They actually put a tractor transmission in one of the cars at the drive-backwards-fast-chase scene. You can see that actor(never watched the movies) put 2 levers in gear before they start driving the other direction.
@@RichardBetel An 18-speed has 3 slots to move the shifter in, and they use air for some of the shifts. A Spicer 6x4 has a 6-speed driving a 4-speed auxillary transmission, and the gear pattern is unusual.
Almost all truck gearboxes like that have a normal 6 slot h pattern design and the extra gears come from a rangebox and splitter which are like 2 speed gearboxes attached to the end of the regular box
Multiplier gear boxes are quite common in manual tractors. A lot of the one's built around and after the 2000's for example use a 24/24 6 speed with either 4 groups, or 4 intermediate gear that can be changed without clutching. Some 80's/90's Renault tractors also have a third optional box to make them a 24/24 from a 12/12. This was done by adding a two speed intermediate box to the already existing 3 Groups +4 Gears and Reverser box.
@@XMaster340 Porsche didn't really build tractors for that long though, and the production was sold to MAN, but they stopped a few years after that as well.
@@jeremygalloway1348 they made tractors till 2003 when Claas bought out Renault Agriculture, but still made some Renault models till 09, mainly the Celtis. And to add to XMasters comment, Lamborghini also started out by making tractors, mainly out of WWII surpluses, they only started cars when the Mr. Lamborghini wanted a original Ferrari part for his Ferrari, and even went to Mr. Ferrari, but he said to Mr. Lamborghini something along the lines of 'you're just a tractor builder' or similar, but definitely nothing nice. So Mr. Lamborghini wanted to show Mr. Ferrari that he can do more. Now days Lamborghini cars are well now high quality, while Lamborghini Tractors has been part of Same for a long time now, and SDF ever since Same bought Deutz Fahr, with Deutz being the primary brand, and Lamborghini just being the lesser known cheaper option. Comparable to Audi and VW, just that DF is Audi and Lambo VW, just lesser known.
I have experience with 3d printing and mechanics myself and let me tell you, this man has to be part insane to have the dedication to design such a complex print. Hats off to you!
I have rebuilt transmissions from big trucks. It’s not as hard to imagine the building process as it’s all simply gears. To get the different ranges, one can simply add reducers and multipliers to a section behind the main gear set. The final drive is important here, as it needs to be matched with the horsepower going through the input shaft. The torque is managed by how robust the gears and shafts are, so little beyond making them hardy enough to stand the maximum torque is the simple part. Trading speed for the torque is the big trick, because the needed horsepower can be easily overwhelmed by just having too much at the final drive for the engine to keep moving!
Just gotta remember the equations and remember which gear is which though it does help that they'll all splice to together. Gotta love that diesel program in tech schools.
5:34 your solution is to print the pieces separately, not as one piece, then attach them during the build because very little stress will be applied to their junction point.
And screw them together. And I hope that Micro Center will sell housings for partially 3-d printed toroidal torque converters, which I hope can use thermometer alcohol as transmission fluid so that the heat can get squeezed out in a skinny pipe in front of and above the engine! But with a bike you need to use pipes connected together by rubber tubes held together by woven metal if rubber is insulating. P.S. The One Piece is real!?!
Depending on how strong it needs to be and how importand the asthetics are you could also lay it on the largest of the suggestet gray blobs. Then it is at an odd angle and you need some support but not that much and it is a lot stronger than the vertical solutions.
I am so fricken glad someone else noticed that 🤣🤣 I heard that and immediately ran to the comments I don't think I've ever heard more than those first couple lines of the song tho 😅
Essentially, if you put power to the other end (your current 'output' shaft), you've created a compound truck transmission.. similar to a Fuller/Eaton RoadRanger. They generally just have a low and a high set for the multiplier, and then 5 ratios behind that, in the case of the 10 speed. You basically run through the 5 gears in the low range and then pop the button up to shift to the high range, and row though the 5 ratios again until you reach the 1:1 ratio on the output. Pretty interesting experiment! A bit lighter than the typical 1000 lbs. or so for an actual compound transmission!😂
Hey look at that you made a twin stick transmission. Some truck drivers love that type of gear box. I don’t think I ever keep track of where I’m at, but did you know that there is triple stick. I guarantee that trans is blowing up on my first trip.
You forgot to mention the fact you've effectively duplicated many of the ratios, and that the ideal shift pattern wouldn't be 1 through 12 on 1x, 1 through 12 on 2 x, 1 through 12 on 3x, etc ect, but rather you may have alternate between shifting front and rear to hit all possible ratios in the correct order. But as I mentioned there is significant overlap, so they may be much fewer than 40 unique ratios. At the very least the 1:1 and 2:1 gears in the 12 speed will be duplicated by each successive gear in the 5x multiplier , IE, 2:1 in the 12 speed on the 1x will be the same as 1:1 in the 12 speed on the 2x...
He said the last gear of the first gearbox almost reaches 2:1, so its strictly less and the first 12 ratios are unique in the Interval [1,2). Therefore after multiplying with 2^n for the big ratios you'll always end up in the [2^(n-1), 2^n) Intervall for n \in {1,...,5}. Therefore each of the 60 total gear ratios is unique and increasing exactly in the order you described (1,1), ..., (1,12), (2,1), ..., (2,12), ..., (5,1), ..., (5,12).
