Now imagine hitting that same guy with artillery and chemical weapons only to see him shrug it off by drinking boos and eating random food pulled from his pocket.
US troops in WW1 impressed the Germans with how well they could shoot, to balance their poor tactics (they didn't have years of experience in the trenches). Almost like if they had constitutionally-protected training.
That actually happened, look up Sergeant Alvin York, guy took 132 German soldiers prisoner after getting headshots on at least 30 that attacked him and his squad, including 3 machine gun crews and at least 1 officer
Obviously this is not canon and probably something we will never see, but I could definitely see Jack going to fight in Europe as part of his story arc. Perhaps in an effort to put an ocean between him and the trouble he caused by killing Ross. It is pretty intriguing however, that considering if Jack lived an average lifespan, he saw so many different changes in the technology, landscape, development, and politics of the United States. He probably died in an air-conditioned home with running water, electricity, and an automobile parked outside. And incredibly far cry from his earliest days spent on the lam, living with nothing separating him from the elements but a few folds of canvas.
Given the first game takes place in 1911 he likely lived to the late 80’s maybe even mid 90’s at his healthiest. Like imagine being born in the final years of the American Wild West and seeing people playing video games and eating fast food and stuff as an old man.
@@steakinbacon8593 If Jack lived to be 100 years old (very possible), he'd have died in 1995. He would have died just at the dawn of the Information Age, and likely would have been remembered as the Last Gunslinger of the Old West, as well as the last living member of the Van Der Linde gang. I can see Jack coming home from WW1 and writing about his childhood growing up in the gang, becoming a bestselling author of Old West novels centered around the exploits of the gang. I don't see Jack truly fading into obscurity, not when Western movies really became popular in the 1950s and 1960s.
@@saulgoodmangaming1 I know that.But I never said that they should make this a sequel since by the time of 1914 the wild west is dead.But it could be a spin-off game.After RDR1 with Jack in WW1 or how he turned into gunslinger after his parents death and life into crime.In my opinion if they where to make a RDR3 I would like a prequel to RDR2 and play as a young Dutch and see how the gang was formed and being the leader and see more of the story and if not Dutch a younger Arthur or a very young John before he got his scars and show how the Blackwater heist went.
@@LoneWolf84694I think there was a theory or something that rdr3 could be about young Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur when the gang was made and you could switch between them
@@downseir yes it is i see it as the only way to continue the story going back will just fuck up the story line we need to continue Jack's story then create new story
Corporal Jack Marston of West Elizabeth, served with honor along side the US Army's 1st Division. He fought at the Battles of St. Mihiel and Aisne-Marne. His Valor include the Purple Heart, and a Silver Star
I think Jack would if it meant he could learn how to fly a plane. In the end of RDR1 Jack said: “One of them machines could turn men into Angels” and it they are bringing a plane for demonstration a year after Johns death. So who knows maybe our Jack would become an Ace
@@cheeziestpotato Well canonically he did live until 1992-1996, so drafted or not, he DID survive both WW1 and WW2. It's assumed in that time frame between 1914-1996, he becomes a famous writer/author, though he could also have gotten into piloting and aeronautics. We don't really know unfortunately.
actually, it’s a holiday. 11/11 used to be called “armistice day” until the Korean War, when the us changed it to “Veterans Day”. though people may celebrate it, it’s a shame only one person launched fireworks where i am
crazy to think that some don't. respect to all sides on WW1 as it was a wasteful war fought by empires for land and power, and respect to the heros who kept the world free in WW2.
This would be a fantastic opening to RDR3. Jack gets drafted, the combat tutorial is him fighting in Europe, and then he returns to become a gun-for-hire or vigilante in a 1920s Mafia/bootlegging storyline.
@@kimlsnyder And what does that have to do? The game does not have to be yes or yes in the West, apart from that the game does not have to be yes or yes of cowboys, since the title does not say that red dead cowboys of the west, does it?
At that year, Jack had 21, a young adult. I think in those three years he would have a lot of things to do or to think. And that is what those three have the Jack's development character potential. I love this video, and I hope you make more of this PD: I wanna have RDR2 on PC and make a series of this
Amazingly at the end of Red Dead Redemption, you can see some of the paths Jack could take, through the different unlockable outfits with one being the route of a soldier.
