I did not think of top quark even though I know what they are. In case they ever come up again, the other quarks are bottom, up, down, strange, and charm. You are definitely not stupid Simon, thousands of people come to watch this channel because of how smart you are. I always love watching the videos, especially when you’re nice.
Agreed. I figured out Top Quark once he got TOP?U?R? but, I had to go check the google to learn that Quark is a type of cheese. No feeling stupid, Simon. That was brutal if you're not into sub-atomic physics AND obscure cheeses.
@@steveamsp When Murray Gell-Mann named the particles, there were thought to be only three types - up, down and strange. It brought to his mind the line "Three quarks for Muster Mark!" in James Joyce's "Finnegans Wake". Joyce's wordplay turns "three cheers" into "three cheese" and then translates "cheese" to "quark". So the subatomic particles were actually named after the cheese.
@@stephencolwill148 I remember a photo in New Scientist decades ago that showed some physicists chatting at a conference. The caption gave their names and added something like "Dr. X has a delightful speciality: she is an expert on charm."
I thought the big end vs. little end of the egg conflict was the point of contention between the Lilliputians and the Brobdingnagians. It has been decades since I read Gulliver's Travels and I could be misremembering.
Please don't feel stupid Simon! Quarks aside, some amazing knowledge and fantastic solving today. Edda, Amice, Titus Groan, Adenoidal and Big End all very tricky from where I'm sitting and solved brilliantly 😊 Thanks as always for these Friday videos!
Honestly this was brilliant and although it always a joy seeing you get excited when solving puzzles it is refreshing seeing you show you came close to solving. It takes someone truly great and humble to upload this despite the defeat.
Top quark came to mind, though I hadn't heard of quark cheese. I couldn't possibly fast-forward though - it's just so compelling to follow Simon's thought processes as he battles against the clue that stubbornly refuses to yield. I also love Simon's ironic catchphrase - 'I don't have a clue'. Hugely entertaining as ever.
I'm from a country where quark is popular, and would never have thought anyone would consider it a cheese - it's treated more like yoghurt here. There's even a German quark yoghurt blend for sale that I used to eat before I dropped dairy. I also didn't know there was an English name for it, so was doubly unable to guess that. A funny coincident is that acording to Wikipedia Tacitus described quark (or something akin to it) in his work.
In "Gulliver's Travels" the major conflict among the Lilliputians was between the Big-Endians and the Little-Endians, referring to which end they chose to crack their breakfast egg. (A conflict deliberately encouraged by the neighbouring kingdom of Blefuscu, which took in many Big-Endian refugees.) In computing, "big-endian" and "little-endian" refer to the order of bytes within a machine word in memory, obviously in homage to Swift. (edit: the unspellable race of horses were the Houyhnhnms, while I've got my copy of the book to hand)
At the political level, Swift is referring to England and France, and the exile of the Stuart pretenders and their followers in the French court. However, as an ordained priest in the Church of England, he did not think the differences between Protestants and Catholics were trivial, but as a satirist he is willing to cut back against himself. There is a lot of this in Tale of a Tub.
As soon as Simon placed the Q in that cheese one, I got it and started shouting at the screen ahaha. And I got the physics ["tiny"] reference in that one, too. What a sneaky, clever clue!!!
Great video. These have basically gotten me addicted to cryptic crosswords to the point I think I'll have to subscribe to The Times to access theirs as I am currently limited to The Guardian's free ones. I did get 'STAIR' almost immediately, likely because of my newbie and unattuned brain just thinking of the litteral alternative to taking the lift.
It's worth knowing that you can subscribe to just the puzzle section of The Times for £5 a month (or, presumably, your regional equivalent) which is about a fifth of the cost of a full subscription.
If you just want the puzzles, the £5 a month limited-access deal does give you full access to the puzzles and the Crossword Club. You can start with the Times Quick cryptic, which is a little more challenging than the one in the Guardian. When you've finished, or given up, you can read the Times for the Times Quickie blog and see all the parsings and comments from other solvers.
I think this was a valiant effort Simon. It was a beast. You have helped enormously with my being able to solve these I can now often finish the QC and the early week puzzles on my own after watching these for several months. Also congrats on being number 3 on the leaderboard for today’s concise, that was a good time. Thanks.
Appreciated the speed run at the end, like last week! Nice work. I saw top quark in the comments and, I had a vague idea what that was, have no idea how you’d get that from the clue. Cheese? Amazing work with a tough puzzle.
