@无敌忍者 Cantonese is one of the individual language under Chinese language family. If you love Cantonese, please study more linguistics of Cantonese and Chinese language family.
@无敌忍者 of course...Just want to point that out as being the sub culture in China. I just wish that people can learn Cantonese officially, just like the way to learn Mandarin ..There are lots of words only exist in Cantonese..You are not gonna find them in the typical Chinese dictionary.
Thanks for learning the language, in a sense, preserving our cultural heritage, while china is killing the language. Kids in Canton province don’t even use Cantonese in schools since 10 or 20 years ago. I doubt the kids consider mandarin their native, instead 😭
I'm a HKer and native Cantonese speaker. I feel so touched when I watched the whole clip as Cantonese is very difficult to learn. And also the song is very meaningful to us Hong Kong people especially in the meantime. Thank you so much for singing this song. You guys really did a great job. Thanks👏🏻👏🏻
我是韩国人，在广东生活已有20多年，我也会唱那首歌。非常经典的老歌，我们这个岁数的都很喜欢，特别佩服那位美国大妈能用那么精彩的声音打动我们心。 She must have been a professional singer in her younger age, if not, that's too amazing to have such a beautiful voice. May God bless all those talented people around the world!
I’m from Hong Kong and that’s one of the signature songs my family and I love it!!!! Thank you so much for promoting this song with your incredible voice !!!!!
This song means so much to Hongkongers! Appreciate how you're not afraid to sing in this 'one of the most difficult language'! And you pronounce Cantonese so well!
Thank you so much for you and your Mom, 雪蓮！ As a mandarin spoken Chinese living in Taiwan, I still can't speak Cantonese yet. But your Mom sings so terrific accent and full of passion, It's so heart touching and moving. I hear this song again, again, and again. Very great tribute obviously due to your Mom's professional skill of Broadway theater actress. Thank you so much.
It's the multicultural zoom video with them singing along and clapping together. Sadly we're so divided in race, color and creed right now. Seeing this is what we need. We need to be united more and divided less
Dear Nancy, Your singing in Cantonese is so impressive, and it touched our hearts Immediately, we totally understand your Cantonese without reading any captioned in Chinese. Appreciated your lovely and encouraged Song! You are amazing! Nancy! Wishing you both have a blessed Christmas and a Happy New Year!
I don't always comment on youtube, but I have to give this video a thumbs up. Your mom sings amazing with good Cantonese accent. She makes this song so beautiful!
No, you cannot as each year the quota is two and it has been taken up by Jillian and Nancy. Have to wait till next year. LMAO. Welcome to the club, of course. LOL.
She has an excellent voice, very clear enunciation and her courage to tackle one of the most popular Cantonese songs is just amazing. Even native Chinese singers dont usually dare to tackle Cantonese.
I grew up with Beyond's music. This is one of the best 《海闊天空》after Ka Kui, not mention it was sung by a group of people from another side of the world. We are not alone.
作為一個香港人，聽到好感動！尤其最後大合唱。謝謝你， Nancy!
是啊，你所說的正是我想講的！
me too
中国分
me 3
Me 4
老太太把我唱的眼泪汪汪 即是音乐的魅力 也是人的魅力 能把这首歌演绎好的 必定是一位可敬 善良的人 祝老人家健康快乐 长寿幸福
身為香港人，聽到雪蓮、雪蓮媽媽跟其他不同國籍人士唱出海闊天空，好感動！多謝你地🙏🏻
香港语文考试怎么考的？因为标准中文考试多音字和拼音输入法都是用标准汉语，粤语没法拼写这些字。
北方人虽然有方言，比如东北话，河南话或者山东话，但是这些话基本上跟普通话差距不大，而且都很容易听懂，广东话就完全变样了。
聽到喊
尤其喺今日嘅香港.... 那會怕有一天只你共我
黎明有日會到來😭
@@oneonly12345 你在说什么？
香港大抓捕啊，一天就抓了50多个。
只有真正地懂得什么叫做自由的人才能够真切地感受到那种深深的触动。这是我听了二十多年的歌了，再听还是心潮澎湃波澜起伏……
雪蓮媽媽你實在太棒了，歌聲大氣滂沱，作為一個外國人來唱廣東歌你實在了不起。
太強了，，雪蓮與媽媽真是滿滿正能量，充滿活力的母女，，看到雪蓮媽咪唱廣東歌，中國14億人，會講廣東話，唱廣東歌的人也不多呢，，還唱的很好，，太棒了
作為一個香港人，我為Beyond感到無比的驕傲！因為Beyond已經是華語歌壇公認的三座不能超越的大山，第一是鄧麗君，第二是Beyond的家駒，第三是小寶張雨生。當然我也希望大家不要忽視Beyond其他三位成員的努力！唯一感到有點遺憾的是當年家駒在生的時候，我還是十幾歲未有經濟能力去看他的演唱會。
張雨生粉+家駒粉簽到😢
媽媽唱得很好聽，大合唱很感動，謝謝你們!
