Title is misleading. He’s against protesting not being Pro Palestine. I’m don’t agree with Shamsi on a lot of things, but let’s not lie about our brother.
@@OCEAN-fc9wl so you don't know proof from Qur'an and Sunnah, that slandering, insulting and selling out your brothers in need is haram? You must be totally new to Islam.
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
@@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte what are you on about The palestinian scholar lied about that shamsi called palestinians mushrikeen when shamsi in a recent video already clarified that he didnt say palestinians are mushrikeen, he only said that there is shirk happening in palestine (churches, when people visit and do all kinds of craziness around grave of prophet ibrahim etc)
@@OCEAN-fc9wl so there is no shirk happening in algeria or morocco? Should these countries also be raped and destroyed by zionists without any help from muslimeen?
He is not saying he is against Palestine. He is saying that we need to do the same as what the prophet and his companions did when they were oppressed. The most powerful tool Muslims have is dua. We need to use that and turn to Allah.
I made a mistake about brother Shamsi, he's also right but in todays world as minorities living in the west, protesting is a form of resistance. Allah knows best.
@kashmirmylove6243 People like you would be making objections of Umar Khittab RA who got rid of the ruling of punishment according to Quran & sunnah for theifs during a famine. We Muslims in the west can't physically support the Palestinians but we can atleast voice our support.
@@lionroar26 I’m from Kashmir and under Hindus occupation I have understood that senseless protests are unacceptable and it doesn’t move the opponent even an iota. Learn Deen my brother. Don’t be taken away by your emotions. Follow the Scholars of Ahlus Sunnah.
The issue of Palestine is NOT a political Issue. It’s our Deen to take it away from the Zionist and it can’t be done except following the way of Sahaaba.
We have been told in a Hadith that upon you is the Sunnah of the Prophet and the Sunnah of rightly guided Khulafa. So we understand this act of Khalifa Umar as the act of Sunnah!
I think Shamsi has made some very valid points in this and lines up with what intellectual Palestine people are saying that Hammas should not have carried out the attack on "so called" Israel as they do not have the means to sustain a war on them. So sad to see how you were cowardly and brutally attacked at SC dear brother, sending you loving thoughts and prayers for swift healing.
He follows the quran and sunnah upon the understanding of the salaf on "creed". Salafis can follow any of the the four imams on "fiqh". Scholars such as Shaykh Salih aal-alshaykh, Salih Fawzan, Rabee Al madkali, muqbil, Obaid aljabiri, Ali ahudayfi aldeni, bin baz, Ibn Uthaimeen, Al-Albāni... Many more. All scholars of ahil asunnah. May Allah guide me and you
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
No Different of yoy and other including Daniel. Yiy all are just Muslim with Different Sect. Ya Allah SWT, may Allah SWT protect us from people anyone like Sect.
Allah SWT want us to Not Just Pray BUT Put Efforts. As long as we don't commit crimes, illegal doings, no negative intentions, positive passion, NOTHING IS WRONG TO VOICE FOR ACTUAL VICTIMS. You are Human yourself, as rational Muslims, as often happening in modern era, I won't be surprised if yoy get paid by someone or some people. *BRO, BE MUSLIMS THAT AMAR MA'RUF NAHI MUNKAR.* Much better if you Promoting how Muslims Liberals to stop supporting LGBT. Disappointed. Won't ever watch you again.
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
>Shansi this week lost all credibility he had amongst muslims No he did not. He is Alhamdu lillaah , a caller to Tawheed and Sunnah Meanwhile you lot are keyboard warriors
@@sheikhshakilakhtar1865 he cancelled himself. Instead of explaining to the umah his position in a calm manner, he stabbed the Palestinians in the back
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Schwestern Shamsi, die Salifia-Gelehrte, sagt, dass ihr Frauen nicht schreien und sagen solltet: „Frei, frei, Palästina, der Fluss, das Meer, Palästina, sei frei.“ Sehen Sie sich seine Aussagen selbst auf TH-cam an
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Aren’t you done with the hypocrisy doing all these things didn’t help Palestine and will never help we Muslims should start being Muslims that’s when victory comes
@@jojoahmd123 He worried about free mixing while people getting killed seriously... Isn't he free mixing in the park anyway ? straight up weirdo trying to find any excuse to attack muslims and defend the oppressor Why doesn't he teach people to support palestine instead, isn't that Islam?
