Is the SC right to haul in Prashant Bhushan, and how do the contempt law & top Judiciary intersect
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- #PrashantBhushan #ContemptofCourts
In view of the Supreme Court's notice to advocate Prashant Bhushan on grounds of contempt of court, Shekhar Gupta breaks down the Contempt of Courts Act (1971) along with some of his brushes with in journalistic life in episode #529 of Cut The Clutter.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Faizan Mustafa's piece Contempt jurisdiction should be used sparingly here: www.tribuneind...
Read Court on its own motion Vs Chanchal Manohar Singh here: www.the-laws.co...
Read Chanchal Manohar Singh vs High Court Of Punjab & Haryana And ... on 30 September, 1996 here: indiankanoon.o...
Read Shri Surya Prakash Khatri & Anr. vs Smt. Madhu Trehan And Others on 28 May, 2001 here: indiankanoon.o...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/Subscrib...
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
We count on good people to pay for good journalism. Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/ This includes the link for subscription from overseas too.
In a nutshell you need an excellent lawyer to get away with contempt charges.
Excellent in slander and mudslinging?
@@bobinpune c bless n
Try Harish Salve, Kapil Sibbal will loose 1000%.
Mr Harish Salve, I request don't ever help loose brats, SHISHUPAL has to meet Punishment from Shri Krishna The Supreme Court.
@@rumubhaduri7878. U
@@nitinchandrapchaudhari6657
Harish Salve is a brilliant lawyer. I am shocked that the BJP doesn't hire him in a more official capacity though I presume that might be to preserve his credibility (any lawyer who once joins a party becomes a Politician)
"Your Liberty To Swing Your Fist Ends Just Where My Nose Begins" - Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr
It was John Stuart mill
@@smakaraiiiiv Yes and No. It has a dubious history. It is also credited to Lincoln. The famous quote "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing" is supposedly by John S Mill but it is often attributed to Edmond Burke. Although I doubt it was Mill, a noted liberal of his time.
@@bobinpune Still on the same conspiracy? Back then Leftists hailed Rajan Gogoi as some kind of HERO after his PC. Soon they did a 180 when Gogoi delivered favorable justice on Ram Mandir. Now he is a pariah to LEFTISTs after he joined RS.
@@bobinpune And are you some "Antaryami" who knows everything?
@@bobinpune kya logic hai tera. Agar court kisi ko tadipaar karti hai toh woh sahi hai. Aur wahi court jab kisi ko absolve karti hai aur agar woh Hindu hai to tu chillata hai ki court compromise ho gaya! Haa, agar woh Muslim hota toh tu unki tareef karta. Ja Burnol laga. Tujhe to teri aukat dikha denge.
A politician in Kerala was jailed for a month for calling a High Court judge stupid.
@@bobinpune You are just like Prashant Bhushan. Can talk nonsense without evidence.
bujumbura burundi तू वकील क्यों नहीं बन जाता, 10 साल वकालत करना फिर परीक्षा देके जज बन जाना फिर जज लोया का केस खुलवाना फिर उसको सजा दे देना, प्रशांत भूषण इतना ही ज्ञानी तो परीक्षा देकर जज काहे नहीं बन गयाl
2018 में चार जज ने दीपक मिश्राजी के खिलाफ मोर्चा खोला था, जब तो भूषण बहुत उचक रहा था, उन चार में से दो ने उसके मनमाने फैसले नहीं दिए तो उनके बारे में ऊलजुलूल बकवास करने लगा
A BJP in Tamil Nadu, H. Raja Sharma called High Court 'Mayir'(human hair). Not even a contempt of court was allowed in the court. So it depends.
@@bobinpune सत्य को छुपाया जा सकता है. सत्य के परिणामों को नही. मोदी जी के विरुध्द अभी भी पत्रकार और बहुत सारे लोग दंगो का आरोप लगाते है. जितना आप जोर लगाओगे उतने मजबुत ये लोग होंगे.
@@sarsonsar0 this comment is too sarcastic 😄😄 good one
Please explain the issue of Prashat Bhusan case. Was the contempt called upon him only because of his tweets or because of some "other" reasons? (His work to show prevalent corruption in the judiciary). Moreover, why was the contempt case given to a judge whom Prashant Bhusan had earlier criticized at many occasions?
These points raise grave suspicions.
