Telegraph Road ALCHEMY - Rock Drummer's Reaction and Rating
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Rock Drummer Reacts and Rates - Get ready for a rhythmic journey as a seasoned rock drummer, delves into the beats, fills, and musical intricacies of Dire Straits' live version of 'Telegraph Road' - Alchemy
In this episode, I’ll break down the song's overall musicality. As the song unfolds, watch me react to the twists and turns and finish the video with an overall rating of the track.
Whether you're a fellow drummer or a music enthusiast, this reaction promises to add a unique dimension to your listening experience. Join me as we explore the beats that make the music come alive.
Lyrics:
A long time ago came a man on a track
Walking thirty miles with a sack on his back
And he put down his load where he thought it was the best
He made a home in the wilderness
He built a cabin and a winter store
And he ploughed up the ground by the cold lake shore
And the other travellers came walking down the track
And they never went further, no, they never went back
Then came the churches, then came the schools
Then came the lawyers, then came the rules
Then came the trains and the trucks with their loads
And the dirty old track was the Telegraph Road
Then came the mines, then came the ore
Then there was the hard times, then there was a war
Telegraph sang a song about the world outside
Telegraph Road got so deep and so wide
Like a rolling river
And my radio says tonight it's gonna freeze
People driving home from the factories
There's six lanes of traffic
Three lanes moving slow
I used to like to go to work, but they shut it down
I've got a right to go to work, but there's no work here to be found
Yes, and they say we're gonna have to pay what's owed
We're gonna have to reap from some seed that's been sowed
And the birds up on the wires and the telegraph poles
They can always fly away from this rain and this cold
You can hear them singing out their telegraph code
All the way down the Telegraph Road
Well, I'd sooner forget, but I remember those nights
Yeah, life was just a bet on a race between the lights
You had your head on my shoulder, you had your hand in my hair
Now you act a little colder like you don't seem to care
But just believe in me, baby, and I'll take you away
From out of this darkness and into the day
From these rivers of headlights, these rivers of rain
From the anger that lives on the streets with these names
'Cause I've run every red light on memory lane
I've seen desperation explode into flames
And I don't want to see it again
From all of these signs saying, "Sorry, but we're closed"
All the way
Down the Telegraph Road
Reacting to:
Artist: Dire Straits
Song: Telegraph Road
Album: Love over Gold
Released: 1982
Genre: Classic Rock, Progressive Rock, Art Rock, Jazz-Rock.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
🌟 Thanks for tuning in, everyone! It's clear this video strikes a chord with so many of us on a profound level. Mark Knopfler's brilliance, along with the incredible talent of the band, is undeniable. I usually don't revisit my own videos once they're up, but upon watching this reaction again, I noticed something intriguing. Can you all help me out with this? Around the 10:30 mark, did it seem like MK was getting emotional, maybe even shedding a tear? That part of the song really resonated with me personally, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on it. 🎸✨
Yep, he was having a moment, no doubt about it..
He was lovely & vul;nerable for about a minute there. How could you sing those words stoically? He's everything, the full package.
@@florodrigues8715 Love getting a woman's perpsective about this. Thank you.
0:40 I see that you reacted to the album version of Tunnel of Love already, but the live version is magical (Wembley 85), Mark exhibits that vulnerability, and it oozes from his guitar in the final solo. The song is more autobiographical, thus personal. Would love to see you react to this. Thanks again. 🤟😃
A couple of other things to say: Mark's Father came to some of the shows and maybe he caught a glimpse of his Dad in the audience? Secondly, the whole song in some ways resonates with the fact that during the late 70s Margaret Thatcher's UK government oversaw a great deal of industrial decline in the North East of England where Mark grew up, with many key industries closing down, leaving those areas with high unemployment, rising crime rates etc. The story of industrial rise and decline, although not initially written about England, certainly resonates poignantly with the challenges that Marks part of the UK had in the 70s and 80s
When time passes us all, Mark's music will stay ❤
Damn right! Thanks for watching.
Such a masterpiece. My favorite guitarist. Still banging today.So humble. When you are the GOAT and play it down. Gilmore with Time and Comfortably Numb may come in second. Facts
And don’t forget that Mark composed all the music’parts on this track,a genius
Absolutely, MK's genius as a composer shines brilliantly in "Telegraph Road." His ability to craft intricate melodies and captivating arrangements is truly remarkable. It's one of the many reasons why this song is considered a masterpiece.
Great reaction this is a masterpiece nobody plays guitar like Knopfler and the whole band is top notch.....
Thank you so much for your kind words! I couldn't agree more-MK's guitar playing is truly astonishing, and the entire band's talent shines mega-brightly in this performance. This song is a masterpiece, and it's a pleasure to experience the magic of Dire Straits together.
As I said after Sultans, I was at Hammersmith for this gig, I was so lucky.
You're right, this was the encore, its such a complex piece that we wondered whether they'd play it and if they did, do it justice.
As we can all see, they more than gave it justice!
We stood open mouthed for most of it!
I think we are so lucky that the best tech of the day was used to record this, so we can all enjoy it again and again. It doesn't feel like 40 years ago...
Wow, what an incredible experience to have been at that gig! It's amazing how certain performances stick with you for a lifetime./ And you're absolutely right about the recording-it's a testament to the band's talent and the advancements in technology that we can still enjoy it in all its glory today!
damn lucky. Lived in the uk 1984-1990 but never got to watch them live. My fave rock album of all time. The lyrical quality of this song lifts it up beyond just a mere rock anthem
Me too, and Wembley, I saw the live in 85 tour as well, how lucky were we?