You didn't let anyone down Simon, you are very far from stupid and are much too hard on yourself. som of us can't solve three quarters of the clues you do. Please, please, please stop being so hard on yourself my lovely, it is totally misplaced. you are a wonderful, intelligent man and we love you for it x All of these videos are good as they help me with solving cryptic crosswords with tips and techniques for sorting throught the clues. please keep them coming. have a great weekend x
In 8 down the definition of gist is just point, not 'sticking point'. You have to read the clue as 'if you stick point and right in a word for behind you get a word for doctor'
I eventually got quark but not familiar with top quark and very notably I only got that because you’d solved the rest of the grid which I wouldn’t have managed given a month of Sundays! The Times crossword is too hard for me but I do learn loads from watching these videos. Thanks
TH-cam must REALLY hate crosswords, today I got a notification for Wordle In A Minute but not for this video, despite having your channel set to notify me of ALL uploads. I was literally wondering if you'd decided to skip it this week. Haven't watched the solve yet but I'm about to!
Thank you for the wonderful crossword masterclass. I remember my Grandpa trying to teach me about crossword clues and how to break them down. Seeing you do this has really helped me understand what he meant. A wide range of knowledge was necessary for todays puzzle and that you were able to have so much at your fingertips is very impressive. Please don’t dwell on the ‘one that got away’ although I understand completely how frustrated you feel when you can’t find that one word.
18:18 I think something that is often overlooked when you debate the inclusion of an article in the clues surface reading is whether the clue remains sufficiently cryptic without it. "At home opening wine pipe" gives too much away on the surface even without checking letters.
Watching you blitz through that simple puzzle at the end was something special. You really hold yourself back in these solves sometimes, watching you go with little restriction is just phenomenal.
As TH-camr and science educator Hank Green once sang: “Up, down, strange, charm, top, bottom: if you don’t know what a quark is, it don’t matter, you still got ‘em!” Thank you for a very entertaining video! It’s oddly reassuring to see that not everything is automatic and even the greats still struggle at times.
As soon as Simon put that Q in, I got it. Brutal puzzle overall. I don't think you can be sad about not knowing a cheese when you do know obscure medieval Irish texts!
Oddly I got the last three clues on first reading, and then had to wait, watching as Simon worried over them! Slow signs of improvement from me! Bravo Simon!
Thanks Simon! I could never have got anywhere in the main puzzle and, for reference, you managed the QC in a third of my time too. These videos are a reliably lovely way to finish the working week and I look forward to them immensely.
Hour and 10 minute crossword!?!? What a treat to ring in this Friday morning and have Simon dazzle us with his solving. Absolutely adore and cherish everything about these!!
I once read about Quark as a substitute ingredient in a Delia Smith cookery book, so I was familiar with that type of "cheese". I knew that "quarks" were particles, but I did not know that some of them were "top" quarks. That I got from the crossing letters. I managed to fully solve this one, but I had to use the dictionary more than once. I think you did a phenomenal job in this video, well done and thank you for uploading it for our enjoyment (and education!).
I've heard of top quarks and quark cheese and I still didn't get it, you didn't let anyone down. Yet another extremely enjoyable video. Looking forward to the next one:)
Sometimes when I watch these I will on occasion make a realisation about a solution just before Simon, rarely without his assistance. I did it once in this puzzle and it was as the Q went in. Every time Simon said quart, I prayed something would click. I was aghast that Simon had never heard of a quark, until I realised that I have absolutely no idea why I have any such knowledge of sub-atomical particles as a graphic designer. Excellent solving, as always!
(someone has probably already mentioned this, but) it's worth noting that for your concern with 27 across - Clarinets are divided into types based on the note they're pitched around (plus size, among other things). If I remember correctly, the two most common types of clarinet are A and Bb, so "a pipe" could perhaps be taken as "A Clarinet." It gives at least some justification for the "a" in the clue
I know that Sudoku is what gets the views, but I'm here for the crosswords. This was monstrous. I'm no Oxbridge scholar, but have a reasonable working knowledge. Brutal is the only word that describes this crossword. If anything the Snitch underplayed things. What I enjoy most is knowing I'm too stupid to solve this puzzle, *but* I won't be left bereft of scratching the itch in my brain because Simon is positively amazing at these. I'm more than happy to await the answer as I grew up in an era where if you didn't know, it went unanswered to your tomb.
