Hi 🌏!!! Thank you for watcing our video! Show us your ❤ with Subscribe, Like👍 & Comment and Share! 🌏hyejin / 5959hyejin 🌏Jane / yingying3333 🌏Kotaha / kotteji
I just wanna point out that although Qipao is a traditional clothing, because of China’s history and different dynasties, there are many different kinds of Chinese traditional clothing, not just Qipao. As a Chinese, I can say that actually most Chinese people won’t actually choose Qipao as the first traditional clothing they would think of when we talk about traditional clothings, but it is an interesting fact that most people from other countries would think of Qipao when they think about our traditional clothings and we would love to show you guys more about our traditions.
@@harryzhang1511 So explained why all of sudden the hanfu became so important for you guys you live in today right? ladies in China are now like the ballon skirt than the slim fit? lol
@@caap2701 Well if you take a look at all eastern Asian countries in past decades, all of these countries are finding the very root of their own traditions after WWII. Hanfu, Hanbok and Wafuku etc. are one of the signs of east Asia cultural identity. Recent years of economic growth has made us realize that Qipao, originated from Qing dynasty, is not an appropriate representative traditional clothing while Hanfu sure takes the role. It's just hilarious that you think ppl prefer Hanfu than Qipao just because ladies like "ballon" skirt than the slim fit. It's about culture not just fitting. Not sure where u from but we do think our history is important for us. Also, I'm quite curious that why you are educating Chinese ppl of our own culture? Is it arrogance? lol
@@caap2701 "Qi(旗)" means "Qiren(旗人)", literally "the Manchu from Eight Banners", "Pao(袍)" means "traditional long dress"， so "Qipao" means "traditional Manchu dress". Since the time when Manchu took power in China, they became the representatives of the Chinese people, thus "qipao" became the so-called "Chinese representative traditional costume" , but actually the QING only lasted for no more than three hundred years which is a small portion compared to China's long history. But Qing is the last dynasty where the world began to know more about China, or we can say that all they know about China is mainly from Qing. so I think the Qipao, which is a traditional Manchu dress, can only be called one of the representative traditional costumes in China, Hanfu, which is worn by ancient Han people in China is also a Chinese representative traditional costume, but it is never "officially announced" .
@@jeffrey_wang Your government announced Qipao as national custom clothing in 90s I don’t believe your historic story as so many things are distorted and made recently haha trying to mimic and steal every good thing from all of the countries~~
@@ione-gn5gu But for Japan and South Korea, the 90's clothing is the more representative traditional clothing they have studied and still use today - from the traditional style, is inherited more. The cheongsam of the 1990s in China does not represent "traditional dress". Don't turn it upside down, not all countries in the 1990s represented the country's traditional dress. Or, the show should change its title to "Nineties Dress for Three Countries."
I'd just like to point out that the qipao was Manchu inspired attire invented during the 1920s in Shanghai and the version Kotoha is wearing was popular in 1960s Hong Kong. Vintage, yes, but hardly traditional for a country with 3000 years of history.
@Jk u mean its what the government declares is official. what if official has nothing to do with it being cultural. qipao is manchurian clothing, so not as chinese as people think
5000 years of Chinese history only to show qipao which is invented in 1920s (about 100 years ago). I wish Jane would introduce more about different dynasties outfits (e.g., Qin, Han, Tang, Song, Ming dynasties). They’re all part of Chinese traditional outfits.
If we apply chinese logic, Korean and Japanese even can be said that The clothese which had worn during the range BC century to 17century are traditional clothes, And Before the Qipao, There is Changpao which had worn during 17century to 21century by publics, You can see the black-white picture of 19-20century chinese. They all wore ChangPao or Qipao literally. There was No Hanfu at all.
@@Cats_Bread Stop talking like that You are the real theft. And even you don't have the right to say about it because Hanfu(for examples Tangfu) was maden by Nothern race peoples with south chinese. You even hadn't participated producing hanfu. You are just a decendent of the people. And, I think you possibly are a Manchu because there is always plenty possiblity that your ancestor is manchu because Manchu Peoples ruled the Han between 1616 to 1912. So stop insult your ancenstor yourself you manchu boy.
@@물멍-d8b It’s the Chinese who define which are traditional clothes and it’s not simply a logic. Also, no matter how much you spread your logic, Hanfu will never change its name to Hanbok. Thanks.
한푸는 2000년 이후에나 들어보기 시작한 단어인데요. 굳이 한복과 비슷한 단어를 가져다 쓴 이유를 모르겠네요? 한푸가 한족의상이라면서 왜 몽골인 지배층 왕족과 귀족들이 즐겨 입던 고려양을 자랑하는 걸까요? 그러면서 왜 청나라 만주족(여진족)들이 입은 의상은 배척하고요?ㅋㅋ 고려양 복식을 명나라 한푸라고 소개하는 어느 중국 여자 유튜버를 보았어요. 중공이 중공함
if you want to communication, i can tell the truth to you, no arugment, i just so curious why so many korea just want to put qipao as chinese clothing, acutally, qipao is from manchu people if you google it, you can find it on wikipidea. no offence.
@@江集-v1p 中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago.
How can Qipao represent china’s traditional clothing? The China’s Civilization is over 3500 years old yet you represented a modernized clothing that barely is 100 years old. That is like saying the tuxedo is the traditional clothing of America. Shame.
Usually representing traditional cloths are lineages down from closes Era to modern times. Like korean hanbok and japanese kimono those tradition never stopped till modern times. So long as china claiming what Qings have accomplished before and claiming Qing eras rights, China is Qings descendent nation. Qings tradition is direct chineses tradition
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s.
Qipao is more popular Chinese representation than hanfu in western media. Most westerners and even Asians would think of qipao when thinking of Chinese dress. It's been the case since the Qing dynasty. The revival of hanfu is very recent and is only a representation of the Han majority.
But Hanfu has longer history than Qipao, Chinese people never think qipao is the traditional cloth cause it showed up in late 19th century but Hanfu has come into being for thousands of years.
@@kingbobleung3801 It's not about which has a longer history, it's about representation. Qipao, although a minority attire, was worn during the Qing to the present at a symbol of Chinese identity. Hanfu is but a symbol of the Han majority of China. But if you are to show pictures of Qipao and Hanfu to people and ask them which is a Chinese costume. They would likely choose Qipao. Qipao has been the costume representation of China for ages, since the Qing dynasty. It is already hard to change it. Hanfu revival is quite recent. Hanfu is a costume representation of the Han majority. Qipao can be said as costume representation of Chinese identity.
@@shuhsuush China only got ONE Traditional costume, HANFU, through different styles changes thru era but its still HANFU, just like Han characters also changed through the time but we still call it Han language but not something else, if its make sense to you
@@Cats_Bread Only Han people is chinese? There are many ethnic people in China. China is ONE country (一个中国), and Qipao brings all chinese together. Han-chinese nationalism is prohibited in China. Do you want China to divide?
@@oliviaolivia3326 Hanfu was not traditional clothing, Actually your grand grand father and his father never wore Hanfu, but always wore Manchu clothing with pig tale hair style. Hanfu was just invented by few decades ago, It is not traditional, The meaning of tradition should actually wore by old and long time ago people, But they never wore Hanfu. So It is very close to custume play such as Italian plays Roman Toga in the show or event.
Hanfu is traditional babe.It's clothing before the Qing Dynasty，Such as Tang，Han，Song and Jin.It's the real traditional clothing of China.Qing clothes appeared much later.
Deliberately shirtless is truly what korean traditional clothes were like. But if people go to korea and look around, they will find KOREANS NOWADAYS ARE PLAGIARIZING CHINESE TRADITIONAL CLOTHES --- MINGFU (one type of Chinese tranditional clothes form Ming Dynasty(A.D.1368-1644) ). What a shame on those plagiarisers!
@@user-urwedfvftgfr228 that's how cultures work, the language and people diverge from the chinese culture a long time ago and even the japanese. Then they also trade ideas and items with each other, exchanging the already different clothes, language etc. kimono, yukata, hanfu, qipao, hanbok are all similar in styles but are different. Just like maritime south east asia. Sarong, kain samping, kain pelikat, kain batik, kebaya are all worn and tied differently from pattani to singapore, mindanao, java, aceh, ternate etc.
@@prunprun3803 We dont even have a term called Mingfu here in China. I'd say those who pretends to be Chinese are having really low knowledge nowadays.
you are wrong QIPAO is not a Manchu costume Modern clothing invented by Shanghai women Manchu costumes are not this. And the name QIPAO was invented later And the banner man does not represent the Manchu Because half of the banner people are Han
@ODELIA . (00000015129) And Manchu is not a real nation, more like an interest group Because half of the Manchus are Han, there are Mongolians, and even a few Koreans.
@ODELIA . (00000015129) Maybe part of it However, with the exception of the Han within the Manchu, the other Han and Manchus do not marry. And today's Manchuria also belongs to China, and the Manchus have completely become Chinese. This is a very good result for the Chinese
Chinese dynasties have different costumes, should have included hanfu alongside qipao...quite disappointed not seeing the most traditiona chinese costume not being mentioned here...
@@carlapereira9449 yes .. What the hell man...she should have proposed to the team. I like her personality but I don't think she's suited to represent her ethnic and country...
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
What do you mean? Chinese government says that China is multiethnic country. Why can't Manchurian culture represent China? You mean Qing Dynasty is not Chinese history?
Qing dynasty definitely is part of Chinese history but not the entire Chinese history. Also, Hanfu has thousands of history but Qipao just showed up in the late 19th century. Surely Hanfu is the best costume to represent our Chinese traditional cloth.
@@ione-gn5gu OK, put yourself in another position. Do you think China can represent Asia? Even though China's population, land area and cultural influence are very important in Asian countries, do you think other Asian countries are willing to be "represented"? Won't they be angry? Whether cheongsam can represent Chinese traditional clothing is the same. Asia includes China, which cannot represent Asia. Chinese traditional clothing includes Qipao, which is difficult to represent Chinese traditional clothing, It is difficult to represent Chinese traditional clothing. The history of Chinese clothing, the history of cheongsam and the group wearing clothes are not so high. Hanfu may be a better choice, but the types of Hanfu are also very complex. It has experienced the evolution of Han Dynasty, Tang Dynasty, Song Dynasty, Ming Dynasty and other dynasties.
how about hanfu, this clothing is more like 'traditional clothing". the time period of it is greater than Qi Pao. The qi Pao only came in, in the 1920s, so it was not that long, whereas hanfu existed even before the xia dynasty.
The term hanfu did came from the Han dynasty, but in the modern world the term hanfu is used for any clothings that has simular features of the clothing of the han or tang dynasty.
The Changpao and Qipao are also clearly chinese traditional clothes. If you deny this, It means that chinese government has oppresively ruled Manchu peoples now, and Your History in 1616 to 1912 had rather ruled by Manchu peoples than can be said chinese history itself, and the areas like manchuria, Tibet, Uygur are not your lands because these land had governed by manchu peoples. So I ask you once again. Is it clearly true that Qipao and changpao are not your traditional clothes?
