exactly. if this lawyer does indeed know, how can he NOT give those details to her poor family? Sounds to me, like hes a narcissist too like Drew. I am in shock hearing that.
@@BelfastManUtdTherapy I remember when they had a press conference at the beginning of Drew’s trial and they were all wearing sunglasses and joking about how she was living it up on a beach with another man. If he knew all that time what exactly happened to her, he is just as disgusting as Drew Peterson. Not to mention when he was also right by his side when they did a Win A Date With Drew contest.
I think the judge is full of Sh't!! Lawyers should be able to provide answers once their obligation to their client is over and will not change the outcome of appeals. The family has the right to get their loved one back. Drew already got his due course and more rights than Stacy ever had.
Joel a pariah? More like a bottom feeder. Probably looking to write a book. Joel you are almost 70 years old. Please draft 2 letters to the wives 2 and 3's families telling them what you know. Keep it in your safe to be read after you pass. Those families need to know what happened to their loved one, and Cassandra needs to know where her sister is.
The attorney is awful. Just trying to make money off of the story. He could have anonymously told the families or law enforcement rather than do it this way.
Or he really doesn't know anything. Anyways, if what his says is true and he knows all this information, I'm pretty sure client attorney privilege doesn't apply. At least to the extent that he cannot knowingly let his client perjure himself. What he can and should of done is contact the ethics board and discuss it with them. They can tell him what to do. CYA
Attorney-client privilege most certainly applies. You can know you client is guilty but if you allow them to testify and lie then you're in trouble. Which is why most defendants don't testify. So yes you're right you can't allow your client to perjure themselves but the way around that is to not allow them to testify. Also, if you're client revealed to you that they are in fact guilty you cannot then tell the world years later and inform everyone of what he/she revealed to you. That is a breach of the privilege between attorney and client. The client forfeit the privilege and start telling people what he/she disclosed to the attorney and then the attorney can discuss it but if the client doesn't forfeit it then the attorney is bound by the privilege of attorney and client and cannot reveal that information.
He actually has a good point that the other crooked attorneys got to keep their license so he should keep his and how about the crooked wife knowing her own husband should be disbarred and isn't, why is she still on the bench? Are they elected or is there no peer judicial review of personal conduct and double standard codes? Why aren't they given the same sanctions?
So many politicians are corrupt these days! The system is broken. Before Nancy Pelosi retired, she and her husband were well known insider trading monsters. That's how she amassed a $200 MILLION fortune on her $196k per year former speaker salary, and now she gets a huge salary and benefits for life. There is no way anyone is that good at trading stocks. Give me a break. She is a thief and corrupt. Makes me so damn angry. This guy's license should be reinstated but if he blabs his client's secrets, then no. Attorney-client confidentiality is crucial to our justice system, even if it involves a scumbag like Drew.
The whole judicial system is corrupt, it's plain to see , look how they are bringing false charges on Donald Trump for a political witch hunt to manipulate his run for a second Presidential term even though the majority of Americans want TRUMP for president, look what there doings to him ,all controled by the democRATS, FJB ! TRUMP the real ( Mvp ) ...most valuable President ! MAGA 2024
Drew will never reveal anything because he's NOT a man. He said Stacy abandoned her children, ran off with another man, took her bikini and is dancing somewhere. So stupid and insulting. This lawyer should do the right thing, even if it breaks law doctrine and help give closure to the families.
These people have the audacity to judge each other and talk about trust. SMH! They are the biggest crooks! This guy knows the truth therefore don't want to continue practicing law.
4:21 Than do it or shut up about it!! Keeping a family hanging after all they have been through wanting answers is cruel & indignant..Did someone say Air time money at the expense of heartbroken family members???😢
That's crazy but what's even crazier...i actually believe him. I think he really has a guilty conscience about what he knows and just can't live with regrets anymore. He maybe a little bitter about dome stuff in his career but I do believe he knows what to Lacy and that Drew Peterson was responsible for it.
Why is it the "ultimate treachery" or "despicable" for a lawyer to tell the truth about where a man buried his wife, but it's ok to kill his wife in the first place?
