Inside the Secret Network Helping Protesters Flee Hong Kong | The Dispatch
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ธ.ค. 2019
- Risk years of imprisonment or flee? We traced the journey along a covert pipeline helping Hong Kong protesters escape to Taiwan.
Read the story here: nyti.ms/2RyijP8
Subscribe: bit.ly/U8Ys7n
More from The New York Times Video: nytimes.com/video
----------
Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch.
![เปิดบ้าน เปิด Supercar อั๋นโอกิ เคยเอา rolls Royce เเลกพระ องค์ละ 100 ล้าน l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FeGwJwXauZ0/mqdefault.jpg)
If you are doing this story NYT, you need to blur out more and change the pitch of the interviewee.
If the US truly cared they should hand out immediate Green Cards to the US!
The HKG police is hunting those who tried to murder a policeman
th-cam.com/video/y1SdGwOxo2k/w-d-xo.html
So, they escaped to the US.
@@jakelaw9768 I don't think giving out green cards would help. All it would result in is a lot of people fleeing to the US. These people are the catalysts for change in Hong Kong and need to stay fighting for what they believe in. If they leave, you are just handing Hong Kong to China on a plate and have a lot of people in the US who don't want to be there.
Time To Destination why?? what will happened to them??
Time To Destination If they repeated what they have done in Hong Kong in New York, I believe NYPD will brutally crack them down.
Why are you making this public??!!
Exactly. Now the government nows
Arvin Lagaso Because they want US to take more refugees
Another attempt to smear the image of the Chinese government otherwise why published it as well as no attempt to blur the images. The secret pipeline leads to the US embassy in Hong Kong. It's a foregone conclusion. More violence will happen, a tactic to provoke the the Chinese government to order in their PLA so people like Pelosi can pressure the congress to enact some more laws to destabilize China.
So that these criminals can be caught and brought to justice. You think they should be allowed to go free after taking part in 5 months of vandalism, assault, and destruction?
they have snitches acting as protesters, chances are they already knew.
You are exposing them rather than helping them
Good. These criminals should be caught and arrested.
Here’s the logic. NYT doesn’t care whether these young ppl are safe or not, they are only interested in propaganda and their own political or financial interest. If these kids just escape, there’s no value, so they just publish this to tell their own story. Arent we suppose to discuss whether these young ppl are actually innocent, what charges is or isn’t legit if they are in other countries? Freedom is not free from charges for criminals.
Watch out - they are short of psychos so trying to recruit more idiots telling them they will be help to escape when fail. Which is a lie, evil intend.
the same 2 obvious chinese trolls replying to every comment lmfao :D
Duh they deserved it.
"secret network": exists
NYT: hold my beer
As a report, yes, it is very interesting and well produced. But what about the repercussions for protesters? Is not China more likely to invest on clamping down on these practices if she has the means to after this information is made public? What are the ethics of this? Or am I approaching this the wrong way?
I suspect China is well aware of this already
I'm sure NYT has internal measures when it comes to reporting sensitive issues to make sure that none of the people involved are harmed in any way be it the protestors in the vid or the reporters themselves. China can't touch them as much as they can't touch China and what I mean by that is China is powerful enough (and knows they are powerful enough) that things like protestors fleeing HK isn't something for them to worry about. That's why there is little to no progress despite all the pressure from HK protests. HK/China puppets will not give in to any pressure because it's very easy for them to stifle any progress.
If the US truly cared they should hand out immediate Green Cards to the US!
Hey There China will done nothing to them.
unless they are criminals. they must take responsibility. prison await them.
thats just common sense
The repercussions are that these criminals will be caught and arrested, and the world will be a safer place.
no blurring? ur exposing people to be arrested , erase this video
Its called human insurance. If the plan didnt go well, throw these people under the bus and slow down the HK or main land investigators as much as possible. The people behind them want a trail of distraction.
Why do you need to blur something that doesn't matter? It's not a secret. Anyone can leave HK or mainland China for that matter. If you believe the narrative that "people need to escape" then you are a sheep.
