Giving EVERY BRAWLER a New Rarity!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ธ.ค. 2023
- forgive me spike
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@carnagegameyt...
Membership: / @carnagegameyt
Twitter: / carnagegameyt
Discord: dsc.gg/carnagegame
Instagram: / carnagegameyt
#carnagegame #brawlstars - เกม
Based on the devs' "how hard it is to play against" criteria, Crow and Spike should totally be legendary. If you don't have much experience with them, they can completely demolish you without giving you a chance, and when you first get them it feels like you're unstoppable. Sure their mechanics aren't all that unique, but Carnage changing their rarities is a crime.
Something I like to think about is what if spike was a brawler that was released this year and was told he was going to be a legendary, compared to cordelius, chester and sandy, he doesnt really have much to offer thats 'innovative' I agree that he can demolish people early into their time on brawl stars but that might just be because of his current place in the meta. I dont really disagree with you though
@@CarnageGameYT
Gus feels more legendary than him
@@Ocram0If Gus's more legendary than spike, spike'd be worse than rare because he's just a rosa variation
True for Crow, Spike deserves Epic-Mythic in my opinion, though.
Spike's splitting of his attack is pretty unique@@CarnageGameYT
It was revealed to us that the only reason Crow and Spike were Legendary on the release of the game was because they were the only brawlers in the game that were clearly not human or robotic.
fax
Really? Where did they said that?
Ig SC themself couldn't decide what makes a brawler a certain rarity
Where dod theu day that ?
@@Fokk40 little bro cannot spell😭
@@Fokk40💀 u must not be amerca or yo litle bro gremmer is supr trsh
In my opinion the entire reason Crow was a legendary in the first place is not only because of his poison damage but his ability to nerf healing and reveal damaged enemies in bushes
His ability to nerf healinh was added years after his release
@@DgreegdI think he means nerf healing the the sense that you have to wait 6 WHOLE SECONDS after getting hit to start healing
@@potat9189 Oh yeah
DoT was a relatively "new" mechanic at that time so it was worth a legendary
He was a legendary before star powers
I personally think Lou being a legendary makes more sense. his attack gives the frost attack which only Lou has. his super is so unique with the slipping. the only draw back is his gadgets, star powers, and hyper charge are a bit less unique.
His Hyper charge is insane… he can change the whole situation in different modes very easily.
Mortis a legendary?! Bro has been taking the same drugs as edgar mains
Im not taking drugs im taking Hallucinogenic Mushrooms 😠
@@AI-DreigonGPT you mean cordelius’s poisoning mushrooms?
Just what I thought, he really bias toward him
@@Walter.white_likesmoneyShrooms in general.
Bro is speaking facts💀💀
Bro made his own rarity
💀
cactus from 32014
@@Le_Doge yo hi le cate
@@DeathwatchBrawlStars hello
@@DeathwatchBrawlStarsu got the low quality clown pin
I like the list but idk about Maisie being super rare like her shots are kinda hard to hit especially if you get her so soon
And her super can be spammed alot bcuz of how easy its to get back
Maisie is one of the best brawlers in my opinion
I guess i forgot to consider that she is designed to get supers very fast, that is epic material for sure
@@CarnageGameYT yep also i literally spawn trapped a whole team in brawl ball spamming her super…
On hypercharge
5:59 I don't really agree here, as Amber can place a liquid on the map that stays permanently there if you don't use it, you literally can influence the map and how people walk on it! I think she pretty much does deserve legendary.
Nah
on top of that, the way her ammo works is one of the most unique ones in the game, unlike single ammo brawlers, the first one being carl, but then a lot of others came out, like bea, charlie, etc
@@renanwi9436By that logic a lot of there brawlers also deserves legendary status. I like Amber, she is my 2nd favourite legendary but she is mythic level.
@@soumyadeepmukherjeeLIKE WHO FOR EXAMPLE? Amber has he number 1 most unique way on reloading and unloading+unique super + can be tricky for noobs to play against her
@@Yowatchadoing Her super isn't unique? It just burns people at contact and deal damage.