Im far from the first to say this, but I imagine most people know nothing about quarks of any kind (other than the barkeep on Deep Space Nine), and I'm reasonably confident that the venn diagram of people who knew that quarks are subatomic particles and those who knew it's a type of cheese is two circles. Also it's Edda to rhyme with header
“a pipe” rather than “pipe” in 27A: I personally have no problem with this. In everyday English, we sometimes use a noun with an article and sometimes not. If you showed people a clarinet and asked them what it was, I feel sure that the majority who gave you a correct answer would say “a clarinet” rather than “clarinet”. I don’t know where exactly the idea that “any word that isn’t vital to the logic must be erased” came from, but I doubt very much that it was Ximenes. It’s not easily to tell, as his book doesn’t present all of his principles in a clearly organised way. Looking at later authorities …. In his A-Z of crosswords, Azed says, under “Don’t waffle”, that there should be “no superfluous verbiage”, but doesn’t provide any examples of superfluous verbiage. In chapter 19 of the latest version of Don Manley’s book, he mentions a clue (labelled [7.3]) which uses “a sailor” to indicate AB, and says that although the A is strictly redundant, “by a long-standing tradition we may allow ourselves to introduce an article when defining a noun”.
Quark is a pretty common food in Germany, however I'd consider it more akin to yogurt than cheese, which is why I don't think I'd have guessed it. I'd also heard of quarks as subatomic particles, but I wouldn't have guessed it from that either, because I just can't wrap my head around these English cryptic crosswords, even though I haven't missed a single one of these videos.
Remember Fawlty Towers where Basil thinks "burro" (Italian for butter) is also Spanish for butter and Manuel doesn't understand and goes "i ahh i ahh". There's too much butter on those trays... un dos tres...
A joke about big ends (in car engines...oooh, you are awful!). Man goes to a motor dealer, looking for a car. Dealer says: "Sorry, sunshine, go nuffing left...except for this Morris which is pulled along by a giant Hen!" Man is sceptical, but the dealer assures him that it goes like the clappers. So, he takes it out for a run. "Get going", he urges the giant bird. And it miraculously starts off at a steady 20mph. "Faster" he urges, and it's up to 40mph. Astonished, Man yells " as fast as you can, Hen!", and the towed vehicle reaches 65mph, before tragedy strikes, and the Hen stumbles and lies down, motionless. Devastated, he flags down a passing AA vehicle and relays his tale. Man asks "what is the problem with the car?". Mechanic replies " Sorry, Guv, your Big 'En's gone".
Amazing how much easier the Lilliputian clue was for me because i just read it literally. (And knew of the engine part.) (This generally works badly for the rest of the crossword, but it worked here!)
18:17 I asked a similar question last week and the consensus seemed to be that if the 'a' is part of the definition, and not part of the wordplay, then it's not a problem. Still seems dodgy to me but I'm no cryptic crossword expert.
I saw "vegan quark cheese" in one of the menu options for a dinner I went to. I didn't try it, and neither did anybody else on my table, so I still don't know what it is .....
For that last one, I first thought of "quart" (as in, an abbreviation for quarter) and then "top quark" suddenly popped in my head, knowing that it's one of the fundamentals of quantum physics, and a quark is a type of curd cheese. Still getting the rest correct proves that you're definitely not stupid, just that you don't know absolutely everything. And there's nothing wrong with that. Just see it as a learning opportunity.
When you put in burro you might have been thinking of burrata, which is a type of cheese a bit like mozzarella. It was still an impressive attempt with everything else you managed to work out, so don't feel too bad!
If you watch the video on a touchscreen device, you can zoom in on any part of the video while watching in full screen mode. If you're watching on a non-touchscreen device, take a screenshot and zoom in on the image to be able to read the clues.
Don't feel bad Simon. The only ones I thought of during the watch were stair and top quark, and both needed at least three letters from you, and maaaybe a Q. The rest of them _I_ stared at. "Amice. Wait, that's a word?"
Biblically speaking, you have St Paul's epistle to St. Titus -- so Titus Groan is well justified. I adored Big End, and wished Simon realised what a superb clue it was. But - a lovely end to a challenging Friday. Thank you
What surprised me a little is that Simon had never heard of the book, which was still fairly popular in the UK when he was younger. American solvers like me wouldn't know it, but I did construct it from the cryptic.
I think 4 down is much bigger superfluous a offender than 27 across Simon focused on, especially given it's right after the word "after" which is used in clue for positioning
Interestingly, we seem to solve in opposite ways - you get the answer first, and then parse it, while I build the answer from the cryptic and then see if it might match the literal. I had to build get along, Titus Groan perpetrate, clarinet, Jeremiah, tousle, and registrar from the cryptics. Unfortunately, I failed to build amice correctly, but my wrong answer does match the cryptic - it's just not a word.
