@@Ravagerblade why did he let her to stay on the ship for 5 years then? Let's be honest Wano ending was very rushed and left a lot of plot threads unresolved
It’s crazy that after all these years, the strawhats are finally about to travel the seas again without any other people that aren’t in the actual crew on board or without the crew being separated in different groups. It’s actually surreal to me
True. It's also surreal to me that they don't have any next targetisland in their journey. Since Punk Hazard they always had an idea where they must go next. Now they will wonder the sea without a clear aim to go where ever they want to go.
I am beyond glad that Toei made those two extra episodes to make the ending of Wano feel way less rushed and to give us a chance to properly say goodbye to those characters. Carrot especially was done beyond dirty.
Thank you Toei for adding this scene, Oda may not have seen Carrot as Straw Hat potential but god damn did we need at least some acknowledgement of the time and bond she had with the crew.
More like Oda was rushing to wrap up Wano. Often times he has lamented scenes he wanted to do but got lost in deadlines. He's not one to snub a character intentionally.
@@XenoJehuty84 I don't think I have the talent Oda does but I felt like the minks could've set sail at the same time and Carrot could've been right in the background saying goodbye before the Momo scene.
@@XenoJehuty84 Oh yeah I get that, with recent chapters it looks like he has left a lot of spots for the "anime" to fill in. Still sad about Carrot but whatever.
Carrot got shafted so hard. Didnt get to avenge pedro, and then gets kicked out with a consolation prize of being queen. She didnt deserve any of this.
For a character like her that's not even a consolation prize, she was introduced as someone who craves for adventure and now she's stuck in a place being some kind of ruler, Oda just didn't know what to do with her anymore, she would have been better off forming her own crew of mink explorers like Pedro did and look for some clues of "the dawn of the world" or something like that while being part of the straw hats allied fleet
@@rafaeljmc6313 lol right. I genuinely think Oda turned out to not like Carrot and just wanted her out of the picture. She was absolutely not the type to want to sit back and rule. She craved adventure. It feels like he set her up to be a legitimate Straw Hat candidate but turned out not to like her very much so he did this as a way to get her away from the crew for good.
Based on Pedro's "Someday you'll see why it was necessary to help Luffy and his friends escape" and "Everyone gets their moment" this is not the end of it.
I'm sure we'll see her again in the final saga. Still sad she never joined the crew officially though. Even though she could be considered to be part of the Straw Hat Fleet I would have loved for her to be the crew's main look out.
It's rather unfair, Inuarashi and Nekomamushi got to have plenty of adventures with Oden when they were with Whitebeard and Roger's crews. Carrot has been to two places, Tot Land and Wano (three if you count that Marine base from the mini Filler arc). As for Pedro's Will, he wanted to see the dawn of the new era which if Carrot could've joined the StrawHats she'd be there to see it in Pedro's stead.
I legitimately think Oda initially wrote Carrot to be the last Straw Hat member but ended up not liking her for some reason and wanted her out of the picture. She was not set up as a ruler type character. She craved adventure. I think Oda just really wanted to do this as a way to get her away from the Strawhats for good.
She was a *perfect* candidate to join the straw hats, she has a great chemistry with all of them, and gets along with the crew specially with Luffy, Nami, Chopper and Brook
She was never going to be a straw hat. And as far as still joining she had 8 years and nothing happened. This scene is definitive and final. She’s taken the job and willingly became ruler of her home country. So it’s goodbye to her tell the final war. 🐰🥕🫡
I will forever be salty about Oda not including Carrot as part of the Strawhats. The only narrative move he's ever pulled that i'm 100% against in every way.
There really isn't room for 1, let alone 2 more straw hats. Wano was inflated enough with 1 chapter fights because every single character needs something to do.
To me this is such a cop out answer, yes certain crew members would not get as much shine but that doesn’t mean they can’t be on the crew. Oda could remove the focus that non important characters get and put it towards the crew.