Exactly. This communist gov will arest these network and so the way for protesters will be closed and they will not be able to escape.
Never be afraid to raise your voice for honesty and truth and compassion against injustice and lying and greed. If people all over the world...would do this, it would change the earth.
Beautiful
Thanks
The earth will be doomed
J K gg I don’t like u ! You make whole thing boring
Aweso • 38 years ago then God bless China. truth is China did nothing wrong. justice for China.
Bruh there are two Chinese bots replying to these comments.
Now the Chinese sea police will stop and check every boat outbounding from Hongkong.
Hot take: they're doing Beijing a favour.
If the US truly cared they should hand out immediate Green Cards to the US!
@@jakelaw9768 The US Gov't is the perpetrator.
Really thankful NYT wasn't around during the days of the Underground Railroad. Videos like this are not helpful to people trying to flee for their lives.
I’m fairly certain that the government knows more about this than the public. Just like when a video of how to protect you valuables is posted up... the thieves know 10x more than the person making the video (unless that person is a professional thief that is).
Anything shown here would not amount to new insight for a government trying to piece together “where is everyone going?!”
The only informing is really to the public and what these kids are going through.
Maybe that's true. Maybe it isn't. If I were the one using this route to escape, I certainly wouldn't want a video put out about it. There may be subtle things in that video that show things or be that final missing piece that a government needed to shut the whole thing down. Since we don't know what they know, it's best for the safety of all involved to not show it.
LaRhonda Turner nothing bad or evil things happened like all of you think. there are no reasons they want to flee unless they are criminals. thats just common sense.
they would not be feeling for their lives if they didn't go against the law in he first place.
@@LaRhondaTurner Shifting public opinion and informing your peers is very important, protesters know this better than anyone else. It's not like the NYT did not warn them, I'm sure these brave people did this with the full knowledge of the risks involved.
And about the government not knowing about this, are we talking about the same China that disappears journalists and librarians, that has already implemented a nation wide Orwellian tracking system that totally controls and imprisons millions? Of course they knew about it, they have more forced informants and spies than the entire population of Hong Kong....
you should have kept the church/priest anonymous as well! wtf you are endangering their whole plan and that priest
priest = NGO. Lock the fake priest up.
If the US truly cared they should hand out immediate Green Cards to the US!
The church is well known. They sheltered the first batch of protesters. They all returned to HK tho after they ran out of money.
@Gen Info IDK. There are a lot of circumstantial evidence NED is funding the riot. But I am not sure who's funding them. But if they are out of HK, there is no reason for NED to fund them.
5:19 I see a cross drawn on the pillar.
This reminds me of the revolution in Romania, in which many Christians were involved. They were singing hymns as they gathered, just like in Hong Kong.
Search Results
Web results
1 Samuel 18:27 Read it and understand what true Christianity is all about.
People's Power Revolution in the Phillipines overthrowing Marcos had backup from the Catholic Church as well, IIRC...
@Richard Yang I didn't say all protesters are Christian. In times like these evil people take advantage of the chaos and frenzy and go crazy.
Not all protesters are the same. From my understanding most are peaceful.
Richard Yang Are you sure? I saw many shelter those who are pro-Beijing.Additionally when questioned they could not speak any Cantonese. Suspicious much?
These rioters should be brought to justice
Yes the police should be brought to justice for allowing a dictator to control them
doesn't the USA support them? why not go to the USA?
Andy Y because America is long distant
And because of trumps cruel immigration program
@@reveranttangent1771 There is a special category for immigrants fleeing oppression, imprisonment and a threat to the life of the person. These people can apply for asylum
in the US. Because of the sympathy we feel here for the Hong Kong people, I think fleeing Hong Kongers stand a good chance of becoming a permanent resident and eventually, citizenship. In any case, while the case is pending they can stay in the US. The problem though is money, getting a job, etc. I'm sure there are churches here which would help.
@@wangjim3361 You do not have to get to the US. Basically, You can escape to any countries that don't have a strong relationship with China and seek Asylum with or without a passport. That said without a passport it'll be harder to get out of Hong Kong. But after you're out, Your physical body is free.
