YEs. What you said made alot of sense. When Michael Cambias on All My Children got killed so many folks had a motive to kill him and it was Bianca Montgomery. He raped her, she got pregnant for him, and when she told him, he scoffed at her. She was sup angry and upset she shot him. She repressed what she did for a long time but confessed.
5 years later and this will forever be one of the best most gripping and compelling storylines to reach Eastenders. Phenomenally well acted from the cast I remember the good old days where at school all we would talk about was who killed Lucy and put bets on it.
To now know that Cindy was within meters of the house when Ian told Peter makes this storyline even more impactful and directly contributed to everything that happened to her over the last decade
I know in real life she didn't know until some time before the reveal, but Jane did well to act as though she was totally stunned when she found out Lucy died.
She went in to the house and found Lucy on the floor starts to cry then bobby walked in with the box talked she carried Lucy to the woods she bobby don't get the blame 😌😌😌😓😓
I was so way off when I thought it was Mr. Smithers. I thought he was playing the "Jilted Lover Wannabe" Game. It was one of the most funniest Storylines in the History of The Show.
If you think this was bad, check out what happened with the "Who Shot JR". To This day there's never been a Storyline on TV that captivated the whole world. Even The Queen Mother wanted to know who shot him.
Abi done it A: she was disrespectful about Lucy on the day of her funeral B:she was jumpy when Summerhayes and Bryant first interviewed her C:she helped Max "destroy" evidence at the car D:she killed Tramp on purpose and said to Summerhayes "Things die" E:her face looked guilty as hell when Cindy opened the gift containing Lucy's jewellery box F:she could be the possible killer Summerhayes met on New Year's Day
I'm annoyed that Cindy is a final suspect I mean she was five months pregnant at the time Lucy died there's no way she could have killed while pregnant Ben and Jay shouldn't be suspects either because they are witnesses
After seeing the recent episode where (SPOILERS) Max said "I know you killed Lucy" to Abi, I doubt it because the murderer is revealed tomorrow. This would just mess things up
Bobby was in bed and Cindy was together in the house but when Lucy was in the house bobby take the Jewellery box and whacked Lucy on the head but who put her forest?????
mickeyzxworld mad how I'm watching this and I happen to find a reply to a comment from three years ago you posted it an hour ago how the world works😂👌🏽😱
I love how everyone predicted it would be max, jane, iain, jane, cindy, peter, denise or lee. But then we get told it bobby 😂😂😂. I still think they should never have killed lucy off. But i want another "who dunnit" thing on eastenders
Without a doubt one of if not the best storyline Eastenders have ever done! But I would love for someone like one of the producers or whatever to explain what some of the other characters were doing in relation to this storyline. Maybe I’ve forgotten a lot of it by now lol but obviously Bobby did it we know that and Jane covered for him. So why did Les have them pictures of Lucy and then hide them under washing machine and Pam found them? Why were Max and Abby cleaning up blood (assuming Lucy’s) at the car lot? Also what else was Max hiding?
Billy was the one with the pictures. He kinda fancied her and this was confirmed in the flashback episode. Lucy had fallen in the car lot a few days before she was killed and left blood so Max and Abi were hiding what happened. Max had contact with Lucy on the night she died and knew that Abi hit her. So they were keeping that between them.
Francis Condon Ahh ok thank you for clearing that up for me. There were so many mini storylines going on around the big storyline that it was hard to keep up and remember everything so I appreciate you explaining it all. 👍
@@xalexis.editsx When you do one of the Biggest Soap Opera Storylines in UK History, it's very hard to do a follow up. What do you guys think of this "New" Bobby.
The UK are fantastic when they do a Who Killed So and So. Then when you find out who did it, you are beyond shocked. I live in Canada and we don't get EastEnders but I remember seeing Clips about who killed Tom King back in the day.