No she won’t be missed. She was a literal waste of time and effort that went to where. Thank god she’s the queen of zoa. Can’t image her being the final straw hat. 🤢
It makes zero sense, she was introduced as someone who craves for adventure and now she's stuck in a place being some kind of ruler while also she's 15 and is not the sharpest tool in the shed, Oda just didn't know what to do with her anymore, she would have been better off forming her own crew of mink explorers like Pedro did and look for some clues of "the dawn of the world" or something like that while being part of the straw hats allied fleet
It kind of makes no sense to me as well for her to be a leader They couldn’t ask I forgot her name the dog woman to be the leader because she was more of a leader than carrot
Key word being real time. She's only around for about 6 wewks, maybe 8 in universe time, while Vivi had a whole saga and was there for about 3 or more months. Carrot is cool, but she never feel the same as Vivi imo
@@frostyblade8842Vivi may have been the centerpiece of that arc, but Carrot's bond feels stronger on a personal level, and with individual members of the crew.
I thought she would have been a perfect main stay pick for permanent strawhat! She would’ve been a great lookout with all the time she spent on the crows nest. Her abilities, race, and even her gender would add a lot of diversity to the crew. And her dynamic and personality was a great fit for the strawhats too. I’m gonna miss her! Can’t wait to see how she leads the minks though.
I mean, Spot for a proper Lookout on the 1000 sunny is still open. It’s the same with Jimbey, before he joined technically everyone was steersman, but now a real pro is at the Job.
Pedro: "Keep moving forward!" Perospero: "Go back to Zou and chew on some grass!" I guess the Dukes meant she carries Perospero's will, not Pedro's. What a complete clownery of a story.
I truly think Oda has a limit on how many people he wants in the Strawhats. Carrot was bieng built up to be part of the Strawhats, Then Yamoto. Now Bonney. Goddamn it Oda make up your mind!
Bonney is undoubtedly just the brand new supernova that tye crew us befriending , the fans are the ones who are insisting that Bonney is joining , oda ain't setting up anything with that. If Bonney is gonna join any group , it be the revolutionary army
I still think Carrot should have been the final crewmate. She's more than earned her stripes, perhaps moreso than anybody else that qualified to be on the ship.
The fact that Carrot didn't have any big moments and was never featured in any of the following OPs post Whole Cake Island like Jimbei made it clear she wasn't joining the crew, as much as we would have liked.
My best guess is that oda didn't give carrot a goodbye was because (HOPEFULLY) he plans on bringing her back soon to officially join, therefore a goodbye would be pointless right?
ahh man Carrot could've been one of the Straw Hats....but I'm glad Carrot help them out big time and I'm really gonna miss her. But I'm glad she had a very great time
Carrot should've joined but we're probably gonna see her again, she may have experience being on the seas which is why Dog and Cat said she's the next leader of Zou, but I still think she needs more experience plus she also carries Pedro's will as well, plus she was a great lookout for the strawhats with her role at the crow's nest of the Sunny.
I understand Carrot not joining the Strawhats but what I don't get is why was she chosen to rule Zou, for me at least it felt kinda forced upon her and not something she truly wanted
I don’t think this was a good move by Oda. Carrot fit the crew perfectly and she even said she wanted to see the sea. I’m not buying that she was satisfied by just going to a couple new islands. It was fun while it lasted anyways.😢
Thank the lord in heaven above no one else is in charge but oda. Having carrot join as the last member would have been unbearable. This whole thing could have turned into a massive fanfic if this rodent managed to weasel her way into the crew. Crisis averted and all is right in the world so thank you oda. 🫡🙏🥹
I'm gonna miss her. She brought a lot of youth to a group of old soldiers, but perhaps it's for the best. As strong as Carrot is in her own right, she wouldn't fair well against the likes of Blackbeard and beyond.
She spent more time with the crew than freaking Jinbe, it doesn't make any sense for her character to not join and it feels just wrong that Luffy doesn't have any real mink on his crew :/
I felt sad so sad for Carrot at the scene when Jinbei joins the strawhats and they're are about exchange cups together. Carrot is nowhere to be seen during this even though we know she was on the ship when Jinbei first shows up. I keep imagining her cryin on the floor somewhere inside the Sunny 😂
Watch episode 1084 here! got.cr/cc-op1084
I really wanted her to officially join The Straw Hat Crew.
@@jessetorres8738True
Carrot united straw hat?
I like how Toei straight up acknowledged that Oda messed up by no giving Carrot a proper goodbye
I don't consider it a mess up, Oda knew carrot was unimportant.
