BMW X1 vs Mercedes GLA vs Audi Q3 vs Volvo XC40 best premium compact SUV comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- This is our in-depth comparison review of the BMW X1 vs Mercedes GLA vs Audi Q3 vs Volvo XC40 for the best premium compact SUV. We're taking a look at Exterior, Interior and the driving experience.
►Follow us on Instagram @autogefuehl and @thomas.letsgo
►Subscribe here: th-cam.com/users/autogefu...
00:00 Best premium compact SUV comparison!
00:19 BMW X1
48:41 Mercedes GLA
1:25:31 Audi Q3
2:14:56 Volvo XC40
2:56:27 Which one would I take home?
#Mercedes #Audi #BMW
Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.
WATCH OUT FOR SPAM/FAKE ACCOUNTS. Across TH-cam, you'll find fake accounts taking the identity of original channels, they use the same profile pic, similar names and include a telephone number in the name or their comments, trying to get you to message them on Whatsapp or Telegram. DO NOT MESSAGE THEM, they are trying to get your personal details, bank accounts etc. and in the end, they will ask for money. They promise you giveaways, prices etc. Do not fall for these cheap tricks and PLEASE HELP everyone and MARK THEIR MESSAGES and their whole accounts/channels as Spam. We from Autogefuehl will never ask for your bank details. Check out our original channel marked with the verified badge.
We do have other official channels, so you can identify them and also subscribe if you like e.g. in your native language:
2nd channel:
/ autogefuel
Spanish: Auto Sensación - Prueba de coches a fondo
/ auto sensación
Arabian: حس السيارات
/ @hiss.sayarat
Korea: 오토센스
/ @autosense_kr
Japan: カー フィーリング
/ @car-feeling
Russian: Анатомия Автомобиля
/ %d0%90%d0%bd%d0%b0%d1%...
►FULL REVIEWS 2022 Q4
• Mercedes C-Class vs Au...
►FULL REVIEWS 2022 Q3
• FULL REVIEWS 2022 Q3
How to support Autogefühl?
►Subscribe, activate notifications (bell symbol) and bookmark our direct channel: www.autogefuehl.com
►Support us on Patreon: / autogefuehl
►Exclusive supporter: Ajlan Saeed
What is Thomas wearing?
► Noah shoes www.noah-shop.com/
Autogefühl viewers get a 20 % shoe discount with the following code: Autogefuehl-20
Social Media & Blog
►Facebook: facebook.de/autogefuehl
►Twitter: / autogefuehl
►Instagram: / autogefuehl
►Instagram: / thomas.letsgo
►German Blog: autogefuehl.de
Autogefühl is your no. 1 resource for in-depth car reviews and your no. 1 community to discuss cars. Each year we present you 150 cars from every segment and from a wide range of brands. If you have any suggestion, just write a comment or contact us on our other socials. Even if you have further remarks, just let us know. - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
►Follow us on Instagram @autogefuehl and @thomas.letsgo
►Subscribe here: th-cam.com/users/autogefuehl
00:00 Best premium compact SUV comparison!
00:19 BMW X1
48:41 Mercedes GLA
1:25:31 Audi Q3
2:14:56 Volvo XC40
2:56:27 Which one would I take home?
#Mercedes #Audi #BMW
Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.
🤽♂️
Just bought a new x1, very pleased, I looked at all 3 of the others but the x1 just felt better quality and design, only the poor bottle holders and lack of small storage drawer could of been better otherwise excellent all round
Thats why they the x3 😂
@@Bussdownbandit😊😊😊😊😊k
Thomas, as always, thank you for your in-depth review! Always informative, always entertaining
🙌🙌🙌
We bought the XC40 after driving all of them. It felt to use your words more sophisticated as a package.
I can't really decide between Q3 and volvo... I am leaning towards volvo though, does it feel over all better?
@@sarahyousef5978 yes it does. Can’t help feeling Q3 maybe sharing just a few too many parts from VW. Plus no one does interiors as well as the Swedes
@@chrisg3780Volvo infotainment is trash. Outdated
@@chrisg3780 it depends if you want a fancy interior, germans are better it's more shinny when people get in or if you want the classic luxury interior, simple but efficient then it's volvo
Grateful for this very detailed comparison! I currently have a q3 but want to switch to a bmw x1, so this helped me make up my mind. Super handsome reviewer so that made the long video more enjoyable too :))
cheers !!! Please recommend :)
Much needed comparison in this segment. Very detailed walkthrough, it covers most of the aspects before making own conclusion. Thanks Thomas!
Glad you enjoyed it!
