The Gare de Lyon Disaster | A Short Documentary | Fascinating Horror
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2024
- "On the 27th of June, 1988, a busy commuter train was bound for Paris’s Gare de Lyon station..."
As always, THANK YOU to all my Patreon patrons: you make this channel possible.
/ fascinatinghorror
SOCIAL MEDIA:
► Twitter: / truehorrortales
► TikTok: / fascinatinghorror
► Suggestions: hello@fascinatinghorror.co.uk
CHAPTERS:
00:00 - Intro
00:36 - Background
01:35 - The Gare de Lyon Disaster
07:44 - The Aftermath
MUSIC:
► "Glass Pond" by Public Memory
SOURCES:
► "Train Driver Jailed for Crash That Killed 56 People" by Patrick McDowell, published by AP News, December 1992. Link: apnews.com/article/c6a225aa4c...
► "Seconds from Disaster: Paris Train Crash" broadcast by National Geographic, November 2005.
► "Death Toll Now 59 in Paris Train Crash" by Steven Greenhouse, published by The New York Times, June 1988. Link: www.nytimes.com/1988/06/29/wo...
► "Catastrophe Gare de Lyon" by INA, June 1988. Link: www.ina.fr/ina-eclaire-actu/v...
#Documentary #History #TrueStories
Andre was a hero. I wouldn't have had the mental fortitude to make that order myself. He knew that he would die, but his duty was to his passengers. Rest in peace, sir.
He probably thought he could both make the announcement and survive
I feel like many of these people might not do what they did if they genuinely knew they would die
Still a hero none the less
@Patriots Nation 4 life honestly I don't think that most people in these kind of situations think about the consequences for themselves, time sorta slows down in a crisis if you are calm, and not panic, but you don't have time to think about tomorrow or even 5 minutes from now, you just have this moment and you have things to do right now
Amen.
I don't think I could have done it. It's amazing that he had the calmness of mind to decide to stay instead of fleeing.
@@ithinkdoyou I agree. Even if Patriots is right and he didn't think he'd die, there has to have been even just a second or two of terror that felt like hours.
It's cases like this that make you appreciate the complexity of many serious accidents. It's often a chain of unfortunate cause and effect events rather than a simple mistake.
Good example of a recipe for disaster
Yup, in aviation we call it the swiss cheese model (imagine slices of swiss cheese with holes in them, multiple holes often have to line up for a disaster to happen).
When humans panic and do stupid stuff.
You can see the same in basically any air disaster. Planes are incredibly safe machines, and it takes multiple redundant safety failures or operator errors to cause a sever accident. In situations like this, it's almost always a series of unfortunate and unlikely events that lead to the tragedy. Multiple small mistakes that quickly build into a large one
@@Transilvanian90 Yeah, not really. It's like this story I heard on a podcast, where a guy's van is overheating, so he's just panicking putting different fluids into the vehicle. Long story short, he ends up destroying the engine, he didn't address the main problem and instead created a completely new issue. Basically the wrong fluid / oil ended up in the wrong area of the engine. So, during a panic, only wrong choices are made. We never make good choices during a panic, or as is said "the Prometheus school of running away from large objects"
Huge respect to Andre Tanguy
He is a real hero of this tragedy...
Never ceases to amaze me that folks like Andre are willing to stick it out until the end to save as many people as possible.
Consider the orchestra on the Titanic, which continued to play as other people fled to lifeboats. Consider the Capitol Police in DC, who defended it and besieged Congress members from the violent MAGA mob’s weapons until they were crushed or beaten grievously. There is enormous bravery among us every day, often shown without fanfare or glory seeking. And there is also enormous cowardice, largely from the bullies and fools who want nothing but more power, more control over us, more money, more hero worship.
@@judeirwin2222 yes. Perfectly stated. Thank you.
@@judeirwin2222 The only Capitol Police fatalities there were heart attacks and self-executions after the event.
"her motives unclear"
It was pretty damn obvious that she wanted to get off at that station and didn't realise this train wasn't going to on the new timetable
Paraphrasing from Wikipedia The person who pulled the emergency brake was a young mother named Odile Mirrior. She told investigators that she normally used train 153944's stop at the Le Vert de Maisons station to pick up her children from school. However, she was unaware that the new summer timetable meant that her train would not stop at Le Vert de Maisons. So not wanting to keep her children waiting, she pulled the emergency brake and left the train.
Agreed, she inconvenienced everybody on that train just because SHE had to get off.. typical. I hope guilt destroys her mind.
@@Victor-sk8by She just stopped a train. Bruh. Im pretty sure it's not her fault this accident happened.
@@titandarknight2698 it’s called emergency brake for a reason lol
Or maybe she was psychic and had a bad feeling.