I doubt Jack would go willingly to fight for a war for a country he has no attachement to Even if he did go, there will be no one waiting for him at home. However, it would be nice for Jack to meet other young men and help gain a new found family among other brothers in arms but who knows the direction this story will take place? Either a sequel to RDR1 or another prequel to RDR2 Once GTA 6 is completed and sells well, only then maybe we see another game for red dead Nice video by the way, probably took some time
it doesnt have to be willing, he would most likely be drafted. OR he could have been forced into it like john, and is offered to get away from his murder of edgar and the fact his father was a criminal by joining the war
Just a fan continuation story; After Jack served the US army during the First World War, he went back to farming at his ranch. Maybe have a wife and kid in mid 1920s or stick to being a underdog virgin. Then decided to move to a big city like New York or Chicago to find better work after selling his ranch. His new city life was going well until the Great Depression hits forcing him to be a smuggler or criminal to make ends meet. Meanwhile, “bam” the Mafia game’s storyline unfolds in the background.
I had an scene where the enemy artillery destroys Jack's position and some of his mates ends dead, but Jack survives while a lot of his allies starts to retreat without him. Jack rises and sees through the smoke some germans coming in. He waits for them and the german tells him to surrender, but suddenly Jack uses his revolver with the dead eye and kills the german unit
I think Jack would if it meant he could learn how to fly a plane. In the end of RDR1 Jack said: “One of them machines could turn men into Angels” and it they are bringing a plane for demonstration a year after Johns death. So who knows maybe our Jack would become an Ace
With deadeye, i wouldnt be too worried in WW1. Also a full movie or game about Jack would be sick tbh. I read somewhere that the lite is he died close to the year 2000, having experienced the dying west, ww1 + 2, cold war Vietnam and mobile phones.
In some battles like Verdun, 80% of combat casualties were caused by artillery. Not by a rilfeman of MG crew shooting at you. Plus non-combat causes like diseases and whatnot.
Personally I want rdr3 “Red dead revelations” to explore Jack going on the run for killing edger. We pick up a few weeks after he killed him and we tell that story. The game world of 1911 and 1914 in rdr1 looks and behaves mostly the exactly same way. So even by rockstars own timeline it seems the old West is still not dead yet. So we got some story room for Jack in an old west environment and we could also use Mexico as well. Ww1 is an event that could easily be mentioned only by newspapers and Npc’s at most. WW1 started in July 1914 and ended in November 1918. America itself didn’t join the war until April 1917 but regardless ww1 was never at any point fought on American soil. So the entire war is really a non-issue if we want to keep the entire game strictly western based. Or you could find a way to put jack in the war as part of his story like during the epilogue section or as DLC. As for the Mafia angle nothing demands Jack’s story needs to told from that angle either. As far as the rdr franchise is concerned, the mafia has existed at least since 1899. So you could argue the setting years in rdr2 and rdr1 could just as easily have been used to tell a purely mafia story. Mafia with horses in 1899, mafia with cars in 1907/1911. So unless you choose to set a Jack story in a big city somewhere there’s no reason why the game needs to be mafia styled. Especially considering westerns primarily take place in the rural west, rural Mexico and the actual wilderness. But regardless, Nothing about Jack post rdr1 is actually confirmed Canon. Rockstar has never once confirmed anything about him after rdr1. That one book that you find in GTA 5 that has Jack’s name on it. It’s just an Easter egg, but for argument sake let’s just say it is canon. There was no publishing date on that book anywhere so that book could just as easily have been written in 1915 or 1950 for all we know. So that does not prove that Jack lived a long and peaceful life. and even if what some sources claim is actually true and Jack did live to be an old man, I’m very interested to see how he managed to secure that future. Especially after doing what he did to highly ranked, respected, and well known retired fed back in 1914. Considering in this franchise actions have consequences and revenge is a fools game.
i think more settings could be interesting, since RDR 1 had Mexico and RDR 2 has Guarma we could see Jack fighting in the Russian Civil War and Warlord Era China. two places where it feels like the wild west didn't truly end
Fantastic job, honestly, this is exactly what I wrote when I wrote an epilogue for Jack three years ago. In mine, after he came home, Jack married a woman he met in France and had a family, working as a professional hunter, trapper, and guide. Dying at the age of 90 of a heart attack out on the trail. He was buried at Beacher's Hope beside his parents. This was a great tribute, I hope you got the chance to do something for Rememberance/Veteran's day. I took in a great local ceremony with my mum and veteran grandad.❤🇨🇦
I was told a while ago that my great grandfather served in Vietnam and worked with a antifoliage chemical called Agent Orange. The U.S. was unaware of the long term effects of the chemical and my great grandpa died a heroic death in 1970. He did get to see my grandmother again, but not for long. Mad respect to **all** veterans of any war.
Tanks made me laugh, kind of want one now! Very well done video, especially enjoyed attention to detail with (predominantly) the use of the 1911 pattern pistol. I'm not much aware of repeaters being used in large amounts during America's entry into the Great War, but the bolt action rifle from RDR2 is (essentially) the rifle Americans were issued during WW1 - except different caliber/internals/and a capacity of 10 rounds. Loved seeing that in action! Thank you for the short film, enjoyed!
