I have been a BB fan since I was a child, and have followed Brian Wilson's recordings very, very closely. This was BY FAR the best rendition of H&V I've ever heard.
Hi. Mark I have your new channel I like 🌴 boys so I will this long version in my playlist so keep the old songs coming I grew up in the 60's your no.1fan I am am 64
The original song as it was released is perfect, my favorite Beach Boys recording. This one is interesting certainly but just too disjointed. Nice it exists though.
The Beach Boys disagree with your assessment of the original release. There were much longer versions everyone in the band and Van Dyke Parks considered far better. No idea how close this is to those though
@@andrewkathe3471 If you mean that was the group consensus, fine, but if this opinion is strictly Brian's, an image of him planted in his sandbox is not as annoying as him denying us true stereo recordings early on because of his own infirmity. Not a big Wilson fan.
I consider this the definitive version of this song! One of my absolute favorites. Thanks so much for making this.
I have been a BB fan since I was a child, and have followed Brian Wilson's recordings very, very closely.
This was BY FAR the best rendition of H&V I've ever heard.
this is the best version of heroes and villains with rare parts, gee, a tannerin, strange souds, do you like worms, a part of surf's up!
Psychedelic barber shop music. Beautiful.
Fantastic version! Flows together so well, loved the choice for the opening!
HI i watched your video it was GREAT
This is one of the greatest tracks I've ever heard
1:41 them claps/stomps went hard
Everything up until the 3:38 mark is perfect, almost exactly as how I would sequence the track myself
i have to agree! my sentiments exactly
This was one of top two favorite Beach Boys songs of Al Jardine.
Hi. Mark I have your new channel I like 🌴 boys so I will this long version in my playlist so keep the old songs coming I grew up in the 60's your no.1fan I am am 64
Thank you.
At 3:13.....who says "you're under arrest"? It sounds exactly like Joe Bruce aka Violent J from Insane Clown Posse...
7.07 Anyone notice little out take from surfs up? Canvas the town.....
Change that period . after the first 7 to a colon : and you'll have a working link to the section you refer to.
Like this: 7:07
4:09
May I use this song something?
Unafraid of what a Dude’ll Do
What’s the very ending part from? It’s different than the other orchestral ending and I’ve never heard it before
brian played it live before th-cam.com/video/dVu7pyjG9AU/w-d-xo.html
but im guessing its from another take
it's from the 2004 version of Smile
The original song as it was released is perfect, my favorite Beach Boys recording.
This one is interesting certainly but just too disjointed. Nice it exists though.
The Beach Boys disagree with your assessment of the original release. There were much longer versions everyone in the band and Van Dyke Parks considered far better. No idea how close this is to those though
@@andrewkathe3471 If you mean that was the group consensus, fine, but if this opinion is strictly Brian's, an image of him planted in his sandbox is not as annoying as him denying us true stereo recordings early on because of his own infirmity. Not a big Wilson fan.