Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Mulan in 15 Minutes or Less
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Sinning CinemaSins' Mulan video.
Enjoy!
Intro song: True To Your Heart cover by Chloe Qisha: • Video
======================================================
===IF YOU'D LIKE TO DONATE TO ME===
Paypal: PayPal.Me/Th3Birdman1515
Patreon: / th3birdman
Twitch Donation: streamlabs.com...
===IF YOU'D LIKE TO FOLLOW ME===
Twitch: / th3birdman15
Twitter: / th3birdman15 @Th3Birdman15
Instagram: / th3birdman15
Discord: nQZRn5m
Subreddit: / th3birdman
Facebook: / th3birdman15
Subscribe: / th3birdman
======================================================
Disclaimer: I actually REALLY enjoy CinemaSins, and am only making fun of them here. I do not hate them, nor am I a "hater". This video is all in good fun.
======================================================
***Th3Birdman merchandise can be purchased at either of these links:
teespring.com/...
represent.com/...
======================================================
The "EWW CinemaSins" Playlist: • EWW CinemaSins
CinemaSins' Channel can be found here: / cinemasins Subscribe!
Their "Mulan" video can be found here:
• Everything Wrong With ...
My Equipment:
Microphone: Shure SM7B
Editing Software: Premiere Pro CC 2020
Thanks for watching, and have an awesome day buds!
#Mulan #EverythingWrongWith
Thank you for watching this video! If you liked it, please consider sharing it! Links to support or follow me are below:
Patreon: www.patreon.com/Th3Birdman
Twitch: Twitch.tv/Th3Birdman15
Twitter: twitter.com/Th3birdman15
Instagram: instagram.com/Th3Birdman15/
Discord Invite Code: nQZRn5m
Subreddit: reddit.com/r/Th3Birdman
Facebook: facebook.com/Th3Birdman15
Haven’t watched the vid yet
I shall consider it.
Your channel is so amazing!!!
I love your work but I don’t have friends to share it with :(
(This comment is a joke)
Hello.
149: Also, the reason Mulan joined the army in the first place was because her father's wellbeing was her top priority. Now that the battle is over, she feels that the best way to care for said top priority is at home with her father.
I got you, fam
1:49
@@Melmeltheclown N... No...
@@Melmeltheclown I do believe the 149 is reference to how many sins there were. Followed by a statement explaining Mulan's motivations for going back home at the end of the movie. But good try.
Yeah.
14:07 - 14:59
To the people whose argument is just "CinemaSins is satire" and leave it at that, may I present a counterpoint:
Comedy/ Satire (like any other form of art) CAN be criticized. You can defend it as satire all you want, but that doesn't mean it's good satire. If bad satire is your thing, that's okay and more power to you, but stop saying "it's satire" as if it shields Jeremy and CinemaSins from criticism
Good point!!
Tldr but i agree
Also, "you shouldn't apply criticism to this, it's comedy" severely undersells the value of comedy as an artform.
"this is bad comedy!"
Exactly
I just want to say THANK YOU for that beginning point of "it's ok if girls want to be pretty for men" shaming of being super feminine is literally giving one of my closest friends anxiety and panic attacks.
Sure. My official opinion on matters such as this are women can do whatever the f*ck they want to do, whether that be uber feminine, or masculine and "butch". Birdman likes em all!
plus, I don't think Jeremy should be the one talking about womens liberation here... he clearly just sees girls as sp3rm banks. lol. also he totally wants to Frick highscholers
Being feminine ≠ being pretty for men. Ofc you can be pretty for men if you want to but that isn't what femininity is
That’s tuff
@@Th3Birdman based
*prepares for jeremy sinning whats literally just chinese culture because its GOING TO HAPPEN*
Same
He basically did for the whole video
Either that or "Da cartoon don't make no sense"
cant wait for the mulan disney+ movie in a few days
Darkwolf523 to be honest the one downside to the Mulan Disney+ movie is Mushu's not gonna be in the film.
Man now I’m half tempted to watch the original to see how many sins he gave “A Girl Worth Fighting For”
Jeremy: “Eurwu this movie is sexchist! Merh!”
Also Jeremy whenever a woman is doing literally anything: “*Heavy breathing* Scene does not contain a lap dance! She’s not my girlfriend EUGHHHH!”
Eh most people that are heavy into social justice I've found end up having some demons
@@Mixinnitup Most? I'll save you time: ALL OF THEM are like this
Only people with spherical brains believe that Jeremy’s wokeness is legit.
