What most don’t accept is Modi is destiny’s child. Years of ignoring the docile majoritarian sentiments in the name of vote bank politics, political correctness was destroyed by one man. Love him, like him or hate him, you cannot ignore him.
right on...congress and the Gandhi's through their cronies both in govt (civil servants, award vapsi gang) and media have successfully created this notion of them being the torchbearer of secularism. 1st of all, the word secularism was shoved into constitution by Indira during her dictatorship (emergency) so, what moral authority this family or party has to talk about it. when i see commentators talking about congress being a secular party then 2 things come to mind a) they r conveniently being ignorant and b) that congress is nothing but a minority appeasement party. for a long period of time, every party other than BJP and Siv Sena (till last year) followed that path and that's the reason BJP got an opportunity to find space and huge vote base to be relevant by becoming a hindu nationalist party. politics is all about opportunism and Modi/Amit Shah/BJP have become very good at it. however, i think BJP/Modi's problem is that they are not as good as Congress and left at managing the narrative through their cronies in media and institutions. Congress has the lever because we still see their sympathizers everywhere in govt and institutions that they have curated for so long. unless, bjp does the same, they will always face the heat
The reason Indira Gandhi declared emergency is because of Allahabad high Court judgement. What was the judgement about? Apparently a magistrate erected a stage for her election campaign using public money. And for that offence, her election was nullified and then she was disqualified from standing years election for 6 years. If she was not disqualified for 6 years, there would not have been emergency. Now Modi party campigning every where using public money and the disaster releif fund. And no one has filed a complaint nor has the court taken so moto cognaizance. Indira was not aware the magistrate was using public money. Still she was held liable.
@@AsmaSohailMRTH while Bharka seems to be anti BJP, She also seems carry a chip on her shoulder against the congress party. I have seen her trying to belittle congress in many of her interviews .
@@Suresh_Kamath That could be true. I never thought of it that way. However, I do feel she is also a bit traumatised like Rajdeep Sardesai for being attacked strongly by the right wingers.
As a pm he try's this farmers law for a year....he is also a human.....by the way how many PM of India says sorry to his country people in past although in this country pm imposed emergency situation to this country people for secure her chair ....and in past many more incidents happen in this country like this....how many people bought to jail and how many people died please read about this incident from history.....
@@sangramdash9337 which PM made like this notebandi, no black money has come back, still BJP is hiding the list of people holding money in Swiss account, chowkshi all runway, new special plane which PM bought, new parliament new Palace new car BMW, Trump visit all money who wasted , fakir every day 5 dresses change, going on world tour, not a single official press conference in 7 years, every thing from Airport to Railways all good money making sold, which PM sold check.
Congress has ruled the country for most of the year post our independence. They have a powerful family that has practically created a narrative that gives an impression that only Gandhi family were responsible for India’ s freedom. It is almost like a monarch and RaGa is the prince who despite his inabilities is forced on people of India. They know that narrative created by them is not reality and if an opposition governments stays in power with absolute majority they will always fear being exposed. Congress would have been calmer if this was broken verdict. This is precisely the reasons they supported regional parties as they knew as long as people are divided they will find it easy to loot the country.
@@Bhooshanoo7 - They are not doing anything to provide an alternative to the current government. They themselves have reduced a national political party to a laughing stocks with jokers and clowns like rafool ghandy 😂😂 but chamchas lo like you continue to bootlick them. Shame on you
@@WorkWizdom uneducated, telling lies,from notebandi GST Trump new plane new Palace new parliament, corona mis handling, national property sold to corporate, from 15 lakhs to 2 crore jobs, not a single hospital school college jobs still u stand with this ,please my friend think twice.
@@WorkWizdom you are illiterate man ..can't you see 23 crore moved into poverty line ... 45 yr high unemployment and 80 crore given free ration gives support to my statement. ..Bangladesh having more per capita income then India ...which was about 55% of india speaks volume ...
@@WorkWizdom illiterate people like you don't know India has a population of 140 crore ...who will become PM ..is dependent on our democracy. ..you find only Gandhi family ..fact is its not necessary to have pm from Hindu belt ...shashi taroor can be ...an opportunity in 1977 led to maroaji desai being PM of india ..similarly VP SINGH ..Manmohan Singh ..etc complete list ..only dumb and illiterate like you vs modi vs whom ..it's democracy vs autocracy. ..etc ...
12 baje comment kiya tha kya?? Nehru parivar ka naam suna hai?? Manmohan Singh ko desh ki janta ne PM chuna tha ya Sonia Gandhi ne?? Can a non Gandhi become president of the party? Do some research first
OK guys,, let's have a debate between Christophe Jeffreylot versus Francois Gauthier. Christophe stayed outside India and analyzed India whereas Francois lived in India for decades and knows India.
And other leaders like - Boris Johnson, Erdogan, Imran Khan, Trump, Biden, Sonia G ( in fact all of them) - are not election oriented? What amazing "analysis" and conclusion from this writer!
The interview with the author Christophe has brought out the pros and cons of BJP regime under Modi in an unbiased manner. why such convincing political analytical work is not done by our own Indian authors?
As long as the people are controlled by the hampering factors such as religion, caste and creed while analysing the challenges concerning political social economic and religious issues objectively and logically with transparent mindedness, making our world's largest democracy more relevant,effective and successful will become a herculean task.
Chanced to listen it today only. Could see the signs of sorrow and disappointment on his face throughout as is common on the dispositions of Marxist -Liberal- Islamist apologists. Very very difficult for them to digest that Hindus could one day rise above their second class status to the level of equality with their pampered Muslim compatriots . Also Modi’s arrival on the scene saw the downfall of Khan Market crony intellectuals of Congress in India and abroad . It substantially affected the deep state formed earlier . Hence author’s worries are more about uprooting of about old deep state than forming of new one .
Nobody has given Hindus a second class status except for those people who suffer from an inferiority complex . The haters like Modi RSS VHP and the gang of 4 Gujarati's.
@@johnfaith9486 there are no ideal country . We have to imbibe good qualities from several countries . Like rule of law . Complete absence of communal riots and lynching should be learned from middle east . Liberal values and democratic sprite from West. High growth rate and plural peaceful structure to be copied from East Asia like Indonesia Malaysia Thailand Singapore etc
What an absolute ausum IAS level discussion Below points were ausum : 1) Using radio to communicate in Saintly voice 2) Welfarism as dignity 3) Netanyahu and Erdogan example 4) How will Bjp sustain post Modi Feeling Blessed to witness such high quality discussion 🎓S off to d Author🙏
If you look up to the IAS as something worthy of emulation, you are sadly mistaken. They are the reason why India is still a 3rd world country, along with the our Indian political class, of course.
Wow... IAS level talk.... From where do you get such terms.... You people are from different breed.... Now we need author like Barkha dutt who is responsible for death of so many soldiers.... She did all that for her publicity and now after being sidelined by her own media house.... Somehow still looking for relevance
If and when any groups population is greater than 5%, we should not give minority status. We made a big mistake and are reaping the consequences. There is more trouble to come.