The same UK judges send Tommy Robinson to non bailable custody within 15 minutes of hearing for contempt of court on bride grooming case!!
It matter what the narrative is!
@@gluttonousmanu2725 so what if it's sou moto? Doesn't change the fact that mighty Indian Court got hurt by a tweet. When you have Supreme Court top judges complaining to the people of injustice - we ARE living in an undeclared emergency! If you can't see that then go get therapy. Reading books won't help you.
@@gluttonousmanu2725 use your brain AND MANNERS while replying. You don't need to show your intellect and upbringing in your comments
Akhand Bharat zindabad!
Modiji zindabad!
Brahmanwad murdabad!
Akhand Bharat Mata ki Jai!
@@gluttonousmanu2725 @bujambura burundi has been brainwashed in universities like JNU.. he cannot think of anything else.. Just that his teachers forgot to teach him that almost all the dictatorships incl. that of their fav. leader Hitler have been in communal/socialist regimes
@@bobinpune dictatorship me to yaha comment nahi kr Raha hota bhushan k sath concentration camp me gas sungh Raha hota
Shekhar, I think instead of cleverly pleading in his favor you ought to have shared PB's tweets that warranted the SC action. I believe PB is inherently a mischievous person and he should be reprimanded for his mischief.
Sure let’s check his history
- Bofors Scam pe book in 1990
- Fought against Privitisation of BPCL
- Fight against corrupt IAS of UP
- Fought 2G scam
- Fought against Coal Scam
- Fought against Congress appointing a allegedly corrupt official as CVC
- yes no one can defend him .. mischievous because he is against the present dispensation as was he against the Congress
Srijanx Gaming our Take on privatisation may differ and certainly it isn’t a crime and he is against Death punishment .. sometimes that means defending Yakub Menon.. do I agree certainly not .. but I understand where he comes from .. and all this certainly doesn’t diminish the fact that he fought Congress better than the opposition BJP
@@vbond585 Thanks, people often don't see beyond headlines and the buffoons in corridors of authority. who are stakeholders of those headlines
SG called prashant bhushan a commie in the most polite way possible
Is there any old song which says something like "pagal ko pagal rahene doh"?..... because it seems like what SG is saying for PB.
@@bobinpune jihadio ko burnol laga jankar ek aneri khushi hoti hai. Pakistan mein Hindu ko bebas karte ho aur yahan aap equality chahte ho!
@@bobinpune teri bhasha se hi pata chalta hai ki tu madarsa chhaap hai. Tere jaise bahot dekhe jo apni jihadi naam chhupane ke liye alag I'd lete hai.
Is program ke har comment thread mein copy karke paste kar same alaap raha hai. Usse pata chalta hai kitni Burnol ke zarurat hai😁
@@bobinpune tum log ki jaat hi aisi hai. Tum ka darazza dene ki koshish ki, aur tum mughalai karne pe utar aaye.
Thank you Mr. Shekhar Gupta and the team of the print for so much information within one video.. Hats off to your journalism...
Mr.Prashant Bhushan deserves this.He thinks himself above Supreme court. He should be fined by the Apex court.
Why for speaking the truth in this 😂
@@bobinpune ayodha verdict kya ayi. Supreme Court fascist ho gya. Vahi Supreme Court jab suo moto sabrimala pe verdict deta hain toh Supreme Court ki jai vaah re dogle log... Sirf kuch gine chune logoki kabar khud rahi hain isliye wahi log dictatorship ka natak kar rahe hain baki sara desh India aur government ke sath hain...
@@bobinpune 99%hindu 😯😯😯😯 data provide Karo bakwas nhi...
@@bobinpune You are just like Prashant Bhushan. Can talk nonsense without evidence.
GAND marwale Bobde
2 cents:
No doubt Supreme Court has been good. But, starting with Gogoi's sexual harassment case things have changed 180°. And now Bobde has made it worst.
People use the word *alleged* if it serves their purposes, innit.
Prashant bhushan has always gone way to far. He thinks whatever he says and believes in is always right
So what do you believe which is wrong?
Cute dp
The charm of stories laden with wonderful experiences is so enriching
Please have a video on foreign minister Jaishankars most recent comments about indian foreign strategy from now on.
No need total confused they are on foreign policy, after the faliure of the renewed policy they will renew it again !!