@@물멍-d8b qipao is a more modernized type of Chinese clothing with Manchu influences/origins. It was made and popularized in the 1920s, and it was influenced by the modern world so it’s not really “traditional” compared to “traditional” hanfu styles. Also china does not mean “Chinese/han”, china is the country while what people refer to as “Chinese” or Han is one of the many ethnic groups of china.
HANFU DEFINITELY NOT TRADITIONAL CHINESE CLOTHES FOR SURE. BUT QIPAO IS, AND ITS IRREPLACEABLE. HANFU WAS BANNED IN QING DYNASTY. ITS HISTORICAL INCIDENTS. （剃发易服 ）NOBODY'S FAULT. MANQING TOO IS ONE PERIOD OF CHINESE HISTORY AND HERITAGE. AND KIND IMPORTANT ONE. IN CHINESE WE SAY *HANFU ONLY HAVE THE PAST BUT NO FUTURE * THIS IS FROM CHINESE MEDIA. QIPAO IS ONE AND ONLY CHINESE TRADITIONAL CLOTHES HAD REPRESENTED CHINESE THROUGH QING DYNASTY. WW1 .REPUBLIC OF CHINA. WW2. PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA. DENGXIAOPING ERA. OLYMPIC GAMES AND SO MUCH MORE. WARNING CHINESE DON'T EVEN THINK OF TRYING TO RUIN THE PLACE OF QIPAO. THANK YOU!
Chinese people would never choose Qipao as our Most Classic clothing .But other nearby countries' people do. Do you know why ?The answer is most of east Asia culture are origins in China ,but they ignore this fact and always want to prove their culture is independent .Since their own clothes couldn't get changed , they make the videos always only show Qipao .Because they are afraid of others finding out theirs clothes come from older Chinese cloths.They are willing to eliminate people's impression on Chinese clothing that is delicate and baggy ,making their clothing looks unique . That's a trick for some bad reasons .China have 5000 year history ,but these people always choose a kind of clothing only got popular for 20 years ,they are seizing Chinese culture by making stereotypes for westerners .that's weird .
These Qipao are really beautiful and show your figure. Qipao is an improvement of Manchu costume. Hanfu is more representative of the present Traditional Chinese dress.
But why Qipao shouldn't count as a Hanfu? If Hanfu is defined as what is worn by Han chinese people, then Shouldn't Qipao be the most recent han traditional clothes? The fact that its origin is in Manchuria or influenced by the west has nothing to do with the representativeness of Qipao. In Qing dynasty, Chinese and Manchurians wore one and the same clothes all alike. There have been barely no distinction between chinese and manchurians for the past 300 years clothes-wise. They put on the same clothes. I have nothing against clothes from earlier periods, but they are, strictly speaking, not 'tradition' in that most of the elements those clothes have had are not handed down to the recent generation. Because Japanese or Korean traditional clothes featured in this video are also the most recent traditional clothes not some 1000 year old relics revived only by some archeological works, the same should go for chinese traditional attire too
@@랙쇼랙쇼 Hanfu and qipao are different in Chinese culture. People use Hanfu and are familiar with it, it's not a relic. Chinese people wouldn't be confused by made-up definition.
@@랙쇼랙쇼 it's not 300years.chinese people still wears Hanfu,it is not a relic. Manchuria is not china, just a state in china. Just like Korea is not China ( Korea was a vassal state) so what's wrong with people mentioning Hanfu? Its a dress that belong to the major Han ethnic group that is still in billions of numbers including the overseas Chinese migrants in SE Asia
Agree, as a Chinese, I wouldn't choose Qipao to represent Chinese traditional close. If I have to choose one, I would choose either Han dynasty cloth or Tang Dynasty cloth.
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
qipao鞑子 SHOWN IN THIS VIDEO IS NOT CHINA'S TRADITIONAL COSTUME，IT'S FROM MANCHUKUO OR MANCHURIAN 和服是参照汉服而设计的。。 YOU SHOULD SEE PURE HAN COSTUME th-cam.com/video/90rzAbr955I/w-d-xo.html
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
@Jk Hanfu is the traditional clothing of the the han people in China, and it’s not discontinued nor is it cosplay, that is quite rude of you to say about a country’s tradition.
@@feili1469 Hanbok has been steadily worn and developed for 5,000 years in Korean history. The basic form of hanbok is pants/skirt+jacket. The prototype of hanbok was established during the Goryeo Dynasty, which refers to the relocation of Joseon. In other words, the Joseon Dynasty is the last dynasty in Korea. Gyeongbokgung Palace in this video is also a palace from the Joseon Dynasty. Until the middle of Goryeo Dynasty, clothes were tied with belts, not ribbons, but during the Goryeo Dynasty, ribbons were used to fix the coat due to shorter tops and difficulties in belt. (Some argue that ribbons came from Mongolia, but ribbon-bound clothes have been found since the Silla period before Goryeo.) Also, during the Goryeo Dynasty, there was a country called Won (Mongol) in China. After the war between Mongolia and Goryeo, exchanges between Goryeo and Mongolia became active, and Goryeo culture began to become so popular that it was called Mongolians as exchanges between Goryeo and Mongolia became active. In addition, Goryeo women became empress of Mongolia, and the trend spread further as the number of Goryeo people in the royal family increased. At that time, people did not originally wear clothes but wore Goryeo hanbok. It can be seen that Goryeo culture was very popular in the Yuan Dynasty. (There are still many pronouns starting with Goryeo in China, and they have been handed down since then. After the fall of the Yuan Dynasty, there was the Ming Dynasty, a Han Dynasty, in China. People in the Ming Dynasty continued to wear clothes that they had worn since the Yuan Dynasty. And the clothes are traditional Korean clothes. However, the Chinese deny that their culture is superior to Korea and claim that Korea stole Chinese hanbok, but this is the opposite. The clothes of the Ming Dynasty were greatly influenced by the hanbok of Goryeo. Emperor Hong Chi-je of the Ming Dynasty knew this and banned traditional Korean clothes. Attached is a phrase from the Chinese history book below.
Yea it’s sad. Qipao is from Qing dynasty which dates back only hundreds of years. I feel we Chinese have lost connection with Hanfu culture….time to bring it back!
@@newbabies923 The Manchus are actually Eastern Siberian people. They mostly came from the province of Heilongjiang, fomerly known as Manchuria and was part of Russia. The people have more in common with the Mongols than the Hans.
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” 'Hanfu' is NOT daily cloth in china. Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago.
Qipao rarely can represent Chinese long history , basically its a clothing developed from Manchuria,Hanfu is more likely Chinese clothing. LOL Koreans.
Of course a korean channel will want to advertise Qipao being Chinese traditional costunme, even though it was only invented 100 years ago compared to Hanfu!
Yeah. Korea's traditional cloth is Hanbok. Japan's traditional cloth is Kimono, China's traditional cloth is Qipao. Why is some country try to steal/change something? There are already a lot of Korean, Japanese, Chinese movies showing their own traditional clothes. Every country actor is wearing their own traditional cloth. If you can not believe it, go watch each country's movie.
Cheongsam is not a traditional Chinese dress. It has a history of only 100 years. It has evolved from Western three-dimensional tailoring and is a modern dress. Traditional Chinese clothing is loose flat cut. You can see it in many Chinese costume dramas.
All the Koreans speaking for Chinese people about Chinese history and what is actually considered hanfu or not probably don’t even truly know their own history because if they did, they would know what the sinosphere is and what kind of influence China has had on Korea’s history and culture. Stop telling Chinese people what is and isn’t their own culture.
I wish Jane would've pointed out that qipao is a recent 20th century Chinese dress. While it is a very distinct Chinese style of dress, the more traditional is the hanfu.
@@djdkdnhshdhd57 no hanfu was another country’s back in the Won era. Style of Hanfu was developed by Koryu, and that trend kept until Ming. I’m really confused why Chinese are trying to change their history
If you are Chinese, it's really a shame for you to translate the "Qi" of "Qipao" into "flag". If not, sorry to be some offensive. Anyway “Qi” is actually a nationality( also called "Man") of China -- they are called "Qi ren".
@Ben Kang More than 70% of the genetic deviations of Koreans can be a nation, and 90% of the Han nationality is of the same origin but has become politics? The Koreans retain only 30% of the ancestry of the Tunguska people, the rest are Han, Mongolian, Japanese, Fuyu people! The Han nationality has always accounted for more than 60% of the world's population in history. The pure blood Mongolians who ruled the Han nationality did not exceed 200 thousand, and the Manchus only had tens of thousands. This was just a drop of ink in the sea for the Han people of hundreds of millions of people at that time!
@Ben Kang But for Koreans, the number of Han, Mongolian, and Manchurian people who rule Korea is not a drop of ink dripping into the ocean! But South Korea has a population of only a few million ~
@Ben Kang Wrong! No region today except the Middle East and India retains the traditional trappings of Nissan life! So according to your definition is that there is no traditional dress! So even if you wear traditional hanfu at sacrifices, weddings and funerals like han people, you would say they wear cheongsam?
@Ben Kang Cheongsam passed down from generation to generation? Sacrifice, wedding, funeral can not wear the dress how to pass down from generation to generation?
@Ben Kang Why do Koreans use hanbok as a traditional costume in a country that is as extinct as everyday clothing? Do you still inherit the daily clothes of 100 years ago? Wasn't it all on the occasions I was talking about? So the Han people don't wear traditional clothes, right? 😜
@Ben Kang As long as it is a korean channel, the Chinese will always wear cheongsam, although koreans, Japanese and han people alike only wear traditional costumes on specific occasions! Korea is like a domestic servant whose master has been kidnapped. The master comes back but hogs the master's estate and doesn't let go! This kind of Korean traditional costume in Chiguri + Hanfu of the nobles = Hanbok! This kind of idea is really ridiculous！All kinds of software by han people to take out the cultural relics in the face, laugh 😂
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
The Qipao in this video is not even the traditional costume of Manchu people. Even if you don’t use Hanfu, just taking out a piece of clothing from 56 ethnic groups in China is much stronger than this kind of modern improved qipao, which is tight and impossible and no one wears daily, right? Or is it a Korean Channel? Even the Republic of China does not wear such a qipao like this style. If you dislike Chinese, just say it directly.Don't spread wrong knowledge.
Why putting Qipao as the Chinese traditional costume? The most of people don’t even know the existence of Hanfu and they only know about qipao. There are also some people when see a Hanfu they think the hanfu is Korean or Japanese costume and it’s really bothering me. Qibao arrived in the modernization era of China so putting kimono and hanbok with qibao it’s just not the same time lines.
I love these types of traditional clothing, and its interesting learning about other cultures. My personal favourite’s are the Chinese hanfu, and the kimono. But i also love the hanbok so much ahhhhh Its so hard to choose there all pretty
OMG what the hell r u talking about😂HANFU is literally a simple translation for 汉服(“Traditional Chinese Clothes”). Don’t tell me that traditional Chinese clothes came after hanbok….