@@jogooge6384 So lucky, although you don't appreciate it so much at the time
Christ what a drummer Terry Williams is ,mind the song is a masterpiece
Terry Williams's drumming on "Telegraph Road" is truly exceptional, adding another layer of brilliance to this masterpiece. Thank you for watching! 🥁🎶
On sultans of swing in London he was giving it 110% as his dad was in the audience for the 1st time
How lucky were we back in the day, such wondeful music.
Completely agree. 60's-70's-80's- Stellar
It's the timing, words and masterful playing by all members of the group that makes this performance so memorable. The subtle changes in volume on the lead guitar along with the clarity he achieves is amazing. The sound of the ringing in the telegraph wires cleverly reoccurs throughout the video. An excellent review by someone who recognises and congtatulates real talent. Thank you.
Absolutely agree-it's those subtle details and the band's impeccable timing that make this performance unforgettable. I'm glad the review resonated with you. Thanks for watching!
Love your genuine appreciation for the musicianship. The whole band smashed it!!
Thanks a lot! Absolutely, Dire Straits absolutely killed it with their performance in Alchemy. The whole band's talent is just off the charts! Appreciate your comment!
Lovely reaction
As I said after your Sultans reaction, I was there, we didn't think they'd play this, its so complicated, its a masterpiece.
They didn't play it, they smashed it!
In many ways I think of it as Alan Clark's song, his keyboard/piano is outstanding!
What a tight band they were, he mashes the keys and Terry Williams is on it with the cymbals and drums.
I'm glad you noticed Hal Lindes on the guitar, just going straight through the thing, amazing.
How John Illsley can jump around for over two hours and still play the bass is also amazing to me.
We knew Mark was good, not that good, how does he do it?
(As it turns out, this was the last song, the encore was Solid Rock. Someone looked it up and told me off for saying it was the encore, I'm working off memory!)
40 years later, it still gives me goose bumps...
Fantastic reaction man. Mark was brought up in my little home town in Northumberland so I’m so proud. He is a complete genius.
Thank you! And, I agree 100%. He's a godsend.
Amazing! I am 61 and had this album on VHS. I wanted to be Terry Williams.
I'm not far behind...Ah, the VHS days! If only we could rewind time like we rewind those tapes-imagine the epic jam sessions we could have!
A friend and I have seen DS and MK here in Toronto at every concert from 1985 until 2019. To say we are rabid fans is an understatement. I’ve also ordered the book he was reading as he travelled along Telegraph Road, from my local library.
Great reaction! I recommend tunnel of love from the same concert. It’s another rollercoaster with an insane end solo
Thanks for the kind words. Love the song. I covered the studio version on the channel here. Fun Fact: The little clip of me drumming at the beginning of my videos, is to the song 'Tunnel of Love':) I'm going Pink Floyd next week, but yes, I've only scratched the surface here.
A true MASTERPIECE! AND one of the greatest live performances ever recorded! 😂❤❤❤
Absolutely! It's an iconic performance that never fails to amaze. Thank you for watching!
Happy, fun, and if you can think how this applies today with Chicago, New York, San Fran & Minneapolis you are smart.
It's about the start, growth, and demise of Detroit by government & business. SULTANS of Swing & Telegraph Road are the rock Classics of the Classics. You all must check out the lyrics to bring Marks music to the next level. He makes the cosmos better and even serious or sad songs still leave you uplifted and happy. Incredible
@@earlellison7533 Yes, MK is the man. I hear you loud & clear regards the tie-in regarding USA’s blue cities and states. Thanks for watching and for the interesting comment.
I bought this album on release in 1984 and it's as fresh today as it was then. I feel privileged to have grown up in an era when there were bands like DS and Queen etc who were writing compositions rather than just songs.
Amen to that brother. Just scratching the surface on this relatively young reaction channel. The list ahead is long and celebrated. Thanks for watching.
Great reaction. Thanks for your genuine sincerity and emotion. Bonjour de France 🇫🇷 😊
Merci beaucoup! I'm happy you enjoyed this (raw) reaction. Greetings back from wherever you are in France! 🇫🇷😊 Thank you for watching!
@@llarose Cannes, French Riviera ! ( half italian blood obviously 😁🤘🏼💪🏼)
the whole Alchemy concert was epic! And also Wembley 85 also great (Tunnel of Love live = phenomenal)
Absolutely, the Alchemy concert was a masterpiece. 'Tunnel of Love' live eh? Dire Straits never disappoints! Thanks for sharing your thoughts! I covered the studio version here: th-cam.com/video/ewHtF6eULfw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=W3CAlKP4uatLbcCN
I’ve watched a ton of reactions to this particular Alchemy version of the song and yours is currently my favourite. This is due to the fact that you’re a musician, a fellow Canadian, and most of all because of your raw, emotional reaction to the performance and to the song’s story. It’s so refreshing to see people become vulnerable enough to share their feelings and like you did as I had tears throughout the video as well. This is hands down my favourite Dire Straits live performance and is perhaps the best I’ve ever seen in my many years of experiencing live music.
Because of your approach and the fact that you have a graded list (which I wholeheartedly agree with), I subscribed to your channel and will continue to support you as your move forward.
Ps. I have an unapologetic man crush on Mark Knopfler as well for the same reasons. I’m also drawn to drummers and Terry Williams slid into my top 5 list of favourites (with Carter Beauford from Dave Matthews Band in the top spot). Mark Knopfler is hands down my favourite guitarist with David Gilmour following closely behind.
Again, brilliant reaction to Telegraph Road and Sultans. You have a great channel and next to Polo’s site, the both of you provide such refreshing insight. Please keep it up as you have a gift for this stuff.