@@Ravagerblade why did he let her to stay on the ship for 5 years then? Let's be honest Wano ending was very rushed and left a lot of plot threads unresolved
@@vovabars1234 Carrot was barely a thing in Wano. Carrot was only in WCI for the Alice in Wonderland vibe.
@@Ravagerblade which again, makes people question why Oda even included her in Wano if she barely does stuff there
@@vovabars1234 Because the Minks were apart of the Alliance, are you really not grasping this?
It’s crazy that after all these years, the strawhats are finally about to travel the seas again without any other people that aren’t in the actual crew on board or without the crew being separated in different groups. It’s actually surreal to me
True. It's also surreal to me that they don't have any next targetisland in their journey. Since Punk Hazard they always had an idea where they must go next. Now they will wonder the sea without a clear aim to go where ever they want to go.
Don't forget about Caribou
What makes this story a truly great one. You can go on the journey with them.
Sheesh its been like 10 years hasnt it? Thats insane
Indeed. After spending so much time with Law and Carrot. The fact that they will no longer be with the strawhats doesn’t feel real
I am beyond glad that Toei made those two extra episodes to make the ending of Wano feel way less rushed and to give us a chance to properly say goodbye to those characters. Carrot especially was done beyond dirty.
Thank you Toei for adding this scene, Oda may not have seen Carrot as Straw Hat potential but god damn did we need at least some acknowledgement of the time and bond she had with the crew.
I feel like this was Toei being like damn she not joining lol
@@qncymrtn SPOILER:
Gonna have another scene for next week if that's what is going on.
More like Oda was rushing to wrap up Wano. Often times he has lamented scenes he wanted to do but got lost in deadlines. He's not one to snub a character intentionally.
@@XenoJehuty84 I don't think I have the talent Oda does but I felt like the minks could've set sail at the same time and Carrot could've been right in the background saying goodbye before the Momo scene.
@@XenoJehuty84 Oh yeah I get that, with recent chapters it looks like he has left a lot of spots for the "anime" to fill in. Still sad about Carrot but whatever.
She and vivi are still honorary members in my heart 😭
No they arent. one of the most annoying female characters are not honorary members
@@talal3c*is
Good for u
@@talal3c ok!? Thats cool and all and things and stuff but...,, WHO ASKED! + WHO CARES
@@Idkwhatgrassmeans ur never getting 100k subs buddy 😂😂😂
She was crying in the thumbnail because Toei cared about her more than Oda
Yeah... that with Carrot felt very rushed. It's like Oda wanted close this chapter with Carrot as fast as possible.
Carrot got shafted so hard. Didnt get to avenge pedro, and then gets kicked out with a consolation prize of being queen. She didnt deserve any of this.
For a character like her that's not even a consolation prize, she was introduced as someone who craves for adventure and now she's stuck in a place being some kind of ruler, Oda just didn't know what to do with her anymore, she would have been better off forming her own crew of mink explorers like Pedro did and look for some clues of "the dawn of the world" or something like that while being part of the straw hats allied fleet
@@rafaeljmc6313 lol right. I genuinely think Oda turned out to not like Carrot and just wanted her out of the picture. She was absolutely not the type to want to sit back and rule. She craved adventure. It feels like he set her up to be a legitimate Straw Hat candidate but turned out not to like her very much so he did this as a way to get her away from the crew for good.
Carrot joining the crew would’ve made a lot of sense but I doubt this is the last time we will see her
Not really. We gonna see her in final battle or in a reaction montage of luffy’s bounty/news
How come it would have made sense?
@@r12j78 it felt like she had a lot of chemistry with the crew already and she’d be a unique member like everyone else on the sunny.
@@toasterbath2069 the real question is what role would she play
@@Kinta17The lookout
Carrot you'll be missed and you had your moment in the sun too.
In the moon too.
I will miss her too
Based on Pedro's "Someday you'll see why it was necessary to help Luffy and his friends escape" and "Everyone gets their moment" this is not the end of it.
So sad we won't see this little bunny again 😢
Don’t say never. Zou could be useful in the end and may join luffys grand fleet
I'm sure we'll see her again in the final saga. Still sad she never joined the crew officially though. Even though she could be considered to be part of the Straw Hat Fleet I would have loved for her to be the crew's main look out.
Knowing One Piece we probably will for a big or final battle!