Read his address at the Ramnath Goenka lecture
Any source to see?
th-cam.com/video/LZ1WOEU2Sdo/w-d-xo.html
Aadi the main point is to do away with the dogmas of the past.
I sincerely hope sir your channels grows to 100 M
Indian needs good journalism and journalist and you sir are one of them
Congratulations to SG Sir and whole team
Fingers crossed, Mohit! Thank you for your fantastic support and encouragement! Do tune in for a special live episode of #CTC at 7 pm tonight!
Sedition law : government
Contempt of court : judiciary
And we are in a democracy....
TBH ... NO
Democracy ke naam par har kisi ki gand me ghusne ki azadi le lo tum, Bhushan case is different he goes with petitions everytime to same court one which he do not have trust, now if you dont have trust then why you go with new new petition and whenever he loses case, he tweets...jaise chota bachcha rota mummi mera toy nahi diya supreme court ne...halwa hai kya...har bar...and I am sure court will not punish him since supreme court is not what bushan want to portray. And I wish and sure will get relief with stern warning...
Hi Yash, the sedition law only prevents you from talking anything that degrades the integrity of the nation. That's because, we still are a young country and learning to be tolerant. At times of extreme internal disturbance, this is used. Everything else if protected under the free speech. Making a rhetoric statement on democracy because of these statements is too much of a exaggeration right?
@@shishirsks do you think this person has the cognitive capability to understand what you just stated?
If he did possess intelligence, he wouldnt have commented that in the first place.
@@shishirsks seditious speech in itself is not degrading the integrity of the country. There are many riders attached to it, like does the speech incite violence, harms public order?
So the govt needs to use it cautiously, any speech cant be labelled seditious.
That is how we move to a mature democracy
Congratulations on the million. I feel so happy for the print’s success.
Thank you Preet! Don’t forget to tune in at 7 pm tonight for a special LIVE episode of #CutTheClutter!
No one need to lower reputation of judiciary these days.
Who would like to hurt a person when the person himself is doing that by himself?
so you want sc to work on your will?
@@tipsandtricks5289 it'd be better if you have shared some information supporting your opinion, not using slang.
@@tipsandtricks5289 Sheldon Cooper of comments section😅 just sayin
Congratulations to Shekhar gupta and his team, now the print family is 1M and growing..
Prashant Bhushan needs to be thrown into prison .... next the rest of the gang of bench fixers must face the judicial music.
He and his father always stood against the evil
He fought the case for victim in shahbhuddin acid murder case in supreme Court.
Just because he has different ideology doesn't mean he should be in jail.
Liberty is a part of our constitution , I'm not taking anyone side but just saying that just putting someone in jail because of contempt shows how intolerant we are
Sure let’s check his history
- Bofors Scam pe book in 1990
- Fought against Privitisation of BPCL
- Fight against corrupt IAS of UP
- Fought 2G scam
- Fought against Coal Scam
- Fought against Congress appointing a allegedly corrupt official as CVC
- yes no one can defend him .. not from blind people and Bhakts
The SC has not bought laurels for itself by some of the most controversial verdicts in history.
They were brave to put india from third class dragging old cases with full proof for political purposes to opening India to new road
Whatever said and done, we need to exercise some amount of restraint in everything we do. Seems like basic courtesy and common sense have been sacrificed at the altar of own ego and self importance.
Marine engineering from which college ?
@@bobinpune abey chutiye har comment K neeche jake yhi bhadwagiri kr rha h.. Nhi sunte kafeel Khan ki chutiya h kafeel Khan.. Jaa ukhad le jo ukhadta ho
@@bobinpune You are just like Prashant Bhushan. Can talk nonsense without evidence.
@@bobinpune You are just like Prashant Bhushan. Can talk nonsense without evidence.
@Marine: Cant put better than that!
Clearly described Contempt of court, giving national and international cases. Lawmaker to put up an example to the public. 👍
Prashant Bhushan has been going on too long with this. Good job Supreme Court.
Excellent analysis on the issue of Contempt of Courts.
“Our democracy will not sustain if we can’t guarantee freedom of speech and expression,” Prime Minister Narendra Modi said in June 2014, after a month in office. Indeed, free speech is so ingrained that Amartya Sen’s 2005 book, The Argumentative Indian, remains as relevant today as ever.
