WSDC 2011 England vs Scotland
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2012
- A quarter final debate from the World Schools Debating Championships, held in Dundee, Scotland.
The motion is 'This House Supports Free Immigration'
England is proposition and Scotland is opposition
This video is not my own.
Scotland win the debate 4 -1 - บันเทิง
![ช้างศึกสู้ต่อไป!! พาเปียโน ดูบอลไทยครั้งแรก ตกรอบแบบโคตรเสียดาย!! l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4WloIH645Lg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Intelligence-High School Debate] Ep.14 - To be Global Citizens Instead of Instilling Nationalism](/img/n.gif)
I laugh every time one of them says "no thank you" and dismisses any rebuttals with a wave of the hand. I want to see more of that.
POI's, not rebuttals, but yeah me too
Professional Bathroom Singer what does poi stand for
karan abrol Point of Information.
*point of interruption
_ Naufaldi141 _ Pretty sure it's Point Of Information, maybe there's two meanings
I think everyone deserves to know that the first Scottish speaker is my Geography teacher and he no longer has that hair, it is rather short now :)))
jung hopeseok wah, time flies so fast, isn’t it?
@@anggellachristoferisa1528 fs
I wish i could just make my hand wave and make my classmates sit down and shut up😂
Okay, I just want to make this clear to people who are saying "skirks" they're not skirks they are called Kikts. You can bash me or whatever, but I really don't care. I hate it when people do this. I'm proud of my Scottish heritage. Thanks, have a nice day.
'Kikts' lol
It auto corrected it. It's supposed to be "kilts"** lol
So it's some sort of a skirt?
nah, its more like skirts
Scotland probably had a flag so that their skirts would be hidden
wow i was angry
People are not making fun of your country traditional clothing
but theyre not skirts
Grouch RACIST ALERT, he was just making a joke, you're vile.
+Flame Thrower I just read a comment war saying some pro-English stuff that is pretty offensive to scots (btw you lost) but if you are so English then why constantly watch video about Scotland? You can certainly tell where Salmond is coming from when he says he wants to get away from you guys...
First Speaker Aff: 4:08
First Speaker Neg: 13:19
Second Speaker Aff: 11:14
Second Speaker Neg: 31:55
thank you 😄
thanks 😄
Ellie Rogers It's GOV and OPP.
btw what is the motion, thank u
Who else just watched this to hear their accents?
Kayla Moehn 🐇✋
First opposition speaker: We think..... Ladies and gentlemen, We think...... Ladies and gentlemen
on the other hand it gives both him, the speaker, and the audience a pause in the stream of information
As a bit of a "ladies and gentlemanner" myself, I think it's a poor man's pause. It's easier for you vocal chords and keeps you speaking, but ultimately it would be way better to just hold a pause _between_ statements rather than a "ladies and gentlemen" _interrupting_ them.
i'm not sure. For me, pauses are inconsistent as they are just a blank, it's a bit awkward as i have to wait for the speaker to continue or give me any other cue for his stream of thought. instead, i end up contemplating the given information and trailing off. Then they keep talking but i'm already somewhere else and i need to catch up and figure out if what they're saying is related to what was said previously or a new, or slightly different, topic. "L&G" is a clear "i'm done. now, listen here". The guy here might've overused it, thought. it's a lack of other sign words and connectors that harms him.
KGAUAMSFSI HE'S MY GEOGRAPHY TEACHER
Hermione Granger is that you?!
Omgggggggg Lmaooo. I was about to make this comment 😭😭😭😭😭 she sounds and looks like her.
Excellent debate. What a shame that the video cut out for the last English speaker. Is there a part 2?
OMG!!! Their English accents were just *AWESOME !*
Was the first speaker of Scotland rapping? I couldn't really catch what he said, tbh.
I think, ladies and gentlemen
WHAT? Where's the rest? Please upload. I need resolution!
th-cam.com/video/n_9A7PDEBjE/w-d-xo.html
Kindly upload the scond part already,mate :((
I am eagerly looking forward to it...
Dont want to miss out on the last speeches :(((((
PLEASEEEEE!
Lmao 9 years ago
I'm here to test how good I'm as non native at comprehending English
Very curious if any of these debaters have changed or entrenched in their views.
wheres the second part? its been about 8 months already :/
Are you still trying to post the second part? :(
7 years later were England was all about Brexit...
Where is the finished speech of third speakers?
please tell me I'm not the only one watching partially due to their accents... *-*
Oh my god ... where's the rest ?
I think Scotland won because England make it sound like everything is perfect and everything is the best when you let immigrants in . However that's not the case and Scotland easily rebutted that . Scotland's points were more strong . But I gotta see the rest to be sure 😫😫😫
th-cam.com/video/n_9A7PDEBjE/w-d-xo.html
The description says Scotland won
Alright, but no need to invoke God in this comment
@@iulianion5565 in 2022, the link says the video isn't available. Do you happen to know where we can watch the rest of the 2011 debate?
@@yaolika Unfortunately I can not find it either.
how does anyone get involved in this?
When the POI they're hand are really low and its hard to tell what they are doing
What about the third speaker?
A bit behind the curve, but if anyone watching this someday knows where to watch the third and reply speeches...
Why isn't debate like this in the US?
22:40 and wonderful beaming smiles from the Nepalese
does anyone know what the first speaker said at 9:46 when the guy tried to present a point of information all i heard was alfie and skirt
She said, "Alfie you may not look better than me in a skirt than I do, that is why I'm not taking the POI"
may not- meaning you are not allowed.