Well then, what about "we won"t see her for a very, very long time"?
You forget.
This isn't any series that just forgets characters.
Carrot deserved to be part of the crew😭
Oda played with our heart strings on the Whole Cake Island Arc, wanting us to hope that Carrot joined the Straw Hats by the end of Wano.
I’m glad she wasn’t added.
@@hydqjuliilq27ok cool you’re just a hater
I'm gonna miss Carrot so much especially her whole adorable sibling-like relationship w/ Chopper🐰🦌❤
It's rather unfair, Inuarashi and Nekomamushi got to have plenty of adventures with Oden when they were with Whitebeard and Roger's crews. Carrot has been to two places, Tot Land and Wano (three if you count that Marine base from the mini Filler arc). As for Pedro's Will, he wanted to see the dawn of the new era which if Carrot could've joined the StrawHats she'd be there to see it in Pedro's stead.
They definitely should have given her more time to adventure before becoming the ruler.
I legitimately think Oda initially wrote Carrot to be the last Straw Hat member but ended up not liking her for some reason and wanted her out of the picture. She was not set up as a ruler type character. She craved adventure. I think Oda just really wanted to do this as a way to get her away from the Strawhats for good.
Carrot will forever remain the biggest cinnamon roll of the straw hat crew. Even if she isn't in the Straw Hat Crew.
Carrot should of joined... that's what Pedro would have wanted
Yeah Oda, so much for Carrot carrying Pedro’s will 🫤
How stupid do you have to be to dig up a fictional character’s grave to guilt an author into doing something he clearly didn’t want to do.
This is basically the last time we'll hear Carrot call Chopper Choniki.
It’s downright criminal Carrot didn’t join the crew
She was a very fun character to bad she couldn't join the crew
She was a *perfect* candidate to join the straw hats, she has a great chemistry with all of them, and gets along with the crew specially with Luffy, Nami, Chopper and Brook
She had been with the crew for so long I already kinda considered her part of it
I 100% believe she would have been a perfect addition to the straw hats, but i'm also positive that we will see her again
She was never going to be a straw hat. And as far as still joining she had 8 years and nothing happened.
This scene is definitive and final. She’s taken the job and willingly became ruler of her home country. So it’s goodbye to her tell the final war. 🐰🥕🫡
I will forever be salty about Oda not including Carrot as part of the Strawhats. The only narrative move he's ever pulled that i'm 100% against in every way.
There really isn't room for 1, let alone 2 more straw hats. Wano was inflated enough with 1 chapter fights because every single character needs something to do.
To me this is such a cop out answer, yes certain crew members would not get as much shine but that doesn’t mean they can’t be on the crew. Oda could remove the focus that non important characters get and put it towards the crew.
@@durpanda123 Luffy said he wanted 10 crewmates from the beginning. There will be one more
I think you forgot about pell. He should have stayed dead. Never liked that he survived a huge explosion.
Carrot is like Vivi. They both developed and got experience from sailing with the crew that will help them rule their kingdoms.
Goodbye carrot, we'll miss you and we'll always love you 😭🤍🧡💚🐰🥕
I will never forgive GOda for leaving Carrot behind.
Carrot will always be an honorary staw hat in my herat 💖
We're gonna miss Carrot ❤😭😭😭😭😭
Especially her Mommy Form, I mean.. Sulong form 👀
She was awesome
@@austincox8506 For real!❤🐇👍
Don’t worry. We will see her again.
No she won’t be missed. She was a literal waste of time and effort that went to where. Thank god she’s the queen of zoa. Can’t image her being the final straw hat. 🤢
😢💔 We'll miss you, Carrot! Best of luck in your new chapter! 🥕👋
Carrot as leader of the Minks makes no sense. There was no buildup or development.
Makes sense for now. Wano needs defences from invaders. That's the whole reason.