@@mauricereichert2804 and this is how we get "honest" marketing claims that leave customers upset. You're completely accurate technically. But it isn't going to really deliver on the claim. The range is going to overlap sufficiently enough that it may as well not exist.
@@richardbrooksshnee The ranges aren't overlapping at all. The only interesting thing is how close is almost 2:1 to real 2:1 and how are the steps seperated. If he choose the teeth count ratio such that it approximate 2^((m-1)/12) for m \in {1,...,12} in a good rational way (e.g. exactly like a western piano 7 white + 5 black =12 tone steps), it's gonna feel very natural and every single gear shift will increase about the same factor and maybe even sound harmonically. :D
@@mauricereichert2804 yes they are. The operator would be skipping that last gear as x~2 and x2 are close enough to the same that any rpm differences would be negligible from their standpoint and so there is no worthwhile reason for the overlap. You're going to shift to x2. You're ignoring the point and purpose of a gear box. Effectively the same is wasted and is an overlap in range. Damn near the same output to engine rpm & torque. Your "but the numbers are slightly different" is obnoxiously pedantic to the point of counterproductivity and ignorant to the point of a drive train. You can cry technically right all you want. You're effectively wrong.
Hey, you do also technically have CVT gearboxes, they are generally not used in manual gearboxes because it makes no sence too, but some automatics use them, and they have a "infinit" amount of gear ratios between Min and Max :) I think it would be really cool to see you try to make a manual CVT gearbox!
@@dawsonramdass1145 Take a look at the belt drive section from a 2J-type Bridgeport milling machine. It's literally a manual CVT. There's a little crank you turn to adjust the pulley diameters, and it takes your single speed motor and turns it into 500-4200 RPM if you're in hi-range and 50-500-ish in lo-range. There's plenty of good drawings and such available to see how it works.
I`ve got manual CVT transmition In Chinees drill press. And it`s really just level + and - , which you move to adjust speed. Level just shift one of cone, and another holding by spring
Incredible Job! Steven, the transmission is so mind blowing to see it in action you did a great job designing how the first transmission gear set continues in to the multiplier gear set your best video yet Great job happy holidays Steven.
the rod goes into the square hole btw cool build lego actually used a "gear multiplier" to make the gearbox in the 911 gt3 rs, chiron, sian fkp and also the daytona sp3 its a 4 speed sequential with a 2x multiplier attached to it, so it can get 8 speeds, in a pretty small package
I have considered joining two motorcycle engines together to make two fours into one straight eight, leaving their two transmissions separated. Each transmission would backdrive a different side of a differential, with the resulting output from the ring gear driving the rear tire. Gear ratios from the two transmissions would be averaged by the differential, giving 9 useful ratios out from the two five speed transmissions, or 11 useful ratios from two six speeds. Can you play with that?
They already do this with Hayabusa engines. Look up amateur F1 Radical cars. Very common in that field. But still VERU COOL. My brother-in-laws are mechanics for these types of race cars.
Those "couplers" you speak of are otherwise known as a synchromesh, they are tapered inside to allow for gears and shafts turning at different speeds, to engage. It gradually brings the layshaft and input shaft up to speed, or synchronization.
@@pytbob Yep, those are the "dogs". I thoroughly enjoyed the vid, but it would have added to the learning if he used the real terms such as the shifter forks, dog toother gears etc. Many would have an "ah-ha!" moment when they read about dogbox gearboxes.
@@amorag59 so many nuances in transmissions and I'm far from an expert... I do know that dogs refer to teeth on the face rather than the periphery of a gear. They were used as the step between sliding mesh and synchros
Maybe you said this in the video and I missed it, but this is very similar to how its done in bikes. Two different sets of gears that can be changed that allow for way more speeds than one set
I feel like another example of this gearbox + multiplier system that people may be more familiar with is on bicycles. The right shifter is your transmission and the left shifter (front sprocket) is your multiplier. So if this engine transmission is still hard to understand, look at your bicycle and apply the same lessons learned in this video!
If you do it really smarty, the compound gearbox can share the intermediate axle removing 1/4 of all the sprockets and also making it a lot more compact.
The correct terms you're probably looking for is main gearbox and auxiliary gearbox; in your instance you have a 12 speed main box with a 5 speed auxiliary. Semis use an 18 speed which is a 4 speed w/ L main box with a 4 speed auxiliary
Where layer lines create weakness or the need for supports, split the model so you can print all of it flat but with a designed connection that will take a screw or with an effective glue area.
another suggestion for strength you could have added a couple mill sized fillet at the 90 degree angle of the shifting linkages to distribute stress to avoid a break.
I would love to see someone make a gearbox that reverses ratios halfway through, so the outside gears are both spinning really fast and the middle gear is spinning really slow.
Reverse input to make it a 56 speed reduction box. Old Semi-Trucks used twin box setups with two 4 speed or a 4 and 5 speed combo. Yes I know there are 60 combinations but 4 are the same ratio.
@5:41 I would print a part like that in two pieces and join them after. Also I've seen people have success restarting a print when it's run out of filament etc. I wonder if you could lay a flat part down and get layers to stick to it. Maybe start at high temperature to help it stick and have an enclosed print bed kept at high temperature. Maybe I'm an idiot.
If you really break it down, how many unique ratios does it actually have? 1:1 times 4 would be the same as 1:2 times 2, and I can imagine there are more overlapping ratios.