So according to this guy we all need to be super duper islamic then victory will come I find that to be unrealistic even during the time of the prophet PBUH some people where strong and others where weak in the deen
In Surah Noor Ayah 55 Allah said that He would grant us power over land when we avoid shirk and become completely obedient to Allah. So yea, we need to be super duper Islamic. And all Sahabahs were super duper Islamic
@@thetruthful1612 what shirk did Palestinian muslims do? does Allah give trials and tribulations exclusively to the wrongdoers as punishment or also to the righteous as a test? what evidence from what authority do you have to prove that Palestinians are given punishment and not a test? if you answer just "quran and sunnah" again without elaborating and connecting with facts of these events WALLAHI i pray to Allah for the plight of the Palestinians to be lifted up and immediately be put upon you
@@exceed.charge I didn't say Palestinians are committing shirk. I didn't say Palestinians are going through punishment neither did i say they are going through test. I didn't say any of those things. I just posted a verse as a solution for having power over lands. And btw, Muhammad peace be upon him said that it's not allowed to curse fellow Muslims.
@@thetruthful1612 then why did you quote the verse in this thread? what did you imply with your previous comment? if we CURRENTLY need to be super duper islamic then what are we NOW? not good enough? if Allah's help comes only if we're already super duper islamic then western reverts wouldn't stay as muslims for long living in the west.
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Nope, in my Country wahabi preacher also said the same thing. That Palestinian (and muslim as a whole) should not fought Israel, that Palestinian should leave palestine to another country, that we shouldn't give donations to palestine, etc
@@jojoahmd123 You could hear it yourself, you could search "Riyad Bajrey Palestina", he is Indonesian speaking wahabi preacher. And so many Ahlussunnah Ulama has debunk his statement.
@@jojoahmd123 "what he said but the truth", is this how a muslim should behave? Just listen to one opinion and than claim the ultimate truth?? May be you should learn more deep about Islam before opening your mouth
Atleast he said something positive here. But I am against his thinking here. Women shd come out in these times, even they may need to raise swords and fight. So those who r raising their voice in protest, salute to them( if in pardah). Those who say women shd not come out, shd come and live in Afghanistan, entire west is dirty. Men shdnot even go to market, its haram(u can't control ur eyes, u can't even raise ur head)
>Women shd come out in these times, even they may need to raise swords and fight. Is this a command from Allaah and His Messenger(salAllaahu 'alayhi wa sallam) or your desire to watch women?
@@TH-camvideo22t they all are martyrs. He is a deviant. Hv not watched the entire video so can't say if he said so. Every individual being killed in Palestine if they r Muslim are all martyrs.
Embarrassing conduct from shamsi.. claims to have knowledge but insults people for lack of knowledge when they ask him. Instead of explaining to his follow muslims he is shouting and getting emotional
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine ….. he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
@@jojoahmd123 I watched him attack Muslims and try to embarrass them on camera asking them about the Deen . He's trying to say these kids know nothing about Islam yet they want to defend Palestine. Can you imagine how arrogant that comes off. He knows more about the Deen and tries to use that as a weapon against other Muslims who know less. Then there is the other question as to why he believes it's okay to criticise Turkish leaders and Palestinian leaders but says it's haram to criticise Saudi leaders. What's the difference between gulf nation leaders and Turkish and Hamas?
We hold that the ruler is to be obeyed, whether righteous or sinful. And rebellion against the tyrannical Muslim ruler is forbidden, even if he behaves like a Shaitān, does not practice the Sunnah, beats the backs of the people, imprisons them and takes their wealth. This is in accordance with the statement of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم): “You will have rulers over you. They will not follow my Sunnah, nor follow my guidance. There will be amongst them men who will have the hearts of devils in the bodies of men.”Hudhaifah (رضي الله عنه) asked: “O Messenger of Allāh! What should I do if I reach that time?”He replied: “Hear and obey the ruler, even if he beats you in your back and takes your wealth. Hear and obey him!” We hold that one is obligated to be patient with the tyrannical ruler, just as the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said: “If one of you sees something from your ruler that displeases you, then be patient.” We believe that it is forbidden to publicly rebuke the Rulers as that is the way of the misguided Khawārij, just as the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said: “Whoever desires to advise the Ruler, then he should not do so publicly, rather he should take him by his hand and take him into seclusion [and then advise]. So, either he accepts the advice from him, and if not, then he has fulfilled the duty that was upon him.”
Title is misleading. He’s against protesting not being Pro Palestine. I’m don’t agree with Shamsi on a lot of things, but let’s not lie about our brother.
Even a palestinian scholar denounced shamsi by name. Allah exposes many hypocrites and imposters.
I saw the video of this palestinian scholar, and to no surprise, he did not quote a single hadtih or verse to use against Shamsi.
@@OCEAN-fc9wl so you don't know proof from Qur'an and Sunnah, that slandering, insulting and selling out your brothers in need is haram? You must be totally new to Islam.