I think that the reason Supercell did not put Chuck in the legendary rarity is because they wanted people to have him.
Rarity is based on how unique a brawler is
Not how hard it is to counter
Rarity is scaled with how complex the brawler is. Basic brawlers such as shelly and colt simply deals damage but higher rarity brawlers such as Mr.P has tons of strategies, best ways to use super or gadgets and which star power to use. Cordelius and Surge are one of the most unique brawlers and that is why they are legendary.
Ok, thank you.
I disagree with so many of these placements 🤣
But that's kinda the magic to it in a way. It's interesting to see how so many opinions can differ so much from one person to another.
Love the new rarity too!
same here
I would argue we need a new rarity between mythic and epic since those two are way to overpopulated
Lola has really big Legendary (or I guess Exotic) potential.
Lets remember at first she was intended to be played by placing the Ego away from you, basically splitting the brawler into two independent targets.
Going by that, noobs would just be very overwhelmed by not being able to dodge all the incoming bullets.
But, with the playstyle people went with and that supercell just apparently adopted as her actual playstyle (putting the Ego on top of yourself), she's definitely Mythic at most.
I am personally fine with Lola being epic because she does not feel that unique to me.
at the end of the day, she's just a damage dealer with the ability to spawn a pet (akin to Nita's bruce, Jessie's turret or Ash's robot rats.) Her ego is capable of copying lola's movements but that does not feel unique or complicated enough to be mythic.
I disagree her attack is basically Pam’s or pearls and her super is not that unique.
@@speed0291 I mean, unlike the other pets Lola's ego is able to copy Lola's movement. Can be very overwhelming for new players, plus you can do a lot of funi stuff with it. That's just me though.
People really think that maisie attacks are simple 😂 , and they themselves never show a single gameplay of Massie because they know that they will not able to play with her well. Because her mechanism is hard and her super is also too good .
She's interesting tbh. Was a little difficult to play with when she was first released tho
He didn’t show massie because sandy is just way too goated(and she is boring as shit to play)
Its a solid list, but id argue that Maisie deserves Epic or maybe even Mythic.
Sure, at first glance, her attack and super might seem basic, but her kit is surprisingly complex. The way her super, gadget, star power, and main attacks combo into each other that makes her more comicated.
Especially if were basing this off of how hard it is to learn how to play against, i can already imagine a noob trying to perform Maisies combos, or trying to wrap their head around them.
I mean, picture yourself as a kid who just installed the game maybe a week ago, and seeing Maisie cycling supers, using her gadget to close the gap and stun people, then getting another super and dealing huge AOE damage...
It would be completely overwhelming to play against, and hard to learn.
In my opinion, people underestimate how complex Maisie is, because at first glance she seems really simple and basic, but her kit is much more than the sum of its parts.
@@castanh4 Yeah, but I'm just saying that she shouldn't be any lower than Epic.
(edited)
@@pig3032 You could say that about any brawler though.
It's the fact that her whole kit combos into something else that makes her interesting.
Her attack, super, gadget or star powers aren't that interesting by themselves, but it's the way each one combos perfectly into another part of her kit that makes her playstyle feel so satisfying.
As maisie main, i kinda agree. Maisie is also a relatively tought brawler to master, and she does have. a very solid kit. Both gadgets are amazing.
@@castanh4 The thing about Colt is that his super is just a stronger version of his main attack, which is kind of one of the biggest traits of low rarity brawlers.
Maisie, on the other hand, has a super which is completely different from her basic attack, but also combos with it, so a lot of the time it doesn't feel like it's two completely different moves, but rather two parts of one whole.
This is further exemplified by how much better the super is when combined with the gadget and star power.
8:38
Well, you predicted the future. Because Angelo is second brawler that, he can walk on water, so, you did great!
True❤❤❤❤
I would think they have to do with the complexity of the brawler, rather than how easy they are to play. That complexity doesn't have to come from an over the top brawler; for example invisibility has a ton of versatility on how it can be used.
