মুসলমানদের মধ্যে রেনেসাঁ হয়নি কেন? | অধ্যাপক ড. মোহাম্মদ আজম
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- মুসলমানদের মধ্যে রেনেসাঁ হয়নি ইংরেজি না শেখার কারণে?
মোহাম্মদ আজম
অধ্যাপক, বাংলা বিভাগ, ঢাকা বিশ্ববিদ্যালয়
“বাংলাদেশের নবজাগরণ ও মুসলিম সাহিত্য সমাজ” শীর্ষক প্রবন্ধ: • সেই জাতি সৌভাগ্যবান, য...
আয়োজনে: রিডিং ক্লাব ট্রাস্ট
চিত্রগ্রহণ: মোহাইমিন আহমেদ আশিক | ভিডিও সম্পাদনা: ওসমান সরকার
ˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍFind Me Onˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍ
✅Telegram► t.me/msi_khan
✅Facebook ► / msikhan11
✅Instagram► / msi.khan
✅Tiktok ► / msi.khan
✅Twitter ► / msikhan11
✅TH-cam► / msikhan
✅Soundcloud► / msikhan
✅E-mail ► saiful-10th-2015313960@his.du.ac.bd
ˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍˍ
যে ঘুমিয়ে আছে তাকে জাগাতে পারবেন , যে মরে গেছে তাকে কিভাবে জাগাবেন ।
Cultural fight e srestho tike thakbe, Hindustan kobitay robindronath Hindustani superior culture ke okaron galagali koresen , fole Bangali ar Indian prodhan montri hoite parena...but Iqbal Indian o arob superior personality er sathe British technological superiority somonnoy ghotiyesen fole Punjabi aaz England er pm hoyese risi sunak o sadik Khan aaz England er London er meyor 7 bosor dhore...bangali , punjabi er 50 bosor age theke london jawa suru korese but bangali london gele nomo nomo suru kore , london ke bujhte chay na, taile tumi kivabe london er meyor hobe? Tumi cultural baggage nia aschho take bichar koro, nomo nomo korio na abar bidroho korio na, robindronath nomo nomo sikhiyese aar nojrul bidroho sikhayese...nomo nomo koriyo na ba bidroho korio na, england ke bichar koro, tumi kisu dike england er cheye srestho abar england kusu dike
Tomar cheye srestho, tumi matha thanda kore shakespeare er sathe kant ,goethe , hegel er tulona koro jeta uttar bharat kore fole tara england er pm hoy , london er meyor hoy...boro boro bisoy gula te hat dao, khali sisir bindu o technical details nia poira thaiko na...england er personality te hat deo, tara tai chai, british ra aaz india bangladesh er manush er kase addhattik sahajjo chay ...
@@EnlightenedpersonaVai risi sunak ekhon England er pm na
@@EnlightenedpersonaAR turkey Ra Arab language change kore Greek language Niye ase nai British Ra mostofa Kamal ke boisaiya languages change korse and Muslim der against e kaj korse kintu ekhon ardogan Arabi language Niye asche and nastik gula je Muslim der against chilo ajk turkey te tara development kortase
that’s really great , awesome & congratulations 🎉🎉🎉❤❤.
Assalamualaikum dear prof dr. muhammad azam.
আলোচনাটি অসাধারণ হয়েছে।
renesa ek Abar Goethe er renesa arek...goether renesa alor renesa aar Hitler er renesa Kolla fela renesa...Goethe theke Kolla fela sial Churchill o Hitler ek dine toiri hoy ni , majhe khane tiger lord Curzon er barthota hisabe ante Hobe...Hitler o Churchill apnar itihas bodh nostho Kore diyese...ekhon rakabat , khudfaramoshi ,protidondita , attovola ek sovota dekhte passi, je renesar utso gazzali o ibne rusd ta Europe ke alo diyase but je renesar utso crusade ta Hitler o Churchill namok sial present Korese , lord Curzon ke crusade namok onnay somor toiri Korte pare na....Lloyed George ta ka ? Ekta sial
30 bosor dhore England er rajniti te silen , tini lord Curzon namok dilwalar Ulta, lloyed George sial Wala jokhon jekhane dorkar moto mithya bolte parten, Europe ke duita bisso juddher dike niasen , England ke sob gula colony sere dite hoyese kintu majhe khane koti koti pran duita bissojuddhe chole jete hoyese...you can not govern your moral superior ...etai to Goethe er Kotha ,German Der Kotha, Japan will rule the world ,eta to Kant 200 bosor agei dekhte peyesilon ...Indiar Hindu Muslim morally superior to British eita to German Ra onek agei jenese but llyoed george o Churchill er sial er buddhi seta sikar koreni...Ekhon asi culture bolte bangali o robindronath ki bujhe? Robindro sial culture bolte churchill o hitler ke bujhesen ,goethe o goethe er sottobadita ke bujhen nai...fole
Mithya badi churchill o hitler er kotoe bangali durniti baz, prithibir srestho durniti baz hoyese, goethe er moto sotyabadi o creative kintu bangali hoy ni...goethe sotyabadita ke bangali bokami mone kore...kaizer o lord curzon namok dui dilwala 1 st world war er por sesh hoyezan...ase naked mithtyabaditar jug , ase churchill o hitler namik dui mitthybadi sial jug...mithya bad o desh dokhol o aircraft banono e jodi renesa hoy tobe japan proman korese seta japan o england er cheye valo pare, so fire eso german alor doeson er kase, sere dao asiar dilwala nation gula ke, michiavili o plato , tomader soytani o soirotontro nijer kasei rakho , brave heart asia o japan will dominat the world, sadik khan o kamala will govern britsh city london and us politics...
