ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ย. 2024
- What Did PM Modi Achieve in Ukraine? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi reiterated New Delhi's commitment to peace in a high-stakes visit to Ukraine. But President Volodymyr Zelensky's statements claiming that his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin does not respect PM Modi have led to questions on whether the visit was necessary at all. Palki Sharma tells you what Modi's trip achieved.
---
Russia Ukraine War | Narendra Modi | PM Modi | Ukraine | Volodymyr Zelensky | Russia | Vladimir Putin | Firstpost | World News | News Live | Vantage | Palki Sharma | News
#russiaukrainewar #narendramodi #pmmodi #ukraine #volodymyrzelensky #russia #vladimirputin #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.c...
![Shareปลาวาฬ ส่งท้าย SS1 พาเปียโน ขึ้น Ferrari ก่อนไปขาย แลก Nissan l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KAknGkTNIvg/mqdefault.jpg)
Went for Diplomacy not to provide weapons 😂😂😂. Zelensky is lost
That's nonsense. India is supply by Russia for most of it's military weapons. India cannot risky offending Russia not when Pakistan and China want to fight India.
Volodymir Zeleneski is getting plenty of financial help and pampered by America and Euros ! He is not at all interested to end the war !
Europe wants peace. Climate Change has to be stopped!
I think Ukrine trying to defend itself. Ukraine is not Russia, but Putin seems to think so. Look what happens to Crimea, Ukraine.
Indian, you and I know that most your weapons comes from Russia. China is currently sitting on your lands with an army on it. India cannot risk offending Russia but either can it support it in what it is doing in Ukraine.
Don't forget Vladimir Putin more than willing to bomb Ukrainians cities with Indian nationals within it. Only when Modi offered Russia a massive bribe did Putin back down and allow Indian nationals to leave Ukraine did Putin stop the bombing. Just remember that, Indian he no friend to India. He should have allowed Indians to leave first not been bribed what kind of friend is that???
@@HellBot-gi5siWhat would risk profit ratio for India in support Ukraine, a nation which backs Pakistan's interests against India in most occasions?!?
Zelenskyy can even irritate *Buddha*
😂😂
Putin is weak old man!!!
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
U can’t irritate Buddha…u can irritate budhi…
As far as domestic view and opposition view....it doesnt matter bcoz Modiji has the vision and farsight that none of our politicians can even dream...in the path of World peace..there can be few ups and downs...what matters it the real intention...Bharat has good intention...and someone as ambitious as Zelensky can never understand. We are with the people of Ukraine....sooner or later they will understand the real culprit is their leader. Jai Hind 🙏
😂😂
Wah re anpadh
Wonderful n best move from Modi ji ❤❤
you have done realistic analysis of modiji trip no other news channel can see it your way
India ❤️❤️🙏🏽
Zelensky is a joke
Big joke?
@@bndiayelelion2469Biggest joke
@@rishikeshdora4594 Thank you teacher.
@@rishikeshdora4594Dude, I am lil confused here. Is he the biggest joke or a joker (understanding of his comedian experience)?
Modi is a joke too
Making an attempt to resolve the conflict is indeed a good step. It may or may not work.
Quote....Modiji said....India is on the side of Peace...Period.
Jai Hind 🙏🙏
Wr should make peace with Pakistan and Bangladesh too.
The intention is simple: to show the West with a balanced hug against the previous Putin’s hug. Peace is just a label to cover up the cheap Russian oil.
@@rajshreekhandarkar2093 You are comedian like Zelenski ! To mr president Vladmir V Putin. Modi and Zelenski are two comedian 😆. Mr president Vladmir V Putin know Pm Modi was sent by America 🇺🇸 and the West for so called peace talk 😆 🤣 😂.
@@shotokankarate6836 Definitely..Bharat has neighbour first policy. The day pakistan stops terrorism against India....that day we will talk about peace with them..🙏
@@bndiayelelion2469India dgaf about western, modi is pro russian, western can't be trusted.
I support Modi. I voted for Modi. I trust Modi.
That's good for you! But we Russian not ready for so called peace that Zonist little boy 👦 Zelenski and his alliance have to feel the pain !!!
@@bndiayelelion2469 Zelensky is just a puppet.. He is dancing to the tunes of US.. Russia should protect itself from US
Modi couldn’t even solve the rape crisis in India, let alone a peace deal…
@@bndiayelelion2469brother a superpower like Russia should have defeated country like Ukraine in 15 to 20 days why it is taking too long it has been like 2.5 years since war started
good for you, but the majority of Indians and the world people say otherwise.