It was abi,Denise and bobby because abi hit her and then Denise punched her and then bobby waked her and it was all on the head so they all did slight damage to her brain so they all just made her brain go dead and bobby was the one to finish her of so Jane covered him do he wouldn't get taken away from her anyway put a thumbs up if you agree
+Zahra Abowath Before Bobby was chosen, it had been Jane at first and then Cindy. While it was a bit silly for Bobby to kill her in my opinion, it does open up interesting possibilities for him if he gets older and we see his violent and psychopathic nature develop. Plus, according to the Christmas storyline for the Beales this year, Bobby and Denny are gonna fight continuously, with Bobby apparently doing something to traumatize Denny, until it ends up putting lives in danger!
This is what confuses me. They were making out that someone's phone was going off. If bobby killed lucy how comes he wasn't there when emma texted him?
Anyways why kill Lucy Beale? it makes no sense too be honest, but the music to this, diamonds by josef salvat the song goes so good with it bye bye Lucy Beale 😢😭😭😭😪 xx
Bobby said why “ Whatever she says, she started it. She made everyone unhappy” She slept with her business partners father, slept with her friends boyfriend, she always started a problem with someone. It’s true
Yes, and sadly enough Bobby was brave enough to say what the other ones were too scared to say. I'm sure that Ian must have thought to himself, "I didn't have a fraction of what I was able to give Lucy but it wasn't enough, she was unhappy, bitter, and hateful, and now she's dead."
To this day I’m still confused of the evidence that Lauren found that identified the killer. All I saw was numbers on that yellow paper. Can someone please explain how that linked to the killer?
You know what's so sad and sick, if Max Branning did sleep with Lucy Beale, it kind of evokes Memories of when Michelle Fowler slept with Dirty Den Watts in the 1980's. Could someone please tell me why he has this sick fixation on Young Girls, sleeping with Stacey even though she married his Son Bradley, does he have anger issues because his own father wasn't there for him?
Even 4 years later, still one of the best storylines i have ever seen. Truly worthy of being done by the eastenders cast.
Agree
Music so cringy
100%
The Dominic Treadwell-Collins era of EastEnders was fantastic, this whole storyline was fantastic
@@lucyagb true that
One of the best eastenders story lines by far!
This goes down as one of the best storylines in EastEnders history, and it makes sense that bobby is still traumatised. Brilliantly executed by all
YEs. What you said made alot of sense. When Michael Cambias on All My Children got killed so many folks had a motive to kill him and it was Bianca Montgomery. He raped her, she got pregnant for him, and when she told him, he scoffed at her. She was sup angry and upset she shot him. She repressed what she did for a long time but confessed.
Vicky Silk Virgin atlantic you are simply the best!
5 years later and this will forever be one of the best most gripping and compelling storylines to reach Eastenders. Phenomenally well acted from the cast I remember the good old days where at school all we would talk about was who killed Lucy and put bets on it.
This storyline was so well done. 👏
To now know that Cindy was within meters of the house when Ian told Peter makes this storyline even more impactful and directly contributed to everything that happened to her over the last decade
When was that revealed?
During her return week we had flashbacks
Peter's scream still gives me goosebumps today xx this was a brilliant storyline and so well executed xx
Same here. The scream and pouring out of emotions is haunting..
I know in real life she didn't know until some time before the reveal, but Jane did well to act as though she was totally stunned when she found out Lucy died.
I remember how big this was omg the whole of the UK was talking about this istg
I know I remeber 😂 I was only 6 lol
I miss Lucy she was the best acter in EastEnders I love the song in the background
Boy it seemed that Lucy had alot of "issues" with the residents of Albert Square and everyone had a motive to kill her.
