Aloysius Pang death: How did the accident happen? | AR reconstruction
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 พ.ค. 2019
- Using a 3D reconstruction of the Singapore Self-Propelled Howitzer, CNA traces the missteps that happened inside a Singapore Self-Propelled Howitzer that led to the death of NS reservist Aloysius Pang.
Read the COI's findings here: cna.asia/2LlUqsz
What happened in the Singapore Self-Propelled Howitzer: cna.asia/2GZT15D
An external panel has expressed concerns about "safety lapses and weaknesses in safety culture" in the SAF following Pang's death: cna.asia/2LpGeig
Subscribe to our channel here: cna.asia/youtubesub
Follow us:
www.channelnewsasia.com
/ channelnewsasia
/ channelnewsasia
/ channelnewsasia
t.me/cnalatest
![เกิดใหม่ทั้งทีก็เป็นสไลม์ไปซะแล้ว ซีซั่น 3 - ตอนที่ 58 [ซับไทย]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TgNEbYSTY0Y/mqdefault.jpg)
safety is everyone's responsibility
therefore everyone at fault
Lets begin fault finding with the designer, engineer, approver, customer, manufacturer.
One For All, All For One.
WHOLE LOT KNOCK IT DOWN
@@jia_lat_limlol7980 *clap clap* 你家！
School always says safety starts with me
The real issue now is that the boys are doing this mandatory service for the nation, that’s why we need more responsibility and accountability from the government. Only due to the fact he’s an actor and somewhat an public figure, the issue was magnified if not it could be just another “case” simply sweep away without much details known to the public.
The government has formed a COI to investigate the matter. If it is negligence and non-compliance on the officers' part when there is protocol already put in place, honestly it is unfair to put the blame on the government. If it happens to a few officers not following procedures, you can't generalize to say that the whole army is at fault isn't it. Hopefully due to the public nature of this case, there would be more awareness of the importance of safety and compliance.
everyone is blaming the yellow and blue guy just because pang died. u all have very poor judgement
Than prove something
okay thats your opinion but just wanna say aloysius will always be our angel
Pang obviously didn't follow protocol when ask to move to a safer spot. He was negligent and paid with his own life. Hey, at least NS is emphasizing everyone not to be the next Pang
shannen xarmy an angel who doesn’t believe in listening to commands
plz stop blaming aloysius dont make him suffer again
at least he is free now
All 3 seems poorly trained to me
You want to replace them?
@@arvin6606 nobody needs to replace anyone. Just need our money that paid the taxes to be used correctly as in training our soldiers better.
Condolences to the victim and his family.
But this is straight up a negligence and insubordination issue. The victim broke the chain of command whilst the commander didn't either secured the situation or act rightfully according to SOP.
So, train the soldiers better to avoid this horrendous incident in the future.
Yellow dude not supervising Aloysius.
Aloysius was instructed by commander to move away from the gun barrel.
Commander did not double check, resulting Aloysius being hit by the barrel.
Therefore, it's everyone's fault
KieronKN Singapore yepppp n elloooo
In that case, the protocol or the army is at fault. In the context that this is a noisy environment as expected, you can't just shout "Clear" and exonerate yourself from responsibility, from actually making sure that the area is in-fact cleared as this is a matter of life and death of your own comrade. Also I find it plausible that the sequence of events could be inconsistent. How much time has elapsed from the technician acknowledgement to barrel being lowered? The acknowledgement could have been superseded by time of events.
When there's severe injuries in the US they try to mitigate deaths by responding and getting the victim to emergency surgery in the golden hour period or 60 minutes. For example the 5.56mm round yaws and tumbles in human flesh and causes a lot of damage but with advanced surgery and emergency care, survivability is greatly increased when rushed to hospital in 60 minutes.
I think for Aloysius' case, 3 whole hours is really unacceptable before he was evacuated especially when there is severe trauma to the injured soldier. What should have been arranged was an immediate medivac or helicopter evac of the wounded on the site of the event occured. This should all have been planned out.........
So now you know how dangerous combat vocations are. And the sad thing is people in combat vocations are not appreciated but treated like dogs
NS is so fair
yes i also agree more recognition for people in combat team regardless if its infantry guard armor or air or navy side~
Poor ns man 😪
Combat vocations are dangerous. It is also the NS men own responsibility to follow and comply with the TSR at all times.
Sad and sorry to say, in the case of Aloysius Pang here, he did not heed the safety instructions. He compromised it. Hence, he is partly also to be blamed.
The clerk interacts with the CO all the time and gets best soldier of the month. Meanwhile the combat soldiers on the ground are just like pawns to be deployed.
these are soldiers lmao. Sorry if they dont give out free hugs, kisses and candy bars
Safety rules are set for a purpose - save lives. Once breached, one will be endangered regardless of who you are.
It's a negligence didn't follow instructions given , compromise and comply all the safety regulations.
I miss him so much and this is making me so sad
An innocent had been lost
May he be in a better place
RIP AP
Sad case
Oh my . . I just know this right now.
Yes.
Blame the dead as he cant defend himself
I wonder if the dialogue stated ever took place at all.