America doesn't like dogs!
let send 1 million of HK protesters to Taiwan for good.
China has a woman shortage, mainlanders don't mind sucking each other off
Do u really think Taiwan government wants them??
Taiwan government keeps them for temporary is because they want these hk protesters fool's to go on hunting China.
After a while they will be kick back to hk for jail!!!
shut up with ur winnie the pooh leaders
Can't hurt to get some cheap labour
just don't let the chinese gov see this lmfao
@The beast Is here true dat
Why? These protesters leaving HK is exactly what ccp wants lol. Meaning those who dont leave are pro beijing
It’s treason act... not sorry
The beast Is here if China does t care it should let go. If not HK, no one will accept fake Monopoly money RMB. HOng Kong banks help the CCP launder BILLIONS overseas, no one will do that for the, except HK
E PD wait... how much stuff did Amazon sellers manufacture out of Chinese blood and sweat? Just saying
You can run, but you cannot hide....
They don't need to hide they run so that they can come back to make you run if you or anyone else wanna take their freedom. The world is with the brave people of Hong Kong not the genocidal criminal state of china!
They say their trying to help em but it’s the opposite, making this.
They are loans people .They can not paid then you know what is going to happen
They did the crime, but don't want to do the time!
what crime have the majority done other than defending their City?
Laws are suppose to protect the people. If the laws fails to do that, it is the duty of the people to disobey it.
Is that something too much of an American concept for your little brain to wrap your head around with, Mainlander?
well if you wanna make a change in the society, gotta have the courage to face the consequences.
however hard it is, take the responsibility, don't leave that to other people.
made the city a mess then running away, how childish.
ale? ?? Exactly! Instead they create a sh*tstorm and cowardly run.
You are talking about normal people. These are spoiled brats. Can't even clean up after themselves.
ale? ?? true
Thank you, kind people of Taiwan! Hope the US or Germany can give them refugee status.
Taiwan already decided to send them back to Hong Kong. 😂😂
@@user-ej9dw7qs8m Really, and the source ?
US won't even help their neighbor
We Americans hate antifa, and as such we hate Chinese antifa... you can keep the trash we do not want it
you can Hope all you want But USA will NEVER expect you!!!!
I’m serious their privacy is extremely important the consequences of you showing their identity is EXACTLY like killing them, in time they have a great chance to suffer extreme repercussions by the extremely strict Chinese government..
You get what you give, fair deal...
send them all to the US. maybe there's some MRT station that need remodelling?
I have moved to and sleeping in my husband's 'parent' 's house in Ireland, and I have nightmares of my dad and stepmom and exams EVERY SINGLE DAY. The therapist says that I have used up all the 12 sessions so her boss say they can't see me any more.
Good for you that the church has a good psychiatrist.
These cowards said they wanna free HongKong, but what they doing right now are abandoning their own home.
Michael Gu what else could they do then
@@hyeokjinkim6297 stay in Hongkong!
why you didn’t come up with why they are untested ??? Why they should flee?? Ok. Let’s talk “ stand with HK? If this is their belief , why they can’t stick to that no matter what price they should pay for?
Don't run...cowards! You can run, but you can't hide!
If you believe in karma, make sure in life, you do right by all, otherwise your Karma will follow you some day.
No I don't as there is no love or grace, or forgivness to sins in 'kama'. Belive on the Lord Jesus Christ only. But there are consequences which is NOT the same thing.
@@ShaneM7075 Whether you believe it or not! You will never understand the damage you did to someone else until the same thing is done to you and that's why I'm here. Karma
Sincerely,
BOOK OF PROSPERITY
You lot said you fight to free Hong Kong and not afraid of what's coming but end off the day you run off and hide.
it is immoral to disclose the details at this very moment of time!
Why? These criminals need to be caught and face justice.
@@fluxmuldar Criminals? You mean the CHINAZI CCP? Sure, detain 1million XinJiangers and oragan harvesting them is certainly Criminals!
