There is a mistake at 32:10 In BMD ( At "A" point 10.11 is positive so it will be on Right Side ), the Same Mistake ( at "D" point 10.11 is Negative So it will be on Left Side ) If you have any further Doubt in BMD Sign Convention Plz watch this video at time frame 27.50 Minute in this video:- th-cam.com/video/NztLfIY7wDU/w-d-xo.html
Thank you bro.. you explain in such a simple way.. tomorrow is my exam of Structural Analysis.. i was stuck in this method.. but this video helped me thanx. 🤟
BMD ka diagram galat hai. Agar same sign hote h kisi member pe to line cross krti hai. Or sign convention bhi galat hai. Baki problem solve karne ka explanation is VERY GOOD.
Sir, I have two doubt. Can you pls clear my doubts? Plss sir My doubt arose when I started studying MDM and other force displacement methods for indeterminate structures. My doubt is that: 1) we get moments on column while analyzing a structure by MDM or other methods. So, how we will know whether the moments generated on column are Mux or Muy ( moment about x and y axis) I mean you know we need moment about x axis and y axis for design of biaxial columns. So, how will we know which one is Mux and Muy from the moments we get by MDM method or any other merhod? 2) we were taught that we provide ties in column just to hold main bars cause there is no shear force acting on column but from analysis by MDM I came to know there is also shear force acting on columns so why I was taught that we shouldn’t consider SF to provide ties. We just provide ties to hold main bars and provide ties as per SP 16 and IS 456. Why is it so sir? There is clear shear force acting then why we don’t consider it and design ties according to that same as we do in case of beams to tackle shear force? PLEASE PLEASE ANSWER THIS TO CLEAR MY DOUBTS SIR. I’ll always be grateful to you. I’ll be waiting for your reply. Pls ask asap sir.
Certainly! Here's a polished version of your request: Could you kindly consider teaching in a single language? I don't intend to be impolite, but it would greatly benefit those who are not familiar with Hindi. When certain concepts or information are conveyed in Hindi, it might pose a challenge for a broader audience to comprehend. Thank you.
Regarding support reactions..for example span AB. We are taking the moments about A. It means the forces and moments which are passing through joint A will not consider..why you consider moment at A for calculating reaction B. Please clarify. It will be applicable fot all other spans.
There is a mistake at 32:10 In BMD ( At "A" point 10.11 is positive so it will be on Right Side ), the Same Mistake ( at "D" point 10.11 is Negative So it will be on Left Side )
If you have any further Doubt in BMD Sign Convention Plz watch this video at time frame 27.50 Minute in this video:- th-cam.com/video/NztLfIY7wDU/w-d-xo.html
Thank you very much sir ,, its so cleared wow ....
Ql^2/8=20×16/8=320/8=40kN.m.It's not 80kN.m ,from Brasil.
Tq sir
Yes and what about height of Bmd..Wl²/8
@@prithaspalette lol he is too busy to give you time sweetheart ! why should he spend time on you when he can do some better things?
Thank you bro.. you explain in such a simple way.. tomorrow is my exam of Structural Analysis.. i was stuck in this method.. but this video helped me thanx. 🤟
I am proud of your teaching technique sir,
Thank you so much sir.
Sir your Teaching Skill is Awesome👏,
It's Great.
Sir big fan ....I will. Score very good marks in dss and it's all because of u sir,now I'm preparing for SA and for that I'm watching ur video
I have never seen a teaching skill like u awesome sir
☺Thank you sir... For ur grt explanation.. And we will correct the mistake from 32:10..😃.
Thank you for sharing the videos
Please make video on Sway frames by MDM and flexibility method, please
Thank you sir For ur great explanation.
BMD ka diagram galat hai. Agar same sign hote h kisi member pe to line cross krti hai. Or sign convention bhi galat hai. Baki problem solve karne ka explanation is VERY GOOD.
Yes dear in BMD the 10.11 of A point and D point will be inside.
Sir You are great🎉
Thanks Sir.... sway frame ka aur types karaiye
lovely u
Thank you Sir. Girlfriend s baat krte krte concept smjh m aa gaya
Thanks sir really this video's really satisfied
Sir. You have explained very well. ....but the vedio is blur...so next time please check it once
Videos are not blur, u might be playing on low quality, kindly check video quality setting
There is a mistake at 31:35..Sir u have written free bending moment diagram for parabola(WL2/8-for UDL). The value is 40,not 80
Thanking of you
I really like your way of explaining. Please also make videos on Sway Analysis of frame by moment distribution method too .
🇳🇵🇳🇵
Sir please Share the Sway Frames Questions by Moment Distribution Method.