The author Christophe is a French national...he knows a lot about and has experience with North African and other muslims.... including how tolerant they are, do not behead people for cartoons... do not kill old Jewish woman in homes and market place...and these two jokers are deciding what's good and bad in India under Modi...
In Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan minority Hindus, Sikhs and Christians are very rich enjoying and living very happily under peaceful hightech Sharia law
He is atleast right in his approach, equally criticizes Pakistan, Turkey as well. Notice how Burkha Dutt was diverting whenever he mention these countries, saying those countries are different (as if they are entitled to it and right if they do it).
Atrocities on minorities in those countries, at par with Hitler's ethnic cleansing. I hope he realises and alerts his countrymen to take necessary action against growing terrorist menace in France. France drafted strict laws recently to counter them. if India adopts these laws, there will be big hue and cry from media, foreign journalists immediately jump marking them as draconian laws , beating their chests and another Mojo interview will follow... Nowadays if we write anything, against India, against our PM, our religion, beat our chests about minorities (be careful here, you should not mention about ethnic cleansing of Kashmiri Pundits) we will get immediate recognition, we will join the ranks of intelligentia, who knows we might get some journalism award from leftist ilk. Our media has lot many Quislings and need very little foreign assistance to write against our nation.
Sudhir Nair, Yes! they do enjoy a peaceful life in Pakistan. And No! there is no Sharia law in Pakistan. See Pakistan or any other Muslim country can never claim that unfortunate incidents wouldn't have happened regarding communal issues BUT the people in government and political leaders acknowledge those incidents as UNFORTUNATE events and are first ones to condemn it and discourage any motivation around it. On the contrary, in India, the communal violence is gaslit and motivated by the BJP-RSS leaders who form the government in India right now. The hate speaches made by Mr.Subrimanyam and Amit Shah like leaders, become the reason behind the mob lynchings, harrasments and all the sorts of communal violence. Also the mainstream Indian media misinformation to the common people is being spoonfed-which is solely intended to hate muslims and sikhs and to produce sommunal divide. These accumulative measures have lead to state sponsored violence against Muslims in particular. Stripping off acrticle 370 in Kashmir while house arresting all Kashmiri leaders and turning Kashmir into a jail in itself was a huge uncalled for act. The riots in Gujrat, the mass massacre was an uncalled for act, the beef ban was an uncalled for act, the NRC, CAA was an uncalled for act, the JNU attack was an uncalled for act, the arrest of Aryan Khan was an uncalled for act and all of these anti-muslim acts were government lead and state lead. The media isn't independant anymore so the truth is brushed under the carpet and only propagates the narrative of the BJP. Also the media is being used by the govt to propagate hate against muslims into the hearts of a common man. This culture of killings, harrassment and abuse by BJP workers on muslims in incidents where they beat them to their deaths because the muslim wouldn't chant wande mataram or Jai shiri ram is very evidently govt supported. So yes unfortunate incidents happen in Pakistan too but they are only unfortunate and incidents, not state or govt sponsored like in India.
Excellent talk, the author has excellent knowledge of Indian politics, he is candid n honest in his conclusions on Modi’s personality traits, I wish to read the whole content of this book.
'Kya se kya ho gaya.....tumhare pyar me'...Once Barkha used to interfere in cabinet reshuffling Cabinet in Manmohan- Soniya regime....now she is depended only TH-cam 😉😉😉
Bharkha madam, can you please do a discussion once “what’s wrong with Nationalism when you are surrounded with nations who wants to capture what ever possible “
India is the best country to live for all communities and all are given equal opportunities The minorities are portrayed as deprived lot and they play the victim card world over They have given opportunities for the last 70 years but are carried away the action of their religions leader Most people including you got have got it wrong CAA is giving citizenship to 30 k people who are already living in India Hindus at some point of time under Sonia Gandhi leadership felt left out and they have shifted their loyalty to Modi
woh toh sab politicians hote hai. Agar Rahul PM hote toh bhi woh politics hi karte. Opposition mei rehke mudde uthana jyada aasaan hai. PM ki kursi sahi maine mein kaanton ka taaj hai.
True the position of PM is not for everyone.But functioning of the PM is between election to election without taking into account the harsh reality that is what I mean.only intention is winning the election at any cost.
India have divided to Modi and Anti modi. It's spread out the every sector. Arthashastra of Chanakya said that even if the opposite slogan comes from outside or inside nation more and more then note that national leader have on the right way of ruling, That national leader of that nation have to go forward on straight line or way of the progress of the nation not mind it slogans of opposition. Modified India is the current trend of nation.
Bhai, he gave up all that for simple, minimum clothes. Current people have only changed their designer - from western styled clothes to Indian styled clothes. They are expensive all the same
Is that wearing good clothes makes a rich person ? This is what your QURAN teaches you , how to degrade and how to is materialistically You should hsil your TALUBAN KHAN and yoyr country enjoying with TERRORISTS
There may be hours and hours of discussions, analysis etc. on Modi...... but I think that the Modi juggernaut will roll on..... His intentions & vision for Bharat, his honesty, his personality, his self confidence, his charisma, his leadership etc. are simply awesome! There was no Indian leader like him in the past........ Also, the elite slaves of the Nehruvian-Maxist line of thought, who this far were in the limelight are now a worried lot in our country...... all of them are in panic..... I look forward, among other things, to our Bharat's history being put in its proper perspective and our Constitution (which presently reflects a strong colonial influence) being relooked for appropriate indigenization in line with our glorious Indic/vedic civilizational values......
@@ajayjain9207 did you?? By seeing your comment, I don't think you lost ability.. correct?? Or is it like that family members saying before 2014 my son IQ level ability was good and after 2014, my son lost?? Is this?? Or we just made our perception??
Theoretically n practically in both terms, writer has left mindset...how he says, minority in india is denied very basic rights to education, job eyc...rubbish
This guy has a biased view towards BJP and Modi... no wonder he is trying to equate India and Israel... there too many differences on different levels... clearly this gentleman has a one dimensional view and lacks the other facets/point of views...
@@Bhooshanoo7 Israel is a country with much less diversity & population equal to a small state of India...They can've direct democracy with astounding technological achievements...India'll need many more years to mature as a democratic nation where only about 20 families & their members control the political power corridors...
Mam u need to translate the conversation between u and Mr Christophe Jaffrelot becoz Andbhakts r striking their heads against the Feku walls as they r not able to get it 😁😁😁😁😁😁
What ever your book has to say but the people of India knows our PM Modiji is the best PM India ever had. Many people are envying him, or jealous of him because they couldn't do what he is doing for India. So no matter what you or Barkha says will not make any difference... . .God bless you protect our Modiji. Jai Hind.
