Saving Private Ryan (1998) Movie REACTION!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 พ.ย. 2022
- For Film Friday #51, Madison watches "Saving Private Ryan" for the first time.
#savingprivateryan #tomhanks #benaffleck
Become a channel member: th-cam.com/channels/CRO.html...
Become a patron: / madisonkthames
Website: madisonthames.com
Instagram: @madisonkthames
Twitter: @madisonkthames
Facebook: @madisonkthames
Edited by: @creativeoliverx - บันเทิง
Madison, love your channel. I'd just recently retired from the Army [20 yrs, Master Sergeant, Infantry, Airborne, Ranger] when this movie was playing in the theaters. While watching it my wife was constantly whispering to me "Are you OK?", because I'd been to some of the crappiest places our world has to offer, lost friends, and I really don't want to think about the lives that I've taken. Now, this movie has even more meaning for my wife and I. In 2004, we received that "Knock on our door" to face an Army notification team, telling us our youngest son had died in IRAQ.
Sorry for your loss.
So sorry for your loss. No words can express how grateful I am for your and your sons service. My kids live free because of the two of you and the men you served with. Thank you.
Thank you for your service and you son's service 😞 I'm sorry for your loss ❤️🩹
Sir, I'm a retired Captain from the 1st Battalion across the pond. Please accept my condolences. All good wishes, sir.
Thank you for your service, Mark. And I’m so sorry for your loss🙏🏻❤️
Ryan already earned it,loss of brothers ,his own service.saving ryan is a metaphor for all of us today,who benefit from sacrifices of your soldiers and wartime civilians.
When Tom Hanks says "Earn this", he was talking to all of us. This movie should be shown in every High School History class.
To busy with Critical Race Theory
I found it too cheesy. I think they could have gotten the point across in a better way.
The one who never owned up is Japan..They have, to this day, never apologized for the atrocities they committed in SE Asia, which are just as brutal as the Germans.
@@scottmoyer8923 Right, because we're supposed to be learning from our own history like Jim Crow laws. Those specific laws may gone but there are still laws and other systems in place that have similar effects.
@@ImAlsoMerobiba there’s nothing in place ,the system in place gives blacks an advantage over other races but still can’t compete
Hard to believe that this movie lost Best Picture to "Shakespeare in Love" that year.
Not really.....a lot of people say that, but in truth, Ryan's script was awful with huge flaws (eg. Ryan is found very late in the film and you don't care about him, as all your investment is with Capt. Miller/Hanks by then )...also you can't base a film on 2 intense battle scenes only.......On the other hand Shakespeare was a more complete film (whether it was your 'cup of tea' or not is another matter)...so in my opinion, Ryan got pretty much what it deserved in the end Oscar-wise: best Director, Cinematography, Editing, sound....
@@fabianpatrizio2865 What are the huge flaws?
Yep absolute joke it didn’t win
@@fabianpatrizio2865 fuck Shakespeare in love get fucked Saving Private Ryan has a BRILLINT SCRIPT!
Another thing you can blame Harvey Weinstein for. He was the single most powerful man in Hollywood and he pressured the Academy into voting for Shakespeare In Love. Absolute joke.
Most people react the same about Upham. Upham had never been in combat, these soldiers were highly experienced. He was also not as highly trained as this group of Rangers. Basic is all Upham had, Rangers go through jump school and far more rigorous training. The reactions to combat can vary from fight, flight or freeze. Freezing up is what they want to drill out of you. Flight is necessary sometimes so you can regroup and come back more prepared. Fight is obviously the preferred reaction.
Spielberg explained that the Upham character was a stand in, for himself. He said he would have been a coward in that situation, and said how could you not be, when faced with such insurmountable odds. The fact that so many did their duty in the face of this, in spite of everything, shows just how special all of the men who served were.
Speechless throughout that movie was pretty much a prefect response to it. ! Seeing you so completely involved was all that was needed. Thanks for the Great reaction.
Earn this, earn it.
Speechlessness is a legit reaction.
For the longest time I thought he said "Ernest", like he was telling Matt his name.
@@Gundam944
I should tell you how i've desecrated some of rock's great lyrics over the years, growing up. This may be why God created subtitles.
@@Blue-qr7qe lol, I'd be lying to you if I said I haven't done the same thing .
@@Gundam944
It all began when i was listening to a song called Louie, Louie. 'Not my fault.
