I am an atheist, but if ever I consider a religion, I have no doubt it will be Sikhism. I am glad people like Bhai Mandeep Singh are spreading correct, factual information on such a ghastly attack. As an Indian, I will forever be shamed at what conspired in 1984. I have learnt so much from this channel and hope to continue doing so.
@@yogeshgupta3940 Please provide links to any documents or actual footage of the interviews you are talking about. I have heard Subramanian say he was short tempered but couldn’t find anything about killing hindus.
This video should be broadcasted during June every single year. The amount of people that quote lines of the Indian govt, trying to debunk the fight for equal rights, will surely think twice. Great work BoS team. Keep up the good work!
Yes. The Indian government who just fast tracked Indian visas to Sikhs in Pakistan and Afghanistan, is trying to "debunk" the fight for equal rights lol. The Indian government hates Sikhs so much that they're trying to protect them from Islamic theocracies where they are persecuted... Don't be naïve.
The Panjab story brings back a lot of memories for me. For me it was the mystic of the foreign correspondent. When foreign reporting came from a very distant place. I met the BBC guys in the very early 2000’s. Mark Tully & Satish Jacob who reported on this. I spoke extensively on this subject to them. I started my career in journalism at that time. I can always remember Mark Tully saying to me that Major General Shabeg Singh was a military man in presence. P.S “The Broken Butterfly”. Here’s a possible title idea for anyone who would like to write about the tragedy that is Panjab.
Hi my dear Sikhs 😊💗, I'm a Hindu and my family runs a temple in Delhi and Inn 1984 during the Sikhs riots my dad told me that many Sikhs came to them to seek refuge and out all places we could have hid them we hid them in the alter behind the murti of Shri maha laxmi Narayan and my dad questioned my grandfather that there are other places the alter is only for brahmins and pujaris but my wise dadaji replied saying the Sikhs have made so much sacragice for our faith that they deserve to be honoured by going in the alter and sitting there this was the level of respect we have for Sikhs, and of course the congress mobs came and he saw congress party logos on the cars and they tried to attack the temple but failing to do so they then poured Kerosine around the complex engulfing it in flames they all survived by the fire not being able to penetrate the thick whiles but that night I believe just shows to our family so much about everything it was a revolutionary year
@@supdasaaf go read some more, you are parroting government propaganda. Read Hindu Punjabi book The Gallant Defender by AR Darshi to learn about Sant Ji or go read Anandpur Resolution (both free online)
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Is it possible to know when the documentary on 1984 would come to Malaysian Cinema or at least be available online? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Check out their website and also follow them on social media ji: www.battleofamritsar.com/ It probably won't be put online for some time, but you can also message them and try and organise a showing near you, even at a Gurdwara!
Sorry ji as this is mostly in English we haven't actively translated it, you can also turn on the Auto-English Subtitles/closed captions on TH-cam (although some words are not accurate)
Can you please provide the sources and links for the quotes you mentioned throughout the video I’m doing a project on this and would really appreciate it
Bhindranwale said he would kill 5,000 innocent Hindus if the government did not release his bus (Puneet Sahani on Facebook or Twitter has the clip). He also encouraged violence to Nirankaris and Sikhs who didn't agree with him. Tell me where Gurus ever sanctioned the killing of INNOCENT people in Sikhi. Bhindranwale is a terrorist.
How come you guys never mentioned General Shabeg Singh he was the man who Organised the defences and the man who gave the indian army the hardest fight
As a Muslim pathan who is born in Britain Birmingham I had many sikh friends and family friends especially living in handsworth soho rd and rookery rd growing up as pathans warrior code we protect anybody who is suffering also imran khan is doing what most pathans do
@@BasicsofsikhiTV oh dear is there any chance you can humbly request him to please add it back on the channel many of my for friends who r into sikhi and hare Krishna movement want to watch it
Is this not a debate that should be settled by Sikhs themselves? That being said the country of India comprises of many many groups of people and I think that should be taken into consideration when it comes to participating in a Republic. To take absolute measures does not bode well for a democracy to function.
This is the issue Ji, 'Democracy' has not functioned and is continuing to fail today; as humans we are all one, and we should all strive to help each other make the world a better place 🙏
@@BasicsofsikhiTV Yes. And please tell me where a theocracy (which don't get is what Khalistan would be if it were implemented) has been used as a successful model any where in the world. Helping people means telling them the truth and not spreading propaganda. Bring on Puneet Sahani an objective Sikh on the Khalistani movement.
@@WingZero0101 where are you getting info about a theocracy? When has a theocracy ever existed? Ranjit Singh Raj was a monarchy, Misls Raj was not a theocracy but Federalism.