I’ve had the Audi Q3 40TDI Vorsprung since June 19. I’ve had many cars, but frankly, this is the best. Not wishing to tempt providence, but nothing has gone wrong. Everything still works. It is averaging 37 mpg (6.36 l/100 km), which considering is quite good. Adaptive cruise control & lane keeping assist are crucial for a constant motorway driver. The leather seats still look new. The B&O stereo is awesome and the boot swallows my camping gear whole. It has held 65% of it’s value. When the lease period expires this June, will I buy it outright? You betcha, no brainer!
Thank you as always great video
🙌🙌🙌
I just got the new X1 (18i) with the M sport package. I had the previous X1 version. Overall, I can say that it’s a completely different car, in every aspect. Almost like night and day when comparing both generations. Very sporty when you need it, and very confortable!
Thanks for sharing
Don't they have exactly the same chassis, drivetrain and engine? How are they so different? Or maybe you mean you had the E84 version?
@@GeorgeSotirov Well we have had the E84 (18d) and then 2 different models of the F48, first the 20i and now we have the 25e. Everyone has been a major stepup, even from the 20i to 25e as newer model. I dont doubt a single second that the U11 is as big stepup as from the E84 to F48. That step was HUGE.
18i is slow as a dog lmfap
@@roboticvenom1935 i also order this one. For high speed races i will use the bmw s1000rr
I like how his videos are simply showing the car and not his opinion. great work
Thanks 🙏
Wonderful video, Thomas. Am Leaning towards the upcoming GLA mild hybrid over the 3-Cylinder engine BMW X1 available in Singapore.
cheers m8 !
I have had my X1 18d s drive M Sport for over a month now and it’s a very capable car. Great driving position and fantastic handling. The only thing I don’t like is the new operating system is not as easy to use as my old 320i touring also I find the driving modes a bit gimmicky but apart from that it’s a brilliant vehicle.
What is the noise level in the Audi Q3 sport? How does it compare to the BMW X3 and Mercedes's new GLC?
I agree with your assessment. I ordered the iX1. We only had an X1 for test driving but the interior is basically identical and it was similar enough to make the decision. The iX1 is going to be faster than the X1 we drove and who can go past having Hans "Zimmer In Your Bimmer".
I am undecided between X1 and iX1, I will appreciate your further advice. I can spend more on accessories if I go for X1?
I found the BMW X1 to be the best when it comes to customization and mitigating the cost. You can really fine tune a custom package that will fit your budget. When trying to add options with audi and mercedes the price really sky rockets quickly.
The new Mercedes GLA 220d 4 matic is a great car on bad roads & quiet on tarmac , built strong as i drive in it 7000 miles a year. It always works.
1:45:29 that's a German in him right there. From Chill to No chill in a second 😅😅👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
Has the Head-Up Display the same size and functions like the other BMW Models like 3-Series or higher? Is the projection in the disc identical and exactly nice and big?
Thank you Thomas, for sharing the link. Would love if you could also add Tonale to the line up and also give us your recommendations on it. Given there are some reliability issues with Alfa Romeo, would it be safe bet to go with them or stick to either XC40 or Q3.
New xc40 also have android automotive infotainment: th-cam.com/video/xkkCC-KsyYg/w-d-xo.html
Hey thanks again for this amazing content-Keep up the good work-Autogefuhl Team😍😀..........
Our pleasure!
Have the 20i x drive x2 for 3 years now wheel must be 18s very fast and handles amazing recommend a test drive
Great comparison! very detailed! Greetings from Mexico City! In Mexico we have a lot roads in a very bad conditions so I love the way that my Audi Q3 S-Line normal edition (No Sportback) performs in this roads with very bads conditions. The Audi suspension is very comfortable!
Thanks keep tuning in !
Would you say the Q3 has the greatest ground clearance of all 4 vehicles?
Hi Thomas love and greetings from Toronto Canada I must say u do such a great job and u r very hard worker too I m not just saying but I mean it although excellent comparison but it's not my cup of tea it's too small for my taste keep it up bravo
Wow, thank you 🙏
Love it will probably order it but as an Etron 55 owner with virtual mirrors. Please Polestar put glass in the back with a standard rear view mirror !!!
great comparison!
Appreciated 🙌
Thanks a lot for the review. I've ordered x1 M sport xdrive23i as well. One thing is I read so many other reviewers saying X1 got some hesitation when going from stop or traffic. Did you felt any when compared?
Cheers!
Hmm with this tester here it was fine
@@autogefuehl okay, happy to hear that you didn't had that. It's mainly noticeable when in economy mode and won't notice it when in sport mode is what they say. Hopefully BMW could sort that out if there is.
