i thought i was the only one, i mean they did great and most of their voices sounds typically jyp artists' voice. Also even tho it didn't reach the original tone and voice, for me, they did good job covering this..... but some comments are just....
Same, quizás no estén en el nivel de Twice. Pero ésta es una escuela de ídolos y se supone que están aprendiendo. JYP es una empresa fuerte, con fuertes artistas. Creo que éstas chicas lo hicieron bien
But how about if Natty do this ... She’s almost be a member of twice.Have you watch Sixteen??Natty even in major group while twice member in minor group.(means she even still better than some of them)
To those who said this is a easy song to sing then you totally wrong.. Even 15& Park Jimin said it a hard song and she having a hard time singing Cheer Up and we all know how powerful her vocal can be and expert vocal like her know her limited and admit that this song is hard is already a proof and she won Kpop star first season. Now let's not pretend like a expert LMAO.
Alexandrea W. What do you expect, then? An exact replica of Twice? That’s more unrealistic. For their average skill level (because they certainly has some strong voices but then also about two that were less skilled), the difficulty of both the song and the dance, and the fact they did this all live: - they were in tune (except for a couple of the girls as previously mentioned) - they danced well - they must have been nervous but I didn’t hear it in their singing at all So, you’re entitled to your opinion. But it’s not “unrealistic” to enjoy this cover and think it’s good, even if it’s not the best in this competition.
And haters are still thinking TWICE cant sing...go and listen to the MR removed of others songs,like loa,TT,knock knock, signal, all these are good enough...I admit that some cheer up mr removed is really bad, but if you have seen the practice of cheer up in IDOL SCHOOL, you will know that cheer up is really not a easy song... BTW HAYOUNG LOOKS SO CUTE, FIGHTING
Btw i tried it and i ran out of breath while only doing Momo part ( which is not that much as you can see at Cheer Up line distribution ) ( I tried Jihyo, Nayeon and Momo lines )
miraisyh she's tasha!!:) shes extremely talented. She debuted before in a group called skarf 5 years ago but it kinda flop:( u shld check out her dance practices tho its bomb af:)
Where is the justice???? where???? i need to call my lawyer... I really salute jihyo for being a good main vocal... This really proves that Cheer up is not an ordinary song to sing.... Twice jjjang!!!!
Kokona Haruka cheer up high note and AOA heart attack high note Isn't even real. You can't do it again and again. If you do , It will hurt yourself. So I think there's good if they don't sing that part
李Filbert Fausta agree. It will only give jihyo and nayeon vocal nodules if they'll keep on singing songs like cheer up that goes up to a Eb5 every chorus. But i think jihyo sometimes sings the high notes of cheer up's chorus live
now we know the fact "cheer up" is hard song, i remember when someone said jihyo can't do highnote, but now? I've tried to sing this song, but always fail in jihyo part.. Even though that girl who sing jihyo part and his team has do the best, We must appreciate their hard work too!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 let's give support and don't bring down each other, if can't? please go away!!
That's a lie. Jihyo is not allowed to sing the high note live because it is so hard and if she does it every time she'll damage her voice in the long run. When twice won 1st place on music bank with cheer up for the first time, jihyo hit the high not live for the first time when they sang the encore. While crying, too. So yeah, haters are just clueless.
I'm like TT 'cuz Jihyo slayed my life yeah i know that, haters always say twice bla bla and bla but they don't know it is so hard if their try it self😂😂 they always says twice song is never hard, but not for cheer up and LOA song
I'm so disappointed in some of you ONCE. Why are you letting these girls get the same hate twice got? Like damn respect these girls instead of seeming like we are the ones being rude 24/7.
@@hello-tt2ml so because twice got worse comments, it's okay to bash these girls as well? Ever heard of treating others like you want to be treated? Smh compassion lacks in this community.
CAN EVERYONE JUST TALK ABOUT TASHA HOW IS SHE GETTING so little votes i mean like this isn't a easy song after all those korean ppl only vote for visuals not talent someone as talented like tasha should deserve to debut and after all she isn't ugly at all like AT ALL SHE'S vvvv pretty to me like really pretty probably korean ppl just dl foreigners or what ??? i mean like pd101 s2 samuel was a talent that they missed out and JONGHYUN omg idw tasha to have the jonghyun tragedy, she's like a leader and she gives me a leader vibe i really want her to debut IM PROUD OF YOU TASHA 💙
kaebsong ̣ it's just u know int fans aren't blind or deaf and the votes clearly show an incline towards their local pretty faces so. It's a well known fact that they are rather superficial and xenophobic so ur arguments are invalid
well in the first place... idol school was made on the criteria they have the pretty face and will to debut... no need for talents or skills... sigh i wish tasha can debut tho :( she's been on haitus for so long
this song is so bloody hard to hit on live. this grp had it like its like the exact opposite of whistle the charisma and cuteness concept is there but damn all the notes where u gotta add more drama cuteness inside rly made it hard to enjoy. they cld have put in background voices tbh for the 'get it together' or the end after cheer up chorus. that + high pitched voice and ppl are saying twice songs are easy to sing generally. 😂 as long as jihyo and nayeon hits it, its a jam.
