Guys- The fact Hwasa didn't call Moonbyul "unnie" until she knew she was live- That's huge stuff- How she just said "what are you doing?~" as a greeting in such playful, borderline flirty, way melts my heart The way Hwasa got all "Why do you mean you're having a party without me?" had me smiling so hard xD And the way she got even more upset when Moon revealed it was a party with a "small amount of people", those type of parties are usually more personal or intimate in the sense that only a few carefully chosen people are invited. Hwasa's "SO THIS IS THE MEANING OF BETRAYAL" translated in my head to "this little brat has the audacity to make a personal/vip party and doesn't even invite her girl- SMH" Moon adding "We're seeing each other soon, no?" is also so meaningful- as if saying "Why are you even upset if we already have plans, don't we?" making sure Hwasa remembers time with Hwasa is time with Hwasa alone- No need for other people... romantic :") But, Moon also added "As for us- We'll meet December 24" (MAYBE A STUDIO MOON NIGHT with Hwasa? or a sub-unit collab?" maybe she just wanted to somehow disguise what she had said before about having plans that involved Hwasa and no one else 🤔 Cause Hwasa didn't even touch that subject... she just went "who are you with?" This part is where Moon got defensive- THIS IS A CRUCIAL HwaByul moment- Why did Moon felt like she had to explain why Mirami was there? Saying "Mirami-nim came to surprise me- I didn't know about it-" I could almost hear her adding "I swear-" in her head lol maybe it was because of how Hwasa had suddenly focused on who was there with her, ignoring the rest of the conversation. Maybe it was because of Hwasa's tone while saying "who are you with?" in the end most couples know when their partner is being serious about something, they know when their voices seem upset or when they are "warning" you you are close to actually upsetting them... Also, check out how Moon says "Mirami-nim"... that's formal- Which for most Koreans means they are not very close with one another. She used formal there- maybe she was making sure Hwasa knew they weren't super close(?) 👀 what do you think? Hwasa's "I'm following you with interest" for some reason I could picture that being a watered down version of _"I trust you with Byulyi...nevertheless, don't make me change my mind, I'll be paying you close attention"_ lol
As absolutely precious as this entire exchange was however, now that I've had time to think about it, if that convo had started off with Hwasa saying ANYTHING else...not quite sure how that would've ended/get covered up. By this, I think you know I mean if she started the call with a pet name/term of endearment 😅 Edit: About Mirani, I definitely feel like Byul tacked in the 'nim' to reassure Hwasa that nothing was going on, because the two seem to at least be friendly enough where the 'nim' doesn't seem necessary lol
On 24th mamamoo wil be on SMN 😌 yes the who are u with speaks louder than anything for me, it will be awkward to ask that if u're not super close with that person, yet hwasa ask like its nothing
@@NoxNovak yess! Me too! I don't know if that will be live or havr it lre recorded but at 1st yul said we will meet up soon and why woukd u add on 24? She means with the member but maybeee just maybe she purposely add that so it wouldn't be too obvious to listeners :)
MoonFlower, this channel will forever be a inspiration for me, and a HwaByul safe haven in general. Thank you again for delivering high quality content, as always 💜
you're welcome .... but see when we talk ..... hwabyul is the boat that unites us in this group that follows this channel, thanks to you I do my best .... my mini-flower moon 💜🍒
My exact same feelings. I've been following this channel for a few months but I was a shy silent fan. As I kept reading the comments within each video, it started to feel like a good spot to discuss Hwabyul in a cool, respectful atmosphere. Now I eagerly await for comments of the regular ones like Adore the king, T Camp, Mj, and others with their unique insights and thoughts. Thank you Moonflower for creating this lovely space.
Me three! Your channel honestly brought us all together in a way. Your videos created a safe space for Hwabyul stans to discuss and lay out their thoughts without getting railroaded by other shippers. And for all my years as a MooMoo, I never thought that would happen. You really gave us a lot MoonFlower ^^ Thank you for all the effort you put into your vids and this channel as a whole 😁
Me 4! I feel content bc we all discuss more abt little details and respect each other opinion not forcing or being too fanatic over them! I feel this is a safe place to speak up our analysis ehhehee and Merry Xmast to all of u! Hope all the joy come in our waaay and happiness over mamamoo!
Awww, I remember seeing this yesterday ❤ People on Twitter were raving about Moonsun so this bit got ignored or downplayed. It's a struggle being a Hwabyul stan over there 😐 Hwasa really went into that convo with such a cutesy voice lmao Then she had to dial it back when Byul told her they were live 😂 I felt like we saw a brief glimpse (at least on Hwasa's end) of how they tend to talk to each other in private lol Also, hey MoonFlower! 👋 Hope you're doing well ^^ Thanks for dropping this vid!