Well said Palki
Solution is- Modi
Zelensky not interested to end war he thinks these are jokes
the other is more interested in buying cheap Russian oil...
What PM Modi achieved is showing Indians at home and the world what is the true nature of Zelensky
Guys this is the same Zelensky who supports Pakistans bid for Kashmir. He has never been Indias friend.
India always with Russia ❤
Zelensky is a JOKER, India should not try to help him!
putin isnt any different
@@richurichu8781 Putin wants to show his power to the world.
@@ashakuldip1657super power countries like America, France, Italy, germany helps ukraine
After Hitler, US & USSR poached the scientist of Nazi for their own growth. After that USSR & US became enemies knowing that there is no threat against each other. The real thereat to the world is Pieceeefools & US know it well and colluded with them for US, UK, EU economic growth & backstabbed countries like India & South Asian countries.......
@@aharonmercy6433 France, Germany and Italy are not superpowaaaars, they are vassals of US! 🤣😂
Thats what happens when u make comedian ur President , thats comedy not comments 😂🤣
So peace is comedy these days. What are you? Insane?
You are lost
@@demontrader1222 Zelensky doesn't want peace , he is happy enjoying the Western dollars 💰
Are you really okay or do you allow someone to think for you?
@@MrSahbunky Zelensky doesn't want peace , he is enjoying the Western dollars 💰
Then India is not learning from the past. If India didn't actively support Russia, how is it grateful for what Russia did for her in 1970s war with Pakistan when the west support Pakistan and no country but only Russia came for their help and protected them? What kind of loyal friend is India? I'm sure, Russia and other countries will revisit how they help India in the nearest future once again
Modi should hold a "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" conference. All countries should come to India for a Peace Summit to discuss the future of Mother Earth. Let Putin and Zelensky both listen to top class Hindustani Music in Raag Bhoopali and Raag Durga and sign a peace treaty. This summit can be hosted in Udaipur, Auroville, or Mysore
Thanks!
Russia is still our friend. We should not forget 1971
Great digest!
Good analysis 💯
Thanks Palki ji. Also, the sad thing in today's Geopolitical system is that there are Anti-Semitism,Anti-Nations,Anti-Religions etc., also Pro-Nation, Pro-War, Pro-Politics everywhere. But no Anti-Fanatism of any kind or Pro-Humanity as Human in Man has Vanished in the flood of Politics and Power Hunger
😢
Zalensky being a clown of the West😢
Modi ji a leader of responsible world,real vision for a great mission
Ukraine considers India as weak or dumb nation and that has been displayed a number of times when they spoke against India in the UN on terrorism and other issues and the fact is they are dumb to continue the war since 2 years and bring their economy to zero, zelenskys attitude hasn't softened or think logically, Indias wise advice is falling on deaf ears ,let him continue to learn his lessons, we should leave them alone, we need not be Mahatma
Modi stopped the war. Thank you, Modiji.
War will end; not in a way Zelenski- his masters have been wanting. But when it ends, time will tell that there was a guy called Zelenski.
Person who filled with HATE who never agree for any Negotiation , Our Proud PM Modij put all his Efforts to Bringing peace .
How has he brought peace in Manipur? He travels thousands of miles away to try to negotiate peace when he can’t even goto Manipur… 🤷♂️🤦♂️
@@kevinclasher3160 He can bring peace in Manipur without visiting there.
@@kevinclasher3160Peace has returned to manipur bro, the meiti and kuki community have reached a settlement brokered by the Indian government. Update yourself.
@@naitikgupta7450how about Kolkata, and the child cases? any idea fm Modi to really solve the problem?
@@Lee-Van-Cle you need to ask mamata, cm of wb for this case.
Ukraine’s struggle exemplifies the unyielding resilience of the human spirit.
❤World peace please ❤
I agree with u Palkijee
Just a question it was said Russia owe India 600 milions in dividend... but at the some times I-m reading that surplus of Russia with India in trade is nearly 60 billions... so shouldn't be quite easy to compensate?
Smthing must be there.. Both must be different scenario
Yes, you are right. But, I have seen many news related to this issue that Russia has already exhausted most of its Rupee surplus by investing in Indian refineries (buying stakes) and Indian businesses and stock market. These days you can’t be sure what’s actually happening!!
Your forgetting another thing. When this war started there where many Indian nationals studying in Ukraine. Vladimir Putin did not give India warning and Modi had to give Vladimir Putin a massive bribe to get all the Indian nationals safely out of Ukraine. What kind of friend is that?