@@Gundam944 I thought Matt Damons character name was James.
Very good Reaction. We Vietnam Veterans, when we see this movie, react the same way you do. We feel it, and miss our brothers who didn't come back home with us. Thank you. I recall when I was 20, we would talk to the WWII Vets, and some of them had enlisted when they were 15 or 16 years old. My Boss, after I left the military, was 16 years old, and was a Marine on Iwo Jima and Okinawa. My God! The stories he told, made me feel lucky I didn't have to fight in that war. God Bless all of them.
"I was speechless." Yeah. This movie, and the story it tells us, does that.
'The Greatest Generation'
...and then some!
Cue the “Band of Brothers” HBO series.
Empire of The Sun is another classic Spielberg WWII movie
Please watch "Das Boot".
watch "come and see" or even the "liberation" 5 movie series
Madison, great review as always! You didn't have to say much.Your emotions spoke volumes to us! This story was about Europe. The movie, THE THIN RED LINE is about the war in the Pacific. It is worth viewing & reacting to. Thanks for all you do!
very recommended. a real gem. it set's a very different tone and is not so gory, but very powerful. i personally like it much more but they are not really comparable. anyway, as said, very recommended (gets way too little attention and reactions).
One of the better reactions I've seen from one of my very favorite reactors. I've long held that this movie and The Patriot should be required to be shown in our schools. May we remember why we're free instead of spittin on what was fought and died for.
SAVING PRIVATE RYAN should a required viewing for THANKSGIVING DAY because this movie will make you feel grateful for everything you have and it is also a fantastic movie too.
The BEST reaction to any movie you have ever given.... I hope your peers and contemporaries watch and understand your reaction to this movie and I hope they can understand that your silence and facial expressions speak so much more than you could ever have... the best reaction. Thank you!
This movie never fails to amaze me. I'm so glad that you were brave enough to watch it today Madison. It is always my hope that movies like this one will start people reading the history of WW2 so they can put the movie in a broader context, and understand our place in the world now as well.
And now it’s in worse shape than before with the sneaky attack on humanity using fear and mass compliance conditioning to accept whatever the government (any government) dictate on the once free people of the world.
Fun fact: Tom Hanks was nominated at the 1998 Golden Globes for this but lost out to Jim Carrey for Truman Show.
Which I’m glad to because Tom Hanks already won 2 Oscars before, it was time to recognize other talent for a change
THEE BEST WAR MOVIE...PERIOD.
I don't trust the humanity of anyone who is not moved by this movie... Spielberg and Hanks, after this movie was released, were instrumental in fundraising for the National WWII Memorial in Washington DC.
When Spielberg was having a private showing for the technical advisors and crew of this movie, before it's general release... Just a few minutes into the Normandy scene, he noticed there were some of the WWII veterans walking out. He stopped the film, and went to see why (the though they hated it). Here he found these old men, these veterans of Normandy, in their 80's at the time... breaking down crying in the lobby. It was almost 80 years ago, and for them, it was still just TOO real.
This isn't a movie - it's an experience.
Your comments were heartwarming.
Love your channel. Dang onions.
Watched this opening weekend on the largest screen we could find. Emotionally and physically draining experience.
the two German soldiers who they cant understand trying to surrender at the beginning and are shot are shouting "Please don’t shoot me! I am not German, I am Czech, I didn’t kill anyone! I am Czech!"
The two "surrendering" soldiers were shot because they were walking up toward the Americans. From the American soldiers' perspective, they could have booby traps.
“Hacksaw Ridge” and “We Were Soldiers”
One of the most powerful movies ever made. This movie makes me appreciate those that sacrificed and appreciate how valuable freedom is.
Appreciate your reaction. Don't worry about being silent, that spoke volumes. The survivors of the war went under 1m a cpl years ago. A tough war against tough opponents. Most kept silent about it, I always tried to get my dad to tell me stories about it but he would only tell me side issues.
Madison, I loved your reaction to this movie! I am a Veteran of Desert shield/Storm and I come from a family of servicemembers. My oldest uncle passed away a few years ago - he was at Pearl Harbor on 07 Dec 1941. He was awarded the Purple Heart and he never talked about what he witnessed that day, not even to other family members that served. He sometimes talked about the other campaigns he was in over in Europe, but never about Pearl Harbor.