I get you, T Camp. Sometimes it does feel a bit lonely around Moonsun shippers, but the upside of being a Hwabyul shipper is that I find A LOT of interesting comments and hindsight.
@@yadichong True! Several Hwabyul shippers are surprisingly sharp-eyed and astute. A lot of them seem to notice things I wouldn't have given a second glance otherwise! If anything, this fandom is pretty impressive. Is it still frustrating stanning the most unpopular Byul pairing in Mamamoo? You betcha. Are the conversations worth it? Definitely ^^
@@yadichong , @TCamp do not get discouraged, nothing happens ... I just tell you that the relationship between the moon and the flower is that you have a conversation where you feel a unique chemistry ...
@@yadichong yes if u pay close attention on twitter actually u will got some precious hwabyul crumbs i agree, they even still curious abt you're my sunshine that byul wrote for hyejin on the last smn and why would the twit tape would be there on byul's photoshoot for her utube channel 😂 some of them do have sharp eyes!
Moonflower🤗 thank you for the vid. To add to the convo, what's telling for me is Byul's smile didn't see that smile with Yong, the playfulness, the laughter, not to mention the warm relaxed "can't wait to see you" vibes ..these 2 are giving me life!
you're welcome ... if the way moon stays with hwada every time he looks at her, hugs her, they talk to each other and others are different ... as he really was a gay panic of his entire life ... a love that passes more afterwards of their looks 😍
here we are I was not going to leave this for January ... but hopefully wait for new material ... ay videos of hwabyul in interaction hopefully you are well greetings
Am I the only one who just melted of cuteness at 01:04 when Hwasa called Byul "Mansaeng, Mansaeng!"?
What does it mean? Idk any Korean words
@@piike_the_garbage Mansaeng is Byul's Cantonese name. Hwasa likes to call her that way.
Guys- The fact Hwasa didn't call Moonbyul "unnie" until she knew she was live- That's huge stuff-
How she just said "what are you doing?~" as a greeting in such playful, borderline flirty, way melts my heart
The way Hwasa got all "Why do you mean you're having a party without me?" had me smiling so hard xD And the way she got even more upset when Moon revealed it was a party with a "small amount of people", those type of parties are usually more personal or intimate in the sense that only a few carefully chosen people are invited. Hwasa's "SO THIS IS THE MEANING OF BETRAYAL" translated in my head to "this little brat has the audacity to make a personal/vip party and doesn't even invite her girl- SMH"
Moon adding "We're seeing each other soon, no?" is also so meaningful- as if saying "Why are you even upset if we already have plans, don't we?" making sure Hwasa remembers time with Hwasa is time with Hwasa alone- No need for other people... romantic :")
But, Moon also added "As for us- We'll meet December 24" (MAYBE A STUDIO MOON NIGHT with Hwasa? or a sub-unit collab?" maybe she just wanted to somehow disguise what she had said before about having plans that involved Hwasa and no one else 🤔
Cause Hwasa didn't even touch that subject... she just went "who are you with?"
This part is where Moon got defensive- THIS IS A CRUCIAL HwaByul moment- Why did Moon felt like she had to explain why Mirami was there? Saying "Mirami-nim came to surprise me- I didn't know about it-" I could almost hear her adding "I swear-" in her head lol maybe it was because of how Hwasa had suddenly focused on who was there with her, ignoring the rest of the conversation. Maybe it was because of Hwasa's tone while saying "who are you with?" in the end most couples know when their partner is being serious about something, they know when their voices seem upset or when they are "warning" you you are close to actually upsetting them...
Also, check out how Moon says "Mirami-nim"... that's formal- Which for most Koreans means they are not very close with one another. She used formal there- maybe she was making sure Hwasa knew they weren't super close(?) 👀 what do you think?
Hwasa's "I'm following you with interest" for some reason I could picture that being a watered down version of _"I trust you with Byulyi...nevertheless, don't make me change my mind, I'll be paying you close attention"_
lol
As absolutely precious as this entire exchange was however, now that I've had time to think about it, if that convo had started off with Hwasa saying ANYTHING else...not quite sure how that would've ended/get covered up.