Jeremy is a typical neoliberal, who uses commercialized and fetishisized version of progressive points for marketing purpuses. Just like Buzzfeed or a lot of game journals do. Do you really think these people and corporations genuinely believe all of that? This is just a way for making more money.
@@MrNoobomnenie This is pretty damn spot on.
Been waiting for this ever since Cinemasins made that video
Same, when I saw the video I wanted Birdman to make a video on it
That’s a big mood
I’m amazed TMNT v Batman didn’t get priority. Watching that video Jeremy knows he’s going to be sinned on that. 😈
So basically any CinemaSins video then
Same! There were so many things that made me mad
Shan yu: *has yellow/orange eyes and wears a hood*
Me: A SITH LORD!?!
.... yes.
"How do you know this?"
The falcon must be his apprentice. Always two there are. No more. No less.
Holy shit that actually is very accurate
SO HELP ME GOD, YELLOW EYES!
Do you just play a recording of yourself saying “Jeremy makes a pop culture reference that isn’t a sin of the movie cliché”? Because your tone, inflexions and cadence are extraordinarily consistent. I like consistency.
Lol that's a pretty big compliment. I actually say it every single time I record a new video, and I record the line MANY, MANY times in order to get the inflection right and consistent with the other lines.
I've been adjusting my microphone settings, so the sound wouldn't match the rest of my voiceover if I didn't record the line every single time I record for a video. There's actually two versions of the line, where I flip the usage of the word "movie" for "film". That should settle it lol..
CinemaSins: unable to understand the movie's intentions.
Th3BirdMan: Dishonour on you, dishonour on your whole family, dishonour on your cow!
It's actually common for a woman's menstrual cycle to "pause" during times of prolonged physical stress. Such as boot camp or competition training.
This was one of my least favorite CinemaSins videos, so I appreciate you making it a lot better.
The most infuriating part of Jeremy's video was, there was a total of 1 sin removed. Not for the amazing songs, or for Mulan's intelligence and resourcefulness, but because he thought it was funny how long Chi-Fu posed for a portrait
Ridiculous
Perfect timing. At work and needed something like this to break the monotony 😎
Watched, and kick ass as usual 👏🏼
In addition to your points, a woman dressing up and trying to look attractive to get men's attention isn't something this movie made up, this was actually a huge part of the culture the movie attempts to portray at the time it's portraying. A movie isn't sexist for honestly depicting a historical era. Beyond that, there is your point, that if someone wants to get the attention of men by looking attractive, they're perfectly entitled to, and pretending they're not is more oppressive than the thing feminism is supposed to be fighting.
As for sending women to fight, this was more a cultural thing than a logical one, although it roots from a logical point. Basically if you have a ton of women get killed your population is going to have a much more difficult time bouncing back than if a bunch of men got killed.
In terms of how effective women can be, weapons already were an equalizer on battlefields for a long time. Upper body strength and average bone density don't matter very much with a sword or spear. It doesn't take much force to cause fatal damage with a weapon, especially with bladed weapons, and most blocking techniques with those weapons tend to be parries or redirects rather than static blocks that would require a lot of strength. Grappling range might be a problem, but if you're using a 6 foot long polearm and someone gets into grappling range with you, you've likely already lost that fight quite some time ago. Not to mention that there were grappling techniques that existed around that time that could help compensate for the size disparity. There were also cultures that had women train with weapons in order to help guard properties and estates while the armies were away, however it was extremely rare that they had any part in actual battles.
Heck, it’s not even specific to a culture or historical period. It has happened, happens today and will continue to happen as long as humanity exists! AND men also pick up styles and trends to attract women!
14:30
She left home to save her dad, Not for self discovery. It so happened that this journey was a great thing for her, but yeah, not really the point is it?.
How dare cinema sins! But I will gladly listen to your delicious voice. Thanks for the upload.
10:26
Dear CinemaSins,
Periods don’t always start at the “worst possible time”. Most of the time we just say that because we’re complaining that our time of the month is here in general. Please stop being a male and commenting about the inside habits of a woman’s period without a viable source.
Sincerely,
Every Girl Out There
You're content is so much better than cinemasins. It literally has more content. Jeremy makes a lot of pop cultural references that I don't get and have nothing to do with the movie, or sins things that are later explained. So glad I found this channel. You just won a new subscriber. You should try doing tvsins, if you haven't already.
2:04 Why am I not surprised, of course Genghis Khan out of all people would pass it.
Because your wise enough not to be surprised at anything Genghis does.
@@TheDapperDragon shh don't jinx it
Did you know that Genghis Khan animated Mulan all by himself. He even sang the demo for « I’ll make a man out of you », whilst finding a cure for cancer! And he built the tower of Pisa.