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
@@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte what are you on about
The palestinian scholar lied about that shamsi called palestinians mushrikeen when shamsi in a recent video already clarified that he didnt say palestinians are mushrikeen, he only said that there is shirk happening in palestine (churches, when people visit and do all kinds of craziness around grave of prophet ibrahim etc)
@@OCEAN-fc9wl so there is no shirk happening in algeria or morocco? Should these countries also be raped and destroyed by zionists without any help from muslimeen?
I agree
He is not saying he is against Palestine. He is saying that we need to do the same as what the prophet and his companions did when they were oppressed. The most powerful tool Muslims have is dua. We need to use that and turn to Allah.
Did the prophet and his companions celebrate Halloween?
He is Saudi agent.
@@ZeeshanAnsari-hy5zgNo
Wrong they fought when it was time to fight u clown
Yes, they did dua and they also took action. In the Palestinian cause we pray, protest and boycott
14:33 which hadith is shamsi referring to here please
I like this guy
I think that the one who wears black glasses and a white hat and covers his face is the preacher 'Ali Daawa' , Who agrees with me?
😆
Don't think so brother, wild guess though
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
I made a mistake about brother Shamsi, he's also right but in todays world as minorities living in the west, protesting is a form of resistance. Allah knows best.
Is protesting legislated in Islam at the first place.
@kashmirmylove6243 People like you would be making objections of Umar Khittab RA who got rid of the ruling of punishment according to Quran & sunnah for theifs during a famine.
We Muslims in the west can't physically support the Palestinians but we can atleast voice our support.
@@lionroar26 I’m from Kashmir and under Hindus occupation I have understood that senseless protests are unacceptable and it doesn’t move the opponent even an iota. Learn Deen my brother. Don’t be taken away by your emotions. Follow the Scholars of Ahlus Sunnah.
The issue of Palestine is NOT a political Issue. It’s our Deen to take it away from the Zionist and it can’t be done except following the way of Sahaaba.
We have been told in a Hadith that upon you is the Sunnah of the Prophet and the Sunnah of rightly guided Khulafa. So we understand this act of Khalifa Umar as the act of Sunnah!
May ALLAH be the judge
Shamsi is Waiting for birds to throw stones
Even if that's true then it's better than cause more harm than good
I think Shamsi has made some very valid points in this and lines up with what intellectual Palestine people are saying that Hammas should not have carried out the attack on "so called" Israel as they do not have the means to sustain a war on them.
So sad to see how you were cowardly and brutally attacked at SC dear brother, sending you loving thoughts and prayers for swift healing.
I want to ask brother Shamsi which law school he follows and does he recognize the 4 law schools
and who are your scholars that you follow
He follows the quran and sunnah upon the understanding of the salaf on "creed".
Salafis can follow any of the the four imams on "fiqh".
Scholars such as Shaykh Salih aal-alshaykh, Salih Fawzan, Rabee Al madkali, muqbil, Obaid aljabiri, Ali ahudayfi aldeni, bin baz, Ibn Uthaimeen, Al-Albāni... Many more. All scholars of ahil asunnah.
May Allah guide me and you
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Man dont even know what year it is.
How about when muslims conquered the land from the Jewish people and Christians in 640+ AD something….
No Different of yoy and other including Daniel. Yiy all are just Muslim with Different Sect. Ya Allah SWT, may Allah SWT protect us from people anyone like Sect.
Allah SWT want us to Not Just Pray BUT Put Efforts. As long as we don't commit crimes, illegal doings, no negative intentions, positive passion, NOTHING IS WRONG TO VOICE FOR ACTUAL VICTIMS.
You are Human yourself, as rational Muslims, as often happening in modern era, I won't be surprised if yoy get paid by someone or some people.
*BRO, BE MUSLIMS THAT AMAR MA'RUF NAHI MUNKAR.*
Much better if you Promoting how Muslims Liberals to stop supporting LGBT.
Disappointed. Won't ever watch you again.
The best way to not prevent Israel oppression , is to just keep talking about it..just keep talking and everything will be fine.
It's been 75 years
Yet here you are. Whining in youtube comments, meanwhile Shamsi is teaching people the deen.
@@sheikhshakilakhtar1865 thanks for your input. My point still stands.
Best way is dua first. The Prophet salahallah alaihi wasallam did dua in similar circumstances
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Shansi this week lost all credibility he had amongst muslims
Hi try to win it back by talking about zionist
>Shansi this week lost all credibility he had amongst muslims
No he did not.