Why people think that this is a bad cover? Ok, it's not like the original, but I think this sounds pretty good and Sia's High Note was sooo good. Maybe this isn't the best performance of Idol School, but I really enjoyed the stage
1:03 Tasha she's a dancer, 1:04 Lee Nakyung (now in fromis_9) (i'm not sure which you were referring to) and 1:55 is Shin Sia whose a vocalist. she was on Finding Momoland, the survival show that created Momoland and now she does covers on youtube
Not hating on these girls and I'm not even a twice fan. But the haters really need to stop. True, overall Twice vocals might not be as good as Taeyeon or Hyorin or other legends. But! They definitely own their songs. The whole package is what makes them successful. Just listening to this, it's not awful, but it's bad enough to get all the criticism.. Twice songs may seem easy but they're not. They're just like Miss A and WG's songs, where all of them seem easy but not. That's the charm of JYP production.. It's time to accept the reality, dear haters..
The girl that sung cheer up baby part the first time is really talented! And actually a lot of them are amazing in this! I’m so proud!!!! You go girls!
LOL, what you do want then? They have improved a lot or I should say songs like TT, signal, knock knock are suitable for TWICE...cheer up isn't a easy song to sing...
i don't think they worst, everyone think it was bad bcs they didn't had twice's vibe. even eunsuh ex jyp trainee, she also didn't has it. and they wrong to choose their main vocal.. jihyo has big-loud voice and she didn't. so, it's just they didn't suit the song, not they worst.
after hearing a lot of cover for Twice songs. I'm convinced that no-one can sing Twice songs but themselves like it was tailor-made for them Jihyo, Nayeon and Jeongyeon's Power Vocals, Mina's gentle voice, Sana's high pitch cute voice, etc. the lists goes on.
Not hating on Koreans but I feel like they only Stan/vote for visuals. International fans are actually looking at talents. I know this is just an opinion, but natty and Tasha's rank are dropping. Tasha is amazing but so underrated. I wish us international fans can do something about it. People think natty is overrated but she's not first. Mnet better not do these girls wrong like Samuel
If koreans had only voted for visuals then snowbaby, jung somi, and yang yeonji wouldnt have been eliminated. Look at p101, if ifans had been allowed to vote then ha sungwoon (the most talented member of wanna one) wouldnt have made it to top 20. Both ifans and kfans are the same, only stan talent when it's your faves
The way I saw many bad comments about the girls like lmao, is people know the behind story of why they choose this song? They got no choice. Mostly of them has lower key voice and this song is very different from their usual tone. A note to be remember, there are all trainees. If you come here to compare the OG, nah. It's not your place. The original would remain the best no matter what.
It was not that bad seriously ! Tasha and the one who look like Tzuyu did a great job and the one who sang the high note too , but when some people say that they did better than Twice I just can't agree , go watch MV removed of cheer up Mama ! You will see that Twice can sing Cheer Up very well anyway it the performance of Idol School was okay but the best team is me gusta tu team ❤ Peace ✌
who said they did better than Twice? talk about delusional. Twice literally has the best variety of voices that create a unique sound. they are not all high pitches like almost ALL the new ggs out there. thats why idol school girls nail songs like weewoo and ah choo and do songs like this badly. if there is more than 4 girls doing the song, it usually turns out badly.
JYP groups are precious ! I agree with you in one point that this group didnt do better than twice but the mama performance you are talking abt is where i ve found that most of twice members cant sing thay were not stable at all there are a lot of better performances
Not hating, but Produce 101's vocal is so much better than idol school's. All of the performances were okay. I feel like if they were in produce 101 they'll be in F (or lower). Talent is still better than beauty. Goodluck to these girls. Imma still give my support. Just my opinion.
I actually loved Natty. She improved a lot. But really, I know not all of them trained but I don't know if they will even improve with that short span of time unless they REALLY work hard. Still don't get what beauty has to do with being an idol. I thought being an idol means having at least some decent talent or star potential. But I don't see it. *mentally bashes mnet* like mnet, wtf, admission requirements to enter idol school is to only have beauty? Wth
Omg guys, give these girls a break, most of them have never gotten any trainee experience(unlike pd101), so it is natural for their voices to be bad plus THIS IS THEIR FIRST STAGE. geez. Personally, they didn't do that bad, they can and they will improve.
Once appreciate them❤️ Btw Thrice will still be haters. Good or bad they will still blame twice, provoke other, and say this better than original. So thrice Sorry we already know your thoughts🙏🙏
aww thrice expected to see them to do good so they could drag twice....HAHHAHAHHA anyways these girls honestly just proved how hard it is to Vocally sing 'CHEER UP' live ..even 15& jimin said it was hard
ONCE & TWICE everyone lip syncs special stages though. Twice lip synced me gustas tu as well and the song Gfriend was singing like ooh ahh not cheer up. Cheer up is a hard song, but I would remove gfriend from your comment and replace it with Jimin from 15& saying that she the song was hard instead.