Seconds before Disaster’s episode on this was also fantastic. It highlighted how Andre Tanguy’s actions were commendable , similar to Coleman’s in the Halifax Disaster
Seconds from Disaster is just a fantastic documentary in general, but totally agree!
I really miss this docu series.
I was a kid when I watched that episode back in National Geographic Channel.
I think by his choices it's clear that he grew up with Seconds from Disaster. I'm pretty sure the king's cross fire is up next and the Kursk sinking will come soon.
I watched that episode on youtube when I was six. It strangely gives me nostalgia
As a former SNCF worker and a Gare de Lyon dweller, I had many occasion to get in the tunnel. The slope is steep and the trains go down fast. Sometimes I think about it and get the chills.
👎
Wow. Very interesting
Merci, c’est toujours un accident présent dans les esprits effectivement 😢
It kind of gives me chills the lady only got a fine for such ridiculous selfishness.
The CF was the same game that James Bond played?
This happened on my 5th birthday (which makes it the 35th anniversary this summer, I just realised). I think of all the videos on this channel, this one might be the absolute most unfortunate sequence of events. The timetable change, the mother trying to get to her kids on time, the driver's actions on the brakes, the skipped station to make up lost time, the downhill approach, the driver's *other* actions, the general alarm freezing the points, and the packed train waiting at the platform. Really feels like something out of Final Destination when so many freak occurrences have to coincide (including the driver making multiple mistakes that he frankly should not have made).
It's called the Swiss Cheese Effect, when all the holes line up bad things happen and this one took a fair few holes to align to make it so.
@@marvindebot3264 Definitely feels like more holes than cheese
But if it wasn't for driver incompetence none of this would have ever happened.
@@IgglePyggle And if the mom didn't pull the emergency cord, the driver wouldn't have needed to reset the brakes, and if the timetable wasn't changed the mom wouldn't have needed to stop the train. I do agree that most of the fault is on the driver though but there's plenty of other circumstances that might have prevented it from happening.
M..
3q0
I like how you also add the after effects of the tragedy in these stories. Like if conditions got better or positively changed.
This is pretty similar to the 2021 Hualien train derailment in Taiwan, in which the mistakes of one single person caused a deadly chain of events that killed dozens. A flatbed truck from a construction site rolled down a hill onto the tracks just before a tunnel. A train came and hit the truck, derailed, and everything piled into the tunnel which was barely wide enough for 1 train to pass. I will always remember the interview they did with one of the first responders, he was diagnosed with PTSD because the scene was so gruesome. This was what he said: "It was like walking into a human blender, it was dark, there were body parts everywhere, the air was mixed with blood so it was difficult to breathe. I could hear people screaming and crying everywhere but I couldn't see or reach them. If hell ever existed, that was it."
That sounds horrible!
God really does look after us all.
God, how awful 😔
@@lobstrosity7163 "God looks after us all?" I hope this is sarcasm, because it's things like this that make the existence of a compassionate and omnipotent god a complete fantasy.
My bbsbbqs
I agree with the Union here. Granted the driver was not blameless in everything but I feel that pinning all the blame on him was the company trying to get out of fixing major issues with their system that led up to what happened.
He bled the brakes, it was his fault. He had no right to bleed the brakes.
@@jdmb03 Like @Nostripe361 said, he wasn't blameless (he could have also activated the electric brakes as pointed out), but the overall alarm system was not only pointless, but created more problems than it solved, in averting the collision. The problems were systemic. One person should not unintentionally be able to cause such a disaster while trying to prevent it.
There were definitely issues in the alarm system, especially how it prevented the train from being sent away from the station, and kept the stationary train in place until it was hit.
He didn't seem to know what he was doing. Turning off the main brake valve, bleeding the brakes, contacting the station but not telling them which train he was driving. I cannot speak about company policy as I don't know what that was in 1988, but the fact is, the driver is the captain of his ship. He should know that if anything goes wrong whilst it is under his control, that he should follow policy and call the technician out to check the problem. Ironically, once he started it moving again, that train was never going to stop until it hit something. All he could then do is place his head between his legs and kissing his arse goodbye.
He didn't deserve all the blame, but he did deserve to serve his entire sentence (four years is already extremely generous for 56 counts of negligent manslaughter).
Imagine the entitlement of thinking that using the emergency brake because the train isn’t stopping where you want it to, and inconveniencing hundreds of other people, is the right thing to do.
Andre was basically doing the "captain goes down with his ship" principle, RIP to him and the passengers.
9:32 If I die and this is what they give me for a memorial then I want somebody to get fired!
lmao best comment
I paused for awhile, staring at it, trying to figure out how on earth it memorialized the victims. I could not!
