Your correct because on my career mode in done a stand tackle with Hector Bellerin in the penalty box and I didn't touch him and it counted as a FLIPPPPING PENALTYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Alex 1999 no it’s not you tool if it was thdt then how does gorilla get better skill points when he plays most his games on Sunday than people who play all 40 games Friday
jml 1877 He doesn't play all 40 on Sunday, though, does he? Even if did you play all 40 on Sunday, you'd still get skill points, just slightly less. Skill points are normally split up by a couple hundred at most, in fact, usually tens split 2 people apart in the top 100, so the gap really isn't all that conspicuous.
Yeah if it’s under 3 goals but what happens if you over 3 goals up and then they rage quit? Say 5-0 up in the 80th and they disconnect of crack the poos
I cant gain EASFC level. Me and a lot of other people have this problem. Its been 2 month and nothing got fixed. We have a post on the official Forum but they just dont care. Will never be able to go above 50 players on the transfer market. Please like so Andy can see it and maybe EA lostens to him..
AJ3 one of the main issues for many is the time constraints average players have. 13 hours in one weekend is just too much for people who want to relax after work, finish tasks for school/uni and people might work on weekends too.
RF>CF and CF >LF (and vise versa) position change cards would really open the game up. You'd see more variations of players and a higher demand for position change cards.
Andy, this is a problem for weekend leaguers and the best players at the game, but for a lot of lower players the biggest problem is just stupid stuff like input delay and passes not going where they are aimed
I agree with you that match making needs looked at big time or at least explained better, pes did a system years ago where it had daily cups based on your division rank which had a weekly cut off point and then an open cup with no rank, surely something like that could be worked out and as you say champs could run week to week with a cut off point ?
Acceleration and Sprint speed are not weighed equally. I believe Accel. is weighted at 45% of pace, while Sprint speed is at 55%. Therefore, the weightier stat being lower, you round down. If it was 86 Accel. and 87 sprint speed, overall pace would be rounded up because the weightier stat would be higher.
The odds that a top 100 player search at the same time as a player who has a similar record are so slim because there are so many fut champs player and only a small % have a elite 1 to top 100 record and the odds at they search at the same 5 seconds are very slim
Great video mate, keep up the awesome work on the channel. I'm a bit crap at FIFA so I make football vlogs instead. What team do you support? Maybe I should do a vlog there?
Hey AJ, And this is for Tass also! I watch all your videos and one problem with Fifa is Delay/lag a.k.a latency issues! I was with Sky and it was awful :-( I had ports open and did all I could do to solve lag, I spent all last year learning about the Internet and ports and DNS servers etc... So I know a lad who I became friends with last Fifa and he had a mega team and I beat him with a good ish team in Div 1 and he messaged me and I asked him if he gets lag/delay/latency issues and he said no! He is in the top 10 at the moment for qualification and he lives in Cornwall and said he was with BT and his game play is fine. So in January I moved to BT (I could be an elite player easily and I get Elite 1 in squad battles every week (just to let you know I'm okay at the game) but any tiny bit of latency issues and I can get beat of an average player, Well when your defenders don't challenge because the information is not coming through properly then I'm basically screwed :-( and I'm not talking peak time lag here, I'm talking all the frigging time, after many many many calls to Sky then BT and being stressed at why I can't play Fifa like all these TH-camrs I watch and pro players there was only Virgin left to try. So from 2 weeks ago I have 300mbs download and 21mbs upload and after alot of tinkering (manual I.P address, Ports open, Dmz open etc etc... And going from Gold 3 at a struggle with my best friend latency lag chewing on my back side. The weekend before last I was 15wins and 2 loss. At last :-) stil a bit of slow gameplay at times but my players did what I asked. But I couldn't play all my games as I work Friday and Sunday evenings. But I have learnt that the Internet structure is different in different places i.e cities will have better connection than Towns, also it depends how far away from the exchange, The DNS servers, EA servers etc.. etc... Now some people may think the game is different at times and that's how it is (yes Fifa is programmed like real football and shit happens) but there is a difference, For example, I have Chellini and he's stood right in front of and Attacker and doesn't challenge! Now the game might seem fine and some people may say Chellini is crap but that's not the Mechanics THAT'S LAG! I know exactly what my team can do and I could spot it if Neymar took a shit the wrong way (joke) yes I do have Neymar. There are many different types of lag :-( So how many people suffer from this because if you don't then you are already 50% ahead of the game. If pro players got what I got then no way could they win, this isn't real football, we can all only press a button to challenge no matter how good you are at Fifa... Which I know pro players are good. But my point is this, How many people win in FUT champs against people that had what I had???? Food for thought hey. And if you or anyone bothers to read all this and thinks I haven't got a clue what this guy is talking about then consider yourself lucky because you don't suffer from something that isn't your fault, I pay the same price as you guys, but your Pint of milk is full and my pint of milk from the same company is a quarter full. But explain that to them and all they say is "But your receiving your Mbs speeds" :-( put my bin on my head and run at the wall and knock myself out hey. Great videos by the way. Love squad builder showdown :-) you and Itani are funny "couple of interesting picks hey" don't I know it from service providers.....