CinemaSins: Makes an EWW
Th3Birdman: "Let's get down to business."
🎵To defeat... the Huns~!
Did they send me daughters, when I asked... for sons~?🎵
And you could call the CinemaSins 'Huns' in this case XD
Mulan's motivation to join the army was not about exploring the world and not conforming to societal expectations. It was to protect her father from having to fight in a war he'd surely die in because he was no longer physically capable. She chose to return home because she had brought honor to her family, which she LOVED - a love that drove her to risk her own life. By doing so, she both had to continue to pretend to be someone she wasn't, but also got to experience a life other than the one originally expected of her. She returned because she MISSED HER FAMILY.
9:21 anyone else realize how close he was to finding out Mulan was a girl that whole or does nobody want to talk about it
jeremy: but she just completed her adventure and saved the emperor! why is she going home?!
Jeremy is just used to New Game+
i lost it when
Th3Birdman start counting n i read the subtitles at 11:13... XD
Are we just going to ignore that Jeremy completely ignored the second part of that line from Reflection? “Why won’t my reflection show…WHO I AM INSIDE”
His complaint about the thick horse -- horses in Chinese art are characteristically drawn very broad and large. So in keeping with a lot of the animation hearkening back to Chinese art style, the horse should be big.
Technically speaking, you could "swim" out of an avalanche (you would die but hush we don't talk about that). Wet and dry snow avalanches are basically just shifting snow in either water logged sludgy form or dry powder snow form. A third type is slab snow avalanches which is when entire chunks of large solid ice and snow start a domino effect of sliding down and, well, causing an avalanche. Slab snow is most likely what the avalanche in the movie is and it is the deadliest considering it's giant ice chunks rolling down.
Tl;dr basically, let's say you had the durability and strength to escape an avalanche, then technically speaking you could Aquaman style "swim" out of it depending on the type of avalanche. I could always be wrong so if anyone wishes to correct me go ahead, I'm merely saying the stuff I know about the topic and relating it to something I saw in the video
Bonus sin for Jeremy not realizing that Mulan likely decided to go back home because she did accomplish her goal of showing the world who she really is and saving her father from being sent to (likely) die in battle. She saved the Emperor's life for crying out loud, that's the sort of thing that gets people talking and for sure a few songs written about you and most definitely shows the world that you're not just some lazy farm girl
CinemaSins: This is how many seconds the title are.
Pop culture reference
Question about what's going on that's answered in the previous/next scene
Pop culture reference
Me: So... was anything wrong with the movie?
You make Cinema Sins look like an asshole...
I LOVE IT!!!
I’m Chinese adopted and Mulan was an important movie for me, I’m glad your covering this cuz I get more material
11:30 "Nobody got sad" while showing a scene where at least one person shows some sign of sadness. Yes, he's not crying out loud but you can still see his feelings at seeing this massacre.
Not to mention Ping (Was it Ping?) bring the helmet to his general also showing a IMO sad face...
Anyone who defends CinemaSins with "They're satire" fails to recognize that - even if that were true and CinemaSins really were just satire - satire can be criticized.
Yeah, just because it's satire doesn't mean it's actually funny. Bad satire definitely exists.
You go Birdman! Be cool if you did an 'original' version of your own CinemaSins to a movie. Love the content!
I genuinely do mis the 90s. That ska punk version of “We’re All Dudes” hits right in the feels.
Actually….it’s generally advised, if you can’t get out of the way of an avalanche, to swim. Technically you should swim downstream not up. Flail your arms…not sure if that would work on a horse, but it would probably help you keep your head above the snow. Poor horse 😭
"Ultimately my point is that radical feminists and SJWs like to pretend that any woman that wants to do something for the benefit of a man is 'internalizing misogyny', and it's just not that simple."
Th3Birdman is a feminist *removes 92049234892349082348 sins*
Edit: I was NOT expecting the ska cover of the dude song from Goodburger and that's worth at least an infinity more sins removed. Birdman, you can't be funny, handsome, and have rad music tastes. SAVE SOME COOL FOR THE REST OF US.
Alright, that's it! Honor, Birdman! Honor on your whole family!
13:32 I didn't think of it like that, til you said it like that. And now it's funnier.
I absolutely loved this. I watch cinema sins on a regular but it really grinds my gears when he sins things just for the hell of it or because he personally didnt like a creative choice. ESPECIALLY in fantasy or animated films. He pays no attention to the world building and essentially bitches about shit that doesnt need bitching about.