A new awakening is taking place ; Modi could not have arrived too soon ; Hinduism is not a religion but a culture, a way of living and thinking without any dogmas or belief systems, where one can get logical answers for both the mundane and the spiritual ; people are beginning to think for themselves like never before and they want logical answers and in a couple of decades, most scriptures would collapse unable to answer the inquiring minds ! The world needs Hindu culture more than ever before to bring in the much needed sanity to allow the world to live like one family !
that is what the islamo fascist / marxist / christian evangelist alliance is so worried about. how will they make their living in india peddling their lies ?
I have worked in multiple companies... I don't see any description in job interview or selection... Also, I have seen a lot of Muslim in government job... and I couldn't see any discrimination there... even in my heart and mind.... where is discrimination in propaganda? with some extremist on both side?...
"Jaffrelot - based on the research and understanding of Indian society and politics - predicted that the Hindu nationalist ideology-based Bharatiya Janata Party will not be able to win general elections and form the central government, a prediction that proved to be incorrect to Jaffrelot's misfortune. " Walter Anderson
That’s because Jaf didn’t take EVM manipulation into account: the bamman - Bania cabal cutting across all political parties had conspired to get Modi elected way back in 2011-12 ….these foreign journos are ridiculously unaware about the caste-dynamics in Indian politics …
Modi's India is the most peaceful INDIA. Till Modi was elected as Priminister nearly for 70 years every month there would be hundreds of Pakistan sponcered violence in the country as though it is part of five year plan . But from last seven years the miscreants are keeping quiet . The very name Modi works as deterrent for Anarchist mob. As for the development, in 1947 British colonizers left India after handing over ruling authority to Nehru family. The family took it as a gift and enjoyed the position as other Rajas and Maharajas. As such there was less scope and little time for development. Whatever development works happened during that time did happened inspite of the ruling family ,rather because of them. But it is natural for family loyalists to shout " BHO PARAK " of Nehru family.
HI Barkha, please use a standard (35mm) lens, if you are using full frame camera to broadcast. the wide angle you are using giving a distorted look of you, which is visually incorrect. or sit little further back from the lens.
Muslims don't have access to jobs, flats, occupations... Mr. Christophe Jaffrelot, may we know if we have any data to back this? You are making a very strong claim!
@@roshan321ful we don't want upper caste gandhi family dynasty ruling us for decades. You people are crying bcoz someone like modi who comes from a poor background and lower caste can also become a pm of our country. You are casteist
Ask your clan to stop going to Madressaa and start attending colleges. Stop building Mosques and ask for Collages. Give up Jihad and join the main stream. Instead of asking everything from the state, do something in return for a change !! Opportunity is for you to take, not to keep asking !!!!
@@yuribezmenov9257 You divide people in the name of cast and you call me casteist? Select the PM based on merits not based on emotions. Tumhare emotions ke chakkar mei desh ke L laggaye. I know people ll vote Modi for more couple of decades and no one can stop it. When andhbhakts realise the incompetence of this Feku, it will be too late. I don't care if people go on roads begging because you reap what you sow.
Christophe I am happy that this book will open the eyes of many. If you think that Modi alone is responsible for the way we are, you are wrong. There is some one who guides his hand and that is Amitsha.
@@nimlanguage2707 why should we go to Pakistan. Why not to middle east Indonesia Malaysia and western countries where is there complete riot free and lynching free atmosphere. As gandhi ji said we have to borrow good points from others and discard bad points from all corners
do we really need books to understand Modi :) it is nice having books ..they used political power and also used cultural power. he has moral support from all over, not only bjp voters. all supporters may not vote for bjp and modi, but emotionally they fully connect edto him.. , they converted their friends into enemies , so when they need political help, they can help. other time politics are normal. example is Shiva sena, who knows even tmc mamata also their friend :) in my view all parties are Modi friends :) if need help few guys jump and support else how they manage to pas all bills. so unity is already happened, like how things happen in US, Israel . they do politics, but when it comes to nation , they unite. something happening in India.. gr8 job done by Modi..
Inki Rozi Roti Hi Modi k karan chal rahi hai dusre koi leader hi bache nahi hai 😂This Lady Rajdeep and The NDTV has Great Contribution for Rise of Modi 😆😆😆
Let the Professor articulate his ideas. The issues you are raising are not relevant to the criticality of the debate. Listen in to the erudite scholar on the subject and let your viewers decide whether they agree with the Speaker. Your interjections took away the learning opportunities for your viewers.
He is almost very prophetic in the surprises that he gives as if he receives messages from God and then he just comes on tv and makes announcements without a democratic discussion with party or people.
He gives surprises, but they are always followed by negative outcomes and in cases painful to the countrymen. This is all because he gets revelations not from God but from uninformed people. He is the rollback leader . Hon' ble CJI has put it so beautifully well in his convocation address in Puttaparthi all the political leaders should do self introspection every day about the impact of their decision on the people. Surprise decision making thrills the leaders and surge of dopamine gives top of the world feeling but causes severe pain to the vast majority of the citizens. Running a country is not the same thing managing a family. In family matters give surprises but not in statecraft.
I would like CJ to talk about the looting away of India’s wealth under the european invasion and the divide and rule to create tension between the Indian communities which were previously living peacefully
barkha nice interview. The author has covered many areas well. But he is not looking at the origin of India, global influence, the many wrongs that have happened to the current mindset of right supporters and many more I am sure you can give the notes to him in offline mode. Thanks again
Any Indian leader- starting from corporate executive to top most political leader( be it PM to the lowest rung ) can't win the hearts and minds of his followers with out mimicking the characteristics laid down by Indian religion, for lack of appropriate term , I am forced to use Indian religion. I appreciate the insights of Prof Jafferlot.
INC under the leadership of Sonia Gandhi / Rahul has also lost people's hope / trust totally in all the elections held after 2014, including the panchayat elections as they’ve not done anything for the people, in the last seven years, being the opposition. And even during this pandemic situation COVID-19, Congress has not been taking caring of the people in the country by means of extending any co-operation with the ruling party, extending any help to the people affected during 2nd wave by providing required things / medical facilities like Oxygen etc. and making any donation to PMCARES fund, except politicising every activity of the ruling Govt. and making false propaganda thro' media, on hatred politics, without knowing the seriousness of the situation.
Till I thought in West authors are very intelligent but I never thought there will be this kind of Authorsas well. Then I thought he must have been educated in some madrasa.
This gentleman is so flaky that it is embarrassing to watch. He has the persona of the all knowing one, while the supporting evidence he puts forth is easily exposed. 'Muslims don't have opportunities for jobs', 'CAA discriminates on the basis of religion' (completely sidesteps the history of CAA), etc. Barkha's question about the opposition was an opportunity to explore with curiosity. He came to the conversation with his mind set in concrete and had handwaving arguments for everything, which is a calling card of the left-wing. That is to not brush away the complex social history of India and the realities of now, but simplisticating it with an Abrahamic dichotomy knife of us/them fails at the gate. I upvoted it for the questions and definitely not for the answers.
Either you have a democracy where all citizens are treated equally or you have an elected dictatorship where everyone is not equal nor have any opportunity for equality- which is what we have in India.