I'm glad someone is actually talking about this. These devs have to change it to a normal competitive experience. But about rewards I would make everyone play 40 games at least a week to prove that they r still the quality that they were last week. If you don't play 40 u get nothing for that week, to prevent people placing elite week 1, then collecting totw packs for nothing. Seasons shall reset every month, and monthlies will be based on where you were for most of the month. This system is gaining a lot of momentum, and works way better. If not changed and it stays random, then see ya fifa 19 and the hundreds of dollars on fp
Oh and one last thing lmao, £250 pounds on Xbox One £50 for Fifa 18 £50 for Internet £30 for xbox live £ cost of electric etc... And I got lag :-( happy days hey, I knew I should of stuck to Monopoly £12.99 at Toys r Us! (Don't quote me on that!)
I'm quite new to fifa and fut champs. I have played all weekend leagues in FIFA 18 and I usually end up in Silver 2 Gold 3, and now two weeks ago I learned this to defend with its CDM / CM and now I get gold 1. It should definitely NOT be be like this. Really damn embarrassing by EA to call FIFA 18 "eSport ready", and lets not start off with kick off goals, refs blocking passes and claching with kits
Andy I hope you get this. I have been gold one 3 weekends in a row. This weekend I lost 15games in a row on the Saturday playing 5 top 100 players and I finished with 16/40 wins. This needs fixing so bad!
Matchmaking is very complicated at higher levels since there are few players queueing at any given time. Therefore, it is improbable that the matchmaker can produce fair games without making the queue times really long. With a really good matchmaker Fut champions players would probably have longer queue times and winrates closer to 50%. The amount of points you get would also be determined by how skilled your opponents are, instead of how many wins you get. This is the only way it could be fair
It's okay Andy you'll finish better one day, also I got 10/40 so I only finished what Silver 3 or bronze 1? That's when you really know the struggle I don't even know how I qualify tbh though.
Biggest issue is defending. People have literally given up trying to actually tackle and just stand there instead. Should’ve kept it the same as last year, with a little less AI help.
there are bigger issues. AI defending, no loss glitch, poor server quality, players backing out when they're not the home team, etc. i could name a few more but these came to me quickly. i'm a gold 1 or elite 3 player and i would be perfectly fine playing whoever i'm matched with as long as bigger, gameplay related issues are fixed.
Why shouldn't the pros play each other all the time? They are pros, it should be their job to play each other to see who is the best, not who will get the most gold player to beat.
The entire reason EA do fut champs is to find the best players to make their tournaments better. How would it work if Tass is playing Harry then Gorilla etc? It needs to be random.
Pace is Spint Speed x2 + Acceleration divided by 3. All stats are weighted differently into their overalls. EA don't release the formulas but some of them have been deduced.
It shouldn't be whoever is in the same division cuz it would make the top 75-100 level players not get top 100 cuz they're only playing better players so it's really unfair on them. Just cuz your mental thoughts ate it gets harder shouldn't mean pro plurs don't get top 100 cuz they're only playing better players than them
E.A should never release how matchmaking works, because people would just abuse it. If they said connection was priority number 1, then skill. People would make their connection really terrible in matchmaking, and then fix it during the game. Then the person on the other side would be sausaged with way worse connection (because it is a dedicated server, there is a ping both players, so 1 player can have 10ms ping and the other 200ms ping).
Apparently Pros conspire to wear a certain kit to avoid each other as it is the only info given before the game loads. So while Top 100 players might get matched against each other they back out because they see the agreed upon Kit. Why lose or potentially lose when you can avoid the top 100 and be Top 100 What most determines who you play is when you hit the search for a game button on your controller. If I'm 39-0 and your 0-39 and only us 2 are on, we are playing each other. Ideally in WL and Divisions you would play somebody in the same Division and same Elo Rating ( Skill point system used to help match players +100 win against bad player +1000 for win against good player ) and with no lag. But when given the opportunity between playing a perfectly matched opponent after waiting an hour or a gamble of who you'll play waiting 10 - 20 seconds, most will gamble. This is how FIFA matchmaking works.
I personally don't play fit champs. However my thoughts on the 'Skill rating' which is deciding who is top should consist of the Goal difference, average percentage of possession and shots on target etc.