Also one other thing, X1 might infotainment might get iDrive9 Android Based update in this year as per CES 2023. Fingers crossed!
@@rjk08 it won't get the updated, not compatible my friend. (work at bwm dealer)
Hi good evening.. I want to ask you.. Is it for sale?
I could watch these videos all day
Enjoy 😊
Hi Thomas. How would you compare the comfort of X1 suspension with 18-inch and 19-inch wheels? Thank you for your review.
Smaller wheels bring more comfort
@@autogefuehl thank you
Hi Tom! Great comparison thoses SUVs, it will help some people do better decision to buy new car. All cars are produced with details, and buyer will search something for itself from this comparision.
Maybe also good topic for movie is about prices new cars, some forecast, short interview with car sales / cars producer - what they think ( from inside of the market ), are they can produce cheaper car, why price are so highy ( In my opinion ). It will help understand market, why some price of new car will rised 20%-30% or more.
Cheers!
Super great video! 3 hours of review!! This is a record I guess!
Personally, I am Not a fan of BMW’s comfort level. I drove x3 and 228i. The seats are killing my lower back. X3’s is more tolerable but I expect a much better seat from a luxury compact SUV. I hope the latest generation offers some improvement on that. Recently, I picked Volvo and ordered an XC40 ultimate for how comfortable the seats and the ride are, and the safety features/records of the brand offers. It will be my EDC for the next few years. So comfortable ride for long hour driving and top safety are the top priority. Driving dynamic, acceleration and handling are more than adequate for how I use it everyday. When your seat is hurting your butt, the handling, acceleration and driving dynamic becomes meaningless. Coz all you want is to get out as soon as possible.
Thanks so much! Yeah the Volvo seats are amazing
Two days before Xmas I purchased the "BMW X1 SDrive 20i Xline", but the (estimated) delivery-time is ... January ... 2024 !? 🙄 (I am living in Belgium)
Hi. What you said around 28:00 about the steering i know what you mean but dont agree that its not in the bigger ones, i felt exactly same thing with x3 on highway that hey whats up with the steering why is it so weird - found it difficult to stay centered in lane on long drive and wondered how can bmw with so much R&D and testing end up with final results like that esp when making cars for so many years i just dont understand it - thanks for your amazing reviews
Thanks for the feedback!
I’ve felt this on a 3 series too
If you think it can't get any better... what a video!
🙏🙏 please share 😎
J’ai été surpris par le prix local Réunion… merci pour votre essai
super comprehensive, danke!
welcome!
If Thomas came to explain everything about my car personally to me with his soothing voice, I would buy any car he suggested
I have just ordered the new bmw x1 sDrive 20i with M package and I'm waiting for my SUV !! I'm so excited!!😁
enjoy =)
I think there is one another HUGE benefit to x1- trunk size. It is 540L which is nearly same as 550L on x3 and largest among all of those cars
Also hybrid x1 u11 trunk is 490L, which is a lot compared to other hybrids! (X3 hybrid g01 = 450L, x5 45e g05 = 500L!)
While acceleration of x1 30e y11 is as fast as fastest g05 45e g05! 5.6sec 0-100 😅 while all with air resistance of bmw 4 series = 0.26 I (think MB gla glc is about 0.32-0.35 = alot less efficient)
Bro finna make me spend my money😢😖😭🤣🤣👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 great video
Thanks 🙏 please recommend 😎
looks like all 4 of them needs final touches for exterior designes. For interiors, I am an audi fan but I really hate that gear selector. It is killing the premium look.
Hi, would you please try and review the Cupra Formentor? Thanks
here we go: th-cam.com/video/obfAQId-qDY/w-d-xo.html
I just ordered a 24 20i with the msport and msport pro packages. I cant wait for the pro seats which just became available, in the alcantara finish. Im just really torn between the mineral white and the frozen grey. anyone have the frozen grey? is it as sensitive as they say? I love the mineral so no real loss either way. Thanks.
Should I be concerned that Volvo XC40 1.5 cc turbo is only 129 (hp)?
Between the iX1 vs XC40 Recharge P8(2024 RWD biased) which is better?
Both nice for sure! Testing the updated XC40 in a couple of weeks
I'm looking very closely at the iX1 when the lease (because I wanted to test/experience the electric side) on my Active Tourer 225e ends.
if it wasn't for this video, I didn't know Volvo can be such an amazing car. I drove one few hours ago at my Volvo dealer and yes, you feel very special when you are inside and you drive it through the city and on B roads ... such an amazing feeling of not owning none of the 3 others brands which almost everybody buy them just to own in front of their friends ... everybody looks at the Volvo on the streets, it is a really head turner and inside it is absolutely 5stars hotel, just amazing. I thought it is a chinesse crap but not at all, just the money came from China but the car is made in EU, amazing!