A moral obligation to tell, and a legal obligation to keep his mouth shut. In such a conundrum, considering that he's over 70 years old and has lost his license to practice law, he should probably lean more towards his moral conscience than his legal ethics at this point. He won't hurt himself or anybody else with this information, but he will help Stacey's family.
@@JarethTheGoblinKingForever Jareth, he does not have a legal obligation to stay quiet once a client accuses him of ineffective council. He pointed this out to the judge. The judge told him he has a good point. But he had to wait until Drew Peterson appeal is over. Now there's a gag order. He should be patient. Drew P. did not see this coming. Another murder charge.
This would be good him revealing. I’ve always been wanting to know the truth hopefully it’s the full truth. Stacy deserves the Justice and her story being told proper burial for her children and her family and friends ❤️God bless Kathy and Stacy they are both angels 😇
DON'T FORGET THAT STACEY COVERED FOR HIM WHEN SHE KNEW WHAT HE DID TO KATHLEEN !!!! SO NOW YOU HAD TWO 👹DEMONS😈 CONSPIRING WITH EACH OTHER !!! WHY WOULD STACEY STAY WITH DREW WHEN SHE KNEW HE WAS A KILLER !?!? SHE WAS NO DIFFERENT FROM HIM, BUT NOBODY TALKS ABOUT THIS because she's a WHITE GIRL !!!
This information would be a gift to those who loved the victims. Especially given some local law enforcement's threats to imprison anyone who retrieved a body found by searchers hired by Stacey's family. Criminal blue wall actions.
If Brodsky knew his client was guilty that's a sticky situation because he can not misrepresent or lie under oath. Meaning he can not lie in defense of a client's guilt to help him cover up a crime or get off..
Why is no one complaining about the people who sign settlement agreements, take money, and then sell their story again!!! Like Elon Musk's flight attendant. She got paid, and now she is in breach of her agreement, and sold the story again. This is a murderer, we deserve to know what happened. The client is not harmed, and the attorney can ease his conscience. Why should he live with another man's sins?
Gotta love other lawyers saying the disgusting thing is a lawyer possibly breaking the confidentiality of his client, when his client likely murdered two of his former wives. Lawyers are trash.
The difference between ethics in the legal sense, and morality. The ethics of the law protect attorney-client privilege; basic morality protects the victim and the victims family from being further damaged by the acts of a convicted murderer, and gives them & Stacy the dignity & peace of knowing what happened and where she is.
Wow! Just think about how many defense attorneys are walking around with the answers to the whereabouts of missing/murdered people. What a heavy, life threatening burden. Sleeping with one eye 👁️ open must be rough!
This is why I don't like lawyers - the jack ass at the end bitching about Peterson's former lawyer bringing some closure to a family and telling them the truth. The guy is a heartless murderder - I don't care about any damned attorney-client privilege.
Whatttt??.... okay first of all, the guy is no longer even a lawyer --- he's not trying to be a lawyer anymore --- in my opinion, not being able to reveal the truth isnt much different from tampering with evidence or lying to the police. If he knows where the body is and what happened to stacy, he needs to come out and say it (hopefully he isnt gonna say something like, she's in the pacific ocean which can never be verified)
I've always wondered what happened to Stacy and always wished her family could bury her and have a final resting place for her of their choosing. Does Joel have any daughters? If he did he would have already let that family have their peace. Tell Joel. Just do it. For the right reasons not the wrong ones.