I'd like to know the amount of torque required for each of the different gears and how the multipliers affect the amount of torque to spin each of the different gears
you can always some how mesh the corners of the arm linkages. that way you can print both sides laying down, without supports. all u would need to do is bolt them together, or have a dove tail or something.
There are trucks with twin transmissions. When people drove those trucks they would call a twin sticking lol. But it was essentially companies just sticking two of their transmissions together so the combinations of gears was pretty much random and very disorganized. It would take a lot of memorization to properly drive these transmissions. Honestly an impressive feat. Then there are brownie boxes. Which is pretty much what you built you have a standard transmission with a three or four-speed brownie box that gives you three or four different ranges for your transmission. They are the precursor to the modern load rangers.
I own a 1953 Packard with a 3-on the tree plus a Borg-Warner Overdrive that kicks in above ~25-30 mph. It's very interesting to drive as you go 1st, 2nd, 3rd, Engage overdrive, back down to 2nd (4th) and then back up to 3rd (5th) if you're doing a full gear run. It's not quite as extreme as a twinstick, but it was certainly a bit of a learning curve.
Most modern semi transmissions are still 2 transmissions, they just share one case and one "stick". Depending on what transmission you have, it can be a 5+4 with low range on the bottom is a 9 speed. A 5+5 is a straight 10. A 5 speed with a splitter is a super 10. You take a 5+4 and add a splitter to the top 4 speed and you get a 13 speed. 5+5 with a splitter on both the bottom and top 4 is a 18 speed. Plus a whole lot more different combos.
@@dammityoutube your transmission math is a little wrong, the transmissions would be 5+2 for super and regular 10, 5+2+(2(high range only)) for 13, and 5+2+2(not limited) for 18, Yes, I know the numbers don't add up to the actual gear counts, its because of how they label and layout the patterns. 13 and 18 have the same pattern with the difference being the splitter useable in low range, the "missing" 2 gears in a 18 are in the "low" position ( 13 has low (low range)/ high low low - high high low (high range w/ splitter), 18 has the low range split as well. Most drivers only use the "lo" position in the lowest and highest possible ratios (if at all, those gears are extremely low) because the other ratios are barely different, the usual shift method is to go sequential and not use the splitter unless you need to, the splitter basically does 1X/1.5X with X being the gear (1,2,3 ...16,7, etc). 10s will get you there, 13s are better, and 18s are the best. The reason is because every incline has a gear ratio that maximizes speed for current situation (your weight, your engine, % grade, etc) and an 18 has the best chance of getting you as close as possible to it without going "over".
If you actually make it solid the part will become even more rigid. Sure, it will have less of a chance of breaking but actually fitting the piece will probably become impossible.
Change the input to be the shaft going Into your mega multi box and the output on the other end and your 32:1-1:1 twin stick transmission Is very similar to what a twin stick semi trucks transmission used to be like. Insane torque!
Hey hey hey, ADD SPRINGS TO HOLD THE ARMS FROM MOVING LEFT AND RIGHT, so the ideas is to put a spring that can hold the arm in the middle so they dont accidentally engage wile your in a different step, and then the sring can flex inwords, or be flexed outword.
most gear boxes dont increase speed until the highest gear(s). for example, the standard 5 speed transmissions gear significantly down from gears 1-3, 4th gear is direct drive, and fifth gear is slightly over driven. most transfer cases gear down even more, and the diff gears down for the final drive ratio. most cars engines are spinning roughly 3 times faster than the axle in the highest gear. a better design for this is to either flip the input and output so you're always gearing down, or make the 1:1 gear either 6 or 7 and up or down from there, including the multipliers, which to eliminate doubling gear ratios, should be a 5 speed with 1:4.05, 1:2.05. 1:1, 2.05:1, and 4.05:1 or something similar. that way, gear 30 is 1:1 approximately, and every other gear is higher or lower than the input.
Racheting cvt. it's a lot smaller and solves the tourqe slipping problem with normal cvt's. You just need like 8 different transmissions side by side to smooth out the bumpy output it's going to be bumpy under load maybe better for electric generators and use the electric power to run a electric motor for a more comfortable ride.
There’s a reason large gear boxes with many speeds use “ranges” in essence a second gearbox that shifts the entire range of the second gear box It’s just more efficient
Future reference older trucks or twin stick trucks would have a 18 speed trans or whatever and a 4 speed spicer so every gear you can break further down using the spicer 4 times so say you had an 18 speed that would be 72 gears if you split every gear into four but the secondary is called a spicer
But how do you do reverse? Car gearboxes have a reverse option so how do you make that? Also it would be nice to see a video of you putting a gearbox like this (but maybe not this many speed options) in a 3D printed car and use a electric motor to power the input shaft. It would be fun to see how it works while moving around.
My modded ender 3 v2 produces incredible layer adhesion. I use a high performance fan shroud, titanium heatbrake, copper heatblock and nozzle, dual z, and geared extruder direct drive.
Thats basically a semi transmission. Back in the 70s and 80s their were trucks with two shifters. A 5 speed and a 4 speed. Now days a really common one is a 5 speed with a pnumaticaly shifted 2 speed behind it. The second trans is usually called the auxillary.
Put a 2 speed rear end and you got yourself 120 gears. Had 4x4 and 4x5 two stick simi trucks, later on guys would put the auxiliary box on their 18 speed which was AWESOME, and questionably useful after weight and overlapping ratios taken in to account.