Punjab Ch Ludhiana Ch gurudaware te Nishan sahid te bulldozer chala Dita Koi v Sikh veer aage nhi Aaya 2022 Ch teen gurudaware te hamle ho chuke ne But Sikh komm anjan baithi es to Up Ch Oddisha Ch gurudaware thaah ke laiterna bathroom banna dita Sikha Di zameer maar chuki aa th-cam.com/video/QCytF983DDs/w-d-xo.html
I am an atheist, but if ever I consider a religion, I have no doubt it will be Sikhism. I am glad people like Bhai Mandeep Singh are spreading correct, factual information on such a ghastly attack. As an Indian, I will forever be shamed at what conspired in 1984. I have learnt so much from this channel and hope to continue doing so.
Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa
@@yogeshgupta3940 Sorry Gupta Ji, I don't drink the Indian State Kool aid. Good luck with your biases.
@@yogeshgupta3940 Please provide links to any documents or actual footage of the interviews you are talking about. I have heard Subramanian say he was short tempered but couldn’t find anything about killing hindus.
Don't believe this guy. He gave a very biased account of events.
@@WingZero0101 sure. then share links of unbiased accounts, more than happy to hear them too.
This video should be broadcasted during June every single year. The amount of people that quote lines of the Indian govt, trying to debunk the fight for equal rights, will surely think twice. Great work BoS team. Keep up the good work!
Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa!
Yes. The Indian government who just fast tracked Indian visas to Sikhs in Pakistan and Afghanistan, is trying to "debunk" the fight for equal rights lol.
The Indian government hates Sikhs so much that they're trying to protect them from Islamic theocracies where they are persecuted... Don't be naïve.
The Panjab story brings back a lot of memories for me. For me it was the mystic of the foreign correspondent. When foreign reporting came from a very distant place. I met the BBC guys in the very early 2000’s. Mark Tully & Satish Jacob who reported on this. I spoke extensively on this subject to them. I started my career in journalism at that time. I can always remember Mark Tully saying to me that Major General Shabeg Singh was a military man in presence.
P.S “The Broken Butterfly”. Here’s a possible title idea for anyone who would like to write about the tragedy that is Panjab.
Hi my dear Sikhs 😊💗, I'm a Hindu and my family runs a temple in Delhi and Inn 1984 during the Sikhs riots my dad told me that many Sikhs came to them to seek refuge and out all places we could have hid them we hid them in the alter behind the murti of Shri maha laxmi Narayan and my dad questioned my grandfather that there are other places the alter is only for brahmins and pujaris but my wise dadaji replied saying the Sikhs have made so much sacragice for our faith that they deserve to be honoured by going in the alter and sitting there this was the level of respect we have for Sikhs, and of course the congress mobs came and he saw congress party logos on the cars and they tried to attack the temple but failing to do so they then poured Kerosine around the complex engulfing it in flames they all survived by the fire not being able to penetrate the thick whiles but that night I believe just shows to our family so much about everything it was a revolutionary year
The worst part is no media ever wanted to here our story and all the other temples which helped Sikhs this is the divisive politics our nation
Thank you to your family for doing the right thing. Please avoid far right Hindutva that tries to divide communities.
@@supdasaaf go read some more, you are parroting government propaganda. Read Hindu Punjabi book The Gallant Defender by AR Darshi to learn about Sant Ji or go read Anandpur Resolution (both free online)
@@supdasaaf Hindutva is not Hinduism, Hindutva is far right extremist Hindus who get false information from WhatsApp groups and spread lies
@@supdasaaf GBS Sidhu worked for RAW and created fake Khalistan movement
ਕੋਟਿ ਕੋਟਿ ਪ੍ਰਣਾਮ ਸੰਤ ਬਾਬਾ ਜਰਨੈਲ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀ ਭਿੰਡਰਾਵਾਲਿਆ ਨੂੰ 😢❤️🙏
Coward using holy place for combat becomes a saint😂😂😂
As a Punjabi Hindu the attack on harmandir is just as upsetting for us Hindus as it is for Sikhs my dad an ancestors were doing seva there for years
Vaheguru 🙏
Vaheguru my siksh brothers ❤️
Bless your beloved father and your family 🙏🙏
@@gurdittsingh7787 thank u
@@gurdittsingh7787 many Hindus make pilgrimage to harmandir Sahib to uphold unity and give thank to sikhi waheguru
Im also sorry for the Army atrocities and Genocide inside India.💔😖
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕਾ ਖ਼ਾਲਸਾ, ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕੀ ਫ਼ਤਹਿ.
this is reaally good as person who wants to get closser to waeguru it brings me a good understanind about our history
Waheguru Ji! 💙💙💙💙💙
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Is it possible to know when the documentary on 1984 would come to Malaysian Cinema or at least be available online?
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Check out their website and also follow them on social media ji: www.battleofamritsar.com/
It probably won't be put online for some time, but you can also message them and try and organise a showing near you, even at a Gurdwara!
