As a student of Economics,I was a big fan of Bishwo sir but this interview looks more like he is saving the face of government and his post ! I know bureaucracy won’t allow him to go against but most of us have been considering him as an independent economist and he should move beyond the comfort zone !!
Thank you for the pushback on the statement made by Arjoo. Biases on his part were annoyingly obvious. This interview is mostly about the guest defending his institution and his lackluster performance. I also spotted a lack of acceptance of responsibility, good explanation for the setbacks and in-depth explanations for failed policies. One of those interviews where the host is better prepared and more driven for change than the so-called “intellectual and scholarly” guest. Nevertheless, an informative interview as always. Thank you 🙏🏻
I think you’re undermining the guest. Watch this interview th-cam.com/video/-CuOvnnyfeY/w-d-xo.html where he is given a better chance to talk and explain compared to this interview.
पहिला भ्रष्टाचार गर्ने हरु लाई समात्नु।किनकि मेयर देखि वाडा अध्यक्ष सम्म भ्रष्टाचार ले भरिएका छ्न।खास गरी मधेस प्रदेश मा-त्यस पछि बजेट निकासा गर्नु हौउ....
Dil bhusan sir, even he was completely capable, he didn't explain any of the plan of nepal planning commission with logical and fullproof plan. No matter how complex is planning, it must be understandable by general financial literate people like me. And he is normalizing all the fault and pointing it to the whole system and finding an excuse. He is politically driven and he is defending the government which is seen clearly rather than expressing the energy for the change. And sir, interview mustn't only be informative, it must be interrogative too.
नेपालमा जहॅा जो आए पनी , जती, जहॅा पढेको भए पनी हुनेवाला केही छैन् , जब सम्म “ चाकडी “ नगरने वाउको छोरा आउदैन् । जब सम्म चाकडी तव सम्म नेपालीले दु:ख पाईनै रहने हो । सिॅफ ठूला ठूला कुरा मात्र हो।
The Problems are in Public Financial Management and Public Procurement area. None of the interviewee have such knowledge in these fields. NPC is unable to tackle the project bank, monitoring and evaluation-even it is done it is ritual. If the problems of budget analysis and preparation is good then half problem is solved, then the problems are in procurement preparation and contract management-lack of punishment. Therefore, a joint conversation with economist-PFM-Procurement expert can be a useful dialogue and the public can be benefitted from the dialogue. If you really want to deliver a fruitful result of discussion. Suresh Pradhan Fmr. Fin.Comptroller
This guy didnt explain any of his plan. He was on the surface on most topics. He also seems pro-congress. Everytime you ask him question be brings out failure of A-Ma-le sarkar
The journalist did not ask this economist why budget is sent in Mangsir. This economist was saying somewhere that budget actually takes off in Mangsir by tender process. He could have asked why not budget is sent in Shrawan 1. Why tender process is delayed? Does Ministry of Economic Affairs prints each page, keeps in envelopes and sends the information to each individual palikas or how? How many workers are there in Ministry of Economic Affairs? Why does things get delayed? Why not Shrawan 1 if budget comes in Jestha 15? If the journalist could have asked these questions, at least we could understand the process of budget implementation which could help us understand the process and protest against such practices. I request journalist to ask these questions next time if he invites somebody to explicitly talk about budget and its processes.
Everyone is praising this guy. He is defending this government no matter what. He is saying the rate at which we have been completing our project is fine. This guy is a total puppet of Nepali Congress. Rather than being responsible and criticizing this government he would not miss the chance to blame last government.
This man completely puppet of some political party not a planner but politician has got view whats going economically in country but cant do anything to improve it. Interview herda ni interview line sir manmanai socheko hola jasto kasto manxe lai NPC ko yesto pad diyeko hola. Haha
You can study from Hardvard or MIT, if you are okay with the current state of Neplal and thinks that government can’t do anything than you are not capable. If your prime minister and government is not capble of change than why are you and your prime minister there? Why don’t you leave?
Interview dekhda tw vison tw xadai xaina kay,yo garxu tyo garxu vanne tw jo aaye ni tei vanxan tara tyo kaam haru kailay vayena……junai jogi aaye ni kaan chiryeko.
Just woww😍
As a student of Economics,I was a big fan of Bishwo sir but this interview looks more like he is saving the face of government and his post ! I know bureaucracy won’t allow him to go against but most of us have been considering him as an independent economist and he should move beyond the comfort zone !!
Person with depth knowledge ! Amazing !
आरजुको मान्छे रछ स्पस्ट थाहा भो !!😏🤨
Thank you Dilbhusan sir!
Really intesting bahash 🙏🙏🌹🇳🇵
you helped with my project thank you, sir❤
नीति तथा कार्यक्रम कार्यान्वयन नहुने पक्का भो
Keep going
Thank you for the pushback on the statement made by Arjoo. Biases on his part were annoyingly obvious. This interview is mostly about the guest defending his institution and his lackluster performance. I also spotted a lack of acceptance of responsibility, good explanation for the setbacks and in-depth explanations for failed policies. One of those interviews where the host is better prepared and more driven for change than the so-called “intellectual and scholarly” guest. Nevertheless, an informative interview as always. Thank you 🙏🏻
I think you’re undermining the guest. Watch this interview th-cam.com/video/-CuOvnnyfeY/w-d-xo.html where he is given a better chance to talk and explain compared to this interview.