Jack just laying waste to the enemy, quick drawing and destroying them as his fellow soldiers watch from the trench behind him, amazing at the sight of someone who is seemingly an old west gunslinger, something they would never think to ever see.
Honestly Rockstar could make a damn good WWI game that focuses on story more than the FPS action that most games rely on. Like the gun play is fun and intuitive but not competitive and helps prevent that desensitized competitive feeling an FPS gives, add in third person and give us a character with a face and feelings there might be something close to respectable than what we got.
Imagine your a German soldier in the trenches missing your family and friends and all of a sudden some 22 year old man comes down and dead eyes you and your whole battle buddies
I always thought this would be an epic idea. Jack flees to Canada after killing Ross. Enlists with the Canadians and fights. Comes back and the game takes place in the Canadian wilderness.
Honestly RDR 3 could work with Jack being a U.S. Army soldier in the First World War. Think his family spent years fighting laws and civilization. Now the ultimate redemption is the rejection of outlaws and the embracing of order.
love it, but it bothers me that they all have repeaters and handguns... didnt the americans use the springfield? and officers had revolvers or 1911s instead of your average joe?
As a man whose father was killed by the Federal Government and, in response, ended up killing a former Agent of the Federal Government, I can't imagine Jack would not dodge the draft.
great video! Loved it!! Rockstar needs to make a Jack WWI DLC story. I don't care if its on the rails or less than 10 hrs but we need some more Jack adventures. With the planes and tanks and everything!!
Your so amazingly genius! I love this video much your camera angles and the mods and the way you did everything is top tier , you should be ecstatic about yourself man I love this!!!!!!!
It was already outdated but as a " screen use " prop the Krag Jorgensen bolt action rifle would have been a way more historically accurate choice : Because lever action such as the Yellow boy has seen service only unofficially with 1870's cavalry in the USA only.
@@HunterRamirez-rl3by Yeah ! Even at the time if weapons available were scarce for some reasons the U.S soldiers would use a trapdoor Springfield for trench warfare instead of a Winchester !
"Y'know, the day he died, I told my pa that one of them machines up there could turn men in to angels; but now all they seem to be doing is bombing us all to hell."
The tank animation is hilarious. It’s like the way you had to advance the plastic tank for an Army men set lol, wobble and walk it forward lol 😂 I know it was created by you lol but some things to note the hand crank Gatling gun was never used in WWI. By then it was obsolete. You had the Vickers and the Maxim. Both belt fed. And operated with a trigger mechanism. The only lever action gun that I know of in WWI was the Martini Henry, and it wasn’t that widely used. The Germans used the Gewehr 98 and the British used the Lee Enfield Mark 4 No. 1 and the Americans used the Springfield 1908. All were bolt action rifles. Side arms were the P08 Luger, and a Luger made revolver. For the Germans. The British used the Webly revolver made by Lee Enfield, and the Americans had the only semi automatic pistol the 1911 made by Colt. Tanks were the German No. 1 which looked like a big box on caterpillar tractor tracks, with 4 10 pound guns form a naval vessel. The British used the Mark 1 that looked like a trapezoid on caterpillar tractor tracks. The British design was actually superior for the type of fighting. Cause the trapezoid design allowed the tank to cross over trenches without falling in them or getting stuck. It was armed with 10 pound naval gun on one side and a machine gun on the other side. Being the first tank ever designed, it also gave birth to the idea of a tank being equipped to defend against both armor and infantry. The German tank was strictly anti armor, and if it tried to cross a trench it would fall in and be stuck in it. Forcing the crew to abandon it. Kinda of a wasteful design. German tank crews had to learn to keep it away from the trenches, massively reducing its mobility stats, compared to the British Mk. 1. But WWI, was the first war ever with tank warfare, so designing tanks was a massive learning curve for every country involved. In 1918 the Germans developed an antitank rifle that basically looked like an upscaled Gewehr 98 with a pistol grip and tripod. It fired a 13x99mm cartridge with an armor piercing steel cored bullet, that proved to be effective against the British Mk. 1 tank. From about 200 yards it could penetrate into a British Mk. 1 tank, and once inside it bounced around inside killing the crew inside pretty nasty results.
wow what a nice make of this. God bless you .this makes me want a red dead game during the civil war , how nice would that be. considering ww1 game is a totally different genre and would get its own title out of rockstar .
In RDR3 jack returns from the war a broken traumatized man and now sees that his home is long gone and now must survive in a new age if crime. This game takes place from 1917 to 1922.