Thank you to all veterans and to their families! 🙏
The part that never fails to bring tears to my eyes is when the older Ryan is talking to Capt. Miller graveside and then asking his wife if he led a good life.
And the wife was like "yeah you are... can we go shopping now please"
@@jackprescott9652 I laughed hard and sadly this is a modern day western cultural problem
"I'm not really good with gore" Oh boy.
Thanks for watching this with us.
God bless all of our veterans.
All gave some and some gave all so that we can sleep in our beds peacefully tonight
Definitely check out Band of Brothers, one of the best mini series ever.
This is such a hard film to watch, but it does one of the best cinematic jobs of helping us to understand the bravery and dedication of our forces in WW2.
Being speechless and somber is a perfect reaction to this movie. I've seen people be chatty all the way through and it's obvious that they're not getting it. They don't stop to appreciate what it was really like. You expressed the proper sentiment and admiration for the sacrifice so many made for our freedom. Thank you.
My father was in Patton's 3rd Army 42-45 (687th FAB).....He was 2nd wave Normandy beach . After losing a howitzer in the drink, his first duty was litter bearer. Picking up the human aftermath..... Then he was in the battle of the hedgerows, battle of the bulge, helped with the Bastogne rescue..... His last duty in Europe was helping with the cleanup of the Buchenwald camp.......He saw ALOT of death!!!!
That was a great reaction. Many don't realize that sometimes expressions alone can say more than words. Kudos to you for powering through this amazing movie especially having admitted that graphic war scenes aren't the easiest for you to endure.
After this Tom Hanks and Spielberg went on to collaborate on Band of Brothers, which, is at least as good, and maybe better in that it has more time to tell the story ... Even if you don't want to react to it, you should watch it.
Band of Brothers is far better and more real than this movie.
I very much look forward to your film Friday reactions Madison. Another classic Tom Hanks film that tears at your heart. Tom Hanks is truly a national treasure.
I highly recommend "DOWNFALL" from 2004.
Yes. Incredible film told from the 'other' side.
Thank you for your unspoken reaction. You expressed it magnificently through your eyes and facial expressions. Steven Spielberg's, Saving Private Ryan, change war movies forever. The gut-wrenching realism had never been displayed like this before.
That being said, both Spielberg and Tom Hanks were involved (producers and Hanks even directed an episode) of the much acclaimed, Band of Brothers. This was an HBO mini-series concerning Easy Company of the 101st airborne, and it won many awards. What sets this series apart is that the people depicted in this film were actually real people (unlike Saving Private Ryan). Before the start of each episode, we are introduced to different characters that survived the war. We don't actually know who is who until the last episode (although I got a couple of my guesses correct). It was an amazing achievement and will stay with you for the rest of your life. If you can, please review this magnificent mini-series.
6:13 The sad part is those two soldiers were trying to explain that they weren’t German but they were Chechen a lot of people who are in prison during the war within forced to fight for the axis powers it’s a shame
Upham was doing his part for the war effort quite well as a clerk, and I think Captain Miller made a mistake forcing him into a combat situation. In any case, the last thing Spielberg intended was for viewers to hate Upham as many do. He represents every soldier who might have lacked the courage to act at a key moment and was haunted by it for the rest of their lives.
He also represents human nature of freezing under extreme conditions. As well as a character changed by extreme conditions.
Many soldiers were just kids out of high-school. No matter what career each soldier has above all they are infantry and trained to fight. No one knows how they will act under fire. Upham represents people which freeze or even run.
Miller needed an interpreter and Upham spoke French and German. If Upham was not to blame, then neither was Capt. Miller.
@@davedalton1273 wrong, Upham was a soldier first. A linguist second.
He went through the same training as everyone else. Captain Miller needed a linguist and there weren't too many on the beaches of France. Being brave is continuing forward even when you're scared.
When you think you are ready for another war film, you should watch the true story "Hacksaw Ridge". Loved your reaction.
Great to see you react to this, Ms. Thames. Your reaction was totally understandable, because there simply are no words. Looking forward to your next vid.
The GOAT war movie. No doubt. It's perfect.
"Tell me I'm a good man..." Is on one of my favorite lines of all time that makes me cry every time too!
Glad you made it through this one!
Please, do NOT ever apologize for being silent! All that means is you are completely immersed in a movie, which is what all movie makers and fans dream of!!!