বাংলা একাডেমি একজন যোগ্য মানুষকে খুজে পেয়েছে।শুভকামনা রইলো।
Another bull in a China shop!
"Bohu sroto bichitrovabe kaj korese" kothata khub important
চমৎকার আলোচনা ❤❤
মুসলমানদের রেঁনেসা হলে তারা অনেক refined হতেন। এত উগ্ৰ ধর্মান্ধ হতেন না, উন্নত হতেন জীবনের প্রতিটি ক্ষেত্রে।
মানে ধর্ম ছেড়ে স্যেকুলার হতে বলতেছেন, যেভাবে খ্রিস্টান হয়েছে? আমার মনে হয় স্যেকুলাংগার নাস্তিক ইসলামোফোব আর এস এস এর দালাল রা যদি রিফাইন্ড হতো, কিন্তু না তাহলে তো উপর থেকে টাকা আসবে না। কি বলেন?
Purab poschim movie dekhen monoj Kumar er, sei movie te jibon eastern o western alad fole renesa o alada hote baddho
@@Enlightenedpersona With all due respect, muslims in the subcontinent (or for that matter in the whole world) do not have any such legacy of renessaince.
রেনেসাঁস হয়েছে ইসলামি সভ্যতার অবদানে, Islamic Golden Age এর জ্ঞান বিজ্ঞান ধার করে পাশ্চাত্য রেনেসাঁস ঘটিয়েছে
যা, এবার গিয়ে গরুর মাংস খাওয়া বা রাখার মিথ্যা অভিযোগ তুলে আরও কয়েকটা মুসলমান জবাই করে তোদের *refinement* - এর পরিচয় দিয়ে আত্নতৃপ্তির ঢেকুর তুল গে যা!!!
আসলে এই বক্তব্যের কমেন্ট গুলো পড়তে এসে হতাশ হলাম,প্রায় প্রত্যেকেই বাংলাটা ইংরাজিতে লিখেছেন!
সেটাই। খুব বিরক্তিকর।
প্রায় প্রত্যেকেই না,এই বাংলিশ লেখা কমেন্টধারী একাই অসংখ্য কমেন্ট করেছেন। খেয়াল করে দেখুন, মজার ব্যাপার।
@@kikhabo9344হ্যাঁ ভাই, ইংরেজি অক্ষরে বাংলায় ইকবাল আর উত্তর ভারতের প্রশংসায় কমেন্ট সেকশন ভাসিয়ে ফেলেছে
বাঙালি মুসলমানের আর কিছু থাক বা না থাক আছে identity crisis. বাঙালি না মুসলমান, তাই ঠিক করতে পারল না এখনও ।
Bangali Muslim er desh ase. Ase onek surjer asha by sordar joinuddin...but sobar ridoye robindronath likhleo Kolkata ekhon galib Iqbal er nam Kore sesh Korte hoy Uttar Bharat er etoi provab aar galib Iqbal Bangladesh ke bivokto Kore na
But Kolkata na pare galib Iqbal ke accept Korte na pare kolkatar Hindi vasi Der reject Korte !!!
@@Enlightenedpersona What a digression!!!!!!!!!! It is hard to understand why Ghalib and Iqbal have been brought in the context of identity crisis of Bengali muslims. 😂😂😂
Perhaps you are not aware of the fact that Mirza Ghalib spent some years in Calcutta. He is very much accepted among Bengalis and assimilated much better than Bangladeshis. Iqbal may not be acceptable due to obvious reasons.
It is hard to understand from your ill-phrased comment in ROMAN-BENGALI what do you mean by rejecting a group of people of a different language in a secular cosmopolitan society. Such vile efforts are not entertained anywhere in india.
Despite of having a nation still Bangladeshi Muslims are confused whether they are Bengalis or Muslims or Arabs or Indians or should they behave like their ancestors (Hindus) or behave like Arabs or how to behave like Bengalis or how to behave like muslim bengalis or how not to behave like Bengalis (Hindus). Sounds like an unsolved puzzle.This is the crisis I am talking about.
আমাদের ক্রাইসিস নাই, ক্রাইসিস ভারতের কিছু দালানুদাসদের
@@Rousseau123no bangladeshi muslim is confused. Either you have never been to Bangladesh or lived in a bubble. Islam is an ideology not ethnicity. Only Islamophobe gandus who confuses every problem with religion sounds like you. You guys are short sighted and can’t understand other social and material aspects of any problem.
@@Rousseau123Arak Boka choda bole Ki aghe bol tui ki Janis Bangla Muslim empire chilo Bangla Muslim empire ja development korse seta Asia keo korte pare nai ektu pora suna kor ar Bangla Muslim Ra India thekei asche Boka choda
Students of literature are usually poor but work with high thought. There is high level of risk to accept/reject their analysis.
Student of philosophy and science ki korse??? Bergson, Kant o Bertrand Russell science er student silen...Goethe silen law er student...