Thanks, for airing the episode, only an acceptable election does not mean democracy, what this democracy is doing to the rights of the muslims and also to those of other minorities?
We have 1.4 billion population which consists of a lot of Non Voters who are Poor: pavement dwellers , homeless people, beggars. These are all Indian who are not Voters. Who should take care of them. Governments either State or Centre. First their Existence has to be recognised and then THINK about their welfare . But the governments are BUSY in elections ????
Hope the book includes covering stories of the 'BURNOL' that has been spend for anti Nationals and jihadis for their recovery
✌🏻😎💥
I hope the book deals with the automatic reign and the megalomaiac personality of a ruler.
true
hindutva goons should be given the book
yes there is aa Burnol Ad on bck cover
😅🤣
Rise of Adani is more dangerous then rise of Taliban🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. After Adani banned Drugs supplying countries at its Port I think so.
Adani is the summugler!
What most don’t accept is Modi is destiny’s child. Years of ignoring the docile majoritarian sentiments in the name of vote bank politics, political correctness was destroyed by one man. Love him, like him or hate him, you cannot ignore him.
right on...congress and the Gandhi's through their cronies both in govt (civil servants, award vapsi gang) and media have successfully created this notion of them being the torchbearer of secularism. 1st of all, the word secularism was shoved into constitution by Indira during her dictatorship (emergency) so, what moral authority this family or party has to talk about it. when i see commentators talking about congress being a secular party then 2 things come to mind a) they r conveniently being ignorant and b) that congress is nothing but a minority appeasement party. for a long period of time, every party other than BJP and Siv Sena (till last year) followed that path and that's the reason BJP got an opportunity to find space and huge vote base to be relevant by becoming a hindu nationalist party. politics is all about opportunism and Modi/Amit Shah/BJP have become very good at it. however, i think BJP/Modi's problem is that they are not as good as Congress and left at managing the narrative through their cronies in media and institutions. Congress has the lever because we still see their sympathizers everywhere in govt and institutions that they have curated for so long. unless, bjp does the same, they will always face the heat
They may not agree, but Barkha & Rajdeep were responsible for the rise & popularity of Modi.
True. Vishwas politics. This is what the caste system also gives - next janma you will be reborn...
Treat him as untouchable beast.
OMG they can’t even ban him and the book . Neither put him behind jail or address him as deshdrohi..
😂
True
FDI.....invented by Fakendra
Feku's IT cell bhakt can troll him😂
He is telling the truth.
Modi is the hope of the nation to develop
Good joke.
Yess lol Oxygen shortage
@@rish517well you're the clown
The reason Indira Gandhi declared emergency is because of Allahabad high Court judgement. What was the judgement about?
Apparently a magistrate erected a stage for her election campaign using public money. And for that offence, her election was nullified and then she was disqualified from standing years election for 6 years. If she was not disqualified for 6 years, there would not have been emergency.
Now Modi party campigning every where using public money and the disaster releif fund. And no one has filed a complaint nor has the court taken so moto cognaizance. Indira was not aware the magistrate was using public money. Still she was held liable.
Qqaqqaqaq
That is why we can confirm that a deep state is already entrenched in India. This is what Christophe is afraid of and Barkha seems to be denying it.
@@AsmaSohailMRTH while Bharka seems to be anti BJP, She also seems carry a chip on her shoulder against the congress party. I have seen her trying to belittle congress in many of her interviews .
@@Suresh_Kamath That could be true. I never thought of it that way. However, I do feel she is also a bit traumatised like Rajdeep Sardesai for being attacked strongly by the right wingers.
Don't re-write history with your pathetic analysis
Says sorry when he needs votes...
AWAKEN INDIA
JAI HIND
As a pm he try's this farmers law for a year....he is also a human.....by the way how many PM of India says sorry to his country people in past although in this country pm imposed emergency situation to this country people for secure her chair ....and in past many more incidents happen in this country like this....how many people bought to jail and how many people died please read about this incident from history.....
@@sangramdash9337 bhai shod na. Inka rona rhega he agr woh farm law laayein tab bhi hatayein tb bhi. Inki cheekhein nikaali hai usne
Congress k kitne PM bane lekin sikho k hatyakand par kisi ne bhi desh se Maafi nahi mangi
@@thethreespikes9737 sirji, in dirty politics for vote our politicians become jokers . Remember Didi o Didi.
@@sangramdash9337 which PM made like this notebandi, no black money has come back, still BJP is hiding the list of people holding money in Swiss account, chowkshi all runway, new special plane which PM bought, new parliament new Palace new car BMW, Trump visit all money who wasted , fakir every day 5 dresses change, going on world tour, not a single official press conference in 7 years, every thing from Airport to Railways all good money making sold, which PM sold check.
He got more knowledge about India than any citizen of this country.😱
Very true. It is embarrassing and enlightening at the same time to realise that!
India is his area of interest
Appu Lao desh ke l lagao
Chup kar sabko apne jaisa na smjha kr got it
Dude he is a Political Scientist
Congress has ruled the country for most of the year post our independence. They have a powerful family that has practically created a narrative that gives an impression that only Gandhi family were responsible for India’ s freedom. It is almost like a monarch and RaGa is the prince who despite his inabilities is forced on people of India.
They know that narrative created by them is not reality and if an opposition governments stays in power with absolute majority they will always fear being exposed. Congress would have been calmer if this was broken verdict. This is precisely the reasons they supported regional parties as they knew as long as people are divided they will find it easy to loot the country.
Seven years after nothing to speak about achievements but still blame the Congress shame on andh bhakths
@@Bhooshanoo7 - They are not doing anything to provide an alternative to the current government. They themselves have reduced a national political party to a laughing stocks with jokers and clowns like rafool ghandy 😂😂 but chamchas lo like you continue to bootlick them. Shame on you
@@WorkWizdom uneducated, telling lies,from notebandi GST Trump new plane new Palace new parliament, corona mis handling, national property sold to corporate, from 15 lakhs to 2 crore jobs, not a single hospital school college jobs still u stand with this ,please my friend think twice.
@@WorkWizdom you are illiterate man ..can't you see 23 crore moved into poverty line ... 45 yr high unemployment and 80 crore given free ration gives support to my statement. ..Bangladesh having more per capita income then India ...which was about 55% of india speaks volume ...
@@WorkWizdom illiterate people like you don't know India has a population of 140 crore ...who will become PM ..is dependent on our democracy. ..you find only Gandhi family ..fact is its not necessary to have pm from Hindu belt ...shashi taroor can be ...an opportunity in 1977 led to maroaji desai being PM of india ..similarly VP SINGH ..Manmohan Singh ..etc complete list ..only dumb and illiterate like you vs modi vs whom ..it's democracy vs autocracy. ..etc ...
Rightly said. Never before power was concentrated in a few hands. So never before decisions were taken by a single person.
Indira Gandhi! remember the name?
