Gin is famous for “eating CD” in the Cantopop scene, as her live singing sounds exactly like her studio versions (or even better). I was there the exact same night of this performance (her solo concert) - she sounded amazing. The other one on the contrary, well, no comments. 🙂 Gurl can write melodies tho, gotta give it to her
Yay, Gin Lee, a Malaysia-born HK-based singer. In the video《Gin Lee New Beginning Music Live 2023》she sings in Cantonese, Mandarin, English and Japanese. Her rendition of《Superwoman》is simply amazing. In 2010 she spent 3 months learning Cantonese intensively and by 2011 she became a fluent Cantonese speaker and released her first Cantonese EP in HK. She is currently the best female singer in HK. Gin was the singing coach and mentor of Gigi Yim (who you have reviewed) when Gigi was in a singing competition and ended up winning.
Gin is known for her perfect pitch. She is never pitchy. She practices 1000 times before each performance and holds herself to an impossibly high standard. I think the female host (face not shown) meant Aga when she said Gin has been pitchy.
Thank you for the reaction to Gin Lee, It’s much-anticipated❤️ I’ve been listening to Gin Lee since her debut in Hong Kong. She never disappoints audiences! It’s so good to know the upcoming video is “Heart-Wrenching” of Gin while she was participating in “The Voice of China”. This performance was almost 10 years ago, Gin has been gaining more experience and more confidence in performing different songs, whatever her songs or cover. If you all feel interested in Gin Lee, Please check out her recent performance as well!
This was taken from Gin Lee's 2018 Solo Live Concert《First Of All》in HK and AGA was her guest. You definitely should check out her more recent live performances. I recommend (again) her rendition of《Superwoman》in《Gin Lee New Beginning Music Live 2023》(from 39:47). Apart from singing in Cantonese, Mandarin and English, she also released her first Japanese Pop song early this week.
I remember gin lee from the voice. Shes one of my favourite singer from that show. I kept looking up if she had any more works or show shes on, that are on youtube and there just wasnt much. I thought she kinda stopped and felt it was such a shame. I'm glad shes still singing. I think the last I've seen of her was that show that was something about the Grammys, and it had CuiJian who do rarely appear on tv. I really thought shes one of those great singers that came out of the voice that just fade away and I'm only one of not too many people that appreciates her but reading these lyrics,I'm really glad that so many shares the sentiment. Hope to see more of her works
Gin's live performance is always so amazing! Thanks for the comments and looking forward to the next episode on reaction to Gin's 心痛. In fact, there is a recent version of 心痛 sang by Gin, which I think is a better version of the version years ago. th-cam.com/video/LSZe3Hof4X0/w-d-xo.html at time 1:32:00
did the girl behind the camera mistake gin lee as aga? as gin lee's well known for her accuracy in pitch. in contrast though, aga has really been pitchy in live performances these recent days
Rozette, Thank you so much for commenting on Gin Lee and AGA!!! I literally DM’d you on IG and ask you to talk about Gin Lee in May, finally see you talk about her. Gin Lee is an amazing an talented singer, not only she sings very well, her attitude towards singing is much worth learning. AGA is an experienced singer, but she has some bad habits in vocal which affects her singing. So she needs more improvements and adjustments in her vocal. Btw, hope you can comment on singers and singing performances more directly and straight forward. Don’t worry too much about how fans think, we loved to know your truth thoughts and opinions on them and also how they can improve and sing better.
We used to listen to this song in McDonald's stores... We jokingly say that the songs of AGA and Gin Lee are full of the savory taste of the French fries or the Big Mac! Both of them are great singers and thank you for commenting on their singing! AGA has composed this song (remarkably, she wrote ALL of her songs which is extremely rare in HL) and Gin is also a singer-songwriter for some time.
I guess vocal coaches are meant to be more critical of other vocal coaches? Maybe intimidated by Gin's voice, talent and skills? The lady hardly comments on AGA who does not even open her mouth when she "sings", but keeps picking on Gin "I can appreciate her, but...", "mushy mushy", "it’s edited". Gin is a great live performer, give credit where credit is due. Of course, there’s always room for improvement for every singer, but being so nitpicking when hearing someone for the first time is not normal behaviour. I always have reservation on whether it's appropriate for someone to judge singing performances in languages they don't speak. This has confirmed the answer is “no”. It’s just not possible for them to appreciate the nuances and subtleties of the particular languages and how the pronunciation can be manipulated to express different emotions and tones. I have a feeling this lady will be very harsh on Gin’s performances in English. I won’t be watching any of her reaction on non-English songs anymore. “This must be Cantonese because of the “oi” sound", that's pretty disrespectful. Just ask your sidekicks what language it is for goodness’ sake. Also, why the hell the sidekicks keep picking performances from years ago?