外國人唱廣東歌。真是難於上青天。而且唱得這麽有感情。真是難以形容｡只有👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
人家唱百老匯歌劇的、再差也差不到那裡去
@@FBI-9527 真是，一听就知佢係 professional.
比我唱得好😂
唱🉐️很不錯👍👍
廣東話即使是華人都難以學會，世界上數一數二難學的語言那幾個，外國人唱到這樣超勁！
香港人是我們的兄弟，加油！
I’m native Cantonese speaker from HK, most HK people know this song and you made us all so proud 🙏🙏🙏
@无敌忍者 I agree. Beautiful language!
@无敌忍者 Cantonese is one of the individual language under Chinese language family. If you love Cantonese, please study more linguistics of Cantonese and Chinese language family.
@无敌忍者 btw. The UN already announced Cantonese as a language, not a dialect any more
@无敌忍者 of course...Just want to point that out as being the sub culture in China. I just wish that people can learn Cantonese officially, just like the way to learn Mandarin ..There are lots of words only exist in Cantonese..You are not gonna find them in the typical Chinese dictionary.
Thanks for learning the language, in a sense, preserving our cultural heritage, while china is killing the language. Kids in Canton province don’t even use Cantonese in schools since 10 or 20 years ago. I doubt the kids consider mandarin their native, instead 😭
唱得非常好，將首歌嘅氣與魄都演繹得淋漓盡致
雪莲 替我抱抱你妈妈 唱得太棒啦 10分 最后好感动 一起为香港加油
太佩服了！粵語歌居然唱的那麼好！
香港國歌! 感動😭 thank you Nancy🙏
這首歌曲，引證了什麼叫音樂無國界，謝謝你，很好聽。
3:57 ... exactly when I burst into tears... in a world so divided... this is exactly what we need. Thank you.
Thank you so much! ☺️
Same ! Especially this year and at this moments in states. As an international student I couldn’t thank more for finding this video.
Beyond 黃家駒
遺下嘅每一首歌
深深令來自五湖四海真正嘅人類……
刻骨銘心……
全世界加油！！！
早日同疫症絕交！！！
这是我最喜欢的广东歌之一，雪莲妈妈唱得我满眼泪水...
香港歌，謝謝
這首歌屬於香港，生於香港
@@劉鴨鴨 祝你们香港独立
懷念家駒
比花花發音標準
熱淚盈眶
太棒了…唱出了原唱的味道，发音准确，伟大的妈妈，太赞了！
I'm a HKer and native Cantonese speaker. I feel so touched when I watched the whole clip as Cantonese is very difficult to learn. And also the song is very meaningful to us Hong Kong people especially in the meantime. Thank you so much for singing this song. You guys really did a great job. Thanks👏🏻👏🏻
身為香港土生土長的人、聽你唱首歌真的很感動！丅ks！
多謝多謝多謝👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
無論香港定全世界都發生太多事，多謝你地既用心，用心唱既歌真係好好聽
我是韩国人，在广东生活已有20多年，我也会唱那首歌。非常经典的老歌，我们这个岁数的都很喜欢，特别佩服那位美国大妈能用那么精彩的声音打动我们心。
She must have been a professional singer in her younger age, if not, that's too amazing to have such a beautiful voice. May God bless all those talented people around the world!
學無止境，媽媽真是個好榜樣⋯⋯
雪蓮媽媽太棒了，要給你按讚讚讚，唱得太好聽了
Mom中文歌的咬字和气息真好，每一个咬字都可触及灵魂。
I’m from Hong Kong and that’s one of the signature songs my family and I love it!!!! Thank you so much for promoting this song with your incredible voice !!!!!