Hebraism ke Mathew Arnold bolsen fire and strength jekhane culture ke bolsen light and sweet ness...taile hebraism thekei culture utponno hoise karon fire and strength thekei light and sweetness ase but tini Greece theke culture aschhe bolsen jeita Mathew Arnold er birat osongoti but onek Bangali Mathew Arnold er culture and anarchy poresen kintu bisoy ta keu dhorte paren nai...hoy to eita porei bonkim hindutto badi DER fire diyesen uddipona diyesen but vul agun ghor poray bote karon
Hindu agun vul agun karon Tara bornobadi....
Anondo niya apnar boktrita mojar...
Personality er noukay technology er mal ante hoy...personality er ase urdho mukhi plobota aar technology er ase nimnomukhi plobota ....urdhomukhi plobota er cheye nimnomukhi plobota besi hole nouka dobe...greek sovvota evabei dubese...
Fole Uttar Bharat dokkhin Bharat devanand er guide er moto movie Korte perese jar English version USA te koti koti
Taka kamiyese but Dhaka Kolkata Azo guide movie banate pareni...Dhaka Kolkata guide movie bojheo na....
যারা মন্তব্য করেছেন তারা রোমান হরপে লিখেছেন । 😅 বাংলা লিখতে অসুবিধে কোথায় ?
Muslim DER moddho sobcheye developed turkey, khilafat sere arbi horof sere roman dhorese...so roman sobar bujhte subidha...
ঠিক তাই
@@Enlightenedpersonaabal er baccha Roman er cheye Arabi language sohoj
ভালো লাগে
Ekhon dekhi 6 jon sikha gosthir liberal humanist ke ke??? Abul husen,kazi abdul wadud, motahar hossen choudhury,kazi motahar hossen, abul fozol baki ke ke???
Shonibarer chitihi sompadok nirod c choudhury 102 bosor bechesen seta sobai jane...but sougat sompadok nasiruddin je 105 bosor bechesen seta ki amra jani ???
Student of philosophy and science ki korse??? Bergson, Kant o Bertrand Russell science er student silen...Goethe silen law er student...
Asole Mathew Arnold sommondhe Alochona Korte German dorson Jana lagbe jeta bangalir Jana nai...na Kolkata na dhakay Bergson ba Mathew Arnold ba renan ba Ezra pound Nia Kono Alochona
Hoy ...
hindu renesa bolte bojhay jat protha , sotidah-sohomoron, esober bilupti. egulo to muslim somaje chiloi na. to renesa hobe ki
For them renesa means, become secular/atheist 😂
@@Rattttattaএইযে 'তারা খারাপ এবং তাদের সবকিছু খারাপ' মানসিকতা পাল্টায় নাই, এটাই মুসলিম সমাজের পিছিয়ে থাকাকে ইঙ্গিত করে
Muslim somaje ja ache segulo ki bodol hobe? Apni mone hoy janen na sesob bepar.....
Mesmerizing lecture
Gota question tai bagher ridoy o sial er buddhir....lord karzon er silo bagher ridoy aar lyoed george er silo sial er buddhi ...bagher ridoy er dristite purbo Bangla kolkatar Cheye developed Abar siayler buddhir dristite Kolkata developed...gota bapar tai dristi vongir...loyed George er sathe lord curzon er tulona korer silen Churchill tar great contemporaries gronthe...Hitler obossoi lord curzon er moto tiger ke follow koren nai Koresen loyed George er moto sial ke follow, Hitler mithyar por mithya bole ektar por Ekta desh dokhol koresilen
Jemon kul hu allahu ahad khub chhoto sura but gota kuran sorif er 1/3 Holo kul hu allahu ahad...mane Kotha kom kaj besi eitai islam er mul motro
Purab poschim movie dekhen monoj Kumar er, sei movie te jibon eastern o western alada fole renesa o alada hote baddho
Culture er definition ta German Goethe o Kant theke neya uchit
Motei gozamil Wala British Mathew Arnold theke noy...
1947 sal ke bujhte lal salu o syed waliullah ke bujhte hobe karon oi somoy ( 1947-48) boita( lal salu) likha hoyesilo...
1947 sale bujte toke historical evidence Porte hobe tor lal salu Diye Tui ki bujbi Boka choda
Culture englande noy germany te develop koresilo, tara bolto kooltar, romanticism er moto kooltar o bikrito british verson ba hasahasir joggo british verson e amra peyesi...
Amra victorio jug ke gurotto dei karon colonial manusikota , abar victorio jugei Germany gyan biggan poetry o philosophy te uthe aschhilo,but seta keu bolena...
Mojar bisoy shikha gosthir sathe porobotite syed waliullahr somporko ki silo???