Thanku so much sir, 😄😄🙏
You saved me from today's SA exam
Sir agar same ans me agar jidr - he udar + aaya to chalenga kya
Udl ki bmd height 40 aati hai sir, but nice teaching I like sir
Thank you so much sir
Thank you sir
Thank you sir 🙌🙌🙌💖💖
Plz make the video on sway frame moment distribution method
Sir we need more type of problems
Sway and non sway frame
Superb guru
life saver
Sir u are great.....
It is not said in question to draw SFD. So can we neglect it or not
Thank you
Veryyy knowledge vidio
Good video
There is an another small mistake Wl^2/8= 20*4^2/8 = 40 kn.m not 80kn.m.. please clarify 😊
Sir, I have two doubt. Can you pls clear my doubts? Plss sir
My doubt arose when I started studying MDM and other force displacement methods for indeterminate structures. My doubt is that:
1) we get moments on column while analyzing a structure by MDM or other methods. So, how we will know whether the moments generated on column are Mux or Muy ( moment about x and y axis) I mean you know we need moment about x axis and y axis for design of biaxial columns. So, how will we know which one is Mux and Muy from the moments we get by MDM method or any other merhod?
2) we were taught that we provide ties in column just to hold main bars cause there is no shear force acting on column but from analysis by MDM I came to know there is also shear force acting on columns so why I was taught that we shouldn’t consider SF to provide ties. We just provide ties to hold main bars and provide ties as per SP 16 and IS 456. Why is it so sir? There is clear shear force acting then why we don’t consider it and design ties according to that same as we do in case of beams to tackle shear force?
PLEASE PLEASE ANSWER THIS TO CLEAR MY DOUBTS SIR. I’ll always be grateful to you. I’ll be waiting for your reply. Pls ask asap sir.
Certainly! Here's a polished version of your request:
Could you kindly consider teaching in a single language? I don't intend to be impolite, but it would greatly benefit those who are not familiar with Hindi. When certain concepts or information are conveyed in Hindi, it might pose a challenge for a broader audience to comprehend. Thank you.
Nice explanation.
Without kiye problem ko proceed nhi kr sakte h kya
Thanku sir , plz keep it up
Regarding support reactions..for example span AB. We are taking the moments about A. It means the forces and moments which are passing through joint A will not consider..why you consider moment at A for calculating reaction B. Please clarify. It will be applicable fot all other spans.
Bro moment is considered at A but moment due to forces will be zero as perpendicular distance will be zero
gold flex kar raha hai chapar ganjo
btw nice lecture
Bm of curvature is 40
Sir support reaction krna jaruri h
Love you sir
Sir, You are ❣️
Sway frame ke liye?
Sir ...can u help me with a T frame ?
Sir I need ans for 4member in one joint means then what we will do in sway analysis steps,,,, how to write df value for 4 members
For computer analysis (etab) which type of frame selected for concreate frames
1.ordinary, 2.nonsway.
Best
Bhai thank you 👏😀
Where is Sway question ???
Please upload video on that
Thankyou sir
even if the values are close to zero you should not stop your iteration at the carry over step you should stop your iteration at distribution step
When will Sway analysis part came?
Reaction RB is wrong. It should be 6.07-40=33.94 kn. Moment of UDL answer should be 40knm instead of 80 knm
Kya baat hai
I think RB reaction is correct , of it's wrong then plz.. explain it...
bm diagram me kaunsa sign convention follow kiya ?
Solve complex frame also this one is simple frame but questions have too many attached frames
Externally Sum Fy toh 12.14 hai
How's that possible?? Ra 40 hi aaega na
Sway frame k sum jaldi kijiye sir
SIR I HAVE DONE PRACTICE PROBLEM IN STAAD PRO BUT I DIDN'T GET PROPERLY ALL ANSWERS
sir do some more question of frames....(sway)
Aaj meri 5th sem ki sessional exam hai bs half n hour hai paper ki
Wl² /4.?
Muller breslau pe numerical krwao bhai ..
Sry Bro Abhi possible nii hai banana..
you also calcullate wrong Value of k, it is 4EI/L for fixed end support.
correct it
Stifiness ka problem ka videos banao na sir by matrix ka
Haa 2 din Mai aajaiga
Net bending moment diagram wronge h AB & CD k liye 🔥🔥
☺💗☺🤗
Sir... How can we rotate papars in exam hall sir 😄😄😅
Can I know how you got 20.46 in tha final moments
Can anyone know please answer it
Add all things instead of {M and DF..
plus to sahi krlia kro B point and C ka total krna final ka galt h..
Bending moment diagram sign convention is wrong...
bhai yar bmd kuch galat lag raha h
i think BMD is wrong.....
Yes! It is.....
Ganesh sir udl ka BM wrong hai
Aur BMD sign galat hai Please ek baar repeat karo
BMD me galti hai aise nhi banega
Diagram smjh ni ata ye
It's wrong
Thank you sir
Sir pls upload video on sway frames on moment distribution method
Thank you sir
Thank u sir