Thank you so much for your incredibly kind and thoughtful comment! I'm truly touched by your words. It means a lot to me that my reaction resonated with you on such a deep level, especially as a fellow Canadian and musician.
Dire Straits' Alchemy performance is indeed something special, and I'm happy to have shared that emotional experience with you. It's always been my goal to bring genuine and heartfelt reactions to the table, and I'm glad that it comes through in my videos.
Your support and subscription are greatly appreciated. Mark Knopfler is a true genius, and I totally understand the man crush! Terry Williams and Carter Beauford are both phenomenal drummers, and it's awesome to see them getting the recognition they deserve. Stay tuned for more reactions, and thank you for being part of this community!
Thank you for watching! 😊
I can feel your emotions man. Right in the hart! Made me cry.
I don't know what to say. This song is profound for so many of us, possibly for a thousand different reasons. MK is someone special. Thanks for watching.
Well done; happy to see others feel the same emotions and teary eyes that I get with each replay of this song. So impressive.
At about 10:30 of this song, I see MK himself get very emotional for about 45 seconds. Brilliant performance and song. Thanks for watching.
Every band member a master of their craft. Loved the reaction. Your detailed intro to the song is appreciated. Subscribed.
🤟😃
Thanks so much! Agree, every member of Dire Straits is a master in their own right, and that's what makes their performances so captivating. Glad you enjoyed the reaction and found the intro helpful! Welcome aboard! 🤟😃 Thank you for watching!
Thanks Larry for your truly genuine reaction! It is so nice to hear that this song brings back memories for you. Next to a brilliant guitar player, Mark is a fabulous storyteller. I hope you consider listening to the live version of Brothers in Arms at the "on the night"- tour one day, because that's a story that's still going on these days ...Greetings from the Netherlands
Thank you for your kind words! It's wonderful to hear how Dire Straits' music resonates with fans from around the world. MK's storytelling ability truly adds another dimension. I'll definitely check out the live version of "Brothers in Arms" from the "On the Night" tour. Greetings from Brazil! 🎸🎶 Thank you for watching!
Great reaction. ❤ sometimes there is a song with superb lyrics, superb music and in a perfect moment as if it were out of time, touched by grace.
Thank you and very well put. Magnificence on display. Love, love, love it!
Nice review 👍.
Thanks for watching. "Tunnel of Love" is up next (Wednesday) from the same concert:)
@@llarose not a bad choice. One of the songs I fell in love for about 40 years ago 😊.
Great to see finally able to upload this
Great reaction dude check out telegraph road live from this concert
This was Telegraph Road:) I had to make the video smaller, then got the thumbs up. Thanks for watching.
Like your reactions Larry. Thanks.
Glad you like them! Thanks for watching. They are released every Wednesday at about 4pm Eastern time:)
They are crying because this is in their home town, Sheffield. The motorway around there is still fscked up 35+ years later! I've been lucky enough to see them live twice.
Interesting insight! It must have been quite an experience to witness them live, especially with the emotional connection to their hometown. it's unfortunate to hear about the ongoing issues with the motorway. Thanks for sharing your firsthand experience!
Magnificent song, brilliantly performed and wonderful heartfelt reaction! Please try 'Brothers in Arms' live 'On the Night'...Deeply moving, as Mark wrote the song as a tribute to a friend killed in the Falklands war.
Agree, an outstanding performance and song. Yes, the concept of 'Brothers in Arms' is not lost on me. I will get to it. Thank you for watching.
Lyrically this is the most poetic of all Dire Straits' tracks. Brothers in Arms is close, but the poetry together with the passion of its delivery makes this stand out. Other great guitarists were as technically able as Knopfler. They could play music and accompany songs, but for me no one can make the instrument cry, sing and move like him.
I agree with everything you said. Yes, the Jimmy Page’s and SRV’s of the world are at the top, but methinks MK and David Gilmour are of a different ilk and just mesmerizing in their unique way.
Funny how it takes a Brit to reveal our origins for us. Mark has an eye and an ear, and his work is unparalleled.
I've seen Dire Straits 4 times and I've never come out of their shows without mist in my eyes.
There are few composers who understand the impact of silence. Mark Does!
Very interesting comment. How did Britain pump out so many profound musicians? Holding it together during this song is tough. Yes, MK is the MAN! Thanks for watching.
He did it again with his song sailing to Philadelphia..it’s about the Mason-Dixon Line. He do it together with James Tayler
@@moonlightfairy100He actually reads! Fascinating.
Thank God for Mark Knopfler and Dire Strait
Mark Knopfler's guitar skills are so good, even the gods are taking notes!
If you want to check out just how good his song writing is check out the sound tracks for Local Hero and The Princess Bride MK did both, plus a few others
Thank for the intel and tips. I’m going to check these out. Thanks to the folks commenting here, Alchemy is a new journal on my end. Cheers!
And for local hero watch the movie … it’s amazing
It is very hard not to like dire straits no matter what music you listen to. I really believe that they were one of those complete bands, like Rush. It needs nothing less and nothing more. The drumming in this: perfect for the song. Contained, yet very much part of the song.
Absolutely, Dire Straits has a universal appeal that transcends genres. They're one of those rare bands, like Rush, (a favorite of mine), that just seem to have it all-great musicianship, timeless songs, and a unique sound that's instantly recognizable.
Also, if you want heartfelt "Straits" check out "Brothers in arms" and, better, "The Mans Too Strong". Morre emotion there for you butt
Thanks for the recommendation! I'll definitely check out 'Brothers in Arms' and 'The Man's Too Strong.' Always enthusiastic to explore more of Dire Straits' emotional depth in their music.