He is Alhamdu lillaah , a caller to Tawheed and Sunnah
Meanwhile you lot are keyboard warriors
@@sheikhshakilakhtar1865 he cancelled himself. Instead of explaining to the umah his position in a calm manner, he stabbed the Palestinians in the back
He lost credibility in the people of bidaa and desires and gained credibility in the hearts of people of sunnah and athar
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
12:00👈🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
It’s not allowed to share pictures of dying Muslims to create helplessness in the Muslims.
@@kashmirmylove6243 hi is playing games talk about naked woman lol hi is king of playing who is naket
@@kashmirmylove6243 who is naked please show me hear good at his words mind trickss
Bro r u being serious wallah you guys are so arrogant man how can u say he’s wrong for this it just shows how arrogant this ummah is wallah fear Allah
Special Agent Shamsi is acting as a double agent now
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Schwestern Shamsi, die Salifia-Gelehrte, sagt, dass ihr Frauen nicht schreien und sagen solltet: „Frei, frei, Palästina, der Fluss, das Meer, Palästina, sei frei.“
Sehen Sie sich seine Aussagen selbst auf TH-cam an
Shamsi's right , he backups with Qur'an and sunnah . But you follow your desries
@@machinegunkely4417
Than you saving
Everybody stop saying
Free free Palestina
Go home en pray 24hour for peach
@@adjiedguman67 bro learn how to talk i cant even understand what you are saying come back after passing 5th grade
Shamsis right, because his evidence is the Quran, allah told women to stay at home and not raise their voices so that non mahram cam hear them
@@OCEAN-fc9wlhow many men left in palestine compare to women?
Hamas is just mad i understand that
If Shamsi just shuts up at this point it would be better, helping the oppressor over you're opressed muslims brother is not it and can lead to kufr.
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Aren’t you done with the hypocrisy doing all these things didn’t help Palestine and will never help we Muslims should start being Muslims that’s when victory comes
@@jojoahmd123 He worried about free mixing while people getting killed seriously...
Isn't he free mixing in the park anyway ? straight up weirdo trying to find any excuse to attack muslims and defend the oppressor
Why doesn't he teach people to support palestine instead, isn't that Islam?
You can have your disagreements with Shamsi - but he spoke nothing but facts in this video. Cope
How come speaking from Quran and hadith is helping the oppressor?
So according to this guy we all need to be super duper islamic then victory will come
I find that to be unrealistic even during the time of the prophet PBUH some people where strong and others where weak in the deen
Yes returning back to Allaah will bring victory
In Surah Noor Ayah 55 Allah said that He would grant us power over land when we avoid shirk and become completely obedient to Allah.
So yea, we need to be super duper Islamic. And all Sahabahs were super duper Islamic
@@thetruthful1612
what shirk did Palestinian muslims do?
does Allah give trials and tribulations exclusively to the wrongdoers as punishment or also to the righteous as a test?
what evidence from what authority do you have to prove that Palestinians are given punishment and not a test?
if you answer just "quran and sunnah" again without elaborating and connecting with facts of these events WALLAHI i pray to Allah for the plight of the Palestinians to be lifted up and immediately be put upon you
@@exceed.charge I didn't say Palestinians are committing shirk. I didn't say Palestinians are going through punishment neither did i say they are going through test. I didn't say any of those things. I just posted a verse as a solution for having power over lands.
And btw, Muhammad peace be upon him said that it's not allowed to curse fellow Muslims.
@@thetruthful1612 then why did you quote the verse in this thread? what did you imply with your previous comment?
if we CURRENTLY need to be super duper islamic then what are we NOW? not good enough? if Allah's help comes only if we're already super duper islamic then western reverts wouldn't stay as muslims for long living in the west.
yo shamsi you should go to protest and telll every girl to not scream and shamsi u should scream on behalf for them
We don’t want to show our weakness. Why should we scream. Instead go to the Palestine to help them in their Hospital and with their food.
Shamsi go home 🙏
He's a pro Rishi Sunak
Disappointed in shamsi May Allah guide him
Shamsi should just stfu he really thinks he’s someone important his opinion doesn’t matter
Whatever the direction of the body of the Ummah goes, you will find banu shamsi going the opposite direction.
He clearly not follow people but quran and sunnah!
@@peace2203no hi is kind of mind fuckkk
@@peace2203yes by bootlicking saudia
@@1usacalifornia yup.. better then ur country!
@@peace2203 yes better than my country. But still worst among Muslim Countries. & I'm not hypocrite like you defending governments
Definitely a paid agent of you know who
Shamsi talk same as seikh Ahmed Deedat. That's why i love him.
if hamas is shia group and put flag of zahra hussain fatima on al aqsa then im not happy with it.
until Mehdi come and solve this issue who is sunni
@@MS-Hussainis happening sunni countries celebrating halloween and organise big concerts
@@amensar5492 only a few
Shamsi speak truth but its bitter and heavy
Because he is full of hates for shia and make bad assumptions to this countries. But is it true muslim behaviour?