Everyone knows how many times she democratically imposed president rules. No one can be as fascist as she was.
lol.. nehru family..heard of them
@@subadeepdas3397 so we r f@@@@
Same like Punjab 😁where cm is still sikh only since 70 years... is it good for secularism??
12 baje comment kiya tha kya??
Nehru parivar ka naam suna hai??
Manmohan Singh ko desh ki janta ne PM chuna tha ya Sonia Gandhi ne??
Can a non Gandhi become president of the party?
Do some research first
Gang of leftist hounding Modi..Beta tumse na ho payega
😂🤣FarmLawsRepealed3MonthsBeforeUP/PunjabElections"HndtvAatnkwaadis"TumhareLachhanAchhe(Din🤣🔥🤣)NahiDikhRaheTumseNaHoPaayega"
leftist farmers ?
leftists + jihadis alliance is global
@@ramrao668 tradsPlusRaitasAllianceIsLocal😂🤣😂🤣
OK guys,, let's have a debate between Christophe Jeffreylot versus Francois Gauthier. Christophe stayed outside India and analyzed India whereas Francois lived in India for decades and knows India.
"Narendra Modi is election oriented"..!! He hit the nail on the head.
And other leaders like - Boris Johnson, Erdogan, Imran Khan, Trump, Biden, Sonia G ( in fact all of them) - are not election oriented? What amazing "analysis" and conclusion from this writer!
@@hemamin5747 my dear friend, i have quoted from the video clip interview. Please go through the video before you pass your "amazing" comments.
Translation : Prachar Mantri
@@ivangomes2411 pretty feeble rebuttal from someone who also endorsed the quote
It always takes a foreigner to analyse and not be swayed by emotions .
Hi th-cam.com/video/uEC7hV0M_Zg/w-d-xo.html
@@TheEnglishator q🙂
@@TheEnglishator ⁸ò⁹9
Yeah, Like the Turks And The Mongols and The British And The Gandhis.
I would like to read the book just to see what pains the author has taken in his narrative to divide India along the hindutva cracks.
✌🏻😂
The interview with the author Christophe has brought out the pros and cons of BJP regime under Modi in an unbiased manner. why such convincing political analytical work is not done by our own Indian authors?
If they do....they will be either lynched...or behind bar with anti national tag!
They are Afraid Sir
Yup modi controls people in what they say. He's not a person who is ready to accept otherwise but so many hate him.
As long as the people are controlled by the hampering factors such as religion, caste and creed while analysing the challenges concerning political social economic and religious issues objectively and logically with transparent mindedness, making our world's largest democracy more relevant,effective and successful will become a herculean task.
They can do such analytics with putin or Ximping and see the effect.
Chanced to listen it today only. Could see the signs of sorrow and disappointment on his face throughout as is common on the dispositions of Marxist -Liberal- Islamist apologists. Very very difficult for them to digest that Hindus could one day rise above their second class status to the level of equality with their pampered Muslim compatriots . Also Modi’s arrival on the scene saw the downfall of Khan Market crony intellectuals of Congress in India and abroad . It substantially affected the deep state formed earlier . Hence author’s worries are more about uprooting of about old deep state than forming of new one .
yes 🤣😅 pigs 🐖 cry
pupil of asharam also have same point of view.as of modi fan have
@@varunduttswami452 and people of Madrassa also have same view as this fellow in interview
@@myfuhrerr Nazi Germany is being develope for madarsa pupil by Hitler of India.
Nobody has given Hindus a second class status except for those people who suffer from an inferiority complex . The haters like Modi RSS VHP and the gang of 4 Gujarati's.
India will remain Modi s India and People like Barkha Dutt will keep trying new levels of beneatheness.Best of Luck dear ...
even outsiders can see the dark impact of modiji..when will citizens understand it especially the andhbhakts
Which is your favorite country?Which country do you inspire India to be?
They are feeding vyou propaganda idiot
Then who are you? Albert Einstein? Or Swami Vivekananda?
@@johnfaith9486 there are no ideal country . We have to imbibe good qualities from several countries . Like rule of law . Complete absence of communal riots and lynching should be learned from middle east . Liberal values and democratic sprite from West. High growth rate and plural peaceful structure to be copied from East Asia like Indonesia Malaysia Thailand Singapore etc
@@logicalindian9227 Complete absence of communal riots and lynching in middle east is complete joke.There are no minorities left to begin with.
What an absolute ausum IAS level discussion
Below points were ausum :
1) Using radio to communicate in Saintly voice
2) Welfarism as dignity
3) Netanyahu and Erdogan example
4) How will Bjp sustain post Modi
Feeling Blessed to witness such high quality discussion
🎓S off to d Author🙏
If you look up to the IAS as something worthy of emulation, you are sadly mistaken. They are the reason why India is still a 3rd world country, along with the our Indian political class, of course.
Wow... IAS level talk....
From where do you get such terms.... You people are from different breed....
Now we need author like Barkha dutt who is responsible for death of so many soldiers.... She did all that for her publicity and now after being sidelined by her own media house.... Somehow still looking for relevance
Once M population reaches 51% in India, will the country remain secular?
Andhbhakt.
@@mohdtahir1013macho 6 6 bache tum paida karo or andhbhakt hum. Wah wah wah wah
just need to look at any other islamic country for the answer
@@mohdtahir1013 andhbhakt is better than”BHDWA”
If and when any groups population is greater than 5%, we should not give minority status. We made a big mistake and are reaping the consequences. There is more trouble to come.
The author Christophe is a French national...he knows a lot about and has experience with North African and other muslims.... including how tolerant they are, do not behead people for cartoons... do not kill old Jewish woman in homes and market place...and these two jokers are deciding what's good and bad in India under Modi...
To get a good job, you need to go college not Madarasa .
The de-Indianised jokers are always good for a laugh.
In Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan minority Hindus, Sikhs and Christians are very rich enjoying and living very happily under peaceful hightech Sharia law
I enjoy the sarcasm bro. These quislings keep yapping.
He is atleast right in his approach, equally criticizes Pakistan, Turkey as well.
Notice how Burkha Dutt was diverting whenever he mention these countries, saying those countries are different (as if they are entitled to it and right if they do it).
Atrocities on minorities in those countries, at par with Hitler's ethnic cleansing. I hope he realises and alerts his countrymen to take necessary action against growing terrorist menace in France. France drafted strict laws recently to counter them. if India adopts these laws, there will be big hue and cry from media, foreign journalists immediately jump marking them as draconian laws , beating their chests and another Mojo interview will follow...
Nowadays if we write anything, against India, against our PM, our religion, beat our chests about minorities (be careful here, you should not mention about ethnic cleansing of Kashmiri Pundits) we will get immediate recognition, we will join the ranks of intelligentia, who knows we might get some journalism award from leftist ilk.
Our media has lot many Quislings and need very little foreign assistance to write against our nation.
Sudbury Nair. Do you want to be like Pakistan and Bangladesh ( actually they seem to be doing better than us) or like the Scandinavian countries?
