This is absolutely brilliant. The eloquent description he gives is very close to my own memory of seeing The Virgin Spring at the Cornerhouse (Manchester) in the late 80‘s, part of a Bergman matinee ‘Double Bill’ with (I think) Summer with Monika. It's still a favourite 'Top 10’ or Top 20 movie, for many of the very same reasons he gives, and it totally floored me - still remember being numb at the close, leaving the theatre and returning into the daylight. Knowing Ang Lee experienced the same ‘shock and awe’ kinda makes it even more special.
I had pretty much the same experience as Mr Lee seeing this film. It slogged me to such an extent that I couldn’t see it for 30 years afterwards, but it stayed w me. I am now attempting to see it again. Hope I make it through. I’m no cinéaste, but a poet, writer & cinema critic & understand this sensitive filmmaker v well. I was never the same after seeing this film. You?
Wow! Ang Lee explained to me why I've been haunted by this movie for most of my life. This also suggests how Lee can make a movie like "The Story of Pi."
Felt wonderful to listen to this great film-maker... that too about something so close to his heart.... the passion and authenticity in every word of his... such a great yet so humble film-maker..... thank you so much for posting this....
This is the first time I have heard of this movie, after listening to Ang Lee in this interview I can see Bergmans influence in his film "The Ice Storm", a brilliant film.
It might not be the 'greatest' by popular opinion, not because there are any bad aspects about, but simply because it's less ambitious and grand than his other films such as say Persona or Fanny & Alexander. The fact is though, that every single moment of The Virgin Spring is sheer perfection.
It's a great pity that Bergman's stock has fallen in recent years. It's inevitable however, that a new generation will be wowed by his movies and wonder why they hadn't heard of him before.
I think that's happening now, with Criterion's 2018 set. It was selling out faster than they could supply them. And I thought, well, it's his well-off existing fans upgrading to new transfers, but then I saw so many young people on TH-cam, Letterboxd, everywhere discovering these movies, interpreting them, wrestling with them. Greatness does endure, usually, even if it only gets its due cyclically.
I like how transcendence movies are. As a human you can watch a movie from anywhere. From places you might never hear about and be dragged into the story, relate. We humans aren't as different as we think. Only countries, separate us. I'm going to watch Life of Pi now. Life of have been on my must watch list for ages.
Wes Craven did a horror film remake of The Virgin Spring called 'Last House on the Left'. It is seriously, disgustingly violent and unsettling and probably made more money than the original.
Thank you Mr. Lee for movies like "The Icestorm" and " Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" Movies that opened my eyes to the wonderful world of movie storytelling, since then I purchased the complete Bergman -dvd Box, and what an absolut treat it was for my poor desolate soul that needs cartarsis from time to time And may you be blessed with your vision for what movies should be about
I have seen both Last House on the Left versions. But barely watched The Virgin Spring last week. And Lee got it right. Shows how good Bergman was as a director, because it was a moving for more than one reason. And besides, the assaults that did occur, one wouldn't think The Virgin Spring was a horror movie. And as good as the others were depicting how human nature can be, this one had something that the others did lack (quality wise).
I had pretty much the same experience as Mr Lee seeing this film. It slogged me to such an extent that I couldn’t see it for 30 years afterwards, but it stayed w me. I am now attempting to see it again. Hope I make it through. I’m no cinéaste, but a poet, writer & cinema critic & understand this sensitive filmmaker v well. I was never the same after seeing this film. You?
Now I want to make it plain that the virgin spring must be regarded as aberration. It’s touristic , a lousy imitation of Kurosawa. - Ingmar Bergman , a master praising another master
That's odd. Kurosawa said, "Now I want to make it plain that 'Seven Samurai' must be regarded as an aberration. It’s touristic , a lousy imitation of Bergman."
Bergman credited Kurosawa and Tarkovsky credited Bergman and also Kurosawa. The greats could afford to be generous. Or did they become great because of their sincerity as artists. Maybe some readers will take something from that. Visual literacy is important. Good luck.
@@glengustafson6959 They could afford to be generous to the people they admired. Bergman could show quite a nasty pettiness towards people he despised and could hold grudges for decades, especially towards in his eyes lesser filmmakers.
The Virgin Spring moved me deeply, and this interview moved me all over again. Incredibly powerful.
I'm going to watch it this afternoon...
Brilliant. Thoughtful. No wonder he is so great.
This is absolutely brilliant. The eloquent description he gives is very close to my own memory of seeing The Virgin Spring at the Cornerhouse (Manchester) in the late 80‘s, part of a Bergman matinee ‘Double Bill’ with (I think) Summer with Monika. It's still a favourite 'Top 10’ or Top 20 movie, for many of the very same reasons he gives, and it totally floored me - still remember being numb at the close, leaving the theatre and returning into the daylight. Knowing Ang Lee experienced the same ‘shock and awe’ kinda makes it even more special.
I can’t even imagine having the pleasure of seeing Bergman in a theater. I want it.
‘The Virgin Spring’ is a masterpiece.