This is the very reason why Crow is placed where he is, as opposed Byron and Willow who really only have one job. Crow can do much more than just poison and be annoying.
That being said, the list is pretty good. Not perfect, but based enough for me.
Willow can literally control an opponent and is a mythic brawler.
@soumyadeepmukherjee Willow's application of that is limited, as she can only travel so much distance to make use of it and is only ever used as self-defense or sneaky plays.
If she had it for longer or had access to more abilities, it would be a higher rarity.
noobs can't calculate poison damage
@@KN11F3D Still this ability alone makes her legendary. If she had more range with the super then it would have break the game.
Tbf Byron heals, so he also "can do more than just poison and be annoying."
But he's a support, and Willow is a thrower instead of an assasin
(who in the world ever use Crow like that?💀 He doesn't do that most of the time)
And legendaries tend to be more based on fun or potentialy broken mechanics.
Join the I have a life gang here
wish I could but I don't have one!😊
As a cat i can join 9 times
as a cat i also join nine times
as a human i can only join once
no can do bro i grinded edgar mastery 💀
Bot
Honestly, Gale easily might have been a starter brawler, even lore-wise
Nah his star powers and gadgets are pretty interesting and his Hager’s are as well and he should be at least epic
@@ProGamer-dg7dythe star powers and gadget have Nothing to do with rarity
Supercell taking notes🗿
Add exotics?
8:40 CG just predicts Angelo
Spike should still be a legendary. For starters,his attack consists of two phases, the first is that he throws a simple projectile that upon impact it explodes, the second phase is that his projectile is split into needles . This alone makes him unique than most of the other brawlers, since his attack and survivability makes him a hybrid of a sharpshooter and a shotgunner, even Gene's projectile needs to be expired in order for it to split because the former projectile leaves no trace when it hits a brawler or a wall thus preventing him from doing complex plays compared to spike. That's ONLY for the projectile, as for his super he can either stall, slow or even trap opponents to turn the favour of the battle to him, the aura of the super is indestructible as opposed to sprouts wall or Jesse's turret, moreover it slows the enemy and it deals a lot of Dps as opposed to Lou's super damage being under 100 damage. So by the complexity of his abilities, the synergy between his other abilities (SP, gear, hyper charge, gadget) and the different situations that spike can bring into the battle, he deserves to be legendary, the same goes for crow but supercell for some reason almost killed the effectiveness that the synergy of his abilities bring.
Bro wrote an essay 😂
Personally i think Carl deserves to be an Epic. His attack is very unique as he reloads once he gets his pickaxe back, which leads to him being a much more complex brawler with using walls to bounce your axe to reload faster.
I usually think that the more rare a brawler is the more creative and fun the mechanics of that brawler are.
I feel like sprout could be a contender for legendary since sprouts a thrower with nautical bouncy projectiles (only other being Rico) and the super is the only natural wallbreak (natural meaning no gadgets). On top of this, learning the sprout landing splash is also tricky and playing around these aspects can be hard to learn.
But Rico is a super rare. If bouncy projectiles are so special why not have Rico higher as well?
Ruffs
Legendary means they have a unique mechanic and:
1. Spike is the only brawler whose attack splits when hitting a wall so he is legendary
2. Crow nerf all heals with 40%
3. Meg is the only brawler who lives after dying
4. Otis is the only one with mute and being able to hit invincible envy (except Cordy)
Bruh, then 50 brawlers would be legendary if that's what legendary means to you😑😑😑
@@enymalzzzLola is the only brawler who can create a another of herself
Collette is the only one who comes back from a charge
Willow is the only one who can mind control
Nani is the only one with that attack pattern
Stu is the only one who gets a super in one shot
Lou is the only one that freezes
Fang is the only one that chains off enemy’s in a charge
Gene is the only one who can pull
Mr P is the only one who places a spawner who created spawners
@@DjKirby411. Agreed. Lola should be legendary
2. Colette's super isnt unique at all since coming back from a charge isnt that cool of a mechanic
3.Willow may have the most unique super in the game but her main attack is a byron knockoff
4 Nani's attack pattern is cool but now that mico got added controlling something yourself isnt exclusive to nani anymore
5. The super even if gotten in one shot is just a dash. His attack isnt special either tho
6 Another one i agree with. Carnage didnt cook with that one
7 Same thing as colette, a "special" kind of dash isnt unique at all since jessie's attack works in the exact same way anyways.