Chi Mai Hồ mr removed videos can't remove prerecorded vocals. It was clearly prerecorded like all special stages are. It's not a bad thing or big deal. To even make a removed you have to use the studio version to cancel the voices out and there is no studio version of it so you wouldn't be able to make an mr removed of it because Twice and Gfriend don't sound alike their voices won't cancel.
Why all this negativity? I mean to be honest they did really well especially considering that some of them did not even train and that this is live with no background track. This is amazing and if you're so confident of your group talent then why all the hate?
Amal Gasiem it's not hate my dear, it's having an opinion and voicing it out. they did ok, just ok. i guess people have high expectations on covers on such a popular song, and it just didnt meet it the way they envisioned it. it's not an easy song to pull of after all....
GOT7WG JYP yeah voicing, "they are so bad" thats fucking rude, the trainees are humans too, much more, they faced a lot of obstacles just to perform on a freaking damn stage and yet people can easily _voice their such opinions_ like that yeah just know that, that is the right thing to do.
x dragyula yup those comments are down right rude, people just don't know how to put it into nice words that how they did isn't spectacular or anything, of course they need improvement, they need criticisms just as like as every group who performed. they need it to know so they can work on it. So yeaaah, you cant really tell what people would like to say and what their opinion is ( it is theirs, thats how they see it ) at the end of the day, it is up to these trainees on how they'll take these comments and criticims; for what others think and view is beyond their control...
x dragyula actually, most of them are just students who have no experience in singing or dancing at all and probably thought it'd be a good idea to join this program for fun, which resulted to this ... mess. i mean, have you watched the whistle performance? i'm not justifying the hate, i'm just hoping you understand why they attract a lot of hate. let's just hope the girls will improve as the show goes on.
![Idol School [3회]청량미 甲! ′오늘부터 우리는′ 배은영,나띠,박소명,서헤린,유지나,이다희,이슬,장규리 @ 1차데뷔능력고사 170727 EP.3](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/K8f5PNXSYc4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [3회]청량미 甲! ′오늘부터 우리는′ 배은영,나띠,박소명,서헤린,유지나,이다희,이슬,장규리 @ 1차데뷔능력고사 170727 EP.3](/img/tr.png)
![Idol School [8회]카라 골반댄스 완벽 재현! ′STEP′이시안,신시아,타샤,빈하늘 @학기말고사 170908 EP.8](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3OO6KZbRcwM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2022 MAMA] IVE&Kep1er&NMIXX&LE SSERAFIM&NewJeans - CHEER UP | Mnet 221129 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/d2heDnR3sjc/mqdefault.jpg)
It made me realize that Sana's shy shy shy was no joke.
manzi that's why its trending
True funny voice
Agree!
Agree!! That line was really made for Sana. 😂
Agreed even more 😁
I came here to clean my ears after hearing "Rookie" version
But I don't think there's any difference between rookie version
@@auniafiqah5390 for me sounds better
Sameee
Me too
Same ¡-¡
0:56 did she just call me a calculator??
LOL agree =)))
calculator😂😂
Still Dill 😂
LOOOOL
ㅋ笑lollloll
I didn't think there anything wrong with this cover,then I read the comments :(
Me to... I also think like that :(
yeah i don't get how this was bad . yeah , its not as good as the original (obviously) but it wasn't bad at all
@@lemondo0 their tone don't suit this song, and Jihyo didn't deserve this :")
i thought i was the only one, i mean they did great and most of their voices sounds typically jyp artists' voice. Also even tho it didn't reach the original tone and voice, for me, they did good job covering this..... but some comments are just....
Same, quizás no estén en el nivel de Twice. Pero ésta es una escuela de ídolos y se supone que están aprendiendo. JYP es una empresa fuerte, con fuertes artistas. Creo que éstas chicas lo hicieron bien
As expected, TWICE songs are truly made only for TWICE.
Grace D.
Yes hahaha. Yet others say it's 'so easy' to sing lol
of course 😊
Agree
But how about if Natty do this ... She’s almost be a member of twice.Have you watch Sixteen??Natty even in major group while twice member in minor group.(means she even still better than some of them)
Min Yoongi was she selected? No. She is not better since she couldn't beat them.
Even tho she is pretty good on stage
cheer up is sound like easy but its hard
i appreciate twice so much more after hearing this
amy same
Yhahaha😂😂😂
amy Haha..😂😂
This cover kinda wants to make me feel like I want to *Die*
amy me too
yall stop with the hate this performance wasnt even bad-
Riolen ivern is a kpop fan ? Omg
@@neoreulboyeojwo1496 the nature told me to
Riolen at least you being real
Lux wanted to be a kpop idol but she didn’t have enough courage to be one lol
@@neoreulboyeojwo1496 nature wasnt with her
Riolen lol
To those who said this is a easy song to sing then you totally wrong.. Even 15& Park Jimin said it a hard song and she having a hard time singing Cheer Up and we all know how powerful her vocal can be and expert vocal like her know her limited and admit that this song is hard is already a proof and she won Kpop star first season. Now let's not pretend like a expert LMAO.