BURRO means "butter" in italian. It's not a cheese, of course, but at least is a milk-related product. Maybe Simon had this in mind when he guessed "top burro".
quark is a very common thing used in germany. there isn't a single person who doesn't know what quark is. BUT I did not know it was considered cheese?! it's the german equivalent to american cream cheese, so I guess it makes sense :/
I believe Quark comes from James Joyce, used to describe the sound of a seagull in Finnegans Wake. Later adopted by physicists to mean tiny particles. What a quark is or how it works... No idea.
I feel less bad for struggling really badly with this puzzle. some really obscure ones which I had never heard of and it seems even Simon didn't know. Although I have heard of top quarks (up down strange charm top bottom) I have never heard of quark cheese.
Quick Poll: was 15-across tough for you because of the science term, or because of the cheese? I didn't know it was a type of cheese. (Spoiler below) The answer is TOP QUARK - a quark is a tiny subatomic particle, and also apparently a type of soft cheese.
Same for me (almost)! Plus, when I look outside my window, I can almost see the facility, where 15 came to its glued life... Wow, TOP was found in 1995? That was 16 years later...
Thoroughfare and through street don't quite mean the same thing, a point against the setter there. A through street is explicitly a traffic term, giving right of way in the direction of the through street on all junctions.
I spent the entire video thinking that excellent cheese was a single descriptor, but of course it wasn't excellent = top, cheese = quark (a particularly tasteless vegan abomination, not really deserving of the epithet 'cheese' :D ), still I new about top (and bottom) quarks when they were known as 'truth' and 'beauty' and I was nowhere near getting it. I did get 'big end' though - the Lilliputians were fighting a war over whether it was better to crack an egg from the big or the little end. (I was once taught English Literature by a descendant of Swift so the story sticks in my mind.)
Commenting for the algorithm and to say that I love these puzzles and you, sir, are about as far from stupid as you can get. Imagine thinking yourself stupid, merely for not knowing about a (frankly overrated) cheese. You did great!
I did not think of top quark even though I know what they are. In case they ever come up again, the other quarks are bottom, up, down, strange, and charm. You are definitely not stupid Simon, thousands of people come to watch this channel because of how smart you are. I always love watching the videos, especially when you’re nice.
Agreed. I figured out Top Quark once he got TOP?U?R? but, I had to go check the google to learn that Quark is a type of cheese.
No feeling stupid, Simon. That was brutal if you're not into sub-atomic physics AND obscure cheeses.
@@steveamsp When Murray Gell-Mann named the particles, there were thought to be only three types - up, down and strange. It brought to his mind the line "Three quarks for Muster Mark!" in James Joyce's "Finnegans Wake". Joyce's wordplay turns "three cheers" into "three cheese" and then translates "cheese" to "quark". So the subatomic particles were actually named after the cheese.
@@David_K_Booth - Very few people know both physics and Finnegan's Wake. Those who do are probably pretty good at cryptics.
Top and Bottom quarks are sometimes, rather more poetically, referred to as Truth and Beauty.
@@stephencolwill148 I remember a photo in New Scientist decades ago that showed some physicists chatting at a conference. The caption gave their names and added something like "Dr. X has a delightful speciality: she is an expert on charm."
Lilliputians were either Big Endians or Little Endians, depending on which end they cracked their boiled eggs. It was a satire on religion in Britain.
I forgot about that! Makes me want to go watch the Ted Danson mini series. Was one of my favorites as a kid.
Some say the use of the terms bigendian and littleendian in computer architectures were adopted from that.
If Simon had noticed Big-endian in his crossword window just below big end, he would have found the answer
@@mikechappell5849 The most frustrating part of these videos is when you can see what he's looking for in the dictionary and he skips past it!
I thought the big end vs. little end of the egg conflict was the point of contention between the Lilliputians and the Brobdingnagians. It has been decades since I read Gulliver's Travels and I could be misremembering.
Please don't feel stupid Simon!
Quarks aside, some amazing knowledge and fantastic solving today.
Edda, Amice, Titus Groan, Adenoidal and Big End all very tricky from where I'm sitting and solved brilliantly 😊
Thanks as always for these Friday videos!
I ❤ these! Don’t be hard on yourself, Simon - you got 99%of the obscurity! And brightened the day of thousands of us!!!
These constantly brighten my Fridays..as do you knowing how much you love these also!! 🩵💜
@@davidrattner9 🧡💛❤️🩵
Honestly this was brilliant and although it always a joy seeing you get excited when solving puzzles it is refreshing seeing you show you came close to solving. It takes someone truly great and humble to upload this despite the defeat.
