Eh, I respect Roy Doltrice as an actor but he was overmatched by all the different characters, his pronunciations varied wildly in the same book and he'd change (or just forget) what character he'd given what accent to. I'd love to have those books get re-recorded with a more suitable narrator honestly.
He really did get good at the voices. It's all a variation of Chad summerchild, sweetrobin or Brandon night king. We have his episode reviews from GoT and Westworld to thank for that.
@@brennanbarnes7628 Disagree on a few points. I do agree that he loses track of one or two voices, Tywin gets 2 different ones before finally sticking with the ASOS voice. But Davos, Stannis, Tyrion, Robert, Pycelle, Brienne, Asha, Theon, Vic, Kevan, Moquorro, Shae, Bronn, Penny, Varys, Sandor, Arya (until ADWD), Catelyn, Quenten and Oberyn are consistent and rather impressive. Tyrion especially is done very well, especially in ASOS and ADWD. Every now and again he'll give two characters similar voices or change within the same chapter which is bad, but usually this is only for minor characters. Not to mention, the opposite is also true, in Jaimes AFFC chapters he deals with situations where there are 4 person (3 minor characters + Jaime) conversations who all get consistent distinguishable voices. Jaime changes from ASOS to AFFC, but its not a bad change and is understandable considering the recording situation at the time. When Roy started reading chapters before recording them (ASOS onwards I suspect) he does a pretty good job. I'm just going to say again, Tyrions chapters in Dance are very well done.
Today is my birthday and when I first saw this I thought: "No way. No way do I get a new fanfic chapter of my favorite character (tied with davos) from my favorite TH-camr." I was right. In my excitement, I forgot you were adding sample chapters. Still in my top 5 favorite chapters of all time, so I'll take the small W. I'm sure you'll kill off Davos in the next chapter to negate that though.
I can see in the chapter that the battle takes place in Wyman turning his men last second to fight for Stannis and seconds later being the first to fall through the ice
Justin Massy mission is ridiculous, you don't send ambassador to other countries with 5 minutes of briefing, no detailed plan what to do in case Stanis loses the fight beside 'avange me' , really ?
I have just thought about the Bran chapter in Preston WoW project, it should be roughly at the same time of this chapter so we should have some reference some indication the Bran and the Bloodraven was here
Bran warging crows rescues Theon during the execution at the tree. Theon wrote the pink letter, Stannis directed him. Sellswords will join Jon after the death of Stanis and Sheereen
Why would Jon not remember they had the same eyes. Theon mentions it several times "the eyes, the eyes, the eyes are all wrong. . . They must notice she does not have lord Eddard's eyes" Who else has lord Eddard's the only other one? Jon Snow. It's important we don't know why but it is. Plus remember. Aryas sibling she misses the most is Jon.
@jordanford9320 Depends on how long Jon is dead before he's resurrected, or how many times he dies before meeting Jeyne again. If Jon believes Jeyne is Arya, why would anybody tell him differently when the Northman can use the lie to manipulate him into doing what they want.
So, in this chapter, why do they call Theon a Kinslayer? Greyjoys are not kin to Starks, nor hostages with hostage-takers. I know your theory about the miller's boy being Theon's son, but if Umber knows about this, why do they want vengeance for the stark boys? Edit; Oh wait, was this a GRRM chapter?
Pretty good chapter but I feel like you made Stannis a bit too smart figuring the Karstark betrayal out all on his own. Also, Bran and Bloodraven were kinda just shoehorned in there. 6/10 not your best work so far.
Stannis must truly trust Massey, because he is about to make him a very rich weterosi in Essos What’s stopping Massey from keeping the gold for himself
I think the Iron Bank will only release the gold to Massey if they see that he is actually putting it to good use, hiring mercenaries and ships. They won’t just give him that entire lump sum at once, it’ll probably be in increments. They’ll be shadowing him the entire way.
Hey Preston. I really do appreciate the audios by you, and this isn’t meant to be a knock against you at all, but have you ever thought of sliding the wow fanfiction over to Davidreadsasoiaf? He’s an amazing reader and already did audiobooks for the first five books in the series
I think alot of people were entertaining the idea that these two together would make a great team. When someone asked on David's channel if he would be open to it, I think David responded that he felt like it would be in poor form to read PJs project without being asked to by PJ, which makes sense. I know we as fans would love these two partnering up ❤
Bummed this isn’t new. I hope the delay on your next chapter is due to commitments to your hundreds of jobs including diplomacy, auditing and being a responsible & loving family man. Otw, you’re derelict and you’ve no excuse for not producing a chapter/week. Sigh. OK, I’ll cut you some slack: 1 chapter per month.😉🗽⚖️
Hey Preston do you think you can get a professional narrator for your fanfic once winds is done? No offence, the writing is very good but your narration...not so much
I enjoy hearing Preston read ❤ we've been spoiled by this fandom's creators. Davidreadasoif has spoiled us with an excellent free narration and PJ has spoiled us with an excellent fanfic project.