Damn, Birdman quick asf with the video response 😂😂
Dishonor on Jeremy and his cow.
tbh i was a huge fan of you before @Th3Birdman , but the kevin durant joke makes you the goat
👍 This is sooo much better than CinemaSins!!!
Thank you for playing LTJ in your outro!!!
8:03 hehe bonk
2:01 Fun fact, Shan-Yu is based on Genghis Khan.
Jeremy really thinks Lord of the Rings invented signal towers? No, they're a real thing that many antiquity and medieval civilizations used to transmit messages quickly.
Mulan didn't go to war to show who she really was, she wanted to protect her father. And she didn't go home to conform to society, but she wanted to see her family again. Also it's not like she was homosexual and had a problem with having a man, she just wasn't good at the traditional feminine role. (not a critique against you but cinema sins)
The wall breach line deserves to be sinned. When you hire a guy to let you know if your security has been breached and he tells you your security has been breached...Why did you hire him again?
Also Mulan herself should be sinned because in every telling of this story up until Disney Mulan had been trained by her father. She was full on John Wick when she was recruited.
Also, at 4:46! As a seamstress, I say THANK YOU! We always put our pins and needles in our mouths!
Sin 69: Also this was a REAL historical thing done in China. Fire pits were a much faster way of sending signals to armies across the many miles of the Great Wall than it would have been done on foot.
Sin 74: I wouldn't say Mulan was lazy. She was running late for her matchmaker appointment.
Sin 75: It's called "Exaggerated proportions" and it's used all the time in cartoons.
Sin 77: As a comment said somewhere down here, satire can also be criticized. It's not just an immediate thing invulnerable to all forms of criticism.
Sin 78: Wait...did he say Wumplestilksen or did he mean Rumplestilksen?
Sin 79: The thing about this song, as least how I interpreted it, is that it's based on "traditional" ways of being appealling to men, which for the most part was how things were done in China at the time. Mulan is more of a tomboy, hence why the song doesn't fully resonate with her as she doesn't really see herself in these fancy garments and makeup.
Sin 104: Also (and I might be wrong because it's been a while since I last saw this movie), I don't think she's sleeping. She's sitting out in the rain and crying.
Sin 106: Also, as far as I'm aware, this is one of the scenes that made this movie disliked in China. From my understanding, the Chinese have a very different view of death and the afterlife compared to the West, and bickering ghosts played mostly for laughs is PROBABLY not how the Chinese view their ancestors.
Sin 107: Also in this very shot, you can clearly see an ancestor that's relatively younger compared to all the others, meaning most likely that ancestor died young while the others died of old age.
Sin 108: Also that's NOT an eagle. That's a falcon.
Sin 127: Also, this is ancient China. Traditionally, girls were not allowed to fight in the army at the time. I'm not sure if the penalty for a woman being in the army was death, but I'm pretty sure it was still heavily discouraged anyway.
Sin 129: Also, Jeremy is completely missing the fact that the punching and slapping were NOT the correct thing to do as it immediately starts a brawl.
Sin 131: Wait...did Jeremy think Shang meant he will LITERALLY make a man out of Mulan? I hope not, because that's just...wow. That's dumb.
Sin 132: Basically, during the song sequence, Mulan is struggling with all of the training, and fearing that all that failure may result in the army discovering she is a girl, Mushu cheats so that she can pass. It's only later in the song when Mulan finally gains the confidence to actually pull through on her training and end up being one of the toughest in the army.
Sin 135: A comment answered this about the periods: Women don't have periods during periods of high stress or excercise. As for the "hygiene" thing, she's taking a bath in a lake by the camp, and I don't know about you ladies, but I think it's MUCH harder to hide the fact you're a girl when completely naked.
Sin 138: Besides, just because they aren't crying doesn't mean they aren't sad. There are different ways of showing sadness other than crying. Even a simple bowed head and silence works.
Sin 142: Also, doing a swimming motion when in avalanche is like avalanche survival 101. I'm not so sure about the horse part, but you CAN swim on an avalanche.
Sin 149: Mulan's ENTIRE reasoning for joining the army was NOT because she wanted to prove herself. It was 100% motivated by the love for her family. She joined the army as a replacement for her father, who was an old man that could barely stand with his sword. Of course she would be satisfied with going back home to her family once everything was done!
I'm glad I found this channel because I tried to watch a few of his videos cause I saw other TH-camrs mention him and I was waiting for it to be funny and it mostly made me mad lol
Glad to have ya here, Amber!
2 Dislikes 1 of which is probably from CinemaSins
Ladies helping her get dressed : men want girls with good taste, calm, obedient, who work fast pace, with good breeding and a tiny waist, you’ll bring honor to us all!