Hi, your comment at the end says Gin performances was pitchy in recent numerous video.i.e. Gin Lee singing her own songs out of tune? Oh please! Please do more research before commenting innocuously just for the sake of stamping your mark. 😅
I would say, Gin is one of the most skillful vocalists in Hong Kong nowadays. And she's very versatile in terms of genre. While Aga is more known for her songwriting and music-making. Vocal and technique wise, she's not on par with a lot of other singers.
Gin Lee is a really good singer and she works a lot on her singing skills. I wish to see more comments on her latest performance which I think it’s even better!! AGA never open her mouth round and wide to sing so it sounds stiff
They are the new generation of HK singers. People like Jacky or Eason or Sandy has been in the business over 20 and 30 years so their singing is more old style.
Years ago I would feel this performance was outstanding. But not now! I would still listen. But at the most once. Anyway, nothing wrong with the good singers especially Gin L. My taste has changed
Gin Lee 李幸倪 is Malaysian! Just curious has coach Rozette review on Gabriel Enrique before? “I wanna know what love is”… “Vision of Love”… “I have nothing” just to name a few great songs cover by Gabriel.
Did Flo happen to mix up Gin and Aga's name? Gin has always been known as a consistent and stable performer (even before her noted improvement on delivery and expression in recent years). Meanwhile Aga... hmm, let's just say haha I'm way more drawn to Gin - stylistically, artistically and pure vocal ability 🤪
Can you react for some of NMIXX stage practice ? They’re singing raw while doing the choreography, maybe you’re not used to this kind of videos but it may be a nice change , they have few but I’ll recommend run for roses , Dash , love me like this , these are more vocal based songs but you can totally watch what you want
Finally Gin Lee! But I don't think this is not a good live / good performance for comment. Gin Lee can perform much better & attractive than this live! Take a look at her recent live performance: th-cam.com/video/eGpxDPvJVRA/w-d-xo.html
終於是Gin lee 等了很久
Gin Lee is from Malaysia but she became popular and active in HK.
I loveeee Gin! She's so so talented and technically brilliant. One of the best Canto singers right now.
Finally!! The top tier vocalist of HK, Gin Lee
雖然都係top，但係我覺得Janice更勝一籌
Gin is famous for “eating CD” in the Cantopop scene, as her live singing sounds exactly like her studio versions (or even better). I was there the exact same night of this performance (her solo concert) - she sounded amazing. The other one on the contrary, well, no comments. 🙂 Gurl can write melodies tho, gotta give it to her
Yay, Gin Lee, a Malaysia-born HK-based singer. In the video《Gin Lee New Beginning Music Live 2023》she sings in Cantonese, Mandarin, English and Japanese. Her rendition of《Superwoman》is simply amazing. In 2010 she spent 3 months learning Cantonese intensively and by 2011 she became a fluent Cantonese speaker and released her first Cantonese EP in HK. She is currently the best female singer in HK. Gin was the singing coach and mentor of Gigi Yim (who you have reviewed) when Gigi was in a singing competition and ended up winning.
Her performance of《Superwoman》in the same concert, First of All 2018 is amazing alsooo
i love 《Gin Lee New Beginning Music Live 2023》too. The japanese and english songs.
Gin Lee is truly a talented and hardworking singer. I really like her and hope to see more of her on your channel in the future.❤
Gin is known for her perfect pitch. She is never pitchy. She practices 1000 times before each performance and holds herself to an impossibly high standard. I think the female host (face not shown) meant Aga when she said Gin has been pitchy.
终于等到gin lee❤
Thank you for the reaction to Gin Lee, It’s much-anticipated❤️
I’ve been listening to Gin Lee since her debut in Hong Kong. She never disappoints audiences! It’s so good to know the upcoming video is “Heart-Wrenching” of Gin while she was participating in “The Voice of China”. This performance was almost 10 years ago, Gin has been gaining more experience and more confidence in performing different songs, whatever her songs or cover. If you all feel interested in Gin Lee, Please check out her recent performance as well!