I think that hanfu (汉服) would be more appropriate as a Chinese traditional clothing. Qipao (旗袍) is indeed Chinese, but it's fairly recent (~1920), and would be more vintage than traditional
I wished they would use Hanfu as the Chinese traditional clothing as QiPao means Manchu Clothing, China’s population is around 95 % Han Chinese! But I was kind of shock to see QiPao here, as I watch Chinese dramas especially Wuxia genre (don’t confuse historical wuxia or xianxian Chinese drama, historical is historical, Wuxia is historical but has fighting, flying, Kung fu, clans, Xianxian is historical but has fighting, flying, gods, immortals)
China has experienced a period of change. We have stopped cultural inheritance. Qipao does not represent Chinese traditional clothing. This concept is inaccurate. Hanfu is the right traditional dress, but many people have lost it
The modern style Qipao was only widely worn by the Chinese at the beginning of the 20th century, before that, Hanfu is the actual national costume of China for thousands of years, and the style of Hanfu has influenced the costumes of neighboring countries such as Korea, Japan and Vietnam.
No, After 1646 Ming's collapsed. You han people have forced to wear the Qipao and Pig-tale hair style. So Manchu's tradition clothing were your real tradition, what is the hanfu anyway? You were han people wore the Manchu's clothing for about 4 hundreds years. Not only during 19 century.
@@bkang3132 hanfu is historical han people dress and Qipao is heavily influenced from Manchurian. This is it. And no, Manchurian CANNOT represent China. Qing Dynasty has collapsed in 1911.
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
I always love seeing traditional dresses from other countries. It's really interesting to see China as well as Thailand and Vietnam have similar silhouettes to what my South Asian culture wears. The Qipao and Ao Dai (sorry if the spelling wrong for them) are similar to salwar kameez and Chut Thai (again plz correct me) is similar to the sari. Love seeing these!!☺️☺️☺️
@@serbaserbi6004 Not all of them are in Liaoning, and I believe there are more Manchus in Beijing. Most Manchus live in the north, but in fact, the migration of population in modern society is very frequent. I live in Qinghai Province. There are many ethnic minorities here. Most of the people I contact are Tibetans and Hui, but actually some of my friends are Manchus. In Chinese history, the Han nationality has always been the main ethnic group with the majority, so the Han clothes worn by the Han people can represent the traditional costumes of the Chinese people in a certain sense, at least compared with the cheongsam produced in modern history. For example, I once had a Tibetan girlfriend. She had Tibetan robes (Tibetan traditional clothes), but she also wore Han clothes. China has been a multi-ethnic country since ancient times, and Hanfu is not invariable. In fact, it has been influenced by many different cultures. The system of Hanfu and the culture behind it, including historical changes, have complete ancient books in China. Thanks to our ancestors who liked to record almost everything in books and paintings.
Honestly, anyone speaking and reading a second language has superpowers to me, lol. The ladies did a great job, especially knowing how difficult our R and L pronunciation is for them.
Cheongsam is not full of people. The dress of a warlord's wife during the Republic of China. Clothing in modern and contemporary times in Shanghai. This does not represent our China. Because of the westernization of Shanghai's clothing. It has nothing to do with Manchu.
The problem with QIPAO is that, it came from a dynasty ruled by foreign invaders. Although not in that degree, but showing only Qipao as traditional Chinese clothing without showing Hanfu， is kind of like Indian people showing some pictures of 'traditional Indian clothing' but there are just bunch of British style clothing in those pictures. So the same logic doesn't apply to Korean and Japanese as some people suggested.
The Changpao and Qipao are also clearly chinese traditional clothes. If you deny this, It means that chinese government has oppresively ruled Manchu peoples now, and Your History in 1616 to 1912 had rather ruled by Manchu peoples than can be said chinese history itself, and the areas like manchuria, Tibet, Uygur are not your lands because these land had governed by manchu peoples. So I ask you once again. Is it clearly true that Qipao and changpao are not your traditional clothes?
@@물멍-d8b They are, but from all our whole variety of traditional clothes, many identify more with Hanfu. It’s the Chinese who get to decide which one they prefer and what they want to wear.
@@arles1124 But Qing banned the Ming's outfit and most of modern chinese and there elder's and to the great great grandfather. They never worn hanfu as their outfit, instead they wear Qing's outfit. If you know what actually "traditional" really means. You should not say that hanfu as a traditional clothes...It a Historical clothes. Just like old roman outfit and egypt outfit. If you want to tell its a traditional. Then it should be inherited through your great great grand father to your elders and to you. But it's a lost outfit for long time. And although chinese try to restore hanfu in modern times. We actually don't say that as your "traditional" outfit.
So sad, I was expecting seeing the hanfu as the chinese traditional dress, qipao is a modern traditional chinese dress but isnt the one to represent china. Jane is Chinese, she should know it. If u search on Google, like chinese traditional paints u going to see that the chineses girls are wearing hanfu and only hanfu. I didn't like this video
The qipao isn’t really traditional. It’s a hybrid of Manchu and western elements popularised by socialites and women of Shanghai in the 1920s before spreading to other parts of China. Several of the ethnic minorities of China DO have traditional costumes. But Han Chinese don’t really have one. Han Chinese may try to wear a hanfu but which dynasty style do they go for? It’s inconsistent . it’s tradition got cut by the Qing dynasty midway and a modern Han dressing in a hanfu would be like an American dressing for the renaissance fair. there’s no rules or elements that dictate it as traditional anymore. the qipao is closer to a formal wear for an event or party, but once again isn’t not traditional. (The slit on the side has always been there but before they wore pants underneath) in the 1920s the ladies tried to emulate a western style and stopped wearing the pants which is why it gives off an almost sexy vibe.
The Changpao and Qipao are also clearly chinese traditional clothes. If you deny this, It means that chinese government has oppresively ruled Manchu peoples now, and Your History in 1616 to 1912 had rather ruled by Manchu peoples than can be said chinese history itself, and the areas like manchuria, Tibet, Uygur are not your lands because these land had governed by manchu peoples. So I ask you once again. Is it clearly true that Qipao and changpao are not your traditional clothes?
@@물멍-d8b the qipao is indeed traditional- to Manchurians. That is the loose baggy qipao. The tight one modified my Shanghainese Han socialites is not. And no ethnic Manchu would say it was. Couldn’t care less if Xinjiang and Tibet were or were not part of China tbh and your alluding to them has nothing to to with whether the slit styled qipao is “traditional” or not. Heck, if you try to make me admit to that, I’ll have to admit that somehow the Hanbok is a traditional Chinese costume too since the ethnic Koreans are a recognised ethnicity of China and I’m sure that’s already angered enough Koreans as is.
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
Qipao was popular only started 1920s,I do not think it is Chinese traditional clothing. China can not use one traditional style clothing to represent .becuase there were so many dynasties ,and every dynasty was so different.and many styles .
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念” Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing. It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
Like everyone else said, Qipao isn't the traditional chinese dress, Hanfu is. Qipao is a modern invention that combined Manchu dress with Western cocktail dress
This isn’t a video about the history of Chinese traditional costume. Japan and Korea also have long histories and garments that have evolved over time. They’re just comparing the most recent popularized version of each country’s traditional garment.
Yes the hanfu too but the qipao isnt even in the same category as hanfu. Theres a diffrense between modifying/update and inventing a whole new line of clothing.
Qipao is not wrong, but as a Chinese girl I kinda find that I identify more with Hanfu. Thanks for showing the Qipao but I think demonstrating Hanfu (Maybe those from dynasties that look neither like kimono nor Hanbok) might be better.
😀😃 Tender Plant Lives Hidden Message in the Torah /Tanak / Bible Hidden within within the genealogy first Sons from Adam. Genesis 5 : 3-32 NAMES ---- Name MEANINGS Adam - Man Seth - Appointed Enos - Mortal Cainan - Sarrow Mahalaleel - Blessed GOD Jared - Shall come Down Enoch - Teaching Methuselah -His Death shall Bring Lamech -To Make /Low Mighity Noah -Rest / Favor / Fulfilled Name Meanings written in a Sentence 😳 Man appointed mortal Sarrow Blessed GOD shall come down teaching His death shall bring to make low/MIGHTY , rest favor FULFILLED My Interpretation: Jesus given a task to preform from this earth feeling of deep distress BLESSED GOD shall come down as Jesus teaching Jews as a Rabbi His death shall bring SALVATION to make low to hang on a tree becomes MIGHTY rest/ favor/ FULFILLED HIS Purpose 🤔 Keep this in mind 🤔all 10 generations timeline took place up to chapter 5 of Genesis ,Hidden Message telling Jesus COMING 😲 Approximately 4 thousand years later before it HAPPENED only God ! Ten Trillion people could not have gotten together and had have written 1 fact and placed it in a book Foretelling of there coming Christ 4K years before it Happened . Who hath believed our report ? For and to whom is the arm of Lord revealed ? For he shall grow up before him as a tender plant, and as a root out of a dry ground: he hath No form nor comeliness ; and when we shall see him, there is no beauty that we should desire him. He is despised and rejected of men; a men of sorrows , and acquainted with grief: and we hid as it were our faces from him; he was despised and we esteemed him not. Surely he hath borne our grief , and carried our sorrows: yet we did esteem him stricken, smitten of God, and afflicted. But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed. All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned every one to his own way; and the Lord hath laid on him the iniquity of us all. He was oppressed, and he was all . He was oppressed , and he was afflicted , yet he opened not his mouth : he is brought as a lamb to the slaughter , and as a sheep before her shearers is dumb, so he openers not his mouth. He was taken from prison From judgment: and who shall declare this generation? For He was cut off out of the land of the living: for he was cutting off out of the land of the living: for the transgression of my people was he stricken. And he made his grave with the wicked, and with the rich in his death; because he had done no violence , neither was any deceit in his mouth. Yet it pleased the Lord to bruise him ; he hath put him to grief: when thou shalt make his soul an offering for sin he shall see his seed , he shall prolong his days, and the pleasure of the Lord shall prosper in his hand. He shall see of the travail of his soul , and shall be satisfied : by His knowledge shall my righteous servant justify many ; for he shall bear their iniquities. Therefore Will I divide him a portion with the great, and he shall divide the spoil with the spoil with the strong ; because he hath pored out his soul unto death : and he was numbered with the transgressor ; and he bare the sin of many, and made intercession for the transgressors. Who is this About? KJV in Isaiah 53 The Truth will set you free ! Christ means Messiah , Jesus was a Jew and still is . Jesus is not a religion, Jesus Loves You Believe ON The Lord Jesus Christ You are Born Again Believe as a child Just Believe RAPTURE Very SOON 😳 It is Not Death But Life Tuesday 30 , 2022 Or 3 , Elul 5782 3:37 AM Control time , has not happened yet , any Second Are you Ready , Believe ON Jesus Heaven or Outerdarkness God will not hear your prayers that is hell. TH-cam : Rapture 2022 Please choose Jesus
Chinese in the comments should stop claiming Hanbok as yours lol. History is right there, no matter how hard you want Hanbok as yours you can’t change the history.