Apologies.i meant Sudhir Nair.
Sudhir Nair, Yes! they do enjoy a peaceful life in Pakistan. And No! there is no Sharia law in Pakistan.
See Pakistan or any other Muslim country can never claim that unfortunate incidents wouldn't have happened regarding communal issues BUT the people in government and political leaders acknowledge those incidents as UNFORTUNATE events and are first ones to condemn it and discourage any motivation around it. On the contrary, in India, the communal violence is gaslit and motivated by the BJP-RSS leaders who form the government in India right now. The hate speaches made by Mr.Subrimanyam and Amit Shah like leaders, become the reason behind the mob lynchings, harrasments and all the sorts of communal violence. Also the mainstream Indian media misinformation to the common people is being spoonfed-which is solely intended to hate muslims and sikhs and to produce sommunal divide. These accumulative measures have lead to state sponsored violence against Muslims in particular. Stripping off acrticle 370 in Kashmir while house arresting all Kashmiri leaders and turning Kashmir into a jail in itself was a huge uncalled for act. The riots in Gujrat, the mass massacre was an uncalled for act, the beef ban was an uncalled for act, the NRC, CAA was an uncalled for act, the JNU attack was an uncalled for act, the arrest of Aryan Khan was an uncalled for act and all of these anti-muslim acts were government lead and state lead. The media isn't independant anymore so the truth is brushed under the carpet and only propagates the narrative of the BJP. Also the media is being used by the govt to propagate hate against muslims into the hearts of a common man. This culture of killings, harrassment and abuse by BJP workers on muslims in incidents where they beat them to their deaths because the muslim wouldn't chant wande mataram or Jai shiri ram is very evidently govt supported. So yes unfortunate incidents happen in Pakistan too but they are only unfortunate and incidents, not state or govt sponsored like in India.
Modi has forgotten that "Muslims have the first right on the country's resources", because they are the majority amongst the minorities! 😁
Muslims are not minorities. All hindu castes are minorities not muslims.
Why doesn't he write a book on the PM of his own country
This interview and book has been sponsored by Modis opposition members
Don't demean the animals by calling them Mxxx.....
Relax he is not talking about ur faith which would demean the animals
@@vishnunarayan8850 😂🤣ThePeopleOfFaith/Relgion(WhetherMuslimsHindusChrsistiansSikhs)AreAlwaysRelaxedItIsTheHndtvAatnkwaadisRunningAnxiousWorseThanAnimalsOopsApologyToTheAnimalsForComparingThemToHndtvAatnkWaadis🤣😂
18milion Muslim minority 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Agar Muslim 60 million bhi ho Jay tub bhi yeh log Muslim ko Minority bolengae .
As far my knowledge.... Indian Muslims numbers around 200 million
Acchq kausa shabd use karein?
How to not offend your feelings? Tell us
Yes they in minority against 500 million population of hindus
@@meeraspillai6696 pillai, there are hindus & hindus; all hindus are not the same . Otherwise modi would have been the darling of south india .
Excellent talk, the author has excellent knowledge of Indian politics, he is candid n honest in his conclusions on Modi’s personality traits, I wish to read the whole content of this book.
@@Amit-lh1jz yes, had to Google his name to find out. Not sure if Barkha mentioned.
After watching barkha dutt ...it's only going to anti Modi agenda 😂😂
He said ,"Muslims don't have excess to job".
Really?
I am surprised too.😳He is a sponsored writer.Because a white guy is supposed to be unbiased..colonial slavery.
'Kya se kya ho gaya.....tumhare pyar me'...Once Barkha used to interfere in cabinet reshuffling Cabinet in Manmohan- Soniya regime....now she is depended only TH-cam 😉😉😉
😂
Atleast still she is doing her job...she is not berozgaar....as many people are at present...
He almost look like imran khan if you notes 😂 barkha dutt
When you can't sell a point bring a white guy to make the same point ...Awesome Barkha
WhenYouKnowNothingYouCrowNothingness😉🤣😂
Bharkha madam, can you please do a discussion once “what’s wrong with Nationalism when you are surrounded with nations who wants to capture what ever possible “
@@itsmemaga she won't, that is not an agenda. She will add enemy..that is her hate for Hindus and India
India is the best country to live for all communities and all are given equal opportunities The minorities are portrayed as deprived lot and they play the victim card world over They have given opportunities for the last 70 years but are carried away the action of their religions leader Most people including you got have got it wrong CAA is giving citizenship to 30 k people who are already living in India Hindus at some point of time under Sonia Gandhi leadership felt left out and they have shifted their loyalty to Modi
This Gentelman is absolutely correct
He dislikes Modiji, but he is trying to make money on Modiji, so who is the animal here?
What a hypocrite.
Our Pradhan Sevak is a Electionjeevi or Chunavijeevi
woh toh sab politicians hote hai. Agar Rahul PM hote toh bhi woh politics hi karte. Opposition mei rehke mudde uthana jyada aasaan hai. PM ki kursi sahi maine mein kaanton ka taaj hai.
True the position of PM is not for everyone.But functioning of the PM is between election to election without taking into account the harsh reality that is what I mean.only intention is winning the election at any cost.
India have divided to Modi and Anti modi. It's spread out the every sector. Arthashastra of Chanakya said that even if the opposite slogan comes from outside or inside nation more and more then note that national leader have on the right way of ruling, That national leader of that nation have to go forward on straight line or way of the progress of the nation not mind it slogans of opposition. Modified India is the current trend of nation.
learn basic english first.
@@mohanamohan8726 please give me rectification of which part is wrong.
Gandhiji used to wear 5 Lac rs suit, branded goggles,Mont Blanc pen, shoes while Modi ji is faqeer and public is rich.😂😂 You may laugh.
Are you wearing the same cloths vehicles as done by your elders
Bhai, he gave up all that for simple, minimum clothes. Current people have only changed their designer - from western styled clothes to Indian styled clothes. They are expensive all the same
Is that wearing good clothes makes a rich person ?
This is what your QURAN teaches you , how to degrade and how to is materialistically
You should hsil your TALUBAN KHAN and yoyr country enjoying with TERRORISTS
There may be hours and hours of discussions, analysis etc. on Modi...... but I think that the Modi juggernaut will roll on.....
His intentions & vision for Bharat, his honesty, his personality, his self confidence, his charisma, his leadership etc. are simply awesome! There was no Indian leader like him in the past........
Also, the elite slaves of the Nehruvian-Maxist line of thought, who this far were in the limelight are now a worried lot in our country...... all of them are in panic.....
I look forward, among other things, to our Bharat's history being put in its proper perspective and our Constitution (which presently reflects a strong colonial influence) being relooked for appropriate indigenization in line with our glorious Indic/vedic civilizational values......
Barkha Dutt and Christophe Jaffrelot!!!!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
MANMOHAN SINGH...MASSIVE ...ONE OF THE BEST PMs WE HAVE EVER HAD.