Yet Indian governments at both the national and state level do not always share these values, passing laws and taking harsh actions to criminalize peaceful expression. The Indian government uses draconian laws such as the Arm Force Special Power Act, the sedition provisions of the penal code, the criminal defamation law, and laws dealing with hate speech to silence dissent. These laws are vaguely worded, overly broad, and prone to misuse, and have been repeatedly used for political purposes against critics at the national and state level.
The Supreme Court has so far refused to intervene in the matter or even pose pertinent questions to the executive and hold it accountable for its policies (or lack thereof) to abate the crisis. Even as the government is making patently false statements in court, including the statement by the Solicitor General recorded in the order dated March 31, passed in Alakh Alok Srivastava vs Union of India that as of 11 am that day, no person was walking on the roads to reach their home/village. Not only has the court abdicated its judicial responsibility, it has also demonstrated an unprecedented apathy and heartlessness to the plight of the most vulnerable citizens of the country.
It was the Supreme Court which interpreted the fundamental right to life enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution to mean the right to live with dignity and not mere animal-like existence. The nation expects its rights jurisprudence to advance with each successive generation of its Justices. It is, however, extremely distressing to see statements from the Chief Justice, according to whom as long as migrant workers are being provided food, they do not need to be paid wages, or the absolutely callous manner in which the Court stated that “it cannot monitor the activities of those walking on the road.”
congrats Shekhar Gupta you are an inspiration and a bright light to millions. May God bless you.
Prashant needs to be told there are limits for his free speech.Lately,he was crossing all limits of decency.
when the people u look upto and depend on mess around, what do u expect people who have also worked as activists with the people, do in response to irresponsible decisions??
@@bobinpune You are just like Prashant Bhushan. Can talk nonsense without evidence.
Shekhar sir, THANK YOU. you literally are a clutter breaker.
Do you know? By and large, contemners are let off by the courts with a warning or after an apology. In civil contempt case, it is always so. Even in criminal contempt cases,Very few are actually jailed. But Prashant Bhushan has stepped one too many judicial toes. Even he must learn to restrain himself, just as the judges too will eventually do so.
Wonderfully presented. Hope Justice Arun Mishra and others are watching. If you are in public life and your role is continuous conflict resolution you need to be able to take criticism however unjustified you may think it to be. There will always be aggrieved group. The same goes for the Government. You can't be that touchy.
While there might be some merrit to what you say, but it is also important to look at the intent of the person, and in Prashant Bhushan's case one can clearly see that it was malicious and to sow discontent against the court in minds of people. That to me is very dangerous
Prashant Bhushan is a commie bastard, he doesn't deserve any sympathy
If you're only going to defend freedom of speech with people you like and agree with, then you're not really defending freedom of speech.
@@yusuf.k.m well the same can be applied to judges too then, they also have freedom of speech and our constitution has given their freedom of speech the highest honor which makes it a law. Prashant Bhushan's freedom of speech cannot supercede the will of the constitution
@@yusuf.k.m If someone abuses your mothers character in front of you is it freedom of speech ??.... Understanding the difference between Criticism of an issue and criticism on the character of the judges of the highest court IF what will save freedom of speech.... continuing with " I will say whatever I want" and you cant do shit about it is the sure shot way to kill freedom of speech
@@0609Bhuwan Why will it kill anything if their character is abused?
People abuse Narendra Modi's character all day. They abuse Rahul Gandhi's character even. So what difference will it make it some judges character is abused?
The judges should learn to live with it. With power comes criticism.
Thank you SG and the whole team of The Print, for your journalism. Really appreciate it 👍👏
SG has equated honest mistakes & criticism of decisions with repeated & vicious comments about Judges just because they did not agree with PB. Ignoring such comments will encourage others to follow suit. It is high time he gets a slap on his wrist at the minimum.
Allow me to disagree with your conclusion. For 'a slap on the wrist' that you talk about would not desist people with malicious intent from disparaging the Judges, but what it might do is to silence the honest criticism. And, I don't think it's wrong to criticise judges. Infact the condition where our justice system is, where people have lost faith in judiciary so much so that a common man cheers when gangster or rapists are killed in staged encounteres not because they like this overreach of Police, but because they don't trust in Judiciary to deliver them timely justice. And, the biggest, or maybe even sole blame of this rests on the Judges who have not only done nothing to reform themsleves but have actively obstructed Parliaments attempt to bring about any kind of reforms.