@@TheSilverShadow17 so many gears were over lapping you’d probably change .0001 ratio on more than half if you tried sequential shifting lol. The 4 gear second shifter would be more of a final gear choice and often times a difficult one to shift on the move so if you were empty you take high gear, fully loaded uphill low gear and then shift accordingly on the main.
Person who worked with machinists here: when you have parts that are oddly shaped, like the shifters, try printing two parts with design for a small screw. More work, but stronger part, and less time consuming during print. If its non-structural, then it doesnt matter, but for items like this, it would help save time.
Bicycles could have 12 speeds on single chainring and up to 21 speeds on triple charging (speeds "repeats" on gearing with more one chainring), so it's not that uncommon to have more than 7 speeds on bicycles This was with a derailleur, inner hubs (that uses planetary gears) can only get up to 8 speeds so far
Are you sure this is 60 different speeds, gear 12 has a 1:2 ratio with a 1x multiplier (1:2 overall). Gear 13 goes back to 1:1 ratio in main box but then uses the x2 multiplier gear which would also make it 1:2 overall. This means that every time you go to a different multiplier and back to gear 1 in the main box, the gear ratio is the same. Another example is with 24th and 25th gear, 24th gear uses 1:2 in the main box and a 2x multiplier in the second box (1:4 overall). 25th gear goes back to a 1:1 on main box but a 4x on the secondary box which will result in the same ratio (1:4 overall). This can also be seen with gear 36 and 37, gear 36 is 1:2 in main box, and 4x multiplier in second box (8:1 overall) and gear 37 uses the 8x multiplier and the 1:1 in the main box (1:8 overall). Otherwise it's very impressive how you got so many gears in such a small package.
So this is what the transmissions in the Fast and Furious movies look like.
Lol
They actually put a tractor transmission in one of the cars at the drive-backwards-fast-chase scene. You can see that actor(never watched the movies) put 2 levers in gear before they start driving the other direction.
FR
@@an2thea514 which
Superb
i cant stop hearing "thats right, it goes into the square hole"
Giggity
istg this is real asf
a lot of trucks have 24 speed manual transmissions so its amazing to think something like this exists in several real life applications
That's if you have a Spicer 6x4 transmission. Modern trucks use 18-speed manuals.
@@ColtonRMagby How are the gears arranged? It is an "H-pattern" 9 gears wide?
@@RichardBetel An 18-speed has 3 slots to move the shifter in, and they use air for some of the shifts. A Spicer 6x4 has a 6-speed driving a 4-speed auxillary transmission, and the gear pattern is unusual.
Almost all truck gearboxes like that have a normal 6 slot h pattern design and the extra gears come from a rangebox and splitter which are like 2 speed gearboxes attached to the end of the regular box
@@notanengineer I count every pair of gears as 1 slot because you're moving in a straight line between them.
Multiplier gear boxes are quite common in manual tractors. A lot of the one's built around and after the 2000's for example use a 24/24 6 speed with either 4 groups, or 4 intermediate gear that can be changed without clutching.
Some 80's/90's Renault tractors also have a third optional box to make them a 24/24 from a 12/12. This was done by adding a two speed intermediate box to the already existing 3 Groups +4 Gears and Reverser box.
Never knew Renault made tractors lol. Learn something new every day
@@jeremygalloway1348 Then let me tell you about the amazing beginnings of Porsche and Ferrari 😁
@@XMaster340 Porsche didn't really build tractors for that long though, and the production was sold to MAN, but they stopped a few years after that as well.
@@jeremygalloway1348 they made tractors till 2003 when Claas bought out Renault Agriculture, but still made some Renault models till 09, mainly the Celtis.
And to add to XMasters comment, Lamborghini also started out by making tractors, mainly out of WWII surpluses, they only started cars when the Mr. Lamborghini wanted a original Ferrari part for his Ferrari, and even went to Mr. Ferrari, but he said to Mr. Lamborghini something along the lines of 'you're just a tractor builder' or similar, but definitely nothing nice.
So Mr. Lamborghini wanted to show Mr. Ferrari that he can do more.
Now days Lamborghini cars are well now high quality, while Lamborghini Tractors has been part of Same for a long time now, and SDF ever since Same bought Deutz Fahr, with Deutz being the primary brand, and Lamborghini just being the lesser known cheaper option.
Comparable to Audi and VW, just that DF is Audi and Lambo VW, just lesser known.
@@Renault_75-34MX
I like the renault tracktor ylu have as a profile picture
I have experience with 3d printing and mechanics myself and let me tell you, this man has to be part insane to have the dedication to design such a complex print. Hats off to you!
I think it's funny that those same weaknesses in 3-D printing also applies to the direction of the grain in Wood projects.
I have rebuilt transmissions from big trucks.
It’s not as hard to imagine the building process as it’s all simply gears.
To get the different ranges, one can simply add reducers and multipliers to a section behind the main gear set.
The final drive is important here, as it needs to be matched with the horsepower going through the input shaft.
The torque is managed by how robust the gears and shafts are, so little beyond making them hardy enough to stand the maximum torque is the simple part.
Trading speed for the torque is the big trick, because the needed horsepower can be easily overwhelmed by just having too much at the final drive for the engine to keep moving!
Just gotta remember the equations and remember which gear is which though it does help that they'll all splice to together. Gotta love that diesel program in tech schools.
5:34 your solution is to print the pieces separately, not as one piece, then attach them during the build because very little stress will be applied to their junction point.