@celtic barbarian They? U mean the Chinazi CCP? Yes, They are the EVIL FACIST!
Doing wrong is moral?
courage to the people of Hong Kong!
they should all be jailed. 痞監啦仆街
These so called hongkongers say they are protecting the HongKong’s rule of law. And now when they are facing the charges, they escape? The HongKong juridical system is separated from the HongKong police, if they are so against the extradition bill, then stay and enjoy the justice in HongKong.
I don't believe you you have seen nothing.
Habib Hash it’s called logic.
ccp control hong kong
You reap what you sow, isn't it. Are they expecting US Congress to fight for them in the middle of impeachment process?
I stand with Hong Kong.
thx
Freedom is not free. You all will be remembered by the future generation just like we remember our freedom fighters. Stay strong Hong Kong. Indians are with you.
Haha. Funny how criminals become paranoid. Whah. I suppose these sheeple never thought things through to this end.
Timbuck Too Ok Commie
关门 I bet he’s actually just an American who doesn’t like foreigners😂
@@Scriptum. 2 guesses, both wrong! Regardless of that. You just don't get it Eoghan. Hk's problems are created by the same hidden people that are causing problems globally.
France,Iran, South American countries...just to name a few. It does NOT matter who your government is or what ideology they follow. They are all corrupt. All following the same agenda.
These young people are destroying their own futures and their home for the globalist.
Timbuck Too Oh okay fair enough man, so can you please show me where you found this information? It sounds like you’re onto something big there.
@@Scriptum. You can find these online in pdf for free.
"The Pawns in the Game" William Carr
"The Creature from Jekyll Island" Edward Griffin
Research online "the history of the Kazarian Mafia"
You protest but afraid the consequences.
Please send all of these people to the US.
Journalism at someone's expense.
Eeerrrm, don't we call these networks, people smugglers!
Tony At Google human trafficking yes lol
“Freedom traffickers” lmao. Put the word freedom in front of anything to make it sound better.
Why report this if it’s a secret?
If they are doing sth right as they claimed, why flee?! They’ve committed massive crimes and that’s why they are trying to run away!
Minions of the CIA
Taiwan is teaching the protesters to go ahead and go against the law and destroy everything, after that you will be rescued. But then how far will Taiwan go to help those rioters and risk their own island? that is the big question. It is easy to say hey rioters we support you... but for Taiwan to really go all out to protect and help them...???????
Laws should be made on the will of people. What is the point of making a law that makes 3 million people protest against it?
@@lonelyboyll08 out of 7 million people, 3 million protested... 4 million people followed the law. if law will just be on the will of the people.. then just don't make any laws at all.. what is the point of making laws when it will just be for the will of the people. law is made to be followed for the security of a place.. not for the whims of the people.. that is called privilege.. not law.
@@yumyumhotsauce you're kidding right? you know that 4 million out of 7 million people accept the law because they didn't protest? think again! A law that makes more than 10% of the people spend time to go on protest would be considered a failure! And by the way, if the law made for "security" of the place but make people living feel "unsecured". What is the point?
@@lonelyboyll08 th-cam.com/video/chYRAbqtStk/w-d-xo.html
@@lonelyboyll08 no one needs people like you in HK go to some lawless land and be a happy living thing there
today, HK people who wanted to escape are now trapped in the city forever...
so when she goes out and joins in on illegal activities she gets arrested, well guess what it also happens in my country :/
bob down true. these immature kids think they can get away with everything. its only fair criminals pay for their crime. its only prison of course. it just common sense
It is a necessary step to stop chaos caused by HK mobs.
What is the best way to donate to protesters and help them with their safety?
News & Politics? Wrong channel category, NYT lads.
This is actually a Gourmet show: Tasty & Exotic~Oriental Human-Blood-Soaked Bun, The Favorite Cuisine of Western Journalist.
This video shows how irresponsible those riots could be. They started the rioting and try to escape from the punishment.
Economy in HK is destroyed by them, and then they flee away.
