SHOCKING: "Yes, We are Muslim, but, we DID NOT..." | Cry For Justice Knows No Religion | Tamal Saha
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- Sabbir, a migrant worker from West Bengal was beaten to death in Haryana by cow vigilantes on August 27 under the suspicion that he consumed beef. Incidents of cow vigilantism have claimed as many as 44 lives between 2015 and 2018, mostly Muslims. Hear the horrific ordeal of the family left behind by Sabbir. This too is a fight for Justice.
Report: Tamal Saha
Camera: Suman Gupta
Edit: Arko Saha
#bengal #haryana #muslim #beef #cow #justice #rgkarprotest #mamatabanerjee #nayabsaini #haryanaelection #moblynch #gaurakshak
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @ntt-by-tamalsaha
This is called journalism....keep up the work.
Thanks a lot for highlighting this!
You are a Real Bangali salute to you JOY BANGLA 🐯🐯🐯🐯
Salute to your journalism
I feel bad for u Indian muslims, u got flags all over, u have to prove you nationalism everyday, a 100 good things you do will get distorted due to 1 mistake of urs. India is no longer dar-ul-aman as indian scholars claim. Let's see what awaits ahead.
Yet there's no protest no outrage for him or against Haryana police & administration. The double standards of these protesters sicken me
Very simple answer, We as a Bengali society don't care about poor and minority.
Protesters? Are protesters running the law and parliament? No. It's the police and ministers.
Why is it required that these people will only work if whole India is out on streets? This is just them being lazy and corrupt.
Be mad at ministers who despite having all power refuse to act.
@@ModiAdani420garol ta doctors ra poor ar baki shobar jonne healthcare ta kei thik korche....ajke ora nijera na thik thakle kake treatment debe..ki kore shamlabe...eto hajar hajar doctor ki shudhu elites der treatment dicche....oi rg kar er doctor ta elites der treatment dito?????
????@@ModiAdani420
You will find many people who are supporting this moblynching
RSS who claims to revive Hinduism should b ashamed of these incidents.These incidents shall harm the victims only in the long run.
Tamal I have no words. I are establishing an excellence in reporting. Proud to have you people still on ground while others kept their eyes and mouth shut.
Gold standard journalism 🙌🏽👏🏽👌🏽✊🏽
Thanks!
Tears in the eyes. God bless her and her daughter
I'm happy to see someone like you. You are a good person, a good hearted-human.
Our Country is drastically lacking people like you.
Our country doesn't need hate-monger governments that try to blind people with hate.
When Tamal Saha was listening to victim's family members, I could not distinguish who looks muslim & who hindu
The binding power of language.
Yet muslims are hounded out by gau rakshaks that easily in north india
I am delhi based
So I am frustrated, Where is the team of "We want justice" who showed humanity and "Godi media"...... "Sabka saath sabka bikas" ??? Also mentioned that any other incidents are likely UP, Uttarakhand...
Recently Indore MP, Military trainee officer..
The hate is for being Bengali as well. Our migrants are targeted in the 'cow belt' irrespective of religion.
It's about time even Bangladeshis realized that & said no to these crooks.
When human beings leave humanity, such cases happen, not only to hindu or muslim, but this is shame to humanity
In all society there are some criminals, but problem arises when government and people start praising and justifing the criminals
The helplessness in their eyes
The media has played a big role in spreading hate. I have friends who are highly educated yet talk so much shit I wonder if they abandoned all reasoning.. This channel is a breath of fresh air.. Thank you..
Thanks for sharing this story.. None is asking for justice for this loss.. Why? This is not important for us
Hats off to you Tamal da 🙏
i couldn't hold back my tears
justice chai ei vai r
Thank you, Tamal. You are really working like a good journalist. When the entire media is only covering one incident and each and every related tit-bits and ignoring even the same type of incidents all over India, and common people are hounding each one who is trying to talk about those incidents, you have shown the courage to cover this news.
CM of Haryana should resign. Shame on BJP and Modi. I hate religious politics.... 😡😡😡
It shows in which society we are living in.... We have no sympathy, empathy, humanity n what we have just hate n hate.... The deep down truth is that the politics has created the evilness in us....N lastly a huge applaud to Tamal Da for this kind of work....
This is pure evil 🙁
Thanks much reporter and channel for standing with victim family. What a heinous crime they have done due to hatred 😢 .. they didn't kill only Sabbir but his wife and a little innocent baby ... shame ! Justice will be prevailed for sure.
Thanks a lot Mr. Tamal .. May God bless you ... please stand with the opressed one. 🙏
##Justice for Shabbir and His family##
Grateful!
Hats off to you. Excellent reporting.