Skill points is based on how fast you play your games. So the guy that is first of the 40-0 players played his games faster than the other 40-0 players
I've just packed messi it must have been a bug because things like that don't happen to me on Fifa, I score own goals when my player could clearly smash it away but don't hit it till it goes over the line
And just to add AJ after watching your video (which I thought you was spot on btw) EA is a business like any other business and is more interested in making money than sorting out their servers or making things fair! For example take little Johnny (made up character) who is 15 years old and has just learnt that Africa is a continent, If he plays Tass and Tass wipes the floor with him (which Tass will) and little Johnny who hasn't got a clue who he's playing thinks he's been beat by a guy who has better players than him so little Johnny spends his paper round money i.e £10 on packs and after 20 years may afford Pele (joke) after a couple of weeks or months if he gets lucky can maybe buy a mega team, what little Johnny doesn't realise is he could have the best team on the game and he will stil get smashed by Tass! Poor sod! But he will have put alot of early mornings in the freezing cold to get his players! And even then he won't win. But EA will be round the camp fire with Mr.Burns in Springfield talking about who is richer and how Homer is to fat! Hope you get the picture here. Don't mean to have a go at EA but very clever Marketing. I watched a video the other day on people getting huge players in 2 player packs, and not to my surprise one lad got Lukaku One to watch and stuff like that, the interesting thing was you could see their records and most of them had more losses than wins! So again at the camp fire with Mr.Burns they came up with the idea of, Hey let's give people who are not that good at the game better players in 2 player packs to make them excited and won't to play more (because let's face it loosing isn't fun) and they will buy more packs to do 2 player packs or spend money on a better team to match Lukaku one to watch, Very clever marketing wouldn't you say, now I'm not saying only bad players get good packs, Huge Gorilla packed Guillit (after spending £2,000 might I add! But there is a saying in life, you can't con a conner!!! You can't pull the wool over my eyes and I don't have any sheep as pets! So again food for thought hey! Just like apple, let's make a phone dearer than any other phone we can because we are greedy bas****ds and let's become the first trillion pound company hey, Actually come to think about it Mr.Burns did order 3 pizzas from Domino's and not 2....... (Mr.Burns from the Simmons incase any little Johnnys are reading) (a metaphor) ;-)
I just had an idea about how the skill rating works.. So basically for example Tass will be playing that gold 2 guy and because he was much higher rank then him Tass would get like 5 points to the skill rating board... if he would have played the MegaBit dude he would get 15 points for example Obviously I could be wrong but this seems logical to me Please leave your opinions here.Thanks
I understand most people's explanatorys off skill matching and individual skill rating in FUT champs but FUT champs is the best of the best so wouldn't you kind of expecting to come up against some of the best. However if this is not the case I don't understand it much and have not yet qualified for FUT champs
Your system would work, in my opinion, if you for example need to play a minimum of 30/40 games throughout the week. And than they take the average amount of skill points from all your games to make out what position you should be. Everyone who plays more games than 40 will get the opportunity to alter their average amount of points. But of course, it is not the player with the most games played that gets the most points. Because when you play more games, the average amount of points will stabilise. This way, you can slowly climb up the ladder and it won't come down to one loss or one victory. People will have the chance to play an extra 15 games to clear that 0-3 loss for example. And in the end, just like your overall w/d/l record, this will give a more accurate representation of your skill level. A silly bs loss than won't make the difference between a totw pack or not.
James Wagstaff I can see your point of view, just think that 40 games over 3 days is ridiculous enough, without having to always play against people the same level, I currently don’t see a huge problem because I comfortably get 25+ wins, some people are crap others are unplayable
I don't mind versing better players with the op teams , but its really annoying versing people against the super teams and the lag that comes with it. Its impossible to verse those teams...
The problem with your ladder system is in regions such as Australasia and North America you struggle to get the game normally which means you would have it wait like 1 hour 30 to get a game it just wouldn't work so that's my opinion
Artturi Laine maybe not a bad idea to be honest, like if it was set off a weekly basis than it gives rewards for playing the game basically like not everyone gets the chance for fut champs awards simply because they can't qualify or because they actually use the weekend to meet friends and go out and about so a weekly thing would allow these people to play their 20 or so games a week and the hardcore players can play their 100 games a week and get better awards etc.
we all know that ea will never do that. If EA has something that brings them more Money ofc they do that. I don't say that as a hater , is just a fact. like your vids :-D
it just shows that the match making is broken......it should just be people with the same rank prediction as you who you can be matched up against in weekend league, but top 100 should be a possible prediction
You want it like the fa cup where the small players get into the higher levels ( Knock out stages) and then move up but if they get a loss or something they stay with people that lost a that level
Of course the pros are going to come out and say this is fair, if they're true competitors then they should want to compete vs the best, not just dump on people trying to get to gold....