Pilsung Bright jimin even changed the key of the song so that she can reach it
ikr cheer up is so highhhhhhh
Even GFRIEND have a hard time singing this too
@@migzflores4498 gfriend didn't even sing this song where did u get this information
@@oenothera8099 i think they mean Oh my girl
Someone Said "Twice's Song only for Twice"
And i really ag-
* Stray Kids Entered The Chat *
Stray kids world domination
And itzy too
SF9 entered the chat
stray kids left the chat
And Gfriend
Omg Hayoung and especially Nagyung and Chaeyoung's vocals have improved so much 🥺🤧 Now all 3 can hold high notes!
This isn’t even a bad cover... some of y’all Onces just have to be toxic 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️ but to the other Onces who aren’t being toxic, I appreciate you 😘
XDnarutomaniacIT compare to rookie
This is 5 time better
XDnarutomaniacIT I’m sorry but be realistic this is not a good cover.
Alexandrea W.
What do you expect, then? An exact replica of Twice? That’s more unrealistic.
For their average skill level (because they certainly has some strong voices but then also about two that were less skilled), the difficulty of both the song and the dance, and the fact they did this all live:
- they were in tune (except for a couple of the girls as previously mentioned)
- they danced well
- they must have been nervous but I didn’t hear it in their singing at all
So, you’re entitled to your opinion. But it’s not “unrealistic” to enjoy this cover and think it’s good, even if it’s not the best in this competition.
@@BELLAADONNAA half are screaming
XDnarutomaniacIT I like this cover.. I don’t find their voices bad
Original is always the best
And haters are still thinking TWICE cant sing...go and listen to the MR removed of others songs,like loa,TT,knock knock, signal, all these are good enough...I admit that some cheer up mr removed is really bad, but if you have seen the practice of cheer up in IDOL SCHOOL, you will know that cheer up is really not a easy song...
BTW HAYOUNG LOOKS SO CUTE, FIGHTING
mOmOrIn 2 香港人同胞 support TWICE forever
Actually Cheer up is not that hard but idk about singing while dancing Cheer Up. Probally me singing while dancing would sound not stable
@@nomnomanimations1107 singing cheer up is difficult and dancing with it as well. the only thing easy abt the song was the dance
@@Nicole-db2ub thats what I said, I only said the dance is easy but idk about singing while dancing it depends on the people tho
Btw i tried it and i ran out of breath while only doing Momo part ( which is not that much as you can see at Cheer Up line distribution ) ( I tried Jihyo, Nayeon and Momo lines )
1:10 this girl is amazing!
I agree
Her name is shin sia
2:14 this high note was sooo good!
That’s shin sia! :)
Cheer Up is not easy Lol. TWICE make a hard song like Cheer Up sound easy.
Lee Yee Fu !!!!
Lee Yee Fu the most diff song is cheer up,haha really funny everybody all think Cheer up is easy to sing
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 sure Jan Cheer Up is SOOO dificult
Cheer up has high-pitch, those haters won't hear anything you say btw..
Lee Yee Fu they struggle with the song and even their main vocals lipsync how do they make it sound easy? lmao
This is the proof that cheer up isn't an easy song
exactly👌🏻👌🏻
na bil it's because those who got the most lines don't fit the some.I have to say the only people who actually fit is Sia, Eunsuh, & I think Hayoung
na bil it's just that these girls are not good as well
na bil I can dance and sing it alone. It's super easy
tru
If im totally honest
This gave me a spark of hope after watching rookie
my ears felt a little cleaned after hearing this after watching rookie
only little tho..
Rookie performance was such a mess
I know, no one can't replace TWICE. but in 1:04 I tought she was tzuyu X_X
Same
thats nagyung, and yeah i thought she looked so much like tzuyu when i first started stanning (so do a lot of people!!)
same
Ikr
Because of her hair HAHAHAHAHAHA
the one who did momo's part at 0.59 was really good
miraisyh she's tasha!!:) shes extremely talented. She debuted before in a group called skarf 5 years ago but it kinda flop:( u shld check out her dance practices tho its bomb af:)
Xin Ru Oh thank you for the information :) I know there is a someone who is really talented in this show and i better to check skarf soon :)
Please support Tasha!! See her self camera!! (Sorry for my bad English)
That was like the only good part lol
The one who said CALCULATOR? Lol
I appreciated jihyo's vocal so much after watching this
This isn't THAT bad so chill 😂 But it does prove that even the Shy,Shy,Shy is hard to properly pull off. Even other twice members can't do it justice.
Im not here to judge their performance, because this is a cover but for me, they dance very well, but their voices are bit off for me.
Where is the justice???? where???? i need to call my lawyer... I really salute jihyo for being a good main vocal... This really proves that Cheer up is not an ordinary song to sing.... Twice jjjang!!!!