@@anonymouspm44 OK let me reply..
First I also feel there is a high time that we need judicial reform this is so evident by looking at some current cases as they take eons of time to settle down. But at the same time I don't feel there is a need to defame someone. He has lost cases one by one. It's unjust to say they are wrong when you lost the case. And keep mum when they give verdict in your favor.. If you have any evidences indicating that their position is compromised. Just put it in publicly. That's it..
No suo moto on
- Labour’s on foot travel
- nothing on Delhi Riots
Sure our SC has the priorities correct .. aligned with the Government’s
@@vbond585 Supreme Court issued guidelines for migrant labourers what are you talking about.
Pratik Kantode yes yes they did .. but at first they said “If labour’s can’t wait and want to go on foot then what can govt do.. “ they changed after a month .. wow .. Kudos
One of the Best of @shekhar gupta. Good luck.
Sir, one has to see the intent also. Bhushan intentions are not good. Wasn’t he behind sex allegations against CJI ?
it's not allegation but true incident against former cji.
He used to make false allegations on almost everyone with whom he didn't agree. For me it's too much on the name of FOE.
In tht case shudnt Subramanian Swamy also face contempt charges fr faking 2g scam nos. fr calling SC horrendous names in the past
Appointment of Judges in High Courts and Supreme Court should be limited to One Year only. And should not allow them to make ego clashes in between the Advocates and other Constitutional functionaries. I support Mr. Prashant Bhutan. What he has done is the real facts only. Most of the present Judgments from the Supreme courts are not on the basis of Natural Justice or on Law. It can be seen in Ayodhya Case. Demolishing of Flats in Kerala. Here in Kerala the most sufferers are the common people who spent their hard earned money for dream Houses. what was really gained out of this demolition process. The Court should have punished the actual conspirators and put them in Jail for life time. Decisions must not only be fair and it seemed to be fair also. We afraid the lack of applying Judicial mind in most of the present apex Court Decisions. Very shameful .
Prashant Bhushan part-time is to file PILs.
The SC must try him to set precedent for others. IF the courts itself are not respected, there will be chaos.
No bro.. It is his full time job...
@@bobinpune India is a democratic country and it will remain so.
@@bobinpune India is a diverse country, after every km, something changes,inter-community protests, riots happens in one state or another. That is why the democracy index in low.
For eg. after George Floyd's incident, the American democratic index will decrease, but America is democratic. So that is not a major issue.
Indian democracy is also influenced by foreign powers.
Rishabh Gupta He is a reputed social activist, fights for others when we sit criticising him, he gathers evidence to secure us. Let the judiciary judge its own judgements. No one is incorrigible
Very nice analysis with authentic stories of the House of Lords and India's Supreme Court. Thanks.
Critisism of a Judgement is not wrong, even every person has the right to critise the judge, but what Prashant Bhishan did was he had cast aspersions on the whole institution of justice. He has critised the supremen court as a whole levelling really below the belt allegations!! Which is very different from any critisism of any judgement or a judge or any specific instance!
He gets attacks of विनाशकाले विपरीत बुद्धी
A very witty and informative session with you. I too think that Supreme Court should not punish Mr.Prashanth Bhushan for his tweets. Because in democracy freedom of expression is the highest priority. If judges behave like lords and monarchs, they will have to send many citizens to jail. Defamation is okay because nobody has a right to insult another person.
Yayyee! A live session with SG was much awaited!
So true :D
Yipeeeere
Yes, this was the need of the hour. We all need to know the reasoning and intellect behind this matter. A more detailed analysis is required.
Yes, finally the topic of discussion awaited by the masses is out. Thank you sir for bringing such profound analysis and day to day current affairs to us in such a concise manner.
Vanshaj Setia mn
You are doing a wonderful job Shekhar sir. Congratulations for reaching Million mark.
Thank you! Don’t forget to tune in at 7 pm tonight for a special LIVE episode of #CutTheClutter!
Sir tmrw we need a cut the clutter on the print and your journey in journalism on account of completion of 1 million subscribers
Hi Navi! Don’t forget to tune in at 7 pm tonight for a special LIVE episode of #CutTheClutter!