It makes zero sense, she was introduced as someone who craves for adventure and now she's stuck in a place being some kind of ruler while also she's 15 and is not the sharpest tool in the shed, Oda just didn't know what to do with her anymore, she would have been better off forming her own crew of mink explorers like Pedro did and look for some clues of "the dawn of the world" or something like that while being part of the straw hats allied fleet
It kind of makes no sense to me as well for her to be a leader They couldn’t ask I forgot her name the dog woman to be the leader because she was more of a leader than carrot
I dont understand why carrot is not considered a straw hat like vivi, she was in the crew like almost 8 years in real time
Key word being real time. She's only around for about 6 wewks, maybe 8 in universe time, while Vivi had a whole saga and was there for about 3 or more months. Carrot is cool, but she never feel the same as Vivi imo
@@frostyblade8842Vivi may have been the centerpiece of that arc, but Carrot's bond feels stronger on a personal level, and with individual members of the crew.
@@frostyblade8842wano is 1 year after the timeskip..
5 years in Wano and now we’re saying goodbye
It was more like more than 4 years, wasn’t it?
I thought she would have been a perfect main stay pick for permanent strawhat! She would’ve been a great lookout with all the time she spent on the crows nest. Her abilities, race, and even her gender would add a lot of diversity to the crew. And her dynamic and personality was a great fit for the strawhats too. I’m gonna miss her! Can’t wait to see how she leads the minks though.
It's hard to say goodbye but a new Arc awaits
I really wanted her to join the Straw Hat crew, but I am going to miss Carrot 🥕 so thanks for coming along with them
I mean, Spot for a proper Lookout on the 1000 sunny is still open.
It’s the same with Jimbey, before he joined technically everyone was steersman, but now a real pro is at the Job.
0:05 She is one "Ca" away from beating Freeza.
Goodbye, Carrot. You will be missed. 💔😭
It’s not goodbye. It’s until we meet again
Pedro: "Keep moving forward!"
Perospero: "Go back to Zou and chew on some grass!"
I guess the Dukes meant she carries Perospero's will, not Pedro's. What a complete clownery of a story.
Based.
It would be cliche if she joined the crew now. She's tecnicly part of the crew but not for now. Since Dressrosa straw hats have been growing.
that actually made me sad. she fits so perfect to the strawhats. in every way
I'm convinced that Carrot only didn't get to join because her powers were simple and her backstory wasn't tragic enough.
It may be sad that we won't see Carrot again but at least she got to make a lot of memories with Luffy, and the crew.
We will miss you Carrot 😢😢
I truly think Oda has a limit on how many people he wants in the Strawhats. Carrot was bieng built up to be part of the Strawhats, Then Yamoto. Now Bonney. Goddamn it Oda make up your mind!
Also Vivi flying around close by too.
Bonney definitely joining. The last big role the Strawhats need is a cabin boy/girl & Bonney being 12 fits that role the best.
Bonney is undoubtedly just the brand new supernova that tye crew us befriending , the fans are the ones who are insisting that Bonney is joining , oda ain't setting up anything with that. If Bonney is gonna join any group , it be the revolutionary army
This was such a letdown but I’m glad the scene got added.
I still think Carrot should have been the final crewmate. She's more than earned her stripes, perhaps moreso than anybody else that qualified to be on the ship.
I can think of one other character that deserves it more...
@@ReiseLukasname them.
@@thrillflame4471 Kuma
@@thrillflame4471bon chan
@@ReiseLukas Kuma wouldn’t want to join Luffy. He has other priorities. Like Bonneys safety and the revolutionaries
And i thought it hurt when vivi left
She fit in too well with the crew
We’ll Miss You, Carrot 👍🥺🤩☺️😊🥕🥕🥕🤍🤍🤍
I seriously doubt this is the last time we see our Mink friends
We'll definitely see Zou again, how soon that'll be who can say?
The fact that Carrot didn't have any big moments and was never featured in any of the following OPs post Whole Cake Island like Jimbei made it clear she wasn't joining the crew, as much as we would have liked.
Seeing made me realize that carrot been with us for AWHILE
Imagine having a literal doctor tell you "thanks for teaching me medicine and stuff"
My best guess is that oda didn't give carrot a goodbye was because (HOPEFULLY) he plans on bringing her back soon to officially join, therefore a goodbye would be pointless right?
Carrot was such a fun and cute character, it's too bad she doesn't join the crew!
I couldn’t sleep the night I figured out carrot wouldn’t be in the next arc 😢
NO!! Your supposed to join the crew dammit!!!!
Carrot and Pedro are definitely honorary strawhat members😢😢
She was an amazing asset though the whole cake arc and the wano arc. I almost that Carrot would be a member of straw hats hope we see her again.