Amra Jodi kazi imdadul hoq er Abdullah uponnyas( 1920 sale likha, Moslem Bharat potrikay prokasito) pori ,sekhane e Iqbal pur er Mohabbat Khan ke tini khub ovijat bolesen, mane kobi Iqbal ke kazi imdadul hok khub ovijat bolesen bolai bahullo
Gota duniya tokhon Kotha theke kothay chole gese, German Ra 50 years er sikkhay sikkhato Hoye British french DER nakani chubani khawalo....aar Russia o Italy er senabahini ke pray dhongso Kore diyesilo ei German ra...ei Jonno Tara Kono desh British french DER moto chuse khay ni, borong gyaner rajjer surongo koresilo Islam er atlas er soktiman kabbo o philosophy er duniyay...Mirza galib British french
German philosophy gule Khan ni but dilwala lok silen, Punjabi Renesa fruit ful hoyese , panjabi DER robindronath obogga korten but Tara DUI/ tin ta science Nobel peyesen theoretical physics o genetics e, 3/4 bar sikhra Indian prime minister hoyese, aar Bangla dhaopor sang ektao science Nobel pay ni, ekbaro indiar prime minister hon ni...karon ki? Panjabi renesa brammon vittik silo na , silo Muslim o sikh vittik, aar Bangali renesar dharok bahok Ra sob brammon fole bonkim o robindronath German Persian mainstream philosophy banglay anen ni....robindronath onek gan likhesen but porisrom er gan ektao likhen ni..ek Punjabi Hindu aaz uk er prime minister Hoye Bose ase karon Punjabi Ra German Persian superior philosophy Jane, British french philosophy er puja korena, ektu oboggai Kore...
Ayub khan 13 bosor tiklo ki kore? Pa chata robindro vokto lutu putu bangalir jonno, jei bangali kheplo, ayub khan biday karon pakistan to ayub biday er jonno mukhiyei silo...
Amra vule Jai Germany ek somoy eto scientific boi roptani korto ja England , USA, Canada o France ekotre korto na...
শুনছি, শুনব
Nojrul er por sobcheye talented silen Syed waliullah...shudhu Lal salu porle Hobe na bohi peer o porte Hobe. Sob peer kharap hoy na, Valo peer o ase...tader Kotha bohi peer e uthe aschhe...
1926 sal theke bangali suru kore karon 2nd world war o hilter ke se bojhe but 1st world war o kaizer ke bojhe na...
Ezra pound robindronath Tagore ke keno jodindronath mawhor bollen???
Iqbal indiar olikhito jatio kobi na hole india kobe chinar moto commuinst hoiya jaito...iqbal er jonnoi uttar bharat dokkhin bharat theke robindro bonkim biday niyase
Nirod c choudhury er oi dialogue ta mone porse , tini bolesilen subcontinent er muslim meyerai noy, muslim purush rao porday ase, setai bolsen uttar bharat: bisser buke ekhono royese tomar porichoy songopon, tomar bihone hobe na khodar purno attar unmochon???
Mathew Arnold Shakespeare o hazrat Muhammad ( sm) ke niya ekoi sathe ekoi manob jatir itihase likhte paren nai...but Carlyle eita chesta Kore bartho hoyesen but Goethe ekoi sathe
Hajrat Muhammad nobi o surjer vokto Abar Shakespeare namok batir o vokto, surjor vokto hole batir vokto o Howa jay...setai Goethe dekhiyesen o
British batir voktoder ohongkar
Chaknachur Kore diye tini British dorson ke robotic dorson o french dorson ke bandor er dorson bolesen...
Hazrat Muhammad nobi o Shakespeare kobir moddhe somonnoy o satontro bidhane British Ra paren nai...Milton paren nai, Goethe seta onayase peresen...bangalir Kotha ki bolbo ???ohongkari German jatir Kase motaher Hossein choudhury culture khujen nai, khujesen attorokkha Kari ,oi somoyer chunkali wala, mukhlukano British jatir moddhe...how funny???
Bangali jodi risi sunak hote chay tahole tar loyed george o lord curzon dui jonkei bujhte hobe but robindro sial er buddhi bole british rajniti baba amar noy but purbo banglar tiger ra bole england , seto amari !!!
Sonchoron gronther lekhok kazi motahar hossen somporke bortoman boktar pray 8 bosor ager mot er sathe bortoman moter pray mil nei...
Soukhin ra sobsomoy pesadar der chhariye jay...bengol e pesadar der bokbokani te ground breaking kisu pawa jay na...
Jara bolen debate Valo na tader Jonno Einstein Niels Bohr debate: 1921 e robindro mahatma birodh er
Por robindronath Backfoot e chole Jan, desher netritte asen mahatma Gandhi...but Iqbal Backfoot e jan ni tini karon tinie mahatmar jonmodata...Iqbal asrare khudi o romuj e bekhudi publish er por India er batabaran change hoy, mahatma Gandhir gola silo na but ekjon boisso
Boi porto ,tini mahatma Gandhi, Iqbal er toiri bataboron je lal bal pal tin brammon India er leader silo tader soriye dilen...fole Iqbal pore tin joner sathe debate e gesen...Iqbal neheru debate, Iqbal Hossain Ahmed madani debate...Iqbal Pakistan proposal debate...bola bahullo robindronath debate Valo basten but keya Kore mahatmar sathei robindronath paren nai tahole Iqbal er sathe ki parben..??.robindronath nije mahatma , bonkim ,nobogopal mitra aro oneker sathe debate koresen...debate Nia aro moja ase.einstein Niels Bohr er moddhe science dia debate Hoye silo..er por theke physics er leadership Einstein er hat theke Neil's Bohr er hate chole jay onekei janena...
Hindi , songskrito arbi farsi turki Urdu ei pach vasa theke niyese fole Uttar Bharat eto developed ...takei follow korese south India...jemon Mathew Arnold Nia banglay bortomane kono Alochona nai but Hindi te vuri vuri Alochona ase Mathew Arnold sommondhe...jodio Bangali bonkim sobar age Kono ek juge upomohadeshe Mathew Arnold poresen , Alochona koresen...