8 Jacky
9 It's still a fairly simple concept, spawning stuff wont make it legendary
Ik I was joking bc almost every brawler is different from each other so saying that these brawlers should be legendary because they’re unique doesn’t make any sense
Bro put maisie in super rare and hank in epic ;-; Maisie should at least have been epic because of her gadget + super trick, it will catch noobs of gaurd
I know that there is this one Byron star power that does the same but...i think that what makes Crow legendary is that he cuts any healing source effectiveness + the poison last a hella lot compared to Byron & Willow
Yeah, that's why I hate Crow so much.
"Mico" and "High Skill Cap" should be in the same sentence, ever.
Gus’ ghosts and ghost bar is basically what makes him even super rare. His main attack is just a straight line like R-T’s and his super is just a shield.
I have to agree on nani and buster alot. Her super and attack is pretty unique and busters shield and trait is also very unique. And on cordelius i have to agree with you 101% bcuz his super is one of 10 most unique supers in game and he and buzz only has this special trait
Most importantly, it's the uniqueness and depth of the brawlers attack and super at the time of release.
For example, Lola's ego is much more than a damage boost. It has an insane level of depth you can reach, and it's just not understood very well because of the depth it has. It's especially unique because it was also released 2 years ago.
On the other hand, Ruffs has a supply drop (smaller primo meteor) as a super, that after landing, summons a power up. That is... not very unique, as it's just a better power cube with extra steps.
Let's talk about Spike now. He was the 1st to be able to slow in the entire game (at least I'm pretty sure), AND his attacks split into 6. All as one of the originals to be available at beta launch.
Spike Is legendary
Spike is legendary
Spike Is legendary
Spike Is legendary
Spike Is legendary
Spike Is legendary
Spike Is legendary
Spike Is legendary
Spike Is legendary
Actually, I think Spike should be a mhytich (I dunno how to write that). Most of that rarity is brawlers that have cool and somewhat complex mechanics but also they give the "mhystical" effect and so does Spike!
It's pronounced mythic :)
@@user-ry2fs5uj7m thanks, I hope I dont forget that :)
I like the Exotic rarity, perhaps renaming it to “Ultra” or something like that would make the name even cooler?
ultraman 💀
Carnage has just commited a warcrime for moving Spike to epic
Same thing with Crow
@@AidanBueling nahh crow isnt that iconic
@@remixgameyt1172 yep spike is iconic and he should be atleast mythic
BRO SPIKE DESERVES LEGENDARY HE'S SO GOOD AND AMAZING HOW ARE YOU GONNA PUT MORTIS AS LEGENDARY AND SPIKE AS EPIC BROOOOOOOOOO. I can't I'm gonna explode
I think spike should be legendary because he has one of the highest damage per second in the game and his curveball is really annoying. His super also slows down enemies a lot, give him an opportunity to deal massive damage to the target in a few seconds. Crow's poison is also annoying as it stops healing and reveal enemies location in bushes. his super is also good for both assassinating and escaping and it does high damage
0:40 out of context
I’d say that the rarity isn’t always based on the complexity, but how good it is in general or how hard it is to counter.
You did spike dirty. I'm a spike main and it takes a precision to master where to aim your shots so the needles will hit your opponent.
I think one day they'll change rarities like they changed many times cards for each arenas in Clash Royale
Mortis will be fine as an Epic. I won't argue about leaving him in Mythic, but Legendary?! Hell no.