And screw them together. And I hope that Micro Center will sell housings for partially 3-d printed toroidal torque converters, which I hope can use thermometer alcohol as transmission fluid so that the heat can get squeezed out in a skinny pipe in front of and above the engine! But with a bike you need to use pipes connected together by rubber tubes held together by woven metal if rubber is insulating. P.S. The One Piece is real!?!
Depending on how strong it needs to be and how importand the asthetics are you could also lay it on the largest of the suggestet gray blobs. Then it is at an odd angle and you need some support but not that much and it is a lot stronger than the vertical solutions.
@@TheAnonymmynona whoa, cool idea
@@TheAnonymmynona The One Piece is real!
Since they're being glued together, incorporating a tab and socket system into the print would assist as well.
Can you imagine being in 60th and having to stop at stop sign
All you gotta do is put the thing in neutral, like a normal manual transmission
That's what brakes are for.
@@EarlJohn61As well as putting the gearbox into a lower gear so that you don't stall.
4:41 all of a sudden those gears start comparing me to Huh Duh Six Hungeo's by ol' mate Senny
I am so fricken glad someone else noticed that 🤣🤣 I heard that and immediately ran to the comments I don't think I've ever heard more than those first couple lines of the song tho 😅
Essentially, if you put power to the other end (your current 'output' shaft), you've created a compound truck transmission.. similar to a Fuller/Eaton RoadRanger. They generally just have a low and a high set for the multiplier, and then 5 ratios behind that, in the case of the 10 speed. You basically run through the 5 gears in the low range and then pop the button up to shift to the high range, and row though the 5 ratios again until you reach the 1:1 ratio on the output. Pretty interesting experiment! A bit lighter than the typical 1000 lbs. or so for an actual compound transmission!😂
0:45 thats right it goes in the square hole😂
I hope this never dies
Where does the triangle go, In ThE sQuArE HoLe
That’s right. It goes in the square hole
@@Agentekd WhErE dOeS tHe SeMi-CiRcLe Go
@@That-rat-bastardsit goes in the square hole
checkmate. You have 56 speeds since gear ratios 2, 4, 8, and 16 are repeated. Great work though!
Yeah, but it’s the same principle as shifting on a bike. If you have 3 in the front and 7 in the back, it’s still a 21 speed
He said “almost 2” for the small gears.
12 gears in the first gearbox, 5 gears in the 2nd powered by the 1st box.
12 × 5 = 60
Hey look at that you made a twin stick transmission. Some truck drivers love that type of gear box. I don’t think I ever keep track of where I’m at, but did you know that there is triple stick. I guarantee that trans is blowing up on my first trip.
Honesty is a virtue lol
Honestly. I love the way you teach things with the 3D printing! Inspiring to say the least.
Fast and furious gearboxes be like
Indeed
To put it in to better terms you have a main and a auxiliary transmission commonly found in older semi trucks
Those same weaknesses of 3-D printing also applies to the direction of the grain in Wood projects.
You forgot to mention the fact you've effectively duplicated many of the ratios, and that the ideal shift pattern wouldn't be 1 through 12 on 1x, 1 through 12 on 2 x, 1 through 12 on 3x, etc ect, but rather you may have alternate between shifting front and rear to hit all possible ratios in the correct order. But as I mentioned there is significant overlap, so they may be much fewer than 40 unique ratios. At the very least the 1:1 and 2:1 gears in the 12 speed will be duplicated by each successive gear in the 5x multiplier , IE, 2:1 in the 12 speed on the 1x will be the same as 1:1 in the 12 speed on the 2x...
was about to say the same
He said the last gear of the first gearbox almost reaches 2:1, so its strictly less and the first 12 ratios are unique in the Interval [1,2). Therefore after multiplying with 2^n for the big ratios you'll always end up in the [2^(n-1), 2^n) Intervall for n \in {1,...,5}. Therefore each of the 60 total gear ratios is unique and increasing exactly in the order you described (1,1), ..., (1,12), (2,1), ..., (2,12), ..., (5,1), ..., (5,12).
@@mauricereichert2804 and this is how we get "honest" marketing claims that leave customers upset.
You're completely accurate technically. But it isn't going to really deliver on the claim. The range is going to overlap sufficiently enough that it may as well not exist.
@@richardbrooksshnee The ranges aren't overlapping at all. The only interesting thing is how close is almost 2:1 to real 2:1 and how are the steps seperated. If he choose the teeth count ratio such that it approximate 2^((m-1)/12) for m \in {1,...,12} in a good rational way (e.g. exactly like a western piano 7 white + 5 black =12 tone steps), it's gonna feel very natural and every single gear shift will increase about the same factor and maybe even sound harmonically. :D
@@mauricereichert2804 yes they are. The operator would be skipping that last gear as x~2 and x2 are close enough to the same that any rpm differences would be negligible from their standpoint and so there is no worthwhile reason for the overlap. You're going to shift to x2. You're ignoring the point and purpose of a gear box. Effectively the same is wasted and is an overlap in range. Damn near the same output to engine rpm & torque.
Your "but the numbers are slightly different" is obnoxiously pedantic to the point of counterproductivity and ignorant to the point of a drive train.
You can cry technically right all you want. You're effectively wrong.
Hey, you do also technically have CVT gearboxes, they are generally not used in manual gearboxes because it makes no sence too, but some automatics use them, and they have a "infinit" amount of gear ratios between Min and Max :) I think it would be really cool to see you try to make a manual CVT gearbox!