TBH, my favorite reactions are just like this one! Great job, including the editing!
Unfortunately, silent reactions can get taken down due to copyright, you're supposed to be constantly commenting on the film to follow copyright laws.
@@jkhoover I've seen plenty of reaction videos (that is mostly what I watch) where there isn't much commentary. I just watched a Blair Witch reaction where the guy only says 1 word here and there, and that is it. That leads me to believe it is more important on how much of the movie is shown and copyright laws.
@@anthonyzarate9807 Maybe. I'm not an expert. I'm just going off of what I've heard other reactors have said.
@@jkhoover I get it 👍, I'm no expert either
Great reaction! You should check out the companion piece to this (produced by Spielberg and Hanks), the HBO miniseries Band Of Brothers (which some call the greatest TV series of all time). It's actually closely based on real life soldiers of the 101st Airborne (not a made up story, like this film).
Most veterans that have seen this movie have said this is the most realistic war portrayal ever filmed.
Madison , thank you very much for this reaction! One of my favourite move & love your videos just keep it up and you are such a beautiful woman :)
Great reaction! I always comment this on SPR reactions: There was a Naval and aireal bombardment the day/night before the invasion, meant to soften defenses and to give the Rangers craters to take cover in. It ALL missed Omaha Beach because of fog. Because of that, the Rangers met the full force of Hitlers Atlantic Wall.
Not sure if you noticed, but that soldier Corporal Upham shot at the end was the one they released earlier in the movie.
I wasn't sure if she realize that or not. It wasn't clear if she did.
@@Falconer1128 yeah, I had to relisten to her comment but I couldn’t tell.
Omg I didn’t realize😨
@@MadisonKThames 👍
A lot of reactors mistake the German who stabbed Mellish as the one they let go because they do look similar. But they are two different actors.
Watched this movie several years ago with my WW2 vet grandfather who was at d-day and fought in Europe. He said that this was by far the most realistic depiction of what that day and the war was like that he'd ever seen. Many vets couldn't watch this movie cause they got ptsd due to the realism.
You were doing more than watching a movie, you were watching history. Everyone should go visit their grandfathers (In my case, my father), wherever they may be, and give them the thanks that they deserve. Tell them you love them! Tell them they were good men! Tell them they were the Greatest Generation!
Steven Spielberg and Tom Hanks created a miniseries called Band of Brothers back around the turn of the century. It's about the men of the 101st Airborne Division. The actual men, not fictitious characters, and their stories from training through the end of the war.
Absolutely incredible. AND there are some of the actual Airborne soldiers who parachuted in before D-Day talking about what it was like. I'd say you're pretty certain to cry at parts.
I was a Navy Corpsman, I served 10 years, 8 with Marines. I saw this on a Tuesday afternoon. There were 12 of us. Myself, and 11 others, all veterans. At the end of the movies, the house lights went up. All of us had teary eyes. One old man stated the following- "As far as war movies go, that was the most accurate depiction I've ever seen . As for the ACTUAL D-Day, it didn't come close"
His hat said it all- D-Day Survivor, Purple Heart. I have always deferred to his expert opinion. As bad as you think it was as shown in the movie, it was much, much worse.
WW2 veterans, which an uncle of mine was there, have said the beach landing was like being there, the most realistic depiction they'd seen.
Madison, your being quiet said volumes.
Tom Boyte.
GySgt. USMC, retired
Vietnam 1965-66/1970-71
Bronze Star, Purple Heart
I feel movies, big time (and this is one of many I feel), and I love watching reactors who really feel movies too. You feel them, that's why I really enjoy your reactions. Keep it up!
So glad I found you and this channel. You choose movies I love and your reactions are great. I'm subscribed and I will be watching. Keep up the great job you're doing.
Thanks, Jim!🙏
@@MadisonKThames Your more than welcome. I have one request and then I'll leave you alone! Please react to Forrest Gump, which along with Saving Private Ryan rounds up 2 of my top three movies of all time. I can almost assure you, that it will stay with you for a long, long time. Thanks again for the movies you choose and the reactions you give.
Tough movie to watch but one everyone should watch as an adult. Just incredible filmmaking my Spielberg and everyone else that worked on this movie.
“Close enough but not enough bodies “ was said to me by a DDAY veteran when I asked him about this film. He had some incredible stories!
