@@falaxiathefiregoddess8916part of me wonders if he were in psychosis at this point in time too, and part of me thinks he was just trying to scare them off. if he realized they were kits i doubt he would've actually hurt them.
Rainflower: "theres YOUR nest" Stormkit: "my nest" Rainflower: "you'll need it because your injured" Shellheart finds out "RAINFLOWER" *Rainflower stars calling him crookedkit* Shellheart: "crookedkit?" Rainflower: "it suits him" That crushes my heart.
1:20:05“If only he hadn’t broken his jaw, RainFlower would still love him.” Rainflower never loved him, only his looks, what a terrible mother, she shouldn’t be allowed to have her kits
“Instead she acted like his ugliness was contagious. He tried to please her to make up for his accident. He had fetched her prey from the freshkill pile, until she’d asked him to stop.” Literally made me cry
@@abeenacat I mean, Storm'kit broke the rules, he could have died and killed his brother too... so it makes sense that a clan leader would agree to a punishment like this... It surprises me that they don't use Crookedstar's accident to warn the kits who tries to scoot out of camp...
My thoughts so far I got to chapter 2 so far! Sun/31/Dec 2023 yes it's New Years Eve don't judge me 0:00 super hyped my sweat boi Chapter 1 thoughts Ah yes start the book with a OH NO also shell heart sound like a good dad rainflower sounds helpless Chapter 2 I was laughing so hard when hailstar just aperd behind storm kit 🤣 Over all am love it can't wait to continue
OMG 😱 😢😩i cant get passed the hour. Im at 1:16 and i had to stop because im so very sad for StormKit. His ma is such a bi+c#! To be hurt or rejected by ones mother is the worst pain no one should ever be forced to endure.
My thoughts/theories/musings throughout this book! =^w^= (Spoilers for this part of this book and previous books in publishing order!) 0:00 (27/12/23 14.26) -all i know is that this is about crookedstar XD -he showed up a bit in bluestar's prophecy -he seemed nice -i'm guessing we'll get his whole life story like with bluestar? -onward i go anyway XD 8:11 -wait is brambleberry just a blackberry? -lol 12:09 -is that crookedstar and will his name be changed due to injury? 28:42 -i love seeing non thunderclan pov lol 43:58 -goosefeather? -the top comment is about goosefeather trying to fight babies so I'm excited for this XD 50:34 -oof did he just get his crooked jaw? -also that shenanigan kind of explains why his apprenticeship was put off XD 1:09:56 -yeahh rainflower is annoying 1:12:30 -ok she's more than annoying now 1:20:21 -please stop being soulless and ableist rainflower 1:33:27 (16.48) -this is so crueeel :(( 1:45:21 (28/12/23 19.32) -if it's an interclan romance i'm going to die XDD Finished (28/12/23 19.39) -ooo i'm guessing that's barley's barn :3 -before he moved in I'd say -this book is nice so far!
Anyone first reading/listening, hear this warning:
you will cry.
a lot.
Goosefeather really tried to fight babies
honestly- I'm not surprised.
Neither am I.
To be honest goosefeather is a cat with a mental disability I doubt he even knew they we're babies😢
@@falaxiathefiregoddess8916part of me wonders if he were in psychosis at this point in time too, and part of me thinks he was just trying to scare them off. if he realized they were kits i doubt he would've actually hurt them.
WE STAN A MAN LIKE SHELL HEART
1:04:53 the “I’m sorry… that I hurt rainflower so much” made me choke on my dinner and immediately start crying
Rainflower: "theres YOUR nest"
Stormkit: "my nest"
Rainflower: "you'll need it because your injured"
Shellheart finds out
"RAINFLOWER"
*Rainflower stars calling him crookedkit*
Shellheart: "crookedkit?"
Rainflower: "it suits him"
That crushes my heart.
Starts*
Went from puffed out and all brave to - HES GOING TO KILL US,RUN ,real fast xD
1:20:05“If only he hadn’t broken his jaw, RainFlower would still love him.”
Rainflower never loved him, only his looks, what a terrible mother, she shouldn’t be allowed to have her kits
fr, she even said--when she saw him--"His face! His *handsome* face!" she definitely only loved him for his looks.
“Instead she acted like his ugliness was contagious. He tried to please her to make up for his accident. He had fetched her prey from the freshkill pile, until she’d asked him to stop.”