Whilst healthy criticism, free speech and agree to disagree are hallmark of a vibrant democracy, attempt to malign and arm twist the judges to apply pressure on them are deplorable. An objective evaluation of a judgment is welcome and very much essential. Personel attacks on judges will erode people’s faith in judiciary and undermine the institution. I agree with Mr. Gupta that the judges need to be magnanimous in accepting criticisms. Also, there is a need to draw a red line of propriety and decency that senior lawyers should not cross. I enjoyed watching this episode and, your unbiased and balanced assessment is laudable.
After listening to so much free speech.. I have started having question, is absolute freedom of speech is good or bad?
Only a Sith deals in absolutes.
try reading on the french revolution and the terror that followed, and you'll get the best case study for answering your question
Madness luk at usa ryt nw,the protesters who r protesting against wearing masks reason is they can't touch my freedom of expression and speech
Ashutosh Pandey don’t talk like that about our PM😷
Excess of everything is harmful
Prashant is great. He speaks truth to the power.
We all know how all the institutions are being paralyzed in installments.
We need more people like Prashant who checks the power.
CJI should not have let himself be seen riding a Harley Davidson bike without helmets and masks! That too in lockdown when even the SC was shut denying the right to justice to citizens.
My salute to you for raising this issue even though you don't agree with Prasant Bhusan on many issues.
Prashant Bhushan is that guy who will file a PIL in supreme court of India
even Nepal bans beef
In India, no need to ban. We have mob lynching sponsered by RSS
@Ashley D The guy who led the mob lynching was sitting in the front row of the yogi adithyanth's meeting and shouting slogans. (As per bhakts, it is fake news)
As long as he was with you and your RSS sponsored Anna Hazare drama , he was fine . lol
@@joyal876 here we meet a bag of rice
@Ashley D then why the police? Only mob lynchers like you are needed.
Congratulations on the one million subscribers The Print. So happy.
It's not about SC or judgement. This PB tried to literally and knowingly tarnish the reputation of Chief Justice of India. This is not small matter and this pb is doing it continuously.
He need to be punished. Freedom of expression (Art.19) is not absolute and come with certain restrictions.
Mr. Sekhar ji.🙏🏼
Congratulations on achieving the million subscribers mark. I have been following your videos for quite a long time now. Honestly
I am a big admirer of your knowledge and experience, yet I am very sceptical about your views. That's the only reason I had not subscribed you yet. But since mid- 2019 or so, I am observing a very changed approach of yours and loving it. Now its an honour for me to subscribe you on this special occasion of million mark and I feel happy to be a part of it. And ofcourse I love your storytelling.
Thanks again.
God bless you. Your wisdom is much needed for us.
Criticism is like an appeal that could be attended with all humility and patience !
I am here only because of you sir.You are one of the finest reporter on earth.
Everyone is fallible and so is Shekhar Gupta, Prashant Bhushan and the men in question.
Everyone is fallible except Modi and his bios
So are the courts and the government.
Akhand Bharat zindabad!
Modiji zindabad!
Brahmanwad murdabad!
Akhand Bharat Mata ki Jai!
well said... I would have preferred they send him to exile maybe to Pak or China or sentence to life.. The as$^&le does not deserve to be in the public life...
Congratulations The print. For 1M🌹 empowering the journalism. Thank you Shekhar Sir!👌
Thank you! Don’t forget to tune in at 7 pm tonight for a special LIVE episode of #CutTheClutter!
But what about when someone decides to waste the precious time of Supreme Court..... Especially in India by his petitions after petitions...
For Saving some one who has killed thousands..
Contempt convictions should be 100%, stricter and harsher. Your talk is bunkum.
Now you are trying to Influence Supreme Court and very subtle way..
The presumption would be accurate if the SC judges watch CTC. But I got the same feeling..
Shekhar, has merely given you how democracies deal with such issues. When rule of law gets replaced with Law by Who Ruled, prob are galores
On million subscribers - Many many congratulations Shekhar Sir and the ' Print ' team, and thanks for the quality journalism which is rare these days
Kind words Sachin! Thank you for your fantastic support and encouragement! Do tune in for a special live episode of #CTC at 7 pm tonight!
What all examples you have cited are criticism of judgment or basic human mistakes but what Prashant Bhushan has been doing is nothing related to judgments. He just questioned the very bases of Judiciary by commenting on last 4 cji or by associating current cji with political party. This has to stop PERIOD
If the current CJI behaves this way,the way he was silent on migrant crisis,journalists getting silenced and murdered,numerous human rights violations,not hearing the case of CAA,legality of art 370 abrogation
Wat shud we say then,he's the best CJI india has ever had
The best CJI is the one who tows the line of Prasant Bhushan
@@sagarvijayendra8683 a person with a Communist symbol speaking for freedom of speech lol!