@TheStarcoMarco farmers getting driven off their land homesteads being destroyed and government thugs dragging people outta their homes in the middle of the night. This would make for an interesting plot in RDR3. We went from the old west, the dying west, and now the dead west.
this would actually be so cool as a game. Do a few missions at Beechers Hope, then Jack gets drafted into the war, makes very good friends along the way, typical rockstar makes us bond with them and has them killed, then jack comes back home, etc.
This video is NOT monetised whatsoever. ❤️🪖
Classic TH-cam
@@ShadowKnight785he did it to show respect
This is awesome
Habla bien de tí
Mod ??
The tanks wobbling their way is just hilarious.
truly the horrors of WWI
true
They looked hyped for war
Its actually a guy in a tank suit
@@JeffMcDuffie72MeridianGateI can’t tell if this is satire or just straight up
The “walking” tank 😂
Seriously tho, I can’t imagine how much time it took to do this. Looks great!
Look like a decoy tank
Yes, just call it a decoy
"Walking" Tank? METAL GEAR?!
@@AnakinSkywakkaat-at
@@43potus Also an acceptable answer.
Imagine being a german soldier storming a trench only to see like 10 of your dudes get gunned down by 1 dude with deadeye
Now imagine hitting that same guy with artillery and chemical weapons only to see him shrug it off by drinking boos and eating random food pulled from his pocket.
US troops in WW1 impressed the Germans with how well they could shoot, to balance their poor tactics (they didn't have years of experience in the trenches). Almost like if they had constitutionally-protected training.
Now imagine if john had the evans repeater
That actually happened, look up Sergeant Alvin York, guy took 132 German soldiers prisoner after getting headshots on at least 30 that attacked him and his squad, including 3 machine gun crews and at least 1 officer
The Winchester trench boom was such a magnificent display of American engineering the Germans wanted it canceled
Obviously this is not canon and probably something we will never see, but I could definitely see Jack going to fight in Europe as part of his story arc. Perhaps in an effort to put an ocean between him and the trouble he caused by killing Ross.
It is pretty intriguing however, that considering if Jack lived an average lifespan, he saw so many different changes in the technology, landscape, development, and politics of the United States. He probably died in an air-conditioned home with running water, electricity, and an automobile parked outside. And incredibly far cry from his earliest days spent on the lam, living with nothing separating him from the elements but a few folds of canvas.
Holy balls you are right
Given the first game takes place in 1911 he likely lived to the late 80’s maybe even mid 90’s at his healthiest. Like imagine being born in the final years of the American Wild West and seeing people playing video games and eating fast food and stuff as an old man.
@@steakinbacon8593Jesus no wonder people think the new generation our worthless and lazy
@@steakinbacon8593 If Jack lived to be 100 years old (very possible), he'd have died in 1995. He would have died just at the dawn of the Information Age, and likely would have been remembered as the Last Gunslinger of the Old West, as well as the last living member of the Van Der Linde gang.
I can see Jack coming home from WW1 and writing about his childhood growing up in the gang, becoming a bestselling author of Old West novels centered around the exploits of the gang. I don't see Jack truly fading into obscurity, not when Western movies really became popular in the 1950s and 1960s.
I want to say that some GTA easter egg had Jack Marston living all the way into the 1970s so yeah, he saw ALOT of change
This is so well made.I think Jack Marston in WW1 would make a great game.
Nah rdr is about the Wild West and it coming to its end I doubt it would be good
@@saulgoodmangaming1 I know that.But I never said that they should make this a sequel since by the time of 1914 the wild west is dead.But it could be a spin-off game.After RDR1 with Jack in WW1 or how he turned into gunslinger after his parents death and life into crime.In my opinion if they where to make a RDR3 I would like a prequel to RDR2 and play as a young Dutch and see how the gang was formed and being the leader and see more of the story and if not Dutch a younger Arthur or a very young John before he got his scars and show how the Blackwater heist went.
@@LoneWolf84694I think there was a theory or something that rdr3 could be about young Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur when the gang was made and you could switch between them
@@Mazi_1 Yeah maybe
@Mazi_1 we already know that story already though.
This is so epic man! This would be an amazing DLC or spin-off game
Would love to see it
@@gec8297its perfect for rdr3
@@The_Joker_420no it isn't
@@downseir yes it is i see it as the only way to continue the story going back will just fuck up the story line we need to continue Jack's story then create new story
We need rdr 1 with new jack story
Corporal Jack Marston of West Elizabeth, served with honor along side the US Army's 1st Division.
He fought at the Battles of St. Mihiel and Aisne-Marne.
His Valor include the Purple Heart, and a Silver Star
I think Jack would if it meant he could learn how to fly a plane. In the end of RDR1 Jack said: “One of them machines could turn men into Angels” and it they are bringing a plane for demonstration a year after Johns death. So who knows maybe our Jack would become an Ace
@@KumarAnshs would be cool if he managed to survive WW1 and became an F4U pilot
Marne is French VS German, and Americans joined during 1917.