Kathleen Paige Calixto It seriously is too high to sing.
Bless Twice they handles to sing this well.
Kokona Haruka cheer up high note and AOA heart attack high note Isn't even real. You can't do it again and again. If you do , It will hurt yourself. So I think there's good if they don't sing that part
李Filbert Fausta agree. It will only give jihyo and nayeon vocal nodules if they'll keep on singing songs like cheer up that goes up to a Eb5 every chorus. But i think jihyo sometimes sings the high notes of cheer up's chorus live
Lol, what are you talking about? They did well.
Kathleen Paige Calixto Just call the lawyer on Rookie performance. Worst RV cover ever I heard.
I appreciate Jihyo's vocals so much more after this performance.
0:04 the first girl on the right is Onda from everglow.
Don't judge them all.
They're working hard! Don't talking shit of them,because you should judge them from the process,not a result.
jinyoung addict Plus this is difficult song to sing.
Even for Twice.
now we know the fact "cheer up" is hard song, i remember when someone said jihyo can't do highnote, but now? I've tried to sing this song, but always fail in jihyo part.. Even though that girl who sing jihyo part and his team has do the best, We must appreciate their hard work too!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 let's give support and don't bring down each other, if can't? please go away!!
That's a lie. Jihyo is not allowed to sing the high note live because it is so hard and if she does it every time she'll damage her voice in the long run. When twice won 1st place on music bank with cheer up for the first time, jihyo hit the high not live for the first time when they sang the encore. While crying, too. So yeah, haters are just clueless.
I'm like TT 'cuz Jihyo slayed my life yeah i know that, haters always say twice bla bla and bla but they don't know it is so hard if their try it self😂😂
they always says twice song is never hard, but not for cheer up and LOA song
Lyaandini 123 they said twice song is easy :v then I tried to do the cover :v . It's hard
Lyaandini 123 cause your not a singer and if some singers sing the song and fail then they should be ashamed
twice song is fast paced and always high pitched plus the fast choreo and fast changing position while singing
I'm so disappointed in some of you ONCE. Why are you letting these girls get the same hate twice got? Like damn respect these girls instead of seeming like we are the ones being rude 24/7.
No lmaoooooo
Did you read the comments in Twice Cheer up Mr removed,more worse than the comments in here
Awww oncies are so sweet, thank you!
@@hello-tt2ml so because twice got worse comments, it's okay to bash these girls as well? Ever heard of treating others like you want to be treated? Smh compassion lacks in this community.
most of the bad comments aren't even from us once
I'm in love with Ha Young, she's so cute. Her expression makes my heart melted ❤️
0:49のギュリちゃんかわいすぎなのでは？
CAN EVERYONE JUST TALK ABOUT TASHA HOW IS SHE GETTING so little votes i mean like this isn't a easy song after all
those korean ppl only vote for visuals not talent
someone as talented like tasha should deserve to debut and after all she isn't ugly at all like AT ALL SHE'S vvvv pretty to me like really pretty
probably korean ppl just dl foreigners or what ??? i mean like pd101 s2 samuel was a talent that they missed out and JONGHYUN omg
idw tasha to have the jonghyun tragedy, she's like a leader and she gives me a leader vibe i really want her to debut
IM PROUD OF YOU TASHA 💙
Alexxis Chan I AM SO PROUD OF HER AS WELL ❤ I swear if KNetz pull another "Jonghyun" imma slap a bitch 🔥
kaebsong ̣ it's just u know int fans aren't blind or deaf and the votes clearly show an incline towards their local pretty faces so. It's a well known fact that they are rather superficial and xenophobic so ur arguments are invalid
well in the first place... idol school was made on the criteria they have the pretty face and will to debut... no need for talents or skills... sigh i wish tasha can debut tho :( she's been on haitus for so long
seungcheol's shiny butt tasha is pretty HELLO she is v pretty i'm a singaporean and i'm not really pretty but i think she's really pretty
yeah ik she's pretty im a singaporean too but im just saying.. prob koreans dont find her beauty to fit their standards so
Their dance was good, but their vocal are cringy.
Ting Zhang twice too kkk
Oni Gawara Not at all. It sounds natural with TWICE while it sounds really forced here
Ting Zhang this song really high tho, it is really hard to sing
This song is really hard to sing.
But this is better than Rookie's vocal. Like is a mix of not fitting and forced for Rookie.
I’m not familiar with who sang what part in the original song but the girl that sang the part at 1:49 was so good oh my gosh
Candy Floss Nayeon I believe sings that part in the original song.
JIhyo sang that part.
that’s shin sia in here!
angellovesBTS in the original it’s actually jihyo. nayeon songs the bit afterwards
ms_jc04 ur right!
this song is so bloody hard to hit on live.
this grp had it like its like the exact opposite of whistle
the charisma and cuteness concept is there but damn all the notes where u gotta add more drama cuteness inside rly made it hard to enjoy. they cld have put in background voices tbh for the 'get it together' or the end after cheer up chorus.
that + high pitched voice
and ppl are saying twice songs are easy to sing generally. 😂 as long as jihyo and nayeon hits it, its a jam.