Robindronath nojrul bonkim tin
Joni soukhin shahittik silen but
After that pesadar brammon ra keno banglar shahitto ke keno gile khelo???
Amra vule Jai ekai Germany ek somoy eto scientific boi roptani korto ja England , USA, Canada o France eksathe mileo korto na...ekhon bojha jay Dhaka Kolkata keno science Nobel pay ni ebong pay na...??? superior German Persian philosophy ekhono banglay ase ni....
Pakistan idea o bakti mujib: Pakistan ekti idea silo Jake hatya kora somvob na but bakti mujib ke hatya kora somvob. Azker Bangladesh achorone dhormio riti niti o discipline e ekti swadhin east Pakistan karon jarai Bangladesh swadhin koresilo silo Tara rajnoitik o orthonoitik swadhinota cheyesilen, caltural noy, Iqbal er provab nojrul joshim uddin o golam mostopha er upor khub Beshi silo ,forrukh Ahmed er upoto siloe...Ahsan Habib er upor o silo..but taile Iqbal er discipline
Koi gele bd te? Keno mujib o jia hatya o bdr bidroho Holo? Karon kolkatar sap o Bose silo na...je sap British french colonialism er sap ...kolkatar vodroloker rup dhore egiye esechhilo...
Doshta Kajol roshid Shahin er noy , dosta kazi nojrul Islam o kazi Abdul wadud DUI buddhijibira nijerai confused silen...
Kisu daha miththya clear kora dorkar....abul husen nijeo Urdu te ostad lok silen...tini keno Kolkata gelen? Dhaka university teacher keno notun kore law porlen??? Iqbal lawyer silen tai? Iqbal o college teacher hoyeo notun kore law pass koresilen...tini ki Iqbal ke follow koresilen??? Kazi Abdul wadud bolesilen: nojrul er por amra koyekjon??? Tahole abul hissen er mone silo " iqbal er por amra koyek jon???"...
Abul husen silen sikha potrikar asol sompadok ebong Urdu te kothin ustad je potrikay Urdu chhapiye onubad porjonto den ni..tar dharona tar shikha potrikar porne wala sobai Urdu lipi porte pare???
একজনেই প্রায় সবগুলো কমেন্ট করেছে।
Amader vule jawa uchit Hobe na robiyndro culture o Iqbal culture alada...robindro culture British mithyabadi culture o Germany theke churi British culture aar Iqbal culture original German philosophy o German culture...fole kolkatar buddhikom atel gula kobi amaiya chakravartir upor Iqbal er provab silo, tini je Iqbal er basay koyekbar gesilen seta lukay...kobi amiya chakrawarti er Wikipedia account e jan , Iqbal sobdota porjonto nai...!!!
Pakistan er elahabadi philosophical 1930 prostab ta korai hoyese cultural varience ke tikiye rakhar Jonno, neherur communism ,dhormo o songskriti biddesi Marxist totalitarian India er biruddhe culture Mona Pakistan silo Ekta protibad...amader vule jawa uchit Hobe na swadhinotar vitti 6 dofar 6 dofai silo , orthonoitik ...Ekta dofa o sangskritik noy...
German soukhin ra british french pesadar der dubiye chubiye notun uddipto philosophy enesilo...fole uddipto romantic philosophy germany thekei giye wordsworth shelly bayron der uddipto koresilo...
Islam Korner dhormo, aar Europe o banglay renesa bolte bakwas ke bojhe, baljak 34 projonmo porjonto chorito uponnyas e enesen...but German dorson o Islam er mil ase, french renesa o songskrito mohavarot bakwas e vorti...German dorson o Kormer dristi te dekhle Bangali musolman khubi renesar upojukto
Poddhoti jinis ta bangalir adi kal thekei nai, bonkim communist idea theke sammo boita likhlen but tini sekhan theke bornobadi hindu kivabe holen tar kono bakkha ba poddhoti ti ki silo seta kothao likhen nai, al mahmud o tai, sordar fazlul korim o tai...
যে যখন যার মত করে বলে তখন মনে হয় তারটাই ঠিক। কারও আগ্রহ থেকে থাকলে, এই আপলোডটিও দেখুন - Why MUSLIM SCHOLARS Supported BRITISH Rule in India: The Untold Alliance!
Ulta ta , British supported Muslim...
@@EnlightenedpersonaBritish Ulta Hindu Muslim danggah lagaise jeta ajkeo paoya jay
ETA vul Kichu Muslim British Der support korse kintu onk Muslim British er against chilo Karon Muslim Rai first British Der against war korse
Amar mone hocche uni Salimullah Khaner choto bhai.
পড়াশোনা করে এদের বক্তব্য শোনা লাগে নইলে দুজনের কাউকেই বোঝা সহজ হবেনা
Nojrul er e Bangladesh o begum rokeyar Bangladesh e uddipona koi??? But nojrul o begum rokeya dujonei silen super uddipto....!!!!! kajei bangladesher sangskritik history Kolkata mukhi hoyese...fusion hoy ni jeta hote
Hobe...jatir pita Pakistan andolon koresen Abar Bangladesh jonmo diyesen...ei ghotonar somonnoy ghotate nojrul o begam rokeya ke bojha lagbe, tar Muslim sotta ke( 1947) bojha lagbe Abar tar
Bangali sotta( 1971) ke bojha lagbe...taholei Bangali Muslim Tamil DER moto uddipto Hobe science e Nobel pabe, 200 koti
Budget er movie korbe...tokhon uddipto nojrul o begum rokeya ke bujhte parbo...