This movie is so great! One of the best in my opinion, and also one of the saddest. That opening scene on the beach was the first war scene I ever watched, and I was only 12 years old. I was pretty shocked seeing it as a kid. And watching it today it’s super realistic and brutal, even for an adult. In fact the battle scenes are so realistic, that lots of WW2 veterans back in 1998 who watched the movie in theaters ended up needing therapy because it triggered their PTSD. Also if you’re wondering, 3,000 American soldiers lost their lives on Omaha beach back in 1944.
I know you "don't do well with gore", but that opening scene on the beach is widely acknowledged to be the most realistic depiction of war ever filmed. Veterans who survived that have said that Spielberg captured it down to the little details (like Hanks going deaf briefly at the very beginning). Every time I see the scene, it amazes me how visceral it is. The horror of war really hits home.
Mrs. Ryan has four blue stars in her window, one for each son. When a soldier was killed in action, the blue star turned to gold.
This movie is a thorough masterpiece, I don't know how many times I've seen it and I still feel everything. Your speechlessness is right on.
I have to say though, in a tapestry of perfect film production; for me it's always been the sound department that shines the brightest. From that first moment the door goes down on the beach, to the last scene in the graveyard, the sound production is unbelievable. It draws you right in and makes you feel like you're there.
Great reaction, thanks.
Wow Madison that was a fantastic reaction & summary of your thoughts.
The "I was with the only brothers I have left" line by Damon, man that was amazing. I also felt so attached to the characters that seeing them die was emotional. Really exemplifies what war is.
THE FIRST 15 MIN OF THIS FILM LEAVES EVERYONE SPEECHLESS. JUST IMAGINE YOU WERE ONE OF THOSE MEN WHO WERE THERE.
I WISH YOU GOOD FORTUNE IN THE WARS TO COME MY SWEET.
You are marvelous, Madison. You don't have to justify anything. War should turn our stomachs, & affect us very deeply. One day, there will be no more war, and we will learn how to live in peace with everyone. Thank you for all you do! 😊😊😊
Madison I love your channel. Please keep up the good work.
My grandfather served in WWII, some who watched this that served had to leave they said they smelled the diesel and gunpowder while watching!! They sacrificed for our freedoms always remember!!!
Great reaction Madison! In this war there was a proposal (The Sullivan Act) that I don't think got through into a law but the spirit of it did. The Act was made to ensure no family members were in the same battle group so that an entire family wouldn't be lost together. That is why his brothers were in so many different areas of the war. Your silence was an excellent reaction young lady, it showed how much you were in the movie.
I don't know about an Act of Congress, but, it definitely became a Navy Regulation... Family members cannot serve aboard the same ship, at least.
@@paulfeist You are so correct sir. I think there was something, but it never went anywhere but the Navy for sure adopted it. There is even a movie about it called "The Fighting Sullivans". Thanks for the great reply.
@@Flastew they also named a ship The Sullivans
@@GeorgeTropicana Cool, thanks for the information I didn't know that.
This film is mostly inspired by the story of the Niland Brothers. One brother was shot down in Borneo (presumed dead, but later freed from a Japanese POW camp) in May 1944. One brother, a paratrooper, was killed in the Normandy invasion on June 6th, 1944. The third brother, regular Army infantry, was killed in Normandy on June 7th, 1944. The youngest, paratrooper Frederick Niland, learned of his brothers' fates a couple days later when he tried to visit his brother who was also a paratrooper. He was evacuated back to America without incident.
Elsewhere, the five Sullivan brothers were all killed in the sinking of the USS Juneau in November 1942. They had enlisted with the stipulation that they serve together. The four Borgstrom brothers were all killed between March and August1944 in various theaters. These losses led to the military adopting the Sole Survivor policy.
Says so much about this film that you're speechless for much of it. Appreciate the reaction!
