Robert Pirsig’s Metaphysics of Quality (Zen & the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2024
- Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Patreon: www.patreon.com/untimelyreflections
#nietzsche #philosophypodcast #thenietzschepodcast #history #philosophy #historyofphilosophy #zen #motorcyclemaintenance
Today we continue with our inquiry into rhetoric and dialectic, with Robert Pirsig’s Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. Pirsig, like Nietzsche, saw himself as a modern-day Sophist, and part of his work was the rescue of the Sophistic school from the ill repute visited upon them by the Socratics. Perhaps more expansively, Pirsig devotes his philosophical work to the question, “What is quality?”, drawing on the Greek concept of arete, or excellence. His philosophical ideas do not come to us through a dispassionate treatise, however, but through an autobiographical novel. Pirsig was treated with electroshock therapy, leaving him with a new personality, and the feeling that the person he once was is dead: he merely happens to carry the blurry memories of another man. While on a motorcycle trip with his son, Pirsig struggles to unify the dichotomy between classical and romantic, between substance and form, between the two personalities within himself, and between himself and his son. This work remains one of the most important philosophical contributions to American literature in the 20th century, and hopefully today I can show all of you why this work of “pop philosophy” is one of my favorite books, and one to which I regularly return.
00:00 📖 Robert Pirsig's "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" is a philosophical novel that challenges common sense intuitions and dogmas in Western philosophy, despite its title's misleading association with Zen and motorcycles.
03:08 📚 The book primarily delves into Western philosophical themes, tackling fundamental dichotomies in Western thought and the prejudices accepted by intellectuals.
06:19 🧠 Pirsig makes some claims about the uniqueness of his approach, but there are similarities between his ideas and those of Friedrich Nietzsche, particularly concerning the relativity of human values and the rejection of the subjective-objective split.
14:18 🤯 Pirsig's personal life was marked by high intelligence, an early expulsion from university, a military stint in Korea, a pursuit of Eastern philosophy, and eventually a descent into mental illness and electroshock therapy, which dramatically altered his personality.
21:52 🤔 Pirsig presents himself as two distinct characters in the book: "Fedis," his former personality, and "Robert Pirsig," his post-shock therapy self. He uses this duality to explore metaphysics of quality and challenge dichotomous thinking.
22:07 🤔 Robert Pirsig explores the tension between classical and romantic approaches to life in his novel, "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance."
27:30 📚 The central conflict of the novel revolves around the clash between classical and romantic modes of life and thinking, as well as the attempt to reconcile them.
40:00 🍺 Robert Pirsig's classical thinking is exemplified when he suggests using a beer can shim to fix a motorcycle handlebar, emphasizing functionality over aesthetics.
43:12 🤝 Pirsig aims to find unity between dualistic and non-dualistic modes of thought in his philosophical exploration, challenging the dichotomy between classical and romantic approaches.
44:49 📚 Pirsig criticizes Aristotle for dividing philosophy and natural philosophy, leading to the separation of metaphysics and the hard sciences.
46:09 🗣 Rhetoric is the art of persuasion and speaking beautifully; Pirsig's interest in quality arises from teaching rhetoric and questioning the concept of quality.
49:50 🧠 Quality is an essential element in human perception and experience, not just a subjective preference.
53:24 🌌 Quality is posited as a metaphysical principle that precedes the subject-object split, bridging the gap between mind and matter.
55:52 🧬 Quality is described as the stimulus-response to the environment, shaping the way we perceive and construct our world.
59:18 📚 Education should focus on motivating individuals to pursue quality in their lives, rather than imposing meaningless academic hurdles.
01:00:27 🏍 Gumption, or caring deeply about understanding, is key to mastering complex skills like motorcycle maintenance and pursuing quality.
01:04:37 🔍 Pirsig traces the evolution of the concept of the "Immortal Principle" from Greek gods to abstract ideas, leading to the separation of mind and matter.
01:06:12 🤔 The divisions between mind and matter, subject and object, are dialectical inventions that emerged later in philosophy, according to Pirsig.
01:07:19 🧐 Socrates was engaged in a philosophical battle between those who believed truth is absolute and those who thought truth is relative, with the sophists as opponents.
01:08:30 📜 The Greeks valued "ER" or Excellence in every aspect of life, making personal excellence a central concept in Greek morality.
01:09:54 💬 The sophists believed in debate as a clash of opposing perspectives, acknowledging the relativity of truth and perspectives.
01:10:36 👥 Pirsig points out that Socrates and Plato used emotionally persuasive language in their arguments, much like the sophists they criticized.
01:14:08 🐎 Aristotle introduced the concept of substance, valuing the individual appearances of things and their relation to unchanging forms.
01:16:09 🧩 Dialectic wrongly separates appearance from substance, failing to recognize their relativity.
01:21:25 🌍 The improvement of the world starts with individual values and the pursuit of quality in one's own heart and actions.
I read this book around 9 times and Im still elated to hear about it. Thank you for deciding on making a video on it.
when YOu read it 10 times more
you can make your own Video
This book saved my life.
Hands down best interpretation I’ve heard of this book. Really good stuff man.
to have this popped up in my feed was like a birthday present… I wish this guy would read the whole book love his voice
Really excellent,
Thankyou sir ❤
I was so excited the first time I saw a redwing blackbird. Also when i learned Bozeman was a real place.
They are fabulous birds, one showed up to me at the exact moment I needed an uplifting. That occurrence led me to get a tattoo that subsequently as I was walking around an artfair I met an artist from Asheville that asked Me slit my tattoo of the red winged blackbird and she asked if I had ever read zen and the art of motorcycle mainly which I had never heard of. I absolutely love the book and the red winged blackbird is definitely one of my favorite sky birds. They are just exciting to see!