If you want somber, look at brothers in arms, a masterpiece
Absolutely, studio version, which I'm familiar with od "Brothers in Arms" is another beauty. Its somber tone and poignant lyrics make it a deeply moving and powerful song. I'll definitely consider reacting to the live version in the future. Thanks for the suggestion!
I recommend tunnel of love from the same concert .
Absolutely! Dire Straits really delivered an unforgettable performance. Thanks for the recommendation! 🎸🎶 I covered the studio version here: th-cam.com/video/ewHtF6eULfw/w-d-xo.html
Great reaction, Have you heard Max Webster :"Battle scar" might be a good one for a drummer since is features Neil Peart?
Thank you for the kind words. I'm very aware of Max Webster (a band that frequently toured with RUSH) however, I'm not remembering this song. I'll def check it out, esp. with Peart taking on the drums. Thanks for tuning in.
🎉🎉
Is this about the music...or you? Many of us prefer giving the performers 80% of the screen instead of 20%...just an opinion. btw. Well done.
Thanks for the feedback 🎬🎶
Reaction and rating? A bit of an unfortunate title, don't you think? We can all react to one of Dire Straits' most memorable songs and performances, but "rating" it? Few of us would dare, fewer still are in any position to actually do it in any meaningful capacity. What a spectacle, and how I envy the people in that audience.
Oh, you're absolutely right-how dare anyone try to rate a Dire Straits performance! The nerve! But hey, engaging with viewers and sparking discussions is what it's all about. And yes, the spectacle of "Telegraph Road" live is something we all envy. Thanks for pointing that out and for watching! 😏🎸✨
Wonderful watching your reaction to the Incredible live version here. It doesn't matter that I've watched this a 1000 times before, sharing the journey never fails to surprise me. Sublime band headed by the one of a kind Mark Knopfler. So emotional and was great to share the journey with you once again.
Thank you, brother. Witnessing Mark Knopfler's performance is truly a delight, surpassing any prior expectations. The song's narrative is both captivating and poignant, serving as a source of inspiration and melancholy simultaneously. Your presence here, sharing in this experience, is deeply appreciated.
What’s great about the Alchemy concert is that everyone in the band has their moments to shine. Keys/piano is such an integral part of Telegraph Road, whether studio or live, and Alan Clark is masterful here. As for MK, well he stands out in any performance, even ones where he’s in the background. Telegraph Road is a masterpiece in songwriting, it evokes so much emotion.
It's sad how Alan's abilities didn't get used on studio albums after _Love Over Gold._ Knopfler ended his Springsteen phase by the mid-80s, so Clark's talent was relegated to live shows.
I love Telegraph Road, but the one thing that I still find annoying, is how loud the crowd was, to the point of being disrespectful. During those quiet moments, where every single note should be alighting on your soul, some yahoo is whistling and hooting. They can't hear the music themselves, and they're ruining it for their neighbors. Can you imagine someone doing that during a symphony? There is a time to let the band know you love them, and a time to keep one's mouth shut. Such great lyrics, great story, to Telegraph Road, but this is one time I wish the sound engineers could have cut out the crowd noise. Sorry for the rant. I've been wanting to get that off my chest for a long time. 🕊
@@CuzKatieSaysSo The band clearly enjoyed the crowd's enthusiasm.
Oh, there's no question, a band always enjoys crowd feedback, they feed on it. The band/crowd chemistry at Grateful Dead concerts was part of what made their concerts so magical. But there's a time to let the music alight in your soul, sink down deep, your ears take in sound and if your mouth is open it's just because you're standing there with your mouth hanging open and you just Listen. 😊 And this almost painfully sweet piana solo was one of those times. And during that quiet section, would You have liked it to have some guy start whistling or yelling right in your ear? I've had that at concerts and it's not pleasant. Let's face it, it's rude. And a man's whistle can be loud enough to just about to pierce your brain. Well that's not true, some women can whistle at head splitting levels also. As I said, there's a time and a place. I've been to plenty of symphony performances where you can hear a pin drop, when they are done, the audience brings the roof down.
I've done plenty of showing my "enthusiasm " at concerts too. When it's appropriate. Just my humble opinion.
@@CuzKatieSaysSo The time and place to shout and whistle is ... at a live concert. Where else?!
Loved your reaction. When I witness the talent on that stage it brings tears to my eyes. Mark Knopfler is out of this world.
Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed the reaction. Keeping it real on the channel here. Dire Straits' talent is truly awe-inspiring, and Mark Knopfler's guitar prowess is simply out of this world. It's incredible how music can evoke such powerful emotions, isn't it?
Brought me to tears...again..No matter how many times I hear or watch this performance, I'm gone...😵💫
It's amazing how music can evoke such strong emotions, isn't it? This performance has that power to move us deeply every single time. Thank you for sharing your experience! 🎶😊 Thank you for watching!
I already warned you in my comment in Sultans of swing that this version of Telegraph Road was not going to disappoint you. Actually, Mark Knopfler never disappoints. And not to mention that all the musicians on Alchemy are superb.
Thank you sister. It’s magical and profound how MK did this. And you’re right about the entire band: sublime. Thanks for being with me on the MK/DS journey.
masterclass masterpiece. drummer just like ac/dc was so great and was noticed by many. but marks guitar playing is so crispy its ridiculous lol and then with his story telling voice. piano player superb great band nuff said.
Absolutely! Telegraph Road is a masterclass in musicianship. Terry William's solid, powerful beats & fills anchor the whole performance, much like AC/DC's style. And Mark’s guitar playing? It’s ridiculously crisp-no doubt about it. His storytelling voice and the superb piano work round out an incredible band performance. Nuff said indeed!