Honestly, a plaque detailing the events of that day with names of the victims would have been just fine.
My mother knows someone who was on the waiting train that day. When passengers were told to evacuate she jumped out of the train and went away without looking back. Many were not so lucky.
As a train driver from a neighboring country using the same brakes system i remember being shocked as i heard about that driver's course of actions for the first time... I'm not sure what the rules were in France at the time but i'm convinced they didn't allow a driver to just bleed the cylinders and depart without a test of the brakes. Very sad accident made even worse by the fact that it was SO preventable...
Complacency really kills. He probably didn’t think he was doing anything wrong, unfortunately there’s a culture in almost every workplace of “well we do this all the time so no big deal!” And it sometimes leads to tragedy. I work for a railroad as well and ever now and again something will happen that makes us all shudder and wonder what was going through the person or persons heads. This is just a reminder for the rest of us to always follow protocol no matter how annoying it may seem to be, they were written in blood.
I drive trains in Sweden. If I would ever have to bleed any brakes, I would have do a stationary braketest before continuing. And if the train can not show me digitally on a screen that the individual brakes work thought-out the train, I would have to check on indicators in the outside of each individual brakes. And then I would have to do a moving break test when I get to approximately 90 km/h.
I can understand the first mistake of this driver but not the rest. But granted, this was a while ago and the attitudes may have been more slacked. I guess we do learn from our predicesers.
The mOtHeR 🤡shouldn’t have even pulled the emergency stop in the first place! Send that bytch to prison!!
As a former conductor in the states it’s mind boggling he cut out the locomotive brakes and proceeded to bleed off each car individually, that’s far from routine rectifying anything with the brake system. They already walked the train bleeding it off but didn’t do a brake set test confirming the last car was set??!! It makes absolutely no sense, especially for someone that’s been operating since a teen and was now in his 40’s.
Bleeding all brakes of all cars, no stationary brake test, forgot he had a magnetic brake? How is that even possible? How can a driver make so many mistakes? We all make mistakes, but this just doesn't make sense.
Andre Tungay's actions were heroic, saving the lives of passengers while sacrificing his own. RIP Andre
I don't love insomnia but I DO love getting your notifications at 3:00am. Thank you for your amazing videos.
3 AM gang rise up!
@@myrojyn might as well since we aren't sleepin 😂
Do yourself a favor and mute notifications while you sleep, your brain chemistry will thank you
@@rebeccacarrington1144 this is really great advice, unfortunately it would only work if I did ever sleep. I've had 8 sleep studies in 2 years and they can't figure my brain out so I just raw dog life on one 16-18hr sleep per 4-7 days. It's unhinged and unhealthy but it's all I got. But yes, no phones is good sleep hygiene for most!
My ear is ringing 8[
The sequence of events in this tragedy is just one "oh no!" after another. It seems almost like something out of "Final Destination"... condolences to all the victims' families. :(
It is scary how easily one's actions can lead to such an accident. Hopefully they more thoroughly trained all drivers on how to properly operate the brakes!
Perhaps stupid females will refrain from using the Alarme, just to leave the train.
I am female.
It's true, that the driver (Daniel Saulin) should've called maintenance about a defect in his train rather than cut supply to the brakes and manually disarm them and yes as you said about another brake they don't usually do. It's rather scary that the passenger Ordeal Mirrore (I think I said her name wrong) who is a Partisan French resident I think pushed the emergency brake as the train was scheduled to not stop at her station Vert De Maisons.
It's a great example of the Swiss cheese theory.
@@PruneauYT it is, very much so. So many things had to line up to allow this tragedy to happen (as is often the case).
@@RBMapleLeaf , one is tempted to laid the blame on that woman, but activating an emergency brake should not have this domino effect. Imagine if the brake was pulled because someone fell into the tracks and then this wind up happening.
These videos could be longer, but I do like that they're not made overly dramatic and mostly let the situation speak for itself
I wait for this every week. Congratulations on cracking a MILLION!
Over and over again we hear of accidents that happen because of a series of failed procedures. It is both frustrating and frightening. May those who lost their lives rest in peace. And the man who stayed at his post while encouraging passengers to run should be honored as a hero.
I'm astounded that the brake system is not fail safe. On UK trains if there is no brake pressure then the brakes are fully on - the pressure forces the brake off. So "bleeding" the system would have caused the brakes to stay on. This seems like a bit of a fundamental design error to me!
The train was equipped with that same type of fail-safe mechanism. My understanding is that this is what prevented the train from moving when the main brake pipe valve was inadvertently closed, and that the fail-safe mechanism was only defeated by the subsequent action of manually unlocking each brake.