Good work tamal bhai
বাংলা পক্ষ ছাড়া আর কাউকে প্রতিবাদ করতে দেখা গেল না।
Raise your voice against Injustice. Save Your Democracy and Constitution. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🤝🙏
Thank-you for raising voice for justice 😞
Dada, your journalism is way beyond the mainstream media! Outstanding ❤❤
A journalist of his iwn kind, endangered species with stripes of kindness and empathy.
Keep up the good work
99% journalist from India should learn from mr.Saha
We are amidst a very sad shameful and dangerous situation
Thanks for this report
I repeat this guy is changing the Bengal based media and its role ..great job
You are real Royal Bengal Tiger 🐅
Salute bro
Hat's off to your journalism 👏👏
Lo Bhai
Jis Desh Main Aayedin Minorities Par Atyachar & Bhedabhaav Hota He Rehta Hai. Specially 2014 Ke Bad.
Us Desh Ke Log & Sarkaar Dusre Deshon Ko Minorities Ki Safety Par Gyan Dene Aa Jate Hain.
Kehte Hain Na
Ek Chor Ko Chahiye Pehle Woh Chori Karna Band Kare Phir Dusroon Ko Chori Na Karne Ka Advice De.
Hats off to the true journalism
Excellent Journalism 👏
Too pathetic
Great reporting Bhai.... whole nation is proud of you ❤❤❤
Thanks for sharing the right information
We need to do protests on mass level against these type of mob lynching
Thanks for covering. Supporting you since Manipur reporting
People of this country please awaken your conscience or else it will affect all of us just as shayar Rahat Indori said.
Thanks for covering
Salute to You
Bal mane ki?
Everyone knows who sowed the seed of communal hatred
I'm just a ordinary muslim I'm not religious I don't care what's written there for me it's just sad very sad why are u silent on this I'm sorry to day I don't have faith in my own country judiciary anymore😢
muslim means the one who believe in Almighty. that's the definition of Muslim if you believe in Almighty you are Muslim other things comes later
😢 thanks for sharing
Thank you
This is the nation that Bjp Dream of💔💔 And we call ourselves Civilised People
Salute
Very pathetic.....
He was very from home,bengal to haryan is over a thousand miles,i am from Pakistan haryana is just about 170miles
Thanks a lot for covering such news. In India most of the people dont pay any heed to cow vigilant assaults.
My heart goes out to the bereaved family...what a senseless tragedy all in the name of gau rakshak... while many have lost their lives at the hands of these cow Fanatics, a whole lot of people are either killed or wounded in road accidents all across this country because a cow forgot it's traffic rules, because nobody cares if this animal attacks kids or causes mayhem...but but but a cow outweighs a human life in the ram rajya that has been dumped on us
this news will never come to main stream media
Please add english translation of the victim's family
RSS&Bajrang dal ,cow vigilant should be declared outlawed
Great work👍keep it up
Thanks a lot❤❤❤
First of all i salute my didi Mamata Banerjee, for giving her job.
The is the first video of your's that I watched. Great journalism, awesome delivery. It shook me deep down. I was in tears. Appreciate you from the bottom of my heart. Salute and Thank you for being a TRUE Journalist.
Apnar moto reporter jodi dese 10 ta thakto tahole deser erokom obostha hoto na ,salut apnake
Unless and untill when they lose their loved one by same as this situation, then only they will feel the pain...what goes comes back
Great journalism real journalist
Cow vigilantes are really brave in front of poor and weak!
😢😢
Inko hindhuon se na musalmano se apatti hai
Ye gareebon par zulm karten hai
💔
Best video recent time..
Journalism is this nothing that we see on Tv
May Allah give him and his family justice
Sad very disheartening... Killed muslims no accountability of govt and law and order in India..when if other countries says plight of muslims in India why irked or feel exposed globally
Good work
Good job bro ❤
I would like to raise a few things,
1. This kind of job is easily available in many of our big cities like Calcutta, Siliguri, Durgapur etc. Stii he needed to leave.
2. So, who is replacing the sons/daughters of bengal in such jobs?
3. Remember, the state is still a net positive migration state, means more people come here than leaves.
4. A majority of the people who leaves the state are highly educated. So, we export quality.
5. Still in new India, people make fun of these poor migrants of the state.
6. Why since independece all our governments have allowed such uncontrolled explosion of these incoming immigrants?
7. Communist party, TMC has allowed them to capture all the legacy business. (Firahad Hakim, Goenka etc.)
My humble question, why these people couldn't get those jobs
while the streets of such big cities like Calcutta, Siliguri, Durhapur etc are filled with BIHARI, UP etc?
They are now the majority and bigger threat ti the fabric of the state, check the history of the RAPIST in RG KAR case.
Last I heard bengal is this that, in COW-BELT media, yet you just can't stop your opportunities being stolen away by these migrants?
