Editors' slugfest: 2024 Oscar nominations reactions (and early winner predictions)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Moments after the Academy Awards announced their 2024 slate of nominations in all 23 categories, Gold Derby’s Editors got together to dish all of the egregious snubs and pleasant surprises. Denton Davidson, Marcus James Dixon, Daniel Montgomery and Ray Richmond also gave their early forecasts for who they think will win in many of the exciting races. Do YOUR reactions line up with theirs? Watch our 2024 Oscar nominations discussion video above and then make your predictions at Gold Derby.
SUBSCRIBE TO GOLD DERBY:
/ goldderby
CONNECT WITH GOLD DERBY
Web: www.goldderby....
Facebook: / goldderby
Twitter: / goldderby
Instagram: / goldderby
Newsletter: pages.email.gol...
ABOUT GOLD DERBY:
Gold Derby features celebrity videos plus expert predictions, tracking who will win Oscars, Emmys, Grammys, Tonys, Golden Globes and top reality TV shows 'The Amazing Race,' 'American Idol,' 'Dancing with the Stars,' 'Survivor,' 'The Voice' and more.
Guys, after winning the GG for best comedy pic, and getting 11 BAFTA and Oscar noms (2nd only to Oppenheimer) it’s time to put Poor Things in the #2 slot.
Bradley would be overdue if the work he did was worthy of an Oscar. Maestro is not worthy.
Bradley will win eventually but I don't find him to be a powerhouse behind or in front of the camera.
There was never a moment where I felt "yikes that's incredible!!"
People have their panties in a twist about Barbie, but was it really worthy of nominations?
Incredible parallels between Barbie and Top Gun: Maverick - both made about $1.5 billion in box office and received Best Picture nominations, but missed lead performer and director
How many members of the Academy are in the director’s branch that nominated the directors? They seem to not like to nominate blockbuster directors with Joseph Kosinski getting snubbed last year despite the DGA nom, and Denis Villeneuve the year before despite the DGA nom. Also no James Cameron last year for the highest grossing movie.
Bradley Cooper is not overdue…every time he was nominated, there was someone better in those categories.
except rami malek, bradley should have won for a star is born
@@melisagalvalizi6982Absolutely true
I agree!!!
@@melisagalvalizi6982 True
@@melisagalvalizi6982 Bale should have won for VICE
Top Gun director wasn’t nominated. Greta directed a juggernaut and I think that was the bias.
Love Daniel Montgomery but can Denton or Marcus gift him a microphone. Is he underwater? lol
True, I was struggling a bit to hear him
JULY 21ST/ 21 NOMS
Sorry lads but Christopher and Joyce do it so much better than you.
Good to get both 🤷🏻♂️
Being a nolanite myself I know many nolanites will be watching him win his Best Director Award.
He certainly deserves it
AMEN🙏🏾
Cillian Murphy & Oppenheimer for the wins!!! 🏆
How are the Gerwig and Robbie non noms snubs? Triet had better reviews and won Cannes. Poor Things ( which I not a fan of stole Barbie’s thunder. Was everyone surprised when Top Gun did not make it in director last year?
I really do not understand these cries of bs from punters and ‘critics’ alike. Tome the word ‘ implies a wilful, intentional, artificial omission. There are just under 11k voting members in theAcademy. To be wilfully, intentionally, artificially denied a om by under1k people?? Wow. They must reaydislike the candidates.