Tells You - Ms. Palki selects a set of facts and threads in a pseudo patriotic story. A True Journalist will consider all facts and present a holistic analysis that helps citizens of India to understand and support the correct policies in a Democratic country.
Ms. Palki, who is so talented ends up being loved by her audience, while she is really doing a disservice to our country.
60 billion might be what the whole country earned via trade, but it is the government who owes 600 million.
THE WAR IS LIKE FIGHTING A BROTHER BECAUSE YOU HAVE FRIENDS FOR BACKING YOU
ZALENSKY SHOULD NOT HAVE ANY HOPE FROM INDIA. INDIA IS ALWAYS NEUTRAL
Fantastic analysis by Palki..You have cleared many doubts
Look at childish behavior of Zelenskyy - "we want India from our side?" Does he even know how diplomacy works?
you seem to exactly understand what question runs in my mind... am amazed seriously
Continued.... we Indians & the only the best leader is Modiji whose points of “peace” IS that!!! Please school them with the “misconnected so far untold points”!!! Pls do this Palki?! You would be more nobler!!! Than all!!
That's not the way when she talked about Olympic games, the real competition.
@@Lee-Van-Cle Well ‘I really don’t know’ about it, excuse me. Context is of “the War & Peace”. The “Peace & thus the Bliss” are totally of a Spiritual Matter which a selfless Leader like Modi could possibly point out to the political existence of people of this world which IS being blinded by Wars Wars Wars from the time immemorial. While I am about it, she is Far Better I felt !!
If the Ukrainians had more humility they would have gained even more. But I guess "beggars can't be choosers" isn't something Elensky knows about.
Zelensky is the ultimate beneficiary War😮
World's Best Peaceful Prime Minister Mr Narendra Modi of India
India/Indians like to think and act like they are extremely important on the global stage through 24/7 non stop propagandas on the internet. However, it is not what the netizens see/think/do/feel that is important. It is what the country leaders see/do that reflects India's importance on the global stage. Here are some examples: Palestine and Ukraine (Ukraine's first choice in Asia is China) did not sought India's help. This goes to show that they have little regard for India. India is not a regional power in Asia, let alone a global power. Truth hurts but this is the reality. Businessmen picks China over India all the time eg. Elon Musk postponed a planned trip to India where he was to meet Prime Minister Narendra Modi, citing obligations at Tesla, and went to China for business talks instead.😅More examples of India's influence on the global stage,
1) GDP per capita < 3K🤏 China? China's GDP per capita > 12K ? Is there even a competition?
2) No veto powers, despite begging for it since 1994😭
3) Booted out by Maldives ("India Out") for China.
4) Russia to Superpower India: I know that you are a superpower on the internet/social medias.🤭, but you have to pay for our Russian oil in Chinese currency because we have no use for Indian Rupees. .🤭
5) BRICS meeting: the president of South Africa came to pick up Xi Jinping from the airport in Johannesburg, however they sent a junior minister to pick up Modi, Narendra Modi refused to get off his plane unless a more senior minister came to pick him up from the airport. 🤭
6) India invited 120 countries for their "voice of the global south" virtual summit and less than 20 countries attended. Meanwhile, China invited 150+ BRI participating countries for BRI forum October 2023, 130+ country leaders/representatives attended. (BRI summit videos October 2023). 🤭
Name of Article/Source: India invites 120 countries to ‘Voice of Global South’ summit (Times of India): Close to 20 world leaders are expected to participate in the summit, including Bangladesh PM Sheikh Hasina, Lankan President Ranil Wickremesinghe and several ASEAN and African leaders.
7) more...
There is nothing like perfection in diplomacy. Modi’s efforts were laudable. Zelensky is another Pappu and let his tongue loose. That’s not Modi‘a failure.,
lNDIA is in the side of PEACE 🕊️
@palki Sharma u are good sangi
People stop naming Zelensky. He didn’t start the war. Every country is free to choose their options good for their country. Good decisions pay them back, bad decisions affect them. Like in this case.
We are surrounded by all neighbouring countries against us supported by west and china. But we don’t attack any one first. It's our policy. If someone start the war, you have to defend and protect your territory. This is what Zelensky is doing. What’s wrong !! We will do the same when Pak attacked us. We will protect ourselves first. The difference is we finish the war big time. Teach them a lesson. In this case it’s Russia. It’s a superpower. Ukraine didn’t give up. I am proud of them. But this war is now in autopilot mode. It’s not ending. Other countries are also involved. I feel bad for Ukrainian people who lost their lives and mother land. Modi’s effort is applauded 🙌🏻 Someone has to try hard from their side as well to advocate for Peace ☮️
Nauseating seeing Modi embracing natonazi Ukraine. Putting brotherly hand on Zelensky's shoulder sure scored brownie points with US.