For me The XC 40 is the better Allrounder when our comes to the SUV feel, safety, comfort, features and value for money.
i really like how you say Harman Kardon 😊
I actually have to make the choice. Currently driving a Q3 sportback but need to change. Its either Q3, XC40, or X1. But the latter has long delivery time so out and price wise a little too much. The Volvo XC40 is best priced because its complete. With the Audi, you have to be carefull because all nice features you need to select otherwise they will not put it in. That is something that actually sucks about Audi (also VW). So thanks Thomas for putting these four reviews together. Any choice will be good, it will come to fine details and of course to the cents.😅
yeah agree!
I looked at all of these before buying my xc40. I almost bought the x1, but the xc40 was just right for me. Anyways your reviews help a ton!!!
Realized I said xc40 LOL, I MEANT TO SAY C40 recharge even tho it’s electric , I only went with it bc I love the xc40 but had some issues with it, but the c40 had the things that improved/fixed them
Nice enjoy 😎
@@gian_m just curious, what is improved/fixed on the C40 over the XC40?
after last comparison It’s like u heard my internal thought saying I wish u compared Mercedes too, and here it is
yes indeed :-)
Just ordered a X1 23D X line, got to be more reliable than my last car
what was your last car?
@@roboticvenom1935 Range Rover Evoque 200 Diesel SE Dynamic (in my profile pic) only lost £1,900 in 20 months and 12,000 miles, Range Rovers are well sorted, in fact put my name down for the Electric Evoque in 2024, my BMW X1 is arriving in April, great review thanks
A good point for the germans: 40/20/40 rear bench split is. for me, a major advantage. Especiallly for large dog owners! I would expect all big estates and suv having premium exepvtations to have it, at least as an option!
Really like the Merc GLA or Audi Q3.
Audi all the way, just got one with sport package and black optic
can you review Nissan Xtrail epower ?
Here it is: th-cam.com/video/e1-SD-gpa4c/w-d-xo.html
Great review. Just one comment about the Volvo and its steering feel. As far as I can see, it was the only one on winter tyres which don't give the same steering feel as summer tyres.
Thanks 🙏
Hmmm not quite sure, i d have to recheck. But could be!
Why are tyres so large on these vehicles? They look good, though not always, but spoil the ride and are expensive. Would be interesting if you did a video on this Tomas.
manufacturers put them on because larger tyres look better - yes they are less comfortable in driving
Bigger wheels in general don't make sense in that the wheel arches cut into luggage space. But it's a combination of fashion and profit. Having low profile tyres on my BMW 320 I'd never do it again -not for the comfort so much as the noise they make when you scrape them against a kerb when parking. It's an expensive sound.
I had the XC40 lovely car and so fun to drive! I traded it for a Lexus NX hybrid and although the fuel economy is marvelous I miss the Volvo, nothing exciting about the NX bigger for sure but I felt the Volvo felt bigger, I might trade it for BMW X1 it looks really nice and fun! Not sure if I would get a XC40 just cause now it feels a bit outdated in comparison to the bmw
thanks for the feedback !
حلقة جميلة اذا بالإمكان التصوير بالدول العربية أو بلاد الشام نتمنى لك مزيد من التقدم والنجاح
Thanks 🙏
Check this out: th-cam.com/video/m7Sda74nYHA/w-d-xo.html
Well done Thomas! What a very deep comparison…for me the new X1 is the best among others, only the interior is same premium as the GLA, honestly I really love the floating style dashboard in the X1. Or maybe interior of the X1 is better than the GLA. What do you think? 🤔
Thanks 🙏 please share 😎
Yeah the interior quality is higher in the X1
19-21 wheels, big front surface all not great for fuel consumption. But at least the mirrors are extra streamlined on the BMW 😂
Thank God thats the one I bought !!!! 😍
Which one
@@remy88 should arrive this month. X1 storm bay metallic black and red inside MSport.
Which one you’d NOT pick? Seriously Mercedes looks like it has lost its „German“ touch. Also love the manual control nubs by Audi, hard choice between here vs X1.
Audi looks the best. My opinion.
Q3 looks the best. All of them are great cars
Not a hater and just my opinion...but Thomas could you talk to the German car makers to make cars with less plastic and better build Quality 😄
Tnx
Q3 #1
I owned the GLA and wasn't impressed with the build quality or the way it drove
BMW👍👍👍
Does bmw X1 have lot of tyre noise and road noise when travelling in highway? Does it hold 3 people at the back comfortably??
have you checked it out full length? Also this might help: th-cam.com/video/P4BOtJ1zC5E/w-d-xo.html
@@autogefuehl I did check it. Thanks. Do you recommend a particular engine for a company car purchase ? Or is it better to switch to Tesla?
