NIKON Z9 VS NIKON Z6II | ELECTRONIC VS MECHANICAL SHUTTER
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ม.ค. 2025
- No mechanical shutter - what? Can this even be possible? How about sports and wildlife?
This video is a non-scientific test between Nikon Z6II and Nikon Z9 performed as a follow up test to mathphotographer • Nikon Z9 vs Z7II | Ele... .
I'm truly blowed away by the shutterless Nikon Z9 camera. Please share your questions and comments in the description below. Subscribe!
Nikon Z9 camera with electronic shutter beats Nikon Z6II with mechanical shutter.
I hope most Z9 features will go down to The Z6iii and Z7iii
It would make a great deal if both fall in the same price bracket! For the price the z6 II is one of the best and capable mirrorless cameras in the market today!
@@pravinsp14 I love my Z6II. Great camera.
Did you not notice the horizontal high frequency banding with the z9 shutter?
But doesn't beat when shooting HHS/FP flash with 3rd party flashes =/ In these cases, it easily produces banding
Yeah, I saw that test other day on the mathphotograher video channel, but thank you for taking the time to redo the test and explaining clearly.
My pleasure. I was very intrigued by it and felt I needed to follow through to be fully convinced. Yes, indeed, it works like a charm.
Great test and thank you for taking the time to do it. I shot some video two days ago and found very little rolling shutter when panning with a motocross rider. It wouldn't be noticeable to the average person.
I’m surprised to hear you actually noticed a rolling shutter in video mode. I haven’t tested that for video but good to know. Thx.
Good video!
The bending on the fan blades shot by the Z6II in movement are due to the focal plane shutter that is not so fast. The curtains moving at 1/8.000 s expose a moving slit that causes the bending even in mechanical shutter.
The electronic shutter of the Z9 is faster than the moving curtains of the Z6II.
Great explanation.
It is expected there is no difference when turning it horizontal when photographing a rotating object. The difference could show when fast panning.
I tested in a vertical mode b/c other have speculated that in vertical mode (given the direction of sensor scanning) it will look differently. So, apparently it doesn’t make a difference, at least in my test.
Thanks for the video. A little concerned re bands in the Z9, this is the first time I have seen this on the Z9 : 1. Is this due to lighting/leds or is this still there in daylight images. 2. I saw the effect in the video on the Z9 at also at 1/8000 s/s a little but more on the higher shutter speeds but NOT on the z6ii and it does not look like noise/high iso as it is not uniform. Any ideas as you have the camera ?
how many times are u shooting with LED signs behind u? to be fair though it doesn't look good, perhaps a global shutter down the road will fix that. Though a global shutter uses a lot of processor power.
Hi, I have z6ii with me and I'm unable to switch the mecheninal shutter mode in the camera
Have you tried custom settings - d5 I have it set on auto. for the other setting silent photografie got to "Photo shooting menu" to find it. if you set it to silent, the settings in d5 wil be overruled ;-)
Nice conformation video, thanks. I would have been clearer if you had selected shutter type, rather than silent mode, since it is possible to select electronic shutter when not in silent mode. Having said that, there’s no confusing the wacky image results when the “slow” Z6 electronic shutter was used.
Awesome test man. This will really be good with sports, swinging a bat or a golf swing. Very helpful. Question, on the last side by side image, Am I seeing some banding or not so smooth bokeh on the grey part with the Z9 or is that just because the video is not converted to 4k yet at the time of watching and commenting. Maybe its my eyes. "been reading to much text on the screen lol "or the resolution Im watching the video in. The iso Im assuming is the same at 1/8000 of a sec. in any case thank you for taking the time and making this awesome test. Very clearly executed and explained. Rock n Roll!!!!
btw very cool fan I must say. tells the time and temp. That;s crafty.
I noticed that as well! It would be interesting to see if this also occurs at lower ISO.
Thanks Vahag. Yes, the 3rd image to the right indicates banding with low light, shutter speed 1/32,000 and high ISO. I have tested with a faster lens at f/1.8 which allowed to lower ISO and bending is nearly unnoticeable. But again I’m shooting at 32,000 shutter speed. At shutter speed of 1/8000 and high ISO 25,600, no bending, just some noise/ grain.
It is helpful when I can test and confirm something within my own environment and share with others.
Z9 is on another level.
Hope this helps.
@@Vahagraphy temp is not very accurate. 😅
@@stefan9015 at lower ISO, but high shutter speed of 1/32000, in my test, bending is unnoticeable. I tested with faster lens to confirm that.
Excellent video 😊 .Wanted to know what was that banding ? Do you get that banding while shooting at higher iso at night with z9 ?
This was banding due to super high shutter speed 1/32,000. Typically high use by itself don’t course that
What about the terrible banding issues in your z9 examples of the fan, that seems like more of a problem?
Excellent demonstration!!!!
Hello sir which shutter is best in z6ii for wedding in fast focusing
That was a very good demonstration, thank you for the video, a really cool fan btw, pun intended :)
Thank you for kind words Paul.
9:55 has some really bad horizontal banding.. Still impressive how the ES freezes the fan!
The mechanical shutter beat the z9 electronic shutter. You just caught the blades at a more favorable angle with the z9. Also didn't anyone here see the high frequency banding in the z9 shot at 1/8000s?
Thanks for your comment. There might be very slightest banding at 1/8000 sec for Z9. Mostly noticeable due to high ISO but when it comes to freezing the action Z9 performed well as expected.
I hope they make The Z9 in to a Z8 small body Z6 Body … same spec …
No 8k 60… for 3999$
At some point the specs will be trickling down. Many sports photographers still desire larger camera body to balance lenses.
Z8 will hopefully be with shutter and have better dynamic range and color depth. Hopefully even better than the D810/D850.
@@TH-camr-ku4nk it may have shutter but I can see that future flagship models will be doing away with shutter mech.
@@TouchLifeStudio I think it depends. It's seems that flagship models are focussed on speed and that's why shutterless would make sense. If sheer image quality is the priority then a shutter and a non-stacked sensor is a must.
I think you were spot on back then! The z8 just came out today. It's $3999 U.S. it's the same as the Z9 but in a smaller case footprint. I think it also has 8K60p video capabilities!
Dear admin thanks for your vids...I think the BOMB of 2nd half of 20's decade will be GLOBAL SHUTTER for after 2025 in mirrorless,1st CANON then NKON then the others,then the RED MONSTRO(DSMC2) Vistavision (V lock) price then will FALL to real apropriate price as 20000,the FX9 to 7000$,and the mirrorless global shutters about 10000 $,after 2030 those fall again 50%,i mean real free filmmaking will be available for independent movies after 2030....
I hope these ideas will come to fruition sooner. Thanks.
I have the Z6ii,it only goes to 1/2000 sec shutter speed.Why not 1/8000 of a sec?
It should have 1/8000 sec
My z6ii is DX, the FX goes to 1/8000 of a sec.
Interesting!
Yes,9 is a beast!
in Tunisia we don't even afford food anymore
Wowwww z9 is amazing
and expensive ( i literally make 10$ per day )