Not mindef fault? Then who is the responsible to control the quality of training?
@M. Nurhaikal if he don't go nothing would have happened is either he go or he get charged get it??mindef should be responsible when they force someone to go somewhere!
It was more of the fault of the commander than Aloysius. Yes Aloysius was wrong too but the onus lies heavier on the commander to make sure that all his man are safe.
@@MrPorkered Aloysius was never wrong the day that saf force him back they should take full responsibility unless Aloysius go on his own accord
How defence that thing hit frm behaind ???
Which country made that vehicle? Something not safe with that design?
This vehicle is spore designed and made. It is made to suit singapore soil and terrain
Probably made in New Zealand for Singapore
Not fully train !they just NS man 👎
Haha
No they are well trained, just watch ah boys to men, they are very strong, but i was pretty shocked when i saw this
RIP Heroic Actor!
Rest in peace Aloysius pang
We should make it a protocol that when this action is initiated, commander hand must be in position to push the emergency stop button and in full view of the entire barrel.
RIP aloysius pang.i love you so much ♡♡
Emergency button is wwaayyy out of reach from operator. This is why. Emergency button should be installed on the control panel or nearer to operator.
They should make the safety stop on ground as in whole platform of danger zone. Like if floor of unsafe area is step then the gun thing will not operate. I see this as design flaws and human error. The floor should be mark by color of where exactly is safe /not. Also have reminder placed inside the tank. Just because train does not mean they remembered. Also at time of panic who will think that straight? I hate the way it is shown as push blame
What a way to go
how you can *assume* something without double checking on him???
Cos they prob done this many thousands times and nothing happen. Then this aloy comes along thinking cos he acted as alien with superhuman powers and even gave birth, he can overcome a gun barrel weighing several tons
@@jamesdean810 ,how can a man over Come something like that they should have double check before driving🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
@@teyyiyun6664 agree
Not tryna hate but pretty sure its Aloy pangs fault for not moving out in the first place
Tom Jerry true bro
IlIlIlIlIl- low finally someone who agrees
Commander already double check
Technician is in good position
Pang is... hmmm
Yup.......
I just wanna say that everyone has a choice in whatever you do. At the end of the day, you still held responsible for yourself. So my advice to people, do what you think is right or to be clearer, do what that makes sense.
Choice to take singapore national service or not, cough
@@aureum1464ya there is no choice to do NS or not, pui
So is it his fault? To me the commander seems to be at fault for not taking care of the team
Everyone has a story book. Every story book has an ending.
@M. Nurhaikal The commander should at least be tried for negligence
@Kokwei Phoon The buck stops at the Top ?
How about everyone is responsible for your own safety .... u dun walk across the road without looking and get banged and blame LTA chairman for it
@@vancekangyishu You are not comparing properly. The commander was inside that thing. He should be responsible. If he cannot even protect his men, what is he for?
Why cant they just make the tank abit bigger?the tank should have enough space for them to move and work inside.
@notlenzo whats the reason?if u know
A push of a button could have meant life or death. So sad... Put yourself in a similar senario. Let's say you are speeding down a highway and suddenly you realised you are seconds away to crashing into the back of a heavy trailer, what and how would you react?
I am skeptical if the dialogue really took place. I think all three of them just focused on doing their own thing and led to the final outcome.
That's a huge tank in the studio! 😱
Sacarsm right?
Omg.. so one young life was lost for nothing
Someone tell me, how is this MINDEF’s fault?
If I was I that situation I will be panick too
My commander once fu*ked me so hard for screwing around safety, I guess he got a point
so dead soldier disobey an order? which is he is savvy with the equipment he would know where to be when the barrel is moved.
Stop blaming it on people. Another life have been lost. Do you guys have any sympathy at all ? Before blaming anyone if is someone that you know is doing it then you guys will feel the pain ? Please stop judging let the person rest in peace ! 😤
Kiang Jiu Ho, Mai Ge Kiang
First of all what kind a of shitty tank is that?! Second of all what kinda of training did they get ?one doesn't follow the rules, another doesn't double check on his comrade , and another doesn't lead his team properly and just panic?? finally everyone is at fault no one did what they were supposed to do and no one followed the protocol properly wich resulted in this tragedy. so now let's the man rest in peace and make sure this never ever happen again
Its not a tank & this is what happens when you are busy taking selfies 🙄
The government has formed a COI to investigate the matter. If it is negligence and non-compliance on the officers' part when there are protocols already put in place, honestly it is unfair to put the blame entirely on the government. If it happens to a few officers not following procedures, we can't generalize to say that the whole army is at fault isn't it. In this case, all the officers in the vehicle seem to have some form of negligence and non-compliance in carrying out the exercise. It is everyone's duty to ensure that safety procedures are adhered to, no matter how much they think they are "safe", and also on the commander in charge a responsibility to ensure that all members are in safe positions before activating the exercise. Perhaps some lessons to learn is not to take these protocols lightly and also understand the utmost importance of safety, follow instructions and embrace the responsibilities of their positions at hand, no matter what background the officers came from. As comrades, they should also look out for one another and be brave to flag out issues when there is one. Hopefully due to the public nature of this case, there would be greater awareness of the importance of safety and compliance in carrying out these exercises.