The Volvo looks great. Mercedes was the biggest letdown.
X1 all day everyday
BMW X1
All the favorite routes around Freiburg....
Idk why you keep admiring 3D sound for listening music, no body who loves high end music system in a car cares for 3D.
You actually compare gla with b class, glc and other mercedes. Where it s comparative with cars wich you presented, bmw x1, audi q3?!?!?!?
What exactly are you referring to?
@@autogefuehl I mean on the road test on GLA, heard yourself
I am giving different comparisons caus people also decide inside the brand
que lux por las vistas a mis canciones gracias ........
Porsche Macan would reign supreme if you included it :)
One segment above that is! th-cam.com/video/AJaqgkYqmqE/w-d-xo.html
@@autogefuehl ah thanks!
que lux vamos por el millon de vistas a mis canciones ..........
All day every day Tonale
enjoy our Alfa Tonale review here: th-cam.com/video/Bw9DSpIhf5k/w-d-xo.html
I'm a bit worried about the reliability of German cars. Therefore I'd rather go for Volvo.
if only we got the plug in the US
Range Rover vogue?
XC40 for me
lux un millon de vistas a mis canciones gacias .......
If "Visual choice" is hard for you, maybe try saying "Squirrel" next time :D
WATCH OUT FOR SPAM/FAKE ACCOUNTS. Across TH-cam, you'll find fake accounts taking the identity of original channels, they use the same profile pic, similar names and include a telephone number in the name or their comments, trying to get you to message them on Whatsapp or Telegram. DO NOT MESSAGE THEM, they are trying to get your personal details, bank accounts etc. and in the end, they will ask for money. They promise you giveaways, prices etc. Do not fall for these cheap tricks and PLEASE HELP everyone and MARK THEIR MESSAGES and their whole accounts/channels as Spam. We from Autogefuehl will never ask for your bank details. Check out our original channel marked with the verified badge.
We do have other official channels, so you can identify them and also subscribe if you like e.g. in your native language:
2nd channel:
th-cam.com/users/autogefuel
Spanish: Auto Sensación - Prueba de coches a fondo
th-cam.com/channels/ZospzTclE4Uf6Jvxbh842Q.html
Arabian: حس السيارات
th-cam.com/channels/YSBKhMY_UpvcU1_4j8xJcg.html
Korea: 오토센스
th-cam.com/channels/6S_5hXKrjJ87xOg9GE_AHA.html
Japan: カー フィーリング
th-cam.com/channels/8wumItayAPJnk059DLa30g.html
Russian: Анатомия Автомобиля
th-cam.com/users/c%D0%90%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B8%D1%8F%D0%90%D0%B2%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%B8%D0%BB%D1%8F
I have an GLA 35 AMG........It is miles above the SUV's compared here
Pretention aside I will take a Honda CR-V sport touring.
BMW please listen: I NEED ventilated seats, yeah I know it's gross but in summer I get a sweaty back! Please Autogefuhl try to communicate this with BMW, I would rather have this then heated/massage or anything!
Get a Hyundai Tucson or Kia Sportage...they have a lot of options (including ventilated seats) and very good value for money.
@@gordonnorris4202 I know I saw it but the ride compared to something like this X1 is going to be very bad because already the GLA murders it.
@@revoltoff I have the new Tucson, with ECS (electronic suspensions) and the ride is great...go do a test drive at least ;)
The introduced Volvo is/are the 2021 / 2022 model year one(s). New 2023 models have Google OS and many features changed / improved so this comparison is not 100% valid/adequate anymore.
yes Android Automotive now does great job in the XC40: th-cam.com/video/xkkCC-KsyYg/w-d-xo.html
Volvo
Maybe for me the Volvo but for you maybe something else.
I thought this would be subcompact.
1:22:43...Whaaa? Haha
Your height make the cars look even more smaller 😂
Yes, this guy really tall😂
Audi has to have one of the worst interior designs in any luxury car! Mercedes beats everyone else in that department
Wondering why the Range Rovers are never compared to the competition? In this case the Range Rover Evoque?
Because whoever owned one knows its not a premium! Even Volvo is questionable nowdays with new series. You could count Lexus as premium, and Genesis based on my experience.
I think Land Rover believes that Evoque is in the class of x3, GLC, xc60 and so on.
@@capricornus993 I would of thought that would be the Velar. As every comparison in the UK against the Evoque has been against the Q3 and XC40