I think he should do what he wants to do. And these three wives very pretty what are they doing with this guy something's wrong yet before the murders what are women that I would consider an eighth doing with the six minus no joke serious
🇺🇲 Stacy Peterson's whereabouts are more important than attorney client privilege in this instance! Illinois is the most corrupted state in the nation; the courts; the cops; the judges; the jails; the prisons; the parole boards; the legislature; the county seats; everything! Brodsky needs to reveal what he knows about Stacey! Drew Peterson already broke any rights he had to privileges, by getting a second conviction while incarcerated! WHERE IS STACEY? 😡
if this lawyer does indeed know, how can he NOT give those details to her poor family? Sounds to me, like he's a narcissist too like Drew. I am in shock hearing that. Imagine knowing somethig as monumental as that and not anonymously letting her family know. The deserve to know where she is and give her a proper respectful burial. Sick of these types of human. Its like instead of going to study to become a lawyer because you feel this inner passion to defend or prosecute people or become a doctor to help the sick doesnt exist. Its just, whatever career pays well and gains you status, so you enter that field. sad
This is messed up. There are people who know where Staceys body is and my gut tells me shes in a river . How long has she been missing??? This is the tip of the iceberg.
It’s not Attourney client privilege if the former attorney is not a current attorney! Drew never paid him, and he is saying screw you Drew, I’ll make money somehow! Interviews, books, etc….
I agree. He understands he was unprofessional, but others have done worse. Eff your law degree and help Stacy come home. Drew was a predator and there are exceptions to the rule. He will never get out of jail so who cares?
If you're not allowed to practice law for the rest of your life then I don't see what the problem is. Instead of doing interviews to feed your ego, simply say where in the hell the body is...
Why not send an anonymous letter of where she is
exactly. if this lawyer does indeed know, how can he NOT give those details to her poor family? Sounds to me, like hes a narcissist too like Drew. I am in shock hearing that.
@@BelfastManUtdTherapy I remember when they had a press conference at the beginning of Drew’s trial and they were all wearing sunglasses and joking about how she was living it up on a beach with another man. If he knew all that time what exactly happened to her, he is just as disgusting as Drew Peterson. Not to mention when he was also right by his side when they did a Win A Date With Drew contest.
@@wiccan3548 heya thanks for letting me know, bloody hell, a win a date with drew contest? Thats beyond sick.
would you risk going to jail for a few months to tell a person where another person is buried???
@michael-4k4000 Yes
Well, his comments leave no doubt that whatever Peterson told him led him to believe that Peterson is guilty. That's pretty telling right there.
Tell the public. Give those kids their mother to bury.
She’s probably out in large body of water….Lake Michigan perhaps
now watch him not tell. dont open up your mouth unless you intend on helping her family who are spending everyday in agony.
He needs to reveal what happened to Stacie because her family deserves to know
Give her back to her family.
I think the judge is full of Sh't!! Lawyers should be able to provide answers once their obligation to their client is over and will not change the outcome of appeals. The family has the right to get their loved one back. Drew already got his due course and more rights than Stacy ever had.
Everyone knows Drew Peterson did it anyway.
Can’t you at least tell Stacy’s family.
Joel a pariah? More like a bottom feeder. Probably looking to write a book. Joel you are almost 70 years old. Please draft 2 letters to the wives 2 and 3's families telling them what you know. Keep it in your safe to be read after you pass. Those families need to know what happened to their loved one, and Cassandra needs to know where her sister is.
*_I just said the same thing!! He looks up there in age.. Therefore he should tell the families something!!_* 🙏🏻
I think you made a boo boo. I think you may have meant wife 3 & 4.
You need to reread his story before it was his 3rd and 4th wife's
The attorney is awful. Just trying to make money off of the story. He could have anonymously told the families or law enforcement rather than do it this way.
This guy truly truly gave me the creeps. He has always made my stomach turn
The lawyer should have just not said anything and just for instance made an anonymous tip to the police
He’s too arrogant for that. He wants the spotlight.
Or he really doesn't know anything. Anyways, if what his says is true and he knows all this information, I'm pretty sure client attorney privilege doesn't apply. At least to the extent that he cannot knowingly let his client perjure himself.
What he can and should of done is contact the ethics board and discuss it with them. They can tell him what to do. CYA
Attorney-client privilege most certainly applies. You can know you client is guilty but if you allow them to testify and lie then you're in trouble. Which is why most defendants don't testify. So yes you're right you can't allow your client to perjure themselves but the way around that is to not allow them to testify. Also, if you're client revealed to you that they are in fact guilty you cannot then tell the world years later and inform everyone of what he/she revealed to you. That is a breach of the privilege between attorney and client. The client forfeit the privilege and start telling people what he/she disclosed to the attorney and then the attorney can discuss it but if the client doesn't forfeit it then the attorney is bound by the privilege of attorney and client and cannot reveal that information.