Perfect reaction. Sometimes words don't need to be spoken to get your message out
My dad fought in WW2 in the Scottish black watch regiment and went through hell, even losing his left foot to a German stick grenade. Even he said that the Americans got the worst hammering at Omaha beach. Everything that could have gone wrong did go wrong, but they did a great job. ✌️♥️🇬🇧
1. Many WWII vets left the theaters because the D-Day battle scenes were so realistic.
2. Those communications devices are UHF transvers.
3. The story Ryan tells the Captain is made up. The director told him just to say something that might work. (ugly tree)
4. The German Captain Miller was talked into letting go is the same one that killed him. Upham finally killed him.
I also thought the stabber was the same guy but he wasn't. They just look similar. (Super race and all that)
5. There really was a USS Sullivan's named for the brothers who all died after their ship was hit by Japanese submarine.
Love to watch your reaction to movies I love, loved this one just as much as the others. Had you been a chatterbox throughout I wouldn't have as much, it is absolutely normal to be in awe from beginning to end, it is that powerful of a movie. Glad you saw it, made me realize why some men don't talk about their time in the military, those of us who haven't been there can't really relate with what they've been through so I respect that and let them be no questions asked.
You did very good, Madison. Great reaction. It did feel real. I saw it on the big screen and I was speechless too. When I came out, I broke down. My Grandfather was on the beaches in Normandy and in the hospital in London during the Blitzkrieg and my Dad was drafted into Viet Nam. Both of them lived through it and we're able to come home to Thier families. I am so thankful for that.
They don't call these men "The Greatest Generation" for nothing.
I had just turned 17 that summer when SPR came out & it was the catalyst that fueled my passion (some would say obsession) of WWII history. I was young & eager to absorb the topic & I couldn’t get my hands on enough literature, more particularly the literature written by those who lived it. Then came the curios & relics of WWII weaponry collecting. It’s just wild to think about how this movie shaped so many aspects of my adult life, from hobbies or places I’ve traveled to see & the people I’ve meet just blows me away sometimes. It’s no surprise your video quickly appeared to me considering the topic. I enjoyed seeing your experience in this video..
I'm about 5ish years younger than you but this movie had the same affect on me.
"Earn this." Was not a message to Ryan. It was a message to us all.
Just found your site and just LOVE your reviews!!
The brief reference to the Sullivan brothers was about the five Sullivan brothers who were killed on the same ship. There was a movie based on them called The Fighting Sullivans. The actor who played their father was Scarlett's father in Gone With The Wind.
A neato factoid. Many ww2 vets were still around when this came out and many had freakout flashbacks when going to this movie back when it was in theaters. It wasn't just a few, it was all across the nation. That lends credence to its realism and production value.
I had played call of duty before it hit consoles on pc and the 1st game did the Normandy storming of the beach and it was as close to the real historical record you could get. Then this movie came out and blew what any videogame was capable of even to this day.
This is the sad truth of war, Madison, only for real. This film does show some of the horrors of war and what those who served went through during that time, and what countless others will go through in the future.
Incredible film. Only movie Spielberg has shot without storyboards. I saw this at the Leicester Square Odeon London on opening night. That opening was truly shell shocking. I particularly remember the sound zipping around with auditorium heads weaving left and right. A both thrilling and humbling experience. If I was to criticise the movie then like most of Spielberg's works it's a bit over-sentimental, but the swine does know how to push buttons. No matter how many times I've seen this the mother taking that one wobbly step back before collapsing on the porch, damn I choke up.
This, Band of Brothers and Schindler's List should be required viewing for all, sometimes we need reminders.
this is a very propagandist movie. it is not "reminding", it is telling lies.
He shot Schindler's List without storyboards.
Such a brutal movie to watch. Thank you again for the review. Just realized it was so hard to watch these kids die that i have never been able to watch the whole movie through to the end in one sitting.
"Amistad" & "Schindlers List". Two other masterpieces by Spielberg.
It's movies like this that show what literally millions of men (and now men & women) went through, not just in that war but every war from 1775 right up to Afghanistan & Iraq, and how they fought to protect us and our flag that really makes not just my but millions of other American's blood boil when we see multi millionaire ball players protesting the American flag. BTW the cemetery from the very beginning & end is the Normandy American Cemetery and Memorial. It's located in Colleville-sur-Mer, in Normandy France, not far from where those guys landed at the beginning in June 1944. It's a real place.
One other thing. The Germans they were fighting were the same exact age as the guys landing on the beach. They were just as scared shitless, and just as afraid of dying. But also like the guys landing in front of them they loved their country just as much as the Americans, British & Canadians landing. I say this because l really love history and want ppl to see it without putting politics into everything. Not every (WW2) German soldier was a Nazi anymore than every American is a Democrat or Republican. And they had a job to do. Doesn't mean l wish them well or root for them-cause l don't. Just saying it's not like they wanted to be there anymore then our guys did.