Matchmaker: too skinny.
Like damn make up your minds.
Dont have any snarky one liners today just keep up the good work
we were so close with that 1st sin but then you blueballed us..... and i can respect that for the power move that it is.
As a mechanic I can tell you that women's bathroom thing also applies to their cars. I've found a used tampon balled up in tissue just sitting on the floor of a car. Among other eldritch sights in women's cars
This man is completely turning off the internet from CinemaSins and I respect it!
Mulan handled its feminism message quite well, dispite coming out almost two decades before the main tidal wave hit.
I like how it stated that women can still be badass without losing their ladylike properties (the whole thing that makes them special), rather than essentially turning them into a badass with boobs and whimp-efying everyone else; which is a plot device I have seen too many times in this day and age.
I don't have anything against the feminist movement, It's those special cases who shove it down your throat I have a problem with.
It makes me SO IRRITATED, when people comment on your vidoes “it’s satire” NO ITS NOT, DO YOUR RESEARCH. And don’t believe anything you are told, especially from Jeremy.
I love how all of these basically equate to "wait, Cinema Sins sinned THIS MOVIE??" and this is no exception.
The fact that some of the women “willfully subscribe” to it doesn’t mean it’s not sexism. Go back to 1900, and you’ll find women who teach their daughters that women shouldn’t vote or make important decisions, because it’s not their place/unnatural and that things are better if they just behave and let the men do it, because they’re “better suited” for it. These women are willfully subscribing to this idea, and that literally has no effect on if it’s sexist or not. Obviously these ideas are sexist, these women have simply been taught that they are true.
Th3Birdman makes a video much more entertaining than the CinemaSins video he's sinning cliche.
perfect timing my friend
Wow, I’m so happy I found this channel.!!! 😁
I get the feeling that the Disney Live Action remakes were created with people like Jeremy in mind.
They have a tendency to overexplain things like the audience is so stupid they needed to be spoonfed whatever information they need.
Don't forget the forced woke moments who add more harm than good like Belle's inventor subplot that goes nowhere or Jasmine's power ballad about how she doesn't want to be silenced only to get captured shortly after. (Or how she wanted to be the Sultan but still has to marry someone against her will)
My favorite disney movie ever
I absolutely thought you were going to reference Lion King for that "asshole bird" comment
3:58 "scene does not include a lap dance"
Yo, Im hella late to this video. But I’m here because I watched the 2020 mulan and just got done watching cinemasins and dude. You’re funny af 😂
2:18 the American revolution 😭
I like both of these hilarious channels
genghis khan? i thought the only leader to breach the great wall was general iroh (ding)
Mulan literally sings “when will my reflection show *who I am inside?”* and Jeremy cuts it off before “who I am inside” so he can point out that there’s several different things reflecting her *outside* appearance.
That’s just lazy.
And this is the issue with a lot of internet reviews in this day and age. Just deliberately skipping context just to make a snarky response because hey if we acknowledge this thing explaining what's being done, we can't have a joke so therefore, no pointing out context!
Yh but cinema sins is just jokes
Noah Farai
He did the meme! He did the meme!
@Brutus Mars erm *pauses awkwardly* thank you?
Oh I get it like Bruno Mars but with brutus instead
Caricature sexist lady: “Too skinny”
Jeremy: “Body shaming! That’s a sin!”
Me: uh... that’s the whole point of the character, and the song for that matter. Why do you think Mulan would need to disguise herself as a man if the entire ancient Chinese society subscribed to gender equality? What kind of backward logic is this?!? “You’ll bring honor to us all”. She did, but not by getting a husband, but by saving her country. COME ONNN, even 5 year old me could get this
Gives the same vibe as people saying Hazbin Hotel was disgusting and/or homophobic.
Like, it's hell. That's what hell is.
They weren’t actually criticizing body shaming. It was a joke. Their joke was that the woman was bad which was the same joke the movie made. They didn’t “not get it”.
Lol didn’t he body shame that horse at 2:48
Yeah no shit, and this is Disney we're talking about. They've BEEN "woke" since that time and even earlier. Look at the racial representation in their voice actors and song genres (The musical element in Hercules is basically black church music). None of this stuff is new, it's just kept escalating to the point of excess.
Actually..
Some points you missed:
That sin about her not receiving her period is because women don’t have them under extreme exercise and stress, both are things Mulan is most certainly going through
Second, back then, it was considered weak for men to cry, but your point still made sense for the sin
Lastly, Mulan doesn’t think _men_ are gross, she thinks _those men_ are gross, the entire reason she joined the army is to save her father, a male figure she loves deeply
Eh. Speaking as a guy we are pretty gross.