I'm utterly amazed how Preston managed to get GRRM to write of the fanfic's chapters for him.
Preston is CIA so it wasn't much trouble for him.
@ *state department lol
@@drakengarfinkel3133 that is what he wants you to think
😂😂😂
@@drakengarfinkel3133 yees 🤷🏻♂️
Sad that George's latest chapters are so good. He hasn't lost it, only the output.
these were all written for DANCE so we really don't know
@@authorfarrell7161 he might have lost it. He wrote this chapter 14 years ago.
Woah, Stannis has the same voice as the Night King??? Something something confirmed?!
Yes. One Night Stannis will be crowned King of Westeros.
The guys from "GOT Academy" used to say:
"Boom! Called it! Confirmed!"
As far as recent George chapters go, this is one of his best ever! His quality hasn't gone down, only his time management!
God, this makes me wanna read TWoW... I'm glad at least someone is writing it! 😂 Thank You P-Dawg!
Can’t wait for the new chapter, but it’s great to have this one redone. Keep up the great work PJ
Preston’s no Dotrice but he’s improved so much on his voices. Props to you pj
Good thing too, I can never listen to Dotrice’s slobbering ever again. His Varys voice alone makes me want to jump out a window
Eh, I respect Roy Doltrice as an actor but he was overmatched by all the different characters, his pronunciations varied wildly in the same book and he'd change (or just forget) what character he'd given what accent to. I'd love to have those books get re-recorded with a more suitable narrator honestly.
He really did get good at the voices. It's all a variation of Chad summerchild, sweetrobin or Brandon night king. We have his episode reviews from GoT and Westworld to thank for that.
@@brennanbarnes7628 Disagree on a few points. I do agree that he loses track of one or two voices, Tywin gets 2 different ones before finally sticking with the ASOS voice. But Davos, Stannis, Tyrion, Robert, Pycelle, Brienne, Asha, Theon, Vic, Kevan, Moquorro, Shae, Bronn, Penny, Varys, Sandor, Arya (until ADWD), Catelyn, Quenten and Oberyn are consistent and rather impressive.
Tyrion especially is done very well, especially in ASOS and ADWD.
Every now and again he'll give two characters similar voices or change within the same chapter which is bad, but usually this is only for minor characters.
Not to mention, the opposite is also true, in Jaimes AFFC chapters he deals with situations where there are 4 person (3 minor characters + Jaime) conversations who all get consistent distinguishable voices.
Jaime changes from ASOS to AFFC, but its not a bad change and is understandable considering the recording situation at the time.
When Roy started reading chapters before recording them (ASOS onwards I suspect) he does a pretty good job.
I'm just going to say again, Tyrions chapters in Dance are very well done.
Middle name is Boris
Today is my birthday and when I first saw this I thought: "No way. No way do I get a new fanfic chapter of my favorite character (tied with davos) from my favorite TH-camr."
I was right. In my excitement, I forgot you were adding sample chapters. Still in my top 5 favorite chapters of all time, so I'll take the small W. I'm sure you'll kill off Davos in the next chapter to negate that though.
Happy birthday!
I can see in the chapter that the battle takes place in Wyman turning his men last second to fight for Stannis and seconds later being the first to fall through the ice
Funny how this Tycho character shows up seemingly out of nowhere, after Tyrek goes missing. Hmmmmm.
Idk man. Nobody describes Tycho as appearing horse-like. I don't think there's a connection
@memeaficionado No one describes Tyrek with a Bravosi accent but I'm still running with it.
@@memeaficionado He came to Stannis ahorse. Read Asha's chapter
I love the voice you gave to Stannis
Stannis is the night king confirmed.
Theon. His name is Theon you have to remember your name.
Theon, Theon, it doesn’t rhyme with anything!
@@Ant509yLet Eminem have a try.
Peon?
This one was the key for me. Unraveled the rest from here. "The Iron Bank!?", I said to myself.
I don’t know if this is a joke but I’d love to hear your thoughts
@@elidawkins9455 You're in luck. I was talking about my videos.
ThIs DoEsN't SoUnD lIkE gRrM!
Just the motivation I need to get through my last two finals, see you in 11 hours Preston
I love that Massey has pale blond hair. Possible hint of intermarrying with the Velaryons?
@@Blckrngr Makes good sense geographically.
@joefo458 I know, right? Also Alyssa Velaryon's mother was a Massey....maybe it went the other way as well
Sounds like Preston is back from Damascus. Or maybe he recorded it before his latest "trip to the office".
