Tally Hall -- Hymn for a Scarecrow 8/17/11

Tally Hall performs Hymn for a Scarecrow (by Joe Hawley) at Great Scott in Allston, MA on August 17, 2011. Bora handled the whistling (though he was buried behind Zubin's bass) and Andrew sang Ross's part.

[@loolinonilool]

breaking away from the topic of feelings i do love how ross sings his part even if noone can hear it

[@pho_is_not_interesting]

Wait when does he sing?

[@loolinonilool]

his part is "the wind knows, the wind knows" in the outro. just keep an eye on him at the end of the song.

[@og_eli]

unfortunately he doesn’t sing it in this performance :( you can see andrew singing it on the far left but he still does an amazing job !

[@loolinonilool]

you can pretty clearly see his mouth moving at the requisite part, even if only for a moment

[@PeanutSpring3]

@@loolinonilool I don't see it. I just see Andrew

[@emussanestfan]

1:41 I'M DYIIIINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG I LOVE HIS VOICE

[@fnibbit]

This show was 3 days before the last show they ever played. Tally hall has hit me in the feels once again

[@turkeysandwich123]

SHUT YOUR MOUTH. STOP IT. STOP SPEAKING. SHUT YOUR TRAP. I CANT DO THIS

[@Space_Prince]

You cannot do this to me right now

[@candy_shark]

im gonna cry wtf

[@IsabellaHall-d6h]

Seeing Rob play the weird dissonant sounds is really interesting.

[@chik1k1zou]

Ive always thought it sounded like birds to match the scarecrow theme

[@sentientsid07]

​@@chik1k1zou Same

[@vonpicz]

that moment when real is a feeling and feeling is real

[@DonutProductions.]

watching this after your enemy defeats you and everyone makes fun of you hits different

[@dogfish.dogfish]

real is a feeling and i think im feeling pretty real rn

[@ftroman]

homie hangs around for a living

[@Marigenous_Time]

I feel like I'm in the forest, the sky is dark with a hint of purple and all the stars shine bright it's almost blinding. And I hear a wonderful melody that makes my organs melt in an orange soup as it drifts through the trees. Thank you, Tally Hall.

[@sarooishuman]

ANDREW IS SO BABYGIRL IN THIS

[@TiredEyePilot]

Why do all my favourite bands have to be bands that disbanded? It just hurts me knowing i'll never be able to hear one of these live performances.

[@genericname6724]

ha disBANDed... ha ha ha...

[@Zlash1]

Seriously same. It’s a heartbreaking reality.

[@vivxt6529]

Same, however maybe theres a possibility tally hall might make a return since they never officially broke up, Joe also mentioned on a interview made 2 years ago that a 3rd album is being worked on

[@enkelvind]

@@genericname6724dis band dead

[@genericname6724]

@@enkelvind you are so right...

[@samcolvett6752]

Real is I'm feeling and feeling is real

[@weirdredstone42]

no oh
F E E L I N G

[@MinaWalker]

This song doesn’t sound happy or sad, it sounds poignant. They’re so serious throughout this performance.
3:40

[@jnynv5430]

oh dear it is a feeling

[@butterycake]

This song really makes you feel like you're feeling.

[@JulianCinema]

absolutely wild how this was played on my birthday, and it happens to be my favourite song

[@DonahwithH]

17 days to ur birthday

[@scarfie5877]

happy belated birthday!

[@chorigod8341]

Happy Birthday!! Mine was August 13

[@tatteryt]

happy belated birthday

[@joehawleyjoehawley001]

my birthday is august 20th, their last concert💔😞

[@auking6289]

Oh no it’s a feeling

[@Vari_ram]

i just got done crying here i go again

[@ginger_jenny]

I love this song it makes me feel

[@eh-bc4dx]

oh ho ho is this some sort of.. feeling?

[@EvanStarDream]

I love this comment section, it makes me feel a feeling that is real

[@kitsune630]

I cant stop feeling this

[@StaticFanfare]

right in the goddamn feels

[@loolinonilool]

a feeling? oh no no oh yeah

[@Rap_UpYouTube]

This took place on my 4th birthday lol

[@Zlash1]

I really wish he would perform some of hawaii part 2 live 😭

[@Zlash1]

I wanted to comment “same” until I realized that was my own comment lol

[@scarfie5877]

​@@Zlash1 dw I'll do it for you
same

[@LFLRFPS]

sadly theres no hawaii part ii, but there's variations of a cloud!