More gin lee please 🤩🤩
This was taken from Gin Lee's 2018 Solo Live Concert《First Of All》in HK and AGA was her guest. You definitely should check out her more recent live performances. I recommend (again) her rendition of《Superwoman》in《Gin Lee New Beginning Music Live 2023》(from 39:47). Apart from singing in Cantonese, Mandarin and English, she also released her first Japanese Pop song early this week.
@@sullivaninoz I would also like a more recent solo live performance review of Gin
終於等到Gin Lee，這首很好聽❤
很堅強 都值得一聽。
職聽一定聽gin lee.
Can’t wait to hear Gin !
希望會有C All Star 🙏🏻 佢哋真係各有特色，各個都好聽，加埋合唱又好聽
係四條友各有缺點，但係合起來可以互補😢
Ahh.... Finally coach reacts to Gin Lee. Thank you so much. Her version of "Superwoman" is nice too.
Gin Lee❤️❤️❤️
I remember gin lee from the voice. Shes one of my favourite singer from that show. I kept looking up if she had any more works or show shes on, that are on youtube and there just wasnt much. I thought she kinda stopped and felt it was such a shame. I'm glad shes still singing. I think the last I've seen of her was that show that was something about the Grammys, and it had CuiJian who do rarely appear on tv.
I really thought shes one of those great singers that came out of the voice that just fade away and I'm only one of not too many people that appreciates her but reading these lyrics,I'm really glad that so many shares the sentiment. Hope to see more of her works
2:30 討論的地方是錯的... 原曲也是D F F C Bb🥲
終於到gin lee!😭
Can we have some more technical, showy songs from Gin please? For some ideas - 以愛情的罪名，Falling，今天終於一人回家，後人類的美麗與哀愁? Thank you!
It’s Gin Lee finally! The best vocalist in Hong Kong!
她已是best vocalist in HK 唉！香港
Gin Lee is the best 🎉🎉
Everyone vote for Gin Lee please!!!!!!!!!!
Gin Lee is the best Malaysian female singer performing in Hong Kong!
Gin Lee is really a nice singer! Hope to see more reaction videos please😍😍😍
WOW, Gin Lee!!! Hope to see more of her.
Gin 是馬來西亞華人啊，當初是隻身來香港發展，在香港才慢慢學習粵語，她不是香港土生土長的
More Gin Lee please!
支持GIN!!! 可以聽下新歌無彩色!!日文!!!
Gin's live performance is always so amazing! Thanks for the comments and looking forward to the next episode on reaction to Gin's 心痛. In fact, there is a recent version of 心痛 sang by Gin, which I think is a better version of the version years ago.
th-cam.com/video/LSZe3Hof4X0/w-d-xo.html
at time 1:32:00
Gin Lee is actually from malaysia but she started her career in Hong Kong
可以react 李幸倪 月球下的人
就喜歡這種輕聲呢喃說故事的吟唱
Gin is the best!
did the girl behind the camera mistake gin lee as aga? as gin lee's well known for her accuracy in pitch. in contrast though, aga has really been pitchy in live performances these recent days
Yes!!!! Gin’s live performance is so good. Not sure why she said Gin has pitch problem
Absolutely spot on. Give credit where is due.
I am huge fan of Gin Lee 😊😊
@@parisman711 me too
me 3
Hope can react to Gin’s solo!❤
Rozette, Thank you so much for commenting on Gin Lee and AGA!!! I literally DM’d you on IG and ask you to talk about Gin Lee in May, finally see you talk about her. Gin Lee is an amazing an talented singer, not only she sings very well, her attitude towards singing is much worth learning.
AGA is an experienced singer, but she has some bad habits in vocal which affects her singing. So she needs more improvements and adjustments in her vocal.
Btw, hope you can comment on singers and singing performances more directly and straight forward. Don’t worry too much about how fans think, we loved to know your truth thoughts and opinions on them and also how they can improve and sing better.