Well said ☝️🙌🏻
Zelensky joked that more than any body, Modi needs peace.
Instead of setting his house right, why is he venturimg in such useless trips? It was an utter failure.
Indian media seems to be myopic and annoyed about Zelensky, and displeased with Modiji's Ukraine visit. Modiji's vision is impeccable and grand. India is Washington's only hope, and only one capable of educating the successive American govts to come out of their narrow minded world view. We are indeed witnessing the change (albeit very slow) when Blinken was positively receptive to Jaishankarji's views in Zurich. India's role is pivotal in establishing a neutral, peaceful, and multi-polar world, and Modiji is certainly taking us in that direction. Gone are the days when we can blindly stick to one side even if it is Russia. We have demonstrated our friendship and remembrance to Russia and they know and acknowledge it. In this chaotic and turbulent world, India's role as Vishwabandhu (and Vishwaguru in essence) is not an easy or emotion-based one. This strong commitment and leadership is unimagined of before, in India or elsewhere. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
And for those criticizing Zelensky: Just put yourself in his shoes and imagine for a minute, what his country is undergoing right now. He is up against a Behemoth of a military power trying to crush him. We all thought Ukraine will not be able to stand for more than a month when Russia invaded them. Now its been 2.5 years and still they are putting up a brave, unenviable, and determined fight against the Goliath (although with massive western aid). I am sure Zekensky enjoys massive and unanimous support of the Ukraininian people, and hence he surely represents the true aspirations of every Ukraininan citizen, in resisting Russia's dominance and hegemony. We should certainly respect that instead of blindly conniving and abetting with Russia's actions. A true friend is one who points out a friend's mistake and tries to bring him back to righteousness boldly. And not someone who blindly nods his head in acceptance to whatever his or her friend does. Salute to Ukraininian people's spirit and courage. 🫡
India has to become independent in their weapons reliance. The big powers work for their interests. Nobody is your real friend. India needs to work very very hard to become independent from foreign arms reliance. That's the only way they will treat us as equal powers. The work culture of complacency must change at all levels. We have enough brains but the work culture is in the way of us excelling over all other nations.
He has become so rich with this war, he doesn't want it to stop so the money doesn't stop. India didn't give him money so his press conference
Very well analysed
He looks and behaves very similar to RAGA
Modi simply wants all parties should come to terms. He is not trying to balance. Think peacefully not partially. You cannot solve every problem with deals, we have a heart too, use it for the wellbeing of mankind.
Visits wont help to stop the war and bring piece, diplomacy does
And when you cannot be on right side because you got an old friend
Everyone knows you are not on the right path. Same can be applied when you are in need especially when you are especially surrounded by a country like China
He went to ukraine but did not even come to manipur🤦
"Jocker" wants War not Peace !! Fact is Jocker is earning money from war !
Zelensky is a show man. He is not at all a seasoned diplomat. A great amount of diplomacy is required to run a country. Arrogance and rudeness can't achieve peaceful solutions. May God bless him ! 😂
Zel don't wanna end the war, he's milking billions out of this war. He's losing nothing. #literally
THANK YOU INDIA.🇮🇳🙏🇺🇳
India gained from PM Modi's visit. Looking behind the flash lights, most of the gas turbine engines on India's naval vessels are made in Ukraine. India and Ukraine are talking about cooperation in this field. It won't happen soon. But it's a start. India can make valuable inroads in that technology!
after modoi's visit ukraine has started 911 style attacks on russia, and the war has heated up like never before. reflects moti's influence lol
That’s why they call it “Godi Media.” She’s defending Modi’s questionable decision to visit Kyiv by criticizing Russia. Sorry, but this blunder can’t be justified. Now forget about Russia and play the role of “a kind of mediator” by bringing Ukrainian kids back, that’s the task your new boss “Zelenskyy” has given you😅
It tells the coalition government compulsion. From 2014 to 2024 India had independent foreign policy but after 2024 government is ready to compromise.
Previous jobs of current world leaders:
Biden - Lawyer
Xi - Chemist
Putin - KGB agent
Starmer - Lawyer
Macron - Banker
Trudeau - Teacher
Zelensky - Comedian👈
Modi - Tea seller👈
The best leader is the last one
In many nations, most deals get done during Tea Time. You better start learning from the Master.
Piece by piece.
