channel largeshortfilms isnt showing over youtube??
Naseeruddin Shah s voice 👍👌
Oh such a beautiful story
Get goosebumps 😊 bin bulahi maheman ☺️😊
Same here
What did the award givers see in this movie?
shah voice is just awesome 👍
Such a slow short film, felt so longgggg...
Such a beautiful story
Is there a dedicated book of the shayari's that were recited in the short film? Any idea?
Awesome voice over. A fantastic shotfilm. Brilliant production.
Regards.
I love the way she kept her friendship with her Best friend and later she forgives her boyfriend too....she lost her father a year ago and now she doesn't let go of her best friend and boyfriend even though they cheated on her.
Male voice of those lines is awesome
It was Naseeruddin Shah's voice. Legendary ❤️
Such a beautiful film
this story with the voice of legendary actor Nasir sir is just incredible ❤❤❤
Only a bengali can write something lovely like this....I am proud to be an bengali....if you only know about them to just "machi khabey vaat khabe" or "aami tomake bhalobashe" for your kind information they can do more than those....the writer of this story is also a Bengali.... such a lovely content... thank you
Passport rakh ke Jana aur Laut k ane ka scene abrupt cut hay, bich me ek xtra shot rehta to aur achcha hota....9:40
By the way who was the puri chor, what did she saw in the camera recordings
Daughter n father bonding is lovable
Concepts are so sweet 😍😻
The movie should have been called Puri chor.
🤣🤣
Seriously 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
हाहा! सो फ़नी लोल
आर. ओ. एफ. एल.
it is bad to call a spirit a chor.
Wo recordings मे क्या दिखा वो kyon nahi dikhaya??
I think its Gulzar ji's voice ❤️✨..... beutiful 🌻
no , it is Naseeruddin Shah's voice
poetry is so heart touching...nice concept
this not short film it's a poem and with fantastic BGM..
just wondering how difficult it must have got for the person who has lost a loved one recently!!
and ya do let me know if you did feel his/ her presence while watching this.....
A grt artist...like her mother . Beautiful film indeed
Best work writer. It just made me smile at the end. And the poetries my ghosh!!!!
Ek waqt tera hai, ek waqt mera hai
tujhe ek lamhe ne diya, mujhe sardiyoon main mila hai!!!! (inshallah)
👍mujhe sadiyon mei mila
Woh jo sath nehi rehtey
Phir bhi unki yaadein reh jati hai,
Good job berrel scelet team👌👌👌👌😘
something moved behind the door when she says "kia pata koi bin bulay aa jaye ga"
OMG!! I thought I was the only one who noticed that.
True
I have no words when I seem at end how the box was opened i am literally feel a cold wave in my heart 🥺👍
Phone portrait mode mae lagaya tha video landscape mae kyu record horahi thi?
Beyond the words..
Why is the channel not available anymore
vpn karo
very smart presentation........
This story is partially my experience too. Anshul tiwari , do u believe it could be true?
Yes
Nasser's voice 😍😍
Amazing 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Such a pretentious heavy handed film. The poetry is meaningless, the background score overwhelming, and the acting unfortunately does not live upto the stellar name of Ira Dubey. There are just huge lapses in teb direction, the scene between Dubey and her bf towards the end for example and the scene where Savita seems to be aware of the camera are just thrown in without any build up. Such a useless film
I like your review 👍
Thought and name are same.
Agreed
completely agreed with you, i kept looking for the climax.. but actually nothing happened.. the poetry was completely meaningless
Even I think so.. It's kind of hotch potch nd scattering.. Nothing complements each other.. Poetry cnt b related to d situation...
What’s the background song at @3:32?
Now I'm feeling like to eat puri
😆😆😆
How can someone accept an unfaithful person so easily , i thought it weakened the whole plot.
Accepting unfaithful.. Sometimes we re strong inside that we can forgive anyone
@@speedaddicted1 Its not about accepting the unfaithful at all , everyone makes mistake it's just the time period one needs to forgive someone truly .
Great Ira ..................but mom is mom ....you need more to work to get like your best, magnificent and superb mother
I think the starting line said by naseerudin shah
All backgrounds voice Nasiruddin Shah...
Wow intro sound ♥️
Another good compilation of thoughts... (First 2 minutes)
Lovely💟
Ira … so talented
Agree with me or not but these short movies are far much better then the 2-3 hrs of bollywood big screen shit.
disgree