@@CommentsAllowed you a lawyer?😅😅
I don't really think he knows what happened to Stacy. Why would Drew tell him the truth? Drew doesn't know how to do that
Ethics vs morals
He actually has a good point that the other crooked attorneys got to keep their license so he should keep his and how about the crooked wife knowing her own husband should be disbarred and isn't, why is she still on the bench? Are they elected or is there no peer judicial review of personal conduct and double standard codes? Why aren't they given the same sanctions?
I AGREE! They're all corrupt.
Because there's two justice systems in this country. One for us and one for the elites.
So many politicians are corrupt these days! The system is broken. Before Nancy Pelosi retired, she and her husband were well known insider trading monsters. That's how she amassed a $200 MILLION fortune on her $196k per year former speaker salary, and now she gets a huge salary and benefits for life. There is no way anyone is that good at trading stocks. Give me a break. She is a thief and corrupt. Makes me so damn angry. This guy's license should be reinstated but if he blabs his client's secrets, then no. Attorney-client confidentiality is crucial to our justice system, even if it involves a scumbag like Drew.
@@MB-tb5vt Well said. Exactly!
The whole judicial system is corrupt, it's plain to see , look how they are bringing false charges on Donald Trump for a political witch hunt to manipulate his run for a second Presidential term even though the majority of Americans want TRUMP for president, look what there doings to him ,all controled by the democRATS, FJB !
TRUMP the real ( Mvp ) ...most valuable President !
MAGA 2024
That family deserves to know where she is after all these years of searching
Drew will never reveal anything because he's NOT a man. He said Stacy abandoned her children, ran off with another man, took her bikini and is dancing somewhere. So stupid and insulting. This lawyer should do the right thing, even if it breaks law doctrine and help give closure to the families.
Narcissistic cop if there ever was one !
Attorney Client Privilege would be broken
Did you not understand that he doesn’t think he’ll be able to practice law again anyway. The worst that will happen is a permanent disbarment.
Yes, where is Stacy???
STACYS BODY HAS BEEN FOUND BUT THE COPS DO NOT CARE
TELL! TELL! TELL! TELL!
He must be broke
Its called black balled
These people have the audacity to judge each other and talk about trust. SMH! They are the biggest crooks! This guy knows the truth therefore don't want to continue practicing law.
But like he said, who cares, do the right thing and tell where her body (or all of their bodies) are!
4:21 Than do it or shut up about it!! Keeping a family hanging after all they have been through wanting answers is cruel & indignant..Did someone say Air time money at the expense of heartbroken family members???😢
That's crazy but what's even crazier...i actually believe him. I think he really has a guilty conscience about what he knows and just can't live with regrets anymore. He maybe a little bitter about dome stuff in his career but I do believe he knows what to Lacy and that Drew Peterson was responsible for it.
Actually, Lacey was killed by Scott Peterson. Drew killed many wives.
He'll tell in a tell-all book for money
I pray he does the right thing, the right thing over powers any law or anything else.
Closure possibly. The damage is done. Cannot bring them back.
Why is it the "ultimate treachery" or "despicable" for a lawyer to tell the truth about where a man buried his wife, but it's ok to kill his wife in the first place?
What do you call two lawyers chained to the bottom of the sea?
ANS: A🐟🐟GOOD🐟🐟START.🐟🐟🐟🐟🐟🐟🐟🦀🦀🦀🐡🐠🐟🐙
he should tell everything. The kids, family, and friends of those women deserve to know the truth. Drew is a coward.
Client confidentiality ?
That excitement is only in movies. Dont trust priests, cops, lawyers , judges,, noo body
THE BLUE WALL OF SILENCE PROTECTS THE BROTHERS AND SISTERS IN BLUE!!!