@@Varun-ek2jp y shudnt I,wud u say the same fr a guy who wears the Nazi symbol I wud respect u
But to say freedom of speech is only restricted to liberals,pseudo-capitalist,imperialists,conservatives,orthodoxy etc.
and not commies then there's srsly wrong with u
U think tht we follow Marx ideology the problem is he has listed all the problems but no solution,so we need to move towards free market economy and not one-company economy
@@sagarvijayendra8683
Dont Lie .There is no concept of freedom of speech in communist ideology . Just Qoute one Communist country
Please Do more episodes on law and economics (real not theoretical), because general public are mostly ignorant about these two subjects. You are awesome ❣️
Meanwhile in background : golmal hai bhai sab golmaal h
@@bobinpune You are just like Prashant Bhushan. Can talk nonsense without evidence.
CONGRATULATIONS, TEAM 'PRINT' FOR ONE MILLION SUBSCRIBER.
He is DEMONIZING four judges out of his tweet but he is innocent.
Congratulations The Print for reaching a Milestone.
Thank you! Don’t forget to tune in at 7 pm tonight for a special LIVE episode of #CutTheClutter!
I will buy you autobiography whenever it comes out.
Congrats Gupta Ji . A million strong!!
Prashanth Bhushan lives a live of denial where he thinks everything he do is right
Those leftist always think they are right in whatever they say
@Anti Hater Hey there I have a position in my startup please can you join us and work for free please we don't plan on giving job to anyone who asks salary .... Interested?
@Anti Hater 😂
Everybody do so, don't they?
All of us believe, we are right.
@@rushigaikwad Ha ha, is your startup for the national good?
Listening you helps me complete my day! Keep up the good, glad to be part of first million. Wishing you fortunes and billion milestones of success. Thank you for being a reliable news source.
Loved this episode. Wish it had been much more longer, can't get enough of Shekhar Sir's stories.
I hope our esteemed Supreme Court still has broad shoulders and continues to have it. Justice should be tempered with Mercy and understanding of a different view.
Please start a series where you discuss stories from your past, I am convinced you have numerous of them.
And do tell your learnings & mistakes .
It will be fun.
A very valuable episode. Contempt of court is hardly ever discussed anywhere. Thank you Gupta Sahab.
If sr adv was 'eminent' does he need to stoop to level, mocking SC and their members
sorry i didn't know I was speaking to a judge @@bobinpune
Rangan Gogoi is rajya sabha member. Why?
Well said Mr Shekhar Gupta
Its very difficult to forgive
And easy to Punish
Negative ….always,,.....if you have guts speak on Phalgar incident...
Also on Keezhadi and Gottiprolu.
Many in media and intelligentsia are of the belief that this contempt of court order will create a precedent of sorts. Especially since it's done by the SC. But by targeting the judges rather than the judgement Mr. Bhushan has literally brought it upon himself. And please Mr. Gupta don't disrespect the intelligence of your audience by saying "just because he said something on Twitter..". While prosecuting him will create a precedent, not doing so will do the same. Just like conservatism leads to tyranny liberalism leads to anarchy. To maintain this push and pull balance a slap on the wrist was long due. 😎
Sir how can I express my whole hearted 💔 towards you. The only way I envisage is by hugging you. Hope some day I can do that for you being a finest person in general and in journalism in particular
Congratulations @ThePrint for first 1 million.
Keep spreading truth and knowledge in the world full of lies and deceit.
And Thanks for ur wonderful content.
Cong on 1M Sir!! Totally well deserved :) even if all u had was CTC u would still have these many subscribers :)
Thank you PKJ! Don’t forget to tune in at 7 pm tonight for a special LIVE episode of #CutTheClutter!
Congrats Shekherji on achieving 1 million subscribers. May ur good journalism find many more million ears. All the best.
WHEN POOR LABOURERS WERE WALKING HUNGRY THOUSANDS OF KMS.,THESE WISE MEN DID NOT REMEMBER ,THERE IS SOMETHING CALLED SUO MOTO COGNISANCE ?