And your silence said more than you voice ever could. Your reaction was exactly what it should have been.
Good review.
The was the best reaction. You said everything in your emotions.
I don’t blame Upham. He’s the most human out of all of them. Only had basic training but isn’t enough to cope up the true nature of war. He said he only fired a weapon in basic training never in a real combat situation. He’s there as a translator only. He’s trying not be someone he isn’t. He’s no soldier. He’s nothing like anyone in the squad. That’s why we’re born different. Every one of us is special because no one is like anyone else. Not everyone asked to be hero yet we are. Upham didn’t asked to be a soldier & yet he did after learning the lesson the hard way. Both aspects of an individual are seen clearly when payed close attention to & not distracted by whatever which is common for many to misunderstood only to be quick to judge.
One could say, are or were you soldier? Did you ever take a life? Where & how many battles did you partake in? How many different facial expressions have you seen before, during & after the battle? Do you see their eyes or gestures that showcases defiance, hate, scared, innocent? Could you still be the same person you were before that you are now after going through all that? We all have different reactions to war. Same could be said when taking a vaccine. Your friend got a headache after taking it while you didn’t experience any side effects. Choices have consequences & no one is free or above that regardless.
Furthermore, rules of engagement for soldiers are as follows especially for Officers. POW (Prisoner of War) is part especially if the enemy surrenders. Others don’t give a crap cuz they murdered their friends, relatives, brothers, etc. in combat. Then again we have these rules of engagement for a reason but at the same time it’s questionable. The idea is to keep it professional & humane as possible to maintain as a “civilized being”.
Loved your reaction to this masterpiece.
Winner of 5 Oscars
Best Director
Best Sound Editing
Best Sound Mixing
Best Film Editing
Best Cinematography
I still maintain, they were robbed.... It SHOULD have gotten Best Picture.
They were farm boys and cab drivers, ranchers and oil rig workers, fishermen and school teachers. They came from small hamlets and big cities, and everywhere in between. They answered their nation's call, prepared to defend their homeland, and with it everyone they had ever loved, with their lives if necessary. Boys who had learned to drive on a farm tractor and had never seen a vehicle larger than the family flatbed were trained in record time to operate the machinery of war, each piece worth many times over the price of the family farm. They left sleepy lives, ordinary, predictable, even boring, and were swept as if by an arm of a great giant into a maelstrom of noise and blood and suffering and death. They came from lives where they had never heard a shot fired in anger, and became part of the deadliest fighting force and killing machine ever fielded by the hubris of man. Because they weren't just killing to follow orders. They were killing, and dying, to protect their country, the very lives of their families. And when it was over, the ones who survived came back home, changed forever, yet tight-lipped for the most part about the whole affair. "I'm not proud of what I done over there," one might say, eyes downcast, "We did what we had to." And then the incredulous family member who heard these words, would find a medal or read a letter of commendation or be present at a ceremony, and learn of deeds done by their quiet brother or uncle or father, deeds that would cause the family member's heart to swell with pride, and also give them nightmares for weeks. Acts of heroism, self-sacrifice, bravery, and sheer nerve, would cause them to look at their loved one with awe and a fresh respect. And invariably, such reactions would be met by a quietly-delivered, "Don't go on so about it. Any one of us would have done the same." And then he would get up, walk outside and feed the horse, or get back into his taxi or go teach his 5th-period class. Just like before. Only... not....
Heroes, all. The contrasts they saw within the space of one lifetime defied imagination.
The Greatest Generation, indeed.
The landing scene was as realistic as you could get. The D-Day veterans that were shown a screening said the only thing missing was the smell.
The opening beach scene was filmed about 7 km from my house. Spielberg was told to return the beach to it's original condition after filming. Because of this a lot of people walking the beach today have no idea that scene was filmed there.
Great reaction Madison. Those opening minutes of the movie are tough.
That mother ... collapsing. The most heartrenching scene in this film.
I've seen a lot of war movies. Saw this is 1998 and watched a lot of guys walk out of the theater and honest - I can't think of a movie that had the shock factor this had - the violence in that opening scene was so far ahead of its time. Band of Brothers was like five years later and no one's even been in its zip code for like another 15 years. It was wild, man.
The 2 soldiers trying to surrender were actually from other parts of occupied Europe, that the Nazis forced to fight on the front lines (in effect, they were basically slaves).