@@cheeziestpotato Well canonically he did live until 1992-1996, so drafted or not, he DID survive both WW1 and WW2. It's assumed in that time frame between 1914-1996, he becomes a famous writer/author, though he could also have gotten into piloting and aeronautics. We don't really know unfortunately.
Jack was the sole reason why the Germans were defeated at Belleau Wood.
Crazy to think that some people still pay homage for the soldiers that died in WW1, you have earned my respect good sir.
Soliders*
@@nineraik how you gonna correct him and spell it wrong yourself?
actually, it’s a holiday. 11/11 used to be called “armistice day” until the Korean War, when the us changed it to “Veterans Day”. though people may celebrate it, it’s a shame only one person launched fireworks where i am
@@redcoatdestroyer55its called anzac day in australia after ww2 i think
crazy to think that some don't. respect to all sides on WW1 as it was a wasteful war fought by empires for land and power, and respect to the heros who kept the world free in WW2.
This would be a fantastic opening to RDR3. Jack gets drafted, the combat tutorial is him fighting in Europe, and then he returns to become a gun-for-hire or vigilante in a 1920s Mafia/bootlegging storyline.
Bro, why would you join a mafia if Jack doesn't like killing? At most he could become a bounty hunter
@@starlord131 he is a bounty hunter and a gunslinger i mean even if you dont buy the bandolier Jack will have it in the epilogue
That's more or less the story of Mafia 2, in WW2 though
At that point it’s out of the western era tho
@@kimlsnyder And what does that have to do? The game does not have to be yes or yes in the West, apart from that the game does not have to be yes or yes of cowboys, since the title does not say that red dead cowboys of the west, does it?
You,my friend are a legend for creating such a masterpiece
thank you my man ❤️
At that year, Jack had 21, a young adult. I think in those three years he would have a lot of things to do or to think. And that is what those three have the Jack's development character potential.
I love this video, and I hope you make more of this
PD: I wanna have RDR2 on PC and make a series of this
He was 19
@@360NoScope-nm3lh but I'm referring to 1917, that's the year when American participated in WWI
@@DLCHT oh yeah true
@@DLCHT He likely wouldn't have been deployed to Europe til early 1918, as was the case with most troops
@@Sniper_RX ah okay, guess in that case, he would have 22 years old
People don’t know this, but Jack Marston with deadeye single-handedly won the Argonne offensive
Amazingly at the end of Red Dead Redemption, you can see some of the paths Jack could take, through the different unlockable outfits with one being the route of a soldier.
I doubt Jack would go willingly to fight for a war for a country he has no attachement to
Even if he did go, there will be no one waiting for him at home. However, it would be nice for Jack to meet other young men and help gain a new found family among other brothers in arms but who knows the direction this story will take place?
Either a sequel to RDR1 or another prequel to RDR2
Once GTA 6 is completed and sells well, only then maybe we see another game for red dead
Nice video by the way, probably took some time
it doesnt have to be willing, he would most likely be drafted. OR he could have been forced into it like john, and is offered to get away from his murder of edgar and the fact his father was a criminal by joining the war
Oh God You just reminded Me on how much click bait is going to be made on RDR3 when GTA6 gets released...
i think he may just go and fight, because fighting is all he knows.
Could end up being very loosely based off Alvin York
Gets forced into a war he doesn't believe in and becomes one of the most Decorated soldiers in it
I actually think he would go to flee the country, y’know not every soldier that went over and survived came back, quite a few stayed behind
Just a fan continuation story; After Jack served the US army during the First World War, he went back to farming at his ranch. Maybe have a wife and kid in mid 1920s or stick to being a underdog virgin. Then decided to move to a big city like New York or Chicago to find better work after selling his ranch. His new city life was going well until the Great Depression hits forcing him to be a smuggler or criminal to make ends meet. Meanwhile, “bam” the Mafia game’s storyline unfolds in the background.
I had an scene where the enemy artillery destroys Jack's position and some of his mates ends dead, but Jack survives while a lot of his allies starts to retreat without him. Jack rises and sees through the smoke some germans coming in. He waits for them and the german tells him to surrender, but suddenly Jack uses his revolver with the dead eye and kills the german unit
Little cheesy but I like it
hell yeah
I think Jack would if it meant he could learn how to fly a plane. In the end of RDR1 Jack said: “One of them machines could turn men into Angels” and it they are bringing a plane for demonstration a year after Johns death. So who knows maybe our Jack would become an Ace
2:39 tank walking with his homies
In Red Dead 3 a great prologue would be Jack fighting in WW1. Then for the main game he comes back to the US.