Brock should atleast be super rare, I think that he should be even an epic. That splash damage on his attack is just too op, + he has good Star powers, gadgets, and his super is not a one to be forgotten in higher trophies. But everything other is good...
although your opinion, spike should be at least mythic. w his curveball starpower, there are almost no ods of not hitting the enemy, combined with pretty desend range and damage, he is cool as legendary
he predicted most of the rarities being changed which is cool
Carnage need to get cancel for putting spike in epic 🗿
Nah, Spike mains are annoying. Why?
CURVEBALL
the only bad thing about the tire list is that bull deserves to be a starter brawler
i have a what i think is a good idea:
you pick shelly or colt as your starter at the beginning of the game, then you unlock the other as your first brawler shortly after. how does that sound?
10:52 As a cordalius main i see this as an absolute win 🏆
HOT TAKE WARNING!!!⚠️
Fang should be epic…
If we compare him to an epic brawler like Collette, his main attack and super are no more complex than hers.
Nani is definitely mythic along with Lola who could potentially be a legendary.
Then we have Stu which I think is a perfect brawler for epic.
And get Chester off that Legendary category to Mythic his existence is making legendaries look bad!
Maisie and Jacky are perfect for super rare but Jacky is slightly more unique or it’s a tie.
Spike is staying legendary I don’t care what anyone says he is somewhat unique and extremely iconic.
Kit, I want to say Mythic but his design is cool plus I’m almost on 900 trophies with him so I’m giving him a pass.
I think mythic suits him, as he can chain his supers on multiple enemies, and his attack has 2 phases, the long range one being difficult to use
"as soon as supercell add another brawler that can walk on water" its might seen crazy what I'm about to sayy
Never let bro make a tier list again he wasn’t cooking with this
W tierlist, I saw you once commenting on one of my posts on Reddit saying that out of Sam , Lola and Colgate , Colgate isn't fitting in Mythic as I reccommended once to move them up at least to Mythic. After thinking a little, yes you are really right, only thing is her unique attack. Let Carnage Cook in Supercell HQ imo
colgate? 😭
Colgate
Lol
L tierlist,there's Mortis in legendary,he's max at epic IMO
Man, choosing a rarity for Spike is so difficult. Spike is very simple in gameplay, but you can't put him in rarities like epic, super rare, mythic, I mean, look at him! Cactus in jacket, and his legendary smile. For some reason, to me he is either rare or legendary idk I think he would fit perfectly as a starting fighter same as legendary
Literally nobody saw Mortis being in Legendary comming 😮
Also W Penny placement
As a dyna main I disagree dynamike is really hard to play and can be really complex if you also use dyna jump to perfectly time it to dodge and damage
IMO they should make Nita and Colt Starter Brawlers as well
I can already see the little kids picking him and missing every single shot on the enemy lol🤣
I understand Spike getting to Epic rarity. The only thing that made him special was the attack split. Something Grom (an epic brawler) also has
Putting Chester anywhere besides legendary is a top crime. Yes, his supers are simple but still. His main attack is unique, and no other brawler in the game is RNG based or luck based. So much variety from his supers.
I think crow’s legendary status makes sense now because his poison decreases healing. before that change, mythic would be valid
Bayron has a starpower exactly like that…
I agree mostly with spike, but he is kind of a mix between mythic and epic, as the spikes are tricky to dodge, epsecially with the star power
As an Eve main, i will happily take the "Exotic until another brawler that can walk of water" medal
Edit: I've lost
Hey, another Eve main!
@@v8terror390 Heya!
lol
@@egorpro420 DANGIT
Wait its actually a damn good listtt, i agree with everything and your reasonings all make sense.
Nani appreciation
4:23 there is a fan made rarity of mine: Heroic. A rarity between Epic and Mythic. All chosenly mythic brawlers except Leon and Surge will devolve to Heroic, while Leon and Surge are
Mythic.