Hopeful and full of positivity!
योजना आयोगमा बसेर काम गर्ने मान्छे , पाटिको प्रबता भएर बोल्ने यो कस्तो तरिका हो
From Japan 🇯🇵
पहिला भ्रष्टाचार गर्ने हरु लाई समात्नु।किनकि मेयर देखि वाडा अध्यक्ष सम्म भ्रष्टाचार ले भरिएका छ्न।खास गरी मधेस प्रदेश मा-त्यस पछि बजेट निकासा गर्नु हौउ....
Dil bhusan sir, even he was completely capable, he didn't explain any of the plan of nepal planning commission with logical and fullproof plan. No matter how complex is planning, it must be understandable by general financial literate people like me. And he is normalizing all the fault and pointing it to the whole system and finding an excuse. He is politically driven and he is defending the government which is seen clearly rather than expressing the energy for the change.
And sir, interview mustn't only be informative, it must be interrogative too.
नेपालमा जहॅा जो आए पनी , जती, जहॅा पढेको भए पनी हुनेवाला केही छैन् , जब सम्म “ चाकडी “ नगरने वाउको छोरा आउदैन् । जब सम्म चाकडी तव सम्म नेपालीले दु:ख पाईनै रहने हो । सिॅफ ठूला ठूला कुरा मात्र हो।
नेपालमा योजनाआयोगमा काम गर्ने मान्छे पाटिको मान्छे भयर हो सिधा काग्रेसको पछेमा बोल्ने अली भएन .....की....
The Problems are in Public Financial Management and Public Procurement area. None of the interviewee have such knowledge in these fields. NPC is unable to tackle the project bank, monitoring and evaluation-even it is done it is ritual. If the problems of budget analysis and preparation is good then half problem is solved, then the problems are in procurement preparation and contract management-lack of punishment. Therefore, a joint conversation with economist-PFM-Procurement expert can be a useful dialogue and the public can be benefitted from the dialogue. If you really want to deliver a fruitful result of discussion.
Suresh Pradhan Fmr. Fin.Comptroller
This guy didnt explain any of his plan. He was on the surface on most topics. He also seems pro-congress. Everytime you ask him question be brings out failure of A-Ma-le sarkar
The journalist did not ask this economist why budget is sent in Mangsir. This economist was saying somewhere that budget actually takes off in Mangsir by tender process. He could have asked why not budget is sent in Shrawan 1. Why tender process is delayed? Does Ministry of Economic Affairs prints each page, keeps in envelopes and sends the information to each individual palikas or how? How many workers are there in Ministry of Economic Affairs? Why does things get delayed? Why not Shrawan 1 if budget comes in Jestha 15? If the journalist could have asked these questions, at least we could understand the process of budget implementation which could help us understand the process and protest against such practices. I request journalist to ask these questions next time if he invites somebody to explicitly talk about budget and its processes.
यिनको बोलिमा ओकिलको बोलिमात्र देखियो, बास्तबिक सत्य revenues income र capital expenditure बडाउने ठोस बोलि आएन
Kasto aachama yesto avibekti dine manxe lai pani hajur le dhak chop garna lagnu vayo aaba arko sarkar ma hajur feri ferini vayoo
Everyone is praising this guy. He is defending this government no matter what. He is saying the rate at which we have been completing our project is fine. This guy is a total puppet of Nepali Congress. Rather than being responsible and criticizing this government he would not miss the chance to blame last government.
What have you done to society apart from blaming others
Sarlaiko bagmati KO meyear lai bolaununa sir
This man completely puppet of some political party not a planner but politician has got view whats going economically in country but cant do anything to improve it. Interview herda ni interview line sir manmanai socheko hola jasto kasto manxe lai NPC ko yesto pad diyeko hola. Haha
Compare his interview when he was not in NPC and now that he heads its. Lost complete faith in this so called economist.
You can study from Hardvard or MIT, if you are okay with the current state of Neplal and thinks that government can’t do anything than you are not capable. If your prime minister and government is not capble of change than why are you and your prime minister there? Why don’t you leave?
Absulatelly 🤔🤔
Interview dekhda tw vison tw xadai xaina kay,yo garxu tyo garxu vanne tw jo aaye ni tei vanxan tara tyo kaam haru kailay vayena……junai jogi aaye ni kaan chiryeko.
वायत अन्तर्बत
Yo ta Congre ko maxe po hota kasari yojana ayogako maxe vayo ta
language 131 ho bishow sir
Nepal is totally collapsed !
He don’t have any vision!
very biased, seems like a political debate
nonsen economist
Hahah yo mula...ho arthabid ...yesko attitude nai kam garne khalko xaina..vai..fuche.. Change ur attitude ..