Yes the truth is heavy, look at the hate Shamsi gets for telling the truth...
May Allah preserve brother Shamsi
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
Nope, in my Country wahabi preacher also said the same thing.
That Palestinian (and muslim as a whole) should not fought Israel, that Palestinian should leave palestine to another country, that we shouldn't give donations to palestine, etc
@@Imaddongai
You lie about them as well 😂😂 it is clear what he said but the truth hurts I know
@@jojoahmd123 You could hear it yourself, you could search "Riyad Bajrey Palestina", he is Indonesian speaking wahabi preacher. And so many Ahlussunnah Ulama has debunk his statement.
@@jojoahmd123 "what he said but the truth", is this how a muslim should behave? Just listen to one opinion and than claim the ultimate truth??
May be you should learn more deep about Islam before opening your mouth
@@Imaddongai
He said nothing but Quran and Sunna and you guys don’t like it 😉
Atleast he said something positive here.
But I am against his thinking here. Women shd come out in these times, even they may need to raise swords and fight.
So those who r raising their voice in protest, salute to them( if in pardah).
Those who say women shd not come out, shd come and live in Afghanistan, entire west is dirty. Men shdnot even go to market, its haram(u can't control ur eyes, u can't even raise ur head)
What you need to do is first come out of your basement enter into the real world outside .
Whats hi say they pas away the died they got killed 22:00
>Women shd come out in these times, even they may need to raise swords and fight.
Is this a command from Allaah and His Messenger(salAllaahu 'alayhi wa sallam) or your desire to watch women?
@@sheikhshakilakhtar1865 read the life of the greatest women in history of Islam
@@TH-camvideo22t they all are martyrs. He is a deviant. Hv not watched the entire video so can't say if he said so.
Every individual being killed in Palestine if they r Muslim are all martyrs.
Embarrassing conduct from shamsi.. claims to have knowledge but insults people for lack of knowledge when they ask him. Instead of explaining to his follow muslims he is shouting and getting emotional
You lie about this guy so much may Allah bless him …he only said don’t mix ( men and women) while you are on the streets screaming about Palestine …..
he only call people to acutely practice Islam so Allah will help us but not like that (( practice Islam if you want victory)) that’s all what he saying
@@jojoahmd123 I watched him attack Muslims and try to embarrass them on camera asking them about the Deen . He's trying to say these kids know nothing about Islam yet they want to defend Palestine. Can you imagine how arrogant that comes off. He knows more about the Deen and tries to use that as a weapon against other Muslims who know less. Then there is the other question as to why he believes it's okay to criticise Turkish leaders and Palestinian leaders but says it's haram to criticise Saudi leaders. What's the difference between gulf nation leaders and Turkish and Hamas?
@@Abuzwebstarin a debate with Daniel, Shamsi said that it is not allowed to criticize Erdogan
@@jojoahmd123 If you're a Muslim then why did you have a picture of a dog on your YT profile when I received your reply on my notifications?
@@one4all126
I didn’t you mean the other guy I guess
Of course Shamsi is right
Just because you're bootlicker of rulers, you have to support whatever he does...
We hold that the ruler is to be obeyed, whether righteous or sinful. And rebellion against the tyrannical Muslim ruler is forbidden, even if he behaves like a Shaitān, does not practice the Sunnah, beats the backs of the people, imprisons them and takes their wealth. This is in accordance with the statement of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم): “You will have rulers over you. They will not follow my Sunnah, nor follow my guidance. There will be amongst them men who will have the hearts of devils in the bodies of men.”Hudhaifah (رضي الله عنه) asked: “O Messenger of Allāh! What should I do if I reach that time?”He replied: “Hear and obey the ruler, even if he beats you in your back and takes your wealth. Hear and obey him!”
We hold that one is obligated to be patient with the tyrannical ruler, just as the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said: “If one of you sees something from your ruler that displeases you, then be patient.”
We believe that it is forbidden to publicly rebuke the Rulers as that is the way of the misguided Khawārij, just as the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said: “Whoever desires to advise the Ruler, then he should not do so publicly, rather he should take him by his hand and take him into seclusion [and then advise]. So, either he accepts the advice from him, and if not, then he has fulfilled the duty that was upon him.”
@@SunniAthariGive me the references for these...
@@SunniAthariSo why did Imam Hussain a.s. rise up against yazeed?