By this, I think you know I mean if she started the call with a pet name/term of endearment 😅
Edit: About Mirani, I definitely feel like Byul tacked in the 'nim' to reassure Hwasa that nothing was going on, because the two seem to at least be friendly enough where the 'nim' doesn't seem necessary lol
On 24th mamamoo wil be on SMN 😌 yes the who are u with speaks louder than anything for me, it will be awkward to ask that if u're not super close with that person, yet hwasa ask like its nothing
@@MJ-fp9jk
I'm excited for the 24th then :")
@@T_Camp93
Yup' The "nim" had me laughing lol
I was like "why the nim? you nervous there, Byulyi?"
For some reason I felt cheeky about it lol
@@NoxNovak yess! Me too! I don't know if that will be live or havr it lre recorded but at 1st yul said we will meet up soon and why woukd u add on 24? She means with the member but maybeee just maybe she purposely add that so it wouldn't be too obvious to listeners :)
MoonFlower, this channel will forever be a inspiration for me, and a HwaByul safe haven in general.
Thank you again for delivering high quality content, as always 💜
you're welcome .... but see when we talk ..... hwabyul is the boat that unites us in this group that follows this channel, thanks to you I do my best .... my mini-flower moon 💜🍒
My exact same feelings. I've been following this channel for a few months but I was a shy silent fan. As I kept reading the comments within each video, it started to feel like a good spot to discuss Hwabyul in a cool, respectful atmosphere. Now I eagerly await for comments of the regular ones like Adore the king, T Camp, Mj, and others with their unique insights and thoughts. Thank you Moonflower for creating this lovely space.
Me three! Your channel honestly brought us all together in a way. Your videos created a safe space for Hwabyul stans to discuss and lay out their thoughts without getting railroaded by other shippers. And for all my years as a MooMoo, I never thought that would happen. You really gave us a lot MoonFlower ^^
Thank you for all the effort you put into your vids and this channel as a whole 😁
What a wholesome thread T^T I'm so happy.
Me 4! I feel content bc we all discuss more abt little details and respect each other opinion not forcing or being too fanatic over them! I feel this is a safe place to speak up our analysis ehhehee and Merry Xmast to all of u! Hope all the joy come in our waaay and happiness over mamamoo!
Awww, I remember seeing this yesterday ❤ People on Twitter were raving about Moonsun so this bit got ignored or downplayed. It's a struggle being a Hwabyul stan over there 😐
Hwasa really went into that convo with such a cutesy voice lmao Then she had to dial it back when Byul told her they were live 😂 I felt like we saw a brief glimpse (at least on Hwasa's end) of how they tend to talk to each other in private lol
Also, hey MoonFlower! 👋 Hope you're doing well ^^ Thanks for dropping this vid!
Thank u ,good ,tomorrow new clip vid 💕💕💕
I get you, T Camp. Sometimes it does feel a bit lonely around Moonsun shippers, but the upside of being a Hwabyul shipper is that I find A LOT of interesting comments and hindsight.
@@yadichong True! Several Hwabyul shippers are surprisingly sharp-eyed and astute. A lot of them seem to notice things I wouldn't have given a second glance otherwise! If anything, this fandom is pretty impressive.
Is it still frustrating stanning the most unpopular Byul pairing in Mamamoo? You betcha. Are the conversations worth it? Definitely ^^
@@yadichong , @TCamp do not get discouraged, nothing happens ... I just tell you that the relationship between the moon and the flower is that you have a conversation where you feel a unique chemistry ...
@@yadichong yes if u pay close attention on twitter actually u will got some precious hwabyul crumbs i agree, they even still curious abt you're my sunshine that byul wrote for hyejin on the last smn and why would the twit tape would be there on byul's photoshoot for her utube channel 😂 some of them do have sharp eyes!
Moonflower🤗 thank you for the vid. To add to the convo, what's telling for me is Byul's smile didn't see that smile with Yong, the playfulness, the laughter, not to mention the warm relaxed "can't wait to see you" vibes ..these 2 are giving me life!
you're welcome ... if the way moon stays with hwada every time he looks at her, hugs her, they talk to each other and others are different ... as he really was a gay panic of his entire life ... a love that passes more afterwards of their looks 😍
Yeeesss that little smile speaks louder for me over the entire phonecalls!
I was not expecting any Moonflower material until January... So glad and happy you dropped some new content! 😊
here we are I was not going to leave this for January ... but hopefully wait for new material ... ay videos of hwabyul in interaction hopefully you are well greetings
Me too :) actuallu i didnt expect this hwabyul interaction too ahahha but yesh hwabyul rise!!
♥️♥️♥️♥️
que dicen?
Estava celebrando después q termino video de lunatic... HwaSa dijo lunatic suerte...moon contesto que es una locura....ay q esperar los sub titulos 💜💜