Would skill rating not mean the better higher ranked players you beat = higher skill rating . So #1 would mean he beat higher skilled players. Then you could argue well he had the chance to face them and you would be right.
I would love to see a Weekend League with only Bronze and Silver players so "mortal" players could have a minimum chance agains the pro players. Thoughts?
Parker Zavada so someone in bronze can play someone in elite? I’d rather have it be in the same rank like gold vs gold, but not to specific like a gold 3 has to play a gold 3
I am pretty sure match making matches you up against someone in a similar division e.g. someone in div 10-7 can only play people from div 10-7, then 6-4 and finally div 3-1 play each other. Then it depends on the win record with that certain squad and also the amount of games you have played in the weekend league. so 3 steps of match making are 1) Division 2) Record with squad 3) Amount of games in weekend league
I agree, in a system where a win vs a top 100 player is worth the same as a win vs a silver player matchmaking shouldn’t be very strict, i and I would think almost everyone would want is a ELO based system
I got 28-12 this week aswell and my player also scored an own goal but I got speed up and tried to clear it, so the GK just hit it in the back of the net.
Could the squad battles system they've developed be a test run for a future FUT champs system? Obviously they've tweaked it for use against the AI for now.
This is just a theory, but arent stats like composure and vision for the AI? For example, david silva controlled by the AI can make longer passes than maybe a random defender
THE BIGGEST ISSUE IS THAT THE GAME DOESN'T UNDERSTAND WHAT A FOUL IS AND ADAVANTAGE APPARENTLY LASTS FOR 1 SECOND😤
Lee Cohen the game has like a 99.99% foul judgement accuracy but the way EA animate the game makes it look like half the good tackles are fouls
handballs are not fouls in fifa
Hambomac 16 maybe but my player will get trucked and when my player challenges the AI and taps him, the ref calls a foul🤔
Lee Cohen yeah or that the referees don't know how the advantage rule works
Your correct because on my career mode in done a stand tackle with Hector Bellerin in the penalty box and I didn't touch him and it counted as a FLIPPPPING PENALTYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
How have you managed to make a 25 minute video talking about just you being bad...? huehuehuehue
To true hahaha
Reev yeah
REEV huehuehuehuehuehuehuehuehuehuehuehuehuehuehue
REEV squad builder showdown or checklist challenge will settle this
REEV has
Hater.
Tass need u back in #
sup Tass
Calm down Tass. Jk love your channel
He's a snake
Tass hold on a second ago this had 4 likes ???
Skill points is the same as points in Squad battles your skill points change with the amount of possession/shots on target/corners etc
James Wagstaff 100% this
Wrong. It's based around when you play your games. You get more skill points the earlier you play them.
Alex 1999 no it’s not you tool if it was thdt then how does gorilla get better skill points when he plays most his games on Sunday than people who play all 40 games Friday
James Wagstaff I’ve done and other people have done tests proving it
jml 1877 He doesn't play all 40 on Sunday, though, does he? Even if did you play all 40 on Sunday, you'd still get skill points, just slightly less. Skill points are normally split up by a couple hundred at most, in fact, usually tens split 2 people apart in the top 100, so the gap really isn't all that conspicuous.
The biggest flaw was the patches and how they ruined the game
wer kommt aus deutschland? 😂proownez❤😂
Dachte so: Lol :D
Dito.😂
????
Yes I can understand you
3 days without the rtg?!?!?!
David Harris exactly and he buys the option off camera. SMH
I think EA should do goal difference
Peter DiEgidio would be good but then rage quit games would determine the top 100 so I don’t think it would work. But still a good idea
russell strong 3-0 for a rage quit
Yeah if it’s under 3 goals but what happens if you over 3 goals up and then they rage quit? Say 5-0 up in the 80th and they disconnect of crack the poos
If it's lower than 3 goals and they rage quit it is 3-0 if they score more like 6-1 it should be 6-0
I like the FUT champs idea you came up with it would mean everyone got to play, had the time to play and it would make games fairer
Hi AJ3 im been watching your videos for ages and there really good
I cant gain EASFC level. Me and a lot of other people have this problem. Its been 2 month and nothing got fixed. We have a post on the official Forum but they just dont care. Will never be able to go above 50 players on the transfer market. Please like so Andy can see it and maybe EA lostens to him..
Same. I want to use loans that every one else used against me
ClaymoreLdr you have to play A LOT to gain a high level
But I can't gain ANY xp
Same here
Try winning seasons and play career mode
AJ3 one of the main issues for many is the time constraints average players have. 13 hours in one weekend is just too much for people who want to relax after work, finish tasks for school/uni and people might work on weekends too.