Another safeguard that would seem to make sense is that trying to pull other cars with a closed main brake pipe valve closed should be detected and prevented.
Train brakes are not like a trucks brakes. The way they work is by using a charged resivior of air pressure on the car itself, which is what actually applies the brakes when the brake pipe pressure is reduced. The brakes are not sprung onto the wheels, it is air pressure that keeps them applied. There is a return spring, but this is to pull the brakes off the wheels when the brake piston is no longer recieving air pressure.
What the driver did was bleed the pressure out of the local reservoirs on the cars, hence why the brakes disengaged.
Also, this feature is common to air brake systems around the world. One of the reasons is actually to allow cars to be moved around without their air brakes, specifically to make yard shunting easier. If a cars brakes had to be charged everytime it had to be moved around a yard, it would make shunting jobs take forever. As such the air brakes are only charged and activated for runs on the main line.
Train air brakes are fail-safe, but only against an unexpected train separation on the line. If you manually bleed pressure out of the system, or let them sit long enough without being recharged by the brake pipe, they will disengage.
@@andrewlucia865 Thank you very much for this, very informative.
It did fail safe.
The brakes were locked.
He bypassed that safety by bleeding or the air out of the system.
I assume you’re talking about modern air brakes which lock when they have no pressure.
@@andrewlucia865 Thanks for giving us a clear explanation of train air brakes.
I think this was a case of that Swiss Cheese phenomenon. Just the perfect alignment of things going wrong in just the right ways to lead to the worst possible outcome.
It's so sad that we can only fix problems that we know about, and oftentimes we only know about them after it's too late.
Just what I need to watch before my morning commute.
Really wish you'd do the 1950 Kew Gardens LIRR crash.
Go to the video description and there is a link there to suggest incidents
What a messy chain of events that led to this nightmarish tragedy. Sorry to say I've never heard of this disaster, notice how the pieces always seem to fall into place with horrific consequences.
That’s why they call it a chain of events. If you break a single link then the accident doesn’t happen.
Sometimes the chain of events is convoluted and very specific.
They often involve multiple people ignoring safety rules
Just think, if that lady didn’t pull the emergency stop like she was on a city bus, non of this would’ve happened.
The issue was thr French railway system and its equipment and training, not some woman.
This was a ticking time bomb and one that could've been used by terrorists at the time if someone put it together
@@SudrianTales agreed
you really cant blame this on the woman. emergency brakes are for emergencies, and one may argue if this was an emergency or not, but THIS should NEVER be a result of pulling the emergency brake.
Years ago I did an accident investigation into something and I concluded that an accident is when it is only a financial loss. Disaster is when lives are lost. Unfortunately, both seem to be essential in developing and improving safety standards and we hope that lessons learned are not forgotten.
It is only because of Titanic sinking, that lifeboats became more of a thing. And it is disasters like Gare de Lyon that safety systems are forced to improve. It is sad for the lives lost, but more lives are saved as a result.
@@neilbadger4262
Going out on a limb to defend the Titanic designers, she was overstocked on lifeboats to the letter of the law. Furthermore, lifeboats werent that safe back then, especially if the wind and seas picked up.
I went to Paris about 20 years ago, and even stopped at Gare de Lyon. I only learned about the disaster from this video. Absolutely tragic.
This episode really lives up to your channel's name. So fascinating how a series of accidents and mistakes can lead to such a horrific outcome. If just one or two of those things hadn't happened the way they did, maybe this would have never happened or at least been a lot less severe.
A future video you can do on the deadliest train accident in French history, albeit not during peacetime, was the Saint-Michel-de-Maurienne derailment that occurred on the 12th of December 1917. 675 French soldiers were killed.
It has been covered, if not by this channel, maybe by Plainly Difficult?
Good video as usual.
On the Saint-Michel-de-Maurienne disaster of 1917 there is an excellent French documentary of 60 min:
th-cam.com/video/98REOnlxRyE/w-d-xo.html
French subtitles can be translated into English
Aka Modane Saussaz 1917, during France worst year of the war as the poilus threatened revolt as done in Paths of Glory. An overloaded troop train spun out of control down a steep gradient, caught fire and crashed. Most of the occupants burnt to death and could not be identified.
@@duncancurtis5971 That sounds uncannily similar to Quintinshill 1915 (the worst railway disaster in Britain). Except that was a multiple collision not a runaway train, but it involved a troop train and a fire.
@@cr10001 I still remember that story, especially the part where officers and regular soldiers had to shoot their own comrades to give them a quick death. It must have been horrible for them all.
I don’t get why the woman didn’t just leave at the next stop.