And now I can tell why they hate that bill so much.
god bless
May God bless them and the innocent please!
They're Rioters and Terrorists. God will NOT bless them.
Well, the US see themselves as the God of this world, sanctioning any country that doesn't agree with them.
Nella MC God bless China. China is innocent
You reap what you saw.Rest assured,God is a just God and you can count on Him.
Freedom isn't free God bless from Australia
Yeah, like you'd know that. Didn't't your government take all of your guns away Auzzie? Why don't you support the destruction of your own country?
Yeah, let's have semi-automatic guns so that we can fight against the government who can use heavy armoured tanks, battleships and military aircrafts to decimate dissidents in case they turn evil while risking having hundreds of mass shootings per year.
Eugene Dowling God bless China from Indonesia
America is the best place for them
If they were rioting on the streets then the cops should arrest them.
Maybe NYT can do a sympathic video on Julian Assange and wikileaks?
NYT: Sorry, we're not familiar with telling the truth,you're asking too much of American journalism. Now please enjoy our anti-Chinese propaganda and soak yourself in the fantasy of 'independent thinking'.
why would you wanna trace this unless you have motives ?
Public caning should be introduced !
Yes! Just like in free and democratic Singapore, the apple of America's eye in Southeast Asia, from where a local 16 year old TH-camr (Amos Yee) sought and was granted political asylum in the US for fear of government harassment. They'll even impose the death penalty if you like. Yay!
Ever heard of operation yellow bird? Same thing happened years ago.
People of HK put the word out and I will fly over to help you fight for your home.
How do I contribute? I would like to see all the protesters leave HK.
Give them money to fly to the US?... idk most of them can afford a flight np
@@jackl2257 Just in case any are stupid enough to do the U.S. work without getting paid by the CIA/NED
@@disconnectxd7344 The HK rioters group is basically structured like a pyramid. The top 'leaders' are offered huge money,fame or the opportunity to study in Yale by CIA-related NGOs ;The medium 'warriors(勇武)' receive daily payments and dope from them. The lowest rank called 'brothers(手足)'， most of them are exactly 'stupid enough to do the U.S. work without getting paid by the CIA/NED'. @Bob Grout just want to help these nice young men who don't have money or brain to leave HK ASAP.
Serve them right after committing such atrocious violence to HK, their own city.
Says the guy sitting from the comfort of his own home in a democratic country.
Jay democracy create degeneracy. Dictatorship is better
How can they wave the American or Brit flag but not be able to speak English, when it's basically the 2nd official language on the island. This is strange.
2:53 was shocking to see the guy she interview suddenly gets wild explaining to reporter?
WTF, you break the law and made a decision so you should suffer the consequences.
Come to Montana. We love people who love freedom and human rights
Ready for the 50% house price rise
Oh an interesting story of how people are fleeing oppression. Let's show all the landmarks and some people so that the oppressors can dismantle the whole thing.
It seems a lot of people are fleeing Hong Kong. Seems along with this story, some civilians have also been fleeing due to the violence of some of the rioters, especially due to stories of some protestors setting a man on fire, beating up a Japanese man because they thought he was Han Chinese, and knocking a man out with a manhole cover.
Han Chinese students fled the university awhile back in fears of discrimination.
I hope all innocent civilians there stays safe on both sides.
So they are effectively escaping from jail time after setting buildings on fire and destroying public properties? How is this justified?
In the U.S., you would be arrested and sent to jail immediately.
Hong Kong was number 3 in the world human freedom index, I guess they want to be number 1 !?!??!
So, the protesters that flee are learning to speak Madarin in Taiwan when they refused to speak it in Hong Kong.
Hilarious. So true!
raven scott
Err, you realise there’s no such language as Taiwanese, right? Right? Lol
raven scott
Are you nuts? People in Taiwan speak numerous Chinese dialects, the vast majority of whom speak Mandarin. The majority of Han people are also ethnically Chinese who arrived from, yup, you guessed it, China. Only marginalised aboriginal Taiwanese ethnic minorities can claim that they aren’t Chinese, and even then they speak Mandarin nowadays. There is simply no question otherwise lol
Well said..