We know it's just that cinema sins is incredibly lazy
_Back then_
Periods don't exist in Disney world because sex doesn't. Pretty simple really.
Kyle Gimple as a guy as well, yeah, i can second that
Excellent final point. Allow me to add one other: Mulan just defeated an entire army and is going home with the spoils of war and a VERY significant gift from the Emperor, she doesn’t have to do jack shit including marrying anyone she doesn’t want to.
Yeah, she more or less has diplomatic immunity AND substantial authority from that seal. It all but says "I'm friends with the guy who runs China. Do you REALLY want this fight?"
She is a hero very rare. I like that there is a sequel.
@ANTHONY THOMAS Unfortunately “inspiration” is a foreign concept to the Star Wars sequel trilogy.
@ANTHONY THOMAS Why didn't the original trilogy take more inspiration from Snow White and the Seven Dwarves? We can ask stupid questions like this all day.
@ANTHONY THOMAS @Noe Will There is no further debate on the sequel trilogy.
The sin about the horse being really big is so stupid because there are horses that are that size and bigger in real life.
Especially horses bred for war
Besides, that horse wasn't FAT, that was raw muscle, that horse was buff
And it meant to look like chinese art from the Tang Dynasty
I met a horse named Ruben that was about 10 to maybe 12 feet tall from the ground to the highest standing position. It was crazy.
But not with legs that skinny... That being said, they are a stylization based on ancient Chinese art.
11:40 - this. ESPECIALLY for men, and ESPECIALLY for military leaders. "Saving face" is very important to many Asian cultures. It's even more heartwrenching when you know Li Shang is absolutely decimated on the inside after learning his father died, but he has to hold it all in.
Yes, because when the general starts breaking down, the entire group will no longer hold together.
11:20 Jeremy also goes on to say that absolutely NOBODY shed a tear, and therefore aren't sad at all about these tragic events. Not is this statement just stupid and wrong in many ways (like bruh, I don't gotta tell you "I have depression" to HAVE depression. Most people don't/won't.), but you can CLEARLY SEE IN THE FOOTAGE HE'S SHOWING that Chi-Fu is broken up about this tragedy and averts his gaze in grief and powerlessness. They also made a makeshift grave for the general which shows they obviously care!
Also, they don't know these random dead soldiers. Seeing THE Imperial Army crushed would spark more terror in them than sadness. They are a tiny platoon of newbies who dream of being heroic and all, and then they see the entire main army, a fighting force both more experienced and larger than theirs, being annihilated. And now they have to go and face the enemy that wiped out the people they were aspiring to become. This is NOT a sad event. This is horrifying, and you can see it in their stricken silence.
The only one who has a reason to be sad is Shang as his father died - and you can see a brief moment of grief he allows himself before he has to perform his duties as a general.
Seeing as how Jeremy makes a horrible joke before each sin I always imagine he’s actually just sinning himself.
Makes more sense anyway 🤷♂️
You may have just fixed cinema sins
Then he should have a sin counter for himself and not use the movie
Also on the last sin: she didn't go to war because she wanted to prove herself or "show the world who she is", she went to war to take her crippled father's place and literally save his life :/
She didn't say she wants to go back home and be a housewife she said that she wants to go back home and be with her family because the whole reason behind her being in this situation in the first place was because she wanted to save her dad.
Also, are women not allowed to want family?
@@imthebossmermaid3648No because families are only for close minded people who don’t understand everyone has to be a ceo or they’re oppressed.
@@Data-Expungeded I mean ofc, obvi! 🙄
Plus, filial piety (being a good child to parents) is a very important thing in chinese society.
@@aureliodeprimus8018 That indeed is so.
In regards to Mulan not having her period throughout the war and during training, I stopped having mine when I went through Army BCT and AIT, a total of over 10 months. It just depends on how your body reacts to the strainious activity; some woman stay normal, some get it worse, and others don't get it at all 🤷♀️
“Even inexperienced rice that might get others killed?”
Even poorly trained soldiers serve well as extra bodies or, if need be, meatshields. To quote Stalin, quantity is a quality all it’s own.