@@江集-v1p Lol a lot of you guys using hanbok as Hanfu. When we point that out and then you guys say “Hanbok is a type of Hanfu” or “Hanbok copied Hanfu”. Respect our culture thanks.
Hey, girls! I really enjoy your videos, because I'm very interested in your three cultures. I'm from Bulgaria - a country in Southeast Europe. Bulgarian traditional women clothing called " bulagrian nosia". This clothing is worn mostly on special traditional holidays and unfortunately has very little presence in the modern clothing of Bulgarian women.
I wish people would stop perpetuating the myth that Qipao is traditional Chinese dress. It isn't. It is Manchu, and, at least for women, dates only to the early 20th Century. In China, there is a trend amongst some young people to wear "Hanfu" - clothing of the Han people. Of course, this is pretty broad, since clothing from the Han Dynasty was different from that of the Tang, the Song or the Ming. A decent video on the topic can be found here: th-cam.com/video/o5NDHB2ZSrI/w-d-xo.html
The worst part is that the qipao they showed were modernized Manchu dresses, not even the traditional Manchu dresses lol but I do agree, they should’ve shown hanfu since those are definitely older/traditional instead of modern
I just wanna point out that although Qipao is a traditional clothing, because of China’s history and different dynasties, there are many different kinds of Chinese traditional clothing, not just Qipao. As a Chinese, I can say that actually most Chinese people won’t actually choose Qipao as the first traditional clothing they would think of when we talk about traditional clothings, but it is an interesting fact that most people from other countries would think of Qipao when they think about our traditional clothings and we would love to show you guys more about our traditions.
Back in the 90d Your country officially announced Qipao is Chinese representative traditional costume Okay? How old are you.
@@harryzhang1511 So explained why all of sudden the hanfu became so important for you guys you live in today right?
ladies in China are now like the ballon skirt than the slim fit? lol
@@caap2701 Well if you take a look at all eastern Asian countries in past decades, all of these countries are finding the very root of their own traditions after WWII. Hanfu, Hanbok and Wafuku etc. are one of the signs of east Asia cultural identity. Recent years of economic growth has made us realize that Qipao, originated from Qing dynasty, is not an appropriate representative traditional clothing while Hanfu sure takes the role.
It's just hilarious that you think ppl prefer Hanfu than Qipao just because ladies like "ballon" skirt than the slim fit. It's about culture not just fitting. Not sure where u from but we do think our history is important for us.
Also, I'm quite curious that why you are educating Chinese ppl of our own culture? Is it arrogance? lol
@@caap2701 "Qi(旗)" means "Qiren(旗人)", literally "the Manchu from Eight Banners", "Pao(袍)" means "traditional long dress"， so "Qipao" means "traditional Manchu dress". Since the time when Manchu took power in China, they became the representatives of the Chinese people, thus "qipao" became the so-called "Chinese representative traditional costume" , but actually the QING only lasted for no more than three hundred years which is a small portion compared to China's long history. But Qing is the last dynasty where the world began to know more about China, or we can say that all they know about China is mainly from Qing. so I think the Qipao, which is a traditional Manchu dress, can only be called one of the representative traditional costumes in China, Hanfu, which is worn by ancient Han people in China is also a Chinese representative traditional costume, but it is never "officially announced" .
@@jeffrey_wang Your government announced Qipao as national custom clothing in 90s
I don’t believe your historic story as so many things are distorted and made recently haha
trying to mimic and steal every good thing from all of the countries~~
They should introduce chinese traditional HANFU also 😭
Thought the same thing. Especially with the hanfu movement that's going on in China. It's literally exploded with Hanfu styles from every dynasty.
This. Saw a woman at Otakon in one and the flow just moves the room
@@lordkent8143 yes i think hanfu has different style in every china dynasty . Coz china has long history
Korean and Japanese introduced only 19century style of their dress same as Chinese did.
@@ione-gn5gu But for Japan and South Korea, the 90's clothing is the more representative traditional clothing they have studied and still use today - from the traditional style, is inherited more. The cheongsam of the 1990s in China does not represent "traditional dress". Don't turn it upside down, not all countries in the 1990s represented the country's traditional dress. Or, the show should change its title to "Nineties Dress for Three Countries."
I'd just like to point out that the qipao was Manchu inspired attire invented during the 1920s in Shanghai and the version Kotoha is wearing was popular in 1960s Hong Kong. Vintage, yes, but hardly traditional for a country with 3000 years of history.
Yeah the one the actual Chinese lady is wearing seems like traditional one. But she says it's the formal one
nothing to do with history length. Its simply because its too young to be traditional XDD Its just weird
agree！Hanfu is much more than Qipao and different dynasties have different costumes in fact.
中国古代女人要是穿旗袍出门怕是要被骂死，那么紧身、开衩又那么高的旗袍“代表”了中国传统，也是历史奇观
@Jk u mean its what the government declares is official. what if official has nothing to do with it being cultural. qipao is manchurian clothing, so not as chinese as people think
5000 years of Chinese history only to show qipao which is invented in 1920s (about 100 years ago). I wish Jane would introduce more about different dynasties outfits (e.g., Qin, Han, Tang, Song, Ming dynasties). They’re all part of Chinese traditional outfits.
偷国人不意外啊
If we apply chinese logic, Korean and Japanese even can be said that The clothese which had worn during the range BC century to 17century are traditional clothes, And Before the Qipao, There is Changpao which had worn during 17century to 21century by publics, You can see the black-white picture of 19-20century chinese. They all wore ChangPao or Qipao literally. There was No Hanfu at all.
@@Cats_Bread Stop talking like that You are the real theft. And even you don't have the right to say about it because Hanfu(for examples Tangfu) was maden by Nothern race peoples with south chinese. You even hadn't participated producing hanfu. You are just a decendent of the people. And, I think you possibly are a Manchu because there is always plenty possiblity that your ancestor is manchu because Manchu Peoples ruled the Han between 1616 to 1912. So stop insult your ancenstor yourself you manchu boy.
@@물멍-d8b It’s the Chinese who define which are traditional clothes and it’s not simply a logic. Also, no matter how much you spread your logic, Hanfu will never change its name to Hanbok. Thanks.
@@물멍-d8bhanfu exist in the qing dynasty too
한푸는 2000년 이후에나 들어보기 시작한 단어인데요. 굳이 한복과 비슷한 단어를 가져다 쓴 이유를 모르겠네요?
한푸가 한족의상이라면서 왜 몽골인 지배층 왕족과 귀족들이 즐겨 입던 고려양을 자랑하는 걸까요?
그러면서 왜 청나라 만주족(여진족)들이 입은 의상은 배척하고요?ㅋㅋ
고려양 복식을 명나라 한푸라고 소개하는 어느 중국 여자 유튜버를 보았어요.
중공이 중공함
if you want to communication, i can tell the truth to you, no arugment, i just so curious why so many korea just want to put qipao as chinese clothing, acutally, qipao is from manchu people if you google it, you can find it on wikipidea. no offence.
《独断》（Han dynasty）by 蔡邕：“通天冠：天子常服，汉服受之秦your ignorance doesn't change reality
@@江集-v1p
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago.
How can Qipao represent china’s traditional clothing? The China’s Civilization is over 3500 years old yet you represented a modernized clothing that barely is 100 years old. That is like saying the tuxedo is the traditional clothing of America. Shame.
Usually representing traditional cloths are lineages down from closes Era to modern times. Like korean hanbok and japanese kimono those tradition never stopped till modern times. So long as china claiming what Qings have accomplished before and claiming Qing eras rights, China is Qings descendent nation. Qings tradition is direct chineses tradition
@@RocSaltAndPepperMint你别太离谱😅😅😅
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s.
现在汉服活动很像cosplay，而且也不专业，但也有的还原的不错，中国汉族传统服装从平民到贵族都有很完整的保存了下来，除了一些年代久远的形制有争议，尽管大量的汉服资料文物被保留，但是以前汉服就是被扔在历史中的垃圾堆，没人去宣传，现在又被捡了回来，汉服不是新词，汉服就是汉族传统服饰，就这么简单
I would’ve loved to see hanfu instead of qipao, but oh well all the dresses are beautiful :)
Yess!
Qipao is more popular Chinese representation than hanfu in western media. Most westerners and even Asians would think of qipao when thinking of Chinese dress. It's been the case since the Qing dynasty. The revival of hanfu is very recent and is only a representation of the Han majority.
But Hanfu has longer history than Qipao, Chinese people never think qipao is the traditional cloth cause it showed up in late 19th century but Hanfu has come into being for thousands of years.
@@kingbobleung3801 It's not about which has a longer history, it's about representation. Qipao, although a minority attire, was worn during the Qing to the present at a symbol of Chinese identity. Hanfu is but a symbol of the Han majority of China. But if you are to show pictures of Qipao and Hanfu to people and ask them which is a Chinese costume. They would likely choose Qipao. Qipao has been the costume representation of China for ages, since the Qing dynasty. It is already hard to change it. Hanfu revival is quite recent. Hanfu is a costume representation of the Han majority. Qipao can be said as costume representation of Chinese identity.
@@SeuaDoesntGiveAF What does the west have ANY thing to do with it? They’re in South Korea
Kinda disappointed that hanfu isn’t on the lists :(
same!! hanfu are so pretty :((
Since China has many traditional dresses, she probably chose qipao, the most initial costume of China. But hanfu is as beautiful as qipao!
@@shuhsuush Qipao is not the most initial but the most recent
@@shuhsuush China only got ONE Traditional costume, HANFU, through different styles changes thru era but its still HANFU, just like Han characters also changed through the time but we still call it Han language but not something else, if its make sense to you
@@Cats_Bread Only Han people is chinese? There are many ethnic people in China. China is ONE country (一个中国), and Qipao brings all chinese together. Han-chinese nationalism is prohibited in China. Do you want China to divide?
I tried both Korean, Japanese and Chinese traditional costume. They are all pretty 😀
Have you tried Hanfu (chinese traditional clothing) also?
Its qipao, its not chinese tradition costume, its just a modern chinese costume, nothing do with tradition
@@oliviaolivia3326 Hanfu was not traditional clothing, Actually your grand grand father and his father never wore Hanfu, but always wore Manchu clothing with pig tale hair style. Hanfu was just invented by few decades ago, It is not traditional, The meaning of tradition should actually wore by old and long time ago people, But they never wore Hanfu. So It is very close to custume play such as Italian plays Roman Toga in the show or event.
Hanfu is traditional babe.It's clothing before the Qing Dynasty，Such as Tang，Han，Song and Jin.It's the real traditional clothing of China.Qing clothes appeared much later.
@@mayonnaisecore7074 like Roman toga costumes?
china has so many diffrent types of traditional dresses its so intresting. so ibwould have loved to see a hanfu style represented as well
Deliberately shirtless is truly what korean traditional clothes were like. But if people go to korea and look around, they will find KOREANS NOWADAYS ARE PLAGIARIZING CHINESE TRADITIONAL CLOTHES --- MINGFU (one type of Chinese tranditional clothes form Ming Dynasty(A.D.1368-1644) ). What a shame on those plagiarisers!