Onek atel bojhate chesta Kore purbo Bangla uncultured silo, Hindu bouddho provab er baire
Silo , tai musol man hoyese...taile prosno jage Punjab keno musolman hoyese??? Punjab to very much Hindu bouddho provab e silo...purbo Banglao Hindu boddho provabe silo Kolkata theke Tripura gotai Hindu silo, lokkhon sen er nodiya akranto hole tini tar samrajjer purbo banglay asen...Afghanistan theke combodia boddho silo...boddho silo paharpur mohasthan gor o moynamoti te...asole Punjab o bangala Beshi urbor...sufira Beshi dhormio prochar koresen Beshi musolman hoyese...tai Punjab o banglay Muslim besi...
Ghotona ta ghotese shohidullah, abdul korim shahitto bisarod, nojrul ei tinjon onayasei shikhagosthi jog koredilei holo, sal ta arektu pisiye dilei hoto...but nojrul o begum rokeya ke bangali musolman o poschim banglar hindu rao bujhe na...poschim banglar hindura din kana...karon hindustanti hindura 60 percent kolkata vore felese hindustani hindura...hindustani hindu muslim ra khub valo vabei nojrul ke bojhe karon ei dui jon purapuri hindustani o bangali philosophy er fusion...salman khaner bap bikkhato lekhok selem khan salman khan ke bangladesh aschhilo tokhon take nojrul ke ullekh koresen...nojrul er bangla gan mohammad rofi geyesen but banglay odhik provabsali robindro songit kintu mohammad rofi ganni...
Banglar professor Ahmed shorif keno mithyabollen? Keno paharpur o mohasthan gor ke boddho Bihar bole chalalen o abar moynamoti avoid korlen??? Ei mithyachar o challenge eriye jawa ki bonkim robindronath er moddhe nai???
Thik ei ghotonai ghotese British french mithyabadi philosopher DER khetre..
Tara German philosophy er samne tikte paren nai ,mithyar asroy niyesen...
Asole boddhora combodia theke Afghanistan porjonto boddho samrajjo silo, Kolkata theke Tripura porjontu eksomoy Hindu raj silo ...fole Ahmed shorif er dabi je gota Bangla boddho Hindura kokhonoi sason Kore nai Kotha ta daha miththya ...
humayun ahmed hasina theke mukti dekhe jete pan ni...fascism ke humayun ahmed bujhte peresen? Paren ni...humayun ahmed fascist hasina ke cancer
Bolesen but sei cancer dur korte peresen? Humayun ahmed sorire cancer niye o deshe fascism er cancer dekhe mara gesen...Humayun ahmed ekta janjir, dewar ba sholay likhte peresen??? Motei na...humayun kolkataar gorto otikrom kore mumbai ,lahore ,kornatok jaite paren nai but amader parte hobe, tir hara ei djeu er sagor pari debo re...amra kojon nobin majhi
Bangali Muslim er desh ase seta Bangladesh aar Ase onek surjer asha by sordar joinuddin...but sobar ridoye robindronath likhleo Kolkata ekhon galib Iqbal er nam Kore sesh Korte hoy Uttar Bharat er etoi provab kolkatay aar galib Iqbal Bangladesh ke bivokto Kore na bd te galib Iqbal mishe jay
But Kolkata na pare galib Iqbal ke accept Korte na pare kolkatar Hindi vasi Der reject Korte !!!
হয় শুদ্ধ ইংলিশ লিখুন নয় শুদ্ধ বাংলায় লিখুন. ইংলিশ ফন্টে বাংলা লিখলে বুঝতে খুব অসুবিধা হয়
Romanticism er jonmo data Kant Hegel Goethe bangalee porbena....mul porbe na...but Wordsworth , Shelly bayron pata porbe , bangali chhagol Ra pata khaibe, how funny !!!!!
bangle fact কি???
Bengal pact
Gota duniya tokhon Kotha theke kothay chole gese, German Ra 50 years er sikkhay sikkhato Hoye British french DER nakani chubani khawalo....aar Russia o Italy er senabahini ke pray dhongso Kore diyesilo ei German ra...ei Jonno Tara Kono desh British french DER moto chuse khay ni, borong gyaner rajjer surongo koresilo Islam er atlas er soktiman kabbo o philosophy er duniyay...Mirza galib British french
German philosophy gule Khan ni but dilwala lok silen, Punjabi Renesa fruit ful hoyese , panjabi DER robindronath obogga korten but Tara DUI/ tin ta science Nobel peyesen theoretical physics o genetics e, 3/4 bar sikhra Indian prime minister hoyese, aar Bangla dhaopor sang ektao science Nobel pay ni, ekbaro indiar prime minister hon ni...karon ki? Panjabi renesa brammon vittik silo na , silo Muslim o sikh vittik, aar Bangali renesar dharok bahok Ra sob brammon fole bonkim o robindronath German Persian mainstream philosophy banglay anen ni....robindronath onek gan likhesen but porisrom er gan ektao likhen ni..ek Punjabi Hindu aaz uk er prime minister Hoye Bose ase karon Punjabi Ra German Persian superior philosophy Jane, British french philosophy er puja korena, ektu oboggai Kore...