Love your videos and edits they are always so good and are the highlight of red dead 2 stuff i see!
Dude, this is amazing the amount of black magic you had to do to create this.
With deadeye, i wouldnt be too worried in WW1. Also a full movie or game about Jack would be sick tbh. I read somewhere that the lite is he died close to the year 2000, having experienced the dying west, ww1 + 2, cold war Vietnam and mobile phones.
In some battles like Verdun, 80% of combat casualties were caused by artillery. Not by a rilfeman of MG crew shooting at you.
Plus non-combat causes like diseases and whatnot.
Personally I want rdr3 “Red dead revelations” to explore Jack going on the run for killing edger. We pick up a few weeks after he killed him and we tell that story.
The game world of 1911 and 1914 in rdr1 looks and behaves mostly the exactly same way. So even by rockstars own timeline it seems the old West is still not dead yet. So we got some story room for Jack in an old west environment and we could also use Mexico as well.
Ww1 is an event that could easily be mentioned only by newspapers and Npc’s at most. WW1 started in July 1914 and ended in November 1918. America itself didn’t join the war until April 1917 but regardless ww1 was never at any point fought on American soil. So the entire war is really a non-issue if we want to keep the entire game strictly western based. Or you could find a way to put jack in the war as part of his story like during the epilogue section or as DLC.
As for the Mafia angle nothing demands Jack’s story needs to told from that angle either. As far as the rdr franchise is concerned, the mafia has existed at least since 1899. So you could argue the setting years in rdr2 and rdr1 could just as easily have been used to tell a purely mafia story. Mafia with horses in 1899, mafia with cars in 1907/1911. So unless you choose to set a Jack story in a big city somewhere there’s no reason why the game needs to be mafia styled. Especially considering westerns primarily take place in the rural west, rural Mexico and the actual wilderness.
But regardless, Nothing about Jack post rdr1 is actually confirmed Canon. Rockstar has never once confirmed anything about him after rdr1. That one book that you find in GTA 5 that has Jack’s name on it. It’s just an Easter egg, but for argument sake let’s just say it is canon. There was no publishing date on that book anywhere so that book could just as easily have been written in 1915 or 1950 for all we know. So that does not prove that Jack lived a long and peaceful life. and even if what some sources claim is actually true and Jack did live to be an old man, I’m very interested to see how he managed to secure that future. Especially after doing what he did to highly ranked, respected, and well known retired fed back in 1914. Considering in this franchise actions have consequences and revenge is a fools game.
american troops landed in Europe in the June of 1917
@@redcoatdestroyer55 True, but I was speaking in general about when the United States officially Joined ww1.
i think more settings could be interesting, since RDR 1 had Mexico and RDR 2 has Guarma
we could see Jack fighting in the Russian Civil War and Warlord Era China. two places where it feels like the wild west didn't truly end
@@redcoatdestroyer55 And again in June of 1944. Always June for some reason.
@@theguybehindyou4762 June = 6. 1944 = 1+4+4=9. = 666.
Thank you for posting this, my great grand uncle fought in the korean war.
I thank him for his service to the Korean people ❤️🇰🇷
@@rdr.outlaw He will be glad for your respect
my great uncle was a radioman in the marines during the Korean War, I have a picture of him
Fantastic job, honestly, this is exactly what I wrote when I wrote an epilogue for Jack three years ago.
In mine, after he came home, Jack married a woman he met in France and had a family, working as a professional hunter, trapper, and guide. Dying at the age of 90 of a heart attack out on the trail. He was buried at Beacher's Hope beside his parents.
This was a great tribute, I hope you got the chance to do something for Rememberance/Veteran's day. I took in a great local ceremony with my mum and veteran grandad.❤🇨🇦
His hair certainly wouldn't look like that in the military
This is a masterpiece artwork Outlaw!!!
This could be a great story for a dlc or rdr3 after the ending of red dead 1. You killed it man ❤
but if a jack in war game comes out it can't be called red dead redemption, it would have to be called red dead first world war
The fact there's a movie based on ww1 that roger clark(Arthur Morgan) appears in
I was told a while ago that my great grandfather served in Vietnam and worked with a antifoliage chemical called Agent Orange. The U.S. was unaware of the long term effects of the chemical and my great grandpa died a heroic death in 1970. He did get to see my grandmother again, but not for long. Mad respect to **all** veterans of any war.