I mean a manual cvt would basically just be a up down lever
@@dawsonramdass1145 Take a look at the belt drive section from a 2J-type Bridgeport milling machine. It's literally a manual CVT. There's a little crank you turn to adjust the pulley diameters, and it takes your single speed motor and turns it into 500-4200 RPM if you're in hi-range and 50-500-ish in lo-range. There's plenty of good drawings and such available to see how it works.
@@noiwonttellyoumyname.4385 I saw a similar “friction drive” manual cvt demonstration in a museum recently. It’s pretty neat how simple it is
I`ve got manual CVT transmition In Chinees drill press. And it`s really just level + and - , which you move to adjust speed.
Level just shift one of cone, and another holding by spring
@@skirnir-atf Yep, it's not a particularly advanced mechanism but I still think it would be cool to see one with a ridiculous gear ratio
Incredible Job! Steven, the transmission is so mind blowing to see it in action you did a great job designing how the first transmission gear set continues in to the multiplier gear set your best video yet
Great job
happy holidays Steven.
the rod goes into the square hole
btw cool build
lego actually used a "gear multiplier" to make the gearbox in the 911 gt3 rs, chiron, sian fkp and also the daytona sp3
its a 4 speed sequential with a 2x multiplier attached to it, so it can get 8 speeds, in a pretty small package
Is there any chance of you showing us a 4 gear manual syncromesh gearbox please?
There is surround sound at 0:23
?
@@WXNTXR_playsI don’t even remember making this comment lmao
LMAOOO@@imgoodreally6558
The sound goes right to left
@@imgoodreally6558it was a year ago lol
I have considered joining two motorcycle engines together to make two fours into one straight eight, leaving their two transmissions separated. Each transmission would backdrive a different side of a differential, with the resulting output from the ring gear driving the rear tire. Gear ratios from the two transmissions would be averaged by the differential, giving 9 useful ratios out from the two five speed transmissions, or 11 useful ratios from two six speeds. Can you play with that?
DOT would have something to say about that lmfao
@@craftminer49er I don't see why. It's just a motor swap.
They already do this with Hayabusa engines. Look up amateur F1 Radical cars. Very common in that field. But still VERU COOL. My brother-in-laws are mechanics for these types of race cars.
@@DickNemakas I know. The Arial Atom V8 is two Hayabusa engines joined, but only one transmission.
Those "couplers" you speak of are otherwise known as a synchromesh, they are tapered inside to allow for gears and shafts turning at different speeds, to engage. It gradually brings the layshaft and input shaft up to speed, or synchronization.
This is an unsynchronized gearbox... Those are just shift collars
@@pytbob Yep, those are the "dogs". I thoroughly enjoyed the vid, but it would have added to the learning if he used the real terms such as the shifter forks, dog toother gears etc. Many would have an "ah-ha!" moment when they read about dogbox gearboxes.
@@amorag59 so many nuances in transmissions and I'm far from an expert... I do know that dogs refer to teeth on the face rather than the periphery of a gear. They were used as the step between sliding mesh and synchros
Maybe you said this in the video and I missed it, but this is very similar to how its done in bikes. Two different sets of gears that can be changed that allow for way more speeds than one set
A couple of the 13& 18 speed semi transmissions ive rebuilt had a double countershaft configuration. allows for a shorter package.
So you made a 12 speed transmission with a 5 speed transfer case. Pretty damn cool
I feel like another example of this gearbox + multiplier system that people may be more familiar with is on bicycles. The right shifter is your transmission and the left shifter (front sprocket) is your multiplier. So if this engine transmission is still hard to understand, look at your bicycle and apply the same lessons learned in this video!
If you do it really smarty, the compound gearbox can share the intermediate axle removing 1/4 of all the sprockets and also making it a lot more compact.
For teminology sake, the coupler is refered to as a syncronising ring making your design a syncromesh gearbox
The correct terms you're probably looking for is main gearbox and auxiliary gearbox; in your instance you have a 12 speed main box with a 5 speed auxiliary. Semis use an 18 speed which is a 4 speed w/ L main box with a 4 speed auxiliary
Ah so you are the one that built the transmissions they all used in the fast and the furious movies. Great job!
This is how semi trucks were built a while ago. The most common setup to see restored is a 5+4 shifter. A front 5 speed paired to a rear 4 speed.
Where layer lines create weakness or the need for supports, split the model so you can print all of it flat but with a designed connection that will take a screw or with an effective glue area.
The "back box" is a gear splitter. A lot of trucks and tractors have them, even a few motorcycles have a 2 speed splitter.
I’ve seen either a 12 or 14 gear tractor as a kid. Worked exactly like this. 2 separate gears and the standard 6/7 gears
another suggestion for strength you could have added a couple mill sized fillet at the 90 degree angle of the shifting linkages to distribute stress to avoid a break.
This is essentially how a twin stick semi works, it’s kind fun, less total gears and “speeds” but same concept
best video of manual transmission i have ever saw.
Wow that’s very cool I really think 3-D printing is pretty awesome
I would love to see someone make a gearbox that reverses ratios halfway through, so the outside gears are both spinning really fast and the middle gear is spinning really slow.
Reverse input to make it a 56 speed reduction box. Old Semi-Trucks used twin box setups with two 4 speed or a 4 and 5 speed combo.