Literally made me cry
Can we all just take a second appreciate what shellheart did for his son❤❤ that's right shell heart dump rain flower
Yeah Rainflower is even worse than I expected her to be, and Shellheart outright DIVORCING her due to her abuse was such a triumphant scene
❤❤❤🎉🎉
Kits:watch goose feather*
Goosefeather:chooses violence *
Youre a LIFESAVER
I needed something for a school book report, and when i found this i was so happy, thanks a bunch!!
this is the first ever book that made me cry early into it
help im on chaptor 4 and im struggling to keep in the tears-
Thank you so much for these I love McLeods voices
Why wasn't Hailstar like "Uhhhh nooo, I won't name Stormkit Crookedkit
I know right, Hailstar should have refused and told her "no that's a cruel thing to do"
To right WarriorCatsLTTP 👍
@@abeenacat I mean, Storm'kit broke the rules, he could have died and killed his brother too... so it makes sense that a clan leader would agree to a punishment like this...
It surprises me that they don't use Crookedstar's accident to warn the kits who tries to scoot out of camp...
@mandyeosphantasmas1202 Punishment is needed, but changeing somebodys name to be ableist and abusove is dosgusting.
Chapter 4 in and I already wanna cry :(((
Poor Stormkit
Just wait it gets worse
i started squealing and kicking my feet when i found this you are literally a lifesaver im so happy i found this
You go Shellheart!!! Break up with Rainflower!!!
The way I sobbed when Rainflower became so damn cruel. No wonder I saw people hating her. She's horrible. I love Shellheart, though.
Yay! I finally found this on TH-cam.
Poor baby...
1:06:10 I don’t think I’ve cried so much at a book
My thoughts so far I got to chapter 2 so far! Sun/31/Dec 2023 yes it's New Years Eve don't judge me
0:00 super hyped my sweat boi
Chapter 1 thoughts
Ah yes start the book with a OH NO also shell heart sound like a good dad rainflower sounds helpless
Chapter 2
I was laughing so hard when hailstar just aperd behind storm kit 🤣
Over all am love it can't wait to continue
OMG 😱 😢😩i cant get passed the hour. Im at 1:16 and i had to stop because im so very sad for StormKit. His ma is such a bi+c#! To be hurt or rejected by ones mother is the worst pain no one should ever be forced to endure.
Yes, poor little guy 😞
😞😞😞
This is so good! Ov always wanted to know aby crooked star tysm!!!
Why dose Rain flower hate Crooked kit? IT’S GOOSE FEATHERS FAULT HIS JAW IS BROKEN I MEAN HOW COULD HE DO THAT TO A DAMN KIT
This is so sad😭😭
I hate Rainflower
Same
Me too. The witch with a B.
Who’s cutting onions?
My thoughts/theories/musings throughout this book! =^w^=
(Spoilers for this part of this book and previous books in publishing order!)
0:00 (27/12/23 14.26)
-all i know is that this is about crookedstar XD
-he showed up a bit in bluestar's prophecy
-he seemed nice
-i'm guessing we'll get his whole life story like with bluestar?
-onward i go anyway XD
8:11
-wait is brambleberry just a blackberry?
-lol
12:09
-is that crookedstar and will his name be changed due to injury?
28:42
-i love seeing non thunderclan pov lol
43:58
-goosefeather?
-the top comment is about goosefeather trying to fight babies so I'm excited for this XD
50:34
-oof did he just get his crooked jaw?
-also that shenanigan kind of explains why his apprenticeship was put off XD
1:09:56
-yeahh rainflower is annoying
1:12:30
-ok she's more than annoying now
1:20:21
-please stop being soulless and ableist rainflower
1:33:27 (16.48)
-this is so crueeel :((
1:45:21 (28/12/23 19.32)
-if it's an interclan romance i'm going to die XDD
Finished (28/12/23 19.39)
-ooo i'm guessing that's barley's barn :3
-before he moved in I'd say
-this book is nice so far!
😊😊😊😊
I blame goosefeather and i also hate rainflower
bookmarks:
1:14:44
1:45:57 who is the second cat? Not fallow tail
Is an ad rlly necessary every 4 minutes
Why does it sound so fast
Fast reader
1:33:00
50:52
1:19:10
22:34
24:02
1:26:28
40:35
34:46
1:09:31
1:30:22
1:49:00
1:05:12
1:01:11