@@user-urwedfvftgfr228 average chinese confirmed
@@user-urwedfvftgfr228 that's how cultures work, the language and people diverge from the chinese culture a long time ago and even the japanese. Then they also trade ideas and items with each other, exchanging the already different clothes, language etc. kimono, yukata, hanfu, qipao, hanbok are all similar in styles but are different. Just like maritime south east asia. Sarong, kain samping, kain pelikat, kain batik, kebaya are all worn and tied differently from pattani to singapore, mindanao, java, aceh, ternate etc.
@@prunprun3803 Well, he is using traditional chinese characters so I am pretty sure he is not from mainland china. Maybe a bot from Taiwan.
@@prunprun3803 We dont even have a term called Mingfu here in China. I'd say those who pretends to be Chinese are having really low knowledge nowadays.
'Qipao' means 'Manchu people's Dress'. 'Qi' means 'Manchu', 'Pao' means 'dress'
I think hanfu more prettier than qipao. But maybe they use qipao coz its the last dynasty costume of china.
Its 旗袍 to be precise so maybe more like 'commune' 'cloth'.
you are wrong
QIPAO is not a Manchu costume
Modern clothing invented by Shanghai women
Manchu costumes are not this.
And the name QIPAO was invented later
And the banner man does not represent the Manchu
Because half of the banner people are Han
@ODELIA . (00000015129) And Manchu is not a real nation, more like an interest group
Because half of the Manchus are Han, there are Mongolians, and even a few Koreans.
@ODELIA . (00000015129) Maybe part of it
However, with the exception of the Han within the Manchu, the other Han and Manchus do not marry.
And today's Manchuria also belongs to China, and the Manchus have completely become Chinese.
This is a very good result for the Chinese
Chinese dynasties have different costumes, should have included hanfu alongside qipao...quite disappointed not seeing the most traditiona chinese costume not being mentioned here...
Jane dissapointed me
@@carlapereira9449 yes .. What the hell man...she should have proposed to the team. I like her personality but I don't think she's suited to represent her ethnic and country...
It isn't just china.... Fashion changes every century and more recently in decades....
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
i really dont think qipao is traditional chinese dress when 95% of chinese population is Han not Manchurian
So whats the traditional han dress?
@@newbabies923 hanfu
What do you mean? Chinese government says that China is multiethnic country. Why can't Manchurian culture represent China? You mean Qing Dynasty is not Chinese history?
Qing dynasty definitely is part of Chinese history but not the entire Chinese history. Also, Hanfu has thousands of history but Qipao just showed up in the late 19th century. Surely Hanfu is the best costume to represent our Chinese traditional cloth.
@@ione-gn5gu OK, put yourself in another position. Do you think China can represent Asia? Even though China's population, land area and cultural influence are very important in Asian countries, do you think other Asian countries are willing to be "represented"? Won't they be angry? Whether cheongsam can represent Chinese traditional clothing is the same. Asia includes China, which cannot represent Asia. Chinese traditional clothing includes Qipao, which is difficult to represent Chinese traditional clothing, It is difficult to represent Chinese traditional clothing. The history of Chinese clothing, the history of cheongsam and the group wearing clothes are not so high. Hanfu may be a better choice, but the types of Hanfu are also very complex. It has experienced the evolution of Han Dynasty, Tang Dynasty, Song Dynasty, Ming Dynasty and other dynasties.
how about hanfu, this clothing is more like 'traditional clothing". the time period of it is greater than Qi Pao. The qi Pao only came in, in the 1920s, so it was not that long, whereas hanfu existed even before the xia dynasty.
The term hanfu did came from the Han dynasty, but in the modern world the term hanfu is used for any clothings that has simular features of the clothing of the han or tang dynasty.
Yes, Yao, Shun, and Yu also wore this traditional clothing.
The Changpao and Qipao are also clearly chinese traditional clothes. If you deny this, It means that chinese government has oppresively ruled Manchu peoples now, and Your History in 1616 to 1912 had rather ruled by Manchu peoples than can be said chinese history itself, and the areas like manchuria, Tibet, Uygur are not your lands because these land had governed by manchu peoples. So I ask you once again. Is it clearly true that Qipao and changpao are not your traditional clothes?
@@물멍-d8b qipao is a more modernized type of Chinese clothing with Manchu influences/origins. It was made and popularized in the 1920s, and it was influenced by the modern world so it’s not really “traditional” compared to “traditional” hanfu styles. Also china does not mean “Chinese/han”, china is the country while what people refer to as “Chinese” or Han is one of the many ethnic groups of china.
HANFU DEFINITELY NOT TRADITIONAL CHINESE CLOTHES FOR SURE. BUT QIPAO IS, AND ITS IRREPLACEABLE. HANFU WAS BANNED IN QING DYNASTY. ITS HISTORICAL INCIDENTS. （剃发易服 ）NOBODY'S FAULT. MANQING TOO IS ONE PERIOD OF CHINESE HISTORY AND HERITAGE. AND KIND IMPORTANT ONE. IN CHINESE WE SAY *HANFU ONLY HAVE THE PAST BUT NO FUTURE * THIS IS FROM CHINESE MEDIA. QIPAO IS ONE AND ONLY CHINESE TRADITIONAL CLOTHES HAD REPRESENTED CHINESE THROUGH QING DYNASTY. WW1 .REPUBLIC OF CHINA. WW2. PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA. DENGXIAOPING ERA. OLYMPIC GAMES AND SO MUCH MORE. WARNING CHINESE DON'T EVEN THINK OF TRYING TO RUIN THE PLACE OF QIPAO. THANK YOU!
Chinese people would never choose Qipao as our Most Classic clothing .But other nearby countries' people do. Do you know why ?The answer is most of east Asia culture are origins in China ,but they ignore this fact and always want to prove their culture is independent .Since their own clothes couldn't get changed , they make the videos always only show Qipao .Because they are afraid of others finding out theirs clothes come from older Chinese cloths.They are willing to eliminate people's impression on Chinese clothing that is delicate and baggy ,making their clothing looks unique .
That's a trick for some bad reasons .China have 5000 year history ,but these people always choose a kind of clothing only got popular for 20 years ,they are seizing Chinese culture by making stereotypes for westerners .that's weird .
You‘re right. They can only display qipao, because showing Hanfu will affect their display of North Korean clothing.
2:26 i am always confused with Kimono and Yukata. Thanks for the clarification.
I love the designs. They are elegant and beautiful.
These Qipao are really beautiful and show your figure. Qipao is an improvement of Manchu costume. Hanfu is more representative of the present Traditional Chinese dress.
But why Qipao shouldn't count as a Hanfu?
If Hanfu is defined as what is worn by Han chinese people, then Shouldn't Qipao be the most recent han traditional clothes?
The fact that its origin is in Manchuria or influenced by the west has nothing to do with the representativeness of Qipao.
In Qing dynasty, Chinese and Manchurians wore one and the same clothes all alike. There have been barely no distinction between chinese and manchurians for the past 300 years clothes-wise. They put on the same clothes.
I have nothing against clothes from earlier periods, but they are, strictly speaking, not 'tradition' in that most of the elements those clothes have had are not handed down to the recent generation.
Because Japanese or Korean traditional clothes featured in this video are also the most recent traditional clothes not some 1000 year old relics revived only by some archeological works, the same should go for chinese traditional attire too
@@랙쇼랙쇼 Hanfu and qipao are different in Chinese culture. People use Hanfu and are familiar with it, it's not a relic. Chinese people wouldn't be confused by made-up definition.
@@랙쇼랙쇼 because qi is qi, han is han, different ethnicity groups thats why
I think they chose qipao because its more distinct from hanbok and kimono than hanfu
@@랙쇼랙쇼 it's not 300years.chinese people still wears Hanfu,it is not a relic. Manchuria is not china, just a state in china. Just like Korea is not China ( Korea was a vassal state) so what's wrong with people mentioning Hanfu? Its a dress that belong to the major Han ethnic group that is still in billions of numbers including the overseas Chinese migrants in SE Asia
I didn't know that Kotoha is so tall
Kotaha*
I also didn't know she was tall. I thought Jane was the tallest.
She's 167 cm, or around 5'6". There was a video she made with this tall TH-camr name Gu Chiri 구치리 where she revealed her height.
@@thaothelazycat930 I thought she was around 170-173 cm as her legs look so long in her pics in instagram
The cheongsam（qipao） is a modern Chinese dress, which has only appeared in the past 100 years. Your history is only 100 years old? ? ?
한족친구들아 진 한 같은나라의 전통의상도 소개하라는데 그러면 일본도 처음부터 끝까지 기모노와 유카타의 변천사를 소개해야하고 한복도 처음부터끝까지 변천사를 소개해야해 게다가 치파오가 가장 많이 알려진 전통의상이잖아
yall couldve showed hanfu instead........ :/
I really love japanese dress
Agree, as a Chinese, I wouldn't choose Qipao to represent Chinese traditional close. If I have to choose one, I would choose either Han dynasty cloth or Tang Dynasty cloth.
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
qipao鞑子 SHOWN IN THIS VIDEO IS NOT CHINA'S TRADITIONAL COSTUME，IT'S FROM MANCHUKUO OR MANCHURIAN
和服是参照汉服而设计的。。
YOU SHOULD SEE PURE HAN COSTUME
th-cam.com/video/90rzAbr955I/w-d-xo.html
Manchurian are chinese , chinese not only Han
@@newbabies923 han in 中国，REFUSE USING CHINESE
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
I think Hanfu has been more of a trend lately in China too, so it would have been nice to show that!
한국에서는 한푸에 대한 인식이 좋지 않습니다. 중국인들은 한국의 한복을 한푸라 우기며 한국의 문화를 빼앗고 있습니다.
@@user-xn9gq9ho4e bullshit, learn some history !
@Jk Hanfu is the traditional clothing of the the han people in China, and it’s not discontinued nor is it cosplay, that is quite rude of you to say about a country’s tradition.