Lauren thinks it's Jane but then the twist is Jane was actually protecting either Cindy or Bobby
She went in to the house and found Lucy on the floor starts to cry then bobby walked in with the box talked she carried Lucy to the woods she bobby don't get the blame 😌😌😌😓😓
LittleLoomDirectioner What if it was Jane?? Maybe Bobby is innocent! Probably not but Jane did look really guilty according to everybody
"what ever she says she started it she made everyone unhappy"
it's just crazy how everything that is happening in 2017 is from 2015 like this is the longest storyline ever
ikr
And in 2024
It was Bobby. Just like when Maggie shot Mr Burns.
I was so way off when I thought it was Mr. Smithers. I thought he was playing the "Jilted Lover Wannabe" Game. It was one of the most funniest Storylines in the History of The Show.
They had a contest in The US and the "Winner" not only got a trip to Hollywood but was in the episode as an Extra. 😊
will forever love this story line.
It's got to be someone in the beale household!
Like or reply if you agree!
It was bobby 😃 i through it was jane
Cerys James yeah! I couldn't believe it was him!
Dan Mazhar u were right it was bobby BEALE and jane BEALE was covering so u were right sick guessing :-)
Thanks!
ur welcome :-)
5:26 I love that when everyone goes quiet & awkward lol 😂😂
alisha aimms••_ .,.,., ,m
L
, Mm'p
alisha aimms••_ That's Topsy And Tim's Mum
Whitney: *writes rot in hell*
Also Whitney: “I’m going to try and log into Lucy’s account to block them animals from saying anything”
Who else thought it was Whitney before we knew it was Bobby
This is one off best eastenders storyline ever in history off program and trailer
you all are making it look too real but this story is so well done! Whoever made this 👏🏼
If you think this was bad, check out what happened with the "Who Shot JR". To This day there's never been a Storyline on TV that captivated the whole world. Even The Queen Mother wanted to know who shot him.
I still don't get the summerhayes "you know" comment
one of the best storylines Eastenders have ever done
Abi done it
A: she was disrespectful about Lucy on the day of her funeral
B:she was jumpy when Summerhayes and Bryant first interviewed her
C:she helped Max "destroy" evidence at the car
D:she killed Tramp on purpose and said to Summerhayes "Things die"
E:her face looked guilty as hell when Cindy opened the gift containing Lucy's jewellery box
F:she could be the possible killer Summerhayes met on New Year's Day
I'm annoyed that Cindy is a final suspect I mean she was five months pregnant at the time Lucy died there's no way she could have killed while pregnant
Ben and Jay shouldn't be suspects either because they are witnesses
After seeing the recent episode where (SPOILERS) Max said "I know you killed Lucy" to Abi, I doubt it because the murderer is revealed tomorrow. This would just mess things up
Nah it wouldn't be Cindy she was pregnant at the time Lucy died everyone has seemed to have forgotten that
I thought it was a great twist that it was Bobby though I wanted it to be Abi
It would of been a better storyline if it was abi
It should have been Cindy. Bobby was hardly ever in any of the scenes.
Yeah I know right but that what makes it so shocking
bobby did it
Bobby was in bed and Cindy was together in the house but when Lucy was in the house bobby take the Jewellery box and whacked Lucy on the head but who put her forest?????
jane said she did it
Ellie-May
what really
This was one of the best storylines in a soap Ian Beale Actor is honestly excellent
I love u Sharon xxx x x x x x xx
Ian when he cries 😂😂😂
Phill and Ian was so cute!
mickeyzxworld mad how I'm watching this and I happen to find a reply to a comment from three years ago you posted it an hour ago how the world works😂👌🏽😱
One of the best soap storylines of all time.
5:18 they should have revealed it right there and it should have been someone different like Cindy
Ian played his part so well here ❤️
What version of the song is this I've searched EVERYWHERE
Josef salvat diamonds
So relived when I saw Jay wasn't the killer tbh.
That live episode >>>>>>
Incredible performance. And to think it won British Soap Of The Year
I love how everyone predicted it would be max, jane, iain, jane, cindy, peter, denise or lee.
But then we get told it bobby 😂😂😂.