One day when a loved one in HK is about to pass away and you are not able to return is when you will really wonder what was the purpose of it all... Better to make peace and move on...
correct.better to be a law abiding citizen.if you dont like Hk then just leave.
FUN FACT :
Palestinians throwing rocks at idf is also 10 years.
They know the score, the IDF is defending itself against terrorists.
@@ShaneM7075 that's outrageous
@@ShaneM7075 While the HK police what exactly was doing?
Why is there music in the background? This is not fiction, Vice and other news orgs do this. I don't think they should.
If your intuition is whispering you "Don't go there!", never go there. If your intuition is whispering you "Go this way!", go there. If your intuition is whispering you "Don't do that!", never do that. If your intuition is whispering you "Do it!", be sure to do it.
Whenever you igore your intuition, you will be in trouble. But if you really listen to your ituition and follow it, you will be amazed what you can do and how well you can do it.
What about wrong intuition?
You all just got exposed....you can never run from law.
So do they regret being so reckless and be so violent to the ordinary citizens of Hong Kong and the Police in Hong Kong? Happy punishing yourself since you have chosen to be so violent against the Hong Kong people.
These criminals need to be extradited back to Hong Kong to face justice.
@thatrabbitguy what is your logic? You don't make sense. Please explain yourself.
Hongkongers always welcome to Taiwan! 加油香港!
Ask your president to pass the refugee law then.
@@toy4tao r/sino, back you go.
Assisting criminals is akin to involvement in their crimes.
Those rioters are cowards.
Do not come back! Stay there for rest of your life!
1000s arrested for RIOTING.
Sunzi once said,"Know your enemy, know yourself, and you shall not fear a hundred battles." So study well the organisation and the tactics of riot police. Never fight against their strongest point with your weakest point! Be sure to fight against their weakest point with your strongest point. Do it this way, the victory will certainly be yours!
Too young to understand the completicated politics in Hongkong and the world. If you did not respect the Chinese history. What ever you do will lead to fail.
Fighting for democracy is about changing a lifestyle that , one thinks, would bring more harmony and peace for the sake of the society. Such fight is successful when the leaders in place are ready to accept change , and change takes time.
But when it comes to causing turbulence, havoc, damaging public buildings, hurting and beating passers-by, well this kind of action is tantamount to anarchy and terrorism.
I hope you are getting my point.
Dare to riot but not take the consequences of the British rule of law. Even a pastor is a lover of rioting.
LT L you're a lover of voice rioting..
Britain should not have left us.
This video is OK, all the HKers have been blured, only the Taiwan pastor isn't blured. But the problem is it has showed how HKers escape HK TO hK gov. Just like BBC's stream showed how protesters in PolyU swing down the bridge and escape, that police can block the road on time.
These youngsters have been used and depression will creeps in. The donors will not be so generous as time prolongs.
And Taiwan who had been fueling them to revolt in HK will not be their savior.
May I request a report on the recent developments in India ? It would be enlightening to observe an unbiased report from acclaimed international media.
All I see are sad, cowardly criminal fugitives.
Not easy
China: this seems interesting *clicks video*
Press RB to throw back
It takes a lot of skill to catch a protester's Molotov without having it smash onto the concrete and achieve nothing.
Come to the US on refugee visa. US welcomes every visa except fiancee and spouse visas !!!
now they know
It just doesn't make sense to me.
No self justification can cover the fact they were rioting. Yesterday 2 homemade bombs were found by HK police. So they have moved from rioting to terrorism. In life, everyone needs to be responsible for decisions and actions, don't blame anyone else or society.
2 only? Gonna need to make millions of these for self defence. Hope they share with the rest on how to make such defensive tools.
How much were the HK popo paid to find these bombs by Beijing? Chicoms are criminal thugs like LCN but a very large scale. China can't have a great leap forward anymore with spy sats ovdrhead. In a decade they'll implode like the commie USSR did. Its already started. USA NGOs will assist as requested.