RF>CF and CF >LF (and vise versa) position change cards would really open the game up. You'd see more variations of players and a higher demand for position change cards.
Andy, this is a problem for weekend leaguers and the best players at the game, but for a lot of lower players the biggest problem is just stupid stuff like input delay and passes not going where they are aimed
I agree with you that match making needs looked at big time or at least explained better, pes did a system years ago where it had daily cups based on your division rank which had a weekly cut off point and then an open cup with no rank, surely something like that could be worked out and as you say champs could run week to week with a cut off point ?
eddduk yes
Hi aj3. It looks like the pros get an easy rider. I always thought the pros played elite level players and top 100. Grat vid
The biggest flaw in Andy's audio equipment is the microphone!
Acceleration and Sprint speed are not weighed equally. I believe Accel. is weighted at 45% of pace, while Sprint speed is at 55%. Therefore, the weightier stat being lower, you round down. If it was 86 Accel. and 87 sprint speed, overall pace would be rounded up because the weightier stat would be higher.
The odds that a top 100 player search at the same time as a player who has a similar record are so slim because there are so many fut champs player and only a small % have a elite 1 to top 100 record and the odds at they search at the same 5 seconds are very slim
Great video mate, keep up the awesome work on the channel. I'm a bit crap at FIFA so I make football vlogs instead. What team do you support? Maybe I should do a vlog there?
Hey AJ, And this is for Tass also! I watch all your videos and one problem with Fifa is Delay/lag a.k.a latency issues! I was with Sky and it was awful :-( I had ports open and did all I could do to solve lag, I spent all last year learning about the Internet and ports and DNS servers etc... So I know a lad who I became friends with last Fifa and he had a mega team and I beat him with a good ish team in Div 1 and he messaged me and I asked him if he gets lag/delay/latency issues and he said no! He is in the top 10 at the moment for qualification and he lives in Cornwall and said he was with BT and his game play is fine. So in January I moved to BT (I could be an elite player easily and I get Elite 1 in squad battles every week (just to let you know I'm okay at the game) but any tiny bit of latency issues and I can get beat of an average player, Well when your defenders don't challenge because the information is not coming through properly then I'm basically screwed :-( and I'm not talking peak time lag here, I'm talking all the frigging time, after many many many calls to Sky then BT and being stressed at why I can't play Fifa like all these TH-camrs I watch and pro players there was only Virgin left to try. So from 2 weeks ago I have 300mbs download and 21mbs upload and after alot of tinkering (manual I.P address, Ports open, Dmz open etc etc... And going from Gold 3 at a struggle with my best friend latency lag chewing on my back side. The weekend before last I was 15wins and 2 loss. At last :-) stil a bit of slow gameplay at times but my players did what I asked. But I couldn't play all my games as I work Friday and Sunday evenings. But I have learnt that the Internet structure is different in different places i.e cities will have better connection than Towns, also it depends how far away from the exchange, The DNS servers, EA servers etc.. etc... Now some people may think the game is different at times and that's how it is (yes Fifa is programmed like real football and shit happens) but there is a difference, For example, I have Chellini and he's stood right in front of and Attacker and doesn't challenge! Now the game might seem fine and some people may say Chellini is crap but that's not the Mechanics THAT'S LAG! I know exactly what my team can do and I could spot it if Neymar took a shit the wrong way (joke) yes I do have Neymar. There are many different types of lag :-( So how many people suffer from this because if you don't then you are already 50% ahead of the game. If pro players got what I got then no way could they win, this isn't real football, we can all only press a button to challenge no matter how good you are at Fifa... Which I know pro players are good. But my point is this, How many people win in FUT champs against people that had what I had???? Food for thought hey. And if you or anyone bothers to read all this and thinks I haven't got a clue what this guy is talking about then consider yourself lucky because you don't suffer from something that isn't your fault, I pay the same price as you guys, but your Pint of milk is full and my pint of milk from the same company is a quarter full. But explain that to them and all they say is "But your receiving your Mbs speeds" :-( put my bin on my head and run at the wall and knock myself out hey. Great videos by the way. Love squad builder showdown :-) you and Itani are funny "couple of interesting picks hey" don't I know it from service providers.....
Ladder won't work because ranks aren't evenly spread. There is much less elite players than gold players. Top 100 guys would barely find a game.
I'm glad someone is actually talking about this. These devs have to change it to a normal competitive experience. But about rewards I would make everyone play 40 games at least a week to prove that they r still the quality that they were last week. If you don't play 40 u get nothing for that week, to prevent people placing elite week 1, then collecting totw packs for nothing. Seasons shall reset every month, and monthlies will be based on where you were for most of the month. This system is gaining a lot of momentum, and works way better. If not changed and it stays random, then see ya fifa 19 and the hundreds of dollars on fp
Christopher Mandras do you not realise that people have lives and cant always play 40 games of fifa in the span of one weekend?