Ahmed shorif murkho but dhaka university er philosophy department aro boro murkho karon tara ahmed shorif ,du er banglar teacher, er vul ta dhoriye den ni...
Du hate??? Gota duniya tokhon Kotha theke kothay chole gese, German Ra 50 years er sikkhay sikkhato Hoye British french DER nakani chubani khawalo....aar Russia o Italy er senabahini ke pray dhongso Kore diyesilo ei German ra...ei Jonno Tara Kono desh British french DER moto chuse khay ni, borong gyaner rajjer surongo koresilo Islam er atlas er soktiman kabbo o philosophy er duniyay...Mirza galib British french
German philosophy gule Khan ni but dilwala lok silen, Punjabi Renesa fruit ful hoyese , panjabi DER robindronath obogga korten but Tara DUI/ tin ta science Nobel peyesen theoretical physics o genetics e, 3/4 bar sikhra Indian prime minister hoyese, aar Bangla dhaopor sang ektao science Nobel pay ni, ekbaro indiar prime minister hon ni...karon ki? Panjabi renesa brammon vittik silo na , silo Muslim o sikh vittik, aar Bangali renesar dharok bahok Ra sob brammon fole bonkim o robindronath German Persian mainstream philosophy banglay anen ni....robindronath onek gan likhesen but porisrom er gan ektao likhen ni..ek Punjabi Hindu aaz uk er prime minister Hoye Bose ase karon Punjabi Ra German Persian superior philosophy Jane, British french philosophy er puja korena, ektu oboggai Kore...
Romanticism er jonmo data Kant Hegel Goethe bangalee porbena....mul porbe na...but Wordsworth , Shelly bayron pata porbe , bangali chhagol Ra pata khaibe, how funny !!!!! Kolkatar ram
Chhagol gula ke dhakar pati chhagol
Gula Abar follow Kore, how funny...
Ahmed shorif bolar chesta koresen Hindu boddho ( Arya) Ra gota
Bangla kokhono dokhol Kore nai.... Bangali sudorson Arya ba arob turki DER bongsodhor noy, borong drabir, Tamil, kol, mundari der bongsodhor. ...aamader nayok iliyas kanchon , shalman shah, rajjak ba sakib Khan er samne Kono Kono Kono Tamil nayok darate parbe soundorjor dik diye ??? mohesh Babu theke Rajnikant keu darate parbe na soundorjor dik diya...but tarporo atel kolkatar dadababu
DER dristite Bangali musolman
Anarjo o Tamil kol mundari...how funny !!!!!!!!!!
Aryan and buddha empire somay Puro Bangla dokhol korse ektu history porun
Demagogue .
Already started in Bangladesh. We demolished Ganabhabon , looted under wear and petticoat. We know lungi dance.
Tumi hoila fascist der dhamadhora, tomar moter upore mut dileo seta panir opochoy 😂
Aroj ali murkho seta sobai jane, but ahmed shorif o je murkho seta sobai jane na...karon universal philosophy
German philosophy...british french philosphy sthanio local stupid philosophy...british german philosophy er lorai tai banglar teacher ahmed sorif bujhten na...
যে কারণে জাঙ্গিয়ার book pocket হয় না , সেই কারণে ।
বোকাচোদা তুই
রেনেসাঁস হয়েছে ইসলামি সভ্যতার অবদানে, Islamic Golden Age এর জ্ঞান বিজ্ঞান ধার করে পাশ্চাত্য রেনেসাঁস ঘটিয়েছে
শয়তান যখন লাড়ে,তখন উল্টাপাল্টা তোমার যুক্তি বাড়ে।
ইসলাম টাই রেনেসাঁ। ইসলাম মানলে স্রোতের উল্টো চলা লাগে। ইচ্ছে মতো নিজের রিপুর তাড়নায় চলা যায় না।
আর সতীদাহ নামে মেয়েদের জ্যান্ত পুড়িয়ে মারা গুবর খেকোরা ইসলাম কে যে চোখে দেখে, সেভাবে না দেখে নিজে একটু কোরআন হাদিস পড়ুন।
ইন্ডিয়ান গুবরখেকোদের থেকে সব জানার চেষ্টা করবেন না। ওদের হিংস্রতার রূপ কিন্ত এখন আর গোপন নয়।
এখনো এরা দলিত হত্যা করে, মুসলিম হত্যা করে, নিজের কন্যা সন্তানের ভ্রূণ হত্যা করে। এরা বিধবা নারীদের নিরামিষ খাইয়ে, একঘরে করে তিলে তিলে মারে।
তাই জ্ঞান অর্জন করুন সুস্থ মাধ্যম থেকে। উগ্র, উম্মাদদের থেকে নয়
আবর্জনা
Jemon kul hu allahu ahad khub chhoto sura but gota kuran sorif er 1/3 Holo kul hu allahu ahad...mane Kotha kom kaj besi eitai islam er mul motro
Bangali jodi risi sunak hote chay tahole tar loyed george o lord curzon dui jonkei bujhte hobe but robindro sial er buddhi bole british rajniti baba amar noy but purbo banglar tiger ra bole england , seto amari !!!