Yes I know there are 60 combinations but 4 are the same ratio.
@5:41 I would print a part like that in two pieces and join them after. Also I've seen people have success restarting a print when it's run out of filament etc. I wonder if you could lay a flat part down and get layers to stick to it. Maybe start at high temperature to help it stick and have an enclosed print bed kept at high temperature. Maybe I'm an idiot.
If you really break it down, how many unique ratios does it actually have? 1:1 times 4 would be the same as 1:2 times 2, and I can imagine there are more overlapping ratios.
There are none. Each gear in the back end is a larger multiple than all 12 on the near end.
I'd like to know the amount of torque required for each of the different gears and how the multipliers affect the amount of torque to spin each of the different gears
I heard him say square hole and i got flashbacks
Thats right it goes in the square hole
you can always some how mesh the corners of the arm linkages. that way you can print both sides laying down, without supports. all u would need to do is bolt them together, or have a dove tail or something.
Can we just appreciate how the music absolutely slaps!
Is how a bike with two sets of gears work, like a 1-7 on right hand and a 1-3 on left?
it would be cool to see how different lubricants affect the output shafts speed or the gears smoothness.
There are trucks with twin transmissions. When people drove those trucks they would call a twin sticking lol. But it was essentially companies just sticking two of their transmissions together so the combinations of gears was pretty much random and very disorganized. It would take a lot of memorization to properly drive these transmissions. Honestly an impressive feat.
Then there are brownie boxes. Which is pretty much what you built you have a standard transmission with a three or four-speed brownie box that gives you three or four different ranges for your transmission. They are the precursor to the modern load rangers.
I own a 1953 Packard with a 3-on the tree plus a Borg-Warner Overdrive that kicks in above ~25-30 mph. It's very interesting to drive as you go 1st, 2nd, 3rd, Engage overdrive, back down to 2nd (4th) and then back up to 3rd (5th) if you're doing a full gear run. It's not quite as extreme as a twinstick, but it was certainly a bit of a learning curve.
Most modern semi transmissions are still 2 transmissions, they just share one case and one "stick". Depending on what transmission you have, it can be a 5+4 with low range on the bottom is a 9 speed. A 5+5 is a straight 10. A 5 speed with a splitter is a super 10. You take a 5+4 and add a splitter to the top 4 speed and you get a 13 speed. 5+5 with a splitter on both the bottom and top 4 is a 18 speed. Plus a whole lot more different combos.
@@dammityoutube your transmission math is a little wrong, the transmissions would be 5+2 for super and regular 10, 5+2+(2(high range only)) for 13, and 5+2+2(not limited) for 18,
Yes, I know the numbers don't add up to the actual gear counts, its because of how they label and layout the patterns.
13 and 18 have the same pattern with the difference being the splitter useable in low range, the "missing" 2 gears in a 18 are in the "low" position ( 13 has low (low range)/ high low low - high high low (high range w/ splitter), 18 has the low range split as well.
Most drivers only use the "lo" position in the lowest and highest possible ratios (if at all, those gears are extremely low) because the other ratios are barely different, the usual shift method is to go sequential and not use the splitter unless you need to, the splitter basically does 1X/1.5X with X being the gear (1,2,3 ...16,7, etc).
10s will get you there, 13s are better, and 18s are the best.
The reason is because every incline has a gear ratio that maximizes speed for current situation (your weight, your engine, % grade, etc) and an 18 has the best chance of getting you as close as possible to it without going "over".
5:27 then, why you make hollow parts, instead just make solid parts....🤔??? Tell me about that...??
If you actually make it solid the part will become even more rigid. Sure, it will have less of a chance of breaking but actually fitting the piece will probably become impossible.
Change the input to be the shaft going Into your mega multi box and the output on the other end and your 32:1-1:1 twin stick transmission Is very similar to what a twin stick semi trucks transmission used to be like. Insane torque!
I'm surprised those gears were able to take that much torque.
Imagine driving, and your passenger ask "so how fast does this thing go?" "Oh, haha, light speed"😂
(Dependant)
Kinda reminds me of those Eaton transmissions where they have splitter and ranges, like the 13 and 18 spd, but a 60 speed? interesting.
Hey hey hey, ADD SPRINGS TO HOLD THE ARMS FROM MOVING LEFT AND RIGHT, so the ideas is to put a spring that can hold the arm in the middle so they dont accidentally engage wile your in a different step, and then the sring can flex inwords, or be flexed outword.
most gear boxes dont increase speed until the highest gear(s). for example, the standard 5 speed transmissions gear significantly down from gears 1-3, 4th gear is direct drive, and fifth gear is slightly over driven. most transfer cases gear down even more, and the diff gears down for the final drive ratio. most cars engines are spinning roughly 3 times faster than the axle in the highest gear. a better design for this is to either flip the input and output so you're always gearing down, or make the 1:1 gear either 6 or 7 and up or down from there, including the multipliers, which to eliminate doubling gear ratios, should be a 5 speed with 1:4.05, 1:2.05. 1:1, 2.05:1, and 4.05:1 or something similar. that way, gear 30 is 1:1 approximately, and every other gear is higher or lower than the input.
you know what really grinds my gears....
Racheting cvt. it's a lot smaller and solves the tourqe slipping problem with normal cvt's. You just need like 8 different transmissions side by side to smooth out the bumpy output it's going to be bumpy under load maybe better for electric generators and use the electric power to run a electric motor for a more comfortable ride.