1:22 the soldiers shooting to the sky
I think a siege to fortress
@@arifnurbain7722i don’t think that. Please, watch it again
As he returned to the grave yard, he not only thought of his old friends in the Van-Derlinde gang, but of his comrades who he fought besides in WW1
Tanks made me laugh, kind of want one now! Very well done video, especially enjoyed attention to detail with (predominantly) the use of the 1911 pattern pistol. I'm not much aware of repeaters being used in large amounts during America's entry into the Great War, but the bolt action rifle from RDR2 is (essentially) the rifle Americans were issued during WW1 - except different caliber/internals/and a capacity of 10 rounds. Loved seeing that in action! Thank you for the short film, enjoyed!
The Winchester 1895 saw service in WWI, mostly used by the Russians.
The rifle used is a Krag-Jorgensen, replaced by the 1903 Springfield and the AEF's main rifle was the 1917 Einfield
Jack just laying waste to the enemy, quick drawing and destroying them as his fellow soldiers watch from the trench behind him, amazing at the sight of someone who is seemingly an old west gunslinger, something they would never think to ever see.
If John, Jack, or Arthur go into the army they would BE the army 😂
Honestly Rockstar could make a damn good WWI game that focuses on story more than the FPS action that most games rely on. Like the gun play is fun and intuitive but not competitive and helps prevent that desensitized competitive feeling an FPS gives, add in third person and give us a character with a face and feelings there might be something close to respectable than what we got.
This is what i always thought rdr3 should be like. Jack somehow gets caught up in world war 1 and learns skills from that.
Imagine he sees someone like Arthur and asks “are you gonna take me fishing, uncle Arthur?”
Using pith helmets as World War 1 doughboy helmets: NOICE! 👍
Imagine your a German soldier in the trenches missing your family and friends and all of a sudden some 22 year old man comes down and dead eyes you and your whole battle buddies
John Marston: that’s my boy
As someone who has played Battlefield 1 (which is about WW1) i can confirm this is literally how it happened.
Fighting in ww1 would complete jack marston's entire character arc
0:53 hell let loose US victory song
Over there
@@ricoriquelme1792we’re coming over
Very well done, dint know rdr2 was capabel of such things, the angles werey very nice an you somhow captured lots of emoitions in yor shots. very nice
I always thought this would be an epic idea. Jack flees to Canada after killing Ross. Enlists with the Canadians and fights. Comes back and the game takes place in the Canadian wilderness.
yes, and perhaps the intro cutscene could explain why he was there, and there could be WWI flashback segments once or twice throughout the game
Honestly RDR 3 could work with Jack being a U.S. Army soldier in the First World War. Think his family spent years fighting laws and civilization. Now the ultimate redemption is the rejection of outlaws and the embracing of order.
IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!!!!!
so fckn sick…. WOW,, added to favorites
this was a great video man, can’t wait to see more
How would Jack join the US army after they killed Uncle and John…
Drafted
Lmao, that Renault FT is amazing. 😂
This would be perfect for rdr3
All my brain can think of when it sees the tank walking is "You can tell by the way I walk I'm a woman's man, no time to talk."
Incredible how you put more effort in one video than Rockstar ever put in Red Dead Online!
Jack, in the trench: “I remember uncle Arthur, and his wise words.”
Dream sequence Arthur: “you, sir, are a fish.
2:35 Why is the tank walking??
Tired of running
This would be such a amazing dlc! Keep up the great work!
love it, but it bothers me that they all have repeaters and handguns... didnt the americans use the springfield? and officers had revolvers or 1911s instead of your average joe?
As a man whose father was killed by the Federal Government and, in response, ended up killing a former Agent of the Federal Government, I can't imagine Jack would not dodge the draft.
Nice
great video! Loved it!! Rockstar needs to make a Jack WWI DLC story. I don't care if its on the rails or less than 10 hrs but we need some more Jack adventures. With the planes and tanks and everything!!
awesome!
Probably most of the soldiers used bolt action rifles, but I can’t complain, this too good
come on bro why did you spoil rdr3 lol
I like how later on jack gets a 1000 yard stare
Your so amazingly genius! I love this video much your camera angles and the mods and the way you did everything is top tier , you should be ecstatic about yourself man I love this!!!!!!!
Them walking tanks killed me
jack being drafted to ww1 would be an insane suicide story
The tank be like:🚶🚶🕺🕺🍑 amazing work on this mod
It was already outdated but as a " screen use " prop the Krag Jorgensen bolt action rifle would have been a way more historically accurate choice : Because lever action such as the Yellow boy has seen service only unofficially with 1870's cavalry in the USA only.
Agreed I don't get how some other people in the comments are calling this extremely historical accurate
@@HunterRamirez-rl3by Yeah ! Even at the time if weapons available were scarce for some reasons the U.S soldiers would use a trapdoor Springfield for trench warfare instead of a Winchester !