Gist just means point, which you are then "sticking" into rear, along with the r for right
Top quark came to mind, though I hadn't heard of quark cheese. I couldn't possibly fast-forward though - it's just so compelling to follow Simon's thought processes as he battles against the clue that stubbornly refuses to yield. I also love Simon's ironic catchphrase - 'I don't have a clue'. Hugely entertaining as ever.
Funnily enough quarks are actually named after quark cheese
@@JyotiDas-72 I thought the name comes from Finnegan's Wake, where there's a line "three quarks for muster mark." Nothing to do with the cheese, IIRC.
I'm from a country where quark is popular, and would never have thought anyone would consider it a cheese - it's treated more like yoghurt here. There's even a German quark yoghurt blend for sale that I used to eat before I dropped dairy. I also didn't know there was an English name for it, so was doubly unable to guess that. A funny coincident is that acording to Wikipedia Tacitus described quark (or something akin to it) in his work.
In "Gulliver's Travels" the major conflict among the Lilliputians was between the Big-Endians and the Little-Endians, referring to which end they chose to crack their breakfast egg. (A conflict deliberately encouraged by the neighbouring kingdom of Blefuscu, which took in many Big-Endian refugees.) In computing, "big-endian" and "little-endian" refer to the order of bytes within a machine word in memory, obviously in homage to Swift.
(edit: the unspellable race of horses were the Houyhnhnms, while I've got my copy of the book to hand)
At the political level, Swift is referring to England and France, and the exile of the Stuart pretenders and their followers in the French court. However, as an ordained priest in the Church of England, he did not think the differences between Protestants and Catholics were trivial, but as a satirist he is willing to cut back against himself. There is a lot of this in Tale of a Tub.
I LOVE these cryptic videos. And Simon, you are a GENIUS!
As soon as Simon placed the Q in that cheese one, I got it and started shouting at the screen ahaha. And I got the physics ["tiny"] reference in that one, too.
What a sneaky, clever clue!!!
I still think of them as truth and beauty so I was not going to get it without having to remember the "correct" name
Great video. These have basically gotten me addicted to cryptic crosswords to the point I think I'll have to subscribe to The Times to access theirs as I am currently limited to The Guardian's free ones. I did get 'STAIR' almost immediately, likely because of my newbie and unattuned brain just thinking of the litteral alternative to taking the lift.
Likewise, was the only one I beat Simon to!
It's worth knowing that you can subscribe to just the puzzle section of The Times for £5 a month (or, presumably, your regional equivalent) which is about a fifth of the cost of a full subscription.
If you just want the puzzles, the £5 a month limited-access deal does give you full access to the puzzles and the Crossword Club. You can start with the Times Quick cryptic, which is a little more challenging than the one in the Guardian. When you've finished, or given up, you can read the Times for the Times Quickie blog and see all the parsings and comments from other solvers.
When you said quart I was rooting for you to get quark!!
I think this was a valiant effort Simon. It was a beast. You have helped enormously with my being able to solve these I can now often finish the QC and the early week puzzles on my own after watching these for several months. Also congrats on being number 3 on the leaderboard for today’s concise, that was a good time. Thanks.
Don't beat yourself up - you did brilliantly! Very informative as ever, thank you!
Appreciated the speed run at the end, like last week! Nice work. I saw top quark in the comments and, I had a vague idea what that was, have no idea how you’d get that from the clue. Cheese? Amazing work with a tough puzzle.
I don't know if you got back to this later in the video, but Titus is one of the smaller and less quoted Epistles in the Bible
You didn't let anyone down Simon, you are very far from stupid and are much too hard on yourself. som of us can't solve three quarters of the clues you do. Please, please, please stop being so hard on yourself my lovely, it is totally misplaced. you are a wonderful, intelligent man and we love you for it x All of these videos are good as they help me with solving cryptic crosswords with tips and techniques for sorting throught the clues. please keep them coming. have a great weekend x
Truly a wonderful video. Please be kind to yourself, your skill is exemplarily
Love these videos. ❤ except when you are so hard on yourself!! This was extremely impressive. So many words I’d never even heard of. 🎉
In 8 down the definition of gist is just point, not 'sticking point'. You have to read the clue as 'if you stick point and right in a word for behind you get a word for doctor'
I eventually got quark but not familiar with top quark and very notably I only got that because you’d solved the rest of the grid which I wouldn’t have managed given a month of Sundays! The Times crossword is too hard for me but I do learn loads from watching these videos. Thanks
TH-cam must REALLY hate crosswords, today I got a notification for Wordle In A Minute but not for this video, despite having your channel set to notify me of ALL uploads. I was literally wondering if you'd decided to skip it this week. Haven't watched the solve yet but I'm about to!