Jara bolen debate Valo na tader Jonno Einstein Niels Bohr debate: 1921 e robindro mahatma birodh er
Por robindronath Backfoot e chole Jan, desher netritte asen mahatma Gandhi...but Iqbal Backfoot e jan ni tini karon tinie mahatmar jonmodata...Iqbal asrare khudi o romuj e bekhudi publish er por India er batabaran change hoy, mahatma Gandhir gola silo na but ekjon boisso
Boi porto ,tini mahatma Gandhi, Iqbal er toiri bataboron je lal bal pal tin brammon India er leader silo tader soriye dilen...fole Iqbal pore tin joner sathe debate e gesen...Iqbal neheru debate, Iqbal Hossain Ahmed madani debate...Iqbal Pakistan proposal debate...bola bahullo robindronath debate Valo basten but keya Kore mahatmar sathei robindronath paren nai tahole Iqbal er sathe ki parben..??.robindronath nije mahatma , bonkim ,nobogopal mitra aro oneker sathe debate koresen...debate Nia aro moja ase.einstein Niels Bohr er moddhe science dia debate Hoye silo..er por theke physics er leadership Einstein er hat theke Neil's Bohr er hate chole jay onekei janena...
Hebraism ke Mathew Arnold bolsen fire and strength jekhane culture ke bolsen light and sweet ness...taile hebraism thekei culture utponno hoise karon fire and strength thekei light and sweetness ase but tini Greece theke culture aschhe bolsen jeita Mathew Arnold er birat osongoti but onek Bangali Mathew Arnold er culture and anarchy poresen kintu bisoy ta keu dhorte paren nai...hoy to eita porei bonkim hindutto badi DER fire diyesen uddipona diyesen but vul agun ghor poray bote karon
Hindu agun vul agun karon Tara bornobadi....
Islam Korner dhormo, aar Europe o banglay renesa bolte bakwas ke bojhe, baljak 34 projonmo porjonto chorito uponnyas e enesen...but German dorson o Islam er mil ase, french renesa o songskrito mohavarot bakwas e vorti...German dorson o Kormer dristi te dekhle Bangali musolman khubi renesar upojukto
Nojrul er e Bangladesh o begum rokeyar Bangladesh e uddipona koi??? But nojrul o begum rokeya dujonei silen super uddipto....!!!!! kajei bangladesher sangskritik history Kolkata mukhi hoyese...fusion hoy ni jeta hote
Hobe...jatir pita Pakistan andolon koresen Abar Bangladesh jonmo diyesen...ei ghotonar somonnoy ghotate nojrul o begam rokeya ke bojha lagbe, tar Muslim sotta ke( 1947) bojha lagbe Abar tar
Bangali sotta( 1971) ke bojha lagbe...taholei Bangali Muslim Tamil DER moto uddipto Hobe science e Nobel pabe, 200 koti
Budget er movie korbe...tokhon uddipto nojrul o begum rokeya ke bujhte parbo...
Gota duniya tokhon Kotha theke kothay chole gese, German Ra 50 years er sikkhay sikkhato Hoye British french DER nakani chubani khawalo....aar Russia o Italy er senabahini ke pray dhongso Kore diyesilo ei German ra...ei Jonno Tara Kono desh British french DER moto chuse khay ni, borong gyaner rajjer surongo koresilo Islam er atlas er soktiman kabbo o philosophy er duniyay...Mirza galib British french
German philosophy gule Khan ni but dilwala lok silen, Punjabi Renesa fruit ful hoyese , panjabi DER robindronath obogga korten but Tara DUI/ tin ta science Nobel peyesen theoretical physics o genetics e, 3/4 bar sikhra Indian prime minister hoyese, aar Bangla dhaopor sang ektao science Nobel pay ni, ekbaro indiar prime minister hon ni...karon ki? Panjabi renesa brammon vittik silo na , silo Muslim o sikh vittik, aar Bangali renesar dharok bahok Ra sob brammon fole bonkim o robindronath German Persian mainstream philosophy banglay anen ni....robindronath onek gan likhesen but porisrom er gan ektao likhen ni..ek Punjabi Hindu aaz uk er prime minister Hoye Bose ase karon Punjabi Ra German Persian superior philosophy Jane, British french philosophy er puja korena, ektu oboggai Kore...
Jara bolen debate Valo na tader Jonno Einstein Niels Bohr debate: 1921 e robindro mahatma birodh er
Por robindronath Backfoot e chole Jan, desher netritte asen mahatma Gandhi...but Iqbal Backfoot e jan ni tini karon tinie mahatmar jonmodata...Iqbal asrare khudi o romuj e bekhudi publish er por India er batabaran change hoy, mahatma Gandhir gola silo na but ekjon boisso
Boi porto ,tini mahatma Gandhi, Iqbal er toiri bataboron je lal bal pal tin brammon India er leader silo tader soriye dilen...fole Iqbal pore tin joner sathe debate e gesen...Iqbal neheru debate, Iqbal Hossain Ahmed madani debate...Iqbal Pakistan proposal debate...bola bahullo robindronath debate Valo basten but keya Kore mahatmar sathei robindronath paren nai tahole Iqbal er sathe ki parben..??.robindronath nije mahatma , bonkim ,nobogopal mitra aro oneker sathe debate koresen...debate Nia aro moja ase.einstein Niels Bohr er moddhe science dia debate Hoye silo..er por theke physics er leadership Einstein er hat theke Neil's Bohr er hate chole jay onekei janena...