Oh and one last thing lmao, £250 pounds on Xbox One £50 for Fifa 18 £50 for Internet £30 for xbox live £ cost of electric etc... And I got lag :-( happy days hey, I knew I should of stuck to Monopoly £12.99 at Toys r Us! (Don't quote me on that!)
I'm quite new to fifa and fut champs. I have played all weekend leagues in FIFA 18 and I usually end up in Silver 2 Gold 3, and now two weeks ago I learned this to defend with its CDM / CM and now I get gold 1. It should definitely NOT be be like this. Really damn embarrassing by EA to call FIFA 18 "eSport ready", and lets not start off with kick off goals, refs blocking passes and claching with kits
No good can come from EA telling us how they match games! It would just result in players exploiting it to try and get easier matchups
I can't help but feel the more challenging experience is to have random matchmaking, instead of just facing your own rank
Pro players always avoid eachother and mainly play home
Andy I hope you get this. I have been gold one 3 weekends in a row. This weekend I lost 15games in a row on the Saturday playing 5 top 100 players and I finished with 16/40 wins. This needs fixing so bad!
Matchmaking is very complicated at higher levels since there are few players queueing at any given time. Therefore, it is improbable that the matchmaker can produce fair games without making the queue times really long.
With a really good matchmaker Fut champions players would probably have longer queue times and winrates closer to 50%. The amount of points you get would also be determined by how skilled your opponents are, instead of how many wins you get. This is the only way it could be fair
The refs in this game are absolute garbage
It's okay Andy you'll finish better one day, also I got 10/40 so I only finished what Silver 3 or bronze 1? That's when you really know the struggle I don't even know how I qualify tbh though.
So true. Keep it up AJ3!!
Biggest issue is defending. People have literally given up trying to actually tackle and just stand there instead. Should’ve kept it the same as last year, with a little less AI help.
there are bigger issues. AI defending, no loss glitch, poor server quality, players backing out when they're not the home team, etc. i could name a few more but these came to me quickly. i'm a gold 1 or elite 3 player and i would be perfectly fine playing whoever i'm matched with as long as bigger, gameplay related issues are fixed.
inform Fellaini's pace makes no sense, 52 acceleration, 52 sprint speed and 53 pace
andy the matchmaking u just mentioned for league and overwatch is exactly how pro clubs matchmaking works so they can and should do this
The game has to match him against someone. If there aren't any better players he get matched against lower tier players.
Willz14 ikr.... it is what it is even in real life football teams play teams that are 2 divisions lower then them
Why shouldn't the pros play each other all the time? They are pros, it should be their job to play each other to see who is the best, not who will get the most gold player to beat.
The entire reason EA do fut champs is to find the best players to make their tournaments better. How would it work if Tass is playing Harry then Gorilla etc? It needs to be random.
Pace is Spint Speed x2 + Acceleration divided by 3. All stats are weighted differently into their overalls. EA don't release the formulas but some of them have been deduced.
It shouldn't be whoever is in the same division cuz it would make the top 75-100 level players not get top 100 cuz they're only playing better players so it's really unfair on them. Just cuz your mental thoughts ate it gets harder shouldn't mean pro plurs don't get top 100 cuz they're only playing better players than them
E.A should never release how matchmaking works, because people would just abuse it. If they said connection was priority number 1, then skill. People would make their connection really terrible in matchmaking, and then fix it during the game. Then the person on the other side would be sausaged with way worse connection (because it is a dedicated server, there is a ping both players, so 1 player can have 10ms ping and the other 200ms ping).
Brilliant idea about how the to revamp the matchmaking/leaderboard like league of legends or overwatch, props
Apparently Pros conspire to wear a certain kit to avoid each other as it is the only info given before the game loads. So while Top 100 players might get matched against each other they back out because they see the agreed upon Kit. Why lose or potentially lose when you can avoid the top 100 and be Top 100
What most determines who you play is when you hit the search for a game button on your controller. If I'm 39-0 and your 0-39 and only us 2 are on, we are playing each other. Ideally in WL and Divisions you would play somebody in the same Division and same Elo Rating ( Skill point system used to help match players +100 win against bad player +1000 for win against good player ) and with no lag. But when given the opportunity between playing a perfectly matched opponent after waiting an hour or a gamble of who you'll play waiting 10 - 20 seconds, most will gamble. This is how FIFA matchmaking works.