太经典，每首歌代表一个时代，您个歌声就是送我回去的🚄，太棒了
beyond在华人世界的地位无可撼动，超越了音乐，地域，世代。他们的音乐充满理想，感激。他们的灵魂向往自由，追逐梦想。他们的歌可以唱一百年，我的意思是如果那个时候粤语还在的话。
为什么会不在？你想保留粤语，那就不要管你的孩子在外面学多少种语言，在自己家里坚持一直和他说粤语，就不会有消失的可能性了
方言是家乡身份的一种标志，肯定要保留
@@ming12 不会普通话有毛用。。。
@@时间杀 小孩子在多种语言环境下一样会多种语言，就看大人如何提供了
对 beyond 绝对可以代表华人
但是不包括大陆地区的
他们没资格拥有自由
更不配拥有自己
Wow! She's a very wonderful singer.
This song means so much to Hongkongers! Appreciate how you're not afraid to sing in this 'one of the most difficult language'! And you pronounce Cantonese so well!
i cannot speak even a word... only this awesome..(i'm a big fan of beyond... from korea)
你妈妈又再一次惊艳全场 想听她唱千千阕歌∼
And with her language talent, can mix it with the Japanese original too. 🙂
对！！！
那就再加上 人生何处不相逢，飘雪，红茶馆～
千千阕歌系至爱👍
@@xyz86457 總有夜機
Respect from Toronto
好好聼! 好感動! 作為香港人,聼到呢首歌特別有感覺...自由&理想✌
多謝晒雪蓮&媽媽&朋友! 大合唱好正呀! 媽媽啲廣東話越來越正 👍勁呀！
下次可唔可以唱「獅子山下」呀? 唔該晒~
Omg, this is one my favorite songs to sing in karaoke! Your mom choose a good song!
每次听这首家驹歌的这首歌都是满眼含泪，妈妈👩唱的好好👍
Omg... I missed listening to this song.. u go Mom.. ✌️🥰🤩😎💪
很感动的一首歌 每次听就很感触 谢谢雪莲还有雪莲妈妈 爱你们
Wow...your mum is amazing. Hope she is in good health and please do a couple more songs.
一首很代表香港人精神的廣東神曲
Wow! What an amazing singer!
Omg I love this! My dad used to play this in the car when I was small, now that he passed away this song reminds me of him
unbelievable!!! Just amazed by your voice and performance!!!
聽了真的很感動，爱莲妈唱的很好👍，爱你們，加油。
Bravo! 支持您*****
您的廣東話好過好多老香港，勁！犀利，無得頂*****好過Beyond
香港人的歌！高興見到繁體字幕！
thank you very much love from Hong Kong
4th July 2021
Wow. I feel old now. I remember when Beyond did this song and I was playing it over and over in my car.
很好聽，身在台灣的我，隨不是我年代的歌，但我很喜歡，今天聽到雪蓮媽媽唱，也也不同感受，謝謝你
Amazing mom! How could you learn Cantonese so well! 我们需要海阔天空，关了这么久，这个世界太需要海阔天空！
She still does not know Cantonese. She is an actress
@@TulekBehar She spoke a little bit in one of the videos. One step at a time. That's how we learn.
I am Chinese, but her Cantonese better than me.
Good job !!
对呀。关了七十一年啦。十四亿奴隸何时解放。令人窒息。
这首歌不知不觉让人流泪!让我想起一位故人年轻时喜欢唱的歌。
Thank you so much for you and your Mom, 雪蓮！ As a mandarin spoken Chinese living in Taiwan, I still can't speak Cantonese yet. But your Mom sings so terrific accent and full of passion, It's so heart touching and moving. I hear this song again, again, and again. Very great tribute obviously due to your Mom's professional skill of Broadway theater actress. Thank you so much.
唱得太好了，感动，Your Mom is a brilliant singer.
太好了👏👏！數月前我也曾經，點唱了這首歌，你們真的會唱粵語歌曲，對你們來説非常困難，你們居然也克服了，了不起 ! 👍👍 好感動 ！好感謝🙏🙏！
尾段大合唱，帶來了驚喜 ！但我竟然眼角有淚！是被感動了，謝謝雪蓮、及你的媽媽 ！謝謝你們 ！🙏🙏🙏🙏
Wow, your mom is a great singer and looks great for her age.
掌聲掌聲掌聲掌聲，唱得真好。
老姐姐中气十足，人也美 ！赞了
Amazing. At the end so many non native Cantonese people can sing together. As a Cantonese, we are so proud of you
雪莲妈妈好聲音，好厲害，赞👍
I was touched by this badly. This is something more than just a song. So heartwarming. Please keep at doing it!