Doesn't he have a moral obligation to tell, if he truly knows WHERE she (Stacy) is?
A moral obligation to tell, and a legal obligation to keep his mouth shut. In such a conundrum, considering that he's over 70 years old and has lost his license to practice law, he should probably lean more towards his moral conscience than his legal ethics at this point. He won't hurt himself or anybody else with this information, but he will help Stacey's family.
@@JarethTheGoblinKingForever Jareth, he does not have a legal obligation to stay quiet once a client accuses him of ineffective council.
He pointed this out to the judge.
The judge told him he has a good point.
But he had to wait until Drew Peterson
appeal is over.
Now there's a gag order.
He should be patient.
Drew P. did not see this coming.
Another murder charge.
He thinks it’s Despicable ….. does he also agree the lawyer losing his licence was despicable?
This would be good him revealing. I’ve always been wanting to know the truth hopefully it’s the full truth. Stacy deserves the Justice and her story being told proper burial for her children and her family and friends ❤️God bless Kathy and Stacy they are both angels 😇
DON'T FORGET THAT STACEY COVERED FOR HIM WHEN SHE KNEW WHAT HE DID TO KATHLEEN !!!! SO NOW YOU HAD TWO 👹DEMONS😈 CONSPIRING WITH EACH OTHER !!! WHY WOULD STACEY STAY WITH DREW WHEN SHE KNEW HE WAS A KILLER !?!? SHE WAS NO DIFFERENT FROM HIM, BUT NOBODY TALKS ABOUT THIS because she's a WHITE GIRL !!!
This information would be a gift to those who loved the victims.
Especially given some local law enforcement's threats to imprison anyone who retrieved a body found by searchers hired by Stacey's family. Criminal blue wall actions.
If you're a lawyer and you have any common sense you wouldn't have even talked about this
You seem like a lawyer who cares a great deal about what I have no idea
He should TALK!!!!!!
Just another slimey defense attorney.
Joel has always been a punk attorney. He should never get his law license back.
The lawyer needs a touch up
Let him talk up!!
If Brodsky knew his client was guilty that's a sticky situation because he can not misrepresent or lie under oath. Meaning he can not lie in defense of a client's guilt to help him cover up a crime or get off..
of course he knew that's why Lawyers are called LIARS
He should but he won't reveal..
Book deal coming?
Is it despicable to keep a family from getting closure.
Why is no one complaining about the people who sign settlement agreements, take money, and then sell their story again!!! Like Elon Musk's flight attendant. She got paid, and now she is in breach of her agreement, and sold the story again. This is a murderer, we deserve to know what happened. The client is not harmed, and the attorney can ease his conscience. Why should he live with another man's sins?
LAWYERS ARE LOWER ON LIFE'S TOTEM POLE THEN CAR SALESMEN AND HOOKERS.
Under a house or building I bet.
This attorney is a bottom feeder. He should never be allowed to represent a person again. He is awful.
Gotta love other lawyers saying the disgusting thing is a lawyer possibly breaking the confidentiality of his client, when his client likely murdered two of his former wives. Lawyers are trash.
He never spilled the beans!!!
The difference between ethics in the legal sense, and morality. The ethics of the law protect attorney-client privilege; basic morality protects the victim and the victims family from being further damaged by the acts of a convicted murderer, and gives them & Stacy the dignity & peace of knowing what happened and where she is.
Drew said that Stacy is laying on a beach somewhere....
He did?
@@Powertec-gi2hn Yes, she left Drew. Drew is a "left man". And she's dating what's his name and living it up on a beach partying.
The Judicial System is broken.
Broadsky looks like 🎅
Wow! Just think about how many defense attorneys are walking around with the answers to the whereabouts of missing/murdered people.
What a heavy, life threatening burden. Sleeping with one eye 👁️ open must be rough!
He could call a hot line and disclose where the body is. No name necessary on those lines.
This is why I don't like lawyers - the jack ass at the end bitching about Peterson's former lawyer bringing some closure to a family and telling them the truth. The guy is a heartless murderder - I don't care about any damned attorney-client privilege.