I personally don't play fit champs. However my thoughts on the 'Skill rating' which is deciding who is top should consist of the Goal difference, average percentage of possession and shots on target etc.
Andy has essentially taken 25 minutes to say that they should put the Squad Battles ranking system in FUT Champs.
I didn't understand shit
Nike892 Gaming ok
Watch your mouth
Skill points is based on how fast you play your games. So the guy that is first of the 40-0 players played his games faster than the other 40-0 players
I've just packed messi it must have been a bug because things like that don't happen to me on Fifa, I score own goals when my player could clearly smash it away but don't hit it till it goes over the line
Sprint speed 0.55
Acceleration 0.45
The system we have at the moment is flawed, a ladder system is the best way forward
How wrong you we´re when you thought Tass wouldn´t be offended by using him as an example! :D I think you have a fair point though!
I find Legendary to be a weird difficulty, one game I’ll win 7-0, the next I’ll lost by the same margin
If you only played people the same level as you, then everyone would get the same amount of wins
EA need to have player faces scanned/custom made. How does Casemiro, Carrasco, Asensio, Mertens, Dembele etc not have a generic face
I would have the ladder system restart each week
And just to add AJ after watching your video (which I thought you was spot on btw) EA is a business like any other business and is more interested in making money than sorting out their servers or making things fair! For example take little Johnny (made up character) who is 15 years old and has just learnt that Africa is a continent, If he plays Tass and Tass wipes the floor with him (which Tass will) and little Johnny who hasn't got a clue who he's playing thinks he's been beat by a guy who has better players than him so little Johnny spends his paper round money i.e £10 on packs and after 20 years may afford Pele (joke) after a couple of weeks or months if he gets lucky can maybe buy a mega team, what little Johnny doesn't realise is he could have the best team on the game and he will stil get smashed by Tass! Poor sod! But he will have put alot of early mornings in the freezing cold to get his players! And even then he won't win. But EA will be round the camp fire with Mr.Burns in Springfield talking about who is richer and how Homer is to fat! Hope you get the picture here. Don't mean to have a go at EA but very clever Marketing. I watched a video the other day on people getting huge players in 2 player packs, and not to my surprise one lad got Lukaku One to watch and stuff like that, the interesting thing was you could see their records and most of them had more losses than wins! So again at the camp fire with Mr.Burns they came up with the idea of, Hey let's give people who are not that good at the game better players in 2 player packs to make them excited and won't to play more (because let's face it loosing isn't fun) and they will buy more packs to do 2 player packs or spend money on a better team to match Lukaku one to watch, Very clever marketing wouldn't you say, now I'm not saying only bad players get good packs, Huge Gorilla packed Guillit (after spending £2,000 might I add! But there is a saying in life, you can't con a conner!!! You can't pull the wool over my eyes and I don't have any sheep as pets! So again food for thought hey! Just like apple, let's make a phone dearer than any other phone we can because we are greedy bas****ds and let's become the first trillion pound company hey, Actually come to think about it Mr.Burns did order 3 pizzas from Domino's and not 2....... (Mr.Burns from the Simmons incase any little Johnnys are reading) (a metaphor) ;-)
They should add the background Stadium to whatever you want, like FIFA 16.
I just had an idea about how the skill rating works.. So basically for example Tass will be playing that gold 2 guy and because he was much higher rank then him Tass would get like 5 points to the skill rating board... if he would have played the MegaBit dude he would get 15 points for example
Obviously I could be wrong but this seems logical to me
Please leave your opinions here.Thanks
Sick of packs robbing me of time and money thinking of giving up fut for ever
nobody forces you to play UT stop bitching sorry
Brian Seaton you are one poor Individual.... have a nice day
People aren’t all playing at the same time. You don’t want to sit for an hour waiting for another top player
Yes Andross
Couldn't agree more
I understand most people's explanatorys off skill matching and individual skill rating in FUT champs but FUT champs is the best of the best so wouldn't you kind of expecting to come up against some of the best. However if this is not the case I don't understand it much and have not yet qualified for FUT champs
Your system would work, in my opinion, if you for example need to play a minimum of 30/40 games throughout the week. And than they take the average amount of skill points from all your games to make out what position you should be. Everyone who plays more games than 40 will get the opportunity to alter their average amount of points. But of course, it is not the player with the most games played that gets the most points. Because when you play more games, the average amount of points will stabilise. This way, you can slowly climb up the ladder and it won't come down to one loss or one victory. People will have the chance to play an extra 15 games to clear that 0-3 loss for example. And in the end, just like your overall w/d/l record, this will give a more accurate representation of your skill level. A silly bs loss than won't make the difference between a totw pack or not.
They should use Swiss System to match making during WL. Same used in World Chess Tournaments.