The return of ghoul Stannis. Today’s a great day.
please tell me well get double chapter for christmas
Justin Massy mission is ridiculous, you don't send ambassador to other countries with 5 minutes of briefing, no detailed plan what to do in case Stanis loses the fight beside 'avange me' , really ?
He doesn't need a detailed plan, only obedience
A desperate plan from a desperate man.
I have just thought about the Bran chapter in Preston WoW project, it should be roughly at the same time of this chapter so we should have some reference some indication the Bran and the Bloodraven was here
Hell yeah!!! S'Go!!!
I'm sick on mine and my partner's anniversary, this will make it all better ❤ we're both asoiaf fans, so thank you!!
Bran warging crows rescues Theon during the execution at the tree. Theon wrote the pink letter, Stannis directed him. Sellswords will join Jon after the death of Stanis and Sheereen
No
And we are back !
We need to get an appearance from a knight from a minor house called something like Guddmyn in the fanfic
I had forgotten Theon had a sample chapter.. I was like I thought Asha was next.. and damn you for killing qarl the maid 😭
Love it ❤
It would be funny if Jeyne really does become Arya due to Jon not remembering who Arya really was and Bran mind melding Jeyne's memories.
Why would Jon not remember they had the same eyes. Theon mentions it several times "the eyes, the eyes, the eyes are all wrong. . . They must notice she does not have lord Eddard's eyes"
Who else has lord Eddard's the only other one? Jon Snow. It's important we don't know why but it is. Plus remember. Aryas sibling she misses the most is Jon.
@jordanford9320 Depends on how long Jon is dead before he's resurrected, or how many times he dies before meeting Jeyne again.
If Jon believes Jeyne is Arya, why would anybody tell him differently when the Northman can use the lie to manipulate him into doing what they want.
It almost makes me cry
Elite double raven voice over
20 fucking years
This sounds as good as GRRM’s writing.
It is lol
Let’s getttt ittttttt brooooooooooos
PJ IS BACK FOMOS
Im here Preston!!
LFG
Thanks
No crow voice like a Preston crow voice.
In like Ser Twenty Goodmen
So, in this chapter, why do they call Theon a Kinslayer? Greyjoys are not kin to Starks, nor hostages with hostage-takers. I know your theory about the miller's boy being Theon's son, but if Umber knows about this, why do they want vengeance for the stark boys? Edit; Oh wait, was this a GRRM chapter?
WAHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
BBBAAAACCCCCKKKKKK
Back are we and...
Stannis is Brandon Nightsking!?
Why do i feel like this means Asha in January ??? 🍿🍿🍿🍿
Pretty good chapter but I feel like you made Stannis a bit too smart figuring the Karstark betrayal out all on his own. Also, Bran and Bloodraven were kinda just shoehorned in there. 6/10 not your best work so far.
This is an actual GRRM chapter. Lol
@@matthlavs yes that’s the joke
Stannis must truly trust Massey, because he is about to make him a very rich weterosi in Essos
What’s stopping Massey from keeping the gold for himself
I think the Iron Bank will only release the gold to Massey if they see that he is actually putting it to good use, hiring mercenaries and ships. They won’t just give him that entire lump sum at once, it’ll probably be in increments. They’ll be shadowing him the entire way.
Anyone know what's the next fanfic chapter?
Did you renarrate the chapter, or did you paste the reading from the deep analysis
Hey Preston. I really do appreciate the audios by you, and this isn’t meant to be a knock against you at all, but have you ever thought of sliding the wow fanfiction over to Davidreadsasoiaf? He’s an amazing reader and already did audiobooks for the first five books in the series
I think alot of people were entertaining the idea that these two together would make a great team. When someone asked on David's channel if he would be open to it, I think David responded that he felt like it would be in poor form to read PJs project without being asked to by PJ, which makes sense. I know we as fans would love these two partnering up ❤
WE'RE SO BACK
This chapter makes me absolutely despise the direction the show went with these characters.
Ah yes. The oni.
Yeah Preston, I was down with you fanfic but this one is clearly poorly written. Worst one so far.
Bummed this isn’t new. I hope the delay on your next chapter is due to commitments to your hundreds of jobs including diplomacy, auditing and being a responsible & loving family man.
Otw, you’re derelict and you’ve no excuse for not producing a chapter/week. Sigh. OK, I’ll cut you some slack: 1 chapter per month.😉🗽⚖️
This wasn't GRRM's best work. The prose is so lacklustre. Honestly I daresay Preston, your fanfics outperform his actual sample chapters.
Hey Preston do you think you can get a professional narrator for your fanfic once winds is done? No offence, the writing is very good but your narration...not so much
I enjoy it a lot actually.
I enjoy hearing Preston read ❤ we've been spoiled by this fandom's creators. Davidreadasoif has spoiled us with an excellent free narration and PJ has spoiled us with an excellent fanfic project.