When executive is not doing its duty
Should the sc sleep ?
Eat some wallnut so ur brain start working.
Mr. Shekhar Gupta is a beast in the disguise of a gentleman who had interviewed Sonia alias Antonio Myno. Asked her the most difficult questions of Kitchen instead of the politics. He is on the payroll of Congress & Communist.
Salim Nariman wittiness incident made my day .. And Lord's statement .... Old fool, yes i am Old but to think we are fools is a opinions
Fali Nariman not Salim
I noticed Print now has 1M subscribers. So nice to see such a good channel gaining popularity. Well done Print! This is well deserved
Bhushan kind of guy doesn't worth my time or anyone time. You wasting your time defending an abuser of free speech.
Doesn't mean tht SC has to file contempt charges against him
Then why bother .. just chill
Very right !! This should have been done before.
Arun jetaly's reference made my day
Thank you SG!
Bhushan is another exploiter of court time. Maybe he needs psychiatric evaluation now.
@@bobinpune Jo Bhushan kahe wahi sahi bhushan hi saccha hai certificate bat rhe hai bhushan k office se. Tum kaho toh din tum kaho to raat aur baaki kahe toh fasiwaad Gajab ho bey. Gogoi jab supreme court k bahar protest kr rhe they toh woh adarshwadi aur jab unhone bhushan k khilaf faisla diya woh beimaan. Bobde CJI banne se pehle acche aur bhushan ka case reject kiya woh dogle waah rey bewakoofon Kahan se late ho itna doglapan?
@@bobinpune Duniya mai communism ne sirf aur sirf dictator diye hai aur yahan wahi log democracy k burqe mai ghoom rhe hai😂
@@bobinpune kho gya kya bandu?😂
SG, prasant Bhusan, kapil sibal, rajeev dhavan these guys think they are invincible and get away with all kind of contempt under the self appointed security cover of democracy and constitution. These guys should be in jail. Sg the SC does not issue any contempt notice to any normal citizens. Its these defender of crooks whom the notice is issued. So don't make a big deal.
Track today's Live CTC today here th-cam.com/video/OIx2HJ-JeeQ/w-d-xo.html
Sir
Daily I get a penny more
Thanks
Blindly you are supporting an anti-nationalist, who is a currupt persons, any cost he should be punished.
Dear Shri you are trying to influence honorable Court and giving direction, How to decide preceding to most honorable bench, doubting there wisdom. this is contempt of the supreme court 4 chief justiced of India and contempt of of their four years work ,. doing devaluation of Supreme Court of India. This is not analysis of a particular case. Dr Yogendra Jain
Correction 4 chief justice
Yes all the so-called "liberals" and Left-aligned intellectuals who selectively pick up topics and cause friction must be hauled up and jailed. This include people in the media who have benefited from seven decades of Congress rule - I am talking of real benefits- luxurious bungalows in posh, upper-class localities of Indian cities, money, perks, foreign travel and other deals- and hide their loyalties while selectively raising issues about Courts, judges and the government at the behest of their providers. All of this is done whiled being silent about the Congress-Left corruption and killings that have put Indian democracy in danger- Do you wonder why the "Electronic Voting Machine" (EVM) does not hold any fascination for the Indian media and politicians nowadays?
All of these traitors, self-serving intellectuals should be jailed- better- hung from the nearest lampost after a trial.
The Stature of our Supreme Court is so high that it should not be bothered by such issues.It is now a fashion in our country to go after people who do not agree with one's viewpoint.The SC must continue its job of granting justice to the people which it has been doing so well over the years rather than giving cognizance to any petty comments.Its time is too valuable
Prashant Bhushan thinks that he is above law and last word in wisdom. He cannot rub the courts on the wrong side all the time. He will be put to place by the court, else no one will obey them.
Shekarji you monopolize and capture my interest on current affairts at the cost of all other shouting matches on TV. Thank you sir, millions of us sensible Indians look forward to 9.30 pm everyday. And the Print is a great idea, I think you created a brilliant new business model inadvertently.
I regulaly see cut the clutter n its so enriching me everyday. This is only political view which i see . Hats off u sir . U r doing such a wonderful thing with so much of passion
So much praise for British courts which most of the times stop extraditions of fugitives and culprits to India...
Prashant Bhushan should propose the name of Chief Justice for Rajya Sabha, that will squash the contempt case.