AGA 有一個非常明顯的壞習慣, 就是不打開口唱, 所以聽起來很緊很生硬🤐
腹語系歌手😂
扯頸腹語
Aga唱功暫時只適合幕後😂
@@AK-ce6zv 好聽 不過 哈哈
真
i think you can compare the song 手望(守望版), singing by 王苑之&張敬軒. Another version by Gee Lee and Mike.
Same that would wonderful
我想要的側田什麽時候有？😭😭😭
Gin Lee !finally
We used to listen to this song in McDonald's stores... We jokingly say that the songs of AGA and Gin Lee are full of the savory taste of the French fries or the Big Mac! Both of them are great singers and thank you for commenting on their singing! AGA has composed this song (remarkably, she wrote ALL of her songs which is extremely rare in HL) and Gin is also a singer-songwriter for some time.
Gin Lee!
@難聽歌手俱樂部 waiting for your comment!!!
😂😂😂😂
gin lee the best
I guess vocal coaches are meant to be more critical of other vocal coaches? Maybe intimidated by Gin's voice, talent and skills? The lady hardly comments on AGA who does not even open her mouth when she "sings", but keeps picking on Gin "I can appreciate her, but...", "mushy mushy", "it’s edited". Gin is a great live performer, give credit where credit is due. Of course, there’s always room for improvement for every singer, but being so nitpicking when hearing someone for the first time is not normal behaviour. I always have reservation on whether it's appropriate for someone to judge singing performances in languages they don't speak. This has confirmed the answer is “no”. It’s just not possible for them to appreciate the nuances and subtleties of the particular languages and how the pronunciation can be manipulated to express different emotions and tones. I have a feeling this lady will be very harsh on Gin’s performances in English. I won’t be watching any of her reaction on non-English songs anymore. “This must be Cantonese because of the “oi” sound", that's pretty disrespectful. Just ask your sidekicks what language it is for goodness’ sake. Also, why the hell the sidekicks keep picking performances from years ago?
竟然react这首我超爱的歌！
Please do a review on Gin’s version of Superwoman (first of all live)
Hi, your comment at the end says Gin performances was pitchy in recent numerous video.i.e. Gin Lee singing her own songs out of tune? Oh please! Please do more research before commenting innocuously just for the sake of stamping your mark. 😅
Maybe do a reaction for Gin Lee singing SUPERWOMAN from older competition to newer in her concert
求re Gin的《Superwoman》
Pls pick more solo from Gin thks
AGA❤❤❤❤
I would say, Gin is one of the most skillful vocalists in Hong Kong nowadays. And she's very versatile in terms of genre.
While Aga is more known for her songwriting and music-making. Vocal and technique wise, she's not on par with a lot of other singers.
Gin Lee is Malaysian.
Gin Lee is a really good singer and she works a lot on her singing skills. I wish to see more comments on her latest performance which I think it’s even better!!
AGA never open her mouth round and wide to sing so it sounds stiff
Need to give kudos to the host this time she did a bit background search for Rozette and it’s accurate.
老师今天送福利了
想看 老師評容祖兒的破相(難道好高）
Gin Lee is exceptional!! ♥♥
❤❤❤
對不起 我對李幸倪的印象只有紅塵客棧 和那位大俠 印象太深刻了
They are the new generation of HK singers. People like Jacky or Eason or Sandy has been in the business over 20 and 30 years so their singing is more old style.
阿GIN係來至馬來西亞唔係香港 不過佢學港式廣東話用咗好短時間
Wanna see Jay Fung x 衛蘭 review .. both English and canto songs 🤗
Gin lee唱英文歌都好
Years ago I would feel this performance was outstanding. But not now! I would still listen. But at the most once. Anyway, nothing wrong with the good singers especially Gin L. My taste has changed
我都想听下点评价AGA
Gin Lee 李幸倪 is Malaysian!
Just curious has coach Rozette review on Gabriel Enrique before? “I wanna know what love is”… “Vision of Love”… “I have nothing” just to name a few great songs cover by Gabriel.
我想老師一定喜歡
Aga 圓 這首歌
Please consider Malaysia singer Jaclyn Victor with her live performance "Cinta tiada akhirnye".
Her version of “Gemilang”in Malaysia Idol is the best.