Back in the day, when pop music was an artform. And you actually had to play instruments together.
Absolutely! Those were the days when pop/rock/punk et al was truly an art form, and bands had to play instruments together to create magic. Thanks for reminiscing with me! 🎶🎸
Mark has a new album coming out in April. At 74 he still has it.
Loved your reaction man I am watching this in Perth Western Australia 8.00am ❤ Mark Knopfler has to be the Ultimate Guitarist but the whole band soooo tight amazing band
Thanks for the kind words! Mark Knopfler's guitar work truly is something special, and the band's tightness is remarkable. Watching this in Perth at 8:00 am must have been a great start to your day! Sending you greetings from Rio de Janeiro! 🌞🎸
I grew up outside Detroit in the late 70s and early 80s, and this song describes its history so well. From building nothing into widespread economic prosperity, and then free falling into depression, desperation and unemployment. But even then there is hope. MK is an incredible story teller, composer and musician, and his ability to combine those traits into one package the way he does is truly incredible.
You can also see that so many of us have our own Telegraph Road stories from all over the world. You had front row seats to this masterpiece in real time. Much respect to Detroit (with all its charms and flaws) - Thanks for representing.
This performance along with Once Upon A Time In The West from Alchemy are my favorites. Brothers In Arms and Private Investigations both from Dire Straits Live "On The Night" 1992 are just jaw dropping performances. Loving your channel and reactions. All the best from Australia 👍🎸🎸🎸
Thank you so much for your kind comment and support! "Telegraph Road" from Alchemy is a breathtaking performance, Dire Straits at their absolute best. and, I'll def check "Once Upon A Time In The West"
Absolutely sublime reaction with emotion that mirrored that of this masterpiece! Thank you! Best wishes from the UK! Take care!
Thank you very much! I'm happy that you enjoyed the reaction. It's an indisputable masterpiece, and it's an honor (and sometimes embarrassing:))) to experience and share the emotions it evokes. Best wishes to you too, from South America - all the way from the UK! Take care and keep enjoying the music!
If I remember correctly, weren't you a 'killer' in hockey. Loved this Larry. Nice to see your naked emotions in this incredible performance! You're a layered brother too.
Haha, yeah, that was me. Misguided, angry Mofo. Took listening to MK to tame me. Thanks for watching bro.
Not only did Mark Knopfler write the lyrics he wrote the music and arranged the performance.
He is a story teller.
A shout out to the drummer Terry Williams and piano player Guy Fletcher.
Absolutely, MK's talent as both a songwriter and musician is truly exceptional. Each member of the band brings something special to the table. Thank you for highlighting their contributions! 🎸🥁🎹 Thank you for watching!
The principal pianist is Alan Clark. Classically trained and it shows. Guy Fletcher was the other keyboardist, but it's Alan Clark we see here.
Fantastic reaction, the whole band just work together. Could you please do Tunnel of Love, love to see your reaction . Thanks
Thank you for your kind words! I'm glad you enjoyed the reaction. "Tunnel of Love" is a fantastic song, and I'd be delighted to do a reaction to the live version. Stay tuned. Thanks for the suggestion!
Love your reaction. Mark is indeed a hero here in England. I've listened all my life, so grateful. Live versions of 'Brothers in Arms' always get to me.
Thanks for the feedback! I haven’t seen that live performance yet, but I’m definitely interested in checking it out. Appreciate the suggestion and your support!
A lot is said about the piano in this and a lot is made of the pianist in this piece. but take the drums out and it would be all fall flat. give it to the drummer who was on point and not overpowering everything else.
Absolutely, Terry Williams' drumming adds that crucial backbone to the entire performance. His precision and restraint are commendable, ensuring every element of the song shines. Thank you for highlighting his contribution!
@@llaroseone of the best drumming intros I have heard is from Money For Nothing by Dire Straits. Be warned the lyrics are not politically correct. They are not politically correct for a reason.
There are 3 live performances in rock history that are absolutely epic: this one; Phil Collins, The First Farewell Tour, 2004 (Paris), and Journey, the Escape Tour, 1981 in Houston. (Queen at Live Aid gets an honorable mention: great performance, very stirring, but for the absolute peak of musical genius, falls a wee bit short.) They will never be surpassed.
Those are some epic live performances! Each one captures the peak of musical genius in its own way. Thanks for sharing your top picks! Thank you for watching! 🎶🤘
'Alchemy' is one of those albums that you need to listen to with good headphones, many times over, and focus on listening to one particular instrument at a time. The depth, complexity and interplay only get better when then listening to the whole - a perfect case of the whole being even greater than the sum of the brilliant individual parts
Alchemy is a true showcase of depth and musical craftsmanship. For the record, I have an entire music studio at my disposal, and I have played this 100 times since creating this video... Every time you dive into it, you uncover something new, and that’s what makes it such a timeless album. It's a brilliant example of the whole being greater than the sum of its parts.
Thank you for watching!
Absolute gem of a song, I adore this performance, as I do the whole concert.
What interests me about Telegraph Road is that it was developed by the band during sound checks whilst touring for the Making Movies album. There are DS concert bootlegs from 1981 on TH-cam which show they actually had it in their set list, in a similar spot, before it was recorded on the Love Over Gold album the following year. Says much about the bravery, and confidence of Mark and the band that not only did they play an unreleased song as an encore, but an epic song like this one. Now it was definitely an early draft and probably in need of some refinement, but the quality was there, not to mention Pick Withers was superb on the drums.
Great reaction.