There’s a reason large gear boxes with many speeds use “ranges” in essence a second gearbox that shifts the entire range of the second gear box
It’s just more efficient
Future reference older trucks or twin stick trucks would have a 18 speed trans or whatever and a 4 speed spicer so every gear you can break further down using the spicer 4 times so say you had an 18 speed that would be 72 gears if you split every gear into four but the secondary is called a spicer
I'm currently with a mechanical engineering major and I still can't believe people had the patience do design stuff even more complicated than this.
This isnt complicated at all
“So how many speeds do you want in your transmission?”
“Y E S”
But how do you do reverse? Car gearboxes have a reverse option so how do you make that?
Also it would be nice to see a video of you putting a gearbox like this (but maybe not this many speed options) in a 3D printed car and use a electric motor to power the input shaft. It would be fun to see how it works while moving around.
My modded ender 3 v2 produces incredible layer adhesion. I use a high performance fan shroud, titanium heatbrake, copper heatblock and nozzle, dual z, and geared extruder direct drive.
Thats basically a semi transmission. Back in the 70s and 80s their were trucks with two shifters. A 5 speed and a 4 speed. Now days a really common one is a 5 speed with a pnumaticaly shifted 2 speed behind it. The second trans is usually called the auxillary.
Put a 2 speed rear end and you got yourself 120 gears.
Had 4x4 and 4x5 two stick simi trucks, later on guys would put the auxiliary box on their 18 speed which was AWESOME, and questionably useful after weight and overlapping ratios taken in to account.
It would take quite a while to reach 120th gear unless you have the gearbox in a series of 12 or 24 speeds lol
@@TheSilverShadow17 so many gears were over lapping you’d probably change .0001 ratio on more than half if you tried sequential shifting lol.
The 4 gear second shifter would be more of a final gear choice and often times a difficult one to shift on the move so if you were empty you take high gear, fully loaded uphill low gear and then shift accordingly on the main.
You know how smooth a 60 gear transmission would be you never feel the shifts.
You should check out the 50s era mack triple stick trucks. Or the twin sticks.
Imagine having to go to a stop then input an entire street fighter combo on your shifter
Person who worked with machinists here: when you have parts that are oddly shaped, like the shifters, try printing two parts with design for a small screw. More work, but stronger part, and less time consuming during print. If its non-structural, then it doesnt matter, but for items like this, it would help save time.
Bicycles could have 12 speeds on single chainring and up to 21 speeds on triple charging (speeds "repeats" on gearing with more one chainring), so it's not that uncommon to have more than 7 speeds on bicycles
This was with a derailleur, inner hubs (that uses planetary gears) can only get up to 8 speeds so far
Something I've always wanted to see is how the shifter in fwd cars connects to the transmission using cables
Now attach a flywheel and a hand crank and watch that puppy fly!
You made a gear box for a semi but with a couple more splitter gears
Awesome thing you made here but they were essentially doing this with spicer 6x4’s and 6x4x2’s back in the 50’s and 60’s
This is my new weapon of choice
How many gear speeds can we have?
The minimal amount necessary for the job...which is alot less than 60. But cool
Multi stage transmission I've known them to be referred to as twin sticks like the old semi trucks twin stick transmission
This is exactly the same technique that bicycles with a front and rear derailleur use to give lots of gear ratios.
Hey super cool that you did a multiplier gearbox
I'd be interested in seeing him 3d print a clutch for this. Hook up a motor and shift through them all
You made a big rig transmission and multi gear splitter.
Try using herringbone gears to increase efficiency
shouldn’t the “front” (which is really the back gearbox) gearbox be the other way round?
if you created a dual shift setup tou can have way more gears. look at the old mack duplex and triplex trans missions.
To make them smoother, use syncros
Time to put this in a car to break the sound barrier
Are you sure this is 60 different speeds, gear 12 has a 1:2 ratio with a 1x multiplier (1:2 overall). Gear 13 goes back to 1:1 ratio in main box but then uses the x2 multiplier gear which would also make it 1:2 overall. This means that every time you go to a different multiplier and back to gear 1 in the main box, the gear ratio is the same. Another example is with 24th and 25th gear, 24th gear uses 1:2 in the main box and a 2x multiplier in the second box (1:4 overall). 25th gear goes back to a 1:1 on main box but a 4x on the secondary box which will result in the same ratio (1:4 overall). This can also be seen with gear 36 and 37, gear 36 is 1:2 in main box, and 4x multiplier in second box (8:1 overall) and gear 37 uses the 8x multiplier and the 1:1 in the main box (1:8 overall). Otherwise it's very impressive how you got so many gears in such a small package.
Miata owners on their way to fit this in
You just made a gearbox with a transfer case. Lots of cars have two transmissions like this for 4wd and low gear ratios for high torque/low speed.
Just found you. Have you built a turbo system for a car like this? Would be super cool to see.
Now I need to know what the optimal shifting is, to get from lowest speed all the way to highest speed using all the gears
AH the 60 speed xmission, for when your engine idles at 700rpm and redlines at 800rpm
Do the amount of cogs on each gear matter? Are they all the same amount? How about the spacing?
If you engage multiple gears you can have more gear ratios with fewer parts..
Could you make a non electric power drill with this?
Why not use a second input to limit torsion of the shaft?
Do something similar to a ships reduction gears