As i am not once but not the hater, i appreciate twice more seeing this girl struggle so much to these song cause twice made this song look easy.
I think Tasha did really well in this, i mean she stable in term of vocal and dance i can't believe knetz didn't notice her talent
If you’re hating on these girls, you probably meow when you see a dog. Shut up. This cover is great.
ジヒョたちの声量の恐ろしさがよくわかるな…
Now you know how well TWICE can sing
iyya Choe of course fat ass
iyya Choe SEE THEIR LIVE PERFORMANCE OK IN I CAN SEE YOUR VOICE
Stability has nothing to do with being able to Sing. You could be a good singer but can still not be stable.
hehe
baekhyun exo yes they can sing because They Are Queens Ok Dog?🐶
Shinsia and Tasha omg, i hope they will debut, their voices really
the members who got into fromis have improved SO much wow
1:03 I think this girl look like Tzuyu😍
That’s nagyung
2:43 is a closer look (she’s the middle one) and she does look like her
貓閔 氏 奶 1:26
I think Tasha is onlythe one who dance and sing the best..
Ashley Yeap I'm new here. Can you tell me who is Tasha?
Isabella Malaquias at 0:58 She is from SINGAPORE
because you only look at her lol
queendoyeon I think this is only her opinion
YingYing Jjiang that was wujufromis' point. You cant have an opinion about someone/something else if you only one focus on one
hayoung is so cute... i hope she, chaeyoung, and nakyung get to debut together
i think u predicted the future
に……日本人いますか……？
ジウォンやったっけ？シックスティーンに出ててたよね！可愛い😆
にわかやで、ウンソ、ナッティしか分からんかった。。
Why people think that this is a bad cover? Ok, it's not like the original, but I think this sounds pretty good and Sia's High Note was sooo good. Maybe this isn't the best performance of Idol School, but I really enjoyed the stage
some of them doing good, yes only some not all
none
Fyah Rucker some
I'm Gay none your mom gay
I'm Gay i see why there in idol school they wont ever come out
I don't know, but i think "cheer up" is only just for twice
Buzz In .😓
Buzz In it's a really hard song. Only the member of Oh My Girl could pull it off in my opinion (watch her cover 😌)
Buzz In true
angellovesBTS their not her
Lol😂😂
Original is still better
2:14 omg for a trainee her vocals are a m a z i n g
God Jihyo didn't deserve this
Bangtan's Bae what happened?
Le Cowqueen What is the name of this girl 1:03 and What is the name of this girl 1:55
1:03 Tasha she's a dancer,
1:04 Lee Nakyung (now in fromis_9)
(i'm not sure which you were referring to)
and 1:55 is Shin Sia whose a vocalist. she was on Finding Momoland, the survival show that created Momoland and now she does covers on youtube
What are you talking about punk?
i thought the girl who sang her part was good 😩 and the girl after her
Don't get it, isn't Tasha the most prettiest here in terms of natural beauty? not much screen time for her...
Coz Mnet is playing dirty to her
Her screen time is seriously terrible
@@andreaswidjaja2973 cos shes a foreigner
Singaporean to be exact
Not hating on these girls and I'm not even a twice fan. But the haters really need to stop. True, overall Twice vocals might not be as good as Taeyeon or Hyorin or other legends. But! They definitely own their songs. The whole package is what makes them successful. Just listening to this, it's not awful, but it's bad enough to get all the criticism.. Twice songs may seem easy but they're not. They're just like Miss A and WG's songs, where all of them seem easy but not. That's the charm of JYP production.. It's time to accept the reality, dear haters..
ソンハヨンの誕生日という事で超絶可愛い二つ結びハヨンを見に来た
The girl that sung cheer up baby part the first time is really talented! And actually a lot of them are amazing in this! I’m so proud!!!! You go girls!
Tasha
inoismylife please tell me the group of the groupe
TQueen
Huh ? You say Twice can't sing ? Try watch Twice I can see your voice , they sang cheer up live .
Free to Once up!
That one is without dancing you dumbhead...
LOL, what you do want then? They have improved a lot or I should say songs like TT, signal, knock knock are suitable for TWICE...cheer up isn't a easy song to sing...
I like you 😉👍🏻
Real Savager before calling someone a dumbhead, i hope you know the vocals to this performance were recorded without dancing as well.
hayoung voice it's the most clear
2:14 she’s honestly really good
This is the proof that being an idol isn't just about being pretty
Karen Aguilar ???
Fuck meh this girls are really pretty, but they can't sing good, they sing below the average range
SOMEONE TELL ME WHO THAT GIRL IS WHO DID A PERFECT ADLIB ON JIHYO'S SOLO???? I HAVE TO STAN
jaehyun's yakisoba prince she is Shin Sia ex finding momoland contestant. She has some amazing vocal skills.