Brook: "Parting is such sweet sorrow, it always brings a tear to my eyes. Although I don't have eyes. Skull joke! Yohohohoho!"
ahh man Carrot could've been one of the Straw Hats....but I'm glad Carrot help them out big time and I'm really gonna miss her. But I'm glad she had a very great time
carrot as well as yamatone joining woul d have been dope
Carrot would've been a great strawhat member 😭😭
Yeah…that’s a hard no on that one…🤦♂️😓🤢
Carrot should've joined but we're probably gonna see her again, she may have experience being on the seas which is why Dog and Cat said she's the next leader of Zou, but I still think she needs more experience plus she also carries Pedro's will as well, plus she was a great lookout for the strawhats with her role at the crow's nest of the Sunny.
Somewhere out there, Sanji is writhing in pain because he missed the opportunity to "Garchu" again.
I can’t believe carrot won’t be with the strawhats anymore. Same thing with Law it feels surreal
I understand Carrot not joining the Strawhats but what I don't get is why was she chosen to rule Zou, for me at least it felt kinda forced upon her and not something she truly wanted
honestly thought she was going to join, like a scout
Sending love to all the people who wanted Carrot to join the straw hats crew.💔 She would have been perfect.
I don’t understand Oda’s decisions.🙄
Many good characters came and went. I'm secretly hoping theres at least one more member.
Love this series 😊😊❤❤❤
I don’t think this was a good move by Oda. Carrot fit the crew perfectly and she even said she wanted to see the sea. I’m not buying that she was satisfied by just going to a couple new islands. It was fun while it lasted anyways.😢
it was a great move by oda tf??? This is why hes the author and not you. stay quiet
Thank the lord in heaven above no one else is in charge but oda. Having carrot join as the last member would have been unbearable.
This whole thing could have turned into a massive fanfic if this rodent managed to weasel her way into the crew. Crisis averted and all is right in the world so thank you oda. 🫡🙏🥹
1:08 needs to be a gif
im gonna miss carrot, she was so amazing as a character. I hope we get to see her again soon enough in the series.
Something tells me we've haven't seen the last of her yet...
Carrot giving that whole cake island vibe..
WE MISS YOU CARROT
Seeing the WCI flashback got me teary-eyed, she really has been with us for so long 😢
Was surprised that this scene was added
No way did Chopper just admit it made him happy :O
It's a goodbye after all
I'm gonna miss her. She brought a lot of youth to a group of old soldiers, but perhaps it's for the best. As strong as Carrot is in her own right, she wouldn't fair well against the likes of Blackbeard and beyond.
She spent more time with the crew than freaking Jinbe, it doesn't make any sense for her character to not join and it feels just wrong that Luffy doesn't have any real mink on his crew :/
Awesome One Piece Video.
It crazy to think that after 10 years, this is only the second time luffy sets sail with no destinations in mind in The New World.
Esa fue una despedida muy triste Luffy y Carrot ❤💛 su relacion es muy linda
Time for cliché line: “The journey is the treasure.” 😂
She actually fits well. Another girl and she isn’t prey to Sanji or Brook
Hope to see you again Baby Carrot
I really wanted her to officially join The Straw Hat Crew
Carrot kinda was a Crew Member, just not a permanent one.
Seeing this and knowing Oda didn't have her join the Straw Hats makes me so fricking angry!
This was a filler episode that was absolutely needed. We got to say goodbye to many important characters and received closure for the wano arc.
I'm going to miss her so much 😢😢😢😢😢
It feels like a slap in the face, this farewell so insipid that Oda must have said "if you do whatever you want, the rabbit won't come back."
Im not crying, you're crying! 😭😭
See you in the final battle, Carrot, that's a promise, ok? 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Carrot should've joined
She joined the alliance for the final war.
Man I am going to miss them so much. Can’t believe we are at this point already.
squirrel chick lookin nice >.>
It's crazy to think, in the canon of One Piece, basically everything post Time Skip has taken place in the span of like 2 months max.
I felt sad so sad for Carrot at the scene when Jinbei joins the strawhats and they're are about exchange cups together. Carrot is nowhere to be seen during this even though we know she was on the ship when Jinbei first shows up. I keep imagining her cryin on the floor somewhere inside the Sunny 😂