AWAKEN INDIA JAI HIND
what an enriching discussion Christophe Jaffrelot. Surely a treat to watch. Thanks Barkha.
Yet, she could have let him do the talking more ;)
I am not sure what we lost after Modi became PM?? Can someone tell?
@@ajayjain9207 I am not sure what we lost after Modi became PM?? Can someone tell?
@@singhrabhishek the ability to know and think about it
@@ajayjain9207 did you?? By seeing your comment, I don't think you lost ability.. correct?? Or is it like that family members saying before 2014 my son IQ level ability was good and after 2014, my son lost?? Is this?? Or we just made our perception??
He wants to be Indira. Have the power and influence she had . I think he idolises her .
@Dy Xgd jai periyar
Spot on!
Indira was far better than Modi, even taking emergency into consideration.
@@Suresh_Kamath very true
@@sureshharinathbabu9717 😃😂
Theoretically n practically in both terms, writer has left mindset...how he says, minority in india is denied very basic rights to education, job eyc...rubbish
U r right
Learn to accept the truth and what world really think about India is not that great.
Modi-RSS being criticized by a white man .......that's the thing which hurts the most for andhbhakts.
Not really coz it's not us who are suffering from inferiority complex like you chamchas lmao
@@yuribezmenov9257 ohh really !!!🤪 😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂
This guy has a biased view towards BJP and Modi... no wonder he is trying to equate India and Israel... there too many differences on different levels... clearly this gentleman has a one dimensional view and lacks the other facets/point of views...
You mean to say Israel is far better?
@@Bhooshanoo7 Israel is a country with much less diversity & population equal to a small state of India...They can've direct democracy with astounding technological achievements...India'll need many more years to mature as a democratic nation where only about 20 families & their members control the political power corridors...
Breaking down
Modi's India
Modi's India
Breaking Down
Modi's Breaking
India Down
Any thoughts anyone?
Mam u need to translate the conversation between u and Mr Christophe Jaffrelot becoz Andbhakts r striking their heads against the Feku walls as they r not able to get it 😁😁😁😁😁😁
👍Absolutely true 👌
Rapist mohmad follower and bjp congress kjruddin Mamta left all are same
Dont get too happy maulana...
Atleast we don't keep bombing and blowing people up like you Jihadis !!
Does it matter? Towards the end, he said something about guru shishya relationship - blind followers.
In India you have this guru shishya parampara that is so strong.
Barkha has been earning her "ROTI " from "MODI " since 2002.🤣🤣🤣🤣
Would have loved to listen to Chris but then she started what she does best.
Mam immensely proud of you, salute you for boldly speaking the truth
The economy is in a mess. If it continues to falter, his charisma won't last.
Hindu bano pehle
yes bring in Mamatha to turn things around or RaGa
Enemies have more knowledge about you then yourself barkh is natural to this art
Sir
Very truly siad🙏
TRUE. They only search for pretended negativity on you.
I feel more than the truth he is presenting view with sarcasm. Barkha anyway happy to be against Modi
What ever your book has to say but the people of India knows our PM Modiji is the best PM India ever had.
Many people are envying him, or jealous of him because they couldn't do what he is doing for India. So no matter what you or Barkha says will not make any difference... . .God bless you protect our Modiji. Jai Hind.
Barkha Dutt is asking whether modi is not an rss ideologue!?? Seriously??
A new awakening is taking place ; Modi could not have arrived too soon ; Hinduism is not a religion but a culture, a way of living and thinking without any dogmas or belief systems, where one can get logical answers for both the mundane and the spiritual ; people are beginning to think for themselves like never before and they want logical answers and in a couple of decades, most scriptures would collapse unable to answer the inquiring minds ! The world needs Hindu culture more than ever before to bring in the much needed sanity to allow the world to live like one family !
that is what the islamo fascist / marxist / christian evangelist alliance is so worried about. how will they make their living in india peddling their lies ?
I have worked in multiple companies... I don't see any description in job interview or selection... Also, I have seen a lot of Muslim in government job... and I couldn't see any discrimination there... even in my heart and mind.... where is discrimination in propaganda? with some extremist on both side?...
"Jaffrelot - based on the research and understanding of Indian society and politics - predicted that the Hindu nationalist ideology-based Bharatiya Janata Party will not be able to win general elections and form the central government, a prediction that proved to be incorrect to Jaffrelot's misfortune. "
Walter Anderson
He mis judged poisoned minds of the vote bank of the party...
That’s because Jaf didn’t take EVM manipulation into account: the bamman - Bania cabal cutting across all political parties had conspired to get Modi elected way back in 2011-12 ….these foreign journos are ridiculously unaware about the caste-dynamics in Indian politics …
@@HailStonE999
The first piiig who poison Him mind was from arab 1400 year ago, muh-me-de
@@123xyzabccba
Cross check again if he took Halala, Mutaah and Tahruush Gamea in account?????🤭🤭🤭🤭
@@faisalahmadi9118 : spotted ! Bjp ITCELL joker spotted
Modi's India is the most peaceful INDIA. Till Modi was elected as Priminister nearly for 70 years every month there would be hundreds of Pakistan sponcered violence in the country as though it is part of five year plan . But from last seven years the miscreants are keeping quiet . The very name Modi works as deterrent for Anarchist mob. As for the development, in 1947 British colonizers left India after handing over ruling authority to Nehru family. The family took it as a gift and enjoyed the position as other Rajas and Maharajas. As such there was less scope and little time for development. Whatever development works happened during that time did happened inspite of the ruling family ,rather because of them. But it is natural for family loyalists to shout " BHO PARAK " of Nehru family.
It also shows the erosion of his level of confidence
HI Barkha, please use a standard (35mm) lens, if you are using full frame camera to broadcast. the wide angle you are using giving a distorted look of you, which is visually incorrect. or sit little further back from the lens.
True
Muslims don't have access to jobs, flats, occupations... Mr. Christophe Jaffrelot, may we know if we have any data to back this? You are making a very strong claim!
Another foreigner to drive nail in the secular fabric of India. Indians (irrespective of religion) will not fall for that.
@@DNVKUMAR but fall for illiterate chai wala jo bharat ki watt lagaraha hai
@@roshan321ful we don't want upper caste gandhi family dynasty ruling us for decades. You people are crying bcoz someone like modi who comes from a poor background and lower caste can also become a pm of our country. You are casteist
Ask your clan to stop going to Madressaa and start attending colleges. Stop building Mosques and ask for Collages. Give up Jihad and join the main stream. Instead of asking everything from the state, do something in return for a change !! Opportunity is for you to take, not to keep asking !!!!
@@yuribezmenov9257 You divide people in the name of cast and you call me casteist? Select the PM based on merits not based on emotions. Tumhare emotions ke chakkar mei desh ke L laggaye. I know people ll vote Modi for more couple of decades and no one can stop it. When andhbhakts realise the incompetence of this Feku, it will be too late. I don't care if people go on roads begging because you reap what you sow.