How Russia won Stalingrad 101
Like, recruiting untrained people was common practice for ancient armies. Back then, standing armies of professional soldiers were rare. In times of emergency, they would gathered peasant militia - “levied infantry”, they were called
@@thomastakesatollforthedark2231 except when you actually look at the combat casulties the killratio isnt that much a diffrence about 1,5 to 1 in germanys favour, it climbs to the 10 to 1 when you add all the millions of civilians that was killed and the germans clased as combatans
@@tuehojbjerg2549 and the life expectancy of 24 hours at Stalingrad
Remember that mention of Genghis Khan? The guy who more or less conquered the world before he died? One of his tactics was arming prisoners and putting them on the front lines to catch arrows and exhaust the enemy before his actual troops moved in. NEVER underestimate the value of even one more target in a fight
I find it hilarious that Jeremy criticizes the characters in this movie for being sexist and bigoted... a movie... that takes place in China CENTURIES ago.. if this movie wasn’t historically and socially accurate to those times then he would complain about how Disney is a bunch of SJWS.
You can never win with Cinema Sins I don’t know why anyone supports them. Their videos aren’t smart, funny, or even critiquing films at least not in a good way. They are just 20 minutes of someone talking in a weird tone deaf delivery pointing things out on a screen slap cinematic bars on and a timer and *DING* 9 millions subs. What a fucking joke of a content creator. The saddest part is it’s multiple people creating this Frankensteins monster of a film channel. Pathetic.
Because it's "satire" so it's "funny". Cinema Sins' fans seem to forget that even if it's meant to be a joke, that doesn't mean it's actually funny. You can still criticize satire, and honestly, his videos just aren't good. He tries to sound smart, but he doesn't even do research on the things he's complaining about. It just makes him look ignorant.
When the channel first started, he at least pointed out legit continuity or anacronistic errors; then he got super popular and gained sponsorship, ruining the original foiling nature of the critiques. (I'm sorry if that sounds bloated and elitist. I struggle to use ordinary words.)
Actually tho, fun fact, Mulan was a real person afaik and in the real story… no one gave a shit that she was a woman. She was outed and everyone accepted her
Actually, Frankenstein’s monster (or “the Creature,” as Victor refers to him) is intelligent, well-spoken, and most of all, literate. If you wanted to make an accurate reference to Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein to properly describe Cinema Sins, then make one directly related to Victor Frankenstein himself; a cowardly, pathetic, and spoiled little man
@@ogcolumbinakinnie6556 even victor was smart enough to create human re-animation with no degree. So the smarts wouldn’t be a a good exchange.
_However, the pride and the narcissism_
You missed a sin: "Jeremy wants to see a beheading in a children's movie".
just that last sin...WTF IS WRONG WITH YOU JEREMY?! Mulan's whole goal was to infiltrate the army so save her AILING FATHER! her father that sustained permanent injuries in a previous war and totally would have died if he had gone into another one! the Huns are dead/defeated, the war is over, her goal is done! yeah, she wants to go home! she didnt join the army to show people her true self. its was Mulan realizing that acting like herself and true to who she is is what ultimately saved the day and not hide who she is, which is called CHARACTER GROWTH! Mulan didnt save the day by doing things how Shang or her family wanted she saved the day by doing things on her own terms and not giving up! also Shang and Mulan didnt end up married! they had dinner by the end, they're just dating! it be weird to skip to marriage when they're both just coming to terms with how they feel about each other
I understand your point, but I think her dad wouldn't even make it through training. We see Mulan almost get sent home after she failed a bunch of tests. Her sick dad would have failed them too. Though he probably would be shamed, so she did save their family from the shame he might have brought.
@@rosestar1324 Her father wouldn't have gone through training. Shang was there to train the new recruits. Mulan was new which is why she got training her father already fought in a war and has experience. Pretty sure Mulan's dad would have to go with Shang's dad cause him and all the other already experienced soldiers went out ahead while the new recruits stated behind for training and he would have died on the battle field like all the others did
@@rosestar1324 Her dad was a veteran. He probably wouldn't have been sent to training at all.
I think he basically turned her motivation into "I want to be a strong empowered woman, who don't need no man" instead of her using her different way of thinking to solve the practical problem in front of her and through that find herself (the character problem) so from his very non-self aware perspective of her motivation it does send a bad message. A perfect example of Jeremy simplifying things to suit his need.
Eddie Murphy as Mu-Shu is on the same level as Robin Williams as the Genie.
Damn right.👍
Ehh not the same level but he’s like one or two levels below. That’s a hard act to be compared to.
To bad he’s not In the live action
Facts
The truest thing I've read today
Excuse me, Jeremy sinned WHAT?!?
Exactly why Th3birdman does this
I thought the same when he "sinned" (aka, was plain wrong) about The Fugitive, Up, The Iron Giant, or Godzilla: King of Monsters (just a few movies he was wrong about :D)
This is also a pretty blatant example of casual racism were the writers and Jeremy don't care about cultural context and history like in Moana for example and view things from a white american perspective. Mulan isn't exactly 100% accurate obviously but most of the problems he has is due to the time period and country this movie takes place in. And they claim to care about minorities...