Liking doing the quick too. Thanks Simon. I could get only a handful on the main puzzle - now I know why!
Thank you for the wonderful crossword masterclass. I remember my Grandpa trying to teach me about crossword clues and how to break them down. Seeing you do this has really helped me understand what he meant. A wide range of knowledge was necessary for todays puzzle and that you were able to have so much at your fingertips is very impressive. Please don’t dwell on the ‘one that got away’ although I understand completely how frustrated you feel when you can’t find that one word.
18:18 I think something that is often overlooked when you debate the inclusion of an article in the clues surface reading is whether the clue remains sufficiently cryptic without it. "At home opening wine pipe" gives too much away on the surface even without checking letters.
Watching you blitz through that simple puzzle at the end was something special. You really hold yourself back in these solves sometimes, watching you go with little restriction is just phenomenal.
Wow that was a tough puzzle. Your quick solve was mesmerising
As TH-camr and science educator Hank Green once sang: “Up, down, strange, charm, top, bottom: if you don’t know what a quark is, it don’t matter, you still got ‘em!”
Thank you for a very entertaining video! It’s oddly reassuring to see that not everything is automatic and even the greats still struggle at times.
Excellent. Learning a lot. Please keep going!!
I love the Crossword content! You didn't even look to see your Time or Place on the Quick Cryptic after you were done.
As soon as Simon put that Q in, I got it. Brutal puzzle overall. I don't think you can be sad about not knowing a cheese when you do know obscure medieval Irish texts!
Oddly I got the last three clues on first reading, and then had to wait, watching as Simon worried over them! Slow signs of improvement from me! Bravo Simon!
I got CENOTAPH! The anagram indicator was also part of the cryptic def!
The very high snitch-rating certainly soothed my blushes!
This was a brutal puzzle for sure. I had no clue on top quark, even if I was aware of the term in physics!
I’ve seen lots of signs warning drivers of “not a thru street” around here in America. Well done Simon!
Thanks Simon! I could never have got anywhere in the main puzzle and, for reference, you managed the QC in a third of my time too. These videos are a reliably lovely way to finish the working week and I look forward to them immensely.
Hour and 10 minute crossword!?!? What a treat to ring in this Friday morning and have Simon dazzle us with his solving. Absolutely adore and cherish everything about these!!
I once read about Quark as a substitute ingredient in a Delia Smith cookery book, so I was familiar with that type of "cheese". I knew that "quarks" were particles, but I did not know that some of them were "top" quarks. That I got from the crossing letters. I managed to fully solve this one, but I had to use the dictionary more than once. I think you did a phenomenal job in this video, well done and thank you for uploading it for our enjoyment (and education!).
I've heard of top quarks and quark cheese and I still didn't get it, you didn't let anyone down. Yet another extremely enjoyable video. Looking forward to the next one:)
Sometimes when I watch these I will on occasion make a realisation about a solution just before Simon, rarely without his assistance. I did it once in this puzzle and it was as the Q went in. Every time Simon said quart, I prayed something would click. I was aghast that Simon had never heard of a quark, until I realised that I have absolutely no idea why I have any such knowledge of sub-atomical particles as a graphic designer. Excellent solving, as always!
Genius!! Thank you!
(someone has probably already mentioned this, but) it's worth noting that for your concern with 27 across - Clarinets are divided into types based on the note they're pitched around (plus size, among other things). If I remember correctly, the two most common types of clarinet are A and Bb, so "a pipe" could perhaps be taken as "A Clarinet." It gives at least some justification for the "a" in the clue
My favourite video of the week
I know that Sudoku is what gets the views, but I'm here for the crosswords. This was monstrous. I'm no Oxbridge scholar, but have a reasonable working knowledge. Brutal is the only word that describes this crossword. If anything the Snitch underplayed things. What I enjoy most is knowing I'm too stupid to solve this puzzle, *but* I won't be left bereft of scratching the itch in my brain because Simon is positively amazing at these. I'm more than happy to await the answer as I grew up in an era where if you didn't know, it went unanswered to your tomb.
Im far from the first to say this, but I imagine most people know nothing about quarks of any kind (other than the barkeep on Deep Space Nine), and I'm reasonably confident that the venn diagram of people who knew that quarks are subatomic particles and those who knew it's a type of cheese is two circles.