One fails to understand why the two countries have escalated after Modi left
So, as per Zelenskyy comment he thinks that he can manipulate Indian audience that Putin does not respect India 😂 and he himself contradict his statement and he is more conservative and far from healthy diplomacy. Actually, he does not want war to be stop because he and his ministry keeps getting money and hence, it's done.
I don't know its just in the bucket list.😅✌️😊
Modis mission in Kiev was as messenger boy for Biden and he failed miserably
In the comment section....someone rightly said...Zelensky doesnt want to end the war. Kursk is the proof....forget leverage...you have been constantly triggering the war right from the beginning.
Why treating Rusophone in Ukraine as a second citizen ?
Moodi achieved his favourite bearhug , a paid vacation, making uneccessary noise and an artificially inflated indian egos
Ukraine and Russia is an opportunity for India.. and we need to continue to milk it as much as we can.
Keep getting cheap oil from Russia and get as much technology from US and the western countries.
And if it needs for Modi to go hug some people so be it.
Ukraine is racist towards India, Russia isn't
Mr. Zelensky, Did you recognize when India is/was in trouble? The least you can do is to thank you for the effort.
Most of India’s frontline warships have Ukraine engines. In addition, about 100 odd AN32 transport aircrafts also have Ukraine engine. Ukraine has some of the highly developed military technologies from Soviet Union days that can be of use to India. So it was a good decision to visit Ukraine.
Offering ‘Peace’ is akin to the Police going to a rape victim and asking for Peace settlement with the rapist. Modi’s ‘Peace’ is essentially asking Ukraine to give up the occupied territories to stop the war. History shows that such ’Peace’ agreements have never worked. Lord Krishna enlightens Arjuna to fight for Dharma. As the Biggest Democracy, we must be on the side of Respecting Sovereignty of Nations and do not validate the Russian invasion.
Take a look at all of the nasty things we have said about Ukraine. Our EAM has expressed that India doesn’t have to care for the happenings in Europe.
Ms. Palki is a talented storyteller, and would serve us better if she gives us all sides of the conflict
What did he achieve? Zero, nada, nyet, shunya, sifar etc etc. Absolutely nothing achieved- PM Modi has shown himself to be extremely weak in this tenure
It feels like Ukrainian leader is acting 😂in drama...his expression 🤣in the conference 🌚🤦
Ukraine don't know anything if really want to talk with talk usa nato
Zalenski need to step down;!!!
Negotiation for peace is the only way ...Who and what for are we humans killing ? Are we immortals? Mother Earth will anyways swallow us ...Realise before it's too late and let's cherish this one life we have been given ....
War is a place where young people who don't know each other, who don't hate each other kill each other, be the decision of old people who know each other and hate each other but do not kill each other ....
Modi went to ukraine 😂 comes back empty handed... Yet another country to visit unlocked 😂
Chai wala and a comedian . What would you expect
😊
Let us wait and watch. As of now it looks like a visit with zero outcome
Bharath playing neutral is the best policy in Ukraine-Russia war situation. pm Modi is firm on his stand that he is on neither side but only on the side of peaceful solution to the conflict. If Modi stops buying cheap Russian oil as Zelensky wants, then Modi’s government will be thrown out in India soon due to inflation.
Telling Putin that zelensky don't want peace.
Palki Sharma .... excellent coverage ... as you have been saying your coverage as always “unfiltered & unwatched” & is being Well Received either!! Really Great !! Now that you have achieved & regrded by people, I would suggest you please try n add points “Untold” either, to the waring Politicians to touch their conscience with the points of truth that the “peace” they talk about is “the peace that is NOT the one between two Conflicts which is ALWAYS futile”!!! Pls consider going into it.
Modi ji is on good path
Palki without mention China is like a day lost
A bollyhood puppy can't be a peace maker. 2 puppies in the meeting room.
India Prieminister him talking to other men its not a problem, the problem is, who is losing his people and economic, American are counting how many Russia soldiers left so that they can come and get Putin like Kaddafi and Sandam
Modi gets infrastructure contract for adani. Adani. Zindabad.
Money for war but cant feed the poor
Are you talking about USA?
He doesn't war to end
It's benefiting him
Whenever war will end
Ever enquiry commences ,
He will flee the country
Zelensky attacked russian skyscrapper.. Goodbye to piece talk
Indian, you are forgetting when this war started Vladimir Putin bombed cities in Ukraine with Indian nationals within it. It took Modi offering a massive bribe to Vladimir Putin to get Indian nationals studying in Ukraine out of the country safely. That why India does not support Russia or Vladimir Putin.