I also don’t understand why they punished the driver with years of prison over a mistake that was caused by placement of levers, not merely negligence
He got out after 6 months.
It all depends on how far it was going to be for the mom to walk, how little her kids were, and how unforgiving the school/daycare was regarding late pick ups. Who knows what kind of stress she was under. It took some guts for her to come forward.
@Nicole of Nowhere she got the punishment she deserved.
She was stupid and selfish but she did not cause those deaths.
The driver on the other hand? Definitely guilty of manslaughter through gross negligence. Multiple actions on his part first caused and then exacerbated the situation. He was arrogant in failing to follow established maintenance procedures. He was then negligent in his failure to follow emergency procedures.
SNCF setup made some contribution but the union was wrong: the driver deserved to be convicted, as indeed did the guard for his actions in helping bleed the brakes.
@@davidpnewton spoken like someone with zero knowledge of the pressures Train Drivers face in these situations.
@The Corned Beef Council that is where some of SNCF's blame could be brought in.
However it was him and him alone who made the brake bleeding decision. It was him and him alone who made the decision to break procedure and not get the brakes inspected.
Another night of insomnia and I was rewarded with a new video from my favourite person! Thank you for making my morning brighter.
Thanks for always consistently uploading and always delivering. Been a fan for a couple years now!
I commend your efforts in pronouncing the french words
It's honestly incredibly that only 56 people lost their lives. Extremely tragic for everyone involved.
Brilliant video. You pack in so much information but keep it easy to follow along
Congratulations on 1 million subscribers! Well done!
This illustrates perfectly how 9/10ths of disasters are a tragic combination of disparate events, which converge into one tragedy.
Seen every video (over time) and love them! The music you use is one of my favorite parts!
I click on the thumbs up before I even listen to these videos as I know I will enjoy them and learn more history. The narrators voice is perfect and so pleasant to listen to - thank you so much for each and every one!!
I love these videos because you find out why things are invented or introduced. I knew having been a guard for 3 years on the UK railway that the drivers can override emergency brake applications caused by passengers, but today I found out why
and standout one for me was the emergency exit bar due to the incident in the Sunderland theatre
the pneumatic valve was also confusing with closed position being parallel to the pipe, and also a high degree slope just before the gare de lyon made the train goes from 30km/h to 70km/h. this is some final destination stuff.
Really? That's nuts, parallel is open on every single valve I've ever seen/used.
@@marvindebot3264 yes, it was a bad design, they probably corrected it after the accident.
@@djaysenpai One would hope so!
The holes in the Swiss cheese lined up.
Another train disaster you might want to cover is the Granville Train Disaster, Sydney in 1977.
Great vid FH. I first learned of this disaster from the series Seconds from Disaster. RIP Mr Andre Tanguy, the hero of Gare de Lyon.
Damn I love your videos bro. They’re always perfectly done. You always tell a very clear and concise story, with just enough detail to understand what exactly happened, without being too short or too long. On subject though, it’s amazing just how many issues intersect before disaster happens. In this case there were multiple issues that resulted in a horrific crash, but the driver still could have minimised it had he used the electronic brakes. I’m glad the driver didn’t get too long in prison though. He was definitely negligent, but he was also overworked and attempting to rectify the situation. I agree that it’s better to address the systemic issues rather than blame it all on one man. They say that OH&S rules are written in blood, but it’s a shame that it was such a large scale disaster with so many lives lost for these fixes to finally be put in place. Thanks again for a great video, mate. I appreciate your hard work.
Andre Tanguy could have gotten up and saved himself. But chose to sit there, staring down certain death just to give some strangers a chance to escape.
Very well presented. I was just thinking about what you said about the emergency worker response time. In a well populated area, ten minutes is a very long time...
This is very interesting! I worked in Fontainebleau for 6 months in spring 1989 and fall 1990 and rode the train from Fontainebleau to Paris via Melun often, both with the type of equipment that crashed on the suburban (banlieue) line and the faster and more direct RER style trains. I'm thankful that SNCF quickly stepped up to eliminate the causes of the crash and that I didn't know of it at the time!
Ah I remember sending you a suggestion about that awful disaster a few months ago. I don't know if it's linked at all, but in any case, thank you for speaking of what happened so accurately.
That person who put on the emergency breaks must feel awful.
Here's hoping they do. They got off lightly for their stupidity.
True, but her actions should have had no impact. Had the driver followed the safety protocols including checking the brakes were operative after his actions the accident would not have happened as the isolated braking system would have been noted and corrected.