Also it's Edda to rhyme with header
“a pipe” rather than “pipe” in 27A: I personally have no problem with this. In everyday English, we sometimes use a noun with an article and sometimes not. If you showed people a clarinet and asked them what it was, I feel sure that the majority who gave you a correct answer would say “a clarinet” rather than “clarinet”. I don’t know where exactly the idea that “any word that isn’t vital to the logic must be erased” came from, but I doubt very much that it was Ximenes. It’s not easily to tell, as his book doesn’t present all of his principles in a clearly organised way. Looking at later authorities …. In his A-Z of crosswords, Azed says, under “Don’t waffle”, that there should be “no superfluous verbiage”, but doesn’t provide any examples of superfluous verbiage. In chapter 19 of the latest version of Don Manley’s book, he mentions a clue (labelled [7.3]) which uses “a sailor” to indicate AB, and says that although the A is strictly redundant, “by a long-standing tradition we may allow ourselves to introduce an article when defining a noun”.
Don't feel stupid. For the last answer it was an advantage to have German as a first language. Thank you for the nice start into the weekend!
Quark is a pretty common food in Germany, however I'd consider it more akin to yogurt than cheese, which is why I don't think I'd have guessed it. I'd also heard of quarks as subatomic particles, but I wouldn't have guessed it from that either, because I just can't wrap my head around these English cryptic crosswords, even though I haven't missed a single one of these videos.
Really enjoyed this and was willing you to get it but your genuine humility is so refreshing compared to u tube celebrities thankyou Simon
Remember Fawlty Towers where Basil thinks "burro" (Italian for butter) is also Spanish for butter and Manuel doesn't understand and goes "i ahh i ahh". There's too much butter on those trays... un dos tres...
Delighted to say I got top quark, and knew both the physics and the dairy meanings. But there were many others I didn't get.
Great video, thoroughly enjoyable
Love these!! :)
A joke about big ends (in car engines...oooh, you are awful!). Man goes to a motor dealer, looking for a car. Dealer says: "Sorry, sunshine, go nuffing left...except for this Morris which is pulled along by a giant Hen!" Man is sceptical, but the dealer assures him that it goes like the clappers. So, he takes it out for a run. "Get going", he urges the giant bird. And it miraculously starts off at a steady 20mph. "Faster" he urges, and it's up to 40mph. Astonished, Man yells " as fast as you can, Hen!", and the towed vehicle reaches 65mph, before tragedy strikes, and the Hen stumbles and lies down, motionless. Devastated, he flags down a passing AA vehicle and relays his tale. Man asks "what is the problem with the car?". Mechanic replies " Sorry, Guv, your Big 'En's gone".
Thanks for another great MasterClass! 🙂
Wow solved a clue that Simon couldn't solve mind you he got all the others that I couldn't 😅
I saw a werewolf drinking a pina colada at Trader Vic's. His waitress was perfect.
That give us all hope to do these Simon and it was the hardest for a year.
Always the high point of the week! 😺
"NOT A THRU STREET" is a common sign in the USA to indicate the entrance to a street that dead-ends.
I've come to realize that no matter how loud I yell at the screen you can't hear me.
LOVED IT.
Amazing how much easier the Lilliputian clue was for me because i just read it literally. (And knew of the engine part.)
(This generally works badly for the rest of the crossword, but it worked here!)
I only know this because my sister eats it, and I have to buy her some if I'm ever in Asda. There is a cheese called Quark.
18:17 I asked a similar question last week and the consensus seemed to be that if the 'a' is part of the definition, and not part of the wordplay, then it's not a problem. Still seems dodgy to me but I'm no cryptic crossword expert.
A can be used to clue per, watch out for that!
Maybe "a pipe" was to clarify the noun from a verb? 18:18
I wondered about that too.
I saw "vegan quark cheese" in one of the menu options for a dinner I went to. I didn't try it, and neither did anybody else on my table, so I still don't know what it is .....
The ghosts were howling at you for not getting 6 down
For that last one, I first thought of "quart" (as in, an abbreviation for quarter) and then "top quark" suddenly popped in my head, knowing that it's one of the fundamentals of quantum physics, and a quark is a type of curd cheese.
Still getting the rest correct proves that you're definitely not stupid, just that you don't know absolutely everything. And there's nothing wrong with that. Just see it as a learning opportunity.
When you put in burro you might have been thinking of burrata, which is a type of cheese a bit like mozzarella. It was still an impressive attempt with everything else you managed to work out, so don't feel too bad!
Is there a way to make the clues larger when you click on one? I can’t read them this small and would like to see it.
If you watch the video on a touchscreen device, you can zoom in on any part of the video while watching in full screen mode. If you're watching on a non-touchscreen device, take a screenshot and zoom in on the image to be able to read the clues.