Hanfu was not popular but as you know, When Chinese feel inferior to Korean, China start
@@feili1469 Hanbok has been steadily worn and developed for 5,000 years in Korean history. The basic form of hanbok is pants/skirt+jacket. The prototype of hanbok was established during the Goryeo Dynasty, which refers to the relocation of Joseon. In other words, the Joseon Dynasty is the last dynasty in Korea. Gyeongbokgung Palace in this video is also a palace from the Joseon Dynasty. Until the middle of Goryeo Dynasty, clothes were tied with belts, not ribbons, but during the Goryeo Dynasty, ribbons were used to fix the coat due to shorter tops and difficulties in belt. (Some argue that ribbons came from Mongolia, but ribbon-bound clothes have been found since the Silla period before Goryeo.) Also, during the Goryeo Dynasty, there was a country called Won (Mongol) in China. After the war between Mongolia and Goryeo, exchanges between Goryeo and Mongolia became active, and Goryeo culture began to become so popular that it was called Mongolians as exchanges between Goryeo and Mongolia became active. In addition, Goryeo women became empress of Mongolia, and the trend spread further as the number of Goryeo people in the royal family increased. At that time, people did not originally wear clothes but wore Goryeo hanbok. It can be seen that Goryeo culture was very popular in the Yuan Dynasty. (There are still many pronouns starting with Goryeo in China, and they have been handed down since then. After the fall of the Yuan Dynasty, there was the Ming Dynasty, a Han Dynasty, in China. People in the Ming Dynasty continued to wear clothes that they had worn since the Yuan Dynasty. And the clothes are traditional Korean clothes. However, the Chinese deny that their culture is superior to Korea and claim that Korea stole Chinese hanbok, but this is the opposite. The clothes of the Ming Dynasty were greatly influenced by the hanbok of Goryeo. Emperor Hong Chi-je of the Ming Dynasty knew this and banned traditional Korean clothes. Attached is a phrase from the Chinese history book below.
Surprised there was no mention of the hanfu!
Yea it’s sad. Qipao is from Qing dynasty which dates back only hundreds of years. I feel we Chinese have lost connection with Hanfu culture….time to bring it back!
Haha I'm guessing because hanfu is harder to attain for all three of them to wear.
@@no1xtz765 but Manchu are also chinese
@@newbabies923 The Manchus are actually Eastern Siberian people. They mostly came from the province of Heilongjiang, fomerly known as Manchuria and was part of Russia. The people have more in common with the Mongols than the Hans.
@@newbabies923 Manchus are tungusic people who conquered China in the 17th century.
I hate how the west always use the Shanghai prostitute clothes as national Chinese costume.
Hanfu is the real Chinese costume.
Qipao originated in Shanghai Beach, China
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
'Hanfu' is NOT daily cloth in china. Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago.
Qipao rarely can represent Chinese long history , basically its a clothing developed from Manchuria,Hanfu is more likely Chinese clothing. LOL Koreans.
맞아 우리는 옷을 입지않있어 좋아좋아
Qiaopao is beautiful dress, but not the traditional one. Should choose Hanfu.
Qipao is Manchuria clothing not Chinese!
It’s both Chinese and Manchurian.
@@concernedhermit7153
etnia no
culture no
pronounciation with han characters yes
What is Manchuria?
@@newbabies923 manchukuo
@@中国人的祖宗是共产党 so Manchuria are not chinese?
Of course a korean channel will want to advertise Qipao being Chinese traditional costunme, even though it was only invented 100 years ago compared to Hanfu!
Yeah. Korea's traditional cloth is Hanbok. Japan's traditional cloth is Kimono, China's traditional cloth is Qipao. Why is some country try to steal/change something? There are already a lot of Korean, Japanese, Chinese movies showing their own traditional clothes. Every country actor is wearing their own traditional cloth. If you can not believe it, go watch each country's movie.
Cheongsam is not a traditional Chinese dress. It has a history of only 100 years. It has evolved from Western three-dimensional tailoring and is a modern dress. Traditional Chinese clothing is loose flat cut. You can see it in many Chinese costume dramas.
I think you are misunderstanding tradition and historical
여기서도 봤듯이 한복은 대한민국의 전통의상이며 중국과는 확연히 다르다는 것을 알수있다. 중국정부는 이제 동북공정을 그만해라 제발..
All the Koreans speaking for Chinese people about Chinese history and what is actually considered hanfu or not probably don’t even truly know their own history because if they did, they would know what the sinosphere is and what kind of influence China has had on Korea’s history and culture. Stop telling Chinese people what is and isn’t their own culture.
Qipao is but one of Chinese traditional clothing. Even then, not truly the clothing of the Han Chinese. #hanfurevival
旗袍是清朝几乎灭亡时才出现的，根本不是字面意义上旗人的袍子
Why did they show Korean and Japanese clothing from thousands of years ago but showed a fairly modern Chinese clothing?
because your mao burnt them all
湖北十堰爆炸万岁 河南洪水万岁 山西洪水好棒哦 四川泸州地震万岁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂，南京航空航天大学实验室爆炸万岁 东航737坠机万岁😂😂😂😂😂😂，厉害了我的湖北十堰爆炸
all the clithing were beautiful
ikr. qipao is not even 150 years old. china’s civilization was over 3000 years old, yet they showed the “modernized vers”
Because both kinds of costumes are based on Hanfu.
I wish Jane would've pointed out that qipao is a recent 20th century Chinese dress. While it is a very distinct Chinese style of dress, the more traditional is the hanfu.
She dissapointed me
Qipao is not even Chinese clothing, its Manchurian clothing.
@@mikewallice2795 it is a chinese clothing, its just not a han clothing..
@@lyhthegreat nope, Manchu is not Chinese. Manchu belonged to Mongolic group.
@@mikewallice2795 chinese is a cultural identity of many ethnicities, not just han people
Qipao (Chinese Dress, lit. "flag robe") is actually a rather modern creation...
It is a modern costume in Shanghai. Can not represent the traditional Chinese clothing
Im not sure if this was the name but was it actually a hanfu? I'm by no means chinese so apologies if I made a mistake
@@jennifermary3581 Qipao is Chinese traditional costume what are you talking about
@@djdkdnhshdhd57 no hanfu was another country’s back in the Won era. Style of Hanfu was developed by Koryu, and that trend kept until Ming. I’m really confused why Chinese are trying to change their history
If you are Chinese, it's really a shame for you to translate the "Qi" of "Qipao" into "flag". If not, sorry to be some offensive. Anyway “Qi” is actually a nationality( also called "Man") of China -- they are called "Qi ren".
I don't think qipao can represent China lol.
cuz 90+percent of chinese is Han.
@Ben Kang More than 70% of the genetic deviations of Koreans can be a nation, and 90% of the Han nationality is of the same origin but has become politics? The Koreans retain only 30% of the ancestry of the Tunguska people, the rest are Han, Mongolian, Japanese, Fuyu people! The Han nationality has always accounted for more than 60% of the world's population in history. The pure blood Mongolians who ruled the Han nationality did not exceed 200 thousand, and the Manchus only had tens of thousands. This was just a drop of ink in the sea for the Han people of hundreds of millions of people at that time!
@Ben Kang But for Koreans, the number of Han, Mongolian, and Manchurian people who rule Korea is not a drop of ink dripping into the ocean! But South Korea has a population of only a few million ~
@Ben Kang Japan and Korea are political nations ~
？？？Qipao is not Han Chinese at all...
traditional chinese cloths:
qipao ×
hanfu √
u disappointed us .read more history about china. qipao is a stereotype
@Ben Kang Wrong! No region today except the Middle East and India retains the traditional trappings of Nissan life! So according to your definition is that there is no traditional dress! So even if you wear traditional hanfu at sacrifices, weddings and funerals like han people, you would say they wear cheongsam?
@Ben Kang Cheongsam passed down from generation to generation? Sacrifice, wedding, funeral can not wear the dress how to pass down from generation to generation?
@Ben Kang Why do Koreans use hanbok as a traditional costume in a country that is as extinct as everyday clothing? Do you still inherit the daily clothes of 100 years ago? Wasn't it all on the occasions I was talking about? So the Han people don't wear traditional clothes, right? 😜
@Ben Kang As long as it is a korean channel, the Chinese will always wear cheongsam, although koreans, Japanese and han people alike only wear traditional costumes on specific occasions! Korea is like a domestic servant whose master has been kidnapped. The master comes back but hogs the master's estate and doesn't let go! This kind of Korean traditional costume in Chiguri + Hanfu of the nobles = Hanbok! This kind of idea is really ridiculous！All kinds of software by han people to take out the cultural relics in the face, laugh 😂
@Ben Kang Hanbok is a copycat of Hanfu lol 😂 U scared the truth comes out right?
I was hoping they also wear kimono and hanbok too
nice video as always!
disappointed that the vietnamese ao dai is not included in this video
Hanbok, kimono and qipao❤❤❤❤ but i also love hanfu❤❤❤🇨🇳🇰🇷🇯🇵
Qipao : Manchu
Hanfu : Han Chinese
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
중국 사람들 중에 한복이 중국꺼라고 하는데.. 사실은 한복은 한국에 전통의상인데…
몇몇 중국인 때문에 가끔 혼란스러워
Have to say, I like Japan clothes best.
But qipao is a modern thing
Qipao？😂WTF
旗袍甚至都不是满族人的传统服饰，就算不拿汉服，恁把中国56个民族的衣服随便拿出一件都比这种又紧又不能也没人日常穿的现代改良旗袍强的多吧？还是说这是个韩国节目？这种连中华民国穿越过来的都不是。要恶心人别暗摸摸地做这种视频。
The Qipao in this video is not even the traditional costume of Manchu people. Even if you don’t use Hanfu, just taking out a piece of clothing from 56 ethnic groups in China is much stronger than this kind of modern improved qipao, which is tight and impossible and no one wears daily, right? Or is it a Korean Channel? Even the Republic of China does not wear such a qipao like this style. If you dislike Chinese, just say it directly.Don't spread wrong knowledge.
所以我举报了，要求下架这种垃圾
Why putting Qipao as the Chinese traditional costume? The most of people don’t even know the existence of Hanfu and they only know about qipao. There are also some people when see a Hanfu they think the hanfu is Korean or Japanese costume and it’s really bothering me. Qibao arrived in the modernization era of China so putting kimono and hanbok with qibao it’s just not the same time lines.
骯髒，還好沒把越南傳統服飾放進來，要不然500年前後黎朝的服飾也被講成學韓國，然後20世紀才出現的奧黛被說成傳統服飾。
I love these types of traditional clothing, and its interesting learning about other cultures. My personal favourite’s are the Chinese hanfu, and the kimono. But i also love the hanbok so much ahhhhh
Its so hard to choose there all pretty
Hanfu is a word that did not originally exist, and it is a word that began to be used to copy hanbok.
The word Hanbok didn't exist before the Japanese occupation in Korea in 1900 too.
@@bensontamu r just ignorant
OMG what the hell r u talking about😂HANFU is literally a simple translation for 汉服(“Traditional Chinese Clothes”). Don’t tell me that traditional Chinese clothes came after hanbok….
I think the original chinese han costume is hanfu, not qipao .
Hanfu more elegant than qipao
A you true beauty fan 🤔
这是民国改良旗袍，这是现代服饰而不是“传统”服饰…
I think that hanfu (汉服) would be more appropriate as a Chinese traditional clothing. Qipao (旗袍) is indeed Chinese, but it's fairly recent (~1920), and would be more vintage than traditional
I wished they would use Hanfu as the Chinese traditional clothing as QiPao means Manchu Clothing, China’s population is around 95 % Han Chinese! But I was kind of shock to see QiPao here, as I watch Chinese dramas especially Wuxia genre (don’t confuse historical wuxia or xianxian Chinese drama, historical is historical, Wuxia is historical but has fighting, flying, Kung fu, clans, Xianxian is historical but has fighting, flying, gods, immortals)
China has experienced a period of change. We have stopped cultural inheritance. Qipao does not represent Chinese traditional clothing. This concept is inaccurate. Hanfu is the right traditional dress, but many people have lost it
China : Sexy
Japan : Elegant
Korea : Cute
All : Beauty
I prefer Japan 👍
That's coz the Qipao is invented in 1920. The real traditional chinese dress is the shapless Hanfu.