[@LFLRFPS]

and if you count it, there's candle on the water

[@Pizza_bagels12]

I think they played the mind electric/inside the mind of Simon at some concerts

[@theseventies3798]

oh no it's that Feeling again

[@Space_Prince]

Im fucking ILL

[@Space_Prince]

I am SICK

[@pretzz3l]

Yo are you still sick

[@Space_Prince]

@@pretzz3l YESSS

[@pretzz3l]

@@Space_Prince DUDE ITS BEEN TWO MONTHS WHAT DO YOU HAVE 😭😭😭

[@Space_Prince]

@@pretzz3l
This made me giggle

[@hvzky]

I can’t decide wether to cry or smile

[@rapvelasco1932]

Most beatifull song ever

[@rhyschomps]

Feel good

[@majojoey]

Oh god this is making me feel

[@nyanopteryx]

i feeling a real and it feel felt

[@x.a.t.u]

feels

[@wahwahster]

4:00

[@SanrioKyujitsu]

no thank you
i do not want to die

[@lakinmarie]

is this- a feeling?

[@MinaWalker]

Yes

[@annaranha]

that feeling again

[@Marigenous_Time]

I fussing crying

[@Marigenous_Time]

I'm feeling rn

[@wahwahster]

I feel
Your mom

[@pop2art]

OwO is dis a feewing? supa swaggo bababuwuy o ya

[@thbf5733]

Wtf

[@pop2art]

HELP I DONT REMEMBER WRITING THIS

[@thbf5733]

@@pop2art i can help, click those three dots, and hit delete

[@pop2art]

@@thbf5733 considering it but i kinda like seeing weird old comments

[@mapleshadeeatscats]

Please never delete this 😭

[@unbelievablysuccessfulbusi4940]

im having a Feeling help

[@number1salesman-1997]

2:38 silly rob

[@SanrioKyujitsu]

pure concentration

[@Know1one]

Shit dude not feeling

[@theloserbehindit]

Ever wonder

[@aastrophell]

I feel

[@allegra101]

oh no i am having a Feeling

[@unbelievablysuccessfulbusi4940]

bro i just realized you’re one of the singers from minimall and you started this comment section 💀

[@toriIsDaUltimateX3]

ALLERGA MINIMALL POOKIE IS THAT YOU??????????

[@mapleshadeeatscats]

Stop it Joe please you are making me feel emotions

[@briannamccartin7015]

eleven years later and i’m still feeling

[@colemanshofner3514]

Is this the feeling of vibing? No, this feeling is too great for words to describe.

[@filipinosped]

this was literally the day i was born wtf

[@THEUraniumMaster]

I can proudly say that this was performed on my birthday.

[@ppman2994]

Uh oh I’m feeling

[@-lpsmcg]

why do i feel things i can’t describe when i’m here

[@-lpsmcg]

why am i here again i can’t leave i’m sad i’m very happy

[@-lpsmcg]

bro he makes me feel emotions i can’t even feel its

[@geiayanami]

oh feeling no i having am a

[@meekles.8464]

What is this??? Feeling?!

[@catfree]

Are those just Sennheiser e 935 microphones with green stuff tied around it? or is it a different mic?

[@wavermiss]

I think it’s a shure 2600

[@daeskiz4031]

i feel like this comment section is a giant inside joke i'm not a part of

[@metaxia2450]

i guess it’s a . feeling …

[@daeskiz4031]

Hi Metaxia

[@kitsune630]

I wonder what that *feels* like

[@illumino5874]

Real is a feeling and feeling is real.

[@tatteryt]

real is a feeling & feeling is real

[@rafeelswtf]

if you feel, i know what you mean, this song is about depression, take care of yourself friend.

[@bleyn_5598]

Shit it's emotions

[@thbf5733]

gnileeF

[@Canalman]

I'm feeling

[@Zero-Zero-Zero-Zero]

Hold up, I think I'm feeling something

[@tatteryt]

I'm feeling... a real feel.

[@landon3137]

Woah. Is that a feeling?

[@sincerecinnamon]

I really wish I could have been there live

[@higsopus576]

Something something feeling

[@jackplays2385]

feel real

[@widya8675]

The wind knows

[@Roskaa]

August 17th was my 7th birthday and it is making me feel like crazy

[@noodleiswholesome5946]

I love feeling

[@shobbytheclown2292]

feel

[@could_possiblybe_thane07echo]

Theres a small dot on the screen and its driving me insanejsmsj

[@truestnaffy]

NO I SEE IT OH…

[@kk-kw5ml]

69th comment

[@ilovemenwithlonghair]

I love the drumming in this song, Ross did very good!

[@buozelbirhesap]

I love how Ross is beating the hell out of his crash