I still think they should never have killed lucy off. But i want another "who dunnit" thing on eastenders
Eastenders does Scandi Noir! I missed this when it originally aired but it's brilliantly put together.
Peter when he says no who else thinks it's heartbreaking??😭😭😭
darcy nicholson Me omg😭😭
R.I.P Lucy Beale
Funny how they didn't show a picture of Bobby Beale in the thumbnail. 😂😂
Bobby and Jane did it
Joshua Ridyard God hard to believe it has been 5 Years
Its nearly 7 years ago
If your seeing this in 2022 or later!! I think it’s Bobby 🤣
5:19 look at pam's husband
i miss lucy so much
Without a doubt one of if not the best storyline Eastenders have ever done!
But I would love for someone like one of the producers or whatever to explain what some of the other characters were doing in relation to this storyline.
Maybe I’ve forgotten a lot of it by now lol but obviously Bobby did it we know that and Jane covered for him. So why did Les have them pictures of Lucy and then hide them under washing machine and Pam found them?
Why were Max and Abby cleaning up blood (assuming Lucy’s) at the car lot? Also what else was Max hiding?
Billy was the one with the pictures. He kinda fancied her and this was confirmed in the flashback episode. Lucy had fallen in the car lot a few days before she was killed and left blood so Max and Abi were hiding what happened. Max had contact with Lucy on the night she died and knew that Abi hit her. So they were keeping that between them.
Francis Condon Ahh ok thank you for clearing that up for me. There were so many mini storylines going on around the big storyline that it was hard to keep up and remember everything so I appreciate you explaining it all. 👍
Max was too obvious. Bobby? Please? I did feel a bit let down when we realised it was the little boy
so Jane got the text after the camera passed her..
9 years later the best but saddest death and storyline ❤
5:18 Les's face tho
Omg the woman who yells "LEAVE ME ALONE" was the mother in that kids show Topsy and Tim!
Need another murder storyline like this where theirs mystery everywhere
5:13 mannequin challenge!!😂😂😂
Does anyone know what version of Diamonds is used as the backing of this?
I want to know that too lmao
Bradley Parkinson josef salvat
Thefalloftheelethenth cheers 👍👌
Bradley Parkinson
I miss lucy so much
😢😢😢😢😖😖😖😖😭😭😭😭
I thought it was Ben and Jay before in knew it was Bobby
I thought it was Cindy because Lucy was Ian's golden girl and Cindy was jealous
+THE BLACK HAMMER good theory
+side girls yeah I felt as though Bobby was a wee bit of a boring one but oh well
+THE BLACK HAMMER ikr what got on my nerves the most though was hoe there was a line of 14 people but not 1 of them were the killer
+side girls I know right ! I'm very excited for Max's storylines at Christmas
This video would of been so much better without the backing music.
Gotta miss these days
Good stuff
Eastenders became dead after this they can never do something so amazing like this again
@@xalexis.editsx When you do one of the Biggest Soap Opera Storylines in UK History, it's very hard to do a follow up. What do you guys think of this "New" Bobby.
The UK are fantastic when they do a Who Killed So and So. Then when you find out who did it, you are beyond shocked. I live in Canada and we don't get EastEnders but I remember seeing Clips about who killed Tom King back in the day.
That's the first nice thing I've heard!
1:17 to 1:26 I'm Sorry but I couldn't stop laughing at Ian's crying- no offence
The look Phil Mitchell's face suggests he doesn't like Ian crying
was over the top 😣
It was abi,Denise and bobby because abi hit her and then Denise punched her and then bobby waked her and it was all on the head so they all did slight damage to her brain so they all just made her brain go dead and bobby was the one to finish her of so Jane covered him do he wouldn't get taken away from her anyway put a thumbs up if you agree
Does anyone know who the old killer was???