I prefer Kimono Japan too 👘💗
I am obsessed with hanfu
The modern style Qipao was only widely worn by the Chinese at the beginning of the 20th century, before that, Hanfu is the actual national costume of China for thousands of years, and the style of Hanfu has influenced the costumes of neighboring countries such as Korea, Japan and Vietnam.
응 명나라 때 너네 나라에 고려풍이 유행이었어~ 제발 문화는 서로 주고 받는거야 존나 과거에 자위질 좀 그만해 ㅜㅜ
I love how you use “influence” instead of “originate”, you deserve respect🥰😘
@@dndud858 明太祖朱元璋时期对于高丽王朝的“赐服”，体系非常完备，从国王的衣冠到王妃、王世子的衣冠，从百官的官服到常服。明朝几乎把明朝初期服饰制度中清除蒙元“胡文化”影响，重新尊崇儒教礼仪的衣冠服饰的改革成果直接赠予了高丽王朝，意图给高丽王朝一套完整的服饰体系。从《明实录》《高丽史》和《朝鲜王朝实录》两国的史料参照对比，可以知道明朝衣冠对朝鲜的影响。
Fake !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
No, After 1646 Ming's collapsed. You han people have forced to wear the Qipao and Pig-tale hair style. So Manchu's tradition clothing were your real tradition, what is the hanfu anyway? You were han people wore the Manchu's clothing for about 4 hundreds years. Not only during 19 century.
한푸? 들어본 적이 없는데,, 뭔데 댓글을 점령함?
한汉나라때 입는 복장이라 한국어로는 '한복'汉服 이라고 해요 , 제가 생각했을 때 외국인들이 중국의 사극드라마 영화를 더 즐겨보는 것 같아서 한푸더 잘 알고 있는 것 같아요
@@_janeking6884 简直太可笑了。汉服是汉族人穿的服饰，不是汉代。真的是无知者无畏。只有你说的出旗袍是中国传统服饰。怎么有人可以拿一个国家少数民族服饰按照西方审美改良出来的不到百年历史的衣服当做传统服饰？真tm丢人。
@@_janeking6884 汉字是汉代的字？呵呵
I suggest you spend some time to study East Asian History.
Big mistake: traditional Chinese dress is hanfu, not qipao
@Ben Kang Even Koreans originated in China 😛
@Ben Kang little china 😂
@@bkang3132 hanfu is historical han people dress and Qipao is heavily influenced from Manchurian. This is it.
And no, Manchurian CANNOT represent China. Qing Dynasty has collapsed in 1911.
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
Qipao is not an old costume. Not traditional clothing. It's modern
I always love seeing traditional dresses from other countries. It's really interesting to see China as well as Thailand and Vietnam have similar silhouettes to what my South Asian culture wears. The Qipao and Ao Dai (sorry if the spelling wrong for them) are similar to salwar kameez and Chut Thai (again plz correct me) is similar to the sari. Love seeing these!!☺️☺️☺️
qipao is manchurian clothing, Hanfu is Chinese clothing
@@ohmygodlawl but now manchu is part of chinese ethnic coz manchurian inside china province. If im not wrong the province call liaoning
Lol India 😂
@@serbaserbi6004 Not all of them are in Liaoning, and I believe there are more Manchus in Beijing. Most Manchus live in the north, but in fact, the migration of population in modern society is very frequent. I live in Qinghai Province. There are many ethnic minorities here. Most of the people I contact are Tibetans and Hui, but actually some of my friends are Manchus. In Chinese history, the Han nationality has always been the main ethnic group with the majority, so the Han clothes worn by the Han people can represent the traditional costumes of the Chinese people in a certain sense, at least compared with the cheongsam produced in modern history. For example, I once had a Tibetan girlfriend. She had Tibetan robes (Tibetan traditional clothes), but she also wore Han clothes. China has been a multi-ethnic country since ancient times, and Hanfu is not invariable. In fact, it has been influenced by many different cultures. The system of Hanfu and the culture behind it, including historical changes, have complete ancient books in China. Thanks to our ancestors who liked to record almost everything in books and paintings.
@@ohmygodlawl qipao is as Chinese as the hanfu. Nationality and ethnicity is different in today’s world
Where is Hanfu？
棒国倭国人夹带私货
@@Cats_Bread 哈哈😃
旗袍為滿人服飾，恐非能代表漢文化中心的漢服。
這是個韓國頻道，漢服對韓服影響太深，在韓國歷史去中化嚴重，明漢服對他們來説還是他們的韓服。
@@seegpoint258 晚明服裝就不一樣了，你可以看很多穿漢服的女性大部分都會選擇晚明漢服，因為晚明女性完全不需要交領了！
Honestly, anyone speaking and reading a second language has superpowers to me, lol. The ladies did a great job, especially knowing how difficult our R and L pronunciation is for them.
I knew Hanbok and Kimono.. I knew Chinese dress too but not the name
The video is called qipao, and there is another traditional costume in China,called hanfu, 🥰There are many kinds of hanfu
It is Hanfu and Qipao I know lol
You guys look like really pretty lead actresses from a Chinese romance drama tv series such as Till the End of the Moon, or The Journey of Chongzi !
Actually China should use hanfu not qipao,qipao most like clothes of manchu and hanfu is the traditional clothes of han people
Cheongsam is not full of people. The dress of a warlord's wife during the Republic of China. Clothing in modern and contemporary times in Shanghai. This does not represent our China. Because of the westernization of Shanghai's clothing. It has nothing to do with Manchu.
not qipao...ignoring 95% of chinese population's traditonal clothes -hanfu really disappointing.
你为什么只展示旗袍？你是满族人吗？？百分之90的汉族人的汉服都没有😓
那么满族清朝统治了人口大部分的汉族吗？现在中国过去的游牧民也包括在内，汉族怎么那么大多数？？🤔
The problem with QIPAO is that, it came from a dynasty ruled by foreign invaders.
Although not in that degree, but showing only Qipao as traditional Chinese clothing without showing Hanfu， is kind of like Indian people showing some pictures of 'traditional Indian clothing' but there are just bunch of British style clothing in those pictures.
So the same logic doesn't apply to Korean and Japanese as some people suggested.
Showing Qipao but not hanfu? Nowadays people wear hanfu in the Spring Festival, Qixi Festival, Mid Autumn and more. I forgot also in weddings.
Hanfu is a recently coined term didn't exist. The Chinese communists came up this term for the obvious reason
Hanfu is nothing other than clothes worn by people of Han dynasty
@@곰탱이알러지 A lot of Chinese are Han ethnic. Why would they wear Manchu clothes when it's not Han at all.
@@곰탱이알러지Han nationality:？？？？
Hanbok ❤️ i remember wearing everytime when i visit 경복궁(kyung-bok palace)
As a Chinese, I must say that Hanfu is more common in China. I rarely saw Qipao except in restaurants.
@@kiss526 exactly Qipao only existed 100 years while Hanfu existed way back from ancient times.
@@kiss526 얘네들이랑은 말이안통할거같어요 에고 유명한 중국음식점가보면 저런옷입고서빙하는구만 만주족옷이라자기꺼 아니라네…..ㅓ이없다
The Changpao and Qipao are also clearly chinese traditional clothes. If you deny this, It means that chinese government has oppresively ruled Manchu peoples now, and Your History in 1616 to 1912 had rather ruled by Manchu peoples than can be said chinese history itself, and the areas like manchuria, Tibet, Uygur are not your lands because these land had governed by manchu peoples. So I ask you once again. Is it clearly true that Qipao and changpao are not your traditional clothes?
@@물멍-d8b They are, but from all our whole variety of traditional clothes, many identify more with Hanfu. It’s the Chinese who get to decide which one they prefer and what they want to wear.
@@arles1124 But Qing banned the Ming's outfit and most of modern chinese and there elder's and to the great great grandfather. They never worn hanfu as their outfit, instead they wear Qing's outfit. If you know what actually "traditional" really means. You should not say that hanfu as a traditional clothes...It a Historical clothes. Just like old roman outfit and egypt outfit. If you want to tell its a traditional. Then it should be inherited through your great great grand father to your elders and to you. But it's a lost outfit for long time. And although chinese try to restore hanfu in modern times. We actually don't say that as your "traditional" outfit.
So sad, I was expecting seeing the hanfu as the chinese traditional dress, qipao is a modern traditional chinese dress but isnt the one to represent china. Jane is Chinese, she should know it. If u search on Google, like chinese traditional paints u going to see that the chineses girls are wearing hanfu and only hanfu. I didn't like this video
coz this is a Korea video.
southief Korea wanna steal Chinese culture and hide that thier hanbok was based on Chinese hanfu.
The qipao isn’t really traditional. It’s a hybrid of Manchu and western elements popularised by socialites and women of Shanghai in the 1920s before spreading to other parts of China. Several of the ethnic minorities of China DO have traditional costumes. But Han Chinese don’t really have one. Han Chinese may try to wear a hanfu but which dynasty style do they go for? It’s inconsistent . it’s tradition got cut by the Qing dynasty midway and a modern Han dressing in a hanfu would be like an American dressing for the renaissance fair. there’s no rules or elements that dictate it as traditional anymore. the qipao is closer to a formal wear for an event or party, but once again isn’t not traditional. (The slit on the side has always been there but before they wore pants underneath) in the 1920s the ladies tried to emulate a western style and stopped wearing the pants which is why it gives off an almost sexy vibe.
The Changpao and Qipao are also clearly chinese traditional clothes. If you deny this, It means that chinese government has oppresively ruled Manchu peoples now, and Your History in 1616 to 1912 had rather ruled by Manchu peoples than can be said chinese history itself, and the areas like manchuria, Tibet, Uygur are not your lands because these land had governed by manchu peoples. So I ask you once again. Is it clearly true that Qipao and changpao are not your traditional clothes?
The chinese medieval clothes are hanfu(which had worn 400 years ago), And chinese traditional clothes are Changpao or Qipao.
@@물멍-d8b the qipao is indeed traditional- to Manchurians. That is the loose baggy qipao. The tight one modified my Shanghainese Han socialites is not. And no ethnic Manchu would say it was. Couldn’t care less if Xinjiang and Tibet were or were not part of China tbh and your alluding to them has nothing to to with whether the slit styled qipao is “traditional” or not. Heck, if you try to make me admit to that, I’ll have to admit that somehow the Hanbok is a traditional Chinese costume too since the ethnic Koreans are a recognised ethnicity of China and I’m sure that’s already angered enough Koreans as is.
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
Kotoha looks cute in qipao.
Especially her hair.
I like that hair-cut.