I had pretty much the same experience as Mr Lee seeing this film. It slogged me to such an extent that I couldn’t see it for 30 years afterwards, but it stayed w me. I am now attempting to see it again. Hope I make it through. I’m no cinéaste, but a poet, writer & cinema critic & understand this sensitive filmmaker v well. I was never the same after seeing this film. You?
Clear, sincere, no pretense---a great professor.
'Dont make me Ang Lee, you won't like me when I'm Ang Lee...' 😊
He's so moved just talking about this he almost can not hold back his tears.
A Genius talking about a a genius
RIP Max von Sydow. You are a virtue and truly, amazing actor.
🌿🕊🌿
Ang lee rocks
Wow! Ang Lee explained to me why I've been haunted by this movie for most of my life. This also suggests how Lee can make a movie like "The Story of Pi."
Felt wonderful to listen to this great film-maker... that too about something so close to his heart.... the passion and authenticity in every word of his... such a great yet so humble film-maker..... thank you so much for posting this....
I came here to listen to Mr. Lee because The Virgin Spring is my favorite Bergman film, although I think his best is Persona.
I personally love cries and whispers
so brilliant, yet humble
excellent analysis, convincing point of view, now I understand this extraordinary film much better, thank you Mr. Lee!
3:38 like "I wish I knew how to quit you" in Brokeback mountain.
I'll just say Brokeback mountain. You've honored Mr Bergman in so many ways, thank you!
This is the first time I have heard of this movie, after listening to Ang Lee in this interview I can see Bergmans influence in his film "The Ice Storm", a brilliant film.
Perhaps not Bergman's 'greatest' film but what a stunningly perfect introduction to serious cinema for a future major director.
It might not be the 'greatest' by popular opinion, not because there are any bad aspects about, but simply because it's less ambitious and grand than his other films such as say Persona or Fanny & Alexander.
The fact is though, that every single moment of The Virgin Spring is sheer perfection.
It's a great pity that Bergman's stock has fallen in recent years. It's inevitable however, that a new generation will be wowed by his movies and wonder why they hadn't heard of him before.
I think that's happening now, with Criterion's 2018 set. It was selling out faster than they could supply them. And I thought, well, it's his well-off existing fans upgrading to new transfers, but then I saw so many young people on TH-cam, Letterboxd, everywhere discovering these movies, interpreting them, wrestling with them. Greatness does endure, usually, even if it only gets its due cyclically.
This is excellent. Thank you.
I like how transcendence movies are. As a human you can watch a movie from anywhere. From places you might never hear about and be dragged into the story, relate. We humans aren't as different as we think. Only countries, separate us.
I'm going to watch Life of Pi now. Life of have been on my must watch list for ages.
Ingmar was a pure genius
Thanks for sharing!
Gran cineasta es Ang Lee, reconociendo al mayor cineasta de la historia, a mi juicio el mejor director junto a Clint Eastwood.
@@yu-hsinlee6218 wtf ???
Wes Craven did a horror film remake of The Virgin Spring called 'Last House on the Left'. It is seriously, disgustingly violent and unsettling and probably made more money than the original.
A favorite film.
Fantastic.
Thank you Mr. Lee for movies like "The Icestorm" and " Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" Movies that opened my eyes to the wonderful world of movie storytelling, since then I purchased the complete Bergman -dvd Box, and what an absolut treat it was for my poor desolate soul that needs cartarsis from time to time
And may you be blessed with your vision for what movies should be about
I have seen both Last House on the Left versions. But barely watched The Virgin Spring last week. And Lee got it right. Shows how good Bergman was as a director, because it was a moving for more than one reason. And besides, the assaults that did occur, one wouldn't think The Virgin Spring was a horror movie. And as good as the others were depicting how human nature can be, this one had something that the others did lack (quality wise).
Very interesting, thank you.
This movie shows that rape is a crime of violence. I saw it as child .😪
Did for me too, man
I had pretty much the same experience as Mr Lee seeing this film. It slogged me to such an extent that I couldn’t see it for 30 years afterwards, but it stayed w me. I am now attempting to see it again. Hope I make it through. I’m no cinéaste, but a poet, writer & cinema critic & understand this sensitive filmmaker v well. I was never the same after seeing this film. You?
Now I want to make it plain that the virgin spring must be regarded as aberration. It’s touristic , a lousy imitation of Kurosawa.
- Ingmar Bergman , a master praising another master
That's odd. Kurosawa said, "Now I want to make it plain that 'Seven Samurai' must be regarded as an aberration. It’s touristic , a lousy imitation of Bergman."
Bergman credited Kurosawa and Tarkovsky credited Bergman and also Kurosawa. The greats could afford to be generous. Or did they become great because of their sincerity as artists. Maybe some readers will take something from that. Visual literacy is important. Good luck.
@@glengustafson6959 They could afford to be generous to the people they admired. Bergman could show quite a nasty pettiness towards people he despised and could hold grudges for decades, especially towards in his eyes lesser filmmakers.
🟥♨️My feelings exactly♨️🟥