She's Shin Sia .
thankyou guys 💜
Thanks finally someone appreciates my talented baby 💗
Thanks for appreciating Siah
Eunsuh’s “Shy Shy Shy” wasn’t like Sana’s but I don’t mind. I thought she killed it! It was cute and fresh❤️
Okay y'all talking about the vocals but I'm here laughing at Chaeyoung's awkward smile in 2:23 HSJHSSJ
i don't think they worst, everyone think it was bad bcs they didn't had twice's vibe. even eunsuh ex jyp trainee, she also didn't has it. and they wrong to choose their main vocal.. jihyo has big-loud voice and she didn't. so, it's just they didn't suit the song, not they worst.
Tasha Debut Please!!!
loceanlee 1515 she will deubt
She must debut at top9
Or else she may not continue her career as idol due to her age
Seriously she is being slept on
Andreas Widjaja how old is she?
Shes 28
twice trash 25 korean age (24 internationally)
ALL OF YOU WHO SAID THEY DIDN'T SOUND LIKE TWICE! DID YOU KNOW THAT THIS IS A COVER? WTF ARE YOU SAYING? THOSE GIRLS DID A GREAT JOB !!
after hearing a lot of cover for Twice songs. I'm convinced that no-one can sing Twice songs but themselves like it was tailor-made for them Jihyo, Nayeon and Jeongyeon's Power Vocals, Mina's gentle voice, Sana's high pitch cute voice, etc. the lists goes on.
Even their reaction is fake af
Nurul Izzah Lol, you can say that again😂😂
someone get ice
Lmao.
Nurul Izzah I'm dying but it's so true.
Nurul Izzah
Lmao
Not hating on Koreans but I feel like they only Stan/vote for visuals. International fans are actually looking at talents. I know this is just an opinion, but natty and Tasha's rank are dropping. Tasha is amazing but so underrated. I wish us international fans can do something about it. People think natty is overrated but she's not first. Mnet better not do these girls wrong like Samuel
Katelyn Thao lol. Did you miss Produce 101. Most of the westerns votes were visual. Stop being so entitled
Kinder Slainder but they had talent though. And you could ask many other people. They think Koreans are just picking visuals
Not really, I'm korean and I care about talent and stuff too. A lot of my American friends legit only like groups for there looks tho...
If koreans had only voted for visuals then snowbaby, jung somi, and yang yeonji wouldnt have been eliminated. Look at p101, if ifans had been allowed to vote then ha sungwoon (the most talented member of wanna one) wouldnt have made it to top 20. Both ifans and kfans are the same, only stan talent when it's your faves
Katelyn Thao YeonJung( WJSN) and Chungha say hi
Eunsuh aced her only 2 lines and looked cute af the whole time 💜
The way I saw many bad comments about the girls like lmao, is people know the behind story of why they choose this song? They got no choice. Mostly of them has lower key voice and this song is very different from their usual tone. A note to be remember, there are all trainees. If you come here to compare the OG, nah. It's not your place. The original would remain the best no matter what.
ppl said their voice is cringy, I don't think so tho. try watching rookie
Yeah, i think this cover is better than twice lol
이예슬 this is jokes omg, u should try to watch rookie by other trainees
Neko Poi you might need to get your ears checked. Some of the girls sounded good but most did not.
This group is so cute.. once here to support. 😊
houda razol yep. So many people bashing them so sad. They did great especially (hayoung (improve) eunsuh,tasha and shin siah
I love Tasha and Shin Sia and Kim Eunsuh and Bin Ha Neul in this group
I appreciate more and more TWICE's precious voice after hearing this
Don't underestimate twice cause cheer up is not easy
It was not that bad seriously ! Tasha and the one who look like Tzuyu did a great job and the one who sang the high note too , but when some people say that they did better than Twice I just can't agree , go watch MV removed of cheer up Mama ! You will see that Twice can sing Cheer Up very well anyway it the performance of Idol School was okay but the best team is me gusta tu team ❤
Peace ✌
JYP groups are precious ! i agree with u
JYP groups are precious ! nope, this is the worst cover ive ever seen or heard.
who said they did better than Twice? talk about delusional. Twice literally has the best variety of voices that create a unique sound. they are not all high pitches like almost ALL the new ggs out there. thats why idol school girls nail songs like weewoo and ah choo and do songs like this badly. if there is more than 4 girls doing the song, it usually turns out badly.
JYP groups are precious ! I agree with you in one point that this group didnt do better than twice but the mama performance you are talking abt is where i ve found that most of twice members cant sing thay were not stable at all there are a lot of better performances
What are their names pls x
Hayoung and Sia's voice omggggg💕💕💕 Tasha❤ I really like Sia's voice cuz she has a high vocal range. Her Step performance is soool goooood tooooo.
1:56 i really love this and i replay it so many times like TWO VOICE uhhuh
Not hating, but Produce 101's vocal is so much better than idol school's. All of the performances were okay. I feel like if they were in produce 101 they'll be in F (or lower). Talent is still better than beauty. Goodluck to these girls. Imma still give my support. Just my opinion.
Arlene Rueda ugh! most of them didn't get any trainee experience!
