breaking down the hunger artist is ridiculous...It is a long and beautiful joke...SPOLIER ALERT the punch line (so to speak) and also climax or release, is when he says he couldn't find anything he likes to eat well enough.....the denouement is also of course obvious. But deconstructing it is totally useless and counter productive. Read it ....Listen to it......enjoy it. It is a beautiful and funny and uniquely illuminating story in way that the best art and literature often is and exactly in the way Kafka says it should be. More of a wedge with a little hanmer going tink tink tink until the ice splits rather than an axe but nevertheless......Don t ruin it by deconstructing it!
Isn't your comment also a deconstruction of the hunger artist? "The punch line" is xyz based on your interpretation. Seems hypocritical don't you think?
There is no simple "punch line" in Kafkas stories, that's just a shallow american interpretation. His stories are multifacetted and the point is that you can't just get an answer so easily. But one thing is right: The way this idiot tries to "deconstruct" Kafka('s stories) is ridiculous. "Deconstructing" things should have been outdated for people even in the 80's.
@@candide1065 There is a punch line in the hunger artist. A punch line is not an easy answer it's a point of release for a joke. But I'm guessing you didn't read what I wrote and probably haven't even read the hunger artist
Thank you for sharing these exceptional videos!
The lectures excellent. Amazing points he brings up, great critical breakdown of the Hunger Artist. very mind opening
That's great teacher right there, good content.. too bad school just sucks, now that I've graduated its easy to appreciate
This video is so underrated! THANK YOU!
Spending my Sunday enjoying this lecture. Thank you!
I had just listened to this story on Horrorbabble. Nice of youtube to show me this.
This is excellent... So glad that I found it... He's an amazing teacher...
Thank you professor
where exactly is this school man ? i need a teacher like thatt yepp
I wonder, too.
Me too
Wow , I wonder is it a school, academy or university the environment is amazing. Unlike my university which has only 50 minutes class.
Thank you!!!!
asks more questions than answers..
Asking good questions is just as important as having good answers.
I felt the story was a damp squib. perhaps that was K's point.
Stopped the video and disliked when the boomer guy started babbling about Marx, lol.
My kids can't read!
breaking down the hunger artist is ridiculous...It is a long and beautiful joke...SPOLIER ALERT the punch line (so to speak) and also climax or release, is when he says he couldn't find anything he likes to eat well enough.....the denouement is also of course obvious. But deconstructing it is totally useless and counter productive. Read it ....Listen to it......enjoy it. It is a beautiful and funny and uniquely illuminating story in way that the best art and literature often is and exactly in the way Kafka says it should be. More of a wedge with a little hanmer going tink tink tink until the ice splits rather than an axe but nevertheless......Don t ruin it by deconstructing it!
Isn't your comment also a deconstruction of the hunger artist? "The punch line" is xyz based on your interpretation. Seems hypocritical don't you think?
@@cubone44 No It isn't (it's a possible key) and no It's not and... you sir are a dingo
There is no simple "punch line" in Kafkas stories, that's just a shallow american interpretation. His stories are multifacetted and the point is that you can't just get an answer so easily.
But one thing is right: The way this idiot tries to "deconstruct" Kafka('s stories) is ridiculous. "Deconstructing" things should have been outdated for people even in the 80's.
@@candide1065 There is a punch line in the hunger artist. A punch line is not an easy answer it's a point of release for a joke. But I'm guessing you didn't read what I wrote and probably haven't even read the hunger artist