Christophe I am happy that this book will open the eyes of many. If you think that Modi alone is responsible for the way we are, you are wrong. There is some one who guides his hand and that is Amitsha.
This guy has done his work on Modi with jaundiced eyes
India is one country where majority(hindu) demand for equality...
very informative.
and now I am more scared about my country.
🤣🤣🤣 you better get lost asap
@@vemonxogaming4242
I will for sure,
but first let me try to get rid of the smelly "gobar" from my house.
@@LittleMaster1 I can smell burning🔥 🤣🤣🤣 get lost ASAP as your burden for this country 🤣🤣
You are free to go to Pak or Afghanisthan. Be happy there. We feel secured in India.
@@nimlanguage2707 why should we go to Pakistan. Why not to middle east Indonesia Malaysia and western countries where is there complete riot free and lynching free atmosphere. As gandhi ji said we have to borrow good points from others and discard bad points from all corners
It's not Modi's India..
U SAID IT RIGHT. INDIA DOESN'T BELONG TO MODI. INDIA BELONGS TO THE PEOPLE OF INDIA.
do we really need books to understand Modi :) it is nice having books ..they used political power and also used cultural power. he has moral support from all over, not only bjp voters. all supporters may not vote for bjp and modi, but emotionally they fully connect edto him.. , they converted their friends into enemies , so when they need political help, they can help. other time politics are normal. example is Shiva sena, who knows even tmc mamata also their friend :) in my view all parties are Modi friends :) if need help few guys jump and support else how they manage to pas all bills. so unity is already happened, like how things happen in US, Israel . they do politics, but when it comes to nation , they unite. something happening in India.. gr8 job done by Modi..
Inki Rozi Roti Hi Modi k karan chal rahi hai dusre koi leader hi bache nahi hai 😂This Lady Rajdeep and The NDTV has Great Contribution for Rise of Modi 😆😆😆
Let the Professor articulate his ideas. The issues you are raising are not relevant to the criticality of the debate. Listen in to the erudite scholar on the subject and let your viewers decide whether they agree with the Speaker. Your interjections took away the learning opportunities for your viewers.
He exudes masculinity a man in charge
So now Modi is to be criticized because he has better communication with people.
He is almost very prophetic in the surprises that he gives as if he receives messages from God and then he just comes on tv and makes announcements without a democratic discussion with party or people.
He gives surprises, but they are always followed by negative outcomes and in cases painful to the countrymen. This is all because he gets revelations not from God but from uninformed people. He is the rollback leader . Hon' ble CJI has put it so beautifully well in his convocation address in Puttaparthi all the political leaders should do self introspection every day about the impact of their decision on the people. Surprise decision making thrills the leaders and surge of dopamine gives top of the world feeling but causes severe pain to the vast majority of the citizens. Running a country is not the same thing managing a family. In family matters give surprises but not in statecraft.
I would like CJ to talk about the looting away of India’s wealth under the european invasion and the divide and rule to create tension between the Indian communities which were previously living peacefully
barkha nice interview. The author has covered many areas well. But he is not looking at the origin of India, global influence, the many wrongs that have happened to the current mindset of right supporters and many more I am sure you can give the notes to him in offline mode. Thanks again
Sikkim annexation really.
It was a referendum.
Any Indian leader- starting from corporate executive to top most political leader( be it PM to the lowest rung ) can't win the hearts and minds of his followers with out mimicking the characteristics laid down by Indian religion, for lack of appropriate term , I am forced to use Indian religion. I appreciate the insights of Prof Jafferlot.
The only good thing Modi had done was he did not allow another 'Modi' to emerge in his party! Hopefully, when he goes, there will be light!
Controversial analysis.
Yet there is some truth in it. The author has good points.
INC under the leadership of Sonia Gandhi / Rahul has also lost people's hope / trust totally in all the elections held after 2014, including the panchayat elections as they’ve not done anything for the people, in the last seven years, being the opposition.
And even during this pandemic situation COVID-19, Congress has not been taking caring of the people in the country by means of extending any co-operation with the ruling party, extending any help to the people affected during 2nd wave by providing required things / medical facilities like Oxygen etc. and making any donation to PMCARES fund, except politicising every activity of the ruling Govt. and making false propaganda thro' media, on hatred politics, without knowing the seriousness of the situation.
Great interview! Will definitely add this book to my reading list. His research and knowledge are impressive.
🤣😅 hilarious
@@myfuhrerr what?
@@Lovely-sv1ye You are funny
@@myfuhrerr why?
Saying sorry doesn't make a dead man alive
I see people unlike they can’t swallow the truth
In Pakistan Hindus and Christians are enjoying and living very happily under peaceful Sharia law
@@sudhirnair559 InIndiaHindusAndChristiansAreEnjoyingAndLivingVeryPeacefulLives😉???With80MillionlnSentBeliwPovertyLine😂🤣
Modi is a political beast.
Jai Modiji
Giving gas cylinder which now cannot afford refilling it what a shame
Would love to read this book ❤️🙏
also watch ad on back cover
Burnol 🔥
Prof Jaffrelot should be the PM
Till I thought in West authors are very intelligent but I never thought there will be this kind of Authorsas well. Then I thought he must have been educated in some madrasa.
French teaching Indians about secular morals!!!! Wah Wah!! Like teaching the World to appreciate escargot........
This gentleman is so flaky that it is embarrassing to watch. He has the persona of the all knowing one, while the supporting evidence he puts forth is easily exposed. 'Muslims don't have opportunities for jobs', 'CAA discriminates on the basis of religion' (completely sidesteps the history of CAA), etc. Barkha's question about the opposition was an opportunity to explore with curiosity. He came to the conversation with his mind set in concrete and had handwaving arguments for everything, which is a calling card of the left-wing. That is to not brush away the complex social history of India and the realities of now, but simplisticating it with an Abrahamic dichotomy knife of us/them fails at the gate. I upvoted it for the questions and definitely not for the answers.
Either you have a democracy where all citizens are treated equally or you have an elected dictatorship where everyone is not equal nor have any opportunity for equality- which is what we have in India.
Modi sacrifice his life for India....I consider Modis life more important than mine.
Well tried…but ..difficult to understand modi , I would say very difficult…but people can try….😂😂😂
Nope, understand Modi is very simple, if you put another chai Wala in power he would do the same like the current chai wala 🤣
Even a indian have problem understanding Indian but calling burkh Indian is insult to indians
Thanks, for airing the episode, only an acceptable election does not mean democracy, what this democracy is doing to the rights of the muslims and also to those of other minorities?
We have 1.4 billion population which consists of a lot of Non Voters who are Poor: pavement dwellers , homeless people, beggars. These are all Indian who are not Voters. Who should take care of them. Governments either State or Centre. First their Existence has to be recognised and then THINK about their welfare . But the governments are BUSY in elections ????
What is pakistan democracy doing for minorities
Simply killing, kidnapping , raping and forcefully converting into ISLAM
Aren't they human rights ?
A political animal! Who is a political animal! Exactly said!