Thank you for the great intel and kind word. It really is a grand spectacle of the highest order. Only via having this small channel did I get the heads-up from the comment section that this concert existed. One correction: The drummer here was Terry Williams. Why? I don't know, as Withers was the drummer on the studio version. Thanks for watching and engaging.
I've loved Dire Straits since I first started listening to them in the late 80s. This version is probably my favorite DS performance/song (I'm also very weak for Tunnel Of Love - the live version from Wembley 85) Fantastic review and I particularly like how you explained the background for the lyrics. Being Norwegian I've not read the Knut Hamsun book, which I probably should... Your pronunciation was perfect (supposed to pronounce the K-N sound like you did, unlike for instance Knife where the K is skipped)
Thanks for sharing your love for Dire Straits! "Tunnel of Love" live is coming to the channel soon. . Knut Hamsun's influence on Mark Knopfler's lyrics adds an intriguing layer to the song. I'm glad my pronunciation aligned with your expectations. Knut Hamsun's work offers a fascinating glimpse into Norwegian literature, and delving into it might deepen your appreciation for the song even more. Cheers!
I just wonder if you guys can imagine what it was like coming home with this record in a bag, Love over Gold' in '82, I was 16 that year. I went straight to my room and put it on. The music hitting you... i have no words to describe it. I was totally blown away, although I had Making Movies and DS first album too. This was mindblowing, especially Telegraph Road and still is, 40 years later, unbeatably the best ever ❤. Yes, I heard it LIVE in '85! Thank god for Mark Knopfler, as a musician and songwriter and storyteller! Remember he was an English teacher before he went for a full music career.🙏✍️📚🎸🌏🎶
All the Best, Carin in Sweden
Absolutely, Carin! That feeling of anticipation bringing home a new record and immersing yourself in the music is unforgettable. It's incredible how music can continue to resonate so deeply, even after decades. Thank you for sharing your experience and love for Mark Knopfler's artistry! 🎶🙏 Thank you (from Rio de Janeiro) for watching! Here's my original Love Over Gold Vinyl: th-cam.com/video/tlV8PD-4KEI/w-d-xo.html
The back story as I have it- The story was based on a novel by Knut Hamsun, and follows a man who decides to settle in the wilderness, wants to live a simple life, but everyone arrives and stays, and the road gets wider, and longer. The traveller hates this, as he just wants to live a simple life…. The road in question is Telegraph Road, (US 24) a stretch of pavement spanning almost 80 miles from Toledo, Ohio, to Detroit, Michigan. It was little more than a modest dirt path since it was beaten in the mid-19th century, growing and widening as it became the backbone for infrastructure such as telegraph poles and roadways as the decades rolled onward. In the 1910s, it exploded in usage with the booming auto industry in Detroit, and towns grew off of it as people sought to capitalize on this influx of wealth into the region. But at this point, the story grows achingly familiar. The communities dependent on the road still bear the deep scars of the exodus of the automobile industry. The road
has become the scar of progress that the community now bears. Its history is a drama played over a century.
I ended up reading the book after publishing this video...
"Telegraph Road" really captures that journey from simplicity to industrial growth and the scars of progress. Thanks for sharing this detailed history. Thank you for watching! 🚗📜
fantastic reaction by someone who really gets it ! The legend that is Mark Knoffler and phenomena that is Dire Straits. I was in at the beginning of this and I'm now 77 years of age, and I stll get goose bumps listening to the Alchemy live album !
thank you for sharing
Thank you so much for your kind words! It's truly an honor to receive such praise from someone who has been a fan of Dire Straits since the beginning. MK and Dire Straits are now legends in my book too:) Their music continues to captivate! The Alchemy concert is amazing, and it's amazing to hear that it still gives you goosebumps after all these years. Your support and passion for their music are truly inspiring. Thank you for sharing your experience!
As I have come to expect an excellent reaction to my favorite (live) song from my favorite band. I mean, the studio version of this wasn't so great, was it? But here it is just something that nobody else can do better. The piano, drums, bass and Mark of course, have any band had so many great musicians? Hamsun is controversial but if he in some way inspired this I don't care:).
Thank you for your kind words! It's incredible how DS elevates the song to new heights with their performance. Inspiration can come from unexpected places, and regardless of the source, the result is undeniably captivating. Thanks for sharing your thoughts! 🎶🙏
I mean tunnel of love my apologies lol
I think this song and the Alchemy concert in general is a great example of a band being "tight," i.e. in sync, sublimely together. Can you comment on this thought? Is band tightness something you can feel when it's happening?
Yes, just like a team sport, when relaxation sets in, it’s like a ‘group telepathy’. It’s an addictive feeling. It’s really tough to reach those levels, completely. It’s like a strong mind-altering drug. PF just had the ‘correct’ people together. What doesn’t get seen is the endless practice and frustrations that are essential in getting ‘there’ - thanks for watching.
Hes some guitarist...but as you say the Pianist , drummer also deserve a special mention. He makes me want to burn my guitar.
Indeed, MK's guitar prowess is legendary, including the incredible talents of the entire band. Each member brings something unique to the table, making the music truly unforgettable. No need to burn your guitar - let's just appreciate the magic they create together! 🎸🎹🥁 Thank you for watching!
Beautiful reaction!
I think Telegraph Road is the best song ever written. The Alchemy live version is the best version of Telegraph Road. Guitarist Mark Knopfler and drummer Terry Williams are great, but I think the pianoplayer Alan Clark is one of the best in the world.