When you se a 74 minute running time, you know it's going to be an absolute brute of a puzzle.
I'm happy I got one clue - 22 down as being star with I in it ( following Simon's earlier teachings lol)
Was this the first “Bobbins” appearance in a cryptic crossword video??
no! 😄
Love it (though I was shouting at the screen a bit). Great to see the gnarly ones!
Don't feel bad Simon. The only ones I thought of during the watch were stair and top quark, and both needed at least three letters from you, and maaaybe a Q. The rest of them _I_ stared at. "Amice. Wait, that's a word?"
Wait, we are Friday already ? (this week was a small week in France).
Some more appreciation for 25A being an and lit. Considering that the Norse Eddas have, regrettably, suffered damage and there's lots missing
Biblically speaking, you have St Paul's epistle to St. Titus -- so Titus Groan is well justified. I adored Big End, and wished Simon realised what a superb clue it was. But - a lovely end to a challenging Friday. Thank you
Not easy to get - Titus is perhaps Paul's least-known Biblical letter.
What surprised me a little is that Simon had never heard of the book, which was still fairly popular in the UK when he was younger. American solvers like me wouldn't know it, but I did construct it from the cryptic.
I was so sure that word 2 was 'ascot', which is a neckcloth and Scott did freeze
Thought that was a great effort, Simon - don't be too harsh on yourself - it was a bit of a beast
I think 4 down is much bigger superfluous a offender than 27 across Simon focused on, especially given it's right after the word "after" which is used in clue for positioning
"Whipped off" is anagram indicator for Cenotaph clue.
Interestingly, we seem to solve in opposite ways - you get the answer first, and then parse it, while I build the answer from the cryptic and then see if it might match the literal. I had to build get along, Titus Groan perpetrate, clarinet, Jeremiah, tousle, and registrar from the cryptics. Unfortunately, I failed to build amice correctly, but my wrong answer does match the cryptic - it's just not a word.
A Protoss reference is not what i expected from you lol.
BURRO means "butter" in italian. It's not a cheese, of course, but at least is a milk-related product. Maybe Simon had this in mind when he guessed "top burro".
quark is a very common thing used in germany. there isn't a single person who doesn't know what quark is. BUT I did not know it was considered cheese?! it's the german equivalent to american cream cheese, so I guess it makes sense :/
I believe Quark comes from James Joyce, used to describe the sound of a seagull in Finnegans Wake. Later adopted by physicists to mean tiny particles. What a quark is or how it works... No idea.
I did manage to complete this crossword, but not without a grumble at the godawful 'amice' clue!
I feel less bad for struggling really badly with this puzzle. some really obscure ones which I had never heard of and it seems even Simon didn't know.
Although I have heard of top quarks (up down strange charm top bottom) I have never heard of quark cheese.
Quick Poll: was 15-across tough for you because of the science term, or because of the cheese?
I didn't know it was a type of cheese. (Spoiler below)
The answer is TOP QUARK - a quark is a tiny subatomic particle, and also apparently a type of soft cheese.
Please be Top Quark! I get that one
There were two occasions, when I screamed at the screen very loudly: STAIR and TOP QUARK.
(those were the only two, that I had solved clearly before Simon, except for maybe AMICE, where I had the ICE fast!)
As a German, 15 was kind of easy... Also I got 3 way before Simon. Everything else: no chance...
Same for me (almost)! Plus, when I look outside my window, I can almost see the facility, where 15 came to its glued life... Wow, TOP was found in 1995? That was 16 years later...
Thoroughfare and through street don't quite mean the same thing, a point against the setter there. A through street is explicitly a traffic term, giving right of way in the direction of the through street on all junctions.
I spent the entire video thinking that excellent cheese was a single descriptor, but of course it wasn't excellent = top, cheese = quark (a particularly tasteless vegan abomination, not really deserving of the epithet 'cheese' :D ), still I new about top (and bottom) quarks when they were known as 'truth' and 'beauty' and I was nowhere near getting it. I did get 'big end' though - the Lilliputians were fighting a war over whether it was better to crack an egg from the big or the little end. (I was once taught English Literature by a descendant of Swift so the story sticks in my mind.)
Commenting for the algorithm and to say that I love these puzzles and you, sir, are about as far from stupid as you can get. Imagine thinking yourself stupid, merely for not knowing about a (frankly overrated) cheese. You did great!
12 across - American is US and RT is route ( as in 66) . THRUST. Fabulous entertainment!
Edda rhymes with cheddar.
Not if, like me, you pronounce the "r" in "cheddar"!