I am a great Steven Wilson fan and this song is one my favs!! It makes me cry every time I hear it. This version did not do that to me. But, what a fantastic hommage and tribute to the great Steven Wilson!!! The arrangement is fantastic!!
I'm a huge Steven Wilson (& Ninet Tayeb) fan and the original of this is one of the greatest pieces of music ever recorded IMHO. However, I think this arrangement and performance is great. Someone in this orchestra has great taste (e.g. Lennon, Crimson, Lyle Mays, even Piazzola). The unnecessary dig at the singer by an individual on here is out of order - singing in another language is extremely hard. She does a great 'Roxanne' too - see here: th-cam.com/video/WAwYEHtvzNM/w-d-xo.html
Honorable et audacieuse reprise d'un titre déjà inscrit dans l'anthologie du rock progressif. L'apport du hautbois apporte un avantage remarquable à l'interprétation. Cependant, la basse et la guitare ne parviennent pas à faire oublier Nick Beggs ni Guthrie Govan, et il est permis de se demander pourquoi ces séquences ne furent pas assumées aux cordes mais bon ... Le tout me semble agréable.
to beat the performance of Ninet tayeb is a hard thing to do but she gave the song a very uniqe touch with her rough voice ,i love it. also the orchestra made the song a little more intense in my opinion but i will stay with the duett of steven an ninet. the performance of them together made me cut onions and thats not the only song from steven that made me feel that way. he is one oft the best musicians alive and im glad we didnt lose him to early like some other great people.
yeah..ummmm...NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HORRBLE cover of Ninet's vocals...sorry, but just trying to save anyone else who loves the song from suffering what i just did.
Very well done. You all honoured the song, I’m impressed. Thank you so much. ❤
thank you!
Hermosa versión de una gran composición. Gracias!!!
Cieszę się ż SW jest interpretowany w klasycznym stylu
I my ;))
I am a great Steven Wilson fan and this song is one my favs!! It makes me cry every time I hear it. This version did not do that to me. But, what a fantastic hommage and tribute to the great Steven Wilson!!! The arrangement is fantastic!!
I would love to know what do you think of my version if you have time th-cam.com/video/IZl-CWQO71E/w-d-xo.html
This is a wonderful arrangement of a beautiful piece of music. It really honors the original song. Well done.
World class musicians love their passion it comes through in their beautiful moments while playing
Beautifully done.
Beautiful song, beautifully performed.
One of my favorite songs ever,
Wonderfully performed. It does justice to such a masterful song.
❤️
one cannot improve the perfection
Bellissima versione!!
Beautifully done!
Wow
I'm crying!!!
That's really beautiful. What led you to choose this song ? Who did the orchestral arrangement?
I'm a huge Steven Wilson (& Ninet Tayeb) fan and the original of this is one of the greatest pieces of music ever recorded IMHO. However, I think this arrangement and performance is great. Someone in this orchestra has great taste (e.g. Lennon, Crimson, Lyle Mays, even Piazzola). The unnecessary dig at the singer by an individual on here is out of order - singing in another language is extremely hard. She does a great 'Roxanne' too - see here: th-cam.com/video/WAwYEHtvzNM/w-d-xo.html
I would love to know what do you think of my version if you have time th-cam.com/video/IZl-CWQO71E/w-d-xo.html
Well said that man 👏
Well said
Honorable et audacieuse reprise d'un titre déjà inscrit dans l'anthologie du rock progressif.
L'apport du hautbois apporte un avantage remarquable à l'interprétation.
Cependant, la basse et la guitare ne parviennent pas à faire oublier Nick Beggs ni Guthrie Govan, et il est permis de se demander pourquoi ces séquences ne furent pas assumées aux cordes mais bon ... Le tout me semble agréable.
Tęsknię za zespołem Riders...
To samo pomyślałem gdy zobaczyłem Olę na wokalu.
to beat the performance of Ninet tayeb is a hard thing to do but she gave the song a very uniqe touch with her rough voice ,i love it. also the orchestra made the song a little more intense in my opinion but i will stay with the duett of steven an ninet. the performance of them together made me cut onions and thats not the only song from steven that made me feel that way. he is one oft the best musicians alive and im glad we didnt lose him to early like some other great people.
Ola "Dziewczyna z Żonkilem" Łysiak z pierwszego Idola
Voice notes are not that great as ninet tayeb but instruments and vive are good! And thank you for delivering this unique version to us..
Not Ninet Tayeb… doesn’t sound the same 😢
yeah..ummmm...NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HORRBLE cover of Ninet's vocals...sorry, but just trying to save anyone else who loves the song from suffering what i just did.
La dimostrazione lampante che esiste solo la grande musica e la musica mediocre!
It's Steven with an N. Too bad can't really understand the singer's English...
@Primuz Chamber Orchestra Also Culture Cash is written by Guthrie Govan, but originally performed by The Aristocrats.