Thank you for your kind words! "Telegraph Road" is indeed a masterpiece, and the Alchemy live version captures its essence beautifully. The talent of each member of Dire Straits shines through in this performance, and Alan Clark's piano adds a unique depth to the song. It's amazing how each musician brings their own magic to the table, making the whole greater than the sum of its parts. Truly a timeless classic!
Hey Larry I justed turned 60 this year and DS was and still is my band. I heard this song more than 1500 times and I always get emotional and most astonishing, I always here different tones. These are always my best 13‘ minutes in live. Greetings from 🇨🇭
Thanks for sharing your experience. It's amazing how Dire Straits' music keeps revealing new layers, even after so many listens. Glad you enjoy it as much as I do. Greetings back to 🇨🇭!
Don't worry about the tears Larry, this song touches me very deep every time I listen to it.
You explained it beautifully, the rise and the fall of an entire region, and in the second part, how all of it can get very personal and emotional with the loved one.
What I just saw was a marvelous, emotional reaction to a song that accompanied me for a lifetime.
Thank you for this!
Linus from Switzerland
Thank you so much for your kind words, Linus. "Telegraph Road" is indeed a powerful journey through both personal and collective experiences, and it's heartening to hear that my reaction resonated with you. It's a privilege to share these moments together. Take care, from Rio de Janeiro - and thanks again for watching! 🎶🌍🙏
You should do TUNNEL OF LOVE and PRIVATE INVESTIGATIONS from the same concert....first saw this recording when i was 13yrs old...and it changed my life...
Thanks for the suggestion! "Tunnel of Love" and "Private Investigations" from the Alchemy concert are both going to be covered here on the channel. Here's the studio version: th-cam.com/video/ewHtF6eULfw/w-d-xo.html - It's amazing how music can have such a profound impact on us, especially when we discover it at a young age. Stay tuned, and thanks for sharing your experience!
@@llarose Thank for replying mate....i love the channel. Ive been studying film and broadcasting at college, in ayr, scotland, recently and im the oldest in my class by far (im 52 and most of my class is in their late teens to mid twenties. One of the ways we've connected is through love of bands..partic the ones i grew up with (dire straits, genesis, ac/dc, iron maiden, pink floyd etc) and im constantly asked to recount tales of gigs ive been to and what it was like living through an era when the songs we know now as classics, were fresh and new. Great music does indeed span generations!
Up there with the best songs ever recorded. A masterpiece.
Yes and yes. Absolutely stunning song. Thank you for being here and sharing the journey with me.
Larry you have to listen to tunnel of love alchemy live dire straits
Apparently so, according to about 100 people in the comment section:) I will watch it unprepared, here on the channel (like most my videos..lol). I just need to get a few more performances done in-between. Thanks for watching. Great concert so far!
This is great, if you want to see an equally great performance, look no further than Phil Collins "in the air tonight" live.
Thanks for the suggestion!
@@llarose as a drummer I think you'll appreciate it 👍
Hey Larry, i really love how you evidently connect with the music your listening to, sure DS happens to be my favorite band, but in watching your video's, what makes watching them worthwhile is your emotion and genuine interpretation of what you've heard and what it means to you, lyrically as well. I have a feeling that's what strikes a chord (so to speak) with your followers. I've listened to this live track and the studio version for many years. I remember going to sleep with a girl i met whilst travelling in S.E. Asia like 10 years ago, and i play it whenever i feel the need to, its a great piece of art and it's just always been there in my life. I think its a special piece. But anyway- you can go to the water right away and swim?! Lucky man, and many blessings to you. Keep doing what you're doing, all the best :).
Thank you so much for your kind words! It means a lot to me that you connect with the music and my interpretation of it. "Telegraph Road" isa special piece of art that has touched many lives, including yours and mine. And yes, I do feel fortunate to be able to enjoy a swim whenever I want. Sending many blessings your way as well! Keep enjoying the music and sharing your experiences. All the best to you too! 🎶
Can you actually imagine being at that concert?
The energy from the crowd speaks volumes. Thanks for watching.
Great reaction, what a perfornance, one of the best out there!
Thank you! Absolutely, it's hard to beat Dire Straits' performance in Alchemy. One of the best, no doubt! Appreciate your comment!
Thank you Larry! I grew up in northern Sweden - skiing, playing hockey etc....yes, the mood of all these small towns...the cold winters... the men who built something in the wilderness... the struggle of us ordinary "small" people in the "modern world"... I totally relate.
Thanks for sharing your background, as it adds a whole new layer of appreciation to the song, doesn't it? The imagery and emotions really resonate with the experiences of many, especially those who grew up in similar settings. Thanks for watching.
Dire Straits is the earthy sibling of Pink Floyd
Some have stated that earlier along with Supertramp. I still can't believe how MK burns up that Strat with his fingers. Thanks for watching.
@@llarose Knopfler, Gilmour, Cockburn and McMurtry are my favorite musical companions in road/hiking trips.🎶👍
This is the second time have visited your channel, first time was sultans of swing. I will now subscribe, I have seen this live version so many times and always enjoy it. But your reaction was outstanding. By the way a freind of mine saw them in the early days in my city wolverhampton uk, there was only four people there. John fleshy( bass) mentions it in his autobiography. And to make things worse the cheque ( bounced) was not honoured. They didn't get paid for the gig. Oved the reaction. Maybe try ' in the gallery' I think it was on the comunique album. Not so rocky but a good serious song. Thanks again
Thank you so much for your kind words and for subscribing to my channel! It's always a pleasure to hear from fans who appreciate the reactions. That's a cool story about Dire Straits' early days in Wolverhampton, UK-what a testament to their perseverance and eventual success. I'll definitely consider looking into to "In the Gallery" for the channel here-it sounds like a great suggestion. Thanks again for your support, and I look forward to bringing you more reactions in the future!