Just an average day operating a tank lmao
Y no change the chief
Vehicle interior is not safe proof. Relying on human for safety is a time bomb waiting for accident to happen !!!
Hi
What an poorly engineer tank
Yea piece of 20 Yr old garbage metal tank without proper tech
Let the man rest -_-
Exactly my point. What the hell is wrong with this people.
@@johndin7730 , u wouldn't understand , if it is your love one been hit like that , you wouldn't able to say this word like that😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@teyyiyun6664 Buddy, we were refering to the news readers
@@johndin7730 , urhmm lol....
Commanders error as he’s in charge of his vehicle even when someone is in the wrong position it’s his duty to take charge
Pass away already just move on...
this actor used to acted in "Home Run" movie
Surely this news special is not to Cover someone's backside at the expense of blaming the dead?
At least ur backside not exposed
The dead cannot speak
*Just because he was a goddam actor...*
Lol yea thats what makes people gettin sad and salty
Too busy taking selfie (when photos not even allowed inside SAF vehicle) & didn’t notice the barrel moving 🙄
Pang should of listened
What a crapy desigh tank is this
I guess all of them were pang tied😂
Just plain disrespectful.
Human error - his own error
Can someone please step up and take responsibility for what has happened? Someone's head needs to roll to serve as a warning
生死有命
There it is, the governments favourite skill. Pushing the blame.
ban all tanks and weapons
E
That's bs
Lol who is he?
nice cover up! he is already dead
Stop pretending saf just want to safe their reputation that all and push all the blame to the innocent guy!!!used them as sacrificing tools now still don't admit still add words into his mouth how despicable
Darwin award goes to...
Everyone should know this in the 1st place
......SAFETY are EVERYONE RESPONSIBILITY that rule no.1 always .
Next time put speakers in the tank then can hear properly
We don't care how he died, he has already passed away so the operation of the equipment doesn't matter. As a matter of fact, a death has happened so how are you guys going to answer the public and who is going to take responsibility to ensure the public in future such a thing won't happen again instead of just trying to push blame
Govt already answered by conducting coi and the minister announcing the findings in parliament
He died already no point blaming anyone
I don't know any of the context of this and am here just because TH-cam recommendations but its totally green guy's fault
Are the tanks made in the US? Such garbage design
No the ssph is singapore designed and made to suit singapore soil and terrain
NS for sinkies
Jesus Christ. I'm not laughing on this one. Uuughh, think of the guts spreading out. DX
So it pang fault????🙄🙄🙄🙄 how about his mates 🙄🙄🙄🙄 just bc of the accident we lose him forever , imagine you are the person there and the thing hit you , would you like that say , no right😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
0:55 I hate to say it but it was Pang fault for disobey
@@absoluteking95 ,really meh?
@notlenzo ,oh
@notlenzo , oh 😭😭😭
@@absoluteking95 if he disobey, the team should force him to move to the safer place, this is aBout live or die.. this is a team work, omg
Fail design
He died alr. Move on.
Exactly these fking people
And also it was already explained
Dumb pieces of shits. They only care about delivering the news no matter the repercussions. These guys study too much but still can't even think.
@@johndin7730 SAF needs to be accountable to the public, i.e. what happened inside the tank, root cause of incident and how SAF is going to improve to prevent future incidents. I swear people like you are the true stupid idiots who must have an opinion on everything despite not knowing anything.
@@honeyyybflyyy Did you not see their previous news regarding this Insident. Oh wait I guess morons like you are not up to date on the anything but love to give their input on things. Please check your facts before replying. It will save you the trouble of looking like a fool. Have a great day.
Horrible design of this War machine. Shows how much thought the SAF puts into the safety aspect of it’s servicemen operating it before procuring them. One would have assumed that a dual modular safety redundancy would have been incorporated into it’s design…
If such serious accident could happened during Peacetime, it will CERTAINLY happen AGAIN when chaotic moments happen during wartime!
Noob pang
Noob Nanggala 402
The design is fundamentally flawed and hazardous. There are hardly any considerations for safety of operators.
Do you have any idea how this will affect the victim's family and loved ones when they watch this! Show some decency damn it! Not everything needs to be shown on the news. I'm sure the victim's family was informed of the investigation. How would you like it if this were to happen to your child and everytime you look at the news you are constantly being reminded of this tragic incident. Please just leave this be and give the family a break. I'm sure you guys can do better than that!
Unfortunately if the news did not report this as per what was reported, it will be worst because the public will condemn the SAF even more for covering up the details of what had happened.
His name is Aloysius so don't call him "Pang"
Got it, Yuen
distortdude80 got it dude
Hi I'm gay got it, gay
Yes ,Yuen !
I shall call you. U, So U why you such a busy body.
Stupid design by ST engrg, without considering the safety of the soldiers.
Simply make the behind space longer and this kind of accident will never happened.
the design should have some room when the gun rimmer has been lowered.