Please do a podcast with veggie gains and/or gym singh etc on fitness ❤
ਪ੍ਰਣਾਮ ਸ਼ਹੀਦਾਂ ਨੂੰ
ਸਿਰ ਜਾਵੇਂ ਤਾ ਜਾਵੇਂ ਮੇਰਾ ਸਿੱਖੀ ਸਿਦਕ ਨਾ ਜਾਵੇਂ
Bhai sahab ji could you please add subtitle for the video ?
Sorry ji as this is mostly in English we haven't actively translated it, you can also turn on the Auto-English Subtitles/closed captions on TH-cam (although some words are not accurate)
Khalsa Ji do you have this Singhs Instagram please? I know he mentions having a page in this video but it’s not stated anywhere. Dhanvad. Akaalo
instagram.com/mandeepsinghbookreviews/
Vaheguru Dhanvad ji
Can you please provide the sources and links for the quotes you mentioned throughout the video I’m doing a project on this and would really appreciate it
All sources are provided in description
good video
Bro make more content like this i am from i found this content very hard to find
🙏🏾
Dhan Dhan sant jarnail singh bhindranwale ji 🙏
Bhindranwale said he would kill 5,000 innocent Hindus if the government did not release his bus (Puneet Sahani on Facebook or Twitter has the clip). He also encouraged violence to Nirankaris and Sikhs who didn't agree with him.
Tell me where Gurus ever sanctioned the killing of INNOCENT people in Sikhi.
Bhindranwale is a terrorist.
How come you guys never mentioned General Shabeg Singh he was the man who Organised the defences and the man who gave the indian army the hardest fight
As a Muslim pathan who is born in Britain Birmingham I had many sikh friends and family friends especially living in handsworth soho rd and rookery rd growing up as pathans warrior code we protect anybody who is suffering also imran khan is doing what most pathans do
Dhan Dhan Ramdaspur
I have a question where did the podcast where the hare Krishna go I rlly wanted to watch n so did my family especially my dadima
Apologies ji, it was taken down as per the request of the guest.
@@BasicsofsikhiTV oh dear is there any chance you can humbly request him to please add it back on the channel many of my for friends who r into sikhi and hare Krishna movement want to watch it
ਸਾਰੀ ਸਿੱਖ ਕੌਮ ਇੱਕੱਠੀ ਹੋ ਕੇ ਸਿਮਰਨਜੀਤ ਸਿੰਘ ਮਾਨ ਨੂੰ ਜਿਤਾਓ-ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ਪਾਣੀਆਂ, ਬਿਜਲੀ, ਬੋਲੀ ਤੇ ਵਿਰਸੇ ਨੂੰ ਬਚਾਓ,Unity is our biggest Hope ਏਕਤਾ ਸਾਡਾ ਸੱਭ ਤੋਂ ਵੱਡਾ ਹਥਿਆਰ- ਹੱਲ ਤਾਂ ਇਕੋ ਹੈ-ਰਾਜ ਬਿਨਾ ਨਹਿ ਧਰਮ ਚਲੇ ਹੈਂ
Vaheguruji Ka Khalsa Vaheguruji Ke Feteh
Is this not a debate that should be settled by Sikhs themselves?
That being said the country of India comprises of many many groups of people and I think that should be taken into consideration when it comes to participating in a Republic. To take absolute measures does not bode well for a democracy to function.
This is the issue Ji, 'Democracy' has not functioned and is continuing to fail today; as humans we are all one, and we should all strive to help each other make the world a better place 🙏
@@BasicsofsikhiTV for sure my work recently has been to help individuals approach life from a grounded perspective. 🙃
@@BasicsofsikhiTV Yes. And please tell me where a theocracy (which don't get is what Khalistan would be if it were implemented) has been used as a successful model any where in the world.
Helping people means telling them the truth and not spreading propaganda. Bring on Puneet Sahani an objective Sikh on the Khalistani movement.
@@WingZero0101 where are you getting info about a theocracy? When has a theocracy ever existed? Ranjit Singh Raj was a monarchy, Misls Raj was not a theocracy but Federalism.
@@mariabrar6290 What's the point of creating Khalistan if it won't be a theocracy?
I'm Sorry on behalf of those People who celebrated Golden temple attack by believing govt. and media lies.
Citizens of Democrwcy, Amea Rao?
Waheguru
Punjab Ch Ludhiana Ch gurudaware te Nishan sahid te bulldozer chala Dita
Koi v Sikh veer aage nhi Aaya
2022 Ch teen gurudaware te hamle ho chuke ne
But Sikh komm anjan baithi es to
Up Ch
Oddisha Ch gurudaware thaah ke laiterna bathroom banna dita
Sikha Di zameer maar chuki aa
th-cam.com/video/QCytF983DDs/w-d-xo.html
@Lost World veer ji video link Dita hai
In Odisha they removed the toilet bcuz Hindus rallied around sikhs
Unfortunately this is prolly banned in India.