This song/arraignment is absolute perfection.
The masterpiece section of my ratings system is a hard place to land for any song. This one was a no-brainer. I agree. Thanks for watching.
Great reaction ! You're right -this is a great storytelling - both in music and lyrics. You have to see Tunnel of love, the drum part is insane there !
Thank you for the kind feedback. Love this song so much. I have published the non-live version here: th-cam.com/video/ewHtF6eULfw/w-d-xo.html - However, I have a feeling I'll be coming back to this Alchemy version soon!
I had the Alchemy cd as a teenager in the 90's and just recently got a nice copy on vinyl , probably one of the best live performance ever recorded IMO
There was something special including family members attending regards this unbelievable live performance. I can't give it enough praise. Terry Williams was super-amazing along with the rest of the crew. Thanks for watching.
❤
You have a beautiful soul and heart...you breathe the music and love pure art.This masterpiece IS pure art.I absolutely loved your great reaction and you won another fan.Thank you.
Thank you for the kind words. Keeping it together during this song was very difficult. Only Pink Floyd's 'Dogs' rivalled this kind of profound story telling that just rips straight to the soul. Thanks for being part of the journey.
I’ve been listening to this album since I bought it in the early 80s and I never get bored of it. Telegraph Road has always been my lifelong favourite track and feels like the soundtrack to my life now. I was fortunate to see them in Paris in ‘85 when I was just 16 for their Brothers In Arms tour. Thank you for your appreciation.
That’s amazing! “Telegraph Road” is such a timeless track, and seeing them live in Paris at 16 must have been unforgettable. Thanks for sharing your story and for your support! Thank you for watching! 🎸🌟
And here I thought that I was the only one who's emotions ; from tears to all the beautiful changes ( classical...etc.)...🎉 Great , honest REACTION 😊
Thank you so much! I'm glad to know I'm not alone in feeling such a wide range of emotions from "Telegraph Road." The way it weaves through different musical styles is just incredible. Thanks for appreciating my reaction! 😊
This is one of my 2 all time favourite tracks, alongside "Save Me" by Avenged Sevenfold, very different to each other but equal masterpieces for me. Never too late to learn piano - I started learning drums last year as a hobby to take me into retirement....
Avenged Sevenfold, will look them up. Agree with your sentiment. I've just spent 7-8 years learning guitar and bass. Piano would be a great addition, because of the flexibility of pretty much playing anywhere, anytime. Good luck with your drumming journey. My singular tip, is try and relax and not overthink:)
I`m a Truck Driver in Europe! I heard your words and see all of this all over Europe! You may go, where you want, It`s all the Telegraph Road!
It's fascinating to hear how "Telegraph Road" resonates with experiences across Europe, especially from the perspective of a truck driver who traverses these roads. Thank you for sharing your perspective! 🚚🎶
It was also written on Telegraph Road. Yeah. It’s a real road He was on the bus to Detroit . I’m primarily an Acoustic player so I know how he does it. Everyone should start on an acoustic.
Yes, this is a very good point. It is a real road, but don't we all have a 'Telegraph Road' of our own? Regards guitar, I learned on an acoustic. Can you say 'sore fingers' - Thanks for watching
I always wondered if Mark was also influenced by the TV miniseries Centennial, based on the James A Michener novel. It was shown on the BBC a year or two (from memory) before Mark wrote the song, and also concerned the founding and growth of a town from a 'home in the wilderness'.
That's an interesting observation! It's possible that MK could have been influenced by the themes presented in "Centennial," especially if it resonated with him during that time period. Thanks for sharing your insight! 📺🎶
I love that Mark's geordie dialect kicks in when we says we aren't going to "pay wor toll'"; 'wor' being Tyneside speech for 'our'
He is something special in every way. Tunnel of Love from the same concert will be ready in about 45 minutes: th-cam.com/video/Yh6sDwz1xe4/w-d-xo.html - Thank you for watching.
Love the video. Another great song from alchemy is Young lovers, fantastic song, you'd really like it
I was thinking of covering the entire concert.. given enough time. Thank you very much for the intel and watching.
Saw dire straits live in the 80s still my favourite concert…and now telegraph rd has slowly overtaken all the rest to be my favourite Mark knopfler song it brings a tear how things always change
It's amazing how our perspectives and favorites evolve over time, isn't it? "Telegraph Road" has a way of touching the soul and leaving a lasting impact. Chokes me up. Thanks for sharing your experience, and I'm glad you enjoyed the reaction! 🎶
Telegraph Road - studio version, is absolutely brilliant. Live Alchemy version is transcendental. Beyond borders - physical and mental.
Absolutely! The studio version of "Telegraph Road" is brilliant, but the live version from Alchemy takes it to another level, transcending physical and mental borders. I covered the studio version here: th-cam.com/video/tlV8PD-4KEI/w-d-xo.html Thank you for watching!
Reviewer well and truly immersed 😮😊😢🎉🎉
Absolutely immersed! It's hard not to get carried away with such incredible music. Thanks for tuning in! 🎶😊
Great reaction, very good observations and spot on about both the music and the meaning and emotion of the song, I must have listened to this song about 1000 times and it still just gets better every time.
Nice to hear the personal references as well and how Knopflers writing really hits home.
And if I may just say it - your shoulder tattoos look really nice, that’s a great look!
Thank you so much for your kind words! "Telegraph Road" is truly a timeless masterpiece that resonates deeply with so many listeners. I'm glad you enjoyed the personal insights and observations. And thank you for the compliment on my tattoos-I appreciate it! They hold special significance for me.