Maybe include Bea in Heroic too
0:29 tbh uts would be pretty cool beung able to pick ur starter brawler maybe like they add colt and nita as starter brawlers
this man put my Eve in Legendary (or "Exotic", I guess)
respect for life, I love you Carnage
💀 i made a rarity concept almost exactly like yours before seeing this and now i feel dumb
when I first time played poco in training cave, i didn't even knew what does his super even do🤣
I can't believe josh literally place down leon on legendary while willow and r-t exotic
eve is mythic. walk on water may be unique but its such a simple concept that it cant be over mythic.
W list, i wouldve put colette and emz higher tho. colette is the only brawler that has a percentage attack (?) and it took me way too long to figure out emz does more damage at mid range😅
"cordelius is the most legendary brawler"
chester: has five supers and 4 similar attacks
cordelius: has a super that can be almost replicated by lily's gadget and a boring attack
Maisie is the toughest brawler to play with and this random dude puts her In super rare 😐. Dude her super is also one of the best in the game.
I'll put Jacky as a starter brawler and let new players choose between them (like in pokemon)
This is because Jacky's main attack is super easy to understand and as Shelly's super pushes enemies, Jacky's one pulls them into her.
"Hopefully no negative feedback". Proceeds to put spike into epic
maisie can do teamwipes with her super she does not need super rare epic at the least her hypercharge can do massive damage and her attacks are hard to dodge plus the gadget super combo is amazing she really is a mhytic or epic
Eve is kinda basic to be a legendary ( 3 projectile attack super spawn 3 thingie to chase enemy )
MyTHIC at best
Sure she can walk over the water, but it's not hard to walk on water from the gameplay perspective (it's literally a regular movement)
Bro Penny and Tick as an epic should be a crime when looking at Spike there too, like I can't hit a singular shot with it and the turret is more blind then Jessie's turret. I wonder what will be the hyper for her tho.
those based opinions are something
I know fang is not that complex and not that simple too but people saying he is legendary is saying like shelly is special and unique
The only reason i think spike should stay legendary is because of curveball, otherwise i think mythic fits better
Mortis deserves to be legendary but i dont think the raritys are only on complexety but also on how gun they are
bro said max’s main gimmick is a speed boost when she has FOUR AMMO (no offense)
Alternative video title: Exploiting the mythical and epic quality
Spike? Epic? This must be a late April fools prank
Ngl u should have based on their Release especially for crow
i feel like barley, colt and poco should all also be start brawlers
It would be cool if the starter brawlers were shelly, poco, and colt
Edit: MAISIE AS SUPER RARE. WE THROWING HANDS
I think that there should be like 5 different starter brawlers. You can choose to unlock right before you play your first match (but the tutorial will still always be shelly) I think it would be perfect if the started brawlers were:
Shelly (Close range, High damage attack and super)
Colt (Long range, High damage attack and super)
Nita (Close range, Summoner)
Barely (Thrower, High damage potential)
Poco (Medium range, Healer)
i think this is a really good idea seeing that there would be more options for starters
I know it’s based on how hard the brawler is to learn but also how hard they are to deal with take Pam shoots a lot of shots simple super is a healing turret simple but how do you deal with these storms of scrap she shoots out and is it even possible to take down that turret? Was what I asked myself when I started three years ago and a lot of others did to I’m sure so keep that in mind tho I agree with the tierlist for the most part
8:38 HERE WE GOO (Angelo)
Plus The rarities are good the way they are we just need a little nerf to the legendary brawlers price in gems
Including credits
Since mythic is red and legy is yellow, exptic could be orange and we complete the color wheel
If you had to rank Mico in the list, where would you put him?
Definitely legendary
Fr😊
Epic or Mythic. He'll be broken but he's overhyped.
Monke
Mortis has to be in legendary, he is easily the hardest brawler to master.
For me Nani should totally be legendary.
I know he's hard to use but if you learn its really useful. Super can actually do something.
I'm so freaking happy someone else thinks Spike shouldn't be legendary cuz it took me so dang long to unlock him and I felt underwhelmed once I got him because he was kinda basic compared to other Legendary brawlers.
Woah this is weird to see them with diffrent rareities