+Zahra Abowath Before Bobby was chosen, it had been Jane at first and then Cindy. While it was a bit silly for Bobby to kill her in my opinion, it does open up interesting possibilities for him if he gets older and we see his violent and psychopathic nature develop. Plus, according to the Christmas storyline for the Beales this year, Bobby and Denny are gonna fight continuously, with Bobby apparently doing something to traumatize Denny, until it ends up putting lives in danger!
this death changed the square forever
Eastenders is so cringe and terrible, yet I still watch it as once a year a good storyline like this one comes along
nearly 5 years ago...
BBC Classic EastEnders.
This is what confuses me. They were making out that someone's phone was going off. If bobby killed lucy how comes he wasn't there when emma texted him?
She texted Jane because she was the one who met her earlier in the episode.
2:42 Malachy from Hollyoaks!
Why is the video so ugly when things on screen move.. Do better BBC
Anyways why kill Lucy Beale? it makes no sense too be honest, but the music to this, diamonds by josef salvat the song goes so good with it bye bye Lucy Beale 😢😭😭😭😪 xx
I had a lump in my throat when lucy was dead and the funeral 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
because the Beale family is the oldest family on EastEnders
Bobby said why “ Whatever she says, she started it. She made everyone unhappy” She slept with her business partners father, slept with her friends boyfriend, she always started a problem with someone. It’s true
Yes, and sadly enough Bobby was brave enough to say what the other ones were too scared to say. I'm sure that Ian must have thought to himself, "I didn't have a fraction of what I was able to give Lucy but it wasn't enough, she was unhappy, bitter, and hateful, and now she's dead."
Almina myra True that.
To this day I’m still confused of the evidence that Lauren found that identified the killer. All I saw was numbers on that yellow paper. Can someone please explain how that linked to the killer?
What I don't get is when Bobby killed Lucy his face is different
+Pro Gamer New actor
It was on TV yesterday and Bobby and Jane killed her but I still think its her brother Peter because he wasnt in the house the whole night
When this storyline took place, did they have contests in the Fan Magazines and stuff.
who ever knew it would be an eight year old
Emma is so fit
Does anyone know who sang this cover of Diamonds?
Josef Salvat (2014 cover)
+ScottieGirl20 thank you so much
I didn't know warren used to be in eastenders
And yet this storyline started in April 2014 and ended January 2018
Still going on
I thought it was Bobby from the start
Anyone else know that lady as tipsy and Tim’s mum I have to many cousins 😂✨
Funny how abby wasn't one of the faces showing at the end of the video ...
she is she’s next to peter and jane
I bet it was the dog, Lady Di... :D
PompeiiProductions why the hell would u think it was a DOG?!!?
Nikolai Sander Why the hell didn't you realise it was a JOKE?!?!?
9
PompeiiProductions ok ok funny joke then
:D blame it on the dog. the dog did it. he makes a mess in the house so he made a mess of Lucy thinking she was the carpet. idek anymore.
it’s the way everyoneeee was moving hella sus
It is Bobby
Max knew emma knew so he sufficated her more before he took her to the hospital and said hes sorry he had to do it
God that was sick
What did Patrick mean when he yelled at Ian?
@1:22 Poor Ian😭
I think it's bobby or Lauren
🤘🏽Old however Gold 🤘🏽
Who sings this cover version of Diamonds by Rihanna?
Josef Salvat
What exactly happened on Good Friday?
who that guy at 2.35
The scene where everyone is looking at Emma is so bonechilling. She has everyone staring at her wondering "Does she know it was me."
You know what's so sad and sick, if Max Branning did sleep with Lucy Beale, it kind of evokes Memories of when Michelle Fowler slept with Dirty Den Watts in the 1980's. Could someone please tell me why he has this sick fixation on Young Girls, sleeping with Stacey even though she married his Son Bradley, does he have anger issues because his own father wasn't there for him?
Phill is Lucy grand uncle
Why Lucy killed because of Bobby?
Who else thought Bobby is the killer before it's reveal.