Ask the people of MUMBAI, BENGALURU if I am wrong.
Edit: In new INDIA, asking answers why this poor people need to be killed by such incidents is not condoning. Such an alien idea, that's why I asked, please let these people get jobs in a land that understands secularism and also respects the mother tongue of the person to communicate of such important things in the same, like death certificate in a language that they don't understand, this COUNTRY has FAILED it's people.
You would not condemn an act of killing a person because he was muslim and there was no proof of them consuming meat of a cow. Yet you ask questions that don't even relate to the problem here? Why are you trying to debate from the lynching? So what if someone migrates to work? Don't people always migrate for opportunities from villages ? Maybe the pay was better in Haryana? You lack empathy and you're trying to politicise this issue. Shame on you
@@sharonpenukonda578
First of all, "SHAME ON YOU" is your first thought when you stand in front of a mirror. 🪞
Sorry, I forget this is NEW INDIA. Who in the right mind being a fellow homo-sapines would support this? Also, sorry again for forgetting that this is country of BIG BOSS generation, who wastes 2 months on SSR condoning and being apolitical. What did you achieve, A BIG ZERO. EVERYONE condoned MANIPUR, what did they achieve, more fire. So, I announce my condolences and now ask you those same questions. ANY ANSWERS, other than but, might, should from you.
Then, Read it loudly, ALL ARE VALID QUESTIONS and before you commented if given a bit of thought, it should have been obvious. But, you probably binge watch hindi media to form opinions on BENGAL. So, live in your dreams.
Let me tell what ORWELL said long back, "IGNORANCE IS BLISS". So, go and hide behind your apolitcal veil. Don't preach here. I have been living in the West and seen unlike the citizens of NEW INDIA, this kind of questioning is the reason that Europe remain a democratic and forward thinking place.
But, you please Don't worry, and definitely don't ask questions as it brings politics in daily life, congratulations for being a of citizen of MARS.
👍
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Haryana 1st the killer of female child and till now there old image is on
India politicians is evil BJP👎🏽👎🏽
Ask mamata why they had to go to Haryana . What has she done in last 13 years ? How many Gujratis or Marathis or Keralians come to Haryana ?
So... You mean to say... it's okay to brutally kill a innocent migrant worker for no valid reason...!! What a mentality brother...
Ask nitish Babu and his alliance why Biharis are so widely spread in west bengal why no one from Kerala comes to WB . Why are Biharis occupied in the whole state? Where are those investments our PM promised to them?
Literally you are justifying a murder just by saying why we have to go outside to work?
Can this man say same word for kanihaya lal,rajasthan school boy devraj and Karnataka college girl murder and so many this type of muder held by radical Islamist Don't be selected.not Any body condem kill hindu and stone pelting on hindu religious Yatra . this type of double standard are more dangerous
Go to Pakistan..duur hai to go to Bangladesh
মানসিকতা এত খারাপ তাই তুমি সব কমেন্ট করেছো
Kuu tmharai baap ka hai ya tmhre maa ko dowry mai mila hai hindustan..
SouthBengal based Muslim daily diet part is beef and cowmeat
Tamal or anyone don't do whitewash ok you consume cows in Bengal we all are born and bought in South Kolkata we know each and every thing.
Not everystate is Bengal and not everyone will tolerate
Playing Victim card 😏😏
only bangla pokkho can solve this by their action
Where are they??????? When they will raise from sleep?????!!!!!!
Bangla Pokkho doing protest at Dharmatala Dharna Manch, Kolkata. Their leader is Garga Chatterjee. He is PhD scholar from Harvard University, USA
and yet.. hindu ppl own all the beef factories. the hindu ppl export beef internationally
😭😭😭😭
The only scholar on the planet to compile SANSKRIT-URDU dictionary. th-cam.com/video/EGy-OoF0QuA/w-d-xo.htmlfeature=shared
Ye sab kiya ho raha hai desh mein Musalmano par shame on modi godi andhbhakt shame on return mein tumlogo ko bhi milega so disgusting justice this family BJP RSS hathao desh bachao jai hind
This is called journalism.
Sadharon manus er pase thaka . Sadharon manus er Aawaz k tule dewa. Upor projonto.
Media r kaj etai..
Thanks!
Do these uncivilized hooligans have the nerves to even question leave alone attack Milind Pingle, Director of Allana consumer products, INDIA'S LARGEST BEEF EXPORTER COMPANY.???
Dada, i salute you.
So much hate! in our once peaceful society. The cry for justice will echo on. The first requisite of a civilization is that of justice.
চোখের জল আটকাতে পারলাম না, কোন দেশে বাস করছি আমরা 😢
So sad 😢
Salute !! to your true journalism.
😢