Arlene Rueda natty wont be an F
I actually loved Natty. She improved a lot. But really, I know not all of them trained but I don't know if they will even improve with that short span of time unless they REALLY work hard. Still don't get what beauty has to do with being an idol. I thought being an idol means having at least some decent talent or star potential. But I don't see it. *mentally bashes mnet* like mnet, wtf, admission requirements to enter idol school is to only have beauty? Wth
Arlene Rueda but there are still girls here that would go to A
You should look at Natty, Jiwon, Tasha, Nayeon, U-Jung, Myeongji, Shinsia and more
Arlene Rueda agree, but fans tend to like idols who are "good looking", it might be shallow but it's true.
i think the one that done momo's part suit this song very well. she's pretty and her voice is good ㅠ ㅠ. what is her name?
pacarnya sebong Tasha
Co Al tasha already debut before this right? I kinda remembered her face.. but i dont remember the group name
balqissoo Yes, she debuted in gg name Skarf in 2012 if i remembered correctly.
indonesian ha?
pacarnya sebong the one that suits the song is only the one that sang Momo's part.. honestly..
The main vocalist carried this performance
신시아는 노래 잘하네 시원시원하게 잘부름
this video proves that TWICE vocal is so powerful especially Jyhyo and Nayeon and this song is not easy to sing.
I just realized how Twice actually pulled off this song well now
Thanks for covering our queen's song. Wish you all the best.
I think no one can top sana's natural charisma and cuteness while doing shy shy shy
Omg guys, give these girls a break, most of them have never gotten any trainee experience(unlike pd101), so it is natural for their voices to be bad plus THIS IS THEIR FIRST STAGE. geez. Personally, they didn't do that bad, they can and they will improve.
Once appreciate them❤️
Btw
Thrice will still be haters. Good or bad they will still blame twice, provoke other, and say this better than original. So thrice Sorry we already know your thoughts🙏🙏
Lets admit shin sia Tasha and jiwon save this performance
0:56 "calculator"
Cheer Up is a high tone song, and in this perf, they change and low down the tone already and it make it like a big mess 😑😑😑😑😑
Liar
aww thrice expected to see them to do good so they could drag twice....HAHHAHAHHA anyways these girls honestly just proved how hard it is to Vocally sing 'CHEER UP' live ..even 15& jimin said it was hard
Park EunYoung Just look up Gfriend cheer up. They did a special stage by giving twice me gusta tu and gfriend cheer up
diibii ikr, and this perf. is even pre-recorded. Even if these girls did good, it's still not live
ONCE & TWICE everyone lip syncs special stages though. Twice lip synced me gustas tu as well and the song Gfriend was singing like ooh ahh not cheer up. Cheer up is a hard song, but I would remove gfriend from your comment and replace it with Jimin from 15& saying that she the song was hard instead.
twice not lipsyncs Me gustas tu, you can search MR
Chi Mai Hồ mr removed videos can't remove prerecorded vocals. It was clearly prerecorded like all special stages are. It's not a bad thing or big deal. To even make a removed you have to use the studio version to cancel the voices out and there is no studio version of it so you wouldn't be able to make an mr removed of it because Twice and Gfriend don't sound alike their voices won't cancel.
close to that rookie version this is a paradise for me
Im here supporting tasha..even she was debut as member of skarf,i want she debut back with new girlgroup.fighthing tasha
Why all this negativity? I mean to be honest they did really well especially considering that some of them did not even train and that this is live with no background track. This is amazing and if you're so confident of your group talent then why all the hate?
Amal Gasiem not live, it's pre-recorded...
Amal Gasiem it's not hate my dear, it's having an opinion and voicing it out. they did ok, just ok. i guess people have high expectations on covers on such a popular song, and it just didnt meet it the way they envisioned it. it's not an easy song to pull of after all....
GOT7WG JYP yeah voicing, "they are so bad" thats fucking rude, the trainees are humans too, much more, they faced a lot of obstacles just to perform on a freaking damn stage and yet people can easily _voice their such opinions_ like that yeah just know that, that is the right thing to do.
x dragyula yup those comments are down right rude, people just don't know how to put it into nice words that how they did isn't spectacular or anything, of course they need improvement, they need criticisms just as like as every group who performed. they need it to know so they can work on it. So yeaaah, you cant really tell what people would like to say and what their opinion is ( it is theirs, thats how they see it )
at the end of the day, it is up to these trainees on how they'll take these comments and criticims; for what others think and view is beyond their control...
x dragyula actually, most of them are just students who have no experience in singing or dancing at all and probably thought it'd be a good idea to join this program for fun, which resulted to this ... mess. i mean, have you watched the whistle performance?
i'm not justifying the hate, i'm just hoping you understand why they attract a lot of hate. let's just hope the girls will improve as the show goes on.
Tasha delivered her one and only part so well 0:58 but she got only 14 votes. I'm rioting
That girl winked open the fun screen that people are so surprised?Their voices do not mix
The girl who did the "shyshyshy" is so cute