The idea that Barbie is owed best director and actress just bc it made a billion dollars is laughable. Celine Song was more worthy of the 5th spot than Greta Gerwig. I always thought of Barbie as a formidable player, but not a serious contender to actually win
The Oscars usually switch on picture after award szn. We’ve seen sweeps and then oscar’s will switch it up last minute. I don’t think Oppenheimer is completely safe to win
The universal campaign is too strong, and i thought Holdovers had a chance but the snub to Payne sealed its fate
What is the alternative in your opinion?
i mean it’s still my #1 at this point for Best Pic. I still wanna see what PGA, SAG, and Bafta does tho… like I can see Poor Things or Anatomy of a Fall winning maybe even Holdovers just based on their strong presence and that they’ve all been slowly gaining momentum within the last couple of weeks at the right timing. Oppenheimer could be peaking too early like we’ve seen before or it could just juggernaut and sweep. We’ll see, i’m just saying keep ur eyes peeled.
lets be honest holdovers and poor things fail to get sag ensemble which is a red flag when it comes to best picture winners
@@eddistasio644yes and no. it’s great to watch out for stats but they don’t always correlate. it’s still a threat it has 11 nominations and is the second most nominated this year right behind Oppenheimer.
Bummed that All Of Us Strangers didn't get noms.... especially Andrew Scott and Paul Mescal
four pundits in denial
The discussion of the directing nominations was patchy. As usual, Daniel makes very strong points - I think it's highly likely that (unfortunately) a lot of people thought, "I must have a woman in my five", and given the observable preferences of this branch some will have settled on Triet over Gerwig. But, beyond that, "Barbie" is not the sort of film that makes the cut with this branch, rightly or wrongly. The only film in recent memory I can comp to Barbie that made it in for directing (even with a DGA snub) was "Joker". And "Joker" was led by a best actor frontrunner, which probably created a halo effect. Long story short, I think the principal reason why Greta missed was due to the tastes and preferences of this branch more-so than anything else. Thus Marcus', "if she were Greg Gerwig, would she have made it in," is pithy but misses the mark.
But Joker won the Golden Lion in Venice, and that film has a lot of influence of Scorcesse filmography, it has more appealing for "highbrow" directors. Barbie is seeing more as a comercial movie.
Barbie far outclasses Joker. Its not even close.
So, what if Bradley Coopler has multiple Academy Award nominations?! Glenn Close and Peter O'Toole have almost 10 Oscar nominations each. At least the latter, (may he rest in peace) received an Honorary Oscar. Maestro is walking away with 0 Oscar nominations.
History remembers Peter O Toole, very few people remember the actual person who won in 1963
I seriously think Cillian Murphy deserves it more
Cillian Murphy is a better actor, watch Sunshine and peaky Blinders
@@TheFinalRevelation2 gregory peck fpr to kill a mockingbird, an iconic role!!!!
Oscar nominations or Oscar wins? It has 7 nominations and is a real contender in Makeup and Hairstyle.
I think Jeffrey Wright may take actor. Wright is the best actor in The category. Impressive they shot American Fiction in 26 days.
He could be the so-called "dark horse".
The Academy needs to change the International Film category. It should be merit based not on a quota. 😠
It shaping up to be a very predictable award season, with potential spoilers in Adapted Screenplay and best actress
Can’t Gold Derby reach out to whoever in France selects which film goes into selection for international feature - I would love to hear how they select and how they react to Anatomy of a Fall getting so nominated (and Cannes win).
I think in the case of Triet's film, her speech at Cannes criticizing Macron and the government's attitude towards protests led to the Minister of Culture in Macron's government attacking her and calling her out over the fact that her film was funded partially through a state funded model and yet she was critiquing the government. The committee itself has government appointed members such as the National Film Board president. It seems many French industry producers and insiders were turned off by her political views.
@@saurabhvashist4051 thank you for your insight!
charles meltonl was a shocker for not getting in. the kid was brilliant in may december. Sandra Huller was also brilliant in anatomy of a fall and seeing her get nominated made me still believe in the academy awards voting committee
If Noah Baumbach directed Barbie he would’ve gotten nominated.
🙄
If it turned out to be the same movie, then no.
Emily. Blunt's nomination was BS
Sad but true
America Ferrera nomination is also bullshit.
I think Carey Mulligan will win the SAG and she deserves it. The performance is riveting, she is overdue as well.
and sandra will win the bafta
agree@@melisagalvalizi6982
I like it, and it would shake things up
I would swap Poor Things for Orgin.
LOL. I would swap you for basically anybody.