Ivana Wong 留白！😂
想睇盛夏光年。陳冰同艾薇
Wyman 之前有讚 Moon Tang 唱歌咬字清楚, 新一代唱得清楚D字但又smooth 好似冇乜
What about Jade Kwan 以身試愛❤
Did Flo happen to mix up Gin and Aga's name? Gin has always been known as a consistent and stable performer (even before her noted improvement on delivery and expression in recent years). Meanwhile Aga... hmm, let's just say haha I'm way more drawn to Gin - stylistically, artistically and pure vocal ability 🤪
哟改日期了，本来20让我以为19re周深
Please react Daryl Ong he's brilliant Singer from the Philippines... TNX 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🙏🙏🇵🇭
Can you react for some of NMIXX stage practice ? They’re singing raw while doing the choreography, maybe you’re not used to this kind of videos but it may be a nice change , they have few but I’ll recommend run for roses , Dash , love me like this , these are more vocal based songs but you can totally watch what you want
感覺你們最近出片速度好像比之前慢了！
WE NEED FAOUZIA REACTION
大部分大马人本身都会说广东话了😂
@@glexgino Gin Lee原本係唔識講廣東話，佢自己有講過，係嚟到香港踢館之後決定留喺香港發展先學廣東話，一開始錄歌都未係好識講廣東話，後尾佢仲去報中大嘅廣東話課程。
唔係所有馬來西亞人都識講廣東話，而且就算識講，佢哋講嘅廣東話同香港講嘅廣東話都有唔同。
其实并不是哦。要看你在哪里生长。
我本身家庭就是讲广东话，但身边很多朋友来自柔佛、吉兰丹、槟城等等，都不太能说广东话。即使有些能说的，也非常不标准，甚至会不小心发音像脏话。
而Gin刚好就是柔佛人。她在出道时真的不会说广东话。没记错的话，她的家庭主要是以英语和华语为主。
她说过，她在香港出道时，很努力去学习广东话发音。
*顺带一提：
现在因为中国节目的庞大影响，和香港娱乐圈的衰退，年轻一代的孩子已经不去学广东话。家长也选择跟孩子说华语。就如，我现在居住怡保（一个以广东话闻名的城市），但00后的孩子们基本都选择说华语。他们的广东话甚至会走音。
@@kwoo24 学校老师的错。。都不推动方言。。说方言还要被罚。。
@@kwoo24 对，我也是怡保人。现在基本两千后的年轻人都有些已经不会讲广东话就是讲华语。搞到我看到他们都不知道应该讲什么语言了🫣🫣
Finally Gin Lee! But I don't think this is not a good live / good performance for comment. Gin Lee can perform much better & attractive than this live!
Take a look at her recent live performance:
th-cam.com/video/eGpxDPvJVRA/w-d-xo.html
不知道為什麼說gin有些音準問題，係香港黎講 佢算係音準度好高既歌手
江海迦，唔係汪。
gin lee唱功算好,aga唔活躍同唔算受歡迎啦
AGA 是唱作歌手,親自作曲,不單止唱功
Aga 的鼻音太重。
未聽先估AGA唱歌方式老師唔中意
估錯了😂
自從某CHANNEL吹捧陳慧琳，我已經唔再信任佢所講的滿肚理論，總之好聽就好聽，信自己
希望老师评澳洲李安，逝去的爱，th-cam.com/video/iM-aIDyTpCs/w-d-xo.htmlsi=vJjrnfiAOsxPn5DE
♪(*^^)o∀*∀o(^^*)♪
想老師聽 Serrini的樹木真美、陳慧琳的超級小黑咪、和田光司的Butterfly
♪(*^^)o∀*∀o(^^*)♪
What超級小黑咪？
老师，请点评 周深-“ La Danza Del Dios Sol” 的歌。周深也在24小时就学会唱西班牙语了。🙏🙏🙏
老師一聽到Aga笑容都大不同 聽aga可以 不過不要跟她一齊唱 因為好似唱到壞習慣後悔想改掉就更難
希望會有許廷鏗
The song choices are getting weirder and weirder. What about Mike Zeng?
音準還是有問題。現場這樣可以了，
老師能不能聽一下陳蕾Panther Chan的歌
成日話aga 唔打開口唱歌，講得多就好似好大問題咁。人云亦云。
Aga 唱歌冇gin lee 咁好係事實，但真心唔覺Aga 唱歌難聽，正正常常，唔算差。