How does that make sense tho +hic sunt PHi
I know xD haha. Well It was something like that, because it wasn't clear. the point is clear though.
What did the girl named Alice say to the Scotland boy, that made everyone laugh?
he looked better in the skirt than she did so she didnt want to take that poi
Would really appreciate if someone organize core parts of 2nd speech for non English speaker like meㅠㅠ
God bless you and must go to heaven
The first guy in Scotland talked so fast
can anyone tell me what the first speaker was saying around 6:57 after "because where you are born"
+Seonie Yi i think she said because where you were born was random?? maybe
I think they said "is wrong"
I'm an Indonesian and i disapproved the English' PM's statement
Sooo where is Englands flag
I was really enjoying the debate. I gotta know, who won?
Scotland did
Euijin Kwon thanks :)
YES SCOTLAND MY G
This was an great debate. Scotland punchline was irrefutable," free immigration harm they're going to and the one they left behind".
Harm the country they're going to and the one they leave behind.
It's easily refutable. I study economics of migration so it would be unfair to put me against the average school debater on this specific topic but I agree it's a good punchline.
Looking forward.... :-)
did the prime minister stated there parameters and the def.of terms?
Ronette Castillo I don't think so. They're format is different, I guess.
Ronette Castillo this isn't parliamentary debate. It's world schools. It's proposition vs opposition. There don't have to be parameters or def of terms, they are only there if you have an overwhelming broad topic. However, they do actually have them and they're set up when it's stated that the opposition has to prove x to win the round (I believe in this one it is that they have to prove immigration has been bad).
yes, they are implicit.
i guess the 2nd speaker from Scotland talked way too fast and i really need to know who won..
SumAiyA_zayn's_ loving_gf scotland won
OMG..simply the best...
I know there are time limits, but it is rather funny that they talk fast.
isavin1730 They don't talk fast at all. You haven't seen fast.
Or are you just slow...
Very interesting
the second speaker of the opposition whip is "once of a lifetime" score. no further comment!
Can work on framing but really good debate
Ladies and gentlemen... Ladies and gentlemen...
Part 2, Asseblief :)
What quarantine did with me?!
Is this impropmtu or Prepared?
Sarthak Dhingra both
the second speaker from england team is HOT!!
Ashlyn Tan I'd say third England speaker is HAWT
And I loved his style more. He was much more confident.
the third speaker in prop looks like shawn mendes and first off opp looks like harry styles
MAGUAJA HE'S MY GEOGRAPHY TEACHER IMMA TELL HIM
the Harry Styles lookin one
I will do my best, it has failed me the last few times
"no thank you" omg the best :DDDD
wow very impresive
whats the title
It's called motion. n it is: This House Supports Free Immigration
I have the same verbal tick as the 1st opposition speaker, i say "Ladies and Gentlemen" way too much.
i love this video
did Alex make fun of Alfie's skirt? LOL.
Quite funny watching this after Brexit
:( who won?
Scotland
damn i wish we had poi's in australia its so different in europe wow but i would get so pissed with the amount of times 2nd opp declined poi's
the definite 'no thank you's' and elaborate hand waves to pois are my new favourite thing
It is recommended to at least accept 1 poi per pair in a bp debate
That's interesting bc we actually have POIS in NZ
scotland's 1st speaker was too arrogant. he declined so many POI from England's team. btw, their argument so cool
Did you see how many the first England speaker declined?
It's not arrogant.It's up to the speaker to accept or reject the POIs.
the chairperson is so funny😂
Hello....
Now I am going to get admission in this course....
Well your debating language style I am not getting 💁💁😃😃😃
bro thinks she’s emma watson
0:42
By now You should know di wae
This should be about scottish independence
I wonder where the kids on the right are from
Scotland
Alice***
"WONDERFUL BEAMING SMILES FROM THE NEPALESE"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i would have given my vote to england. lol
Yeah super nice
waow prettty kul
What's with them standing up and stuff?
Are you talking about points of information? It's where you can challenge a statement the speaker made if they accept your POI. :) Normally speakers must accept a certain amount of POIs in their speech. :)
hannibaltheveg what is a POI then?
POI is point of information
wow I thought scotland gonna lose
what a nice accent 😍
Pragmatic
Acctually they y'all did in Scotland
omg dpm on england is so so so funny awww
+kyuhee jo ya
Omg. Fisrt affirmative speaker - Stevie from Miranda anyone? lol.
The girl mentioned Indonesia haha
i didn't hear it well, what was she saying about indonesia?
AsaelCharis98 so what ?
AsaelCharis98 apaan sih el!
England, ever heard of Syrians?
+Sma Das considering this was in 2012 and the Syrian refugee crisis was not nearly as chaotic as it is now, I think they should be forgiven for using other examples
ALFIE.
31:55
22:18
Hi
I think ur one of the judges in a comp
Tob1nga!!!!!!!
Scotland speaks to fast
you havent seen fast
Wtf did I just watched
The preposition team is so cool, i don't really think that the winner is opposition):
*proposition
Why is there so much personal opinion in this debate? I think? I feel? Where are the facts and logical arguments? I'm 16 minutes in but. The affirmative gave the weakest emotionally based intro and the negative is not crushing her for it enough. I cant go on.
Saying "I think" and "I feel" to present facts or logical arguments is common practise in debate. Otherwise the case may come off as flippant.
haha brexit...
Hiiiii
It's Leo