I always interpreted the “this is a novel approach” … “i’m the first to ever think this way” type language was just describing what he thought in the moment, and in a way critiquing it. I think the whole point of the character Phaedrus is to critique himself and his line of thinking
It's been half a decade since I read that book. It's pretty horrifying to think about how subtle a 'life' may be, as in within the exposition here of electroshock therapy. If an electrical shock that is thoroughly non-fatal can 'kill' a man, what can a finely tuned set of social media algorithms do?
Thanks for doing this!
Pirsig has been a long time favorite. Glad to here that you're a fan too.
I love this book, work of art.
Without this podcast I would never have bought this book. Thx!
Also persigs notion of gumption relates to Nietzsche’s quote mans strength is related to the amount of truth one can handle
Fascinating. Never heard Nietzsche brought up in a Zen convo before, love it.
The motorcycle is an analogy to life. One man wants to only enjoy life, he buys a BMW and enjoy the ride. Mr. Pirsig wants to know what the life is and how it works, for the idea of him loosing one lifestyle and getting another is like the death and resurrection in religion. The idea is that each person is born with a unique structure of mind that seeks and understands the life in a unique way, but the situations in life might cause him to live otherwise. It is a good thing if he can live long enough to give up the accomplished life and to engage in a life according to his birth mind set. That is the good life.
Yes, a definitely a quality episode.
Pirsig shows us the root of the frustrations we have with our socio-political system.
A justice system overly concerned with technicalities, incomprehensible language. It’s a game where the slickest wins. We all know that’s not “ good “.
An education system where rote memorization of facts lasts just long enough to write a test. That’s not “ good “.
A beaurocacy focused putting out the right sounding press releases while passing responsibility elsewhere. Not “ good “.
Now all the twists and turns of manipulating language has led us to a place where you can change the meaning of words to whatever you like but still get the benefit of the old definition.
It’s time to put value back in our institutions and insist that there is a hierarchy of quality.
There are no moral facts and moral sentiments are for suckers.
This guy lived a straight Albert Camus novel
I haven’t finished this book yet because I’ve misplaced it but I’ve found it to be a pretty difficult read. I like the biographical parts of it and the practical wisdom of doing your own maintenance but maybe I’m just not smart enough to grasp some of these philosophical concepts. It seems very high brow to me but as soon as I find it I’ll keep on reading 😂
Your analysis is so complete I will subscribe.
The best and most readable books of philosophy have been written by those who were not professional academic philosophers , therefore Schopenhauer ( himself a systematic scholar ) very much despised professional philosophisers.
Wouldn’t have guessed this one . Thanks for all the surprising recommendations, from Coulanges to Michels
Really enjoyed this one
Aside from the great content, I really appreciate the audio quality ,something too many overlook in their presentations.
Thanks for creating this!
Read the book decades ago. The line "the only Zen you find on top of mountains is the Zen you bring with you" stuck. The answer, if there be such a thing, is internal, not external. Perhaps there is not even a question.
@untimelyreflections have you considered doing any videos on Max Stirner? Your analysis and voice are the complete package.
There seem to be documented cases where electroshock therapy caused or triggered a Dissociative Disorder, Pirsig’s description of having "the memories of another person" seems similar to dissociative people without full amnesia. Did schizophrenic symptoms further impact his life?
Exceptional ❤. Quality …. Classically and romantically, rhetorically …
Amazing! The book I picked up in 1976 at a Zen center in Minneapolis is still popular, great.
Who is the person analyzing the book? What other books has this person done?
I own this book but never took the time to dive into it , may give it another look
Good luck with it. I've read it twice, didn't get much out of it, but maybe I'm just stupid. I found it tiresome, to be honest, and not in the least bit enjoyable.
It rocked my world.
This is easily my favorite book. Give it a shot. I recommend the follow up LILA, as well. It continues his working out of the philosophy.
@@martinrea8548did you not get anything out of this summary either?
It’s a great read. You won’t be disappointed.
You could argue that the grandiose claims in the book, belong not to Pirsig, but to the character Phraedus, and that he puts these words in the characters mouth to demonstrate that Phaedrus is off his rocker. He is recover from a mental break, right? It’s been 40 years since I read the book, so forgive me if I’m remembering complete wrong. 7:44
Late 1960's, not late 1970's
Praise She of Many Songs.
Lookit m8, where do you find quality. In the empirical (foreign) appreciation or the visceral (internal) sense. Quality exists regardless of acceptance of either.
I live in Africa. here people do things similar to the can trick everyday in everything. Yet I'm not sure at all that it's because it's because they have a classical mindset. or is it? I always understood this phenomenon as an unhealthy pragmatism that focus of whatever is working enough and a complete disregard of quality. and by quality, I mean the closest neighbor of the ideal working state.
no way in heck phaedrus ddidnt read N.
Its fine.
HOE shyt! cant wait to watch this. Love this book n lila!
Maybe it's difficult to define quality but we can certainly describe it. Here, it's a characteristic of being useful if a tool, beautiful if a woman, sturdy if furniture, easily use-able if software, etc. If something is made well, its quality. It serves it's purpose well. I feel like I could go on and on about the characteristics of quality. I could never get through this book because his arrogance over this topic seemed so absurd.
A german engineer would never use a spare part that is not TÜV tested and DIN normed
Not sure if that's the case today, but in the 1970s, yes...😂
I just remember that he pissed himself