Hyejin and Jane look good too.
Lots of love from India 🇮🇳❤️🇯🇵🇰🇷🇨🇳
얔ㅋㅋㅋ 치파오도 중국꺼 아니잖앜ㅋㅋ
As we all know, everything in the world is Korean😂
@@luzm586 뭐래ㅋㅋ 대한민국은 중국처럼 자문화중심주의 아님^^
Qipao was popular only started 1920s,I do not think it is Chinese traditional clothing. China can not use one traditional style clothing to represent .becuase there were so many dynasties ,and every dynasty was so different.and many styles .
中国青年政治学院教授张跣认为现代汉服运动倡导者所宣传的汉服概念不存在于中国传统文化和现代汉语中，他认为汉服运动倡导者为宣扬自己的思想和观念，总结了明代以前汉族服饰传统而形成的一个假定了“汉服”在发展过程中的“血统”的纯正性的“类概念”
Because before the People's Republic of China was founded, China was ruled by Manchu kings. The Han people were under the rule of the Qing Dynasty for 300 years, so they completely changed into Qing clothing. Modern Chinese people do not wear the now-disappeared Han Chinese traditional clothing as their daily clothing.
It is now difficult to define the Han Chinese because the Han Chinese culture was lost during the 300 years of Qing Dynasty rule. They are mixed now. The Chinese themselves know this. What is now called 'Hanfu' were clothes worn only by the royal family and nobles, not clothes worn by commoners on a daily basis. Also, there is no basis for traditional styles that have been passed down from the past. It began to appear in TV dramas in the 2000s. There are many photographs and video records of the clothes people wore in their daily lives 100 years ago. hanfu was not daily cloth in china.
Like everyone else said, Qipao isn't the traditional chinese dress, Hanfu is. Qipao is a modern invention that combined Manchu dress with Western cocktail dress
我不明白为什么人们要成为韩国人，除非他们抛弃了中国人永恒的历史和传统。 如今，中国人通过未经授权使用版权来制作和观看电视节目，而没有将版权提供给韩国人。 像这样的中国电视剧和电视剧太多了。 中国人尝试吃平时不吃的泡菜，大胆地扔掉漂亮的中国服饰，穿连自己都不穿的韩服，女性化着韩式妆容。 连电子产品都跟韩国一样抄袭制造，自夸。 现在的中国人说韩国历史也是中国历史，中国人不就成了说中文的韩国人了吗？ 为什么要放弃精良的中国文化，去模仿韩国的一切？ 连北京冬奥会都在模仿韩国的一切。 13亿的骄傲在哪里？ 中国的一切都来自韩国文化吗？ 中国文化在哪里？应该把秦始皇和长城带到朝鲜吗？
不好意思，这是东北辣白菜，在东北是穷人家吃的
@@Cats_Bread 湖北十堰爆炸万岁 河南洪水万岁 山西洪水好棒哦 四川泸州地震万岁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂，南京航空航天大学实验室爆炸万岁 东航737坠机万岁😂😂😂😂😂😂，厉害了我的湖北十堰爆炸
This isn’t a video about the history of Chinese traditional costume. Japan and Korea also have long histories and garments that have evolved over time. They’re just comparing the most recent popularized version of each country’s traditional garment.
Yes the hanfu too but the qipao isnt even in the same category as hanfu. Theres a diffrense between modifying/update and inventing a whole new line of clothing.
Kimono : Kawaii 😍😍
Qipao : Sexy 🔥🔥
Hanbok : Polite 😌😌
Korean polite? Lol funny joke
@@sara.cbc92 Was that supposed to be like,,a jab at Koreans? Ethnicity doesn’t define a person’s level of politeness lmfao
@@sara.cbc92 y do Chinese always demean people from other countries? Just keep that in ur diary
@@limlin2312 She’s a known anti Korean Taiwanese troll lol Disregard her. She needs to touch some damn grass for once.
Sorry! I’m not trying to be rude but isn’t Chinese traditional clothes is 漢服???
我没有韩服，只有旗袍所以只展示了旗袍🥰 我也超喜欢汉服
做节目之前是不是应该去了解一下自己国家传统服饰的历史？旗袍是现代服饰，不是传统服饰。旗袍是上世纪20年代汉人在满族长袍的基础上按照西洋服饰改良出来的。而清朝削发易服的历史九年义务有教吧？即使你没有汉服，也应该提一嘴，旗袍的历史不过百年，只能作为现代礼服。还有，不要把汉服打成韩服。
这个问题现在很敏感，中国因为这个对韩国情绪很大，你们这是在火坑上跳舞，最好删了
@@Cats_Bread 怎么可能啊，这可是韩国人的频道。她们这么做，无非就是想把中国的传统服饰限缩在旗袍的框架里，这样她们就可以肆无忌惮地偷了。
Qipao is not wrong, but as a Chinese girl I kinda find that I identify more with Hanfu. Thanks for showing the Qipao but I think demonstrating Hanfu (Maybe those from dynasties that look neither like kimono nor Hanbok) might be better.
感谢你帮助韩国人给中国人灌输旗袍是我们的传统服饰，这样我们的历史就只有百年不到了，正中韩国人的小心思，您可真是韩国人的好内鬼😅
This was fun to watch :) I enjoyed learning about the differences
😀😃
Tender Plant Lives
Hidden Message in the
Torah /Tanak / Bible
Hidden within within the genealogy first Sons from Adam. Genesis 5 : 3-32
NAMES ---- Name
MEANINGS
Adam - Man
Seth - Appointed
Enos - Mortal
Cainan - Sarrow
Mahalaleel - Blessed GOD
Jared - Shall come Down
Enoch - Teaching
Methuselah -His Death shall
Bring
Lamech -To Make /Low
Mighity
Noah -Rest / Favor /
Fulfilled
Name Meanings written in a
Sentence 😳
Man appointed mortal Sarrow Blessed GOD shall come down
teaching His death shall bring to make low/MIGHTY , rest favor FULFILLED
My Interpretation:
Jesus given a task to preform from this earth feeling of deep distress BLESSED GOD shall come down as Jesus teaching Jews as a Rabbi His death shall bring SALVATION to make low to hang on a tree becomes MIGHTY rest/ favor/ FULFILLED HIS Purpose 🤔
Keep this in mind 🤔all 10 generations timeline took place up to chapter 5 of Genesis ,Hidden Message telling Jesus COMING 😲
Approximately 4 thousand years later before it HAPPENED only God !
Ten Trillion people could not have gotten together and had have written 1 fact and placed it in a book Foretelling of there coming Christ 4K years before it Happened .
Who hath believed our report ? For and to whom is the arm of Lord revealed ?
For he shall grow up before him as a tender plant, and as a root out of a dry ground: he hath
No form nor comeliness ; and when we shall see him, there is no beauty that we should desire him.
He is despised and rejected of men; a men of sorrows , and acquainted with grief: and we hid as it were our faces from him; he was despised and we esteemed him not.
Surely he hath borne our grief , and carried our sorrows: yet we did esteem him stricken, smitten of God, and afflicted.
But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed.
All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned every one to his own way; and the Lord hath laid on him the iniquity of us all.
He was oppressed, and he was
all .
He was oppressed , and he was afflicted , yet he opened not his mouth : he is brought as a lamb to the slaughter , and as a sheep before her shearers is dumb, so he openers not his mouth.
He was taken from prison
From judgment: and who shall declare this generation? For
He was cut off out of the land of the living: for he was cutting off out of the land of the living: for the transgression of my people was he stricken.
And he made his grave with the wicked, and with the rich in his death; because he had done no violence , neither was any deceit in his mouth.
Yet it pleased the Lord to bruise him ; he hath put him to grief: when thou shalt make his soul an offering for sin he shall see his seed , he shall prolong his days, and the pleasure of the Lord shall prosper in his hand.
He shall see of the travail of his soul , and shall be satisfied : by
His knowledge shall my righteous servant justify many ; for he shall bear their iniquities. Therefore Will I divide him a portion with the great, and he shall divide the spoil with the spoil with the strong ; because he hath pored out his soul unto death : and he was numbered with the transgressor ; and he bare the sin of many, and made intercession for the transgressors.
Who is this About?
KJV in Isaiah 53
The Truth will set you free !
Christ means Messiah ,
Jesus was a Jew and still is .
Jesus is not a religion,
Jesus Loves You
Believe ON The Lord Jesus Christ
You are Born Again
Believe as a child
Just Believe
RAPTURE Very SOON 😳
It is Not Death But Life
Tuesday 30 , 2022
Or
3 , Elul 5782
3:37 AM
Control time , has not happened yet , any Second
Are you Ready ,
Believe ON Jesus
Heaven
or Outerdarkness
God will not hear your prayers that is hell.
TH-cam : Rapture 2022
Please choose Jesus
Chinese in the comments should stop claiming Hanbok as yours lol. History is right there, no matter how hard you want Hanbok as yours you can’t change the history.
hanbok is from korea, hanfu is from China, and what i saw is korea people come to say hanfu is from korea, please respect each country culture, thanks
@@江集-v1p Lol a lot of you guys using hanbok as Hanfu. When we point that out and then you guys say “Hanbok is a type of Hanfu” or “Hanbok copied Hanfu”. Respect our culture thanks.
@@SeowonYoon respect each other culture and stop argue like a kid
I like Hanbok and the Chinese dress the most 😍❤️
Qipao.
Qipao don't chinese traditional costume , Modern fashion since 1920s The republic of China！！
Hey, girls! I really enjoy your videos, because I'm very interested in your three cultures. I'm from Bulgaria - a country in Southeast Europe. Bulgarian traditional women clothing called " bulagrian nosia".
This clothing is worn mostly on special traditional holidays and unfortunately has very little presence in the modern clothing of Bulgarian women.
Nah, I was expecting Hanfu. This is no no
ya korean channel introduce chinese traditional custume as qipao instead hanfu? something ackward
旗袍是中国的的服装，起源于满族，但不是 汉民族的服装！！
湖北十堰爆炸万岁 河南洪水万岁 山西洪水好棒哦 四川泸州地震万岁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂，南京航空航天大学实验室爆炸万岁 东航737坠机万岁😂😂😂😂😂😂，厉害了我的湖北十堰爆炸
식민지 시절 의복이라 치파오가 싫어?
@@powerajw1163 it is. Just like Korean wouldn't use Kimono as their traditional costume.
I wish people would stop perpetuating the myth that Qipao is traditional Chinese dress. It isn't. It is Manchu, and, at least for women, dates only to the early 20th Century. In China, there is a trend amongst some young people to wear "Hanfu" - clothing of the Han people. Of course, this is pretty broad, since clothing from the Han Dynasty was different from that of the Tang, the Song or the Ming. A decent video on the topic can be found here: th-cam.com/video/o5NDHB2ZSrI/w-d-xo.html
The worst part is that the qipao they showed were modernized Manchu dresses, not even the traditional Manchu dresses lol but I do agree, they should’ve shown hanfu since those are definitely older/traditional instead of modern
슬픈 만주족..