I hope so - her selfishness caused all this
@@piearm1271 it was a series of small things in succession that cause this
@@piearm1271 regardless her actions are what set everything in motion. All because she didn’t want to be inconvenienced 🤦🏾♂️
This incident is a perfect breakdown of natural human behavior: every one of us have acted like the main participants at some point or another: the mother who did something rather careless when she faced the possibility of being late (if you've ever driven a car, you probably have), Saulin who in a moment of extreme stress forgot basic training, and Tanguy who went above and beyond for others. Lest you think I'm vilifying Saulin for his actions, he did show extreme concern for the passengers on his train. By hurriedly alerting them of the danger and escorting them to the rear carriages, he protected them from serious impact.
I really consider this to be a disaster caused equally by human error and a combination of company culture, corporate mismanagement, and design flaws. With a little imagination and a more macro look at the way the line was set up, a disaster like this could probably have been anticipated.
Oh, boy am I ready to watch this video! I have been waiting patiently for you to upload!
THANK YOU for that one, I suggested it a while ago.
That catastrophe had been a catalyst for the french railway company.
Accidents like this are why you should perform a thorough inspection of your equipment before setting off, including testing the brakes. Especially if you've been messing with things.
In trucking it actually used to be commonplace in the pulling of tandem trailers to isolate the brakes of the rearmost trailer if that trailer was empty. This would prevent those wheels from locking up in an emergency, but also concealed any potential leaks. Anti-lock brakes have made this practice redundant.
Cheers for the Million, mate!
I was so happy to see you made a new one!
Great video, friend! Congrats on 1M subs! 🎉
Comedian Dennis Miller said it best. "I don't think I ever want to be on any form of mass transit where the general public has access to the fuckin' brakes. I'd hate to find out we went off the tracks at 200 miles an hour, because Gus thought he saw a woodchuck".
The correct spelling here is "brakes", one hopes (although in the case in question, things really did break).
@jediknightjairinaiki560 "BRAKES," not "BREAKS"
@@b43xoit Didn't notice the autocorrect. I'll fix it.
@@jake12466 Didn't notice the autocorrect. I'll fix it.
So frustrating when you know this tragedy could have been entirely avoided once the driver knew something was wrong with the brakes he should have just allowed all the passengers to disembark and call for help
Easy to say when you haven't got bosses pushing you to strict timetables.
It would have taken less than 5 years to let the passengers of the train I'm sure considering the circumstances they would have understood the situation and the driver could easily have called for help to help resolve it at least no one would have ended up getting killed if the driver did they instead of assuming to know what he was doing and could handle it himself when he clearly couldn't
Actually that was also the procedure. In the situation according to the handbook he should have called over the maintenance crew who would have spotted the error easily. Also the train actually did have a secondary regenerative break. Activating that and using the single pneumatic break still left would have been enough breaking power to stop the train. The regenerative break also is a toggle switch which means you active it and it will keep going so if he was worried about his passengers he could have still activated it before leaving the cabin. It wouldn't have stopped the train completely but it would have slowed it down significantly.
Not to mention when he called for help he forgot to give his identity which meant the controllers couldn't divert the train to an empty platform because they had no idea which train the distress call came from.
@@MrMarinus18 "BRAKE," NOT "BREAK"
A complex case and a series of systematic failures with unfortunate casualties and injured, which led to changes in the years ahead, all of which you masterfully put together in a good and clearly understood way. If you aren't a higher education teacher you very well could be. Thank you for this story!
Thanks for another greatly detailed video❤
So happy to see you ! Your videos ease my anxiety, somehow. l
Same here. It's because, rather than some amorphous horror that _might happen,_ lurking beyond prediction?
Here is this disaster, that we can analyze, learn from, and prevent from recurring.
It turns the unknown dread into a known, controllable fear.
Very soothing.
...I hate meditation, but I do find it helpful. Cheers.
It's alwaus nice to see a video about my home country events. I knew about this one but you do tell the story with reel talent. As I said on another video, have you already spoken about the Bazar de la Charité fire ? It's quite a subject.
Oui, bonne idée !
It's cold and disgusting in North Texas, US of A 🥶. Just your lovely drawl (wait, that's mine); simply hearing your accent from (I'm sorry? I didn't catch that..) and that familiar intro 🎶 have made my day! Thank you for what you do!
That the guy forgot about an electrical backup braking system seems to indicate a severe lack of ongoing training. Hopefully that was addressed as well.
EDIT: typo correction: "breaking" corrected to "braking," thanks to the gallantry of @jake12466
If I recall correctly he argued that drivers were not really trained to use the electrical break. Also, he couldn't be certain that it would be enough to stop the train while he still needed time to tell passengers to go to the rear car before impact.
@@unlapras9365 "brake"
@mgratk "BRAKING," not "BREAKING"
@@unlapras9365"BRAKE," not "BREAK"
@@jake12466 Thanks for the insignificant typo correction, I suppose. I will correct it and give you credit.