Pros disagree because the systems in champs benefit them much more than what a working system would. It's so muh easier for them than it should be
Personally think weekend league is similar to FA cup, non league teams can come up against Manchester United, the gulf in class makes it interesting
James Wagstaff I can see your point of view, just think that 40 games over 3 days is ridiculous enough, without having to always play against people the same level, I currently don’t see a huge problem because I comfortably get 25+ wins, some people are crap others are unplayable
EA should do what they do in FIFA MOBILE vs attack mode. There they use the ladder system.
I don't mind versing better players with the op teams , but its really annoying versing people against the super teams and the lag that comes with it. Its impossible to verse those teams...
The problem with your ladder system is in regions such as Australasia and North America you struggle to get the game normally which means you would have it wait like 1 hour 30 to get a game it just wouldn't work so that's my opinion
I swear your solution is basically divisions with fut champs rewards
Flaws would that be bad?
Artturi Laine maybe not a bad idea to be honest, like if it was set off a weekly basis than it gives rewards for playing the game basically like not everyone gets the chance for fut champs awards simply because they can't qualify or because they actually use the weekend to meet friends and go out and about so a weekly thing would allow these people to play their 20 or so games a week and the hardcore players can play their 100 games a week and get better awards etc.
Hi Tass love your videos and andy
we all know that ea will never do that. If EA has something that brings them more Money ofc they do that. I don't say that as a hater , is just a fact. like your vids :-D
I can beat anyone in fifa and I can lose to anyone :/
Fut champs should have an ELO system like Overwatch
it just shows that the match making is broken......it should just be people with the same rank prediction as you who you can be matched up against in weekend league, but top 100 should be a possible prediction
You want it like the fa cup where the small players get into the higher levels ( Knock out stages) and then move up but if they get a loss or something they stay with people that lost a that level
Of course the pros are going to come out and say this is fair, if they're true competitors then they should want to compete vs the best, not just dump on people trying to get to gold....
Would skill rating not mean the better higher ranked players you beat = higher skill rating . So #1 would mean he beat higher skilled players. Then you could argue well he had the chance to face them and you would be right.
If you play all games at friday/saturday you would get more skill points than if you would play them saturday/sunday (explanation)
I would love to see a Weekend League with only Bronze and Silver players so "mortal" players could have a minimum chance agains the pro players. Thoughts?
andy isnt wrong here... cos that matchmaking right there is a shambles
I think match making should just be random so anyone can play against anyone
Parker Zavada so someone in bronze can play someone in elite? I’d rather have it be in the same rank like gold vs gold, but not to specific like a gold 3 has to play a gold 3
I am pretty sure match making matches you up against someone in a similar division e.g. someone in div 10-7 can only play people from div 10-7, then 6-4 and finally div 3-1 play each other. Then it depends on the win record with that certain squad and also the amount of games you have played in the weekend league.
so 3 steps of match making are
1) Division
2) Record with squad
3) Amount of games in weekend league
This is even worse than what we already have
I agree, in a system where a win vs a top 100 player is worth the same as a win vs a silver player matchmaking shouldn’t be very strict, i and I would think almost everyone would want is a ELO based system
Yeah
Squad Battles and Weekend League should have a points tally rather than number of wins like Seasons does. Just makes more sense.
That's what squad battles is tho dumdum 🤔
Lord Meme he means a win is 3 pts, a draw 1 pt, a loss 0
Unnamed User Then you wouldn't have to play on the difficult settings if you got 3 points for a win.
Lord Meme tell him that it's not my idea it's his
I agree but I think what your saying is divisions and depending on what division you’re in that’s the rewards you get.
Come on AJ how else will Pro Players go to the finals if they play each other? Of course they will get at least 15 "easy" games
Being through on goal going for a low driven and putting it about 10 years over the bar
proclubs you cant find a friendly without it breaking xD
It's common sense Andy, with the attribute details.
I got 28-12 this week aswell and my player also scored an own goal but I got speed up and tried to clear it, so the GK just hit it in the back of the net.
How many pro players are in the world? You can't expect them to only play each other in the weekend league. It would take them all day to find a game.
The biggest flaw in fifa 18 is that the AI is way to easy
Roses are red
Violets are blue
I hate fifa 18
And so do you
I was playing fut chaps and the keeper could of caught it easily but he decided to header it and scored own goal
It's 100% the inconsistencies in the game for me anyway
The biggest flaw is the defending is non existent
Could the squad battles system they've developed be a test run for a future FUT champs system? Obviously they've tweaked it for use against the AI for now.
This is just a theory, but arent stats like composure and vision for the AI? For example, david silva controlled by the AI can make longer passes than maybe a random defender
Hearthstone has similar ranked to Fifa should be like that