In fairness though, he sins settings in Europe for the same kinds of things, so it's less about him being racist, and more about him being willfully ignorant that culture exists... but what do you expect from a communist *cough * sorry... SJW.
@@saribeepo.o5111
Umm, you do know that not all communists are even SJWs or Progressive, what do you think Tankies believe in
they care about their money and have sold their souls to bandvagon long time ago.
@@lemmonboy6459 Never said they were bro. Was talking about a specific person wasn't I? So I was referencing him specifically and the perception formed by his views and actions.
Might want to learn how language and conversation works there my friend.
@@saribeepo.o5111 What's wrong with being a communist?
4:50 and also the reason the matchmaker is saying this is because heavier bodies are better for childbearing. When you’re deciding to live a life as a mother and being judged for you abilities to do so, that matters! She’s not just saying it to bodyshame Mulan, she’s using it as a grading criteria.
which is funny cause nowadays, even in places that arent china, being plump outside of tits and ass is bad and gross and ew...
fuck modern society
genuinely
Okay but “I’ll make a man out of you” is an absolute banger, and there’s something so cool about seeing Mulan climbing to get the arrow while “Be a man” is playing in the back.
Jeremy: (Doesn't know why it seems impossible why a guy can get past the Great Wall of China)
Anyone who has read at least one page of Chinese History: Pathetic.
Anyone who has just even seen the fucking wall: *Pathetic*
tfw you can't even be bothered to google it.
jokes aside in my old middle school history book we had pictures of it, did he not go to school?
Chinese man: Great Wall? Which Great Wall?
@@LolLol-fu2nt the wall of stone to the north that makes you money
Well Genghis Khan Found the weak points of the wall and used them to defeat the wall with out damaging it. But I think there are other weak points like the desert areas or the part that goes into the ocean but I think that the wall was shorter in the mountains and the bad weather hindered the watching of it in the mountains also bad visibility.
Missed sin: 10 sins for even thinking of sinning this movie!
OK, maybe that's just me.
nah i'm with you! 20 sins to jeremy!
@@WakoDoodle make it 30
I'm with both of you and make it 30 sins
Nope not just you movie is still legit
10?
20?!
*30???!!!!!!!!!!!!!*
Are y'all mental or somethin'? It's at minimum 10,000
13:19 Thank you. Animated movies aren't usually made to mimic reality; they should be meant to push reality, you got that 100% right!
Given the strength of silk, I wouldn’t be surprised if that would actually work.
They literally make bullet proof vests out of layered silk and in the ancient times silken clothes were known to protect from swords
They're technically climbing like spiders.
Where's Mythbusters when we need then most? (RIP Grant)
@@sylph4252 yeah and in europe the checz(IIRC the nations name) made hats from paper, fucking paper that managed to stop blackpowder gunshots.
but only real silk, right? not silk hybrids. I can't afford real silk if it is what I think it is. plus, it would be a bitch to clean if I rubbed makeup on it probably.
Woman- does what SHE wants to do instead of what everyone else wants her to do
Cinemasins- NNOOOOOO!!!!!
Noo- bad example for little girls, feminism and women empowerment! Also, [inser hot actress] isn’t my girlfriend/ giving me a lapdance in this scene - CinemaSins, the wokest channel of them all.
Movie: set in Ancient China
Jeremy: SEXISM! BODY SHAMING! SIN!!!
I mean seriously what the fuck? Even putting aside the fact that current China is more patriarchal and misogynistic than the current West, expecting people thousand of years in the past to act in accordance with modern (Western) feminism and social justice is insane. Showing those things doesn't mean filmmakers support sexism, it just means they are telling a story in which it has an effect. You don't expect WW2 movies not to show Nazis being racist and genociding Jews because that is disgusting and wrong do you? No, you have to accept that Nazis existed and were evil and a film portraying that doesn't mean it supports it.
As someone who is currently studying for a history degree I couldn’t agree more.
I know. It's like saying that The Princess and the Frog is racist.
Yeah. What next? Will Jeremy sin « Silence of the Lambs » because Hannibal Lester is a crazy and violent murderous psychopath?
they made scar more politically correct, even though he's a villain. also, jeremy criticized a villain from IT being a villain, so, there's that
12:50
Sin 144: Yes, eat your horse, or your dragon, but not the bucket of dumplings Mushu is currently trying to cook.
Uh...Why is he singing "This is Halloween" when the Huns are riding? That doesn't make sense.
Why else?
*crunching on chips*
To pad the sin count, bro