When you see the tanks walking up onto the battlefield you best get to running lmao. 😂
By the way solid video!
late to the party but the last ww1 us vet was Frank Buckles (1901-2011) god bless you sir
Absolutely amazing. The more I watched the more I got choked this isn't real.
The video is so good and I can tell you put a lot of effort
Cool mods and video.
I loved the walking tanks😁
Arthur just one more war
"Y'know, the day he died, I told my pa that one of them machines up there could turn men in to angels; but now all they seem to be doing is bombing us all to hell."
Я только недавно задумывался, каким мог бы быть сиквел про Джека, участвующего в Первой мировой, здорово, что мне это попалось
I love this because I always imagined jack lived on to fight in the Great War being roughly 22
The tank animation is hilarious. It’s like the way you had to advance the plastic tank for an Army men set lol, wobble and walk it forward lol 😂 I know it was created by you lol but some things to note the hand crank Gatling gun was never used in WWI. By then it was obsolete. You had the Vickers and the Maxim. Both belt fed. And operated with a trigger mechanism. The only lever action gun that I know of in WWI was the Martini Henry, and it wasn’t that widely used. The Germans used the Gewehr 98 and the British used the Lee Enfield Mark 4 No. 1 and the Americans used the Springfield 1908. All were bolt action rifles. Side arms were the P08 Luger, and a Luger made revolver. For the Germans. The British used the Webly revolver made by Lee Enfield, and the Americans had the only semi automatic pistol the 1911 made by Colt. Tanks were the German No. 1 which looked like a big box on caterpillar tractor tracks, with 4 10 pound guns form a naval vessel. The British used the Mark 1 that looked like a trapezoid on caterpillar tractor tracks. The British design was actually superior for the type of fighting. Cause the trapezoid design allowed the tank to cross over trenches without falling in them or getting stuck. It was armed with 10 pound naval gun on one side and a machine gun on the other side. Being the first tank ever designed, it also gave birth to the idea of a tank being equipped to defend against both armor and infantry. The German tank was strictly anti armor, and if it tried to cross a trench it would fall in and be stuck in it. Forcing the crew to abandon it. Kinda of a wasteful design. German tank crews had to learn to keep it away from the trenches, massively reducing its mobility stats, compared to the British Mk. 1. But WWI, was the first war ever with tank warfare, so designing tanks was a massive learning curve for every country involved. In 1918 the Germans developed an antitank rifle that basically looked like an upscaled Gewehr 98 with a pistol grip and tripod. It fired a 13x99mm cartridge with an armor piercing steel cored bullet, that proved to be effective against the British Mk. 1 tank. From about 200 yards it could penetrate into a British Mk. 1 tank, and once inside it bounced around inside killing the crew inside pretty nasty results.
The song at the very start reminded me of "Wild West history be like", and I nearly started laughing
the tanks are so funny 🤣 Good Video! really cool
The fact you put Over there in this makes this 10 times better
Rdr3 they should make a story line with Jack where he gets drafted and sees through WW1
Very good work, love it. A great and sad story for Jack after the tragedy that surrounded him, tho
wow what a nice make of this. God bless you .this makes me want a red dead game during the civil war , how nice would that be. considering ww1 game is a totally different genre and would get its own title out of rockstar .
Crazy thing is this is what I wanted for the prologue of RDR3. Jack in WWI then the game being prohibition era and depression era gangster story.
Awesome work man ! Had the same idea as soon the plane and tank dropped, but I can't top this 😁 !
Bro the tank when they moved is funny but keep the good work man
Jack could have lived long enough to see the moon landing on live tv.
Imagine seeing a man take out your platoon in the span of a couple seconds
this video must be written into the wwI history..
Those tanks are so cute 😂. Nonetheless, great video, as always, man.
Jack having a motorcycle before or after WWI be cool
This gotta be the next red dead game WW1 baby 🎉
In RDR3 jack returns from the war a broken traumatized man and now sees that his home is long gone and now must survive in a new age if crime. This game takes place from 1917 to 1922.
And, once Jack returns, he finds out America had become authoritarian thanks to Sedition Act of 1918...
WILSOOOOON!!
@TheStarcoMarco farmers getting driven off their land homesteads being destroyed and government thugs dragging people outta their homes in the middle of the night. This would make for an interesting plot in RDR3. We went from the old west, the dying west, and now the dead west.
This is the most historically accurate video on WWI ever released.
this would actually be so cool as a game. Do a few missions at Beechers Hope, then Jack gets drafted into the war, makes very good friends along the way, typical rockstar makes us bond with them and has them killed, then jack comes back home, etc.
Enjoyed this a lot actually, good work ❤
Your animation is execelent and thank you for the final prhase, many people have forgiven the millions of persons dead to take the liberty