It is absolutely ridiculous that Saulin got sentenced to prison, while the woman who intentionally pulled the emergency brake got off with a light fine. Saulin was panicked and under pressure, while that woman knew exactly what she was doing when she pulled that brake.
Edit for clarification: I'm not saying that the woman knew what would happen after she pulled the brake, merely that the act of pulling it was purposeful. If someone shouts "fire!" in a crowded venue, they're probably not expecting a stampede that results in multiple deaths, but they should still be punished more severely than a fine for it.
Exactly, according to the 'authorities' women are virtuous and can not be held to account.
Call it White Knight Wanabe syndrome, common among gov agents.
i'm pretty sure she didn't know "exactly what she was doing" considering activating an emergency break doesn't usually kill 56 people
Saulin was released after a few months and it is acknowledged that he should've called a technician; Furthermore, the woman was punished for *exactly* what she did - pulling the emergency brake, which is a fine. She wouldn't have been able to know that it would lead to a terrible crash.
@@dinolil1474 She fraudulently pulled the emergency brake to suit her own convenience; that's way beyond fine material, and creates a chain of events leading to, potentially disaster. It's fully comparable with yelling fire in a crowded theater.
We appreciate the amount of information we receive from this. Keep up the good work.
👎
Weird system. Just anybody can decide where to stop the train? And then they intentionally skip your stop because someone else chose to get off early? Hard to imagine that train was ever on time!
All passenger trains have an emergency handle in the carriages.
@@marvindebot3264 And now they're useless because it requires the engineer to approve an emergency brake activation by a passenger. There's no way to win!
@@nickford17 Well that's pretty stupid. They still work here (Aust) on the mainline and where I drive (a steam tourist road) it's still a cord that directly dumps the line pressure.
No, it’s an EMERGENCY brake. You use it if a train car is on fire and an extinguisher can’t put it out. Or if a person starts attacking someone with a knife. Only in situations where people need to evacuate for their immediate safety. It’s not for using to stop anywhere.
Congratulations on passing 1 million subs!
As a daily passenger of line D at Gare de Lyon, I see the memorial on the platform everyday, and I can't help but think about this catastrophe everyday the train is delayed and stuck at GDL
that memorial is awful
I disagree
Thank you for always mentioning the memorials that were built for these tragedies. I think if a place is created to commemorate the lives that have been lost, it should be shared so people can visit.
Very interesting, as usual. Did not knew about this one. Love the way to pronounce French names too :)
Talk about a cluster fck..... Every part of this disaster was so small but the snowball ended up so big. Fantastic video! Hats off to the conductor who sacrificed himself.
There's only 3 constants in the universe; Gravity, the speed of light in a vacuum, and the SNCF being late.
My mum and I were in Marseille last weekend, and while there we visited Avignon, Arles and Cassis. On the way from Avignon to Arles my mum said she was impressed by the trains being right on time, but that quickly wore off when the train from Arles to Marseille got delayed 40 minutes 😂🇨🇵
Delivered another wonderful overview yet again ❤
👎
Love your narration.
Andre was the real hero in this tragedy. That kind of act takes enormous fortitude and courage. Another very well, respectfully done video. I’d never actually heard of this one.
I can definitely tell you this- that woman may not have faced any legal consequences, but she undoubtedly suffered from a great deal of guilt and self recrimination for what happened… even though it was certainly not her fault the driver didn’t follow protocol.
He forgot about a backup brake!!!!?? 😡
This is, by far, one of the most anguishing episodes ever 😢
What a great material!
It has some similarities to the Caledonian Sleeper near miss a few years ago, specifically a (likely) inadvertent movement of a brake isolating handle, a failure to recognise that the train brakes were not functional, and downward gradients increasing the speed of the train on approach to a station. Luckily in the Caley Sleeper's case, controllers were able to give the train a clear path through Edinburgh Waverley.
While the driver does deserve a lot of the blame, I feel like the woman who pulled the EMERGENCY STOP on a train just to avoid being late got off way too lightly. Although I empathize with the panic of realizing you're not going where you're supposed to be, it's just a bafflingly self-centered reaction to me compared to getting off at the next exit and re-planning your route. It was the 80s, not the 1800s. Find a payphone and let the school know you're on your way but running late. As a teacher myself, I can confidently say that, while we might be annoyed with you, we're not gonna throw your kids in the dumpster or something if you're late picking them up.
KatFangz is exactly right. Folks see the word "mother" and immediately turn off their judgment standards. I guarantee that a kid would get torn to shreds for pulling the emergency brake, though.