2024. Well…?
Brodsky is lying....again.
If he’s deciding to not reinstate his law license, then he should absolutely tell where Stacey is.
OMG tell us where Stacy is
. Who cares about Drew
This man knew his client was guilty. The entire force knew the guy was guilty. The system is trash.
Whatttt??.... okay first of all, the guy is no longer even a lawyer --- he's not trying to be a lawyer anymore --- in my opinion, not being able to reveal the truth isnt much different from tampering with evidence or lying to the police. If he knows where the body is and what happened to stacy, he needs to come out and say it (hopefully he isnt gonna say something like, she's in the pacific ocean which can never be verified)
In Illinois it's not who you know it's who you low.
I've always wondered what happened to Stacy and always wished her family could bury her and have a final resting place for her of their choosing. Does Joel have any daughters? If he did he would have already let that family have their peace. Tell Joel. Just do it. For the right reasons not the wrong ones.
Tell me you’re a narcissist without telling me
Its all good man!
This is bull, if he says he knows everything, then he should tell where the body is!
I think he should do what he wants to do. And these three wives very pretty what are they doing with this guy something's wrong yet before the murders what are women that I would consider an eighth doing with the six minus no joke serious
🇺🇲
Stacy Peterson's whereabouts are more important than attorney client privilege in this instance!
Illinois is the most corrupted state in the nation; the courts; the cops; the judges; the jails; the prisons; the parole boards; the legislature; the county seats; everything!
Brodsky needs to reveal what he knows about Stacey!
Drew Peterson already broke any rights he had to privileges, by getting a second conviction while incarcerated!
WHERE
IS
STACEY? 😡
if this lawyer does indeed know, how can he NOT give those details to her poor family? Sounds to me, like he's a narcissist too like Drew. I am in shock hearing that. Imagine knowing somethig as monumental as that and not anonymously letting her family know. The deserve to know where she is and give her a proper respectful burial. Sick of these types of human. Its like instead of going to study to become a lawyer because you feel this inner passion to defend or prosecute people or become a doctor to help the sick doesnt exist. Its just, whatever career pays well and gains you status, so you enter that field. sad
He may have broken that trust but he's definitely correct about the "dirty profession" ....
This is inappropriate....you were his lawyer and should shutup....
But what if it's the kind of information that should not ever be privileged? How do you make becoming an accessory after the fact ethical?
She’s not living give her back to her family ❤
This is messed up. There are people who know where Staceys body is and my gut tells me shes in a river . How long has she been missing??? This is the tip of the iceberg.
In Illinois it is absolutely about who you know/pay off. It is the reason Drew got to a third wife- to begin with.
It’s not Attourney client privilege if the former attorney is not a current attorney! Drew never paid him, and he is saying screw you Drew, I’ll make money somehow! Interviews, books, etc….
Peterson is, or at least was, arrogantly self-confident, a textbook example of Dunning-Kruger Effect. May he never get out.
Time to repent
Amazing a profession that has no ethics or morals, has censured a defense attorney.
Hey he has a conscience, if he knows what happened and he can’t practice law then give the family peace.
I agree. He understands he was unprofessional, but others have done worse. Eff your law degree and help Stacy come home. Drew was a predator and there are exceptions to the rule. He will never get out of jail so who cares?
If you're not allowed to practice law for the rest of your life then I don't see what the problem is. Instead of doing interviews to feed your ego, simply say where in the hell the body is...
Just let it out before he gets whacked. He just looking for attention for some type of big offer for his exclusive interview.
Good he should . Why should he keep it bottled up
Where is the body?
Brodsky is what is wrong with the system.
Wow he even sounds like Peterson when he speaks!
Let Drew Peterson go. Innocent. Give him $ 50 millions check. No video no proof.
Learn from Sayed Adnan case in Baltimore Maryland 😅
Politics.
He probably wants to write a book,how much you wanna bet
He knows nothing…..otherwise he would have come forward.