It's the multicultural zoom video with them singing along and clapping together. Sadly we're so divided in race, color and creed right now. Seeing this is what we need. We need to be united more and divided less
大合唱一刻，眼淚已流出！
希望雪蓮知道這首在香港人的心中意義。
🤩👍👍👍✌，特別要給個👍你媽媽，唱得太好！對一個不是講廣東話的西方人來說唱這首歌不容易，她還可以唱到有這個水平，amazing！
非常非常感谢分享，非常棒，不可思议🌹🌹👍👍
Beyond 是香港人的驕傲！
我在印尼也聽beyond 的歌！
那你666啊
中国人的骄傲
這句話說的真是太棒了我認同
我为什么听后会不自觉的流泪！是否有同样的人。
全球華人的驕傲。Selamat menikmati lagu ini.Tuhan Yesus memberkati🙏
好勁 ❗👍👍👍
really 🙏 appreciate to sing Cantonese song 海關天空。
'香港人' 聽到會好感動 ❗
Dear Nancy,
Your singing in Cantonese is so impressive, and it touched our hearts
Immediately, we totally understand your Cantonese without reading any captioned in Chinese.
Appreciated your lovely and encouraged
Song!
You are amazing! Nancy!
Wishing you both have a blessed Christmas and a Happy New Year!
omg .........she is good and sing HK legendary song .........must give a LIKE and THUMB UP
I believe you can rest in peace now, 黃家駒… That was an impressive tribute! 👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Her Courage. Thumbs up!
最後的大合唱！太感動了！
Wonderful 雪蓮mama....make me excited
I come from HK, when I listening this song, my tears keep streaming
as a hongkonger，Proud of you， thank u！
This song represents the heart of Hongkongers! Thank you Nancy for singing this song
thanks from HK , SO TOUCHING
Thanks for singing this classic Cantonese song beautifully.We need this going through the pandemic.
那是我再也回不到的过去。。。听到真是想哭。谢谢演唱者
I don't always comment on youtube, but I have to give this video a thumbs up. Your mom sings amazing with good Cantonese accent. She makes this song so beautiful!
Amazing !! Lived in China for 12 years and this was my go to for karaoke
結尾合唱是神來之筆，超有意思。讚!
S
This lady is singing with passion and original spirit, 2 thumbs up
I understand NOT a single word, but MAN!!! That was beautiful. Totally wanna learn Cantonese now!
The subtitles, top left
@@_Wai_Wai_ I was listening to this beautiful lady sing this beautiful song
No, you cannot as each year the quota is two and it has been taken up by Jillian and Nancy. Have to wait till next year. LMAO. Welcome to the club, of course. LOL.
Not much different from the new age pop and rap songs in America then. LOL
Unbelievable performance!
令正直的中国人都会流泪的励志歌，谢谢雪莲妈妈，你们选的曲目都非常有代表性和发自内心的热爱，超级棒👍👍🌷🌷🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
一首港毒反歌令你流泪？名字报出来我去举报你
@鹰酱国大峡谷州AZ自干五-种花家兔酱传媒 立什么志？一直在渲染虚假自由这是西方的骗局，就是一首反歌，该禁
@@95300783 你仆街啦，一首歌都咁多聯想到
黃家駒率Beyond樂隊90年代北京巡演，可謂當時最早到大陸的搖滾樂隊，後譜寫“長城”, 家駒多次稱自己以身為中國人自豪…
那些港毒異類根本不了解家駒… 那個英租年代的本土港星每個人心裡都揣著一顆中國心… 知道自己是什麼人…
@Ali Chu 絕對正確的說法
She has an excellent voice, very clear enunciation and her courage to tackle one of the most popular Cantonese songs is just amazing. Even native Chinese singers dont usually dare to tackle Cantonese.
Oh the last part made my eyes teary. So beautiful to hear a Cantonese song. So much respect to you learning it and singing it so beautifully.
Chorus guys are great as well.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼❤️👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼媽咪不只是演唱家也是語言天才🎵🎵🎊👸🏻👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
多謝你地！將家駒呢一首歌傳遍全世界！係屬於香港人嘅歌！
I can't stop my tears when I heard her singing. Oh, so moving! Great singing, encore!
大妈中气十足，赞赞赞
I grew up with Beyond's music. This is one of the best 《海闊天空》after Ka Kui, not mention it was sung by a group of people from another side of the world. We are not alone.
来自陕西西安，为你点赞！
So amazing! As a native cantonese speaker, I would say you guys have done a very good job. i love this.
雪莲好喜欢你同妈咪唱歌的视频，你们热爱生活气息感染了我。祝你们圣诞节快乐🤶🎄🎁
So touched by your mom's performance, this is one of the forever classic songs as most of Cantonese speakers could sing. Bravo ♡♡ 🤟
太棒了 为你母亲点赞