While I agree, that she had other options then using the emergency break I don't think she deserves anymore then what she got. It wasn't the emergency break that caused the accident. It was the driver not doing what he should have when the breaks weren't working and he even had a backup he didn't use. The emergency breaks are there for passengers to use just in a serious emergency and she got fined for using it otherwise which was correct.
@@TheNelly77 It's got nothing to do with her being a parent, but everything to do with the fact that she didn't actually cause the accident. She exposed an incredibly faulty combination of people breaking procedure left right and center and the tech not working as expected. The emergency brake IS MEANT to be used and is NOT meant to cause a train collision. Hence she clearly didn't deserve to be punished for everything that happened after she pulled it.
@Hephaistos There's a lot of misogyny with this reaction. They're blaming her for the whole thing, not the driver who FORGOT ABOUT THE EMERGENCY BRAKE.
@Hephaistos She should absolutely have faced criminal charges for what she did; it's easy to forsee that if you fraudulently pull a train emergency brake, it might cause problems (a fire, a collision with another train that hits the now randomly stopped train, etc). It's akin to yelling fire in a crowded theater, you're responsible for the subsequent chain of events. Not fully, the driver fucked up too, as did the railway organization, but she's ABSOLUTELY guilty here.
Headline: "Engineer who bleeds brakes of his train is surprised to learn he has no brakes"
‘He forgot there was another emergency way to stop the train!’ That is the train conductors fault. He is responsible for the deaths & injuries to the passengers. The fact that he only served 6 months is tragic!!!!😢
Grateful she came forward. This is just once incident after another. Terribly sad indeed.
All the holes the Swiss Cheese lined up for this to happen didn't they? It won't do him any good but I hope Andre was awarded a posthumous bravery medal for his sacrifice and his family is well taken care of.
Swiss cheese model! You take emergency preparedness too?
@@ferretyluv 25 years in Fire and Rescue
You see... when you said the woman's motives left the other passengers baffled, the first thing to come into my mind was "Karen who said to herself, 'Oh yes the train WILL stop here for ME!'" And sure enough...
She should've been criminally charged and done some prison time for that.
Interesting content as always! Nice One!!
Thank you so much for taking the time and effort to pronounce the french names properly! Rarely to be seen in those videos (sadly)
I thought he erred in that regard. "Societé", he pronounced with an "ai", like in the English cognate.
Reminds me of a comedy bit Dennis Miller did about someone pulling the emergency brake on a train. "I don't want to take any form of public transportation where the general public has access to the brakes... I'd hate to find out that we went off the rails at 100 MPH because Gus thought he saw a woodchuck..."
I'm not a train engineer, but I am a mechanical engineer. The 1872 Westinghouse automatic airbrake is a "fail-safe" system. Air pressure is needed to release the brakes, instead of being needed to apply them. This way, if there is a loss of air pressure in the system, the brakes apply automatically, and can't be released until air pressure is reapplied.
Why would SNCF use a system that wasn't "fail-safe," when this technology has existed for 150 years?
No, you are suffering from a common misconception of how train brakes work.. The pressure reduction opens a valve allowing stored air to apply the brakes, the spring hold the brakes off the wheel not on as in a truck. A train with no air at all is still a runaway. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_air_brake#:~:text=The%20Westinghouse%20system%20uses%20air,air%20stored%20in%20its%20reservoirs.
This in fact was a classic Westinghouse-style air brake, which is fail-safe in theory, but only under certain conditions. The issue is that it uses compressed air as the source of braking force. Decrease in brake pipe pressure is only used as a signal, telling each car (or more precisely, each triple valve) to admit air from brake reservoirs into brake cylinders. There can be no brake application if the system has been bled of air beforehand, which is exactly what happened here.
An inspirational story!! Thank you!!
Awesome video!!
This video does play the driver as totally incompetent, maybe also the system was also incompetent for the lack of regular Emergency training for the drivers...
Imagine doing something as simple as pulling the emergency brake and leaving not knowing you just caused multiple deaths and injuries in doing so
It's basically, "If you hadn't done A, I wouldn't have had the opportunity to screw up B, C, D, and E." You could follow the chain back further, to say, "If the railway hadn't closed down that particular stop" and further to "If the railway didn't exist in the first place."
@@rafetizer Any fool with half a brain knows better than to pull an emergency break for no reason. Her not using any common sense is where that chain ends.
There's nothing simple about pulling the Emergency brake in a non emergency situation.
The 20yr old single mother responsible got off criminal charges injuring and killing those people.
@@FinnishLapphund Good point…
Awesome video yet again.
My father was among the rescue team and I still remember him being sleepless for days after that. You can't see it on the pictures, but he discribed what he saw as "butchery". The consequences were really awful...