Love the first question - that fellow who asked, also has a well-toned speaking voice. I'm not sure if he answered his own question, or not - but, if so: kudos to him !! Even Wynton, who seemed a little lost for words at that moment, couldn't top that young fellow's conclusion. The "Philosophy of Jazz" - that was a gem ! Nicely summarised ;))
@@chasefreak That's kinda my point: Miles rebuked Wynton for inviting himself onto the stage with him - you know, for not exercising some of the kind of 'self-discipline' Wynton's talking about here.
Very meta - reminds me of a movie where students need to write an essay where the subject is 'what is risk?' One student hands in his copy which has only one sentence: "Risk is this!". He gets an A+
@@johnsuggs7828 Question (after WM has said they were done with Q&A): What do you think about self-discipline. Answer: Self-discipline, among other things, means stopping when it's time to stop. An answer that's pertinent both to the young man and to the jazz musician full of himself and wanting to stretch his solo beyond the agreed on limits. Then, generously, WM gives other examples of what self-discipline involves (forcing yourself to learn how to play slow, etc.). Seems plain enough. I guess you only hear as answers the answers you're looking for, which is a great example of lack of self-discipline (which can include accepting answers you don't like, as well as accepting time limits in q&a and in music). Now, let's see how much self-discipline you can show in your reply. Snarky reply--lack of self-discipline. You're right, my bad, I missed it--laudable self-discipline. What do you got?
He sarcastically criticised the student for asking him this question. If that doesn't come from frustration then what is your explanation for why he gave such a tetchy and rude answer?
![AUDIATION [excerpt]: the fundamental music skill no one understands](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Y--4IHz2Njc/mqdefault.jpg)
I've always admired the no-nonsense candor of the Wynton and Branford Marsalis.
that was perfect there is nothing wrong with this at all
Love the first question - that fellow who asked, also has a well-toned speaking voice. I'm not sure if he answered his own question, or not - but, if so: kudos to him !! Even Wynton, who seemed a little lost for words at that moment, couldn't top that young fellow's conclusion. The "Philosophy of Jazz" - that was a gem ! Nicely summarised ;))
That was a great answer to gave.
Public humiliation is always the way to go when dealing with eager young minds.
“Wynton roasts kid but also answers his question”
"Wynton roasts eager kid but finds a way to cover it up"
Ouch!
😭
I wonder if it was Miles Davis who taught Marsalis all about 'self-discipline'?
No, it was Wynton's father, Ellis. Miles didn't care for Wynton
@@chasefreak That's kinda my point: Miles rebuked Wynton for inviting himself onto the stage with him - you know, for not exercising some of the kind of 'self-discipline' Wynton's talking about here.
@@hilariousname6826 it’s ironic
@@chasefreak Exactly.
Decent English is "Wynton Gets FRUSTRATED at Student's Question About Self-Discipline".
😬
Very meta - reminds me of a movie where students need to write an essay where the subject is 'what is risk?' One student hands in his copy which has only one sentence: "Risk is this!". He gets an A+
Just answer the question
He did. Guess you missed it.
@@KH-no7ph didn't miss anything. I guess you accepted anything as an answer
@@johnsuggs7828 Question (after WM has said they were done with Q&A): What do you think about self-discipline. Answer: Self-discipline, among other things, means stopping when it's time to stop. An answer that's pertinent both to the young man and to the jazz musician full of himself and wanting to stretch his solo beyond the agreed on limits. Then, generously, WM gives other examples of what self-discipline involves (forcing yourself to learn how to play slow, etc.). Seems plain enough. I guess you only hear as answers the answers you're looking for, which is a great example of lack of self-discipline (which can include accepting answers you don't like, as well as accepting time limits in q&a and in music). Now, let's see how much self-discipline you can show in your reply. Snarky reply--lack of self-discipline. You're right, my bad, I missed it--laudable self-discipline. What do you got?
@@KH-no7ph ok
@@johnsuggs7828
Wynton wasn't at all frustrated. Stop posting clickbait titles.
He sarcastically criticised the student for asking him this question. If that doesn't come from frustration then what is your explanation for why he gave such a tetchy and rude answer?
@@williamrowley202 Thank you.
Bullshit click bait.